UNIVERSITY of CALIFORNIA RIVERSIDE the Role of Social

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

UNIVERSITY of CALIFORNIA RIVERSIDE the Role of Social UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA RIVERSIDE The Role of Social Capital and Collaborative Negotiations in Multiple Species Habitat Conversation Plans A Dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science by Nancy A. Jimeno June 2012 Dissertation Committee: Dr. Juliann Allison, Chairperson Dr. Shaun Bowler Dr. Thomas Scott Copyright by Nancy A. Jimeno 2012 The Dissertation of Nancy A. Jimeno is approved: Committee Chairperson University of California, Riverside Acknowledgements Someone told me before I began my research that it is impossible to write a dissertation without help. This statement was prescient for me, as I found it necessary to rely on the guidance and assistance of so many people who were generous with their time and knowledge. It is impossible to mention everyone; nevertheless, I would like to recognize certain people for their valuable contributions. First I would like to thank the members of my committee: Juliann Allison, Thomas Scott and Shaun Bowler. In particular, thank you to Juliann Allison, without whom this dissertation would not have been completed. I owe you an incalculable debt of gratitude, Juliann. To Tom Scott as well, who supported me and believed in me and the importance of my topic before anyone else did. And to Shaun Bowler, whose (literal) thumbs up at my proposal was the confidence builder I needed to carry me through this project. Thank you also to Professor emeritus, Richard Regosin, who was my “ghost” committee member, and spent hours of his retirement time reading my work and guiding me toward a better product. And to Professor Sandra Sutphen, who encouraged me to go to graduate school and not to law school, where she correctly reasoned that I would be bored. I extend my thanks to all of the MSHCP participants in Orange and Riverside counties who invited me into their homes and offices for what often ran into hours of being interviewed. Gail Barton’s apricot cobbler was a wonderful treat, and I so much appreciated the three hours of constant information she offered. Annie Borel, who allowed me to depart with her policy and bring my diet drink into her cowboy bar while iv she told me about the history of her family’s land. Elizabeth Brown, whose long years of environmental advocacy were rich with explanation and interpretation of the actions of Orange County’s politically powerful. Cindy Dominigoni, whose sense of humor about her family’s farming accommodating the needs of the Stephen’s Kangaroo Rat put the issue into prospective. Rob Thornton, whose $250 an hour attorney fees were overlooked as he granted me a “pro bono” three hour interview in his plush office. My special thanks to Dr. Dan Silver, who granted me two interviews and innumerable phone calls at all hours, as he answered question after question. And of course, I offer my gratitude to Ed Sauls, who became a close personal friend as a result of my research. My friends and family were a tremendous support system. My daughter and grand- daughter supported me with their love. The Sleepy Peepees provided the necessary fun and exercise, not to mention encouragement that I needed to maintain my sanity through the process. Lori Whitney listened to me whine as we rode, changing her schedule to suit mine for two years. And my mother, who died before I was finished, and who had the foresight to send me to Marywood, which was the foundation for all of my subsequent education. I miss you, Mom. Thank you all. v Dedicated to my husband, T. Mark Jimeno and my mentor, Professor David L. Schaefer vi ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION The Role of Social Capital and Collaborative Negotiations in Multiple Species Habitat Conversation Plans by Nancy A. Jimeno Doctor of Philosophy, Graduate Program in Political Science University of California, Riverside, June 2012 Dr. Juliann Allison, Chairperson Habitat Conservation Plans (HCPs) were established by Congress in 1982 as an amendment to the way the federal Endangered Species Act is implemented on private property. HCPs are an example of a negotiation structure that is established within a legal framework which acts as an “institutional channel” mandating collaborative negotiations and consensus-based decision making. This dissertation examines how competing stakeholders, working within a collaborative negotiation process toward a common goal, establish Multiple Species Habitat Conservation Plans (MSHCP). I argue that the collaborative negotiation model inherent in the MSHCP process fosters social capital that acts as a catalyst, drawing those with divergent ideologies and opposing interests into productive negotiations and toward reaching a workable compromise. Participants negotiate their own regulatory terms, working under a strong legal framework that provides assurances that their “voices” have been heard. While the result may be a vii consensus that is not preferred by individual participants, it is a consensus that participants as a whole agree they are willing to live with. When a compromise is reached, it is deemed legitimate and is therefore less likely to face legal challenge. viii Table of Contents Chapter 1: The Role of Social Capital and Collaborative Negotiations in MSHCPs ..1 Central Argument .............................................................................................................2 Methods ............................................................................................................................3 Review of the Literature ...................................................................................................8 Traditional Methods of Resolving Environmental Conflict ...........................................10 Adversarial Legalism .....................................................................................................11 Property Rights ...............................................................................................................14 Limits on Participation ...................................................................................................16 Emerging Models of Collaborative Methods .................................................................20 Social Capital .................................................................................................................24 Overview of the Dissertation ..........................................................................................26 Chapter 2: Legal and Historical Background of HCPs ................................................29 The Legislative and Legal Background of HCPs ...........................................................35 The Snail Darter and the God Squad: Construction of the Tellico Dam ........................37 Butterfly Meadows: The ESA Comes to California .......................................................43 No Surprises ...................................................................................................................46 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................49 Chapter 3: California’s Initial Regional-Scale HCP ....................................................52 Orange County’s NCCP .................................................................................................62 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................72 Chapter 4: The Stephen’s Kangaroo Rat HCP and its Effect on the Western Riverside Multiple Species Habitat Conservation Plan ...............................................74 Introduction ....................................................................................................................74 Private Property Owners’ SKR HCP Experience ..........................................................76 Participation and Negotiation – SKR Experience Shapes the WRMSHCP ...................82 The WRMSHCP Background ........................................................................................86 A Place at the Table: Who Participates? ........................................................................88 Shaping a Consensus Method ........................................................................................95 ix Negotiating the WRMSHCP ..........................................................................................98 Congressional Hearing in Hemet .................................................................................105 Disagreement Over Science, Differences Over Terms of Process ...............................108 The Challenge of Establishing Reserve Land Acquisition Processes ..........................112 The Habitat Transaction Method ..................................................................................113 The HANS Process .......................................................................................................116 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................118 Summary ......................................................................................................................119 Chapter 5: Rancho Mission Viejo’s Failed NCCP ......................................................121 Introduction ..................................................................................................................121 The Ranch Plan ............................................................................................................123
Recommended publications
  • Irvine Ranch, Once One of the Largest Private Ranches in the United States
    Irvine Historical Society Irvine, California The Irvine Historical Society is dedicated to preserving the rich heritage of the Irvine Ranch, once one of the largest private ranches in the United States Irvine Development to 1950s The outside world had only to look at James Irvine's farm to realize that this man was a gifted agronomist. The thousands of acres of celery, corn, sugar beets, chili peppers, alfalfa, barley, lima beans, black-eyed beans, potatoes and other crops were abundant proof of his farming acumen. The thousands of acres of perfectly laid out rows of citrus, persimmon and walnut trees earned him the awe of everyone in the valley. Though he had wealth beyond most people's comprehension, Irvine was the hardest working person in The Irvine Company and that is not to say that he did not employ a lot of hard-working people. Irvine was in the position of having almost total control of a quarter of Orange County, and he knew every square inch of the property under his control. His love of the land was unmatched, and he planned that it would remain an agricultural preserve in perpetuity. He also made plans to build the town of Myford as a shipment center for the crops. Myford Springs Up Around Railroad In 1887 when the San Bernardino and San Diego Railroad, a Santa Fe subsidiary, purchased a 300-foot-wide right-of-way across the ranch and a four-acre site for a depot, one of the conditions of passage had been that a first-class passenger station be built within six months.
    [Show full text]
  • Exploring Land Use Changes in the City of Irvine's Master Plan by Julia
    Exploring Land Use Changes in the City of Irvine’s Master Plan By Julia Lynn Goldsworth A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the USC Graduate School University of Southern California In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Science (Geographic Information Science and Technology) December 2017 Copyright © 2017 by Julia Lynn Goldsworth To my parents, Carroll and Karen Goldsworth Table of Contents List of Figures ................................................................................................................... vii List of Tables ..................................................................................................................... ix Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................. x List of Abbreviations ......................................................................................................... xi Abstract ............................................................................................................................. xii Chapter 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 1 1.1. History...................................................................................................................... 1 1.2. The New Town Movement ...................................................................................... 4 1.3. Study Area ..............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Irvine Company
    IRVINE COMPANY Irvine Company traces its early roots to the 1860’s with the initial formation of the Irvine Ranch, totaling 120,000 acres. Today, Irvine Company is a private real estate investment company governed by an independent Board of Directors. Irvine Company is respected for its master planning and environmental stewardship of the Irvine Ranch in Orange County, including diversified operations throughout coastal California. Irvine Company brings to life neighborhoods and sustainable communities with a full range of housing, jobs, retail centers, schools, parks and open space. During the last 40 years, under Donald Bren’s leadership and vision, the Irvine Company has professionally planned and master built the all-new City of Irvine and the Newport Coast, creating one of America’s most desirable regions. The City of Irvine currently has a population of 270,000, growing to an estimated 325,000 people over the next 10 years, with an equal number of employment positions. Irvine Company is committed to long-term ownership and operations of a high-quality real estate portfolio, the breadth of which is unmatched in the industry. With each property positioned at the top of its class, the company’s holdings include more than 550 office buildings, 125 apartment communities, 40 retail centers, one coastal resort, two hotels, three golf courses, and five marinas. The company’s investment property portfolio is largely located in Orange County, with about thirty-five percent of the portfolio located in Silicon Valley, San Diego, West Los Angeles, Chicago and New York City. As an environmental planner, Irvine Company has a long and successful history of land preservation.
    [Show full text]
  • Anaheim-Santa Ana-Irvine, California
    HUD PD&R Housing Market Profiles Anaheim-Santa Ana-Irvine, California Quick Facts About Anaheim-Santa Ana- Irvine By Wendy Lynn Ip | As of March 1, 2017 Current sales market conditions: balanced. Current rental market conditions: tight. Overview The Anaheim-Santa Ana-Irvine (hereafter, Anaheim) metropolitan The tourism industry accounts for 99,800 division comprises Orange County, California, and is part of the jobs in the Anaheim metropolitan division greater Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim metropolitan area. and has been one of the greatest sources of Orange County is the third most populous county in California and job growth for 6 consecutive years. Home the sixth most populous county in the nation. As a regional center to 42 miles of beaches, Disneyland, Disney for health care, education, and the development of technology, California Adventure Park, and Knott’s Berry the metropolitan division is also one of the most popular tourist Farm, the metropolitan division received 47.4 destinations in the nation. Tourism spending in the Anaheim met- million visitors during 2015, the most number ropolitan division was $11.3 billion during 2015, surpassing the of visitors of any year since 2000 (California prerecession peak of nearly $9.7 billion in 2007 (Visit California). Travel and Tourism Commission). • As of March 1, 2017, the estimated population of the Anaheim metropolitan division is nearly 3.2 million, increasing by 26,750, or 0.9 percent, annually since 2010, the highest increase in more than a decade. Strong economic conditions since 2010 supported an average net in-migration of 7,525 people annually.
    [Show full text]
  • Robert T. Bunyan
    Oral History Interview with Robert T. Bunyan Date: Saturday, February 25, 2012 Interviewer: Robert David Breton Location: Mission Viejo Library Mission Viejo, California This is a transcript of a video-recorded interview conducted by the Mission Viejo Library and funded by a Library Services and Technology Act grant administered by the California State Library. The initial, verbatim transcript of the interview was sent to the interviewee to give him or her an opportunity to check it for typographical errors, to correct any gross inaccuracies of recollection, and to make minor emendations. This is the edited version of the original transcript, but the original video recording of the interview has not been altered. The reader should remember that this is a transcript of the spoken, rather than the written, word. The interview must be read with an awareness that different persons’ memories about an event will often differ. The reader should take into account that the answers may include personal opinions from the unique perspective of the interviewee and that the responses offered are partial, deeply involved, and certainly irreplaceable. A limited number of visual and audio data from this copyrighted collection of oral histories may be used for personal study, private scholarship or research, and scholastic teaching under the provisions of United States Code, Title 17, Section 107 (Section 107), which allows limited “fair use” of copyrighted materials. Such “fair use” is limited to not-for-profit, non-commercial, educational purposes and does not apply to large amounts or “substantial” portions in relation to the transcript as a whole, within the meaning of Section 107.
    [Show full text]
  • Irvine Company
    IRVINE COMPANY Irvine Company traces its early roots to the 1860’s with the initial formation of the Irvine Ranch, totaling 120,000 acres. Today, Irvine Company is a private real estate investment company governed by an independent Board of Directors. Irvine Company is respected for its master planning and environmental stewardship of the Irvine Ranch in Orange County, including diversified operations throughout coastal California. Irvine Company brings to life neighborhoods and sustainable communities with a full range of housing, jobs, retail centers, schools, parks and open space. During the last 40 years, under Donald Bren’s leadership and vision, the Irvine Company has professionally planned and master built the all-new City of Irvine and the Newport Coast, creating one of America’s most desirable regions. The City of Irvine currently has a population of more than 280,000, growing to an estimated 325,000 people over the next 10 years, with an equal number of employment positions. Irvine Company is committed to long-term ownership and operations of a high-quality real estate portfolio, the breadth of which is unmatched in the industry. With each property positioned at the top of its class, the company’s holdings consist of 125 million square feet and include more than 560 office buildings, 125 apartment communities with 65,000 units, 40 retail centers, one coastal resort, two hotels, three golf courses, and five marinas. The company’s investment property portfolio is largely located in Orange County, with about thirty-five percent of the portfolio located in Silicon Valley, San Diego, West Los Angeles, Chicago and New York City.
    [Show full text]
  • The Irvine Ranch History Irvine Ranch Gives Way to Urban Development
    The Irvine Ranch History Irvine, California The Irvine Historical Society is dedicated to preserving the rich heritage of the Irvine Ranch, once one of the largest private ranches in the United States Irvine Ranch Gives Way to Urban Development At the beginning of the Second World War, the Irvine Ranch operated as one of the largest and most productive farming businesses in California. By the end of the war, urban pressure to develop was in full swing in northern Orange County. To the central and south county, the privately held farms continued to keep the developers away. Myford Irvine Takes Reins James Irvine, Sr.'s unexpected death in 1947 left the presidency of The Irvine Company to his only remaining child, Myford Plum Irvine. Myford was ill-suited for the job, and his short eleven-and one-half -year tenure led the ranch away from his father's agrarian pursuits, straight into commercial and residential development. Myford was the first major landowner to allow development to proceed southwards in the county. Myford was not a farmer. He leaned heavily on the advice of his father's ranch manager, Brad Hellis, whom he allowed to completely control The Irvine Company's agricultural operations. Myford loved the San Francisco social life, and did not share a consuming love of the land as had his brother, his father, and his grandfather. After attending Stanford University, he had elected to take over the management of his father's San Francisco offices and of his stocks and bonds. Known to everyone on the ranch as "Mike," Myford Irvine was a gentle soul - too gentle to run an empire.
    [Show full text]
  • NAIOP October 12, 2020 COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION Socal CHAPTER
    NAIOP October 12, 2020 COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION SoCAL CHAPTER NAIOP 2020 OFFICERS AND Councilman Marqueece Harris-Dawson BOARD OF DIRECTORS Planning and Land Use Management Committee PRESIDENT Los Angeles City Hall Pamela L. Westhoff, Sheppard Mullin PRESIDENT-ELECT 200 N Spring St, Room 1010 Rob Antrobius, Prologis Los Angeles, CA 90012 VICE PRESIDENT Michael Hodges, Irvine Company Office Properties Re: Agenda Item #6 - Council File: 20-1170 Interim Control Ordinance TREASURER Gregory May, Newmark Knight Frank (ICO) OPPOSITION LETTER SECRETARY Justin McCusker, C.J. Segerstrom & Sons Dear Chair Harris-Dawson, PROGRAMS AND EDUCATION LIAISON Fran Inman, Majestic Realty Co. NAIOP, the Commercial Real Estate Development Association, is the leading PAST PRESIDENT Jeff Moore, CBRE national organization of developers, owners, and related professionals in Taylor Arnett, CapRock Partners office, industrial and mixed-use real estate. NAIOP advances responsible Angela Azizian, MetLife Investment Management commercial real estate development, researches trends and innovations, Brian Baker, Bank of America Marc Bonando, Kidder Mathews provides educational programs, and advocates for effective public policy. Andy Bratt, Gantry The NAIOP SoCal Chapter serves Los Angeles and Orange Counties, and is Greg Brown, JLL the third largest chapter in the United States with a membership of over Kevin Burkhalter, Walker & Dunlop 1,000 members. We write you today to voice our opposition to the Interim John Casasante, DWS Control Ordinance (ICO)/ Suspending Ongoing Construction/ Hillside/ Very Michael Chukwueke, Duke Realty Corporation John Cornuke, Nuveen Real Estate High Fire Hazard Severity Zone. John Drachman, Waterford Property Company Drew Emmel, Allen Matkins NAIOP SoCal members are committed to the prevention of fires in both the Ryan Gallagher, Space Investment Partners construction of projects and how buildings are operated.
    [Show full text]
  • Newport Beach, California - Average Sale Price of Homes Range from $1.9-$4.2 Million Please Contact Our Leasing Team
    Irvine Company is one of the most respected and diversified a coastal private real estate companies in America. In addition to the balanced, sustainable master-planned communities it has created, destination the company is admired for its best-of-class real estate portfolio comprising retail and office properties, apartment and residential Often referred to as the California Riviera, the Orange County coastline housing communities, and luxury resort properties in is a world-renowned luxury resort destination. At the coastline’s center is Orange County, San Diego, Los Angeles and Silicon Valley. Newport Beach, a community that epitomizes the relaxed sophistication of Southern California’s resort lifestyle. Within this area are four upscale Guided by an unwavering pursuit of excellence since 1864, shopping centers — Crystal Cove Shopping Center, Corona del Mar Plaza, the Irvine Company’s vision — like its history — is long-term. Newport Coast Shopping Center, and Fashion Island — known as The Coastal Collection, catering to this coastal community, as well as elite residents and PACIFIC OCEAN TRADE AREA tourists throughout Southern California. Orange County vs. United States - Sixth most populous county - First in total retail sales - Third in total restaurant sales - Highest retail demand per capita - Highest average household income at $95,500 Newport Beach - Highest concentration of wealth in Southern California - Ranks third for total restaurant sales in Orange County Fashion Island® | Crystal Cove Shopping Center | Corona del Mar Plaza | Newport Coast® Shopping Center - Has over 20,000 employees located in Newport Center® with additional Class-A office space planned For more information on retail opportunities available, Newport Beach, California - Average sale price of homes range from $1.9-$4.2 million please contact our leasing team: ®The Irvine Company LLC, 2013.
    [Show full text]
  • Industrial Property for Lease Orange County Ca
    Industrial Property For Lease Orange County Ca Mitchel witch limpingly. Coordinated and unpurged Teador defilading her tarantass polychromatic or requote loathingly. Is Welch loveless or gastroenteric after mitered Barrett posing so substantially? The evidence is located at 4564 Redlands Avenue Perris CA and features a 32. Do you wish on get custody of form lease early Leasing as opposed to purchasing property is a great plant for businesses to save costs and enhance profits but it. Apartments for first in Orange County California have a median rental price of. He has the property for all areas, no competition for many industrial properties in florida and weeks. ESDI Inc. Livework homes in Orange County CA Ron Denhaan. Find real estate for? DAUM Commercial Brokers 104339 SF Industrial Lease in. Home for butter in Orange County California. Top 20 Producer Grubb Ellis Orange County 2010 Number and Retail. Uses cookies used cars, industrial property for lease orange county ca for the mhvillage classified ad blockers, profile image with. THE BEST 10 Commercial Real Estate in Orange County CA. Offers leasing services consults on rental rate markets property online. VOLATILE MANUFACTURING SPACE either NOW. Alongside the Irvine Spectrum Center not of Orange County's top shopping and entertainment. By major Property Management offices it's a great option to space in overall property. Move on ucc foreclosures and orange county breeze newspaper llc, even in prime area. In accordance with the Governor of terminal State of California's Executive Order N-2-20. Marterra Properties is a Orange County CA Property Management Company.
    [Show full text]
  • One North Wacker Brochure
    A partner When change is a constant, stability matters. For over 150 years, Irvine Company has worked to cultivate a reputation for trust, quality, and you can count dedication to each and every partnership. As a Forever Owner, we are committed to retaining and reinvesting in our workplace communities, which means that the workspace on now... a customer moves into today will only continue to improve and flourish. It means that you can count on One North Wacker: Now and Forever. and five years from now. 2 • ONE NORTH WACKER ONE NORTH WACKER 1221 OCEAN AVE. IRVINE SPECTRUM CENTER® CHICAGO, IL SANTA MONICA, CA IRVINE, CA A Proven Leader CHICAGO NEW YORK 500+ 136+ 43 LOS ANGELES Workplace Communities Apartment Communities Retail Centers ORANGE COUNTY SILICON VALLEY SAN DIEGO RESERVE AT ORCHARD HILLS THE RESORT AT PELICAN HILL® OAK CREEK GOLF CLUB® IRVINE, CA NEWPORT BEACH, CA IRVINE, CA 40+ 3 3 Residential Communities Premier Resorts World-Class Golf Courses 3 • ONE NORTH WACKER Welcome to the pinnacle of workplace One North Wacker is Chicago’s defining Class A+ Trophy building and a benchmark for quality and craftsmanship in the heart of the Central Business District. excellence The stunning office spaces and energizing amenities were designed to help our world-class customers exceed goals, inspire teams, and impress clients from the moment they step into the iconic lobby. Welcome to One North Wacker 4 • ONE NORTH WACKER Get in the Loop Building Details Height: 51 Floors Size: 1,400,000 SF Location: West Loop Architect: Lohan Associates
    [Show full text]
  • Doug Holte President Irvine Company Office Properties Doug Holte Is
    Doug Holte President Irvine Company Office Properties Doug Holte is President of Irvine Company Office Properties. In his position, Mr. Holte is responsible for the overall performance of the Irvine Company’s 45 million square foot portfolio of over 500 office properties and more than 3,000 customers in Orange County, San Diego, West Los Angeles, Silicon Valley and Chicago. These responsibilities include strategy and execution of acquisitions, development, construction, leasing, marketing and operations. Mr. Holte joined the Irvine Company in 2009 after a 22-year career as a principal in development, investment and asset management of more than 15 million square feet with the international real estate firm Hines. During his Hines career, Mr. Holte was responsible for more than 15 million square feet of office development, property acquisition and third-party client service assignments throughout the West Coast and Southeast regional markets. Mr. Holte is on the Advisory Council for the USC Lusk Center for Real Estate, and a Board member for the Orange County Community Foundation. He is a graduate of University of Southern California and received his Masters of Business Administration from Harvard University. The Irvine Company is an internationally renowned real estate development company known for its award- winning master-planned communities, its vast portfolio of high-quality investment properties and its leadership in conservation and natural resource management. The growing real estate portfolio encompasses office, apartment, retail and resort holdings located throughout California’s premier markets, including San Diego, Orange, and Los Angeles Counties, and Silicon Valley. As a steward of some of America’s most beautiful and scientifically important open space and parklands, the company has donated more than half of the historic 93,000-acre Irvine Ranch in Orange County — 50,000 acres — to permanently preserve these lands.
    [Show full text]