Photon rings of spherically symmetric black holes and robust tests of non-Kerr metrics Maciek Wielgus∗ Black Hole Initiative at Harvard University, 20 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA and Center for Astrophysics j Harvard & Smithsonian, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA (Dated: September 23, 2021) Under very general assumptions on the accretion flow geometry, images of a black hole illuminated by electromagnetic radiation display a sequence of photon rings (demagnified and rotated copies of the direct image) which asymptotically approach a purely theoretical critical curve – the outline of the black hole photon shell. To a distant observer, these images appear dominated by the direct emission, which forms a ring whose diameter is primarily determined by the effective radius of the emitting region. For that reason, connecting the image diameter seen by a distant observer to the properties of the underlying spacetime crucially relies on a calibration that necessarily depends on the assumed astrophysical source model. On the other hand, the diameter of the photon rings depends more on the detailed geometry of the spacetime than on the source structure. As such, a photon ring detection would allow for the spacetime metric to be probed in a less model-dependent way, enabling more robust tests of General Relativity (GR) and the Kerr hypothesis. Here we present the photon ring structure of several spherically symmetric black hole spacetimes and perform comparisons with the Schwarzschild/Kerr case. We offer our perspective on future tests of the spacetime metric with photon rings, discussing challenges and opportunities involved. I. INTRODUCTION Additionally, the observable ring-like direct emission fea- ture is commonly conflated with the critical curve in the The observational appearance of a black hole (BH) has literature. One of the aims of this paper is to clarify that been studied extensively for many years from a purely issue. theoretical standpoint [1–4]. This appearance depends As noticed by [10], the technique of very long base- on numerous astrophysical details, such as geometry and line interferometry (VLBI) is uniquely suited to probe optical depth of the emission region [5–7]. The feature the photon ring structure of black hole images. As sharp depending exclusively on the spacetime geometry is the image domain features, photon rings die-off slowly in the critical curve [8], an outline of the photon shell on a dis- Fourier domain, dominating the interferometric signal in tant observer’s screen. However, since the null geodesics the range of very high spatial frequencies, corresponding comprising the photon shell are unstable orbits [9], the to baseline lengths of tens and hundreds billion wave- critical curve remains a purely mathematical concept. lengths. While such long baselines were never observed Unless the accretion flow itself is spherically symmetric so far and this feat will surely require significant progress [4,6] (which is typically not an astrophysically plausible and new developments in the field of space VLBI, the scenario), the image of a BH contains a sequence of dis- projects that would enable robust detection of the pho- crete photon rings [8, 10]. Each photon ring is a copy ton ring structure are already being discussed and pro- of the direct image of the emission region, corresponding posed, e.g., [7, 10, 11, 17–19], and algorithms to enable to photon trajectories lensed around the photon shell, photon ring detection in VLBI data are already being with the n-th photon ring photons executing n=2 loops implemented and tested with synthetic data [11, 20, 21]. before reaching the observer’s screen [5, 10], see Fig.1. Only recently first resolved observational images of a This sequence of photon rings quickly converges to the BH were obtained by the Event Horizon Telescope VLBI critical curve, and the diameter and shape of the n = 2 array (EHT; [22–27]), presenting the supermassive BH photon ring is already strongly dominated by the space- arXiv:2109.10840v1 [gr-qc] 22 Sep 2021 M 87∗ in the center of the M 87 galaxy with a resolution time geometry – hence it can be used for precise tests of corresponding to 3 r (Schwarzschild radii; [24–26]). the theory of gravity, with only very general assumptions S The measured diameter∼ of a bright ring feature found on the astrophysical model of the accretion flow [10, 11]. in the EHT images was used to test the null hypoth- In the case of non-Kerr spacetimes, most of the previ- esis of consistency with the Kerr metric [27, 28] under ous research has focused on the theoretical critical curve the BH mass prior derived from stellar dynamics [29]. (commonly referred to as shadow, occasionally also as To formulate this test, the scaling relationship between photon ring, which has a different meaning in this paper), the ring diameter and the BH mass assuming Kerr met- which has been characterized for a broad range of non- ric was evaluated using 103 synthetic images generated Kerr spacetimes, e.g., [12–16]. Relatively less work has with general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simula- been dedicated to the observable photon ring structure. tions (GRMHD; [26, 27]). These synthetic images, rep- resenting variety of viable theoretical GRMHD models of BH accretion, allowed to perform diameter-mass calibra- tion and quantify the null hypothesis test. The results of ∗ [email protected] this test were later on reinterpreted as EHT constraints IFT-UAM/CSIC-21-100 Scalar Cerenkovˇ radiation from high-energy cosmic rays Charles Dalang,1, ∗ Pierre Fleury,2, y and Lucas Lombriser1, z 1Université de Genève, Département de Physique Théorique and Center for Astroparticle Physics, 24 quai Ernest-Ansermet, CH-1211 Genève 4, Switzerland 2Instituto de Física Teórica UAM-CSIC, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain As first noted by Robert Wagoner in the nineteen-seventies, if a scalar field is nonminimally coupled to the Ricci scalar and propagates at subluminal speeds, then there exists the possibility of scalar Cˇ erenkov radiation from a moving particle. The mere observation of high-energy cosmic rays could in principle rule out the existence of such scalar fields since any particle moving faster than scalar perturbations would lose energy in the form of scalar waves until it moves slower than those. We compute in detail the energy loss to scalar waves and find that it scales with the square of the ultra-violet (UV) cutoff frequency of the effective field theory (EFT) of gravity. For dark-energy-motivated EFTs, the UV cutoff can be low, in which case that energy loss could always be negligible. In contrast, if viewed as a covariant theory valid at all scales or as an EFT valid at higher energies, perhaps even all the way up to the Planck scale, as may be the case if motivated by quantum-gravity perspectives, then the energy loss to scalar waves may diverge or become dramatically large. In this case, high-energy cosmic rays of extragalactic origin stringently constrain any conformally coupled scalar fields with non-canonical kinetic terms. I. INTRODUCTION of modified gravity and dark energy [15–19]. This constraint arises because many of these scalar-tensor interactions im- here exists, in the context of gravitational physics, an ply non-luminal propagation of GWs due to the nontrivial T ambiguity between missing matter and describing the time dependence of the background scalar field configuration. Universe with an incomplete theory of gravity. As an example, Another, perhaps even more exciting consequence of the ob- unexplained perturbations of the orbit of Uranus led the French servation of gravitational waves, is that those do not seem to astronomer A. Bouvard to predict, in 1821, the existence of a decay into scalar waves, as predicted by degenerate higher- missing planet, known as Neptune, which was observed and order scalar-tensor (DHOST) theories, thereby eliminating their identified as such for the first time more than two decades later cosmological viability [20]. by J. C. Adams, in 1843 [1]. Conversely, it was working with As a follow-up question and since those constraints have the inadequate theory of Newtonian gravity and the observation been so powerful, can we learn anything about gravitational of the perihelion advance of Mercury that led U. Le Verrier to theories from the propagation of other fields such as high- think of a missing unobserved planet, named Vulcan, which energy cosmic particles? It turns out that for metric theories this time, was never discovered [2]. The theory of gravity which possess a direct coupling of the scalar field to the Ricci was incomplete and a more fundamental theory of gravity, scalar, scalar perturbations are sourced by the trace of the general relativity, was shown to solve this missing-matter issue. energy-momentum tensor of matter fields. Their equation of With this historical perspective in mind, and the contemporary motion is reminiscent of the electromagnetic potential which problems of cosmology, such as the inferred missing dark matter is sourced by electrically charged particles that lose energy and mysterious dark energy when adopting general relativity, to electromagnetic waves if they travel faster than the speed it seems reasonable to question the currently accepted theory of light in a medium. This emitted electromagnetic signal, of gravitation. known as Cˇ erenkov radiation [21] compensates the energy loss Alternative theories of gravity of present interest include per unit distance of those particles, as predicted by I. Franck scalar-tensor theories and their generalizations, including Horn- and I. Tamm [22], leading to their Nobel Prize shared with deski theories [3] and beyond [4–7]. A subset of those are P. Cˇ erenkov in 1958. Tight constraints on the speed of spin-2 arXiv:2109.10812v1 [gr-qc] 22 Sep 2021 able to affect cosmological dynamics and evade, via so-called GWs via GW Cˇ erenkov radiation have already been inferred screening mechanisms [8–10], tight precision tests of gravity from the observation of high-energy particles [23].