accepted to ApJ; April 18 2011 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 08/22/09 METAL TRANSPORT TO THE GASEOUS OUTSKIRTS OF GALAXIES J. K. Werk1, 2, 3, M. E. Putman3, G. R. Meurer4, & N. Santiago-Figueroa3,5 accepted to ApJ; April 18 2011 ABSTRACT We present a search for outlying HII regions in the extended gaseous outskirts of nearby (D < 40 Mpc) galaxies, and subsequent multi-slit spectroscopy used to obtain the HII region nebular oxygen abundances. The galaxies in our sample have extended HI disks and/or interaction-related HI features that extend well beyond their primary stellar components. We report oxygen abundance gradients out to 2.5 times the optical radius for these galaxies which span a range of morphologies and masses. We analyze the underlying stellar and neutral HI gas distributions in the vicinity of the HII regions to understand the physical processes that give rise to the observed metal distributions in galaxies. These measurements, for the first time, convincingly show flat abundance distributions out to large radii in a wide variety of systems, and have broad implications for galaxy chemodynamical evolution. Subject headings: galaxies: abundances — galaxies: evolution — HII Regions — ISM: HI 1. INTRODUCTION 1991), large-scale metal blowout (Tremonti et al. 2004), Through nuclear fusion and well-studied stellar evolu- and merger-induced gas flows (Rupke et al. 2010) have all been put forth as potential causes for the observed tion processes, stars with M∗ > 8 M⊙ generate metals in their cores, and return them to the local interstel- metal distributions in star-forming, dwarf, and/or inter- lar medium (ISM) near the end of their lifetimes. Since acting galaxies. galaxies are neither static nor isolated, these metals do Characterizing the metal distribution in galaxies of all not simply stay put. Instead, they disperse throughout morphological types and masses over a wide range of the galaxy, and sometimes flow into and out of the galaxy galactocentric distances is essential for determining the via galactic winds and galaxy interactions (Oey 2003; relative importance of various metal-mixing processes. Tremonti et al. 2007; Oppenheimer & Dav´e2009). These processes, in turn, have significant bearing on our The transport mechanisms that govern how the metals understanding of galaxy evolution, galaxy feedback, and are distributed throughout and/or ejected from galaxies star formation. With regard to observational studies of are widely debated, and remain poorly understood. At galaxy-wide metallicity gradients, there are two key en- the heart of the matter is the myriad of gas-phase metal vironments that have yet to be fully investigated: inter- distributions determined from observational data. Met- acting or disturbed galaxies, and the far outer reaches of als are evenly distributed in some spiral galaxies, while galaxies. It is in their gaseous outskirts that galaxies may others exhibit steeply declining radial abundance gra- reveal how they build themselves up over cosmic time, dients (Vila-Costas & Edmunds 1992; Oey & Kennicutt through interactions and gas flows. In this paper, we 1993). By comparison, dwarf galaxies tend to show probe the chemical abundances of the far outer regions shallow, if not flat, abundance gradients (Croxall et al. of disturbed and/or extended-gas, gas-rich galaxies, and 2009). Very recent work by Kewley et al. (2010) indi- therefore extend the study of metallicity distributions in cates that close galaxy pairs also tend to have flatter galaxies to a new and important locale. To do this study, metallicity gradients than those observed in typical iso- we use HII regions that span a wide range of galactocen- lated spiral galaxies. While there is a steep inner-galaxy tric distances: within the optical extent (r < R25) and abundance gradient in M83, there is an observed flat- beyond (r > R25; referred to as “outlying HII regions”; Werk et al. 2010 ). We search for these HII regions in arXiv:1104.3897v1 [astro-ph.CO] 19 Apr 2011 tening of the radial abundance gradient at large radii (r narrow-band images of galaxies in the HI Rogues Catalog > R25; Bresolin et al. 2009). It is most likely a com- bination of astrophysical processes that leads to the ob- (Hibbard et al. 2001). served metal distributions in galaxies of various prop- The HI Rogues catalog consists of 189 HI synthesis erties. For example, disk “viscosity” and metal-mixing maps of nearby galaxies with extended, unusual, or dis- (Zaritsky 1992; Ferguson & Clarke 2001), a radial de- turbed HI morphologies, including: galaxies with ex- pendence of star-forming activity (Phillipps & Edmunds tended (many times the optical extent) or warped HI distributions, interacting groups, minor and major merg- 1 present address: Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics ers, intergalactic debris with no optical counterparts, and & UCO/Lick Observatory, University of California, 1156 High early-type galaxies with HI inside and/or outside their Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95064; [email protected] optical bodies. As the host galaxies of outlying HII 2 Department of Astronomy, University of Michigan, 500 Church St., Ann Arbor, MI 48109 regions are strongly correlated with disturbances, com- 3 Department of Astronomy, Columbia University, 550 West panions, extended gas, and interactions, this collection 120th Street, New York, NY 10027, USA of “rogue” galaxies provides a potentially rich hunting 4 ICRAR/The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling High- ground for outlying, massive star formation (Werk et al. way, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia 5 present address: Department of Physics, Fisk University, 2010a). Another benefit of the HI rogues sample is that Nashville, TN 37208, USA all galaxies have readily available HI synthesis maps, pro- 2 Werk et al. viding crucial information about the gaseous environ- tional study of the metal content of outlying gas (beyond ments of the outlying stars. In these HI Rogue sys- R25), and how it compares to the metal content of gas tems, the oxygen abundances of the extended and/or within the galaxy. stripped outer gaseous material can place much-needed 2. OPTICAL IMAGING AND HI DATA constraints on metal transport in gas-rich galaxies. 2.1. Extragalactic HII regions have long been used as re- Hα Imaging liable indicators of the current metal abundance of the In April 2005, over the course of four clear nights, gas in their vicinity. At the low electron densities typi- we imaged 27 galaxies from the HI Rogues Catalog 4 −3 cal of HII regions (ne < 10 cm ), forbidden emission (Hibbard et al. 2001) in Hα and R−band continuum lines, such as [OIII] λλ4959, 5007 and [OII] λλ3727, are with the MDM 2.4-m Hiltner telescope. The MDM 2.4- characteristic features of HII region emission-line spec- m telescope direct images, with the Echelle CCD, have a tra, along with the radiative recombination lines of the field of view of 9.5′ × 9.5′ and a plate scale of 0.275′′ per hydrogen Balmer and Paschen series (e.g. Hα). Because pixel. The average seeing over the course of these four the strength of every emission line from every element nights was 1.2′′. These observations were made in a present in the HII region depends on its chemical abun- similar fashion to the Hα imaging of the SINGG sur- dance in the nascent ISM gas, HII regions are valuable vey (Meurer et al. 2006). We used four of the SINGG metallicity indicators (Osterbrock 1989). As such, they narrow−band filters with bandpasses that corresponded trace the star formation history of the gas and act as to the Hα emission line at the target galaxy’s velocity. chemical tags that can aid in determining the origin of The central wavelengths, in angstroms, of the filters used the gas. are 6568, 6596, 6605, and 6628, each with a FWHM of The practice of determining chemical abundance gra- ∼ 30 A˚ (Meurer et al. 2006 contains a full description of dients using HII region emission-line spectra was initi- the SINGG filters). Exposure times were 3× 600 s in Hα ated by Searle (1971), who inferred a declining Galactic and 3× 120 s in R. Targets were selected from the full O/H abundance gradient from the observed increase in HI Rogues catalog on the basis of their visibility from HII region excitation and temperature with radius (with MDM observatory and their recessional velocities, such [OIII]λ4959,λ5007 /[OII] λ3727 and [OIII]/Hβ ratios). that the redshifted Hα emission line is encompassed by Shields & Tinsley (1976) confirmed the anti-correlation the SINGG Hα filters’ narrow bandpasses. Galaxies were between Teff and metallicity, and attributed the radial also selected to have angular optical and HI extents such gradients to a metallicity dependent upper mass limit that they were contained in the 9.5′ field of view. Obser- −1/2 for star formation such that Mupper ∝ Z , a scal- vations of several different spectrophotometric standards ing theoretically determined by Kahn (1974) who mod- were used to flux calibrate the data. eled massive star formation with a radiation “cocoon.” We performed a basic reduction of the data using IRAF Since then, numerous detailed studies have confirmed the CCD processing routines for bias subtraction and flat overall trend for the decrease in oxygen abundance with field division. Images were then combined and astrom- galactocentric radii (e.g. Oey & Kennicutt 1993; Zarit- etry was performed using the SINGG IDL pipeline rou- sky 1994; Bresolin et al. 1999; Kennicutt et al. 2003) tines (see Meurer et al. 2006) modified specifically for in a large number of spiral (barred + unbarred) and ir- the MDM 2.4-m telescope. Photometry was performed regular star-forming galaxies, although the underlying on the images based on observations of spectrophotomet- physical cause is still a subject of debate.