Easements 101
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EASEMENTS 101 DAVID Z. CONOLY, Corpus Christi David Z. Conoly, PC State Bar of Texas 12TH ANNUAL JOHN HUFFAKER AGRICULTURAL LAW COURSE Lubbock – May 24-25, 2018 CHAPTER 2 ________________________________________________________________________________________________________Easements 101 Chapter 2 Table of Contents I. INTRODUCTION TO EASEMENTS .......................................................... 1 A. Elementary Easement Concepts ........................................................ 1 1. Easements ................................................................... 1 2. Affirmative & Negative Easements ............................................... 1 3. Appurtenant & In Gross Easements ............................................... 1 4. Dominant & Servient Estates .................................................... 1 5. Private & Public Easements ..................................................... 1 6. Express & Implied Easements ................................................... 1 B. Nature of Easements ................................................................. 2 C. Easements: Affirmative & Negative ..................................................... 2 D. Easements: Dominant Estate & Servient Estate ............................................ 2 II. EASEMENTS & OTHER RIGHTS............................................................ 2 A. Easement Appurtenant ............................................................... 2 B. Easement In Gross ................................................................... 3 C. Profit a Prendre..................................................................... 3 D. License ........................................................................... 3 III. PRIVATE VS PUBLIC EASEMENTS ........................................................ 3 IV. EXPRESS EASEMENTS ................................................................... 4 A. Signed Writing for Conveyance of Express Easement ....................................... 4 B. Description of Servient Property ........................................................ 4 C. Description of Easement Rights ........................................................ 5 D. Recording ......................................................................... 5 E. Proof of Express Grant or Reservation ................................................... 5 V. EASEMENTS CREATED BY OPERATION OF LAW............................................ 6 A. Easement by Prior Use ............................................................... 6 1. Circumstances for Application ................................................... 6 2. Unity of Ownership ............................................................ 7 3. Apparent, Existing, and Continuing Use ........................................... 7 4. Necessity of Use .............................................................. 8 a. Degree of Necessity ........................................................... 8 b. Effect of Alternatives Other Than Easement ........................................ 9 B. Easements by Necessity .............................................................. 9 1. Circumstances for Application ................................................... 9 2. Unity of Ownership ........................................................... 10 3. Necessity ................................................................... 10 a. Existence of Necessity ........................................................ 10 b. Degree of Necessity .......................................................... 10 c. Time of Existence of Necessity .................................................. 11 4. Location of Easement ......................................................... 11 C. Easement by Reference to Drawing .................................................... 11 D. Easements by Estoppel .............................................................. 12 1. Circumstances for Application .................................................. 12 2. Relationship Between Property Owners ........................................... 12 3. Representation That Easement Exists ............................................. 12 4. Reliance on Representation ..................................................... 13 E. Easement by Prescriptive Use ......................................................... 13 1. Circumstances for Application .................................................. 13 2. Open, Notorious, Peaceable Use of Property ....................................... 13 3. Adverse, Hostile Claim of Right ................................................. 13 4. Continuous Use for 10 or More Years ............................................ 14 i ________________________________________________________________________________________________________Easements 101 Chapter 2 VI. PUBLIC EASEMENTS................................................................... 14 A. Easements Created by Express Dedication ............................................... 14 B. Easements Created by Implied Dedication ............................................... 15 C. Easements Created by Prescriptive Use ................................................. 16 D. Easements Created by Statute ......................................................... 16 VII. RIGHTS AND DUTIES OF EASEMENT HOLDERS .......................................... 17 A. Terms of Agreement Control ......................................................... 17 B. Unambiguous Terms Construed ....................................................... 17 1. Procedure for Unambiguous Agreements .......................................... 17 2. Examples of Unambiguous Agreements ........................................... 18 C. Ambiguous Terms Construed ......................................................... 19 D. Procedure for Ambiguous Agreements .................................................. 19 E. Construing Easements Created by Operation of Law ....................................... 20 F. Right to Change Location of Easement .................................................. 20 VIII. EASEMENT HOLDER’S REMEDIES ...................................................... 21 A. Interference with Private Easement ..................................................... 21 1. Declaratory Judgment ......................................................... 21 2. Injunctive Relief ............................................................. 21 3. Damages ................................................................... 22 4. Attorney Fees ............................................................... 22 B. Public Easements ................................................................... 23 1. Governmental Action Affecting Public Use ........................................ 23 2. Governmental Action Affecting Private Right in Public Road .......................... 23 a. Enforcement of Private Right by Injunction ........................................ 23 b. Compensation for Governmental Taking of Private Right ............................. 23 3. Private Party’s Interference With Use of Public Way ................................ 23 IX. TERMINATION OF EASEMENTS ......................................................... 23 A. By Operation of Law................................................................ 23 B. Merger........................................................................... 24 C. Limitations ....................................................................... 24 D. Abandonment ..................................................................... 25 E. Expiration ........................................................................ 25 F. Strips & Gores..................................................................... 25 G. Easement - Abandonment - Title ...................................................... 26 H. Roads & Streets - State Highway Abandonment .......................................... 26 I. Roads & Streets - County Abandonment ................................................. 26 J. Vacation of or Closing of Streets - Municipal Authorities .................................... 26 K. Petition of Abutting Owners .......................................................... 26 L. Parks & Squares ................................................................... 26 M. Replat - Rededication - Effect on Streets................................................ 26 N. Common-Law and Statutory Dedication................................................. 26 O. Tax Deeds........................................................................ 27 P. Overburdening & Unreasonable Use.................................................... 27 Q. Mortgages........................................................................ 28 R. Municipal Vacation................................................................. 28 X. SERVIENT PROPERTY OWNER’S REMEDIES............................................... 28 A. Trespass Without Valid Easement ..................................................... 28 1. Injunctive Relief and Damages .................................................. 28 2. Statutes of Limitation ......................................................... 28 3. Recovery of Attorney Fees ..................................................... 29 ii ________________________________________________________________________________________________________Easements 101 Chapter 2 B. Easement Abuse by Unauthorized Conduct .............................................