Industry I), Ministry of Environment and Forest & Climate Change Indira Paryavran Bhawan, Jorbagh Road, New Delhi - 110003

To, The Director (Industry I), Ministry of Environment and Forest & Climate Change Indira Paryavran Bhawan, Jorbagh Road, New Delhi - 110003

Proj/TSK/2020/0839 11th November 2020

Sub: Submission of Additional Information for Environmental Clearance proposal for Expansion of Integrated Steel Plant Expansion from 6 to 8 MTPA Crude Steel and 9 MTPA Finished Steel by Tata Steel Limited at Kalinganagar Industrial Complex

Ref: (i) Proposal IA/OR/IND/128148/2016, dt 19th Dec 2019 / 13 June 20 along with copy of EIA / EMP report (ii) File No – IA-J-11011/07/2006-IA. II (I) & letter dt 28th Sept against this file

Dear Sir,

This has reference to your letter dt 28th Sept 20, with respect to proposal for grant of Environment Clearance from 6 to 8 MTPA crude steel and 9 MTPA finished steel for Tata Steel Ltd at Kalinganagar Industrial Complex.

As per discussions held during the EAC meetings held on 26th Jun and 27th Aug 20, we are uploading details of the Additional Information sought vide your letter dt 28th Sept 20. Kindly note that the information is enclosed as annexure 1 – 16. For your perusal and action.

We request for our proposal to be placed before the next EAC for kind consideration and grant of Environmental Clearance.

Thanking you

Yours sincerely,

For Tata Steel Ltd

(Ajit Kothari) GM, Project- Tata Steel Kalinganagar

Contents

Annexure 1: Summary of PH Proceeding ...... 2 Annexure 2 - Revalidate base line data ...... 50 Annexure 3: AAQ modelling ...... 61 Annexure 4: Risk Assessment ...... 69 Annexure 5: EMP Matrix ...... 81 Annexure 6: ZLD Action Plan ...... 100 Annexure 7: Plantation Scheme ...... 102 Annexure 8: Pollution control System ...... 103 Annexure 9: CER ...... 105 Annexure 10: Dioxins/Furan… Hg ...... 107 Annexure 11: CEMS ...... 109 Annexure 12: Solid Waste Management ...... 112 Annexure 13: Drainage of TSK ...... 118 Annexure 14: Skin Care ...... 120 Annexure 15: Slip power recovery ...... 122 Annexure 16: Specific water and power consumption ...... 128

Annexure 1: Summary of PH Proceeding

Query (i): “Summary of the public hearing proceedings highlighting both positive and negative feedback from stakeholders along with PPs response for both.”

Reply: Summary of Public Hearing proceedings highlighting positive and negative feedback from stakeholders along with PP’s response for both is provided below. This is arranged as follows:

A. Brief overview and numbers

B. Positive and negative feedback from stakeholders, speaker wise indicating village, segregated in 6 broad headings

A. Brief overview and numbers 1. Draft EIA Report (June 2019) was submitted to Odisha State Pollution Control Board (OSPCB) for public review and consultation. OSPCB in consultation with the office of District Magistrate (DM), Kalinganagar, Jajpur scheduled the Public Hearing (PH) on 25th October 2019. The PH schedule was notified in the leading newspapers “The Sunday Times” (English daily) on 22nd September 2019 and local daily “Sambad” (Oriya daily) on 20th September 2019 inviting objection, suggestions, views and comments from the local populace residing in the nearby villages of the project area

2. Draft EIA Report and Executive Summary were available in the offices of all local nodal bodies and was also uploaded in OSPCB website for awareness about the proposed project to all the stakeholders

3. In adherence to the Serial No. (i) of the Specific ToR issued by MoEFCC, OSPCB after observing all official procedures conducted the PH on 25th October 2019 at 9:00 a.m at JDCL Complex, village Pankapal, Jajpur, Odisha.

4. PH was inaugurated with welcome speech delivered by Shri Pramod Kumar Behera, Regional Officer, State Pollution Control Board, Odisha. He briefed the audience about the guidelines to be followed for the Public Hearing in the light of EIA Notification, 2006 and its subsequent amendments

5. Shri Santosh Kumar Mishra, Additional District Magistrate, Kalinganagar explained that the views, comments, objections and opinions of the public are necessary while considering the Environmental Clearance of the project. He welcomed the audience and requested the PP to make a brief description of the project for better awareness of the public.

- 2 -

6. On behalf of PP, Shri R. R. Satpathy, General Manager (Corporate Services) of M/s Tata Steel Limited addressed the committee members & the assembled public and made a brief description about the salient features of the proposed project, environmental management, pollution control measures, waste management, afforestation programme and various others peripheral development activities envisaged for the proposed project.

7. Shri Mishra, then requested the assembled public to share their views, comments, objections and opinions on the proposed project.

8. After the public views, Shri Mishra asked the PP to present their comments to the people with respect to the demands raised by the public in the meeting.

9. Shri R. R. Satpathy of M/s Tata Steel Limited made commitment on the issues raised by the public.

10. A total of 128 people registered their names for deliberation during the public hearing, out of which 114 people deliberated and expressed their opinions. Summary of the public hearing highlighting issues raised along with response of the project proponent and summary of positive and negative responses is given in the following table:

Persons registered their presence 326 Panchayat represented 24 at Public Hearing Persons spoke during PH 114 Villages represented 57

Speakers who have: (a) given positive opinion 98 (b) positive opinion with suggestions Speakers who have given negative opinion, 16 though have also given suggestions and (Speaker: 15, 27, 35, 41, 46, 47, 54, 56, have sought facilities / development of area 57, 74, 96, 104, 105, 109, 110, 114) with support from Tata Steel

- 3 -

PUBLIC HEARING PHOTOGRAPHS

- 4 -

B. Positive and negative feedback from stakeholders, speaker wise indicating village, segregated in 6 broad headings

Sl. Opinions expressed Response of Tata Steel Kalinganagar (TSK) 1. Skill Development, Technical Education, School Infrastructure and Livelihood a) School / Collage Education, Technical • TSK is already working on 1000 school project to education & Skill development improve the quality of education in the region. Positive: Also promoting vocational and technical training Ramsulia (2,5), Sukinda (11, 102), Baghuapal to improve skill sets of local youth. (14), Gabaraghati (23), Ranagudi (39), Kaitha • For improving education TSK has already (40), Olia (42), Rangitang (88), Jagadih (95) covered 48 panchyats in Kalinganagar various Tata Colony (7), Sulia (8), Karadgadia (25) scholarship schemes are provided to support Gabaraghati (60), Siatia (70), Trijanga students. - Jyoti Fellowship Program for (90),Dakhinpasi (92), Baragadia (93), Sansailo professional education to assist Meritorious local (100), Salijanga (16), Gabaraghati (20), students. Bandhgan (28), Baragadia (29,93), Trijanga (31), • 4 nos. of Community Education Resource Centre Manatira (37), Golagaon (38), Chandia (55), (CERC’s) are functional in peripheral villages Kalajhira (64), Siatia (70), Sansailo (76), Olia (81), Chandia (82), Rangitang (87), Sulia (97), Pankapal (107), Mirigchal (108), Kendudihi (111)

- Old age education is being provided - Quality of education has improved - Education facility to small children is available - Education to child labours - Education to dropout students - Loyola school established - Training on kitchen garden, tailoring / painting, mushroom cultivation, self- employment - Done lot of development work in 48 villages since 2006 - Tata steel done more development work than other industries - Established Sishu Mandir in village / developed class rooms / lot of development and CSR work by company Positive & Suggestions: TSK is already focused on all these. Some activities Jakhapura (1), Pankapal (9), Gabaraghati (24, that TSK is taking up are: 85), Baragadia (29), • Construction of science block with lab in Duburi Golagaon (38), Baghuapal (49), Nimapali (53) college (timeline - 3 years) Ref CER Table 1b Duburi (66), Trijanga (90) • For tribal students, a Tribal residential School (Ashram school) is planned. For this land & - Quality technical education for Sukinda building approval is already obtained from Govt. Students with free of cost of Odisha. This a 22 crs project for which is likely - Better education facility to tribal people to start early CY 21 and can be completed within - Skill assessment training program to local 24 months. people 48 panchayats of Sukinda • College block construction of 3500 sqft. at constituency Mantira College will be taken up and - Establish skill development training in Duburi construction is expected to start by June 21. area • One College bus from Danagadi to Sukinda - Provide small gardens in nearby schools College has already been started. • Construction of children playing corner in primary schools of nearby villages depending upon approvals - Gobarghati, Baragadia, Kapuriapada, Trijanga, Nariabanga, Duburi. Timeline - 3 Years (Ref.CER table 1c)

- 5 -

Sl. Opinions expressed Response of Tata Steel Kalinganagar (TSK) b) Employment Opportunity, Strengthening of • TSK acknowledges support and appreciation SHG Group /women empowerment, Skill development Positive: Baghuapal (14), Sansailo (21), Duburi (33), Ranagudi (39), Gabaraghati (60), Hatibari (83), Trijanga (90), Sansailo (100), Kaitha (112)

- Employment benefit from Tejaswini Program - Got employment and living standard changed - Training for employment, Employed in company - Provided training on tailoring/ stationery/painting for employment - More employment in local area created - I ndirectly employed in Tata steel - Employed by tata steel / company follows all Govt rules and regulations / good salary compared to other company Positive + Suggestions TSK is committed to its program on women Duburi (6), Pankapal (9), Manitira (10), empowerment and assistance to local community to Khurunti (17), Asanabahali (18), Baragadia (19), improve their livelihood. For this TSK is taking up Gabaraghati (23,24,44), Trijanga (31), following measures: Bhitarmanika (32), Baghuapal (49), Chandia • Establishment of Skill Development Centre & (55), Ambasara (65) Rural Micro Entrepreneurship Incubator at Kalinganagar also planned under CER projects - Importance on Local Employment (Ref. CER table 1a). Timeline- 4 Years - Employment to widows • TSK confirms Self Help Group activities will - Employment to tribal people continue and will be further strengthened based - Employment priority to land losers on specific requirements being received. - Reservation for local people employment • Women empowerment & Vocational training facility (Activities to cover areas like Chandia, Dhapanki, Mangobindapur, Sarangpur, Kacherigan) already being undertaken under CSR in most villages. • Mushroom and kitchen gardens have been proved extremely beneficial during the pandemic situation Negatives • A MOU has been signed with Government of Danagadi (15), Sukinda (35), Baliapal (56), Odisha for employment of local people. This Golagaon (57), Gabaraghati (74), system is already in place and preference is Baragadia (96), Duburi (104), given to people based on eligibility. Baragadia (109,110) Total direct and in direct employment for expansion project will be about 15,000. - Local people not getting employment / Skill • In addition, there will be opportunities for self- harassment to local people employment through new entrepreneurship - Unemployment around 10 km radius program. - Only few people got employment in company • TSK Further confirms that it conducts several program to make local people employable in and around the plant, which has already been mentioned before.

- 6 -

2. Greenery development, Environment Pollution, Rainwater Harvesting a) Air & Water pollution • TSK is committed to control environment Positive: pollution by implementing state of the art Gabaraghati (68), Sansailo (75), Hatibari (83), facilities to attain industry benchmark. Madhuban (101), Mirigchal (108), Mandapada • Existing and proposed expansion project will (3), Dholapathar (30), Trijanga (31) have such facilities like better combustion in coke plant, higher efficiency bag filters. - Air & Water pollution measure taken up by • Pollution control measures have been elaborated company in Chapter 4 of EIA Report. - Taken up pollution control measures inside plant - Plantation done by company in Kalinganagar & jajpur - Plantation done by company Positive + Suggestions: • TSK will install state-of-art pollution control unit Duburi (34), Chandia (69), Chandia (84), in the plant. As required, water sprinkling will be Gabaraghati (94), Bandhgan (103), Sulia (52), carried out on roads frequently. Chandia (69), Bandhgan (103), Duburi (34) • As per regulation, TSK is already providing ambient air quality and water quality data on-line - More plantation to protect pollution to Pollution Control Board and being displayed at - To takeup plantation in nearby villages and in plant gate for information to local people. Same main road to protect pollution will be incorporate in upcoming expansion • TSK is committed to meet 33% green cover in and around the plant. 4.5 lakhs plantation has already been done till FY20 and is continuing to achieve the target • TSK has taken up mass plantation in nearby villages and besides main roads to protect pollution under CER scheme. Negative: • TSK mentions that lot of work is happening as Gadpur (27), Sukinda (35), Gobaraghati (41,46, already listed above 47), Golagaon (57), Baragadia (109,110), • In order to help the villages, TSK is has been Baliapal (56), Kaitha (113), Baragadia (96) developing ponds over last 10 years. This includes watershed management, new ponds, - Air & Water pollution, domestic animal desilting existing ponds. These is as part of affected by diseases / Agricultural field ongoing CSR activities damaged due to scarcity of water • As part of rain water harvesting support, 10 - Pollution / water crisis / kidney diseases / ponds have been dug at different villages in FY Flue Gas emission 20. 2 have been done in FY 21. - Pollution / High TDS in Drinking Water • Green belt development is continuous process. - Low Plantation/Ground water depleted TSK will continue this. TSK has planned mass - Tree cutting by company and not doing community plantation every year within 25 plantation, trees cutting for road widening panchayats around the plant along with road from Duburi to Chandikhol. side plantation in areas is planned in places like Pankhpal chowk to Military chowk and Dangadi to Jakhpura to cover areas like Baghbahali, Jakhapura, Manipatra. - CER initiative (@ 5000 plantation every year) – Ref CER table 2c (Time Line 4 years). • TSK has also planned Development of a Biodiversity Park at Jakhapura of Kalinganagar Industrial area under CER initiatives (Ref. CER table 2a) – Timeline 4 Years • Cutting of trees for road widening is by NHAI and not under the preview of PP. However TSK has contacted NHAI and has offered support to carry out plantation in Kalinganagar area

- 7 -

3. Community Infrastructure a) Improvement in Community development • TSK continuously engages with the local community for their development. Positive: • For example - ARUNIMA three day event was Baghuapal (14), Bandhgan (28), Duburi (33), held from January 30th to February 1st, 2020 at Golagaon (38), Olia (42), Kalajhira (64), Sukinda Bhavan and reached to around 2400 Pankapal (67), Duburi (72), Rangitang (88) beneficiaries in periphery. Same theme will continue for next four years is based on a need - Life style improvement of tribal people felt to focus on education on water in ecosystem - Solar light/Road/communication provided and also inspired by United Nations mission of - Many developments in local area declaring 2018-28 as Water Action Decade - Transportation from sukinda provided • One College bus from Danagadi to Sukinda - Established Club (Rangitang) College has already been started. • Construction of road at Bhardaposi, Chandia GP and Renovation of Pond at Bhardaposi, Chandia GP completed.

Positive & Suggestions: Some of the other being taken up by TSK are: Manitira (4,36), Jakhapura (12) • TSK will initiate repair of village roads at Sulia (52), Ambasara (65), Duburi (66), Chandia, Sarangapur, Khurunti and Nuagan Dakhinpasi (91), Sukinda (102), Pankapal under SIA need assessment. (106,107), • TSK is planning to provide solar powered street lights in Kalinganagar area under SIA need - Park at Duburi assessment - Park at Jakhapura village • TSK is planning construction of Bus-shelter from - NABARD programm in all surrounding Dangadi to Gobarghati (6 Nos.) under SIA need villages assessment - Park in local schools • Biodiversity park at Jalhapura is proposed under - Club house and Puja ghar in Pankpal CER and will take 4 years ((Ref. CER table 2a) - Provide vehicle facility to local students • Community toilet in Duburi Chowk will be taken up under CSR by 2022 (Ref CER table 3a) • Tribal Heritage Centre to be setup in 5 years under CER at Sukinad / Danagadi blockThese initiatives will be further strengthened under CER budget and all panchayats within 10 km Radial coverage from the plant will get these benefits (Ref CER Table 3) Timeline 4 Years Negative: • TSK has also planned development of a Danagadi (15), Baragadia (96) Sukinda (35), Biodiversity Park at Jakhapura of Kalinganagar Hudisahi (114) Industrial area under CER initiatives (Ref. CER table 2a) - Time Line 4 Years - Park and city not developed by Tata Steel • Road side plantation in areas is planned in the - Separate road for transport places like Pankhpal chowk to Military chowk - Placement of Waste bins / Repairing of and Dangadi to Jakhpura to cover areas like schools (Baragadia) Baghbahali, Jakhapura, Manipatra. Ref. CER - No development - Drinking Water, Electricity Table 2b) (Hudisahi) • Children playing corner & parks is planned in primary schools of nearby villages of Gobarghati, Baragadia, Kapuriapada, Trijanga, Nariabanga, Duburi. Time Line - 3 Years b) Irrigation & Check Dam for Agriculture, Rain • TSK is supporting local area with water shed water harvesting management program. It will further strengthen Positive + Suggestions: this under CSR program. Nimapali (53), Fuljhar (58) • Springshed study and water conservation initiative will be taken up under CER (Ref CER Table 5b) Time Line 3 Years

- 8 -

c) Sanitation facilities and Public toilet • TSK confirmed that it will take up construction of Positive & Suggestions: a community Toilet block near Duburi public Dakhinpasi (91) - To construct Public toilet at market is already undertaken under CER (Ref Duburi market CER table 3a). by 2022 • TSK planning to provide Sanitation facilities/public toilets in Kalinganagar area in villages like Baragadia, Chandia, Ollala, Ranagundi & Nadiabhanga under SIA need assessment d) Improvement of road condition from Duburi • Duburi Sukinda road is a NH and not under to Sukinda & Widening of Brahmani and purview of PP. Brahmani and military chowk Military chowk road road is under JCDL (Jajpur Cluster Development Positive & Suggestions: Limited, under Government of Odisha). Manatira (36) • Both road job has been already undertaken by - Brahmani chowk to Millitary chowk road Govt. Of Odisha & NHAI. widening • However, TSK continues to discuss local issues Negative - Sukinda (35) with Govt. Also if the need arises, TSK shall Sukinda Duburi Road bad condition extend support as necessary as per Government guidelines to support the development.

4. Sports & Welfare (Skill development & alternative employment capabilities) a) Training on sports and providing sports infrastructure • TSK has started many coaching centres for Positive: football, athletic, karate and kabaddi are Sukinda (11), Jagadih (22), Kumbhirgadia (63), ongoing. Duburi (72) • TSK also supports local youth group to startup a social enterprise for promoting outdoor training - Provided Training on sports program like mountaineering etc.. - Training and facility provided for Sports and • TSK is also promoting regular events around mountaineering football, athletics and kabadi - Support and training for Mountaineering to local youth provided Positive & suggestions: • TSK has further plans to develop sport Manitira (4), Duburi (6, 66), Golagaon (38), infrastructure like Construction of One Rural Chandia (55), Ambasara (65) sports complex near to Duburi (Sukinda Block) to promote Tribal youth sports & athletics skill - Sports Complex in Kalinganagar under CER. (Ref CER Table 4a) - Play Ground in Duburi • TSK will also facilitate construction of sports - Stadium in Duburi area facilities / infrastructure in upcoming stadium project at Jajpur under CER programme (Ref CER Table 4b) Time Line 4 Years

- 9 -

5. Health, chronic disease prevention and Drinking water a) Extending coverage of Medical Facility • TSK acknowledges support and appreciation through Mobile Medical Units (MMU) & Free Medical facilities and Health Facility improvement Positive: Jakhapura1, Mandapada (3), Sansailo (26), Bandhgan (28), Dholapathar (30), Olia (42), Kalajhira (64), Pankapal (67)

- People are getting quality health care facilities, along with free of cost medicine - Getting treatment at Tata Medica not going to Cuttack Positive & Suggestions: • TSK is committed to reach out to all people in Duburi (6), Gobardhanpur (13), Gabaraghati the surrounding villages and shall extend all the (23,24,85), Golagaon (38), Duburi (50), medical facilities for improvement in the health Ambasara (65), Jajpur Road (71) conditions • For medical facilities Mobile Medical Units - To Provide free medical facility to Local (MMU) are already deployed. These have a people/Mobile Medical facility in all beneficiary base in excess of one lakh per year panchayat in and around Kalinganagar. - Health facility to tribal people - Provide Health facility like other part of India as tata provides

- 10 -

Negative: • TSK will establish community Health Research Danagadi (15), Sukinda (35), Gabaraghati Centre for chronic Health issues for (41,47), Pankapal (54), Baragadia (96) Kalinganagar peripheral villages under CER project (Ref. CER Table 5a). Time Line 4 Years. - Mobile medical facility not provided in Based on outcome of study, way forward will be Trijanga decided along with District Administration. - High treatment cost at Tata Medica • TSK confirms that Medical Mobile Units are in - Bad condition of Sukinda Medical operation for several years under CSR activities - Local People facing Health issue which has a MBBS doctor and operates regular - Not getting health care facility OPD. - People are facing skin issues • TSK assures that it will look into gap of service and take appropriate action. • TSK also assure that health camps will be undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km under ongoing CSR activities. • TSK assured to look into further enhancement of quality of treatment & patients care. • Tata Medica is a 100 bed super specialty hospital, where rates are reasonable / comparable to other similar facilities in state of Odisha. Facilities are ready for expansion to 200 beds. - For Covid it had been providing free service to community - TSK mentioned that Displaced Persons get free medical facility at par with employees - Special ward is provided at Tata Medica to cater economically weaker community at reasonable cost • TSK also mentioned that it has supported other hospital with facilities to enable them give better service: AC ward is provided in Dangagdi hospital, DG set has been provided at Jajpur Road Hospital & Sukinda CHC for enabling better care

- 11 -

b) Enhancing Drinking Water facility to Village • Piped water supply has been established in 5 area villages: In Trijanga village water supply already made to 162 household, in Sansailo rehab Positive: colony water supply already made to 100 Mandapada (3), Ramsulia (5), Bandhgan (28), households, in Ramthenga self-rehab colony Dholapathar (30), Bhitarmanika (32), Olia (42), water supply already made to 22 households Kalajhira (64), Pankapal (67), Rangitang (88) and in Bharadaposi water supply already made to 37 households from these bore wells through - Tube well / Drinking water provided pipeline. - Water scarcity resolved in his area • Full-fledged water treatment plant has been (Bhitaramanika) established in 2018/19 at Gobarghati and is successfully in operation. From this WTP presently piped water supply is already being made to 793 households. There is plan to provide water connection to further 207 households over next 2 years through pipeline. • Bore well & tube well with storage facilities in various villages like - Trijanga, Sansailo Rehab colony, Ramthenga self-rehab colony & Bhardaposi have been carried out. Positive Suggestions: • Drinking water is already a priority item under Pankapal (9), Ampolaba (43), Gabaraghati (99) CSR. • This initiative will continue. Further additional - More importance on drinking water requirement is being examined along with district - Improvement of drinking water facility administration as district administration is taking (Ampolaba, Goabaraghati) up drinking water supply plan • Over 450 tubewell in surrounding villages have Negative - been provided. Kantipur (105), Hudisahi (114) • TSK confirmed that 12 hand pumps already installed in Pankapal Village. - Drinking water problem not solved (Kantipur) • We have installed 28 nos. of tube wells in FY 20 - Drinking water not available (Hudisahi) (Feb and March) and already installed 30 nos. of tube wells in FY 21. • TSK planning for Construction of manual & solar based - borewell & tube well with storage facilities in villages of Gobarghati, Baragadia, Mantira, Trijanga & Sansilo Grampanchayat (Ref CER 5b) in next 2 years 6. Miscellaneous a) Removal of Police verification during TSK confirms that as per standard practice and employment. directive of district administration, police verification is Positive + Suggestions: required for persons being employed. Duburi (34), Kumbhirgadia (45), Duburi (50), Kaitha (113)

b) Shifting of labour colony for safety of local ladies • TSK confirms that it has provided for labour colony at corridor area, which is about 8 km from Duburi area. Positive + Suggestions: • TSK has got in touch with local administration & Duburi (6) police for increasing vigilance in market area • TSK has facilitated grocery and vegetable supplies at labour colony to reduce need of labour to go to market area

- 12 -

Details of issues raised during PH and PP commitments

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 1. Biswajit Welcoming the panel & gathering, he Technical PP is promoting 500 Nayak, expressed that the second era of education vocational and (within 5 years) Jakhapura development to be started by the extension technical training to project of M/s. Tata Steel Ltd. He said that improve the skill Sukinda as well as Kalinganagar area will sets of local youth be more developed if the project comes under various CSR and more development work will be carried activities. However, out by TATA Steel Ltd. He expressed his further provision is willingness towards the expansion proposal kept under CER. and said that living style of local people has been improved because of TATA Steel. Rehabilitated people are also get benefitted. CSR & Many developmental works have been done in his village. He emphasized about the child labour & education. He said that People are getting quality health care through mobile medical facilities along with free of cost medicine. He demanded quality technical education for local & Sukinda peoples with free of cost by the year 2020, so that their skill can be developed and they can easily get job.

2. Laxmipriya She said that old age education has been Training on Present initiative of - Mohanta, initiated by TATA steel Ltd for which old kitchen garden training on kitchen Sulia, age peoples become literate. Apart from to all nearby garden under CSR Rangadia education TATA steel ltd provided different villages activities is for all training programme like cleanliness drive, surrounding villages. kitchen garden etc. They have done PP will look into cleanness drive at roads, ponds, tube wells strengthening it and other areas. Now she is working on further. kitchen garden by the training of TATA steel. She demanded If company provides them land it would be better for them and also suggested to include nearby villages in kitchen garden programme.

3. Pradeep He expressed his views through a poem No specific PP acknowledges Ojha,. and narrate that kalinganagar is a beautiful issue the support and Manda-pada place and such opportunity will never come appreciation again to make a plant by M/s TATA steel.

Huge investment is there and there will be no deficient of money for each of them. Health care facilities, Medical, Medical facilities & free medicine to local villagers, - lift irrigation facilities, tube well construction, drinking water facilities to villages have been provided by TATA Steel Ltd. Plantation have been done by TATA steel to restrict air pollution. They are getting safety & respect because of TATA steel ltd and if the plant will safe they will be safe. Their business is rising day by day & living style is also much more improved because of TATA Steel Ltd.

- 13 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 4. Susant Greeting to the panel & gathering, he Park & Sports PP will develop 1900 Samal, Jilla expressed that the Kalinganagar becomes Complex. playground to (within 5 years) Parisad an industrial hub because of former chief promote sports. Member, minister late Sri Biju Pattnayak, whose Manitira dream about industrial complex in Contract for PP has established Kalinganagar. He requested to ADM & various works contract TATA Steel that one park should be within Steel management provided for local people at Duburi where Plant. procedure for the former Chief minister inaugurated the vendors steel hub. He also suggested to provide a sports complex inside Kalinganagar PP confirms that industrial area to enhance the ability of there is a well- 1. local boys as the local people give their established vendor land to the plant and at present they have selection process no land with them to make a play ground. wherein preference He also told that opportunity for contract of to local vendor is different works inside the plant should be built in. As a result, facilitated to different people who have the a large number of ability and it should not be limited to few local vendor base is people. He told that the few people to already established. whom the plant has given different contract works, have spent the money for unsocial Contract PP will look into the activities should be black listed. At last he termination of matter and demanded to provide a park and a sports contractors who appropriate steps complex. engage in will be taken to stop unsocial work. this menace.

2. 5. Ms Welcoming the panel, gathering & print No specific PP acknowledges Laxmipriya media, He said that TATA steel have done issue the support and Mohanta, more developmental works the area. The appreciation plant has provided education & drinking Ramsulia water facility in this area. TATA steel has done more works on environment. The plant also looks after to the local tribal peoples & their living standard has been changed because of TATA steel. Now tribal children will go to different schools & colleges for education. He expressed that if the plant will come then more development work will be carried out by the plant. At last he gave thanks to TATA steel and requested to the tribal peoples to attached with TATA steel for more development in future.

6. Amar Singh The company has developed education No specific PP acknowledges Banera, system. The life style has been drastically issue the support and Gobar Ghati changed by the company. appreciation

The area would be more developed if we extend supported. The tribal in general would be developed

He supported the project

- 14 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 6. Bhagya laxmi Welcoming the panel, gathering & print Inclusion of all PP confirms that all - Rout, Duburi media, She said that TATA steel has made panchayat panchayats within developmental work only in few panchayat under Tata 10 km radial so that all people are not get benefitted. All Steel’s social coverage from the the panchayat should be included in the benefit. plant are already developmental work. Although Duburi & included. Bargadia panchayat is nearest to TATA steel but facilities has not been provided there. She suggested to provide a play Contract PP will look into the ground in nearby area. She also told that termination of matter and - free medical facilities should be provided to contractor who appropriate steps local people. Mobile medical van is not engaged in will be taken to stop covering all the panchayat. She also told unsocial work. this menace. that a play ground should be provided & she also emphasized on permanent employment. She suggested that the labour colony should be far away from local Health facility PP confirms that habitation so that it will be safer for local improvement Medical Mobile girls & ladies. She told that training should Units are in 400 be given to appropriate people so that they operation for last 2 – (within 4 years) will be get benefitted and they can earn 3 years under CSR money. She said that TATA steel has done activities. PP works including some SSG group and she assures that it will requested to TATA steel authority to look into gap of include all panchayat in the SSG group so service and take that more people can be benefitted. She appropriate action. expressed that their expectation will higher when it comes to TATA steel ltd. At last she told that the few people to whom the plant has given different contract works, who have spent their money for unsocial activities should be black listed.

Employment Already system and Included Sl.No.4 opportunity process for local employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility

Provision of PP will develop Included Sl.No.1 play ground playgrounds to promote sports.

Skill PP is promoting development vocational and training for technical training to women. improve the skill sets of local women under various CSR activities

- 15 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 7. Kousalya Greeting to the panel & gathering, She said Strengthening PP confirms that this - Patra, Tata that TATA steel has provided them training of SHG Group. activity (Self Help Colony for tailoring & paintning. If TATA steel will Group) is underway support them more, they will be advanced and will be further much more. She supported TATA steel and strengthened based requested to give more man power to their on specific SHG group. requirements being received.

8. Manjulata Greeting to the panel & gathering, She said Repair of Fani PP will examine - Mahanta, that TATA steel has provided her training damaged case and take Sulia for cultivation of mushroom and provided a house. appropriate action. room for the purpose of mushroom firming in which she earned money. During cyclone “fani” the room provided by TATA is damaged and she requested to repair the room.

9. Sanghamitra Welcoming the panel & gathering, She said Education PP is already 200 Ray, that mistake will not be repeated again and facilities focused on all these (within 3 years) Sarpanch, care should be taken to local people. She under its CSR Pankapal emphasized on health, education & activities. employment. She requested to make more CSR activities in all the villages. At last she PP is working on told that importance should be given on 1000 school project education, drinking water facility and local to improve quality of employment. education. Under this PP has already covered 48 panchyats in Kalinganagar.

Further various scholarship schemes are provided to support approx. xx students per year. To further strengthen quality of education a school has been established with Loyala Group in Kalinganagar area.

For tribal students, an Ashram school is planned subject to various district administration approvals and support.

- 16 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) Medical For Medical facilities Included Sl.No.6 facilities Mobile Medical Units (MMU) are already deployed. There are 6 such facilities in use and have a beneficiary base in excess of one lakh per year in and around Kalinganagar.

Drinking water Drinking water is 100 facility already a priority (within 2 years) item under CSR and over 450 tube well in surrounding villages. Also piped water supply has been established in 5 villages. PP confirmed that 12 hand pump already installed in Pankapal Village. This initiative will continue. Further additional requirement will be examined appropriate action will taken with approval of district administration

Local Already system and Employment process for local employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility

10. Akshya Welcoming the panel & gathering, He told Employ-ment Already system and - Singh, that they always support the plant and will opportunity process for local Mantira extend their co operation in future. He employment is in demanded that some of the local people practice, wherein will not find employment which should be preference is given resolved. to people based on . eligibility

This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha.

- 17 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 11. Sobha She said, M/s. Tata Steel Ltd, Jamshedpur No specific PP acknowledges - Nayak, has given her quality education and issue the support and Sukinda training on sports and she also trained appreciation many students of her village. She expressed her gratitude to M/s. Tata Steel Ltd.

12. Kalandi Welcoming the panel & gathering, He told Control of PP has already - Sethy, that development has been done because pollution implemented Jakhapura of industries in kalinganagar area. He various pollution requested TATA steel authority to give control measures in more importance to the environment and to their existing provide a beautiful park at abandoned area operating units. in Jakhapura village. The proposed project will install the state of art pollution control equipment. The pollution control measures have been elaborated in Chapter 4 of EIA Report. Total allocated EMP budget would be Rs. 2,620 crore.

Development of PP will discuss & 400 (within 5 Park at seek approval from years) abandoned district area of administration for Jakhapura creating suitable biodiversity park at Jakhapura

13. Sambit She said that environment & water is being Community PP already - Mishra, polluted however TATA Steel Ltd is doing development undertaken various Gobhardhanp best efforts to mitigate these problems. community ur Gobardhanpur Panchayat has come under development the development area of M/s. Tata Steel programme under Ltd. She said M/s. Tata Steel Ltd has CSR activities. provided them knowledge to use rain water These initiatives will in their daily water usage. She suggested be further extended to give training programme to local people under CER budget to deal with skin diseases & other and all panchayats diseases. Every panchayat should be within 10 km radial included in its peripheral development corage from the programme. plant will get this benefits.

- 18 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 14. Rasmita She said that there are many industries but Inclusion of PP acknowledges - Hembram only Tata Steel Ltd listen the views & Baragadia and appreciation problems of people. She said that over Duburi villages Tejaswini Programs conducted by TATA under PP confirms that steel Ltd, in which the hidden talents of the community Badagadia and women were developed & later they got development Duburi village are employment in different plants of M/s. Tata programme already included Steel Ltd. The tribal people have and various developed their life style, education and developmental work can ride the Everest Mountain and it done uder CSR happened because of M/s. Tata Steel Ltd. activities. She demanded not only displaced people but also all the areas should be developed PP will continue this and Baragadia and Duburi village should endeavour under be included in the developmental work. CSR activities.

15. Pritam Kumar Welcoming the panel & gathering, He said Employment Already system and - Ray, Dangadi that unemployment increases day by day. opportunity process for local Local people are not getting employment in employment is in the plant, parks and cities are not practice, wherein developed by TATA steel ltd like preference is given Jamsedpur. Skill harassment have been to people based on done to the local villagers. Mobile medical eligibility facilities have not been provided at Trijanga village. Health care facilities at This is as per MOU TATA medica hospital is very much higher, signed with so that ordinary people cannot afford. Now- Government of a-days people are suffering from Heart, Odisha. kidney and eye diseases in surrounding area of the plant. He stated that such type Health care For Medical facilities Included Sl.No.6 of development is not required. At last he facilities Mobile Medical told that he support to the expansion Units (MMU) are project subjected to employment of local already deployed. villagers. There are 6 such facilities in use and have a beneficiary base in excess of one lakh per year in and around Kalinganagar.

Mobile medical PP confirms that Included Sl.No.6 facilities at Mobile Medical Trijanga village campaign already in place

Heart, kidney PP confirms to carry and eye out health study in diseases consultation with district administration. Based on outcome of study, way forward will be decided along with District Administration.

16. Champa-bati She said that TATA steel Ltd has made No specific PP acknowledges - Mahanta, more developmental work in surrounding issue the support and Saljanga areas and she supported the project. appreciation

- 19 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 17. Bhagyabati Welcoming the panel & gathering, She Employment The total direct and - Jena, Khurati demanded that more employment should opportunity indirect employment be given to local villagers. for this developmental project will be about 15,000.

In addition their will be opportunities for self-employment through new entrepreneurship programme. 18. Ajaya bala She said employment should be provided Employment Already system and - Singh, to local youths opportunity process for local Asanabahali employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility

This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha. 19. Bebina She said that she was given assurance to Employment Already system and - Mallick , get job but till date it has not been done so assurance in process for local Baragadia far. If the matter was consider then she will Tata Steel employment is in be obliged to TATA steel. practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha.

However, PP will examine this specific case and take appropriate action as per set rules. 20. Nanika She said that M/s. Tata Steel Ltd has taken No specific PP acknowledges - Jamuda, many efforts for its peripheral development issue the support and Gobar Ghati and will be continued in future. She appreciation TATA Colony welcomed the expansion project.

21. Basanti She said that she was selling country No specific PP acknowledges - Badra, liquior(Handia) but now she get employed issue the support and Sansailo, in TATA Steel and her living standard has appreciation TATA Colony changed. 22. Swarnalata She told that she was associated with M/s. No specific PP will continue this - Dalai, Tata Steel Ltd since 2016 and she is a issue initiative. Jagadhi mountaineer. Facilities and training has been provided by M/s TATA Steel Ltd, so that she was able to go south America and climb Everest mountain. It was happened due to TATA.

- 20 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 23. Swarnalata Welcoming the panel & gathering, She told More schools PP is already Included Sl.No.9 Banera, that TATA Steel provided better education focused on all these Gobarghati facilities for small children. She welcomed under its CSR the project and demanded more school activities. and better education at displaced areas. Better Medical facilities should be provided PP is working on to people. Displaced people must be given 1000 school project land Patta. The widows should be given to improve quality of employment opportunities. education. Under this PP has already covered 48 panchyats in Kalinganagar .

For tribal students, an Ashram school is planned subject to various district administration approvals and support.

Medical For Medical facilities Included Sl.No.6 facilities Mobile Medical Units (MMU) are already deployed. There are 6 such facilities in use and have a beneficiary base in excess of one lakh per year in and around Kalinganagar. Employment to PP will extend & - widow continue the present medical facilities. Under CSR activities, PP already works on SHG development for helping all such needy people.

- 21 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 24. Babuli Purty, He said the area should be Education, The area will be Included Gobarghati Welcoming the panel & gathering, He said health & developed further Sl.No.1,6&9 the development should be made for local employment to with respect to tribal people under Article 5 & 6 of Tribal tribals infrastructure, Act. The tribal people must be given education, employment. He proposed for better communication, education, communication and health health and facilities to the tribal people. employment opportunities to the local people. In addition, PP provides Jyoti Fellowship Programme and professional education to assist meritorious SC/ST students under CSR activities and confirm that this initiative will continue to develop the skills and education to tribal youths.

25. Musi Nayak, Welcoming the panel & gathering, She No specific PP acknowledges - Karadagadia said, the women were given better training issue the support and for livelihood creation. It was possible appreciation because of M/s. Tata Steel Ltd and it will be continue in future.

26. Trilochan Welcoming the panel & gathering, M/s. Technical PP will undertake Included Sl.No.1 Mahanta, Tata Steel Ltd has developed the areas. Education vocational and Sansailo, Although 100% development have not Centre industrial training TATA Colony been achieved, 60-70% development of programme to the the area is being developed by TATA local youth to Steel. The dropout students are going to develop their skill school now. People do not go to Cuttack sets for employment for health problem but are being treated in /employability TATA Medica. He said the company will do more developmental work for people in future. He suggested providing a Hi-tech technical institute for better technical education & proper training should be provided to the youths.

- 22 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 27. Surendra Welcoming the panel & gathering, He said Disclosure of As per the - Kumar Air & water get polluted due to industry. pollution load regulation, PP will Haibru, Domestic animals affected by many provide the ambient Gadpur diseases and could not survive. Nearby air quality and water peoples are affected by skin, kidney and quality data on-line other diseases. He told that people are to Pollution Control displaced without their knowledge. Board and the same Agricultural field get damaged due to data will be scarcity of water. Pollution control board displayed at the will look after into the matter. He told that plant gate for several complaints made to ADM regarding information to the displacement but no result has been local people. obtained so far. Issues related All standards as per - to displace- Government R&R ment Policy is in place. Half yearly compliance update is submitted to district administration.

28. Binod Welcoming the panel & gathering, He told Pollution level PP emphasized that - Hembram, that TATA steel has done more to be minimised all pollution control Bandhagan developmental work in 48 villages since equipment will be as 2006. Drinking water, solar light, road per best available communication, health care facilities have techniques been provided. If the expansion project will complying to come then more developmental work will pollution control be done and he supported the expansion. norm. The plant will He sugested that pollution level of the plant be designed on zero should be minimised. effluent discharge principle.

29. Biswajeet Welcoming the panel & gathering, He told Skill PP will undertake Included Sl.No.1 Raj, that TATA steel has done more development vocational and Baragadia developmental work than other industries training of industrial training in kalinganagar area. He suggested to Sukinda programme to the provide skill assessment training local youth to programme to local people of 48 develop their skill panchayats of sukinda constituency. sets for employment and entrepreneurship.

3. 30. Sri Dhruba Welcoming the panel & gathering, He told No specific PP acknowledges - Charan that TATA steel has made his commitment. issue the support and Mahanta, Plantation, Drinking water, road appreciation communication, health care facilities have TUKU, been provided. He supported the Dholapathar expansion project and told that If the expansion project will come then more developmental work will be done.

- 23 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 4. 31. Sri Birendra Welcoming the panel & gathering, He told Employment Already system and - Jamuda, that TATA steel has made more plantation opportunity to process for local Trijanga in Kalinganagar as well as in Jajpur. He land loser employment is in told that TATA has done more practice, wherein

developmental work than other industries preference is given in kalinganagar area. He to people based on supported the expansion project and told eligibility. This is as that more employment will be generated if per MOU signed the expansion project will come. He also with Government of suggested that local people who were lose Odisha. their land and houses will give more separate priority in employment. PP is already undertaking training programme for development of the skill of the local people for employment / employability / entrepreneur-ship

32. Biren Tuddu, Sri Tudu greeted the panel & gathering and Employment to Already system and - Bhitar-manika thanked M/s Tata Steel to give opportunity local people process for local to express his views in the public hearing employment is in meeting. He told that rehabilitated people practice, wherein have been benefited by all the facility but preference is given the surrounding area people are facing to people based on issue of dust and air pollution. He eligibility. This is as requested the panchayat members to per MOU signed submit representation to M/s Tata Steel for with Government of 10 to 15 % reservation in direct and indirect Odisha. employment. He informed that earlier they were facing water scarcity in the area but the issue has been solved by M/s Tata Steel Limited. He again reminded Tata Steel to give employment to local people.

33. Gyana Welcoming the dais and gathering, Sri No specific PP acknowledges - Ranjan Sahu informed that local area has been issue the support and Sahoo, developed by M/s Tata Steel. Local people appreciation Duburi have been engaged by direct and indirect employment, a local school i.e. Loyala School has been established by the company. He informed that local area will be developed by the expansion project. He urged people to support the expansion project of M/s Tata Steel.

34. Sashi bhusan Welcoming the gathering, Sri Swain Issues of police PP confirms that as - Swain, expressed his support for the expansion verification per standard Duburi project of Tata Steel Limited. He informed during practice and that the area will be affected by pollution, employment. directive of district so Tata Steel is taking up plantation activity administration, and other environment protective Police Verification is measures to protect the environment. He required for all complaint that their names are not getting persons being shortlisted in the name of police verification employed. and requested to resolve the issue. .

- 24 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 35. Sushant Welcoming the panel & gathering, He Improvement of The road being - Mallick, expressed his displeasure on the bad road condition under NH and Sukinda condition of Sukinda Duburi Road and from Duburi to therefore it is not Sukinda medical. He informed that they are Sukinda. under the purview of facing issue of pollution and kidney PP affected disease in the area. He requested M/s Tata Steel Limited to fulfill the demand Pollution PP will install state- - of public and then they will get support problem of-art pollution from the people. Further, he demanded control unit in the employment to the local people. Finally he plant water opposed the project. sprinkling will be carried out on roads frequently.

Employment The total direct and - opportunity indirect employment for this developmental project will be about 15,000.

PP will undertake Included Sl.No.1 vocational and industrial training programme to the local youth to develop their skill sets for employment and entrepreneurship.

Kidney related PP confirms to carry Included health issues out health study in Sl.No.15 consultation with district administration. Based on outcome of study, way forward will be decided along with District Administration

36. Susil kumar Sri Samal supported the project and Widening of This road is under - Samal, requested widening of Brahmani chowk to Brahmani and JCDL (Jajpur Manatira Military chowk road. Military chowk Cluster road Development Limited, under Government of Odisha)

- 25 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 37. Subrat Kumar He informed that M/s Tata Steel Limited is Employment The total direct and - Singh, taking up CSR and development activity in opportunity indirect employment Mantira the area. He urge public to support the for this company. He further informed that Tata developmental Steel has established a shishu Mandir, project will be about develop classrooms in college in his 15,000. village. He further requested local employment and opportunity to local PP will undertake contractors. vocational and industrial training programme to the local youth to develop their skill sets for employment and entrepreneurship.

38.5. Sudam Sri Nayak greeted the panel and gathering Stadium in the PP will develop Included Sl.No.4 Nayak, and told that development activities has area playgrounds to Golagaon took place in the area. Industrialization will promote sports. lead to development of local area and

development of local area will further lead Health facilities Health campaign to development of the state. He urged with Mobile Medical people to support the expansion project of unit is already in the company and demanded a stadium, place.PP assure transportation facility, health and education that the health facility in the area. He expressed his camps will be support for the expansion project. undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km Education Included Sl.No.9 facilities PP will extend the development of model schools under thousand school projects, so as to promote educational facilities for children.

39. Dhaneswar He told that M/s Tata Steel has supported No specific PP acknowledges - Jena, him in education and training and now he is issue the support and Ranagundi employed in a company. He urged people appreciation to come forward and Tata Steel will support them. He supported the expansion project.

40. Rakesh Sri Chakra informed that M/s Tata Steel is No specific PP acknowledges - Kumar providing educational course and other issue the support and Chakra, facility to local people. He urged people to appreciation Kaithe come forward and try harder for fulfillment of their wishes. He expressed his support for the expansion project.

- 26 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 41.6. Sri Harish He informed that deforestation took place Greenery Green belt 190 (within 5 Chaiburu, by establishment of Tata Steel plant. The development development is years) Gobarghati local area is facing issue of pollution due to continuous process. deforestation. Further local people are PP will continue this

facing health issue in the area. Finally he initiative to achieve

opposed the project. 33% or more greenery in and around the plant. Mass community plantation every year within 25 panchayats around the plant alond with road side plantation

PP will install state- of-art pollution control unit in the plant water sprinkling will be carried out at roads frequently.

Health issue In addition, PP Included Sl.No.6 assure that the health camps will be undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km 42. Sisir Kumar Welcoming the gathering, Sri Barik told that No specific PP acknowledges - Barik, Olia, local area has developed in education. issue the support and Tata Steel is providing Solar light, drinking appreciation water and health facility. He demanded M/s Tata steel to establish small gardens in the local schools.

- 27 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 43. Padmanabha Welcoming the gathering, Sri Mallick Medical PP confirms that Included Sl.No.6 Mallick, expressed his support for the expansion facilities in MMU (Mobile Gobarghati project of M/s Tata Steel Limited. He Gobarghati Medical Unit) is demanded drinking water and healthcare already deployed in facility in his village area surrounding area and includes area referred to. Will further increase depending upon requirement.

Drinking water Between 2012 -16, Included Sl.No.9 3 tube well have been provided in this area. Further a full fleged water treatment plant has been also established in 2018/19 and is successfully in operation. Further supply network extension is also planned over next 2 years. 44. Sri Juna He demanded employment to the land Employment The total direct and - Banara, losing people in the Kalinganagar Steel opportunity to indirect employment Gobarghati Plant project. land loser for this developmental project will be about 15,000.

Already system and process for local employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha.

- 28 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 45.7. Sri Krupa- Welcoming the dais and gathering, he Special PP confirms that - sindhu supported the expansion project and package to land actions in line with Samantray, requested to provide special package to loser. all Government the land losers in Kalinganagar steel plant rules and Kumbhiragadi project, removal of police verification for notifications are a local people during employment being adhered to. Removal of police PP confirms that as verification per standard during practice and - employment. directive of district administration, Police Verification is required for all persons being employed.

46.8. Sri Sini Soy, She told that they are facing various due to Employment The total direct and - Gobarghati establishment of Tat Steel plant. She opportunity indirect employment further told that only people employed in for this the plant have benefitted but others are not developmental getting any benefits from Tata Steel. She project will be about informed that many people who lost their 15,000 and land are yet to get any benefit from the therefore the company. She further told that they have unemployment lost cultivation, water is getting polluted problem will reduce. and local people have died by kidney Non-receipt of disease. She did not support the project. benefit by land PP confirms that loser. actions in line with all Government rules and - notifications are Water pollution being adhered to.

The plant will be designed based on zero effluent discharge and therefore there will be no water - pollution.

- 29 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 47. Mamata She greeted the public and informed that Water pollution The project has - Kalundia, people are facing air, water and soil been conceived Gobaghati pollution. They are getting dirty water from based on Zero the borewell. She further informed that the effluent discharge medical facility provided by Tata Medica is principle therefore very expensive. impact on water pollution is not likely.

Air pollution The present developmental project will install the state-of-art air - pollution control equipment.

Tata Medica is Tata Medica is a very expensive super specialty hospital and rates are reasonable / comparable to other - similar facilities in state of Odisha.

48.9. Ms Draupadi Welcoming the gathering, she has got No specific PP acknowledges - Bahadur, training and support from Tata Steel issue the support and Duburi Limited. She thanked Tata Steel for the appreciation support.

49.10. Sri Greeting the dais and gathering, Sri No specific PP acknowledges - Chakradhar Tamroy requested M/s Tata Steel to issue the support and Tamroy, protect the environment. He further appreciation demanded employment and education Baghuapal facility and hoped for more development by the expansion project of M/s Tata Steel Limited.

50. Biswaranjan Welcoming the panel and gathering, Sri Harassment PP confirms that as - Soren, Duburi Soren expressed his grievance on during police per standard differences in employment to local people verification for practice and as the local people are going through employment. directive of district police verification process during administration, employment. He demanded free medical Police Verification is treatment facility to the local people. He required for all thanked the people for coming and persons being supporting the expansion project of M/s employed. Tata Steel Limited. Free medical Health campaign Included Sl.No.6 facilities with Mobile Medical unit is already in place.PP assure that the health camps will be undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km

- 30 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 11.51. Sri Cludious He informed that no other plant other than No specific PP acknowledges - Pradhan, M/s Tata Steel is doing CSR activity and issue the support and Chakua only because of Tata Steel, the local appreciation people came to know about the work to be

done under CSR. He supported the expansion project.

52. Lal Bahadur He requested M/s Tata steel to plant trees Plantation of Green belt Included Mahanta, on the periphery of the surrounding villages trees development being Sl.No.41 Sulia and expand the widening of NABARD a continuous program to all surrounding village process, PP will panchayats. He supported the expansion continue this project of M/s Tata Steel Limited. initiative to achieve 33% or more Greenery in and around the plant. Tata Steel is already operating mass community plantation, focused on fruit bearing tree, under CSR program.

53. Madan Welcoming the gathering, he supported the Creating check Water shed - Mohan expansion proposal of M/s Tata Steel and dam & management Muduli, requested to make arrangement for check Water program is already Nimapali dam and water conservation to help conservation ongoing under CSR farmers, create small gardens in all nearby activities. PP will schools and direct their Tata Medica examine any hospital to accept ration card as identity specific requirement card. of this area.

PP will undertake awareness programme for the need of water conservation through their CSR acitivities and also provide training on rain water harvesting.

Tata Medical Matter will be hospital to forwarded to Tata accept ration Medical authorities. card as identity card.

- 31 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 12.54. Sri He complained that they are not getting Drinking water Drinking water is Included Sl. No. Sarangdhar drinking water supply, medical facility from supply already a priority 9 Ray, M/s Tat steel Limited in his village. He item under CSR and further complained on high treatment cost over 450 tube well in Pankapal and consultation fees at M/s Tata Medica surrounding villages. Hospital, use of same road for transporting Also piped water vehicles and local public etc. He urged M/s supply has been Tata Steel to provide medical facility, established in 5 separate road, water supply and then only villages. PP go for the expansion project. confirmed that 12 hand pump already installed in Pankapal Village. This initiative will continue. Further additional requirement will be examined appropriate action will taken with approval of district administration

High medical Tata Medical is a - treatment cost super specialty at Tata Medica hospital and rates Hospital are reasonable / comparable to other similar facilities in state of Odisha.

Medical Health campaign Included Sl.No.6 facilities with Mobile Medical unit is already in place.PP assure that the health camps will be undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km

- 32 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 55. Pradip Kumar He greeted the dais and gathering and Employment The total direct and - Behera, expressed his support on behalf of his opportunity indirect employment Chandia village panchayat for the expansion project. for this He informed that the company has done developmental many development work under CSR, project will be about however compared to development activity 15,000. by M/s Tata Steel in Jamshedpur area, this Already system and area has not been developed. He process for local demanded employment to local people and employment is in establishment of a stadium in the area. practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha

Establishment PP will develop Included Sl.No.4 of stadium playgrounds in sonsultation with local administration to promote sports& games.

56. Rama He told that, M/s Tat Steel has not planted Plantation of Green belt Included Chandra trees as per requirement (33%) and local trees development being Sl.No.41 Jamuda, people are facing the issue of pollution by a continuous Baliapa the plant. He opposed the project and process, PP will informed that people will face further issue continue this on pollution by the expansion proposal and initiative to achieve complaint that people outside the state are 33% or more getting employment where as local people Greenery in and are not considered. He further informed around the plant. that ground water level in his nearest Employment villages have been depleted and they are opportunity The total direct and facing drought issue and requested the indirect employment administration to make enquiry and take for this - suitable action to solve the issue. developmental project will be about 15,000.

Already system and process for local employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha Depletion of ground water PP confirms that project has not considered any contraction of ground water and this point is not relevant. -

- 33 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 57. Gagan He informed that people in the surrounding Ground water PP confirms that - Behera, area are facing kidney disease. He told that depletion project has not Golagaon they are supporting industrialization but not considered any environment pllution. He further informed extraction of ground that they are not getting water due to water and this point excess use of borewell water by the is not relevant. industries of Kalinganagar and the water is contaminated with iron dust. They are Air Pollution PP will install latest affecting by the flue gas emission from M/s air pollution control - Tata Steel. He told that earlier people from equipment and the Golagaon had supported the Tata Steel emission of air Project but till now they have not benefited pollutant will be well by the Tata steel project. People outside within emission the state are getting employment but local standard. people are not employed. Employment The total direct and opportunity indirect employment for this developmental - project will be about 15,000.

Already system and process for local employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha

Kidney related PP confirms to carry Included dieses out health study in Sl.No.15 consultation with district administration. Based on outcome of study, way forward will be decided along with District Administration

58. Bikash Purty, Expressing his happiness on the public Irrigation and Water shed - Falihar hearing meeting, he requested to construct check dam management check dam in his village to help agriculture program is already in the area. ongoing under CSR activities. PP will examine any specific requirement of this area.

- 34 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 59. Narayan He informed that local public have not No specific PP acknowledges - Hansda, benefited by the Tata Steel Plant. He issue the support and Baghuapal informed that Tata Steel has not appreciation succeeded in fulfilling all the needs of the people in surrounding villages and requested cooperation from all other plants in the area. He urged the public to support the expansion project and requested M/s Tata Steel to take up further development activity in the area.

60. Rukmini She informed that M/s Tata Steel has No specific PP acknowledges - Laguri, imparted training on tailoring, stationery issue the support and Gobarghati and painting and which has helped her appreciation grow and earn for herself.

61. Sushama She thanked M/s Tata Steel for all the No specific PP acknowledges - Sundhi, initiative taken by the company in her area. issue the support and Gobarghati appreciation

62. Narendra Welcoming the dais and gathering, he No specific PP acknowledges - Mahanta , informed the support provided by M/s Tata issue the support and Mangalpur steel under CSR to the local people and appreciation supported the project.

13.63. Sri He informed that they are associated with No specific PP acknowledges - Satyabrata Tata steel for the last 10 years and Tata issue the support and Das, Steel has supported in all the Youth related appreciation programs for example in Mountain Kumbhiragadi climbing. He thanked M/s Tata Steel a Limited for providing the platform and supported the proposal. 14.64. Sri Ajay He informed that local people came to No specific PP acknowledges - Mahanta, know about CSR and periphery issue the support and Kaljhira development only because of Tata Steel. appreciation He thanked M/s Tata Steel for providing

drinking water supply, medicine, solar light and other periphery development activity.

- 35 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 15.65. Sri Dibya Welcoming the gathering, he requested Stadium PP proposed to Included Sl.No.4 Ranjan Baral, M/s Tata Steel to establish a stadium, park, develop playground Ambasara make reservation in percentage for in consultation with employment to local people and District

reduce/free the cost of medical Administration consultation fee at Tata Medica Hospital. He expressed his support for the Employment The total direct and - expansion project. opportunity to indirect employment locals. for this developmental project will be about 15,000.

Already system and process for local employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha

Free medical Health campaign Included Sl.No.6 consultation at with Mobile Medical Tata Medica unit is already in Hospital place.PP assure that the health camps will be undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km Tata Medica is a super specialty hospital and rates are reasonable / compare to other similar facilities in state of Odisha.

66. Jayanta Rout, He thanked the gathering and complaint Stadium and PP proposed to Included Sl.No.4 Duburi the environment in the Kalinganagar Steel park develop playground plant area with the Jamshedpur Steel Plant in consultation with area of M/s Tata Steel and questioned the District development in Duburi Chowk. He Administration supported the expansion project but urged M/s Tata Steel to provide skill development Skill PP will undertake Included Sl.No.1 training and take up development work in development vocational and the Duburi area. He further demanded a programme industrial training stadium and a park in the area. programme to the local youth to develop their skill sets for employment and entrepreneurship.

- 36 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 67. Balaram Welcoming the panel and gathering, he No specific PP acknowledges - Mallick, urged people to support the expansion issue the support and Pankapal project of M/s Tata Steel Limited. He appreciation informed that Tata Steel is providing medical, water and solar energy facility in the area.

68. Jagmohan He welcomed the dais and gathering and No specific PP acknowledges - Jamuda, informed the public that air and water issue the support and Gobarghati pollution control measures have been appreciation taken up by Tata Steel. He expressed his support for the expansion project.

16.69. Sri Rajesh He requested M/s Tata Steel to take up Development of Green belt Included Kumar Barla, plantation activity in the nearest villages greenbelt development being Sl.No.41 Chandia and main roads to control environment a continuous pollution in the area. process, PP will

continue this initiative to achieve 33% or more Greenery in and around the plant. Avenue plantation PP will undertake road side plantation under CER activity.

17.70. Sri Bijay He informed that Tata Steel has completed No specific PP acknowledges - Kumar much development activity in the area. issue the support and Mahanta, Tata steel has imparted many training to appreciation people and it is the responsibility of the Siatia person to take the benefit of the training.

18.71. Sri Digamber He informed that Tata Steel has provided No specific PP acknowledges - Sahu, Jajpur healthcare and skill development finstitute issue the support and Road in all over India but no such skill appreciation development institute has been established

in the area by M/s Tata Steel. He demanded use of cleaner fuel in Blast Furnace to reduce emission and use modern technology to treat the flue gas before discharge to the atmosphere.

72. Sabalamba He appreciated the Safety system of M/s No specific PP acknowledges - Mohanta, Tata Steel Ltd. issue the support and Sansailo appreciation He supported the project

73. B.Mohan, He requested the project proponent to take Protective PP confirms to - Jajpur Road protective measures during transportation measures examine current of slag. during slag transportation transportation process and of slag address appropriately if any further improvement.

- 37 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 74. Birsa Welcoming the dais and gathering, he Permanent Already system and - Hembrom, questioned the facility provided to the land employment to process for local Gobarghati loser by M/s Tata Steel and informed that land loser employment is in they have not got permanent employment practice, wherein till date. preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha.

PP confirms that actions in line with all Government rules and notifications are being adhered to.

19.75. Sri Welcoming the panel and gathering, he No specific PP acknowledges - Swabalam- informed that the area is affected by the issue the support and ban Mahanta, surrounding plants in the area and M/s appreciation Tata steel has taken various pollution Sansailo control measures and gives preference to safety. He supported the expansion proposal of M/s Tata Steel.

76. Rimsi Soren, She informed that development in the area No specific PP acknowledges - Sansailo has been taken by Tata Steel. She issue the support and expressed her supported and requested appreciation further cooperation.

77. Malati Soy, She greeted the gathering and told that No specific PP acknowledges - Sansailo they are getting benefitted by the Tata issue the support and Steel Plant. appreciation

78. Lina Samad, She supported the expansion project of No specific PP acknowledges - Sansailo M/s Tata Steel Limited. issue the support and appreciation

79. Tuni Patra, She informed that they have benefitted by No specific PP acknowledges - Sansailo the Tata Steel Plant project. She thanked issue the support and Tata Steel and expressed her support for appreciation the expansion project.

20.80. Ms Priti She informed that they have benefitted by No specific PP acknowledges - Dungdung, the Tata Steel Plant project. She supported issue the support and Sansailo the Tata Steel expansion project. appreciation

81. Kanaklata She informed that their area has been No specific PP acknowledges - Mahanta, developed by Tata Steel Limited. She issue the support and Olia supported the Tata Steel expansion appreciation project.

- 38 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 21.82. Sri Hinda Sri Jamuda greeted the public and No specific PP acknowledges - Jamuda, gathering and thanked Tata Steel for the issue the support and Chandia development in the area. He expressed his appreciation hope for more employment and fulfillment

of other development activity by supporting the expansion project of Tata Steel Plant. He supported the expansion project.

83. Debi prasad Sri Mohanty greeted the panel & gathering No specific PP acknowledges - Mohanty, and informed that Tata Steel has taken issue the support and Hatibari many initiatives for development in the appreciation area. M/s Tata Steel is renown in entire India for its CSR and periphery development activity. Tata steel culture is very disciplined and they have taken various pollution control measures inside the factory. He further informed that Tata Steel has given more employment in the area and demanded more employment in the expansion project.

22.84. Sri Rabindra Sri Jasika welcomed the public and dais Pollution control The present - Jasika, and told that the area will be affected by developmental Chandia pollution. Kalinganagar area is already project will install the considered as one of the most polluted state-of-art air

area in the country, hence requested to pollution control install modern technology for dust and air equipment pollution control in the area. He further conforming to stressed on conservation of ground water emission standard in the area. prescribed by CPCB/MoEFCC

Need for PP confirms that conservation of project has not ground water considered any abstraction of ground water.

- 39 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 85. Dabara Welcoming the gathering, he told that Better Health Health campaign Included Sl.No.6 Angarai, education and healthcare facility in the care with Mobile Medical Gobarghati area has not developed. He demanded Better unit is already in better education facility in the area. education place.PP assure facilities that the health camps will be undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km Included Sl.No.9 PP is working on 1000 school project to improve quality of education. Under this PP has already covered 48 panchyats in Kalinganagar.

- 40 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 86. Manoj kumar Sri Jamuda requested M/s Tata Steel to Necessary Health campaign Included Sl.No.6 jamuda, provide necessary facility to the facility to the with Mobile Medical Chandia rehabilitated people in the Kalinganagar rehabilitated unit is already in Steel plant project of the company. people place.PP assure that the health camps will be undertaken in all Panchayats within a radial coverage of 10 km Included Sl.No.9 PP is working on 1000 school project to improve quality of education. Under this PP has already covered 48 panchyats in Kalinganagar .

23.87. Ms She informed various development No specific PP acknowledges - Diptimayee activities taken by M/s Tata Steel Limited. issue the support and Mohanta, appreciation Rangitang

88. Sumitra She informed that the company has No specific PP acknowledges - Behera, supplied drinking water, established a club issue the support and Rangitang and old age education in her village and appreciation thanked for the support. 24.89. Ms Jamuna She told that she is staying in Tata Colony. No specific PP acknowledges - Patra, Tata She expressed her support for the issue the support and Colony expansion project of M/s Tata Steel appreciation Limited.

- 41 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 25.90. Ms She grievanced that educational Educational PP acknowledges - Saritamani development has not taken place in the development the support and Gogrei, area. She further informed that Tata Steel appreciation has given training for self employment to Trijanga local people and thanked for the initiatives On education Included Sl.No.9 of the company. development, PP has various ongoing engagement under its CSR program.

1000 school Technical training Entrepreneurship engagement SHG Scholarship

91. Tikili Balai, Welcoming the gathering, she requested Public toilet at PP welcomed the 50 Dakhinapasi the project proponent to construct public Duburi chak idea and confirms (within 2 years) toilet with water supply facility at market bus stand that few such place of Duburi. facilities will be taken up in consultation with district administration and after obtaining necessary approvals

26.92. Ms Mamina She welcomed the dais and gathering and No specific PP acknowledges - Samal, informed that M/s Tata Steel had provided issue the support and Dakhinapasi her training and she further cooperation appreciation from the company.

27.93. Ms Madhuri Welcoming the gathering, she informed Demand for PP acknowledges Included Sl.No.9 Bahadur, that Tata Steel has given support for the school & appreciation Baragadia training and demanded school and college college PP further confirms in the area. that PP is working

on 1000 school project to improve quality of education. Under this PP has already covered 48 panchyats in Kalinganagar .

- 42 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 94. Abhimanyu He informed people that Tata Steel will do Emission test PP will install online - Mohanta, development activity as per their policy and by Pollution monitoring Gobarghati local requirement. He reminded people of Control Board & equipment. The the Bhopal gas tragedy and demanded compliance monitoring results more plantation. He further requested the will be displayed at pollution control department to regularly the Plant Gate test the emission and discharge quality of (Already such the industry and take necessary step for facilities are compliance. installed in plant and display exists at the Plant Gate) to inform the local people. More plantation Included in the area Green belt Sl.No.41 development being a continuous process, PP will continue this initiative to achieve adequate greenery in and around the plant.

95. Laxmidhar He thanked Tata Steel for rehabilating and No specific PP acknowledges - Dalai, providing necessary education to the child issue the support and Jagadiha labors working in the area. He further appreciation requested M/s Tata Steel to financially help the family of the Everest climber Ms Dalai. PP will continue He supported the expansion project of M/s their endevour to Tata Steel Limited. encourage local youth for skill development.

- 43 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 96. Jogendra He expressed her displeasure on Tata Tree plantation PP is committed to Included Das, Steel for not providing adequate facility to Green belt Sl.No.41 Baragadia the local rehabilitated people. Sri Das told development, which that trees were cut for making widening of is a continuous roads. People within 10km radius are process, PP will socially backward due to non employment. continue this He requested the company to take steps initiative to achieve for employment of land losers. He further adequate greenery questioned the medical facility provided in in and around the Tata Medica as treatment is quite plant. expensive to local poor people. He requested free medical service at Tata Employment of The total direct and - Medica to people staying within 10km local people & indirect employment radius from the Tata steel plant project. He land loser for this reminded that dust bins we're requested for developmental clean drive and repairing of shools but was project will be about not provided. He informed told that he is 15,000. not opposing the project but M/s Tata steel has not provided adequate facility as Already system and required and requested to give permission process for local only after fulfilment of demands. employment is in practice, wherein preference is given to people based on eligibility. This is as per MOU signed with Government of Odisha

Medical Tata Medica is a Included Sl.No.6 facilities at Tata super specialty Medica Hospital hospital and rates and its cost are reasonable as compare to other similar facilities in state of Odisha.

97. Pradeep He informed that Tata Steel has No specific PP acknowledges - kumar commissioned many developemt activity in issue the support and Mohanta, the area, however other plants have not appreciation Sulia taken such developement works which needs to be discussed. He thanked Tata Steel for doing development work in the area.

98. Rabindra He informed people about the expansion No specific PP acknowledges - kumar project and thanked M/s Tata Steel for the issue the support and Jenamani, expansion project. He expressed his appreciation Baragadia support for the expansion proposal of the company.

- 44 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 28.99. Ms Zingi She requested the administration to Rehabilitation PP confirms that the - Hisa, rehabilitate her family which is in the concerned is Gobarghati surrounding area of the plant. She further already rehabilitated requested to provide drinking water and and staying in

informed that she is not opposing the Gobarghati, which is expansion project. R&R colony. All R&R entitlements as per Govt policy has been provided.

Drinking water PP confirms that Included Sl.No.9 water treatment plant has been constructed in this colony and treated water is being supplied.

100. Manika She informed that her earning comes from No specific PP acknowledges - Mohanta, employment in a company within Tata issue the support and Sansailo Steel and by tailoring. She supported the appreciation project.

29.101. Sri Rajendra Sri Haiburu requested Tata Steel to take up Disclosure of PP acknowledges - Haiburu, development work in the surrounding area. pollution level the support and Madhuban He informed that M/s Tata Steel Limited appreciation has taken various pollution control

measures inside the industry. He Also, PP confirms requested the company to visit pass to that ambient air local people to visit inside the plant and quality and water access the environment condition inside quality data is the industry. provided on-line to Pollution Control Board. Also data is displayed at plant gate for information to local people.

PP informs that entry and exit of plant is guided as per Factory Law provisions, which are stringenet for HHA units.

30.102. Sri Welcoming the gathering, Sri Das informed Bus service to PP confirms that - Manoranjan that Tata Steel is finding out the drop out labour bus service is Das, Sukinda students and providing necessary already operational education. He proposed to the company to for most employees

provide a bus service to labor employees through multiple

and establish park facility in the local partners as a schools. productivity enhancement and safety improvement activity. Park in local 50 school PP will support (within 3 years) developmental activities of school

- 45 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 31.103. Sri Expressing his support for the expansion Road side PP confirms that Included Radheshyam project, Sri Mohanta asked the project plantation road side plantation Sl.No.41 Mohanta, proponent to fulfil all the demands raised is ongoing drive in by the public. He further requested for consultation with Bandhagaon more plantation in the area, also on road district sides and take adequate environment administration and protection measures to save the forest department. environment.

104. Laxman Sri Soren informed that he is not employed Employment to PP confirms that - Soren, Duburi by M/s Tata Steel Limited till date even land loser rehabilitation cases after rehabilitation. He complaint for not are dealt as per getting employment by the company R&R policy and although committment was made for updated report is employment. submitted to District Administration half yearly. PP will further examine suitability of this specific case with respect to Govt R&R policy.

32.105. Sri John He informed that even after several Drinking water Request by resident Included Sl.No.9 Albet Gogrei, complaint to the company the issue of facilities at of Kantipur will be Kantipur drinking water supply in his place is not Kantipur examined and solved. He has not benefitted by the Tata appropriate action

steel plant project. shall be taken in consultation with District Administration

106. Minaki She requested Tata Steel to provide some Club house and PP confirms that it - Behera , club house and puja ghara in her village. puja ghar in carries out work Pankapal Pankapal focusing on community developmental activities, which covers this village also.

33.107. Ms She told that M/s Tata steel has done Transport for PP confirms three - Swamamati many development work in the area. She local students buses are already in Rout, requested to provide vehicle facility to local service for students. transportation of Pankapal local students in different areas.

34.108. Sri Salu Welcoming the panel and gathering, he No specific PP acknowledges - Badara, informed that Tata steel has done many issue the support and Mirgichal development work in the area and taken appreciation various pollution control measures inside

the plant to protect the environment.

- 46 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 109. Ajit kumar He complaint that few local people have Disclosure of As per regulation, - Aich, got emplyment in the Tata steel pollution load PP will provide Baragadia Kalingsnagar project. He told that people ambient air quality are facing air pollution and requested and water quality pollution control Board to regularly check data on-line to pollution level of Tata Steel Kalinganagar. Pollution Control Board and the same data will be displayed at the plant gate for information to the local people.

110. Sri Papu He informed that his village people are Employment Already system and - Deo, facing issue of kidney disease. TDS level opportunity process for local Baragadia of ground water in his village is very high employment is in and not drinkable. He expressed his practice, wherein concern that around 15000 unemployed preference is given people are living in the surrounding area. to people based on As per guideline, villages within 5km radius eligibility. This is as should be adopted and reservation (%) on per MOU signed local employment should be fixed, but with Government of those rules are not being followed by M/s Odisha. Tata Steel. He requested Tata steel to give cooperation to local people. PP confirms that actions in line with all Government rules and notifications are being adhered to.

111. Subhadra She told that the company has involved in No specific PP acknowledges - Pradhan, many development activity and she is also issue the support and Kendudihi hoped for many other development activity appreciation by Tata Steel. She supported the project

112. Binod Bihari Greeting the public, Sri Sethy informed that No specific PP acknowledges - Sethy, Kaitha he is an employee of Tata Steel. He issue the support and informed that the company is following all appreciation government rules and regulations and salary structure provided by Tata Steel to Skilled and unskilled labors is good and better than other plants in the area.

- 47 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 35.113. Sri Sri Mohanta expressed his grievance for Awareness PP confirms that - Deviprasad tree cutting by the company and not programme on green belt Mohanty , planting that nos. of trees. He further tree felling development and reminded that some tribal people lost their tree plantation is Kaitha life during establishment of the existing one of its focus plant project. He raised the issue of police areas and is an verification of local people during annual ongoing employment. He told that development activity. Till date activity has been taken up by Tata Steel close to 5 lakh trees but environment protective measures has have been planted not been taken to that extent. He both in and around demanded Tata Steel to explain the Kalinganagar area various steps that has been taken to and various school, protect the environment. colleges, villages. General Awareness programme are also conducted regularly in school, colleges and villages along with TERI under green school project.

Police - verification PP confirms that as issue during per standard employment. practice and directive of district administration, Police Verification is required for all persons being employed. Pollution control - measures. PP has already implemented various pollution control measures in their existing operating units and data is being provided online to Govt. and displayed at the main gate of the factory for awareness to local people. For the proposed project, the various pollution control measures to be implemented is elaborated in EMP chsapter of EIA report.

- 48 -

Allocated Budget with Response implementa- Sl. Name & Issues raised of Project tion time No. Address Public comments by public Proponent (PP) (Rs. in lakh) 114. Sri Sunil Sri Gagrei told that he has been Electricity PP Confirms that Included in Gagrei, rehabilitated by the Tata Steel Project. He facilities solar lights have Sl.No.9 Hudisahi informed that there is no developent in the been installed in area. He further informed that Hudisahi Hudisahi to alleviate village condition is same as Nagada village problem of electricity and they are not getting facility of apart from electricity, water etc. in their village. electrification done by Government.

Drinking water PP also confirms that a drinking water project has already been executed in Hudisahi and is in working condition.

- 49 -

Annexure 2 - Revalidate base line data

Query (ii): Revalidate the base line data by monitoring the physical environment (Air, water soil and Noise) for of one month starting 15-09-2020. All 12 parameters shall be monitored in Ambient Air as per MoEF&CC requirement

Ambient Air Quality Comparing the air quality data collected in 2016-2017 with the recently monitored data, it is evident that both average and P98 values of PM10 and PM2.5 have reduced significantly in 2020. Monitored values of SO2 and NOx have varied marginally when compared between the two time periods. The below summarises and compares the monitored AAQ values in 2016-2017 and 2020.

Frequency of Monitoring: Twice a week Monitoring Period: Dec′16 - Mar′17 & Sept’20 - Oct’20 Standard: NAAQS 2009

Average P98 Station Code Location Monitored values 2017 2020 Dif. 2017 2020 Dif. PM10 89.2 77.1 -12.1 96.5 79.5 -17 PM2.5 50.5 39.9 -10.6 58.0 45.9 -12.1 SO2 6.2 7.1 0.8 6.7 8.5 -1.8 A1 AMBASAR NOX 24.3 26.2 1.9 26.2 31.5 5.3 CO (8 hrs) <0.1 <0.1 - <0.1 <0.1 - O3 (8 hrs) <10 <10 - <10 <10 - PM10 90.9 81.8 -9.1 100.1 85 -15.1 PM2.5 47.3 49.2 1.9 51.7 55.5 3.8 SO2 6.5 7.4 0.9 7.2 9.2 2 A2 BAGHBAHALI NOX 24.9 26.7 1.8 27.6 29.9 2.3 CO (8 hrs) <0.1 0.6 0.6 <0.1 0.8 0.8 O3 (8 hrs) 0.4 <10 -0.4 0.7 <10 PM10 91.6 79.8 -11.8 105.2 81.3 -23.9 PM2.5 54.4 39.3 -15.1 66.3 43.3 -23 SO2 16.8 19 2.2 23.5 21.5 -2 A3 JAKHPURA NOX 37.0 35.6 -1.4 39.4 41.0 1.6 CO (8 hrs) 1.3 1.2 -0.1 1.7 1.6 -0.1 O3 (8 hrs) 26.2 21.3 -4.9 36.5 29.6 -6.9 PM10 87.2 84.1 -3.1 98.0 86.1 -11.9 PM2.5 47.9 44.4 -3.5 56.5 49.3 -7.2 SO2 18.4 13.2 -5.2 24.0 18.8 -5.2 A4 DHOUPANKHI NOX 32.0 28.8 -3.2 34.1 36.0 1.9 CO (8 hrs) 1.4 1.2 -0.2 1.7 1.8 0.1 O3 (8 hrs) 27.6 19.1 -8.5 35.8 24.5 -11.3 PM10 83.0 80.2 -2.8 96.7 84.0 -12.7 PM2.5 42.1 41.8 -0.3 49.9 44.3 -5.6 SO2 5.9 8.3 2.8 6.7 10.1 3.4 A5 RANAGUNDI NOX 25.5 27.6 2.1 29.1 31.3 2.2 CO (8 hrs) <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 O3 (8 hrs) <10 <10 <10 <10 PM10 89.8 82.7 -7.1 97.2 84.1 -13.1 A6 PANASPAL PM2.5 47.5 45.7 -1.8 52.9 49.1 -3.8 SO2 19.7 15.0 -4.7 24.9 21.0 -3.9

- 50 -

NOX 37.9 30.7 -7.2 39.9 34.0 -5.9 CO (8 hrs) 1.6 1.4 -0.2 1.9 1.9 0 O3 (8 hrs) 31.6 17.5 -14.1 36.5 29.8 -6.7 PM10 88.9 81.8 -7.1 98.2 83.3 -14.9 PM2.5 47.4 45.1 -2.3 54.5 49.1 -5.4 SO2 17.3 15.7 -1.6 20.3 19.4 -0.9 A7 BARHAGARIA NOX 36.9 35.5 -1.4 39.6 39.1 -0.5 CO (8 hrs) 1.6 1.3 -0.3 1.8 1.8 0 O3 (8 hrs) 32.7 26.8 -5.9 36.5 36.3 -0.2 PM10 87.2 84.6 -2.1 95.5 86.2 -9.3 PM2.5 45.6 43.5 -1.5 51.5 44.8 -6.7 SO2 6.7 9.4 2.7 7.6 12.7 5.1 A8 MANIAPATRA NOX 27.0 31.1 4.1 30.5 36.0 5.5 CO (8 hrs) <0.1 0.8 1.1 O3 (8 hrs) 0.4 0.8 0.4 0.5 <10

(Pollutants in µg/m3 (24 hrs), CO in mg/m3)

Notes: Method of measurement - as per schedule VII of National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS of CPCB)

- 51 -

Ground Water Quality

The following tables show the variations in ground water quality in 2017 and 2020.

Monitoring Location Map : 11410-97A-000-ENV-0008 Frequency of monitoring : Once a month Monitoring Period : Jan′17-Mar′17 & Oct’20 Standard : IS-10500:2012

GW1 : Tubewell - Maniapatra village GW2 : Tubewell - Baghbahali village

Parameters GW1 GW2 IS-10500-2012 2017 2020 2017 2020 Physical Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour Unobjectionable Colour(Hazen) 1.00 1.0 1.00 1.0 5 Taste Acceptable Accept-able Acceptable Accept-able Agreeable Temperature (OC) 24.60 21.5 24.33 20 - Turbidity (NTU) 1.26 <1.0 1.50 <1.0 1 Total Dissolved Solids (mg/l) 983.33 916 840.67 838 500 (max)

Chemical (mg/l) pH 6.91 7.43 6.70 7.38 6.5-8.5 Alkalinity 217.33 328 158.67 216 200 (max) Total Hardness 360.00 408 258.00 216 200 (max) Residual Chlorine <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 0.2(max) Nitrate 3.07 12.5 4.43 6.6 45(max) Fluoride <0.1 0.37 <0.1 0.49 1.0(max) Phenol <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Total Nitrogen <0.1 15 <0.1 9.5 - Boron <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.5(max) Chloride 139.31 66.11 78.99 19.65 250 (max) Sulphate 30.67 0.76 21.17 25.6 200 (max) Bicarbonate 265.15 400.16 210.05 263.32 - Cyanide <0.05 <0.01 <0.05 <0.01 0.05 (max) Calcium 103.14 109.02 72.68 44.89 75(max) Magnesium 24.64 32.64 18.56 24.96 30(max) Manganese <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.12 0.1 (max) Zinc 0.13 0.05 0.16 0.45 5.0 (max) Aluminium <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 0.03 (max) Iron 2.30 0.45 2.57 1.23 0.3 (max) Chromium (VI) <0.01 <0.02 <0.01 <0.02 0.01 (max) Copper <0.05 <0.04 <0.05 0.38 0.05 (max) Mercury <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Cadmium <0.003 <0.002 <0.003 <0.002 0.003(max) Sodium 41.03 31.83 21.14 25.89 - Arsenic <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 0.01 (max) Lead <0.01 <0.005 <0.01 <0.005 0.01 (max) Bacteriological

(MPN/100ml) Total Coliform nil <1, <10,<100 nil <1, <10,<100 nil Faecal Coliform nil <1, <10,<100 nil <1, <10,<100 nil

- 52 -

Monitoring Location Map : 11410-97A-000-ENV-0008 Frequency of monitoring : Once a month Monitoring Period : Jan′17-Mar′17 & Oct’20 Standard : IS-10500:2012

GW3 : Dug well - Dhapanki village GW4 : Tubewell - Ranagundi village

GW3 GW4 IS-10500-2012 Parameters 2017 2020 2017 2020 Physical Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour Unobjectionable Colour(Hazen) 1.00 1.0 1.00 1.0 5 Taste Acceptable Accept-able Acceptable Accept-able Agreeable Temperature (OC) 22.83 21.5 23.67 20 - Turbidity (NTU) 1.29 <1.0 1.59 <1.0 1 Total Dissolved Solids (mg/l) 717.33 766 736.67 1150 500 (max)

Chemical (mg/l) pH 6.16 7.19 6.33 7.47 6.5-8.5 Alkalinity 85.99 124 115.39 336 200 (max) Total Hardness 110.00 236 148.67 316 200 (max) Residual Chlorine <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 0.2(max) Nitrate 4.50 9.2 6.50 14.89 45(max) Fluoride <0.1 0.13 <0.1 0.28 1.0(max) Phenol <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Total Nitrogen <0.1 12.5 <0.1 18.2 - Boron <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.5(max) Chloride 27.43 <0.04 53.82 17.87 250 (max) Sulphate 29.00 18 30.83 16.4 200 (max) Bicarbonate 82.77 290 95.95 409.92 - Cyanide <0.05 <0.01 <0.05 <0.01 0.05 (max) Calcium 27.25 64.13 32.06 17.87 75(max) Magnesium 10.24 18.24 16.64 36.48 30(max) Manganese <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.1 (max) Zinc 0.06 0.37 0.11 .0.43 5.0 (max) Aluminium <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 0.03 (max) Iron 2.00 0.55 2.18 1.74 0.3 (max) Chromium (VI) <0.01 <0.02 <0.01 <0.02 0.01 (max) Copper <0.05 <0.04 <0.05 <0.04 0.05 (max) Mercury <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Cadmium <0.003 <0.002 <0.003 <0.002 0.003(max) Sodium 12.24 22.48 17.20 27.46 - Arsenic <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 0.01 (max) Lead <0.01 <0.005 <0.01 <0.005 0.01 (max) Bacteriological

(MPN/100ml) Total Coliform 6.6 x 102 8.3 X 102 nil <1, <10,<100 nil Faecal Coliform 2.2 x 102 2.5 X 102 nil <1, <10,<100 nil

- 53 -

Moniitoring Location Map : 11410-97A-000-ENV-0008 Frequency of monitoring : Once a month Monitoring Period : Jan′17-Mar′17 & Oct’20 Standard : IS-10500:2012

GW5 : Tubewell - Karamatia village GW6 : Tubewell - Jamtahurishai village

GW5 GW6 IS-10500-2012 Parameters 2017 2020 2017 2020 Physical Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour Unobjectionable Colour(Hazen) 1.00 1.0 1.00 1.0 5 Taste Acceptable Accept-able Acceptable Accept-able Agreeable Temperature (OC) 24.33 21.5 23.83 19.5 - Turbidity (NTU) 1.75 <1.0 2.61 <1.0 1 Total Dissolved Solids (mg/l) 1113.33 768 750.00 315 500 (max)

Chemical (mg/l) pH 6.70 6.86 6.63 6.77 6.5-8.5 Alkalinity 245.33 144 218.67 44 200 (max) Total Hardness 370.67 224 250.67 60 200 (max) Residual Chlorine <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 0.2(max) Nitrate 2.50 12.5 3.00 5.37 45(max) Fluoride <0.1 0.12 <0.1 <0.1 1.0(max) Phenol <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Total Nitrogen <0.1 15 <0.1 8.2 - Boron <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.5(max) Chloride 96.82 67.89 42.41 16.08 250 (max) Sulphate 90.00 65 35.83 28 200 (max) Bicarbonate 266.21 175.68 266.77 53.68 - Cyanide <0.05 <0.01 <0.05 <0.01 0.05 (max) Calcium 99.93 48.1 61.99 11.22 75(max) Magnesium 29.12 24.96 23.04 7.68 30(max) Manganese <0.1 <0.01 <0.1 <0.1 0.1 (max) Zinc 0.08 0.19 0.17 <0.01 5.0 (max) Aluminium <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 0.03 (max) Iron 3.08 5.55 4.52 17.82 0.3 (max) Chromium (VI) <0.01 <0.02 <0.01 <0.02 0.01 (max) Copper <0.05 <0.04 <0.05 <0.04 0.05 (max) Mercury <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Cadmium <0.003 <0.002 <0.003 <0.002 0.003(max) Sodium 35.00 46.25 36.44 22 - Arsenic <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 0.01 (max) Lead <0.01 <0.005 <0.01 <0.005 0.01 (max) Bacteriological

(MPN/100ml) Total Coliform nil <1, <10,<100 nil <1, <10,<100 nil Faecal Coliform nil <1, <10,<100 nil <1, <10,<100 nil

- 54 -

Monitoring Location Map : 11410-97A-000-ENV-0008 Frequency of monitoring : Once a month Monitoring Period : Jan′17-Mar′17 & Oct’20 Standard : IS-10500:2012

GW7 : Tubewell - Jakhpura village GW8 : Tubewell - Duburi chawk

GW7 GW8 IS-10500-2012 Parameters 2017 2020 2017 2020 Physical Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour Unobjectionable Colour(Hazen) 1.00 1.0 1.00 1.0 5 Accept-able Accept- Agreeable Taste Acceptable Acceptable able Temperature (OC) 24.00 20 24.17 19.5 - Turbidity (NTU) 10.26 <1.0 1.52 <1.0 1 Total Dissolved Solids (mg/l) 887.33 180 215.50 1748 500 (max) Chemical (mg/l) pH 6.60 6.29 7.08 7.52 6.5-8.5 Alkalinity 177.33 24 264.00 400 200 (max) Total Hardness 172.33 36 216.00 476 200 (max) Residual Chlorine <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 <0.04 0.2(max) Nitrate 9.92 6.2 5.83 8.2 45(max) Fluoride <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.36 1.0(max) Phenol <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Total Nitrogen <0.1 8 <0.1 10.5 - Boron <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.5(max) Chloride 18.64 21.44 36.36 91.12 250 (max) Sulphate 20.20 12.6 17.57 32 200 (max) Bicarbonate 216.35 29.28 322.08 488 - Cyanide <0.05 <0.01 <0.05 <0.01 0.05 (max) Calcium 42.22 6.41 48.10 96.19 75(max) Magnesium 16.00 4.8 25.92 56.94 30(max) Manganese <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 0.1 (max) Zinc 0.40 0.36 0.11 0.29 5.0 (max) Aluminium <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 0.03 (max) Iron 22.04 7.4 1.51 0.73 0.3 (max) Chromium (VI) <0.01 <0.02 <0.01 <0.02 0.01 (max) Copper <0.05 <0.04 <0.05 <0.04 0.05 (max) Mercury <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 (max) Cadmium <0.003 <0.002 <0.003 <0.002 0.003(max) Sodium 31.67 16.5 53.29 18.5 - Arsenic <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 0.01 (max) Lead <0.01 <0.005 <0.01 <0.005 0.01 (max) Bacteriological

(MPN/100ml) <1, <10,<100 <1, Total Coliform nil nil nil <10,<100 <1, <10,<100 <1, Faecal Coliform nil nil nil <10,<100

- 55 -

Surface Water Quality

The following tables show the variations in Surface water quality in 2017 and 2020.

Monitoring Location Map : 11410-97A-000-ENV-0008 Frequency of monitoring : Once a month Monitoring Period : Jan′17-Mar′17 & Oct’20

SW1 : Gandanala, Barakhai village SW2 : Gandanala, Ollola village SW3 : Gandanala, Kusunpur village

Parameters SW1 SW2 SW3 2017 2020 2017 2020 2017 2020 Physical Odour (T.O.N) No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour Temperature (OC) 22.5 31.50 25.0 32.00 24.3 32.50 Total Suspended Solid (mg/l) 18.7 12.00 17.7 13.00 19.0 18.00 Total Dissolved Solid (mg/l) 327.0 176.00 289.7 198.00 263.0 355.00 Chemical (mg/l) pH 7.2 7.25 7.2 7.45 7.1 7.23 Total Hardness 118.7 760.00 70.0 84.00 103.0 104.00 Dissolved Oxygen 6.1 5.80 5.7 5.40 5.8 5.20 BOD , 3 days at 27OC 3.7 5.00 6.0 8.00 5.7 8.00 COD 15.0 18.48 23.3 27.72 20.0 36.96 Oil & Grease <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 Salinity (ppt.) Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Kjeldahl Nitrogen 3.0 5.20 3.2 3.80 3.2 5.80 Chloride 53.2 32.50 24.2 14.29 24.2 17.87 Fluoride <0.1 < 0.1 <0.1 < 0.1 <0.1 <0.1

Sulphates as SO4 21.6 13.40 33.7 9.00 25.0 25.20 Bi-Carbonate 146.9 87.84 79.7 97.60 76.5 107.36 Phosphate 1.2 1.09 0.7 1.00 0.7 1.29 Calcium 35.3 17.64 17.6 19.24 28.3 25.65 Magnesium 7.4 7.68 6.1 8.64 7.7 9.64 Sodium 22.2 9.93 23.3 11.42 13.1 15.79 Manganese 0.23 0.29 0.1 0.25 0.2 0.16 Zinc 0.7 0.20 0.07 0.17 0.64 15.79 Iron 0.9 1.10 0.7 1.78 0.62 1.68 Chromium (Total) <0.06 <0.02 <0.06 <0.02 <0.06 <0.02 Hexavalent Chromium <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 Bacteriological(MPN/100ml) Total Coliform / 100 ml. 3.8 x 102 8.6x102 5.9 x 102 1.1x103 5.3 x 102 1.2x103 Fecal Coliform /100 ml. 1.5 x 102 3.9x102 1.9x 102 4.6x102 2.6 x 102 4.2x102

- 56 -

Monitoring Location Map : 11410-97A-000-ENV-0008 Frequency of monitoring : Once a month Monitoring Period : Jan′17-Mar′17 & Oct’20

SW4 : 60m downstream of Kharsua river meeting Gandanala SW5 : 60 m upstream of Kharsua River meeting Gandanala SW6 : Plant outlet near Bridge (Karamatia village)

Parameters SW4 SW5 SW6 2017 2020 2017 2020 2017 2020 Physical Odour (T.O.N) No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour Temperature (OC) 25.8 31.50 25.5 31.50 26.0 32.50 Total Suspended Solid (mg/l) 12.7 18.00 14.3 12.00 11.9 15.00 Total Dissolved Solid (mg/l) 147.7 238.00 343.3 214.00 669.3 183.00

Chemical (mg/l) pH 7.2 7.02 7.2 7.12 7.2 6.84 Total Hardness 68.0 56.00 137.3 48.00 150.7 44.00 Dissolved Oxygen 6.2 5.60 5.9 5.60 5.6 5.60 BOD, 3 days at 27OC 3.0 7.00 5.3 5.00 6.7 8.00 COD 9.6 36.96 22.0 27.72 28.3 36.96 Oil & Grease <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 Salinity (ppt.) Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Kjeldahl Nitrogen 1.9 3.20 3.5 3.80 4.2 8.20 Chloride 12.7 10.72 32.2 8.93 84.2 23.23 Fluoride <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 < 0.1 <0.1 <0.1

Sulphates as SO4 14.3 12.20 43.0 13.80 63.1 12.60 Bi-Carbonate 54.3 68.32 97.5 63.44 189.4 39.04 Phosphate 0.7 1.02 0.8 1.24 1.4 0.98 Calcium 16.0 14.43 33.7 12.83 40.4 8.02 Magnesium 6.7 4.80 12.8 3.84 11.8 5.76 Sodium 11.5 9.70 35.2 8.09 74.3 8.57 Manganese <0.04 0.35 <0.03 0.19 0.1 0.20 Zinc 0.6 0.33 0.1 0.16 0.1 0.15 Iron 0.4 1.10 1.2 2.07 1.4 0.71 Chromium (Total) <0.06 <0.02 <0.06 <0.02 <0.06 <0.02 Hexavalent Chromium <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1

Bacteriological(MPN/100ml) Total Coliform / 100 ml. 3.0 x 102 7.9x102 3.5 x 102 6.8x102 4.4 x 102 1.2x103 Fecal Coliform /100 ml. 1.2 x 102 3.6x102 1.3 x 102 3.8x102 2.2 x 102 3.9x102

- 57 -

Monitoring Location Map : 11410-97A-000-ENV-0008 Frequency of monitoring : Once a month Monitoring Period : Jan′17-Mar′17 & Oct’20

SW7 : Pond water Ambasara village SW8 : 60 m downstream of Brahmani river after road bridge

Parameters SW7 SW8 2017 2020 2017 2020 Physical Odour (T.O.N) No Odour No Odour No Odour No Odour Temperature (OC) 27.0 33.50 25.8 30.00 Total Suspended Solid (mg/l) 14.7 12.00 12.1 14.00 Total Dissolved Solid (mg/l) 156.7 260.00 125.0 245.00

Chemical (mg/l) pH 7.1 7.16 7.1 7.24 Total Hardness 58.0 60.00 52.0 64.00 Dissolved Oxygen 5.4 5.80 5.7 5.40 BOD, 3 days at 27OC 10.3 5.00 5.0 9.00 COD 37.8 27.72 18.9 36.96 Oil & Grease <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 Salinity (ppt.) Nil Nil Nil Nil Kjeldahl Nitrogen 5.7 6.80 3.7 2.50 Chloride 32.9 8.93 22.2 8.93 Fluoride <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1

Sulphates as SO4 23.7 20.60 10.0 23.00 Bi-Carbonate 48.1 68.32 49.5 68.32 Phosphate 0.6 1.36 0.9 0.95 Calcium 13.8 12.83 11.5 16.03 Magnesium 5.7 6.72 5.6 5.78 Sodium 14.1 7.67 11.1 7.49 Manganese <0.03 0.15 <0.03 0.12 Zinc 0.1 0.18 0.1 0.12 Iron 0.5 0.80 0.4 1.52 Chromium (Total) <0.06 <0.02 <0.06 0.12 Hexavalent Chromium <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1

Bacteriological(MPN/100ml) Total Coliform / 100 ml. 5.5 x 102 7.8x102 3.8 x 102 1.2x103 Fecal Coliform /100 ml. 1.7 x 102 3.6x102 1.3 x 102 6.8x102

- 58 -

Soil Quality

LOCATION OF SAMPLING :

S1 : Project site Land (Phase - II) ; (Lat/Long) : 20057'74"N/ 86001'29"E S2: Agricultureal land at Maniapatra village; (Lat/Long) : 20056'8"N/ 85059'27"E S3 : Forest Soil at Madhuban village; (Lat/Long) : 20057'7"N/ 85059'6"E

Key Project Site Rangiagarh Village Kujang Village Parameters (S1) (S2) (S3) Colour Slighty Reddish Greyish Greyish pH (1:2) 7.2 7.12 7.1 Alkanity/Acidity Very slighty basic Very slighty basic Very slighty basic Soil Texture Sandy loam Sandy loam Sandy loam Sand (%) 70 65 73 Silt (%) 20 15 15 Clay (%) 10 12 12 Electrical Conductivity 1.6 2.1 1.4 (ds/m) Hydraulic conductivity 1.8 x 10-3 1.6 x 10-3 1.5 x 10-3 (cm/sec) Bulk Density 1.32 1.4 1.35 (gm/cc) Moisture (%) 18 23 12 Porosity (%) 54 45 50 Infiltration rate 2.5 2.1 2.8 (cm/hrs) Available N 2 510 720 680 (mg/kg) Available P O 2 5 430 720 480 (mg/kg) Available K O 2 1180 1520 950 (mg/kg) Chloride (mg/kg) 1520 1150 1290 Sulphate (mg/kg) 1180 1295 625 Sodium absorption ratio 5.33 4.58 4.93 (SAR) Available Organic 4.2 9.5 7.2 Carbon (gm/kg) Calcium (mg/kg) 1182 1250 520 Magnesium 1390 1685 1290 (mg/kg) Iron (mg/kg) 18250 9850 12980 Copper (mg/kg) 12.8 11.2 8.5 Lead (mg/kg) <3.0 <3.0 <3.0 Chromium <0.20 <0.20 <0.20 (mg/kg) Microbial Population 3.8x105 6.2x105 5.6x105 (No./gm)

- 59 -

Noise

Recorded Values (Leq) in dB (A)

Sampling Station Day Night Industrial Area Tate steel, Gate No - 1 64.70 53.01 Tate steel, Gate No - 3 62.31 53.16 Tata Steel, Gate No - 4 64.72 58.12 Tata Steel, Gate No - 5 62.33 56.81 Commercial Area Duburi Market 66.34 58.41 Silence Area Dangadi Hospital 50.76 39.02 L. N. Government School, Kharida Bazar 61.46 56.81

- 60 -

Annexure 3: AAQ modelling

Query (iii): AAQ modelling shall be done based on worst case scenario glc in µg/m3

Under normal Worst case 2 meteorological Worst case 1 (Simultaneous Monitoring conditions (Worst meteorological conditions) APC Failure of station PM SO2 NOx PM SO2 NOx major units) PM A1 0.1 3.50 5.00 4 (+3.9) 3.58 (+0.08) 5.03 (+0.03) 10 (+9.9) A2 0.5 3.50 7.30 5 (+4.5) 3.58 (+0.08) 7.37 (+0.07) 20 (+19.5) A3 0.1 3.50 5.00 4 (+3.9) 3.58 (+0.08) 5.03 (+0.03) 20 (+19.9) A4 1.5 6.90 7.30 5 (+3.5) 6.97 (+0.07) 7.37 (+0.07) 40 (+38.5) A5 0.5 3.50 7.30 4 (+3.5) 3.58 (+0.08) 7.37 (+0.07) 10 (+9.5) A6 - 1.80 2.60 1.5 (+1.5) 1.88 (+0.08) 2.68 (+0.08) 10 (+10) A7 0.5 1.80 5.00 1.5 (+1.0) 1.88 (+0.08) 5.03 (+0.03) 3 (+2.5) A8 1 8.60 14.30 8 (+7) 8.66 (+0.06) 14.39 (+0.09) 50 (+49)

The following figures depict the glcs of PM10, SO2 and NOx plotted in BREEZE AERMOD ISC Software for normal and worst case meteorological conditions. An additional worst case has been modelled for PM in the event of failure of APCs of major plant units.

- 61 -

3 Predicted 24-hourly average gls of PM10 in µg/m to assess the impact of the Proposed 8.0 MTPA Steel Plant at Normal meteorological conditions

- 62 -

3 Predicted 24-hourly average gls of SO2 in µg/m to assess the impact of the Proposed 8.0 MTPA Steel Plant at Normal meteorological conditions

- 63 -

3 Predicted 24-hourly average gls of NOx in µg/m to assess the impact of the Proposed 8.0 MTPA Steel Plant at Normal meteorological conditions

- 64 -

3 Predicted 24-hourly average gls of PM10 in µg/m to assess the impact of the Proposed 8.0 MTPA Steel Plant at Worst meteorological conditions

- 65 -

3 Predicted 24-hourly average gls of SO2 in µg/m to assess the impact of the Proposed 8.0 MTPA Steel Plant at Worst meteorological conditions

- 66 -

3 Predicted 24-hourly average gls of NOx in µg/m to assess the impact of the Proposed 8.0 MTPA Steel Plant at Worst meteorological conditions

- 67 -

3 Predicted 24-hourly average gls of PM10 in µg/m to assess the impact of the Proposed 8.0 MTPA Steel Plant at Normal meteorological conditions in the event of Simultaneous failure of APC equipment in major plant units (BF Cast House, LD SE and Pellet plant waste gas)

- 68 -

Annexure 4: Risk Assessment

Query (iv): Risk Assessment shall be carried out based on QRA for the existing plant

Reply: QRA based risk assessment has been carried out for the existing plant and same is summarized below:

A. Background: Being an iron and steel-making process industry, TSK involves storage, handling and processing of several hazardous chemicals, whose inventories are above threshold limits as stipulated in MS&IHC Rules 1989 as amended in 2000. This implies that TSK is a Major Accident Hazard (MAH) unit and following two types of emergency situations may occur: (a) On-site Emergency- Incident which has potential to cause impacts within plant boundaries. (b) Off-site Emergency- Incident which has potential to cause impacts beyond plant boundaries.

B. Major hazardous chemicals being stored / processed / used in TSK & related hazard: • LD gas (80000 m3) in LD gas holder storage area (South-west corner of EW-20 and NS-50 junction) at 80 oC and 255 mmwc. • BF gas (150000 m3) in BF gas holder storage area (South-east corner of EW-20 & NS- 30 junction) at 60 oC and 850 mmwc • Chlorine Tonners (Licensed capacity = 20 (Filled: 928 Kg x 16 = 14848 kg) in Raw Water treatment Plant (Chemical House) at ambient T and P = 10 bar. • Propane bullets (Mounded: 300 MT (03 x 100 MT) in Propane storage area at ambient P = 12 kg/cm 2 • LDO tank (Capacity = 2200 Kl (2 x 1100 KL) and 84 MT (02 x 42 MT)) in CPP- 1 at ambient T and P. • Liquid oxygen (Linde): LOX storage tank: 3,400 m3 at and around 70 - 80 mbarg, -196 O C and LOX run tank: 80 m3 at 37.5 kg/cm2 & -196 O C. • Calcium Carbide (264 MT) in DS Reagent storage area at ambient T and pressure of 50 mbar. • Magnesium (78 MT) in DS Reagent storage area at ambient T and Pr. = 50 mbar.

Due to inherent physio-chemical properties of the above chemicals, TSK is prone to chemical hazards as mentioned below: a) Chlorine: Toxic gas with the IDLH and fatal concentration values are 10 ppm with 30 minutes exposure and 1000 ppm after a few breaths respectively. It is 2.5 times heavier than air and tends to flow downward. It is also corrosive and can burn moist body surfaces such as the eyes, nose, throat, lungs etc. Liquid chlorine has a high compression ratio of 1:450.

- 69 -

b) Blast Furnace gas (BFG): BFG is toxic due to the presence of carbon monoxide (CO) (typically 21- 25% v/v) in the gas. It is not typically considered an explosion hazard for the following reasons: • Very high ignition energies are required to initiate BFG combustion; • High concentration of inerts in the gas; • Very low combustion energy (3.2MJ/m 3 ). c) Coke-oven gas (COG): COG is toxic and flammable gas and has a very strong odour. Its toxic properties are due to the presence of CO (typically 9% v/v) in the gas. COG has a specific gravity of 0.43 and therefore, is a very buoyant gas, which tends to disperse rapidly when released to the atmosphere. COG has high concentration of hydrogen and methane, which suggests that the gas can be ignited by a low ignition energy (e.g., static). Therefore, the probability of ignition of COG leaks is likely to be high relative to other flammable gases. COG is also corrosive due to the presence of hydrogen and sulphides (H 2 S = 2500 mg/Nm3). This has significant implications for the maintainability of COG systems, because COG pipework frequently develops small corrosion holes. d) LDG: LDG is extremely toxic due to its high concentration of carbon monoxide (upto 70%) and its lack of detectable odour. It is also flammable given its high level of carbon monoxide (CO). Flammability of LDG increases with oxygen enrichment and temperature increase. Ignition of a release of LDG may result in a flash fire. e) LDO: LDO is a flammable liquid with high flash point of > 66 O C and hence normally it is not a major fire hazard. Under major persistent external heat source in the vicinity, pools of LDO can be ignited to start pool fire. f) Propane: Propane is associated with severe fire and explosion hazards, i.e., Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapour Explosion (BLEVE) under sustained ignition and Vapour Cloud Explosion (VCE). In TSK, the Propane bullets are mounded. As far as probable hazard scenarios are concerned, there is no possibility of BLEVE in mounded bullets. If liquid receiver line (exposed outside the vessel) connected to the mounded vessels gets ruptured, it may lead to vapour cloud explosion/flash fire if not mitigated in time. However, looking at maximum diameter (3 inch) of the line, impact will be localized if controlled in time. Another point is likelihood of a leak of gas/flammable liquid is relatively low. However, there is always a chance that corrosion, structural failure, human error or third party activity could lead to an accidental release. g) Oxygen: The major hazards are the exposure to cold temperature that can cause burn, enrichment of oxygen in the surrounding atmosphere and the possibility of a combustion reaction in contact with non-compatible materials. h) Argon: Argon is a non-flammable gas. It is an asphyxiant and in the absence of oxygen, it may be dangerous to life.

i) Nitrogen: Nitrogen gas is non-flammable and non-toxic, but is asphyxiation by displacement of oxygen. Closed containers of nitrogen may rupture or explode due to

- 70 -

pressure build-up when exposed to extreme heat. Liquid nitrogen poses special risks due to its low temperature and the large volume of gas produced when it vaporizes. Clothing can easily become saturated with the liquid and then if held it for a significant period of time, leading to serious burns to the skin. j) Calcium carbide and magnesium: Dusts of calcium carbide do not constitute a fire or explosion hazard except in the presence of moisture or at temperatures in excess of 1,000°C. Calcium carbide will react with any form of moisture (e.g. rain, dew, perspiration, condensation, atmospheric humidity etc.) to generate highly flammable acetylene gas. Calcium carbide is neither toxic nor carcinogenic. There are no long- term effects of exposure to calcium carbide, and there are no existing TLV for exposure to calcium carbide. Magnesium is considered as a very sensitive fire (Class D category) and explosion hazard because of its low minimum ignition energy (2 mJ). Most accidents associated with ignition of magnesium occur when the processes are maintained, or when powder is filled to or removed from the process.

C. Potential process and non-process hazards in TSK

Due to nature of process, operations, toxic and flammable/explosive properties of chemicals used in TSK, it is susceptible to fire, explosion and release of toxic chemicals. Potential process and non-process hazards in TSK are:

Fire hazard: Fire due to release/leakage of oxygen, propane, CO gas, BF gas, BOF gas, mixed gas and hot liquid metal. Fires can occur in conveyor belt, cable gallery, cable tunnels, cable vaults, LDO tank, transformers, lubricating oil rooms, desulphurization plants, control rooms, electrical switch rooms etc.

Explosion hazard: Explosion due to release/leakage of propane, CO, BF and BOF gas. Explosions may occur in oxygen generating plants, coke ovens and furnaces, basic oxygen steel-making vessels etc.

Toxic hazard: Release of chlorine from tonners, CO gas, BF gas and mixed gas from gasholders and pipeline.

Fire/Explosion due to spillage of liquid metal: Spillage/transfer of liquid metal, liquid steel and hot slag.

Heat radiation due to hot metal handling: Spillage of liquid metal, liquid steel and hot slag.

Asphyxiation: Due to release Co gas, BF gas, Mixed gas, Nitrogen, Argon.

Cold Burns: Due to exposure to liquid oxygen, liquid nitrogen, liquid argon and propane.

Failure of Power supply

- 71 -

Flooding and collapse of roads, structures etc. due to incessant rain and cyclone.

Major hazards in various plant sections in TSK are :

(i) Raw Material Handling Plant: Coke oven battery and coke handling

This area is susceptible for leakage of toxic gases and fire on leakage. The major hazards are:

1. Fire in belt conveyors. 2. Explosion in electrostatic tar precipitators due to higher oxygen in the incoming raw coke oven gas. 3. Explosion in raw and clean coke oven gas pipelines due to higher oxygen. 4. Explosion in the waste gas tunnels due to higher oxygen.

Hazard can also be arisen due to spillage from hot coke from batteries in the discharging side due to misalignment of loco car and pusher car.

(ii) Raw Material Handling Plant: Sinter plant

The critical areas in Sinter plant are gas lines and furnace. This area is susceptible for leakage of toxic gases and fire/explosion. The major hazards are: a) Gas leakage and fire in gas line b) Fire on conveyors. c) High rise building evacuation during emergency d) Electrical Fire e) Total power failure. f) Explosion in gas line g) Failure in service water supply.

Other hazards are fire due to leakage or rupture of piping, and overflow/spill of hot sinter machine due to failure of conveyors or lack of synchronisation speed ratio.

(iii) Blast furnace

Blast furnace is prone to the following three major hazards:

• Explosion in stove due to o failure of combustion air supply o accumulation of gas in stove o malfunction of snort valve o high-pressure build-up • Explosion in blast furnace due to o failure of cooling system o high-pressure build-up o accumulation of gas o instrumentation failure

- 72 -

Other process and non-process hazards that the blast furnace section can experience are:

CO poisoning due to gas injection; fire/explosion due to oxygen injection; fire in conveyor feed belt; fire/explosion due to spillage/transfer of liquid metal; explosion due to lack of periodic maintenance/failure to operate bleeder valves; increase of pressure during cold blast due to rupture in stove/failure of valves etc.; injury due to breakage in skip car rope for charging; CO poisoning due to partial closure of butterfly valve; excess temperature in gas cleaning filter bags; rope breakage during lifting of hot metal by crane etc.

Power and water supply are the two important requirements for the functioning of blast furnace operations. In TSK, the failures of these situations (due to failure of pumps, blower, emergency overhead tank etc.) are taken care of in their S. O. P.

(iv) Energy and Fuel management (Utility department)

• Fire, explosion and toxic release in Coke Oven gas boosting station due to air ingression in booster inlet, failure of interlocks etc.

• Fire, explosion and toxic release in LD gas holder due to high O 2 % in LD gas, failure of interlocks etc.

• Fire and explosion in booster fan due to failure of U seal, failure of interlocks etc.

• Asphyxiation due to release or rupture in liquid oxygen, nitrogen and argon tanks. The release may be due to failure of existing instrumentation, overpressure, overfilling, corrosion (not for oxygen tank) etc.

• Fire and explosion due to accidental release of propane in the storage area.

• Corrosion, structural failure, human error or any third party activity could lead to an accidental release.

(v) Liquid oxygen plant

Oxygen plant is located within TSK premise. Primary hazards that TSK may experience with liquid oxygen are:

• Exposure to cold temperatures that can cause severe burns; • Over-pressurization due to expansion of small amounts of liquid into large volumes of gas in inadequately vented equipment; • Oxygen enrichment of the surrounding atmosphere; and • The possibility of a combustion reaction if the oxygen is permitted to contact a non- compatible material and high decibel noise.

- 73 -

Low temperature of liquid oxygen and vapors it releases not only pose a serious burn hazard to human tissue, but can also cause many materials of construction to lose their strength and become brittle enough to shatter. Large expansion ratio of liquid-to-gas can rapidly build pressure in systems where liquid can be trapped. One volume of liquid oxygen at its boiling point and atmospheric pressure will vaporize into approximately 860 volumes of gaseous oxygen at 21.1 O C and 1 atmosphere.

(vi) Steel Melting Shop (BOF/LD converter)

Various critical operations, viz., blowing, tapping, de-slagging, mixing etc. are performed in this section. All operations are very much critical with respect to continuous supply of power. As far as mechanical and process hazards are concerned, this section is susceptible for:

• Metal spillage (ladle through/converter through) • Ladle breakout at turret in casting position • Gas leakage from gas duct of converter; • Fire inside cable tunnel; • Water leakage through skirt hood, skirt inlet, operating lance etc.

(vii) Gasholders/furnaces etc.

Gasholders, furnaces etc. in TSK are prone to confined space safety hazards. The occupational safety and health hazards that may exist in a confined space are the build-up of toxic or flammable gases, oxygen displacement and engulfment. A confined space often has poor air quality. In addition, many fatalities occur to rescue personnel who respond without adequate planning and protection. Works in confined spaces/temporary occupancy in TSK are related to the repairing on furnaces, gas holders, tanks or servicing a silo etc.

The risk potential of the above hazards and other potential hazardous events are shown in Table 1.

TABLE 1 - ENVIRONMENTAL RISK POTENTIAL

- 74 -

D. Failure scenarios

Looking into nature of process, storage, handling of chemicals in TSK, following events may lead to major accident scenarios: • Heavy release of Blast Furnace gas or LD gas. • Explosion in blast furnaces and LD Shop. • Major fire/explosion in Blast furnace gas, LD gas storage or network. • Major fire in the plant involving materials like LDO. • Fire and explosion associated with calcium carbide, magnesium • Heavy release of toxic chlorine due to catastrophic rupture of storage vessels/tonners. • Leakage from Liquid oxygen storage tanks

- 75 -

• Explosion in air separation units in oxygen plant • Explosion in Oxygen compressors

As per regulatory provisions (As per Orissa Factories (Control of Major Accident Hazard) Rules, 2001 and MSIHC rules 1989 as amended in 2000), OEP of TSK is to be prepared for worst-case release scenarios associated with maximum damage potentials. Worst-case scenarios are considered for the ultimate preparedness planning purposes against any type of scenario. Accordingly, the following hazardous chemicals susceptible for creating on-site/off-site emergency scenarios in TSK have been considered for assessing the damage potentials through consequence analysis and thereby predicting the vulnerable zones and fatality/injured levels:

• Chlorine (Toxic) • Blast Furnace (BF) gas (Toxic) • LD gas (Toxic) • Coke Oven Gas (Flammable) • LDO (Pool fire)

In TSK, the Propane bullets are mounded. As far as the probable hazard scenarios are concerned, there is no possibility of BLEVE. If the liquid receiver line (exposed outside the vessel) connected to the mounded vessel gets ruptured, it may lead to vapour cloud explosion/flash fire if not mitigated in time. However, looking to the maximum diameter (3 inch) of the line, the impact will be localized/on-site if controlled in time. Hence it is not considered.

At present there is no Coke oven gas holder in TSK. However modeling has been carried out for the proposed Coke Oven gas holder.

Worst-case/maximum credible loss scenarios are:

Scenario 1: Chlorine-cata-toxic (Catastrophic failure of a chlorine tonner resulting into instantaneous release of 900 kg of liquid chlorine when the protection system fails)

Consequence analysis show that a chlorine vapour cloud with concentration level of 35 ppm can be felt within the maximum downwind distance of 1438 m from release point when a catastrophic rupture of a chlorine tonner occurs with the release of 900 kg under D class and wind speed of 4 m/s. The maximum impact distance to IDLH concentration (10 ppm) is about 2.8 km from the release point under D class and 4 m/s. The end point distance for the leak scenario from liquid space of a tonner is about 1.8 km from the location for IDLH level under D; 4 m/s.

The consequence analysis results for chlorine vapour cloud are also shown in Fig 1 in terms of footprint of cloud (Footprint is a sort of map of a vapour cloud viewed from above, where the x-axis is the length of the cloud and the y-axis is the width of the cloud) for various concentration levels and variation of centreline concentration of cloud with distance from release. The cloud footprint depicts the impact zones or area affected by the various concentration levels of chlorine in the downwind direction after release.

- 76 -

FIG. 1 - CHLORINE CLOUD FOOTPRINT FOR A) 35 PPM (LD50) B) 10 PPM (IDLH) AND C) 3 PPM (STEL)

- 77 -

Scenario 2: Catastrophic failure of BFGH

Consequence modeling for catastrophic failure of Gas holders has been carried out using DNV Phast Lite 7.1 to quantify the extent of the impact from this event.

For BF gas holders, toxic exposure from failure of gas holders has been considered due to relatively high concentration of Carbon monoxide gas in BF gas.

Fig. 2 shows the maximum concentration footprint of leaked gas from catastrophic rupture of the BF gas holder. The concentration of interest (151.5 ppm) corresponding to the STEL value of BF gas extends up to a maximum distance of around 105 m downwind.

FIG. 2 - MAXIMUM CONCENTRATION FOOTPRINT FOR BF GAS HOLDER

Scenario 3: Catastrophic failure of LDGH

Fig. 3 shows the maximum concentration footprint of leaked gas from catastrophic rupture of the LD gas holder. The concentration of interest (555 ppm) corresponding to the STEL value of LD gas extends up to a maximum distance of around 155 m downwind.

- 78 -

FIG 3 - MAXIMUM CONCENTRATION FOOTPRINT FOR LD GAS HOLDER

Scenario 4: Catastrophic Failure of COGH (Fireball)

For Coke oven gas holder, heat radiation from ignition of leaked gas has been considered due to its relatively high concentration of H2 and CH4. Fig 4 shows the intensity radius for fireball arising due to catastrophic rupture of the CO gas holder. Two radiation levels of interest have been plotted and as observed, the 4 kW/m2 (pain threshold) radiation level extends up to about 200 m distance and the 12.5 kW/m2 (first degree burns) radiation level extends up to about 100 m distance.

FIG. 4 - FIRE BALL INTENSITY RADIUS FOR CO GAS HOLDER

- 79 -

Scenario 5: Pool fire of LDO (900 Kl)

FIG. 5 - FIRE BALL INTENSITY RADIUS FOR CO GAS HOLDER

A radiation level of secondary damage (12.5 kW/m 2 ) corresponding to LDO pool fire will be confined within the distance of only 20 m from the location of tank as shown in Fig 5.

E. Mitigation of On-Site Risks

Consequence of a major hazardous events as described above would be mitigated by implementation of on-site emergency management plan as already available. This would be augmented as required to encompass the risks posed by the units proposed under the expansion.

Moreover, a HAZOP Study for the selected units/areas needs to be undertaken at the ‘design-freeze’ stage, when P&I diagrams, shop layout drawings, control logic diagrams, technical specifications etc are made ready. For these areas, ‘Fault Tree Analysis’ of the failure of equipment/valve component or due to human error can be carried out to assess more realistically risk involved and draw up final management measures. Also HAZOP Study will be conducted for fuel gas distribution network, to incorporate last minute corrections in design of the system from fail-safe angle, prior to commissioning. HAZOP Study for the selected units/areas will be undertaken at the ‘design-freeze’ stage, when P&I diagrams, shop layout drawings, control logic diagrams, technical specifications etc are made ready.

- 80 -

Annexure 5: EMP Matrix

Query (V): Please submit the EMP Matrix indicating; EMP Details, Time line for implementation; Budgetary provision and monitoring schedule and monitoring methodology

Reply: EMP Matrix along with EMP details, timeline, budegetary provision and monitoring schedule is provided below under followinmg headings:

A. Envirnoment Management Plan Matrix - Constrcution Phase - Operation Pahse - Budget

B. Environmnet Monitoring Program Matrix - With monitoing schedule and methodolgy - Timeline for implementation & budegtary provision

A. Envirnoment Management Plan Matrix

• Management measures for pollution control and environmental management in the expansion area are given table

Discipline Potential impacts Mitigation measures Construction Phase Air quality Emission of dust due to - Water sprinkling to arrest fugitive dust construction activities leading to emission. adverse health & environmental - Wind barrier screen provided to reduce the impacts wind speed and consequently, reduce the fugitive dust emission. - Logistics would be designed to minimize movement of trucks transporting construction materials and optimize storage of construction materials at site Water quality Discharge of construction - Labour hutments would be provided with wastewater including sanitary proper sanitation facilities having soak pits. and kitchen wastewater causing - The stockpiles would be protected with toe adverse health & ecological wall of adequate height along with concrete impacts garland drain & catch pits to prevent uncontrolled discharge of runoffs during monsoon.

Noise Increase in noise level due to - Provision of Personal Protective Equipment construction activities causing (PPE) like ear muffs, ear plugs etc. health effects - Noise prone construction activities such as piling, drilling, excavation, cutting, etc. would be done during daytime only

- 81 -

Discipline Potential impacts Mitigation measures Land Adverse impact on land due to - Cleaning of site from all sorts of construction dumping of solid waste like wastes would be done from the respective construction & demolition construction zones. debris, excess concrete & - The construction waste would be stored in an cement, rejected components, earmarked area within the plant & used as packing & shipping materials construction aggregate and domestic waste. - The waste debris would be stored in an earmarked area and recyclable materials would be segregated & sold to entrepreneurs for secondary use. The balance material would be disposed as per prevalent regulations. - Domestic solid wastes of the labour hutments to be collected in colour coded bins for segregation, and disposed as per prevalent regulations. Ecology Adverse effect on the ecology of - Strengthening of greenbelt & peripheral the plant area not envisaged plantation since there would be no removal of vegetation as plant premises already has built up areas Socio- Around fifteen thousand Local employable (both men & women) Economics contract workers would be population would get preference in the proposed employed during construction expansion project as per the applicable phase regulations indicating a positive impact Promotion of Industrial Training & Skill building Both during construction and of local population (both men & women), under operation phases, CER and/or CSR activities socioeconomic development of the local region will occur under Strengthening of vocational training courses and CER and/or CSR activities income generating programmes, under CER and/or CSR activities Social disturbance and strikes may occur with regard to Strict adherence to mitigation measures as hostility towards migrants for mentioned in Chapter 2 & 4 (Pollution Control employment opportunities both Measures & Waste Water Discharge) during the phases construction & operation Recycling/Reuse of treated effluents to attain Zero Effluent Discharge from the plant Both during the construction and operation phases the Investment in Rain Water Harvesting expansion project may Programme for internal use, exerting no contribute to Dust and Water pressure on existing water levels in the study Pollution area, under EMP

Both during construction and Conducting regular health camps and operation phases, augmenting scope & services of the Mobile augmentation and/or Health Units (MHUs) with special focus on construction of approach roads tuberculosis, skin diseases and kidney ailments, under CER and/or CSR activities

- 82 -

Discipline Potential impacts Mitigation measures and linkages (connecting Sprinkling of water by tankers dust suppression interior villages), would on roads lead to better connectivity and - positively impact the local infrastructure Both during construction and operation phases continued emphasis would be laid on the aspect of health & safety of their Supervision and Monitoring of Contractors workers

Delay in payments and biased provision of job opportunities may continue during construction and operation phases Operation Phase Land - No impact on land - All stockpiles would be on top of a stable liner environment in terms of loss to avoid leaching of materials during of agricultural land or loss of monsoon. vegetation - Maximum reuse/recycling of solid wastes - Potential negative impact due through practicable ventures. to temporary storage of raw - Monitoring of ground water quality to detect materials and solid waste contamination due to leaching

Surface Water No adverse impact as additional - Optimum use of water through water Resource water extraction not required for conservation measures the expansion - Rainwater harvesting - Calculation of water footprint, water auditing and provision of water consumption meters for each production facility to facilitate water budgeting, minimize losses and monitor water consumption on regular basis. Waste water Adverse effects on health & - Adoption of Zero Effluent Discharge by quality of surface stream if installation of CETP (with RO) to ensure no untreated waste water is discharge of waste water discharged - Monitoring of storm water discharge point to ensure quality of discharge as per CPCB/OSPCB rules Air Adverse impacts on health & - Selection & maintenance of APC equipments Environment environment due to emission of for fugitive & point source emissions PM, SO2 and NOx - Process optimization to control emission - Interlocking of APC equipments to shut down plant units in case of APC failure - Pneumatic or covered conveying of raw material - Maintenance of Plant roads and use of industrial vacuum cleaners & water sprinkling at regular intervals. - Operation & maintenance of tyre washing system at the strategic locations of the plant

- 83 -

Discipline Potential impacts Mitigation measures Noise Detrimental impact on the - Noise levels for the new equipment and health of working personnel in machineries to be fixed at 85 dB (A) Leq and around the plant premises. within 3 m distance from the noise prone equipment. - Highly noise prone equipment having Leq above 90 dB (A) would either be housed separately or the attending personnel need to be housed in a noise-shielded cubicle. - Noise prone rotating/vibrating equipment provided with vibration dampening anchoring. - Use of appropriate PPEs

Socio- Around three thousand workers Economics would be directly employed during operation phase indicating a positive impact

Local employable population - Initiation of community awareness workshops (both men and women) would (involving local women and youth groups as be given preference propagators ) on consequences and

prevention of addictions

Positive impact due to - Initiation of guidance programmes (especially improvement of the social for the youth and tribal groups) emphasizing environment through CER on physical & mental health, motivation, and/or CSR activities of TSK guidance and character building with regard to alcohol addiction,

allied brawls and violence - Initiation of workshops and organization of

locals groups emphasizing on community

driven safety measures for adolescent girls Specific needs related to and women and against domestic violence provision of piped water supply,

borewells/ tubewells, solar

water tanks, renovation of wells and dredging of ponds would be taken up under CER activities, leading to positive impact on availability of potable water within the study area

ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN

Summary of Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation

The summary of anticipated adverse environmental impacts and mitigation measures are given below:

ANTICIPATED ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION

- 84 -

Impact on Potential baseline Impact on Negative Probable Without Mitigative baseline Discipline Impacts Source EMP Measures With EMP Remarks Constructional Impact Water Quality Increase in Loose soil at -2 During monsoon +1 _ suspended construction season run off from solids due to site construction site will soil run-off be routed to during heavy a temporary precipitation sedimentation tank for settlement of suspended solids. Air Quality Increase in Leveling activity -2 Sprinkling of water +1 The impact dust and and Heavy in the construction will be low, as gaseous vehicular area and on the main concentration movement unpaved roads. approach Proper road will be maintenance of paved with vehicles will be tar. done. Noise Increase in Construction -1 Equipment will be 0 Workers will noise equipment kept be level in good condition provided to keep the noise necessary level within 90 dB protective (A). equipment. e.g. ear plug, earmuffs. Terrestrial Only Grass and Soil enabling -1 Landscaping and +1 Plantation Ecology shrubs activities extensive plantation will be done. will be done. Socio- Land is under - 0 0 economics plant premises. No -- land acquisition is required Operational Impact Water Quality Deterioration of Discharge from -2 Adequate effluent +1 The plant surface water various plant treatment facilities effluent after quality units already in place treatment will conform to the be reused to regulatory maximum standards. possible extent. Air Quality Increase in PM Fugitive -2 Dust suppression +1 The resultant levels in emissions measures will be air ambient air. implemented Quality will Fumes, Acid Emission from conform to the mist, vapors stack APCEs is installed stipulated as per required standards. norms Particulate emission from stack will be kept below 50 mg/Nm3. Solid waste Iron oxide Plant, mills -2 Recycled and sold +1 Dust

- 85 -

Impact on Potential baseline Impact on Negative Probable Without Mitigative baseline Discipline Impacts Source EMP Measures With EMP Remarks powder, to authorized generation Oil sludge, agencies will be Muck, Flue controlled by dust, APCE maintaining dust the area in wet condition. Ecology a. Terrestrial Impact on Fugitive -1 Emission will be 0 As Ambient plant species Emissions controlled as well air quality will as dispersed be within through limits, no appropriate active injury design. to the vegetation is expected. b. Aquatic Impact on Treated waste -2 The wastewater +1 As all the water Water from will be effluents bodies plant provided with will be adequate treated to treatment Pond conform to and the treated prescribed wastewater will be limits, no used for significant Horticulture impact on purposes aquatic life is expected Noise Increase in Equipment in -1 Equipment will be 0 Employees noise main plant and designed to working in levels in the auxiliaries. conform to noise high noise plant area. levels prescribed by areas would regulatory be provided agencies. earplugs/ Provision of green earmuffs as belt and plantation protective would further help device. in attenuating noise. Demography Strain on 0 Local population +2 Overall socio- and Socio- existing will be given economic economics amenities like preference in status of the housing, water awarding work. No area is sources and significant impact is Expected to sanitation, envisaged. improve. medical and Additional facilities infrastructure will be facilities. developed by the project proponents.

Legend: 0 – No impact/Insignificant; 1 – Marginal; 2 – Moderate; 3 – Significant; Positive sign (+) – Beneficial; Negative sign (-) – Adverse

- 86 -

Note: Impact scales are of relative qualitative values in respect of baseline status

• Air Pollution Control (APC)

 Mitigation measures to be installed for management of air pollution and design targets for APC equipment

Fugitive/ Point Sl. Production Emission Sources No. Unit/Facilities Sources emissions Design Target Fugitives: 5 % PLD On-main charging 1% PLL by HPLA 4% PLO BaP < 5 micro gm/cu m Land based coke (at the battery top) side dust BaP < 2 micro gm/cu m extraction (other units in Coke Oven Plant)

Leak proof oven Coke Oven doors, water Combustion Stack emissions: 1. Battery- Stack Battery Existing SPM < 50 mg/Nm3 Sealed ascension SO2 < 400 mg/Nm3 pipe NOx < 200 mg/Nm3

Hydro jet Door De-Dusting Cleaning at a SPM < 30 mg/Nm3 pressure of 600 atm. CDQ SPM < 30 mg/Nm3

On-main charging Fugitives: by HPLA 5 % PLD 1% PLL Land based coke 4% PLO side dust BaP < 5 micro gm/cu m extraction (at the battery top) BaP < 2 micro gm/cu m Leak proof oven (other units in Coke Oven Plant) Coke Oven Combustion 2. doors, water Battery- New Stack Stack emissions: Sealed ascension Battery pipe SPM < 30 mg/Nm3 SO2 < 400 mg/Nm3 Hydro jet Door NOx < 200 mg/Nm3 Cleaning at a pressure of 600 De-Dusting atm. SPM < 20 mg/Nm3

- 87 -

Fugitive/ Point Sl. Production Emission Sources No. Unit/Facilities Sources emissions Design Target

CDQ SPM < 20 mg/Nm3 Stack emissions: WASTE GAS Stock House and SPM < 50 mg/Nm3 Sinter Cooler Air Waste flue SO2 < 200 mg/Nm3 3. Sinter Plant Cleaning by DE gas cleaning NOx < 200 mg/Nm3 System of Fabric by ESP

Filter Dedusting SPM < 20 mg/Nm3 Stack emissions: WASTE GAS SPM < 20 mg/Nm3 Stock House by Waste flue SO2 < 50 mg/Nm3 4. Pellet Plant DE System of gas cleaning NOx < 150 mg/Nm3 Fabric Filter by DE System Dedusting (HLBS, Ball Mill & Dryer) SPM < 20 mg/Nm3

Stack emissions:

Stove SPM < 20 mg/Nm3 SO2 < 200 mg/Nm3 NOx < 150 mg/Nm3

Stock House SPM < 40 mg/Nm3 BF Stove

BF Stock House Stock Blast Cast House BF Cast House BF Stock 5. Furnaces- SPM < 40 mg/Nm3 Emission control House Existing Time of implementation – 10-12 months by ESP BF Cast Fugitive Emission House SPM (less than 10 microns) PM10 (ug/m3)-3000 So2: 150 ug/m3 NOx: 120 ug/m3 Carbon monoxide 8 hours :5000 ug/m3 1 hours: 10,000 ug/m3

Cast House (Pb):2 ug/m3 Stack emissions: BF Stove

BF Stock House Stock Stove Blast BF Cast House BF Stock 6. SPM < 20 mg/Nm3 Furnaces- New Emission control House SO2 < 50 mg/Nm3 by ESP BF Cast NOx < 150 mg/Nm3 House

- 88 -

Fugitive/ Point Sl. Production Emission Sources No. Unit/Facilities Sources emissions Design Target Stock House SPM < 20 mg/Nm3 Cast House SPM < 20 mg/Nm3 Fugitive Emission SPM (less than 10 microns) PM10 (ug/m3)-3000 So2: 150 ug/m3 NOx: 120 ug/m3 Carbon monoxide 8 hours :5000 ug/m3 1 hours: 10,000 ug/m3

Cast House (Pb):2 ug/m3 Stack emissions:

BOF SPM < 40 mg/Nm3

Secondary Fugitive Emission Steel Melt BOF Shop emission SPM < 4000 ug/m3 7. Shop Existing emissions by ESPs stack through SO2 < 150 ug/m3 ESP/Bag filter NOx < 150 ug/m3 Carbon monoxide 8 hours :5000 ug/m3 1 hours: 10,000 ug/m3 Convertor (Pb):2 ug/m3

LF SPM < 40 mg/Nm3

Fugitive Emission SPM < 4000 ug/m3 Secondary Steel Melt SO2 < 150 ug/m3 LF emissions by emission 8. Shop NOx < 150 ug/m3 Bag Filter stack through Extension Carbon monoxide Bag filter 8 hours :5000 ug/m3 1 hours: 10,000 ug/m3

Convertor (Pb):2 ug/m3

Stack emissions:

Waste flue Lime Calcining SPM < 30 mg/Nm3 9. - gas through Plant- Existing SO2 < 50 mg/Nm3 fabric filter NOx < 100 mg/Nm3 Time of implementation – 10-12 months Waste flue Stack emissions: Lime Calcining 10 - gas through Plant- New fabric filter SPM < 20 mg/Nm3

- 89 -

Fugitive/ Point Sl. Production Emission Sources No. Unit/Facilities Sources emissions Design Target SO2 < 50 mg/Nm3 NOx < 100 mg/Nm3 Time of implementation – 10-12 months Stack emissions: Waste flue RHF gas emission SPM < 30 mg/Nm3 11. Mill - Existing - control by low- SO2 < 100 mg/Nm3 NOx oxy -fuel NOx < 250 mg/Nm3 burner

Stack emissions: RHF & LF SPM < 25 mg/Nm3 Waste flue SO2 < 100 mg/Nm3 gas emission NOx < 250 mg/Nm3 12 Mill - New - control by low-

NOx oxy -fuel CRM burner SPM < 25 mg/Nm3 SO2 < 50 mg/Nm3 NOx < 250 mg/Nm3 Waste flue Stack emissions: gas emission SPM < 30 mg/Nm3 13. CPP- Existing control by low- SO2 < 50 mg/Nm3 NOx oxy -fuel NOx < 100 mg/Nm3 burner Waste flue Stack emissions: gas emission SPM < 25 mg/Nm3 14. CPP- New control by low- SO2 < 50 mg/Nm3 NOx oxy -fuel NOx < 100 mg/Nm3 burner

In addition to mitigation measures stated, other management measures would be implemented to further improve the air quality:

i. Pneumatic or covered truck transportation to the Sinter Plant would be employed for the collected dusts from the bag filters/ESPs of various units.

ii. Plant roads would be black topped & kept dust free by using industrial vacuum cleaners and water sprinkling at regular intervals.

iii. Installation of tyre washing system at the strategic locations of the plant to reduce the fugitive dust due to movement of heavy vehicles.

• Noise Pollution Control Measures  The following measures would be adopted for mitigating noise pollution:

i. In order to mitigate the work zone noise level, it is proposed to confine all those noise prone equipment, which do not require continuous attendance in a separate housing. In addition, for those areas such as mills, crane movement, and other

- 90 -

noisy process operations, the operational staff would work from the noise shielded control rooms/pulpits.

ii. At the time of design and engineering of the proposed steel plant, special attention would be provided for selection of low noise prone equipment. Rotary equipment prone to vibration would require vibration dampening at the time of grouting of those equipment. In addition, noise due to ejection of high pressure steam to air or exhaust gas would require attenuation by silencers of appropriate designs.

iii. Use of earmuffs by the operational and maintenance personnel would be required to work in noisy environment for a short duration.

iv. administrative control by preparing appropriate rosters of the operating personnel so that no one stays beyond 8 hrs on a continuous basis in noisy environment of Leq above 85 dB (A).

• WASTE WATER MANAGEMENT PLAN - Covered under ADS reply on scheme for ZLD (Annexure 6)

• SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN - Covered under ADS reply on scheme for Solid Waste Management (Annexure 12)

• GREENBELT DEVELOPMENT - Covered under ADS reply on additional greenbelt (Annexure 7)

• RAINWATER HARVESTING - Covered under ADS reply on ZLD and scheme for improvement of plant drainage pattern (Annexure 6 and Annexure 12)

• CER - Covered under ADS reply on details of CER activities (Annexure 9)

• EMP Budget

Following table shows the EMP budget for proposed project Area Rs., Crore Water Conservation and Wastewater Treatment 660.00. Air Pollution Control Measure 790.00 Solid Waste management 310.00 Energy Conservation 780.00 Greenbelt Development, Rainwater harvesting and On-line 80.00 Monitoring & Environmental Laboratory CER 42.75 Total 2,662.75

- 91 -

Annual operation expenses (OPEX) for operation and maintenance of pollution control measures would be around Rs. 50 crores. However, these estimates may escalate at the time of project execution

- 92 -

B. Environment Monitoring Program schedule and monitoring methodology

Period of Sample Monitoring implement- Sampling Location Type Analysis Frequency methodology tation Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Capex: Nil and Opex: .25 crore AAQ Monitoring (Manual as per NAAQ 2009) AQS#1 (Near Gate-1) PM10 & PM2.5, AQS#2 (Near Gate-4) SO2, NO2, CO, 24 hourly NH , O , Pb, Weekly Manual method as AQS#3 (Near Gate-3) 3 3 Ongoing Composite C6H6, BaP, As, Twice per NAAQ 2009 TSK R& R colony/ Duburi Ni (12 parameters) Online Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Capex: Nil and Opex 0.70 crore AAQMS #1 (Near Gate-1) Automatic (Online) AAQMS #2 (Near Gate-4) PM10 & PM2.5: Beta AAQMS #3 (Trijanga) TSK attenuation R& R colony SO : UV Continuous 2 AAQMS #4 (Near Plot-2) PM & PM , Fluorescence 10 2.5 Ambient Air AAQMS#5 Continuous SO2, NOx, CO NOx: Ongoing Quality (Near BPP Site) and O3 Chemiluminescence Monitoring AAQMS#6 CO: Non-dispersive (Gobarghati) Infrared (NDIR) AAQMS#7 O3: (Near Sansailo) Chemiluminescence Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems Existing Plant Capex: Niland Opex 1.8 crore Captive Power Plant CPP#1 PM, SO2 & NOx Captive Power Plant CPP#2 PM, SO2 & NOx Coke Plant COB#1 PM, SO2 & NOx Coke Plant COB#2 PM, SO2 & NOx Coke Plant DE#1 PM Coke Plant DE#2 PM CDQ #1 PM, SO2 & NOx Sinter Plant WG PM, SO & NOx 2 CEMS: Sinter Plant SP#DE PM Continuous PM: Opacity/Light Within 6 Blast Furnace Stove Continuous PM, SO2 & NOx Emissions Scattering months Blast Furnace BF CH1 PM Monitoring SO2 & NOx: NDIR Blast Furnace BF CH2 PM Blast Furnace BF Stock PM House Lime Kiln #1 PM Lime Kiln #2 PM BOF#SE1 PM HSM- RHF#1 PM, SO2 & NOx HSM- RHF#2 PM, SO2 & NOx Manual Stack Monitoring Captive Power Plant CPP#1 Captive Power Plant CPP#2 Coke Plant COB#1 Source PM10 & PM2.5, Sampling: NOx, SO , CO, Coke Plant COB#2 2 Monthly Manual CO , Moisture, Isokinetic sampling Ongoing Coke Plant DE#1 2 once Stack Temperature, Coke Plant DE#2 Monitoring Flow and O CDQ DE#1 2 Sinter Plant SP#WG

- 93 -

Period of Sample Monitoring implement- Sampling Location Type Analysis Frequency methodology tation Sinter Plant SP#DE Blast Furnace BF# CH1 Blast Furnace BF# CH2 Blast Furnace BF# Stock House Lime Kiln #1 Lime Kiln #2 BOF#SE1 HSM- RHF#1 HSM- RHF#2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems - Proposed Proposed Stack Capex: 16 crore and Opex: 5 crore PLP #WASTE GAS PM, NOx, SO2, PLP # DISCHARGE AND PM HLSB DE PLP #DRYER-1 & 2 DE PM PLP #BALLMILL-1 DE PM PLP #BALLMILL-2 DE PM PLP# SCREEN HOUSE PM HSM-RHF#3 PM, NOx, SO2, CRM-ARP#1 (Dust Emission) PM CRM-PLTCM#1 (Dust PM Emission) CRM-PLTCM#1 (TCM PM Fumes) CRM-CAL#1-1 PM CRM-CAL#1-2 (SPM) PM LP Mills # 1 PM, NOx, SO2 LP Mills # 2 PM, NOx, SO2 COB#3 PM, NOx, SO 2 Along with COB#4 PM, NOx, SO 2 commission COB#3 DE Continuous PM ing of plant COB#4 DE PM (3 to 5 COB#2 CDQ PM, NOx, SO2 years) COB#3 CDQ PM, NOx, SO2 LimeKiln #3 PM LimeKiln #4 PM BOF#SE2 PM LF1#FE PM LF2#FE PM BF#2SH (Iron Fine-1) PM BF#2SH (Iron Fine-2) PM BF#2SH (Coke Fine) PM BF#2CH1 PM BF#2CH2 PM CPP Boiler # 3 PM, NOx, SO2 CPP Boiler # 4 PM, NOx, SO2 Incineration PM, NOx, SO2, Moisture and CO2

- 94 -

Manual Stack Monitoring: Proposed Capex: Nil and Opex 30 lakh PLP #WASTE GAS PLP # DISCHARGE AND HLSB DE PLP #DRYER-1 & 2 DE PLP #BALLMILL-1 DE PLP #BALLMILL-2 DE PLP# SCREEN HOUSE HSM-RHF#3 CRM-ARP#1 (Acid Fumes) CRM-ARP#1 (Dust Emission) CRM-PLTCM#1 (Pickling Fumes) CRM-PLTCM#1 (Dust Emission) CRM-PLTCM#1 (TCM Fumes) CRM-CAL#1-1

CRM-CAL#1-2 (SPM) PM10 & PM2.5, LP Mills # 1 Source NOx, SO , CO, After 2 Monthly LP Mills # 2 Sampling CO , Moisture, Isokinetic sampling commission 2 once COB#3 Manual Temperature, ing of plant COB#4 Flow and O2 COB#3 DE COB#4 DE COB#2 CDQ COB#3 CDQ LimeKiln #3 LimeKiln #4 BOF#SE2 LF1#FE LF2#FE BF#2SH (Iron Fine-1) BF#2SH (Iron Fine-2) BF#2SH (Coke Fine) BF#2CH1 BF#2CH2 CPP Boiler # 3 CPP Boiler # 4 Incineration

- 95 -

Wastewater Monitoring Waste Water Capex: 5 crore and Opex: 0.7 crore Ongoing for Temperature, pH, existing units & Spectroanalyser Conductivity, Phenol, Continuous after BOD outlet Continuous / Electrode Cyanide, DO,BOD, COD, Monitoring commissioning Online Systems TSS of Phase-II units Temperature, pH, Spectroanalyser Continuous Surface Runoff Continuous Conductivity, Phenol, /Electrode Ongoing Monitoring Cyanide, BOD, COD, TSS Online Systems CETP pH, Conductivity, Colour, Turbidity, TSS, Dissolved Oxygen (DO) (mg./l) , BOD (mg/l) , COD (mg/l) , Suspended Solids (SS) (mg/l) , Oil & Greese (mg/l) Phenolic compounds (as Manual Surface runoff Grab sample Daily Ongoing C H OH) (mg./l) , Cyanide Method: APHA at Plant outlet 6 5 (as CN) (mg./l) , Chloride (as Cl) (mg./l) , Ammoniacal Nitrogen (mg./l) , Total Hardness (mg/l) , Iron (Fe) (mg/l) & Alkalinity (mg/l) Surface water Upstream of pH, Colour, Taste, Ganda Nalla at Turbidity, DO, BOD, COD, Barkhai Alkalinity, Hardness, TDS, Downstream of Conductivity, Ca mg/l, Mg Ganda Nalla at mg/l, Na mg/l, K mg/l, Cu Kusunpur mg/l, Fe mg/l, Mn mg/l, Cl Manual: IS: Grab sample mg/l, Sulphates, NO mg/l, Monthly Ongoing Downstream of 3 2296 Se mg/l, As mg/l, CN mg/l, Kharsua river Pb mg/l, Fluoride, C H OH at Jokodha 6 5 mg/l, Hg mg/l, Cd mg/l, Zn (Confluence mg/l, Ni mg/l, Cr mg/l, Cr+6 point of Ganda mg/l, Mineral Oil, SS, Nalla) Residual Free Chlorine, Ground Water - Capex: Nil (Outsourcing through NABL approved Lab) and Opex: 0.05 crore Tube Well at pH, Colour, Taste, Manipatra Turbidity, DO, COD, Village Alkalinity, Hardness, TDS, Conductivity, Ca mg/l, Mg mg/l, Na mg/l, K mg/l, Cu mg/l, Fe mg/l, Mn mg/l, Cl Grab sample mg/l, Sulphates, NO mg/l, Monthly IS 10500: 2012 Ongoing Tube Well at 3 Se mg/l, As mg/l, CN mg/l, Duburi Pb mg/l, Fluoride, C6H5OH Junction mg/l, Hg mg/l, Cd mg/l, Zn mg/l, Ni mg/l, Cr mg/l, Cr+6 mg/l, Mineral Oil, SS, Rsidual Free Chlorine

- 96 -

Drinking Water: Capex: Nil (Outsourcing through NABL approved Lab) and Opex: 0.05 crore Plant Area pH, Colour, Taste, Turbidity, DO, COD, Alkalinity, Hardness, TDS, Conductivity, Ca mg/l, Mg mg/l, Na mg/l, K mg/l, Cu mg/l, Fe mg/l, Mn mg/l, Cl Residential Grab sample mg/l, Sulphates, NO3 mg/l, Monthly IS 10500: 2012 Ongoing Colony Area Se mg/l, As mg/l, CN mg/l, Pb mg/l, Fluoride, C6H5OH mg/l, Hg mg/l, Cd mg/l, Zn mg/l, Ni mg/l, Cr mg/l, Cr+6 mg/l, Mineral Oil, SS, Rsidual Free Chlorine,

Noise: Capex: 0.2 Crore and Opex: 0.05 crore Ambient Noise Monitoring Boundary line (4 locatons- Weekly: Gate -1,2,3&4) Day time Residential Colony at Plot-II (06.00 am to Sound Level Leq, L10, L90, Ambient 22.00 pm) Meter R&R Colony at Gobarghati SPLmax & SPL min Ongoing Noise and Night (IEC 804 (BS R&R Colony at Trijanga in dBA- Weekly time (22.00 6698) Grade I) R&R Colony at Sansailo pm to 06.00 am) Noise Monitoring Weekly: Day time Ongoing for (06.00 am to Sound Level existing units & Work Leq, L10, L90, 22.00 pm) Meter after Plant locations (20 locations) Zone SPLmax & SPL min and Night (IEC 804 (BS commissioning Noise in dBA time (22.00 6698) Grade I) of Phase-II pm to 06.00 units am)

Soil Capex: Nil (Outsourcing through NABL approved Lab) and Opex 0.01 crore Soil Analysis M.I. Jackson One within plant area (Near Texture, pH, Electrical and soil Raw Material yards) and one Conductivity, Nitrogen, Grab analysis from outsideplant area Phosphorous, Season-wise Ongoing Sample reference book (Goberghati) within 10 km Potassium, Sulfur, by radius Organic Carbon C.A. Black

- 97 -

Fugitive Visible Emission Fugitive Visible Emission in Coke Plant Capex: 0.04 and Opex: 0.08 Leakage from door PLD Leakage from charging Fugitive PLL As per lids Visible Bi-monthly CPCB Ongoing Leakage from AP covers Emission in PLO Guidelines Charging Emissions Coke Plant HPLA (second/ charge) Fugitive Emissions: Benzo (a) Pyrene (BaP) in Coke Plant Capex: Nil (Outsourcing through NABL approved Lab) and Opex 0.1 crore Battery area (top of the Fugitive Ongoing for battery) (µg/m3) Emissions: existing units & Benzo (a) Benzo (a) GC after Pyrene Pyrene (BaP) & Monthly Other units in coke oven analysis commissioning (BaP) & VOC plant (µg/m3) of Phase-II VOC in units Coke Plant Fugitive Emissions in BF & SMS Capex: 0.15 Crore and Opex 0.3 Crore Blast Furnace PM10, SO2 NOx, Carbon Ongoing for Monoxide & existing units & As per Fugitive Lead as Pb in after SMS – Basic Oxygen Monthly CPCB Emissions dust at converter commissioning Furnace Guidelines floor of Phase-II units

Fugitive Emissions inside Plant Capex and Opex Included above Ongoing for Fugitive existing units & HVS/Portab Emissions: Particulate after Inside Plant: 30 locations Weekly le Dust Particulate Matter commissioning Monitor Matter of Phase-II units

- 98 -

Meteorological Parameters Capex: 0.10 Crore and Opex 0.01 Crore Temperature Wind Speed Sensor based Meteoro Wind Direction Automatic Meteorological logical Rainfall Continuous Weather On-going Parameters Paramet Relative humidity Monitoring ers Solar Radiation Station Barometric Pressure

- 99 -

Annexure 6: ZLD Action Plan

Query (vi): Actions initiated to achieve ZLD in existing plant and post implementation of the expansion proposal

Reply: Actions initiated / implemented to achieve ZLD in existing plant and post implementation of the expansion proposal is described below:

1. Total estimated effluent generation will be 1130 m3/hr. 2. The existing CETP capacity will be upgraded to 800 m3/hr from existing 673 m3/hr. At CETP, the existing RO system will be upgraded with high pH RO for better treatment & process control. New clarifiers will be added to upgrade primary treatment facilities. This facility will be fitted with crystallizer for zero discharge. 3. New Coke Oven Effluent Treatment Plant (COETP) will be added to treat rest 330 m3/hr coke oven by-product plant (BPP) effluent separately. This facility will have membrane bio reactor (MBR), RO & crystallizer for zero discharge. 4. The simplified water balance is given in fig no. 6.1

Fig 6.1 - Water Balance at 9 MTPA Finished Steel 5. Plant drains which collect rain & seepage water will be connected to Storm Water Reservoir (38900 m3). From here, water will be recovered back & mixed with fresh

- 100 -

water in Raw Water reservoir which is being supplied to plant network after necessary treatment.

Seepage & drains to be collected in storm water reservoir

CETP

COETP

Fig. 6.2 Scheme for Surface Drain Water Recovery

Bund wall RAW WATER RESERVOIR for

diversion, STORM WATER Overflow RESERVOIR will go to plant outlet PLANT STORM WATER DRAIN in case of

Fig 6.3 Plan View of Storm Water Reservoir Facilities

- 101 -

Annexure 7: Plantation Scheme

Query (VII): Additional Plantation scheme in the vacant land to increase greenery and control fugitive emissions as the PM 10 and PM 2.5 levels in the study area are higher than the NAAQ norms 2500 trees shall be planted per ha

Reply: Additional Plantation scheme in vacant land to increase greenery, which will help control fugitive emissions in the study area, with 2500 trees per ha is given below,

Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Total Sl Description (Nos) (Nos) (Nos) (Nos) (Nos) (Nos) a) Road side plantation in 2400 2400 2400 800 8000 areas like Pankhpal chowk to Military chowk and - Dangadi to Jakhpura to cover areas like Baghbahali, Jakhapura, Manipatra (@2500/ha) b) Mass community plantation 5000 5000 5000 5000 - 20000 every year in village within 25 panchayat around our plant. (@2500/ha) c) Development of a 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 5000 Biodiversity Park at Jakhapura of Kalinganagar Industrial area. d) Ongoing plantation in and 37500 50000 62500 60000 37500 247500 around lease area @2500 /ha 45900 58400 70900 66800 38500 280500

Following are considerations for development of greenery:  Indigenous plant species with fast growth are selected under greenbelt development.  Tree density will be @2500 trees/hectare  Maintenance and care of tree sapling planted  Qualified and experts staff will be involved in plantation activity  Trees Species: Akashmoni, Babul, Siris, Amaltas, Gulmohar, Neem, Nilgari, Jamun, Jhaun, Debdaru, Kadamba, Pipal, Am, Gamga imli, Kachnar, Bougainvillea, Karabi, Sisoo,Ganga imli etc.

Remaining area is adequate to accommodate proposed expansion, associated facilities, fabrications area, water reservoirs, etc along with plantation along boundary wall and free area as covered under (d) above (~ 99 hectare).

- 102 -

Annexure 8: Pollution control System

Query (viii): Scheme for upgradation of Pollution control systems to achieve less than 30 mg/Nm3 particulate matter emissions. Further, the estimated reduction in pollution load shall be furnished as the CEPI score for the area is 49.62.

Reply: Scheme for upgradation of pollution control systems to achieve average 30 mg/Nm3 particulate matter emission is given below. Estimated reduction in pollution load is 24.14 tons/day from baseline of 40.5 tons/day as per norms.

Proposed Norm Plan Sl Plant Stack mg / Nm3 Upgradation Scheme 1 Coke Existing 50 50 • This plant has been commissioned in recent Oven process past with single stage combustion chamber stack and going forward improved design combustion system will be taken up during rebuilding. • As per process, regular maintenance activities are being carried out to maintain operating conditions to control oven leakages to control emission levels Existing 50 30 • Modification / upgradation of bag filter system land based DE system New 50 30 • New proposed process stack (underfiring proposed stack) of the Coke Plant will be installed with process three stage combustion process to achieve stack lower emission levels. • This is supported by higher height of combustion chamber.

New 50 20 • New design for lower emission with modified proposed bag arrangement and bag area. land based DE system

2 Sinter Existing 150 50 • Current level of performance is 50 mg/Nm3. Plant stack • We are taking upgradation of existing ESP fields for process stack by installing High frequency transformer rectifier (HFTR) which is expected to lower the emission level.

3 Pellet Proposed 150 20 • New design for lower emission with modified Plant Stack bag arrangement and bag area. •

- 103 -

Proposed Norm Plan Sl Plant Stack mg / Nm3 Upgradation Scheme 4 Blast Existing DE 50 40 • We are proposing modification of ESP to Furnace stack include high frequency TR sets Existing 30 20 • By process control Stove New DE 50 20 • New design for lower emission with modified System bag arrangement and bag area for DE systems New Stoves 30 20 • Process control 5 LCP Existing 50 30 • Upgrade Bag filter stack Proposed 50 20 • Upgrade Design Stack 6 SMS Existing 50 40 • We are proposing modification of ESP to stack include high frequency TR sets, which has been seen to demonstrate lower emissions. Proposed 50 30 • Upgrade Design for 30 mg/Nm3 Stack 7 Mills Existing 50 30 • Process Control (HSM Stack) stack Proposed 50 25 • Upgrade Design for 25 mg/Nm3 Stack 8 CPP Existing 30 30 stack Proposed 30 25 • Upgrade Design for 25 mg/Nm3 Stack 9 Other Incinerator 30 30

Summary of emissions, Tons/day (PM) Norm 40.5 Proposed 8 MTPA 16.36

- 104 -

Annexure 9: CER

Query (IX): CER table based on PH proceedings and SIA conducted shall be furnished. CER expenditure as per capex indicated in EIA shall be Rs. 56.5 Cr and CER activities shall be completed in 4 years.

Reply: CER Table based on PH proceedings and SIA conducted is furnished below with completion time of 4 years. As per previous norms for CER, amount works out to Rs 42.7 crores. However, in the additional information sought letter, an amount of Rs 56.5 crores has been indicated by MoEF&CC. Same has been taken, which is indicative nature and for the purpose of phasing of various commitments as summarised below: a) CER Activities (PH Issues)

Sl. Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Total No. CER Activities (PH Issues) (Rs. in Lakh) 1. Skill Development, Technical Education and School Infrastructure a) Establishment of Skill Development Centre & Rural Micro-Entrepreneurship 100 200 150 50 500 Incubator at Kalinganagar b) Construction of science block with lab in 50 100 50 - 200 Duburi college. c) Construction of children playing corner in primary schools of nearby villages of 20 20 20 - 60 Gobarghati, Baragadia, Kapuriapada, Trijanga, Nariabanga, Duburi. 2. Greenery development in study area a) Development of a Biodiversity Park at Jakhapura of Kalinganagar Industrial 125 125 125 125 500 area. b) Road side plantation in areas like Pankhpal chowk to Military chowk and 30 30 20 20 100 Dangadi to Jakhpura to cover areas like Baghbahali, Jakhapura, Manipatra c) Mass community plantation every year in village within 25 panchayat around our 30 30 20 20 100 plant. 3. Community infrastructure a) Construction of a community Toilet block near Duburi public market 30 30 - - 60 4. Sporting facility ( Skill development & alternative employment capabilities ) a) Construction of One Rural sports complex near to Duburi( Sukinda Block) 300 300 300 300 1200

- 105 -

Sl. Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Total No. CER Activities (PH Issues) (Rs. in Lakh) to promote Tribal youth sports & athletics skill

b) Facilitating construction of sports facilities/ other infrastructure for 350 350 350 350 1400 upcoming stadium project at Jajpur 5. Health, chronic disease prevention and Drinking water a) Establish Community Health Research Centre for chronic health issues of 200 100 200 100 600 Kalinganagar peripheral villages. ** Approx allocation b) Construction of manual & solar based - borewell & tube well with storage facilities in villages of Gobarghati, 50 50 - - 100 Baragadia, Mantira, Trijanga & Sansilo Grampanchayat. Total 1285 1335 1235 965 4,820 b) CER Activities from SIA (Needs Assessment)

Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Total Sl. CER Activities From SIA (Needs (Rs. in No. Assessment) Lakh) 1. Women empower & Vocational training facility a) Activities to cover areas like Chandia, Dhapanki, Mangobindapur, Sarangpur, 25 25 25 25 100 Kacherigan 2. Community infrastructure a) Repair of village roads at Chandia, 100 100 100 100 400 Sarangapur, Khurunti and Nuagan b) Provide solar powered street lights in 40 40 20 20 120 Kalinganagar area c) Sanitation facilities/public toilets in Kalinganagar area in villages like 40 40 20 20 120 Baragadia, Chandia, Ollala, Ranagundi & Nadiabhanga d) Construction of Bus-shelter from Dangadi to 30 30 30 - 90 Gobarghati (6 Nos.) Total 235 235 195 165 830

Total allocated budget for activities proposed under CER = Rs. 5,650 lakhs.

- 106 -

Annexure 10: Dioxins/Furan… Hg

Query (x): Scheme for, control of Dioxins / Furan emissions from sinter plants, charging and pushing emissions from Coke Ovens and mercury emissions from power plant

Reply: Scheme for (a) Control of Dioxins / Furan emissions from sinter plants, (b) charging emission control at coke ovens, (c) Pushing emissions from Coke Ovens and (d) mercury emissions from power plant is given below:

(a) Scheme for control of Dioxins / Furan emissions from sinter

Techniques that TSL is using for reduction or elimination of dioxins and furans formation: 1) Selection of charge material being implemented • Separation or reduction of oil content from revert mix • Input material quality also maintained with proper blending and mixing of various raw materials to limit various impurities like alkali and chloride in feed material • Coke breeze and anthracite coal is used as solid fuel which has very low volatile matter 2) Optimization and inspection of technological processes of sinter making 3) Application of complete combustion

• Further to existing process, Mill scale is proposed to be processed with suitable agglomeration process where dioxins and furans formation will not be generated due to lower operating temperature. This will bring down the oil percentage in sinter raw material to below 0.001%.

4) Emission from Sinter Plant: Dioxins and furans from Sinter Plant adopting above practices are achieving less than <0.1 ng-l TEQ/Nm3

(b) Charging Emission from Coke Oven • During charging, generated fume from one oven is transferred to adjacent ovens by connecting them through a U-tube which is part of charging gas transfer car for redirecting gases into GC main. Suction is created in the ovens by spraying high pressure ammoniacal liquor (HPLA) into gooseneck which connects ovens to Gas Collecting main (GC Main).

In this process ammoniacal liquor is pressurized and injected through specially designed nozzles provided in the gooseneck at the time of charging. This creates adequate suction to create negative pressure inside the ovens and contain gases produced during charging within gas collection system

• In addition to gas transfer by charging gas transfer car a land based de -dusting station is also provided to take care emissions liberated from coke oven door.

- 107 -

During start of coal charging process ID fan gets ramped up which allows creation of suction in the charging emission ducts network and charging emission transfer valve of respective charging oven gets opened which allows sucking and transfer of emission to land based de dusting station where it gets purified by means of bag filters.

• Above facility is already available and in use in existing coke plant

• Same facility is planned in expansion project

• Land based APC (Air Pollution control) system is in operation in existing coke ovens in TSK. Same facility is planned in expansion project • During pushing process, coke is pushed out of the oven chamber by the pusher machine and discharged into quenching car through coke guide provided by CTC (Coke transfer car) Emissions produced during pushing operation would be collected by a hood attached to the coke transfer car and routed to the land-based APC system through ducts. The collected gas would be cleaned in the bag filters of the APC system and vented to the atmosphere after cooling.

(d) Mercury emission from power plant • Existing & proposed power plants are based on by-product fuel gases & heat recovery, for power generation. • As a result, emission of mercury is not envisaged.

- 108 -

Annexure 11: CEMS

Query (xi): The data acquired though CEMS, shall be used for control of processes in order to control the stack emissions. This should include the MIS for closing the non-conformity loop

Reply:

(A) Current facilities implemented for data acquisition & control of stack emission: • CEMS is already installed (List given at end). • HMIs in respective control rooms of different plant units have monitoring facility for pollution data as part of process control. • SCADA system based on client-server architecture comprises of Remote Terminal Units (RTU). • Data transmission and storage at central data logger system for alert generation and use of different type of MIS. • Direct connectivity to OSPCB and CPCB server for online data transfer.

(B) Use for control of processes to control stack emission including MIS • Alarm systems are configured as alerts for operator • From central data logger system, alerts are also given through SMS/e-mail to concerned person. • Daily, weekly and monthly reports generation and review of exceptions by top management

(C) At 8 MPTA Stage – existing processes will be deployed with similar systems in all upcoming plant. Flow Chart for data processing system is given below.

(D) Typical control actions:

While process and plant equipment are designed to perform within emission norms, actions taken for controlling stack emission in case level goes beyond norms is explained through a few examples below:

1) Agglomeration unit (especially sinter plant) - Based on alarms generated in control room Operator initiates (a) Slowing down of speed of sinter machine (b) Checking of Electrical field of ESP (c) Checking of likely reasons for tripping of field (d) Changing of base mix proportion to reduce possibility of ESP trpping (e) Also - Periodic checking & correction of GD screen, baffle plate, collecting and discharge electrode, efficiency of rapping mechanism, alignment of collecting electrode and field strength of ESP is done for controlling the gas cleaning efficiency & stack emission under control. In case of bag filter, checking of filter bags and replacement of same if required.

- 109 -

2) Blast furnace: a) Based on alarm for generated in control room for stove chimney: - Operator will check for air to fuel ratio in stove - Check for calibration / getting flow transmitters recalibrated - If happening in a particular stove – getting impule lines cleaned / changed - …. b) Maintenance actions are also initiated like: If SPM level beyond norms, checking of filter bags and replacement of same if required.

3) Coke Plant:

a) Related to Process: Regulation Air to fuel ratio through recirculation port for ensuring complete combustion, temperature for control of COx, SOx & NOx, checking of fuel quality and optimisation of mix of fuel to curve down the SOx & NOx level if required. b) Related to Maintenance: Checking of stage burning mechanism in multi stage burner system, checking effectiveness of by product plant for regulating SOx & NOx emission, In case of increase in SPM level, checking of filter bags (in case of Dedusting system) and replacement of same if required.

(E) Continuous emission monitoring system (CEMS) is already installed for 24/7 measurement of pollutant load at all existing stacks.

(F) Summary of continuous data forms part of daily / weekly / monthly MIS which are reviewed by different levels within the organization on regular basis.

- 110 -

ENVIRONMENTAL DATA PROCESSING SYSTEM

- 111 -

Annexure 12: Solid Waste Management

Query (xii): Confirmation is sought on the following point

(a) PP shall install a state-of-the-art Waste Recycling Plant (WRP) to process various types of slags and waste generation in the plant to recover and recycle metallic, fluxes, aggregates and boulders (b) PP shall use SMS slag as soil conditioner in watershed management area to supplement micronutrients (c) PP Shall Recover and recycle unburnt carbon from from BF Flue dust and GCP (d) PP shall use steam and CO2 to age and fix the sms slag for use as concrete for road making (e) Confirmation that PP shall practice 100 Presentation waste utilization

(a) PP shall install a state-of-the-art Waste Recycling Plant (WRP) to process various types of slags and waste generation in the plant to recover and recycle metallics, fluxes, aggregates and boulders

Reply: Waste recycling plant for recovery & recycling of metallics, fluxes, aggregates and boulders has been set-up and is in operation. Details are given herewith:

Source & slag & waste requiring such processing and capacity of plant • Steel Melting Shop is the primary location, where slag and scrap get generated, from where this recovery is necessary both from environment & cost perspective. • Estimated steel melting slag to be processed at 8 MTPA crude steel is 1.4 MTPA • Current facility installed is 300 tons per hour, which can cater to generation of 1.4 MTPA considering 60% plant availability.

Waste Recycling Plant flow diagram indication facilities provided This facility constitutes of Drop Balling Station, oxy lance cutting, jaw crusher, magnetic separation and sizing of different outputs. Flow Diagram of main unit is given below:

- 112 -

Details of the plant - Drop balling station is provided to reduce large size skulls in smaller pieces - Oxy cutting station with fume extraction system is provided for cutting tundish skulls/ buttons and jams before being sent for further processing. - There is a jaw crusher to crush smaller pieces further to liberate metallic from slag - These are then passed through magnetic separator to separate metallic - In the process, various recoveries that happen, further processing & its utilisation is given in table below:

Output: • Different size fraction being generated in terms of typical % is given in table below • Size segregation being done is from perspective of its further utilisation opportunity

Size Non-metallic portion Metallics Used as flux in Sinter making / 0-6 mm 34% 12% production of paver block Recycled in steel 6-20 mm 33% 3% Use as aggregates after making process 20-65 mm 10% 2% accelerated weathering 65-300 mm 2% 4% Total 79% 21%

- 113 -

(b) PP shall use SMS slag as soil conditioner in watershed management area to supplement micronutrients

Reply: • Background: - SMS slag has total lime of ~ 60% - SMS slag is a by-product generated during steel making operation. - In recent years new technologies are coming-up for value-added use of SMS slag. One such technology is to make use of SMS slag as soil conditioner.

• Current status: - Presence of Ca and P content improves properties of soil and by increasing plant growth. - In this regard, research project has been taken up at Tata Steel, R&D wherein LD slag will be used for converting it into yellow gypsum. This will then be added as soil conditioner. - Feasibility of using this slag as soil conditioner in watershed management areas would be explored in consultation with concerned authorities.

- Current operating sinter plant and upcoming pellet have capability of consuming BF sludge & BF flue dust (Carbon in range of 30-40%) replacing coke breeze requirements. - BF flue dust can be used in pellet plant with addition rate of 2.8% with input raw material. - BF GCP sludge can be used along with other reverts with addition rate of 9% as a part of sinter base mix. - 100% utilization of BF flue dust & GCP sludge. - Further as a part of value maximization, Tata Steel is also working on project to produce cold bonded briquettes with iron & carbon bearing reverts from BF flue dust and GCP sludge and use it in blast furnace as a replacement of solid fuel.

(d) PP shall use steam and CO2 to age and fix the SMS slag for use as concrete for road making

i. Use of steam for the ageing of steel slag:

o Background ▪ The free CaO present in LD slag reacts with atmospheric moisture and brings with it a volume increase. ▪ The LD slag during expansion develops internal cracks when used as is without any ageing or weathering ▪ Natural weathering of steel slag in open yard takes approx. 5-6 months for completion.

- 114 -

▪ Use of LD slag size >6 mm requires proper ageing to be used as aggregates for avoiding deterioration and increased durability. ▪ Steam aging process is an advance methodology to reduce the free lime present in LD slag.

Input Composition of LD Slag

Composition LD Slag CaO (total) 51-55% CaO (free) >10% FeO 22-25% MgO 1-2% Al2O3 0.5-1% SiO2 14-18% P2O5 2-5% Basicity >3.2

o Current Status

▪ Steam ageing involves the ageing of LD slag by the injection of high-pressure steam injected through perforated pipe in open pit where fresh LD slag is stored. ▪ The aging time reduces from 5-6 months to 6 days. ▪ An open steam aging setup of capacity 20KTPA has been set-up in Tata Steel Kalinganagar.

o Output:

LD Slag having Free lime – less than 2%. The product will be sold as Tata Aggreto branded product.

o Schematic of Open Steam Ageing:

- 115 -

FIG. - OPEN STEAM AGEING

ii. Use of CO2 for the treatment of LD slag:

o Background: ▪ The high content of basic oxides indicates that steelmaking slag possesses a high alkalinity and a high total theoretical CO2 sequestration capacity. ▪ It has been evaluated that approximately 0.25 kg CO2 per kg of slag can be sequestered based on the total calcium content.

o Current Status:

▪ Tata Steel R&D is working on a project for the carbonation of LD slag with use of CO2 present in flue gas. ▪ The project is still under development phase.

(e) Reply: Confirmation that PP shall practice 100 percent waste utilization

- Process solid wastes generated in Kalinganagar would be approx. 5.1 MTPA after the implementation of 8 MTPA expansion project. - Bench mark utilization of process solid waste is 98 % as per available data across the world. - Concept of recycling back into iron and steel making process has been evaluated by analysis of chemistry, granulometry, dry/wet form and applicability of different processes in use elsewhere in industry or upcoming technologies. - Studies for best utilization of the solid waste is carried out with an outcome of ~98 % utilization. This is based on: o Sale after value addition o Recirculation of solid wastes back into the processes after value addition. o Some solid wastes would go for secured land fill as they are zero valued and have no further potential applications and some would get incinerated.

1. Utilization of slags: Slags: Such as BF, LD, LF, DS-Generation would be approx. 3.83 MTPA.

o Granulated BF slag is sold as a raw material for the production of slag cement o Segregation of SMS slags to separate metallic scrap from non- metallic slag o Non-metallic LD slag >6 mm shall be processed through Steam ageing and for use as aggregates o The LD slag of <6mm shall be used in Sinter plant as a replacement of flux and sold to cement plants

- 116 -

o Commercialized technologies for the utilization of LF and DS slag are still under development and hence as on date they are sent to land fill after metal recovery from the slags.

2. Process solid wastes having iron, carbon or both: The remaining process solid wastes would be approx.1.2 MTPA. o Reverts which include BF sludge, flue dust, cast house and stock house; LD sludge, ESP dust, dry GCP dust; mill scale, mill sludge CRM iron oxide dust, CDQ dust, sludges from CRM shall be used in Sinter/ Pellet plants o Carbon bearing sludges from CETP, COETP shall be used back in Coke plant. o Tata Steel is also working on a project utilizing the iron bearing reverts with or without containing carbon to produce briquettes for use in BF as a replacement of solid fuel and in BOF for use as coolant replacing iron ore lump.

3. Process Solid wastes to be sent to secured land fill: Sludges such as Chrome sludge, CETP crystallizer salt and COETP crystallizer salt have no commercial value and shall be sent for secured land fill at rate of 84 KTPA.

- 117 -

Annexure 13: Drainage of TSK

Query (XIII): Scheme for improvement in drainage Pattern of the Plant area

Reply: Scheme for improvement in drainage pattern of Tata Steel Kalinga Nagar is given below

A) Existing drainage system at TSK Plant:

1. Following design parameters have been adopted in design of drainage system and construction has been done accordingly.  Max rainfall intensity has been considered as 100 mm/hr in Phase-2. (In Ph-1, rainfall intensity considered for drainage design is 80 mm/hr.)  Drainage system has free board of 100 mm.  Velocity of flow in drains varies from 0.90 m/sec to 1.00 m/sec, which is more than required self- cleansing velocity of 0.75 m/sec for flow in open channels.  All drains are covered with gratings/ cover slab with holes for unhindered flow of surface run off into drains.  Longitudinal slope of 1 in 750 has been provided along drain.  All drains are connected to box drains through settling pits to arrest heavy particles at source.  RCC hume pipes provided at road crossings in drains are encased with RCC if earth cushion from road top is less than 1 meter.  Catch pits have been provided at both end of pipes for easy maintenance & inspection.  Surface drains are connected to nearest box drains for final discharge.  Trunk box drains are connected to Storm Water drain  Rational formula has been adopted for estimation of peak runoff. Manning formula has been adopted for calculation of velocity of flow in open channel.

2. During Monsoon, ground water seeps out to ground surface at multiple low-lying location in plant area. There is continuous seepage of ground water from underground facilities like cable tunnels/cellars throughout the year. All underground facilities have sump pumps for dewatering and seepage water is pumped out into surface drains. At present, there are approx. 130 sump pumps are in operation.

B) Scheme for improvement in drainage pattern

1. Plant drains which collect rain & seepage water will be connected to Storm Water Reservoir (38900 m3). From here, water will be recovered back & mixed with fresh water which is being supplied to plant network after necessary treatment.  Construction of Storm water reservoir is already completed  Diversion work from drain to storm water reservoir is under progress and will be completed by Feb-21.

- 118 -

 Around 200-250 m3/hr water recovery from this set up is already started from Oct 20  Further augmentation of this capacity to achieve 600 to 700 m3/hr water recovery will be completed in phased manner by Mar 22

2. A study by IIT Bhubaneshwar is underway on Contribution of ground water table to plant drainage system. Based on this study, further improvement to drain network can be taken up as per recommendation.

Drain Network of TSK

- 119 -

Annexure 14: Skin Care

Query (XIV): Details of health centre proposed including Skin care for employees and neighbouring community

Reply: Details of health centres available and further action proposed, including skin care for employees and neighbouring community, is described below:

• PP will establish community Health Research Centre for chronic Health issues for Kalinganagar peripheral villages under CER project (Ref. CER Table 5a). Time Line 4 Years. Based on outcome of study, way forward will be decided along with District Administration.

• Tata Medica Hospital: - Thich is a Super Specialty 200 bed hospital operating at Kalinganagar - It also has “Skin OPD facility”,

• Action for employees - All employees are covered under different medical insurance schemes, which covers their dependents as well - All employees undergo both IME & PME

• Actions for local community - Already provided above - Displaced Persons get free medical facility at par with employees - An AC ward is provided in Dangagdi hospital, DG set has been provided at Jajpur Road Hospital & Sukinda CHC for enabling better care - Special ward is provided at Tata Medica to cater economically weaker community at reasonable cost

• Further PP confirms that Medical Mobile Units were in operation for several years under CSR activities which has a MBBS doctor and operates regular OPD. - This process started in 2005 / 06 with one unit and increased subsequently. This used to cater to approx 34 villages. - Approx one lakh periphery local villagers were getting benefitted by these mobile health care units every year - With a full fledged hospital coming into operation and improved facilities at other hospital, there has been reduction in load. - Subsequently due to current pandemic situation, this had come to a stop. - Two mobile OPD is now planned to be restarted by Dec 20 / Jan 21 - These mobile health care facilities will have MBBS Doctor and Paramedic staff capable of providing OPD service including skin care

- 120 -

- 121 -

Annexure 15: Slip power recovery

Query (XV): Power saving by implementation of slip power recovery system (SPRS) for the large motors shall be practiced in the plant

Slip Power Recovery System is used along with slip ring motor. This is a method of controlling speed of Induction motors and also enhance overall efficiency.

1. Slip Power Recovery System can be used where with slip ring motor is in use. - This is a method of controlling speed of induction motors - It also enhances overall efficiency.

2. Tata Steel has adopted Squirrel cage AC induction motors for most applications, especially all large motors such as fans, blowers, pumps, conveyors etc. - These are already energy efficient motors as per IS/IEC 60034-1 and IS 12615- 2011 standards and compliant with NEMA design classes - These comply to NEMA Energy Efficient category IE2 / IE3 energy efficient as per IEC in various applications. - NEMA standard was also mentioned in EAC meeting.

3. Difference between Slip Ring & Squirrel Cage Induction Motors: - Squirrel cage AC induction motors are being widely used in all applications considering robustness, reliability and energy efficiency aspects. - Slip ring motor have very limited use in Tata Steel, especially in high torque requirements of load lifting etc as it needs frequent maintenance and also high copper losses, etc. - One of the major difference between slip ring and squirrel cage motor is that: • Slip ring motor has an external resistance circuit for controlling speed of the motor. • In squirrel cage motor, it is not possible to add any external circuit because bar of motor is permanently slotted at the end of the ring. • Some other differences are in given in comparison chart, below

- 122 -

4. Examples:

- 123 -

- 124 -

Sl Rated Voltage Rated Power Efficiency Actual Power NEMA Standard 1 6600 V 400 kw 94% 376 kw 95.8% to 95.0% 2 415 V 55 kw 93.5% 51.43 kw 94.1% to 93.0% 3 415 V 160 kw 94% 150.4 kw 95% to 94.1% 4 415 V 7.5 kw 88.7% 6.65 kw 89.5% to 87.5%

5. NEMA design standard for high efficiency motors are in following categories:

NEMA design A • maximum 5% slip • high to medium starting current • normal locked rotor torque • normal breakdown torque • suited for a broad variety of applications - like fans and pumps

NEMA design B • maximum 5% slip • low starting current • high locked rotor torque • normal breakdown torque • suited for a broad variety of applications with normal starting torques - common in HVAC application with fans, blowers and pumps

NEMA design C • maximum 5% slip • low starting current • high locked rotor torque • normal breakdown torque • suited for equipment with high inertia and high starting torques at start - like positive displacement pumps, conveyors

NEMA design D • maximum 5-13% slip • low starting current • very high locked rotor torque • suited for equipment with very high inertia starts - like cranes, hoists etc.

- 125 -

As per NEMA Standard, name plate contains following data:

- 126 -

6. Comparison Chart: Slip Ring V/s Squirrel Cage Motor

Basis For Comparison Slip Ring Motor Squirrel Cage motor Definition Rotor of motor is constructed Rotor of the motor is a squirrel cage as a slip ring type. type. Rotor Cylindrical laminated core with Slots of rotor are not parallel, but are parallel slots and each slot skewed. consist one bar. Other name Phase wound rotor Cage motor Construction Complicated Simple Resistance Added external to rotor Rotor bar is permanently shorted at end of ring; thus it is not possible to add any external resistance. Starter Rotor resistance starter can be Rotor resistance starter cannot be used. used. Starting Torque High Low Brushes Present Absent Maintenance Frequent maintenance required Less maintenance required Copper Loss High Low Efficiency Low High Speed Control Possible Possible with External drives Power Factor Low High Cost Costly Cheap Starting Current Low High Uses Use in hoist, cranes, elevator Use in lathe machines, fan, blower, where high torque is required. profiting machines, etc.

- 127 -

Annexure 16: Specific water and power consumption

Query (XVI): PP shall provide details of specific water and power consumption details pre-and post-operation

Reply: Details of specific water and power consumption details pre and post expansion during operation stage is given below. For specific water consumption, stage wise breakup is also given.

1. Specific water Consumption

Specific Water Consumption (m3/ton of crude steel) Plant Capacity Up to Crude Steel Crude Steel + Mills Along with all Stage facilities Existing 2.9 3.4 4.19 For 8 MTPA 2.6 3.2 4.5* * including other upcoming miscellaneous facility

2. Specific Power Consumption

3.0 MTPA 8.0 MTPA Sl. Plant Group Specific Power Consumption KWH/T KWH/T 1 Up to Crude Steel Stage 309.52 340.545 2 Up to Crude Steel + Mill Stage 461.36 571.59 3 Crude Steel + Mill Stage + Other Facilities 659.92 728.175

- 128 -