So Who Really Shot the Red Baron Down?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

So who really shot the Red Baron down? Happily for all who respect the chivalry of those magnificent men in their World War One flying machines, 21 April 2018 is the one hundredth anniversary of the day Baron Manfred von Richthofen, alias the Red Baron, made history, but unhappily with events surrounding the shooting down of his Fokker DR1 triplane on 21 April 1918, which caused the death of this 25 year old ace who had 80 kills of British allied aircraft to his credit, still being debated by many 100 years later. The unanswered controversial question still fascinating many is: “was the Red Baron shot down by Canadian pilot, Captain Roy Brown, flying a Camel fighter pursuing the Red Baron, who was in fact chasing and shooting at another Canadian, a novice flyer Lieutenant Wilfred May, or was he brought down by ground fire from below … and if so who fired the bullet that killed him”. The scene that day may have looked much like this, with Australian soldiers on the ground firing their .303 rifles and even hand held machine guns upwards at their red target: By the time the Baron’s triplane was brought down in what was ‘no-mans-land’ near the Bray-Corbie Road, near Sailly-le-Sec in France, it looked like this: The words written at bottom right in this picture: “Very like the scene as I remember it” is first-hand testimony of Lieutenant James Lee Smith, a pilot of an RE8 aircraft with 3 Squadron Australian Flying Corp who was later to be awarded a WWI Distinguished Flying Cross after being wounded and crashlanding in August 1918, after flying 108 reconnaissance missions since late 1917. 1 So who really shot the Red Baron down? Lieutenant Smith wasn’t flying on the evening the Red Baron was brought down, so he was ordered to lead a small salvage crew to bring back both the aircraft and the Red Baron’s body still inside his Fokker triplane to 3 Squadron’s headquarters at Poulainville. Even though the crashed aircraft lay between the German and the allied lines, it didn’t stop a few Australian soldiers sneaking out after dark to souvenir what they could of the Red Baron’s possessions and parts stripped from his well known aircraft. Lieutenant Smith later wrote the following recollections of events: 2 So who really shot the Red Baron down? When the 3 Squadron crew returned with aircraft and body, even more souveniring of the Red Baron’s possessions and parts of his aircraft continued. Lieutenant Smith’s own piece of ply he souvenired on 22 April 1918 was taken from the lead section of one of the wings: 3 So who really shot the Red Baron down? 3 Squadron’s senior officers then conducted an official post mortem on his body, photographed at the time: The 3 Squadron official report clearly established that the entry and exit points of the single bullet which killed the Baron could only have been fired from below but not from the height Captain May was positioned whilst firing his aircraft’s guns at the Fokker. 3 Squadron later buried the Baron’s body providing a respectful guard of honour. One of the Baron’s fellow pilots from his own squadron, Jasta 11, also flew over the aerodrome to drop a wreath - a truly cavalier gesture accepted unchallenged by his enemies. But the question still remained: which Australian soldier on the ground had fired the bullet? Investigations followed a variety of claims. They lead to a more or less official opinion that either Sergeant Cedric Popkin or Gunner Robert Buie were in the right place at the right time, with both evidenced to be firing accurately at the same red target. For those who must have a definitive answer, a walk through the Cemetery at Brooklyn, NSW, near the Mooney Mooney Bridge, will reveal this inscription on Buie’s own grave: 4 So who really shot the Red Baron down? Neil L Smith 16 April 2018 5 So who really shot the Red Baron down? Additional evidence written by JLS: 6 .

Copy Link

Recommended publications

The Life and Times of a Yorkshire World War One Airbase and Those Who Served There
BRAMHAM AIRBASE The Life and Times of a Yorkshire World War One Airbase and those who served there Tadcaster and Rural Community Interest Company Ltd supported by This project was delivered by Tadcaster and Rural Community Interest Company with support from the Heritage Lottery Fund. CHAPTER ONE: AN INTRODUCTION TO THE PROJECT AND BRAMHAM MOOR CONTENTS AIRBASE 1. AN INTRODUCTION TO THE PROJECT AND BRAMHAM MOOR AIRBASE ................................................... Page 3 2. A FEW OF THOSE WHO SERVED ....................................................... Page 8 3. THE AIRBASE TODAY .............................................................................Page 21 APPENDICES ........................................................................................... Page 25 COVER ILLUSTRATION Flying between the chimneys - with which the John Smith’s Tadcaster brewery was well endowed - was a popular pastime for pilots, although frowned upon by officialdom. Negotiation of these, not so man-made hazards, being regarded as a foolhardy and dangerous exercise- the late Charles Newham, a Tadcaster based pilot, admitted to having done this several times. This sketch by Norman Appleton, shows what it must have been like. 2 BRAMHAM AIRBASE BRAMHAM AIRBASE 3 THE PROJECT IN BRIEF The project to record the life and times of the former Airbase that sits just outside Tadcaster and whose one remaining artefact – a large, black Hangar – is visible to all who drive along the A64 between Bramham Crossroads and Headley bar – was inspired by the initiative of the Heritage Lottery Fund deciding to fund community groups to write down their stories at the centenary of the end of World War One. Some of the stories around the airbase are known to a few in the vicinity – primarily those involved in Historical Societies such as those at Bramham and Tadcaster.
[Show full text]
British Identity, the Masculine Ideal, and the Romanticization of the Royal Flying Corps Image
W&M ScholarWorks Undergraduate Honors Theses Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 4-2019 A Return to Camelot?: British Identity, The Masculine Ideal, and the Romanticization of the Royal Flying Corps Image Abby S. Whitlock College of William and Mary Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/honorstheses Part of the European History Commons Recommended Citation Whitlock, Abby S., "A Return to Camelot?: British Identity, The Masculine Ideal, and the Romanticization of the Royal Flying Corps Image" (2019). Undergraduate Honors Theses. Paper 1276. https://scholarworks.wm.edu/honorstheses/1276 This Honors Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Undergraduate Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Return to Camelot?: British Identity, The Masculine Ideal, and the Romanticization of the Royal Flying Corps Image Abby Stapleton Whitlock Undergraduate Honors Thesis College of William and Mary Lyon G. Tyler Department of History 24 April 2019 Whitlock !2 Whitlock !3 Table of Contents Acknowledgements ……………………………………………………………….. 4 Introduction …………………………………….………………………………… 5 Chapter I: British Aviation and the Future of War: The Emergence of the Royal Flying Corps …………………………………….……………………………….. 13 Wartime Developments: Organization, Training, and Duties Uniting the Air Services: Wartime Exigencies and the Formation of the Royal Air Force Chapter II: The Cultural Image of the Royal Flying Corps .……….………… 25 Early Roots of the RFC Image: Public Imagination and Pre-War Attraction to Aviation Marketing the “Cult of the Air Fighter”: The Dissemination of the RFC Image in Government Sponsored Media Why the Fighter Pilot? Media Perceptions and Portrayals of the Fighter Ace Chapter III: Shaping the Ideal: The Early Years of Aviation Psychology .….
[Show full text]
Greetings Members and Friends of EAA Chapter 866
Joe Pires flying off the 40 hrs in his experimental Gyro Copter that he recently finished. Greetings Members and Friends of EAA Chapter 866, We certainly have a wonderful group of folks in our chapter, and we had a terrific annual party last month at the Indian River Golf Preserve in Mims! If you were able to attend the party, I hope you had a great time and enjoyed socializing with your fellow chapter members. A HUGE THANK YOU goes out to Kimberly Brennan for all the effort she put into planning the many little details of the event!! Thanks Kimberly! I’ve been spending a little more time at the airport these past couple of weeks, working on the new Panther kit project with my partners Eddie & Bob. I’ll save an update on that for later, but I will say that we’re all very impressed with the quality of the kit, and with the way it goes together, and we’re really moving along on the project. Stop by and see it if you have a chance, but if you’re not careful, we might put a pair of Cleco pliers in your hand! I thought I’d use a little space in the newsletter this month to give you some insight into my thinking as it relates to our great little EAA Chapter. As your Chapter President, I feel some obligation to have some sort of big picture idea about our Chapter’s mission and goals. Renowned American businessman and entrepreneur, James Cash Penney (Yes, that J.C.
[Show full text]
Canada's Aviation Hall of Fame to Induct Four New
Canada’s Aviation Hall of Fame to Induct Four New Members and Honour a Belt of Orion Recipient Canada’s Aviation Hall of Fame (CAHF) will induct four new members at its 42nd annual gala dinner and ceremony to be held Thursday, June 4, 2015, at the Skyservice hangar in Toronto, Ontario, at the Toronto Pearson International Airport. The annual black-tie event is a highlight in Canadian aviation celebration and draws attendance from across Canada. To be honoured by CAHF in 2015 are: Arthur Roy Brown, DSC: Known to most Canadians for his decisive involvement in the epic action of 21 April 1918 resulting in the demise of Manfred von Richthofen, the “Red Baron.” Brown had an outstanding record of service in the Royal Naval Air Service and the Royal Air Force. He was an outstanding combat leader who persevered on active duty despite poor health and injuries. He never lost a member of his flight because of the care he took in introducing newcomers onto operations. Postwar, his steadfast interest in flying led him to found a highly successful aviation company operating in northern Ontario and Quebec westward to Manitoba throughout the 1930s. In poor health and suffering the medical effects of his wartime crashes, he died at the young age of 50 in 1944. James Stuart “Jim” McBride: From initial roots in the technical side of the RCAF, Jim McBride used his entrepreneurial talents to build successful franchises for the marketing of Piper aircraft and Hughes helicopters across Canada. From modest beginnings in the charter business supporting Manitoba Hydro in its major power projects in northern Manitoba, he went on to develop profitable and innovative air transport businesses culminating with the rescue and turnaround of the Winnipeg based regional carrier, Transair.
[Show full text]
Sopwith Camel Has an Accurate Outline and Simplifi Ed Construction to Speed Building Time
CONSTRUCTION BY GERRY YARRISH PHOTOS BY GERRY YARRISH & SAL CALVAGNA e 1/4-scale Sopwith Camel has an accurate outline and simplifi ed construction to speed building time. a bit in length. e lower wing panels plug into place over an aluminum wing Sopwith Camel tube from TnT Landing Gear Products. I designed the Camel around the Zenoah A classic 1/4-scale British icon of World War I G-38 gas engine, but the engine you choose will determine the placement of the fi rewall. Viewed by many as the British airplane structures. I also replaced the thin, e bottom aileron servos are installed that best defi ned air combat during undercambered airfoil with a more pilot- in the wing panels and 2-56 slave rods World War I, the Sopwith Camel is one friendly fl at-bottom wing. If you’ve built connect the bottom ailerons to the top of the best-known fi ghters to come out a kit or two, you’ll have little trouble with ones. e entire cockpit and machine-gun of the Great War. First introduced at the the Camel. hump section comes off in one piece to end of 1916, it was a replacement for the provide access to the radio and the fuel Sopwith Pup, and about 5,500 Camels CONSTRUCTION tank. It’s held in place with rare-earth Vwere produced. Perhaps the most famous Everything can be easily made with basic magnets. e engine cowl is also secured Sopwith Camel pilot of all was Canadian shop tools, but to save time, there is also with several large magnets, and two Captain Arthur Roy Brown, who was a laser-cut wood kit available from sheet-metal screws prevent the cowl from credited with shooting down Manfred von Arizona Model Aircrafters.
[Show full text]
Revell 1/28 Sopwith Camel by Ken Hornby
Volume 49 Number 7 Website: http://www.aerohistorians.org July 2015 Revell 1/28 Sopwith Camel by Ken Hornby July 11 th Guest Speaker the 457 th to complete the 35 Revell Sopwith Camel Ken Rohde 1 st Lt. USAAF mission limit, flying as copilot for by Ken Hornby retired, copilot of B-17G 954Q, “Queenie” and on his very first 748th Squadron, 457 th BG, 8 th mission and others as spare co- The Model AF. pilot for the lead ship. Turning Drafted before Pearl, Ken down a 6 year extension offer in This kit was first released in Rohde became an infantry the USAAF after VJ day, Lt. 1959 and has been re-released soldier and served in the South Rohde retired and became a once about every 5-10 years Pacific. Applying for pilot training, successful engineer with SPX. since. It’s a remarkable piece of it took more than a year and a plastic engineering for its era. half to process the documents, Please join us to hear one of There are a few problems with then passing the written test that the last remaining hero’s of the kit, namely the over-long his orders were finally cut for the WWII. length of the struts, but it can still USAAF. be built into an acceptable model Modelers, bring in your 8th out of the box. However, I Flying in the ETO, from Air Force B-17 and B-24 models decided to correct or improve as August to December 1944, Lt. for display. many of the shortcomings of the Rohde was the first crewman of (Continued on page 5) Page 1 TCAH Officers From the Prez an extended article in the by Bob Maderich II newsletter on the build/ President , Robert Maderich II history of that plane? So, Welcome to the July edition from now on, let's find a Vice-President , John R.
[Show full text]
T H E C O L O P H O N B O O K S H O P World War I Aviation
T H E C O L O P H O N B O O K S H O P Robert and Christine Liska P. O. B O X 1 0 5 2 E X E T E R N E W H A M P S H I R E 0 3 8 3 3 ( 6 0 3 ) 7 7 2 8 4 4 3 World War I Aviation All items listed have been carefully described and are in fine collector’s condition unless otherwise noted. All are sold on an approval basis and any purchase may be returned within two weeks for any reason. Member ABAA and ILAB. All items are offered subject to prior sale. Please add $5.00 shipping for the first book, $1.00 for each additional volume. New clients are requested to send remittance with order. All shipments outside the United States will be charged shipping at cost. We accept VISA, MASTERCARD and AMERICAN EXPRESS. (603) 772-8443; FAX (603) 772-3384; e- mail: [email protected] http://www.colophonbooks.com With an Original Drawing by Clayton Knight 1. [SPRINGS, Elliott White]. War Birds. Diary of an Unknown Aviator. New York: George H. Doran Company, (1926), large octavo, blue cloth . 277 pp. First Edition. Illustrated with color and black and white drawings by Clayton Knight. Based partially on the diary of John Grider and substantially a memoir by Springs, this book is quite often listed as a World War I novel. This copy with a marvelous pencil and watercolor painting on the half-title by Clayton Knight of a British SE5a pursuing a German Albatros.
[Show full text]
Who Killed Von Richthofen?
VIEWS AND OPINIONS WHO KILLED VON RICHTHOFEN? by Lieutenant-Colonel David Bashow If he had been my dearest friend, I could not have felt thereafter, two Ketten (flights) totaling nine Fokker Dr.1 Triplanes, greater sorrow. led by von Richthofen, launched into clearing skies to confront the British threat. Fifteen minutes later, von Richthofen and Leutnant Arthur Roy Brown upon viewing the remains Weiss detached from the German formation and had an inconclusive of Manfred von Richthofen engagement with two RE8 two-seater observation aircraft from No. 3 Australian Flying Corps (AFC) Squadron at 7500 feet over ontroversy is swirling yet again around an epic aerial Hamel. A plucky and effective defence by the Australian airmen encounter from the First World War. This time it drove the two Germans away. However, Weiss’s Triplane was is centred upon Rittmeister Manfred Freiherr von visibly damaged during the scrap, and this resulted in a preliminary Richthofen, the legendary Red Baron, and his death victory claim over von Richthofen once the word spread later that in battle over the Western Front on 21 April 1918. day that he had been felled. This claim was later discounted as CA recent television documentary downplayed the role played in being incompatible with the Baron’s actual time of death. the engagement by Captain Arthur Roy Brown – believed by many to have been the man who shot down von Richthofen. In After this brief engagement, von Richthofen rejoined his the wake of the documentary, family, friends and supporters of formation and, shortly thereafter, led them in an attack on Roy Roy Brown have professed outrage, betrayal and disappointment Brown’s force, which was now south of Hamel.
[Show full text]
20 War in the Air and at Sea Air Aces in Battle
314-326 120820 11/1/04 3:55 PM Page 314 Chapter 20 War in the Air and at Sea Air Aces in Battle Almost everyone has heard of the legendary plane far below. He put his Fokker into a steep “Red Baron.” He was the most famous Ger- dive and moved in on the plane’s tail. His tar- man flyer of World War I. But few people get was a young Canadian flier, Wilfred May. know that it was a Canadian, Roy Brown, who It was a tense moment. May’s gun jammed. finally shot down the Red Baron. Luckily, another Canadian pilot, Captain Roy On 21 April 1918, Manfred von Rich- Brown, saw what was happening and swept in thofen, the Red Baron, was flying high above behind the Red Baron. Brown, in his Sopwith the Somme valley in his bright crimson Fok- Camel, opened fire on von Richthofen. The ker triplane. Suddenly, he spotted an Allied Red Baron was hit and fell into a deadly spin. Moments later the German war ace was dead at the age of 26. Today the seat of the Red Baron’s plane is displayed at the Royal Mil- itary Institute in Toronto. You can put your finger through the bullet hole in the seat. Reflecting/Predicting 1. Based on this story, describe some of the risks World War I flyers took, and Canadian pilot some of the dangers they faced.What Roy Brown. He do you think the life of a World War I once said,“I love flyer was like? flying, not killing.” 2.
[Show full text]
(Fig. 5.1 S01417 Seaplane at the Airbase at Killingholme During 1St World War
Aerial Warfare & Home Defence AERIAL WARFARE AND HOME DEFENCE PREPARATIONS FOR WAR The term 'Munitions' included motor-cars and aircraft when used for war.1 As we have seen, Lincolnshire's factories helped build these, and the county was an early centre of military air bases due to its geography. Its farmland was requisitioned and transformed into landing grounds for aeroplanes, balloons and air stations, the Defence of the Realm (Consolidation) Act, 1914 conferring on the competent naval and military authorities 'an absolute and unconditional power to take possession of land and buildings … even though that act interfered with private rights to property.’ A judgement in the Appeal Court in July 1915, even decided there was no right to compensation.2 In August 1913 the Admiralty ordered the construction of a handful of coastal air stations to include a sub-command and station based at Cleethorpes; this did not materialise. However, it gained rights for a strip of land adjoining the Oil Depot at Immingham so the Royal Naval Air Service (RNAS), which was officially recognised on 1 July 1914, set up No. 8 Kite Balloon Section on the south bank of the Humber. The first aircraft landed there during July and the first operational sortie took place on 21 August.3 Killingholme became a large operational seaplane station to protect the Royal Navy's fuel storage tanks and nearby ports. (Fig. 5.1 s01417 Seaplane at the Airbase at Killingholme during 1st World War. c/1014 Imperial War Museum) Tethered kite balloons were trailed from convoy escort ships, taking observers aloft in a wicker basket to around 3,000 ft to watch for sea mines, torpedo tracks, Zeppelins and U-boats.
[Show full text]
Fighter Pilots Reunion
The American Fighter Aces Association Oral Interviews The Museum of Flight Seattle, Washington BCATP (British Commonwealth Air Training Plan) Fighter Pilots Reunion Recording Date: circa 1970 2 Abstract: This recording contains highlights from a reunion held in Winnipeg, Manitoba, circa 1970, for Canadian and British fighter pilots who were involved with the British Commonwealth Air Training Plan during World War II. Speakers share remarks and humorous stories about each other and pay homage to the wartime service of Canadian pilots. Identified speakers include German fighter ace Adolf Galland; British fighter aces James Edgar “Johnnie” Johnson and Douglas Bader; and Air Commodore John Fauquier of the Royal Canadian Air Force. Also included is an excerpt from a BBC radio broadcast of then-Wing Commander Johnnie Johnson giving a briefing on the eve of D-Day. Background: The British Commonwealth Air Training Plan (BCATP), also known as the Empire Air Training Scheme (EATS), was an aircrew training program implemented during World War II by the Royal Air Forces of the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. A reunion for BCATP-trained Canadian pilots was held in Winnipeg, Manitoba, circa 1970, and the event included a luncheon attended by Canadian and British fighter pilots, as well as at least one German fighter pilot. Several of the speeches made by the guests of honor were recorded. Restrictions: Permission to publish material from the American Fighter Aces Association Oral Interview Collection must be obtained from The Museum of Flight Archives. Transcript: Transcribed by Pioneer Transcription Services 3 Index: Remarks from German fighter ace Adolf Galland .........................................................................
[Show full text]
Remembrance Ni
REMNI 21 April, 2019 remembrance ni Queen’s professor of medicine and the death of German air-ace the Red Baron Thomas Sinclair, (Left), Professor of Medicine at Queen’s University, Belfast, in April 1918, found himself at the centre of one of the major incidents of the First World War, namely the cause of the death of the most famous and deadliest German fighter pilot, Manfred von Richthofen, the Red Baron. Page !1 REMNI 21 April, 2019 During World War I, no name struck more fear into the hearts of Allied airmen than that of Manfred von Richthofen, better known as the “Red Baron.” After scoring his first kill on September 17, 1916, the German pilot spent the next 19 months prowling the skies in his signature red airplane, winning one air battle after another. He was later shot down and killed in April 1918, but not before he became the war’s highest- scoring fighter ace. Professor Thomas Sinclair had an outstanding record in his profession. He was educated privately and intended to go into business. However, in 1877 he entered Queen's College, then a constituent college of the Royal University of Ireland, in which he graduated with first-class honours in 1881, winning the Malcolm exhibition in 1880 and a gold medal in 1881. He then worked at the London Hospital, in Vienna, and in Berlin, acted for a time as demonstrator of anatomy at Queen's College, Page !2 REMNI 21 April, 2019 Baron von Richthofen with one of his triplanes. Belfast, and took the Membership of the RCS in 1882 and the Fellowship in 1886.
[Show full text]