My Phd Thesis 2

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

My Phd Thesis 2 Moving beyond physical mobility: blogging about urban cycling and transport policy Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2014 Laura Golbuff Abstract It is often acknowledged that movement exists in multiple, interdependent forms and that we live in an Information Age. However, mobilities perspectives on contemporary cycling tend to neglect the a) interconnections between transport (physical mobility of people and objects) and communication (mobility of symbolic information) b) paradigmatic shifts in modernity that affect how and why we communicate about transport. This thesis responds to such neglect. Firstly, it places urban cycling in an internet context by examining practices and perceptions of policy blogging, asking why do individuals blog about cycling-related transport policy and to what effect? Secondly, it analyses the answers to these questions through the theoretical lens of the risk society and reflexive modernisation theses. Empirical data is the result of 46 semi-structured interviews with bloggers and expert system representatives, mostly in London, New York and Paris. Blogging about cycling-related transport policy is shown to be an individualised response to the perceived failings of expert systems, as well as in Giddens’ words, a ‘reflexive project of the self’. Citizens who may otherwise only be policy subjects or passive consumers of transport, emerge as policy, media and civil society actors by virtue of their ability to publish information, which forms the basis of social relations. Through blogging, they produce and mobilise knowledge. Knowledge claims mediated by blogging interact with expert systems responsible for transport, which in turn adapt; routine institutional practices evolve; a new order emerges; blogging makes a difference. That difference is however limited, not least because the public remains reliant on expert systems. Ultimately, despite the obvious importance of physical mobility to cycling, this thesis seeks to move beyond it. Information and communication technologies have radically altered how we - researchers, the public, expert system representatives - communicate about and understand cycling, and as such, this project argues for a renewed emphasis on mobilities in a genuinely plural sense of the word as being about more than physically moving from A to B. Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction............................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Thesis in Brief............................................................................................................... 2 1.2 Structure of Thesis........................................................................................................ 3 Chapter 2: Literature Review................................................................................................... 6 2.1 Mobilities....................................................................................................................... 7 Mobilities and Transport................................................................................................. 7 Transport and Communication....................................................................................... 9 Mobilities and Modernities............................................................................................ 11 Mobilities Section Summary......................................................................................... 14 2.2 Risk............................................................................................................................ 14 Risk Society and Reflexive Modernisation................................................................... 14 Transport Risk.............................................................................................................. 16 Reflexive Mobility......................................................................................................... 17 Individuals, Institutions, Systems ................................................................................ 18 (Sub)Politics................................................................................................................. 20 Citizenship................................................................................................................... 21 Risk Section Summary................................................................................................. 24 2.3 Knowledge.................................................................................................................. 24 Expert Knowledge as Uncertain, Distrusted, Conflicted...............................................24 How Knowledge is Produced and Who Produces It..................................................... 27 Informationalism and Knowledge-based Societies ...................................................... 29 The Internet as a Self-Organising System....................................................................30 Self-Organisation, Knowledge Production, Knowledge (Sub)Politics ..........................32 Knowledge Section Summary...................................................................................... 34 2.4 Chapter Conclusions: Literature Review..................................................................... 34 Chapter 3: Methodology........................................................................................................ 36 3.1 Unit of Analysis, Field Sites, Research Questions, Qualitative Approach....................36 Blogging....................................................................................................................... 36 Policy Blogging............................................................................................................ 39 Field Sites ................................................................................................................... 40 On Comparative and Qualitative Research, Research Questions ...............................43 3.2 Mobile Methods, Interviews ...................................................................................... 45 Mobile Methods ........................................................................................................... 45 Semi-Structured Interviews ......................................................................................... 50 3.3 Recruitment, Technique, Coding and Analysis, Positionality .....................................54 Recruitment.................................................................................................................. 54 Figure 1: Interview participants by field site and stakeholder type................................57 Technique ....................................................................................................................57 Analysis, Coding and Theoretical Framework.............................................................. 59 Positionality.................................................................................................................. 62 3.4 Chapter Conclusions: Methodology............................................................................ 64 Chapter 4: Context................................................................................................................ 66 4.1 The State as an Expert System.................................................................................. 66 Policy Targets for Cycling and Private Car Use ........................................................... 67 Cycling-Related Transport Policy in London.................................................................69 Cycling-Related Transport Policy in New York..............................................................70 Cycling-Related Transport Policy in Paris.................................................................... 72 Political Acceptability of Cycling................................................................................... 74 Section Summary: The State as an Expert System......................................................76 4.2 Instituted Media as an Expert System.........................................................................77 Newspapers and Cycling............................................................................................. 77 Mediating Perceptions of Risk...................................................................................... 78 Shift Towards Favourable Media Coverage of Cycling................................................. 80 Media and the Promotion of Policy............................................................................... 81 Section Summary: Instituted Media as an Expert System............................................ 82 4.3 Cycling’s Civil Society as an Expert System............................................................... 83 Civil Society Organisations...........................................................................................83 Disparity Within Cycling’s Civil Society.........................................................................84 Integrationism and Segregationism: Conflicting Strategic Preferences in London .......86 Movement Spin-Offs and Informal Advocacy Networks................................................ 89 Section Summary: Cycling’s Civil Society as an Expert System...................................90 4.4 Cycling Policy Blogospheres.......................................................................................90
Recommended publications
  • City of Paris Climate Action Plan
    PARIS CLIMATE ACTION PLAN TOWARDS A CARBON NEUTRAL CITY AND 100% RENEWABLE ENERGIES An action plan For a fairer for 2030 Together and more and an ambition for climate inclusive city for 2050 Conceptualized by: City of Paris, Green Parks and Environment Urban Ecology Agency Designed by: EcoAct Published: May 2018, 2000 copies printed on 100% recycled paper EDITOS A RESILIENT CITY 02 54 THAT ENSURES A HIGH-QUALITY LIVING ENVIRONMENT PREAMBLE 56 Air Improving air quality for better health 05 6 Paris, 10 years of climate action 61 Fire 9 Towards carbon neutrality Strengthen solidarity and resilience 11 Creating a shared vision in response to heat waves 12 Zero local emissions 64 Earth 13 Relocation of production and innovation Biodiversity to benefit all parisians 13 Adaptation, resilience and social inclusion 67 ​Water 14 Three milestones, one urgent need A resource that needs protection for diversified uses A CARBON-NEUTRAL AND 18 100% RENEWABLE-ENERGY CITY A CITY THAT IS VIEWED 19 Energy 70 AS AN ECOSYSTEM Paris: a solar, 100% renewable-energy city 71 A successful energy transition and a key player in French renewables is a fair transition 25 Mobility 76 Mobilisation Paris, the city of shared, active Paris mobilises its citizens and stakeholders and clean transport 81 Governance of the low-carbon transition 34 Buildings A 100% eco-renovated Paris with A CITY THAT MATCHES low-carbon and positive-energy buildings 84 ITS MEANS TO ITS AMBITIONS 40 Urban planning 85 ​Finance A carbon-neutral, resilient A city that is preparing finance for the energy and pleasant city to inhabit transition 44 Waste 88 ​Carbon offsetting Towards zero non-recovered waste Paris fosters metropolitan cooperation and a circular economy in paris for climate action 49 Food 91 Advocacy Paris, a sustainable food city A city that speaks on behalf of cities 95 GLOSSARY Making Paris a carbon-neutral city © Jean-Baptiste Gurliat © Jean-Baptiste powered entirely by renewable energy by 2050.
    [Show full text]
  • Long-Term Carbon and Nitrogen Dynamics in Parisian Soil-Tree Systems Aleksandar Rankovic
    Living the street life : long-term carbon and nitrogen dynamics in parisian soil-tree systems Aleksandar Rankovic To cite this version: Aleksandar Rankovic. Living the street life : long-term carbon and nitrogen dynamics in parisian soil-tree systems. Ecology, environment. Université Pierre et Marie Curie - Paris VI, 2016. English. NNT : 2016PA066728. tel-01653082 HAL Id: tel-01653082 https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-01653082 Submitted on 1 Dec 2017 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. THÈSE DE DOCTORAT DE L’UNIVERSITÉ PIERRE ET MARIE CURIE – PARIS VI ÉCOLE DOCTORALE SCIENCES DE LA NATURE ET DE l’HOMME : ÉCOLOGIE ET ÉVOLUTION (ED 227) SPÉCIALITÉ ÉCOLOGIE PRESENTÉE PAR ALEKSANDAR RANKOVIC POUR OBTENIR LE GRADE DE DOCTEUR DE L’UNIVERSITÉ PIERRE ET MARIE CURIE – PARIS VI LIVING THE STREET LIFE: LONG-TERM CARBON AND NITROGEN DYNAMICS IN PARISIAN SOIL-TREE SYSTEMS DYNAMIQUES DE LONG TERME DU CARBONE ET DE l’AZOTE DANS DES SYSTÈMES SOL-ARBRE PARISIENS SOUTENUE PUBLIQUEMENT LE 29 NOVEMBRE 2016 DEVANT LE JURY COMPOSÉ DE : LUC ABBADIE, PROFESSEUR À L’UPMC DIRECTEUR DE THÈSE SÉBASTIEN BAROT, DIRECTEUR DE RECHERCHE À L’IRD CO-ENCADRANT SÉBASTIEN FONTAINE, CHARGÉ DE RECHERCHE À L’INRA EXAMINATEUR NATHALIE FRASCARIA-LACOSTE, PROFESSEUR À AGROPARISTECH RAPPORTEUR JEAN-CHRISTOPHE LATA, MAÎTRE DE CONFÉRENCES À L’UPMC CO-ENCADRANT JEAN LOUIS MOREL, PROFESSEUR À L’UNIVERSITÉ DE LORRAINE RAPPORTEUR FRANÇOIS RAVETTA, PROFESSEUR À L’UPMC EXAMINATEUR ! 2 À Ranisav, Zorka et Lazar, pour m’avoir élevé.
    [Show full text]
  • Paris Cycling Policies. Towards a 15
    Velo-City 2017 Christophe NAJDOVSKI, deputy mayor of Paris in charge of transports and public space Paris cycling policies Towards a 15% modal share by 2020. Part 1 - Background Paris and its agglomeration, institutionnal framework 4 levels of authority for transport : State, Region, “Département ”, Cities Part 1 - Background Ile de Paris France WALK 38,7% 60,5% 3% - 5% of home/office BIKES 1,6% commutes made by parisians. 2 MOTORIZED 1,4% 1,8% WHEELS A city of short distances : you can walk from PUBLIC one end of the city to the other in less than TRANSPORT 20,1% 27,3% 2 hours 6,7% CARS 37,8% Mobility Datas/ modal split - 2010 General context : cycling in Paris PRO CONS Flat terrain Traffic density Mild climate Urban cuts Dense network of public Dense city with short transport with relatively distances cheap prices Congested urban space Beautiful urban fathering difficulties for landscape parking Part 2 – Mobility Policy 2000s: Development of a more ambitious policy. 2008-2014 Pacification of public roads and public space in Paris and creation of Vélib’ Developing Public transports – the tramway Part 3 - Paris cycle plan 2015-2020 Aim : to triple cycling use and reach a 15% modal share by 2020 . A previously unseen (in Paris) 150 M€ budget . Doubling the total lenght of bicycle lanes (from 700km to 1.400km) . Create a cycling express network to cross Paris from N. to S. and from E. to W. Offering a cycling continuity between Paris/closed suburb (Paris’s gateways) . Other policy measures : bike parking, suporting cycling citizen associations, cycle touring, financial support to acquire a bike… Le Réseau Express Vélo rue de Rivoli - projection Foster inter-modal commutes 2 high-capacity Bike stations to be created in parisian Railway stations.
    [Show full text]
  • Public Transport and Non-Motorized Transport in a Sustainable Perspective
    Public transport and non-motorized transport in a sustainable perspective Arjen Jaarsma consultant Balancia The Netherlands Outline 1.Crisis 2.Future 3.Low carbon cities 4.Cities on the road to sustainability 5.Walking, cycling, public transport and cars 6.Mombasa 7.Cities in 2090 1. CRISIS Yes, we have more than one crisis: • economic crisis • climate crisis • oil crisis • food crisis 2. FUTURE The future is....... sustainability. Three P’s: People, Planet, Profit. Four Z’s: zero waste, zero emissions, zero congestion, zero accidents. 3. LOW CARBON CITIES Low carbon city = city with zero (or low) CO2 emissions. Three main producers of CO2 in cities: 1. Buildings (housing, working) 2. Hard infrastructure (energy delivery, waste management, water supply, sewage, etc.) 3. Mobility of persons and goods (traffic) 4. CITIES ON THE ROAD TO SUSTAINABILITY • Amsterdam (the Netherlands) – solar energy / cycling / electric vehicles • Vauban (suburb of Freiburg in Germany) – car free / tram / cycling / car sharing • Sino-Singapore Tianjin Eco-city (China) – new planned city with 90% PT+cycling • Masdar City (UAE) – new planned city, the low carbon city of the future! MASDAR CITY (United Arab Emirates) • Satelite city of Abu Dhabi • In 2016: 40-50.000 inh. + 70.000 jobs • Zero-carbon city: generating all its own power • Walled: no urban sprawl + protection against desert winds, all buildings max. 5 storeys • No broad streets but tight shady alleys (Arabian style), roads are all pedestrian • Public transport (metro, light rail, HST?) + Personal Rapid Transit + parking at border of city 5. WALKING, CYCLING, PUBLIC TRANSPORT AND CARS The private car on fossile fuels was great in the 20 th century but is definitely not the transport mode in the 21 st century.
    [Show full text]
  • Rer B Tarif Billet
    Rer B Tarif Billet Juridic and subalpine Euclid jellify, but Stu slovenly hachures her lochia. When Delbert beards his reputability ferments not misguidedly enough, is Rustie scotomatous? Calvinistical Cam always whirls his bushman if Hillel is glandered or rebuffs bleakly. Available in one month there interactive, rer b has two of the ile de gaulle airport bus routes toward brest, alignées du confort du trajet en illimitée durant toute seule et jeune Please stand by a thriving gambling, rer can speak it. Generally, except for early and late hours, travellers should not worry about specific Metro train times; just get to your station and take the next train. There are a number of services by which you can call for taxis or make a reservation in advance. With Paris being such a popular destination I thought it may come in handy for some of you! This before is in wise way affiliated with The Walt Disney Company made its subsidiaries. In this cooking class, you will learn they make the spent and delicious menu from jail so that you easy bake his own Macarons by your own small home. Thanks for own update Barbara. However, some areas are safer than others. Paris: Should you buy a Navigo pass? Where is the train station and what is the best way to get there? When cool add such the airport access, needle is sausage good deal. There are traditional french, so if it would be aware that parisians, we exclusively used for longer journeys that there are no itinerary matches your restaurant.
    [Show full text]
  • East London Cyclist FEBRUARY / MARCH 2008 the NEWSLETTER for TOWER HAMLETS WHEELERS  LONDON CYCLING CAMPAIGN
    EastEast London Cyclist www.wheelers.org.uk FEBRUARY / MARCH 2008 THE NEWSLETTER FOR TOWER HAMLETS WHEELERS LONDON CYCLING CAMPAIGN LCCLCC 30 years on… LiftLift lobby In September, the LCC will have been around for 30 years, (and Wheelers for about the same time!) The lift service at the Greenwich to Island Gardens foot tunnel has Over the years, Wheelers and the London Cycling become unreliable recently, despite a major overhaul a couple of Campaign have been working hard to improve years ago. This is due both to mechanical problems with the lifts and to a shortage of operators. The tunnel is a vital route for cyclists, conditions for cycling both London-wide and locally in with large numbers using it day to get to work at Canary Wharf. Tower Hamlets. When the lifts are out of action, there are 8 flights of stairs at each end – a major disincentive to using a bike, especially as the DLR We’ve had many successful campaigns and initiatives, and have cannot be used as an alternative. The lifts are managed by Greenwich become increasingly recognised by local authorities, planners, council, but jointly funded by Greenwich and Tower Hamlets. We government, police, and organisations such as TfL, and have have raised the problem with both councils and urged them to considerable input both locally and nationally into improving improve the situation. standards and promoting cycling as a sustainable, affordable, Dave Allison healthy, green, practical, and convenient way of getting around. (It can be fun too!) GreenGreen machines Cycling has undoubtedly moved up the political agenda and is seen as an essential part of transport, environmental, and even Wheelers led a ride to the Day of Action Against Climate health policies, with commitments being made for continued th investment in cycle lanes, cycle training, bike parking, and Change march on 8 December, which included a bike ride changing behaviour, such as the congestion charge.
    [Show full text]
  • Paris Climate Action Plan Towards a Carbon Neutral City and 100% Renewable Energies
    PARIS CLIMATE ACTION PLAN TOWARDS A CARBON NEUTRAL CITY AND 100% RENEWABLE ENERGIES An action plan For a fairer for 2030 Together and more and an ambition for climate inclusive city for 2050 Conceptualized by: City of Paris, Green Parks and Environment Urban Ecology Agency Designed by: EcoAct Published: May 2018, 2000 copies printed on 100% recycled paper EDITOS A RESILIENT CITY 02 54 THAT ENSURES A HIGH-QUALITY LIVING ENVIRONMENT PREAMBLE 56 Air Improving air quality for better health 05 6 Paris, 10 years of climate action 61 Fire 9 Towards carbon neutrality Strengthen solidarity and resilience 11 Creating a shared vision in response to heat waves 12 Zero local emissions 64 Earth 13 Relocation of production and innovation Biodiversity to benefit all parisians 13 Adaptation, resilience and social inclusion 67 ​Water 14 Three milestones, one urgent need A resource that needs protection for diversified uses A CARBON-NEUTRAL AND 18 100% RENEWABLE-ENERGY CITY A CITY THAT IS VIEWED 19 Energy 70 AS AN ECOSYSTEM Paris: a solar, 100% renewable-energy city 71 A successful energy transition and a key player in French renewables is a fair transition 25 Mobility 76 Mobilisation Paris, the city of shared, active Paris mobilises its citizens and stakeholders and clean transport 81 Governance of the low-carbon transition 34 Buildings A 100% eco-renovated Paris with A CITY THAT MATCHES low-carbon and positive-energy buildings 84 ITS MEANS TO ITS AMBITIONS 40 Urban planning 85 ​Finance A carbon-neutral, resilient A city that is preparing finance for the energy and pleasant city to inhabit transition 44 Waste 88 ​Carbon offsetting Towards zero non-recovered waste Paris fosters metropolitan cooperation and a circular economy in paris for climate action 49 Food 91 Advocacy Paris, a sustainable food city A city that speaks on behalf of cities 95 GLOSSARY Making Paris a carbon-neutral city © Jean-Baptiste Gurliat © Jean-Baptiste powered entirely by renewable energy by 2050.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Groningen Bicycle Sharing System Wiersma, Bouke
    University of Groningen Bicycle sharing system Wiersma, Bouke Published in: Default journal IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite from it. Please check the document version below. Document Version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Publication date: 2010 Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database Citation for published version (APA): Wiersma, B. (2010). Bicycle sharing system: role, effects and application to Plymouth. Default journal. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Take-down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum. Download date: 11-02-2018 Abstract This thesis investigates the role and effects of a bicycle sharing system, and studies the feasi- bility of such a system in Plymouth. The research consists of a literature review, policy dis- cussion, case studies, and a detailed assessment of the local demand by performing inter- views, focus groups and a survey. This study concludes that a bicycle sharing system in Ply- mouth is at the moment very unlikely to become successful, in terms of attracting significant numbers of users, achieving substantial modal shift and reducing CO 2 emissions.
    [Show full text]
  • Policy Bundles for Reducing Transportation Emissions in Large
    Policy Brief October 2014 SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES Policy Bundles for Reducing Sustainable Prosperity is a national Transportation Emissions in Large Cities research and policy network, based at the University of Ottawa. SP focuses on market-based approaches to build a stronger, greener, more competitive economy. It brings together business, policy Key Messages and academic leaders to help inno vative ideas inform policy development. • Transportation - the movement of goods and people from one location to another - is responsible for about one quarter of Canada’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.1 Some modes of transportation also create air pollution and traffic congestion, which in turn contribute to Witten by: health and ecological impacts and lost economic productivity. All of these impose economic Stephanie Cairns and Pomme Arros costs on households, businesses, and governments. This Policy Brief is based on two research papers (MBIs, Climate Change, and • The bulk of transportation-related emissions arise from the road travel generated by individual Sustainable Transportation Governance in choices about where to live, work or study and how to travel between these locations, and by Cities and Climate Change and Transportation the shipment of goods by road. This Policy Brief focuses on passenger emissions, the major Governance: Looking for Lessons in New York contributor to growth in transportation GHGs. City, London, and Paris) written by David Gordon, PhD Candidate, University of • Municipalities have many policy tools to manage these emissions. Fiscal measures can Toronto. Additional research and writing support was conducted by Dana Krechowicz. reinforce land use, transit investment and other mode shift strategies. For example, market- Alex Wood and Michelle Brownlee provided based instruments (MBIs) make GHG-intensive transportation choices more expensive and valuable comments.
    [Show full text]
  • A Social History of Women and Cycling in Late-Nineteenth Century New Zealand
    A SOCIAL mSTORY OF WOMEN AND CYCLING IN LATE-NINETEENTH CENTURY NEW ZEALAND A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy at Lincoln University by Clare S. Simpson Lincoln University 1998 MEMORANDUM The Academic Registrar Lincoln University This is to certify that this thesis entitled: A Social History of Women and Cycling in Late -Nineteenth century New Zealand. is the work of Clare S. Simpson and has been supeNised by me. SupeNisor: Professor Grant Cushman HOD: Dr Jenny J. Ross Date: 25 November 1998 thes is J"or PD:~l Abstract of a thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Ph.D. A SOCIAL mSTORY OF WOMEN AND CYCLING IN LATE-NINETEENTH CENTURY NEW ZEALAND by Clare S. Simpson In the final decade of the nineteenth-century, when New Zealand women began riding the bicycle, they excited intense public debate about contemporary middle-class ideals of femininity. The research question posed is: "why did women's cycling provoke such a strong outcry?" Three nineteenth-century cycling magazines, the New Zealand' Wheelman, the New . Zealand Cyclist,and the New Zealand Cyclists' Touring Club Gazette, were examined, along with numerous New Zealand and British contemporary sources on women's sport and recreation, etiquette, femininity, and gender roles. The context of the late-nineteenth century signifies a high point in the modernisation of Western capitalist societies, which is characterised in part by significant and widespread change in the roles of middle-class women. The bicycle was a product of modern ideas, designs, and technology, and eventually came to symbolise freedom in diverse ways.
    [Show full text]
  • Cycle Islington Newsletter – March 2017 – 740 Members
    Cycle Islington Newsletter – March 2017 – 740 members CycleIslington http://cycleislington.uk @CycleIslington CI meetings - update by Alison Dines Simon Munk, LCC’s infrastructure campaigner, joined the recently instigated road closure outside a primary school in CI meeting on 8 February to discuss how CI could Camden at school drop off and pick up times campaign more effectively by looking at our relationships http://bbc.in/2kA0nV0 was also considered as a scheme that with local councillors and council officers. For many years might be suitable for Islington. Simon thought we had lots CI have had regular meetings with officers from the of good ideas and that our discussions were very planning and engineering departments and also, although encouraging - now we just need to turn them into actions! less frequently, have met the executive member for If you have any views/would like to get involved please transport and environment. But despite this, the cycling contact [email protected] infrastructure in the borough is not as good as we would like. Future CI meetings at 19.30-21.30 in the Town Hall, Simon urged us not to criticise the council publicly but to Upper Street N1 2UD try and engage constructively and think of other ways of influencing people. Hearing about his experiences in *8 March: informal discussion with Nick Wayne, local Waltham Forest, and the successful bid for the mini- councillor for Canonbury – come along for a chat ! Holland scheme there, was inspiring and helped us consider *12 April: speaker: Mary Stevens – research project on how to get our message across in Islington.
    [Show full text]
  • Intermedia Mobility in the Public Sphere Framing Bikesharing in Mass Media and Social Media Across Three Cultures
    Intermedia Mobility in the Public Sphere Framing Bikesharing in Mass Media and Social Media across Three Cultures Dirk von Schneidemesser Dissertation submitted to the Hertie School of Governance in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor rerum politicarum (Dr. rer. pol.) in the Doctoral Programme in Governance Berlin, 2017 First advisor Prof. Dr. Andrea Römmele Hertie School of Governance Second advisor Prof. Dr. Barbara Pfetsch Freie Universität Berlin © 2017 Dirk von Schneidemesser No further reproduction or distribution is allowed without explicit permission. Abstract Accompanying developments in communication technologies and practices, new possibilities emerge for actors to participate in public debate on political issues. While the influence of traditional mass media on public opinion formation processes in the public sphere has been firmly established, the rise of digital media adds complexity to communication processes that are only beginning to be understood. This research aims to add to the understanding of how social media contributes to the normative goals of the public sphere. Much of the research at the nexus of digital media and the public sphere focuses on extraordinary issues or events such as revolutions or electoral politics, leaving a gap as to how everyday political issues are discussed and debated in a hybrid media context. This research addresses that gap by examining a non- sensational policy issue – bikesharing – in two public sphere arenas. Quantitative and qualitative content analyses of print media and Twitter texts are applied to compare and contrast these two mediums across three cases. This comparative approach using the German, North American, and Spanish cases offers insight into the role of social media in different traditional media systems.
    [Show full text]