See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324678000 Functional traits reveal environmental constraints on amphibian community assembly in a subtropical dry forest Article in Austral Ecology · April 2018 DOI: 10.1111/aec.12607 CITATIONS READS 0 20 3 authors: Julián Norberto Lescano Daniela Miloch National Scientific and Technical Research C… National University of Cordoba, Argentina 39 PUBLICATIONS 265 CITATIONS 2 PUBLICATIONS 5 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE Gerardo C. Leynaud National University of Cordoba, Argentina 49 PUBLICATIONS 476 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects: Analyzing distributional patterns of amphibians and reptiles to inform conservation decisions, with special focus on Argentina. View project The phylogeny of bothropoid pitvipers (Bothrops, Bothrocophias) View project All content following this page was uploaded by Julián Norberto Lescano on 23 April 2018. The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. Austral Ecology (2018) , – Functional traits reveal environmental constraints on amphibian community assembly in a subtropical dry forest JULIAN N. LESCANO,1,2* DANIELA MILOCH1 AND GERARDO C. LEYNAUD1,2 1Facultad de Ciencias Exactas, Fısicas y Naturales, Centro de Zoologıa Aplicada, Universidad Nacional de Cordoba, Rondeau 798, (Email: [email protected]); 2Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientıficas yTecnicas (CONICET), Instituto de Diversidad y Ecologıa Animal (IDEA), Cordoba, Argentina Abstract The relationships between functional traits and environmental gradients are useful to identify differ- ent community assembly processes. In this work, we used an approach based on functional traits to analyse if changes in hydroperiod and tree covers of ponds are relevant for local amphibian community assembly processes. Ephemeral ponds with low vegetation cover are expected to impose constraints on different species with particu- lar trait combinations and, therefore, to exhibit communities with lower functional diversity than more stable ponds with greater tree cover. Sampling was conducted in 39 temporary ponds located along vegetation and hydroperiod gradients in the most arid portion of the Chaco ecoregion. Seven functional traits were measured in each species present in the regional pool. Associations between these traits and environmental gradients were detected using multivariate ordination techniques and permutation test (RLQ and fourth-corner analyses respec- tively). Functional diversity indices were then calculated and related to variations in the environmental gradients. The results obtained allowed us to identify different sets of traits associated with hydroperiod and tree cover, suggesting that these environmental variables are relevant for structuring amphibian communities according to interspecific variations in functional traits from both, larval and adult stages. Contrary to our expectations, com- munities associated with more stable ponds and with greater tree cover exhibited lower functional diversity than expected by chance (and were the ponds with highest species richness). This result indicates that the reduction in relative importance of environmental restrictions imposed by a very short hydroperiod and the lack of tree cover, favours different species of the regional pool that are similar in several functional traits. Accordingly, com- munities associated with stable ponds with high tree cover exhibited high functional redundancy. Key words: anurans, community structure, functional diversity, temporary ponds, trait syndromes. INTRODUCTION research looking at the patterns of trait clustering among co-occurring species along environmental gra- Understanding the mechanisms driving community dients. According to this rationale, environmental fil- assembly is a key challenge in ecology (Grime 2006; tering should increase trait convergence and reduce McGill et al. 2006). To disentangle these processes, functional diversity in the harshest (i.e. unproductive ecologists have shifted from traditional approaches or disturbed) extremes of gradients, whereas trait (i.e. measuring species composition and diversity) overdispersion should be observed in more produc- towards a functional trait-based approach (McGill tive extremes due to niche divergence and limiting et al. 2006; Webb et al. 2010; Mason & De Bello similarity (Weiher & Keddy 1995; Cornwell et al. 2013), since increasing evidence suggests that the 2006; Mason et al. 2008; Maire et al. 2012). How- relationships between functional traits (i.e. traits that ever, other bodies of work have shown contrasting indirectly impact individual fitness via their impacts responses of trait distribution patterns to environ- on reproduction, growth and survival) and environ- mental factors (Flynn et al. 2009; Mayfield & Levine mental factors have the potential to reveal community 2010; Weiher et al. 2011; Grime & Pierce 2012; Spa- assembly processes and to enhance the predictive sojevic & Suding 2012; Cadotte & Tucker 2017). power of ecology (Dıaz & Cabido 2001; McGill et al. According to Mayfield and Levine (2010), high level 2006; Violle et al. 2007; Mason et al. 2008). of competition in productive environments could Community assembly is often assumed as the out- lead to both trait clustering and trait overdispersion, come of two opposing forces: environmental filtering depending on the relative importance of differences and competitive interactions. This environmental fil- in competitive ability or niche differences among spe- tering vs. competition paradigm motivated a body of cies. Other authors have shown that high levels of stress or disturbance could lead to a general conver- *Corresponding author. gence in traits related to resource acquisition and to Accepted for publication March 2018. divergence in traits related to reproduction or © 2018 Ecological Society of Australia doi:10.1111/aec.12607 2 J.N.LESCANOET AL. defence (Grime & Pierce 2012). Contrasting results and canopy cover gradients in amphibian communi- in the literature indicate that interpreting patterns of ties from the Chaco ecoregion. Then we test whether trait dispersion is a challenging task that requires these gradients influence functional structure of detailed system-specific knowledge (Mayfield & amphibian communities by analysing patterns of Levine 2010; Kraft et al. 2015). However, observa- functional diversity. Based on the general theoretical tional data of trait clustering/dispersion remain useful frame, which postulates that environmental filtering to interpret underlying environmental conditions that increases trait convergence at sites with environmen- influence community assembly (Cadotte & Tucker tal constraints, we expect that functional diversity will 2017). decrease in ponds that are increasingly ephemeral Accordingly, analysing groups with complex life and have reduced tree cover. cycles (like amphibians) from a trait-based approach could offer appropriate animal models for disentangling MATERIALS AND METHODS ecological factors that drive community assembly. Since there is evidence of uncoupling of phenotypic traits across life stages in amphibians (Sherratt et al. 2017; Study area Wollenberg Valero et al. 2017), these animals provide The study was conducted in a region of 13 400 km2 the opportunity to explore whether response trait syn- located in the southernmost and driest portion of the South dromes involve combinations of traits from different life American Chaco ecoregion (the Arid Chaco subregion) stages. Moreover, due to their biphasic life cycle (coordinates: 29°2901.22″S; 64°17055.68″W for the north- amphibians depend on changes occurring in contrast- ernmost surveyed pond and 31°35037.72″S; 65°22052.93″W ing environments. Particularly, the whole-life cycle of for the southernmost surveyed pond) (Morello et al. 1985). pond-breeding amphibians depends on both pond The vegetation consists of a mosaic of xeric forest with a characteristics and local characteristics of the terrestrial variable tree canopy cover (40–90%) dominated by Aspi- habitat surrounding ponds. Species ability to develop, dosperma quebracho-blanco. Forests alternate with natural metamorphose and reproduce across water permanence halophytic scrublands and secondary scrublands resulting gradients (i.e. from permanent to ephemeral) depends from forest degradation (Morello et al. 1985; Hoyos et al. 2012). The climate is subtropical, with a mean annual tem- on larval development times and ability of adults to tol- perature of 19.9°C and maximum absolute temperatures erate dry periods, optimize growth and time reproduc- that reach 47°C. Rainfall is concentrated in the warm sea- tion according to water pulses (Newman 1989, 1992; son (October to April) and is approximately Dayton & Fitzgerald 2011; Fabrezi 2011; Edge et al. 450 mm yearÀ1 (Morello et al. 1985). 2016). In addition, canopy cover around ponds affects tadpole larval growth and development through changes in primary productivity and food availability, Pond selection and environmental gradients and represents a key structure for foraging, refuge and reproduction in adult stages (Skelly et al. 2002, 2014; Thirty-nine temporary ponds were selected. Temporary Quesnelle et al. 2015; Rowland et al. 2016; Villasenor~ ponds had highly variable hydroperiods and were located et al. 2017). Constraints imposed by these simultane- along a marked gradient of plant cover changes; thus, pond ous gradients