DOCSLIB.ORG

Evaluation of the Space Heating and Cooling Energy Savings of Smart Thermostats in a Hot-Humid Climate Using Long-Term Data

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Evaluation of the Space Heating and Cooling Energy Savings of Smart Thermostats in a Hot-Humid Climate Using Long-Term Data Evaluation of the Space Heating and Cooling Energy Savings of Smart Thermostats in a Hot-Humid Climate using Long-term Data FSEC-RR-647-16 August 2016 Authors Danny Parker, Karen Sutherland, and Dave Chasar Florida Solar Energy Center Presented at 2016 ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings Copyright © 2016 American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced without consent of the Publisher: ACEEE 529 14th Street, N.W., Suite 600, Washington, D.C. 20045 phone: 202.507.4000 • fax: 202.429.2248 • e-mail: [email protected] • web: www.aceee.org Disclaimer The Florida Solar Energy Center/University of Central Florida nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the Florida Solar Energy Center/University of Central Florida or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the Florida Solar Energy Center/University of Central Florida or any agency thereof. Evaluation of the Space Heating and Cooling Energy Savings of Smart Thermostats in a Hot-Humid Climate using Long-term Data D. Parker, K. Sutherland, D. Chasar Florida Solar Energy Center ABSTRACT “Smart” thermostats regulate the home temperature by self-programming using heuristic evaluation of user habits and occupancy. Within the Phased Deep Retrofit (PDR) Project in Florida, a total of 26 NEST thermostats and two Lyric thermostats were installed in participating homes. Unlike previous evaluations, a full year of sub-metered hourly temperature and heating and cooling system operation data was available prior to the install of the smart thermostat allowing detailed evaluation of temperature-related changes. Overall measured heating and cooling energy savings averaged 9.5%. Unrealized Potential of Programmable Thermostats As thermostats are the central switch that control operation of heating and cooling systems—commonly the largest energy end use in homes—understanding how the occupants and thermostat interact is key to controlling energy use. However, this potential is complex, made up of the control hardware and how homeowners use it (behavior). That energy setup/setback has potential for energy savings has been demonstrated repeatedly in well- controlled measurements. For example, experimental work by Levins at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Levins 1988) showed 20% measured heating savings from thermostat setback in the highly instrumented and unoccupied test homes. More recently, detailed National Research Council Canada test homes in Canada (Manning et al. 2007) showed that both thermostat setback (winter) and setup (summer) reliably produce savings of 13% and 11% respectively. Until the advent of smart thermostats, however, such savings levels have depended on the willingness of occupants to manage their thermostats and make effective control decisions. For example, Blasnik as cited by Bailes (2012) found heating savings of 5%-8% in multiple studies in many occupied homes in the northeastern United States from 1998–2008- less than half of identified potentials. Also, Roberts and Lay (2013) also showed that in 20 homes in New York, the measured interior nighttime temperatures were only about 3°F lower than midday temperatures and, in a similar sample of Florida homes for cooling, the often unoccupied daytime setup was only about 2°F. Thus, achieved temperature setback/ set-ups appear much lower than the potentials, given existing thermostat controls and associated behavior. From 1999–2001, a large monitoring project in central Florida for Florida Power Corporation evaluated 150 sub-metered homes and found that homes with programmable thermostats actually used more space cooling than those with manual slide thermostats because homeowners were more likely to change the daily settings on the manual thermostats due to the nuisance of programming (Nevius 2000). Verifying this finding, the influence of thermostats and load controls was evaluated in Florida homes by utilities desiring to enhance load control. These findings from utilities also showed that programmable thermostats led to increased cooling consumption (Lopes and Agnew 2010). The problems were not confined to Florida, as data from ©2016 ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings 8-1 Minnesota showed much the same contradictory result from programmable thermostats (Nevius and Pigg 2000). Other efforts (Vastamaki, Sinkkonen, and Leinonen 2005) (Meier et al. 2011) indicated that much of the problem stems from an overly complex user interface for programmable thermostat, with only one in four households programming them. Figure 1. The Nest learning thermostat installed at one of the PDR sites showing portable logger recording temperature/humidity right by original thermostat & smart replacement. Smart Thermostats Newer “smart” thermostats get around these problems by self-programming depending on heuristic or machine learning evaluation of user control habits as well as sensed occupancy. Such smart thermostats include Nest (see Figure 1), Lyric, and Ecobee. These modern devices use a combination of data on occupancy, weather, and thermostat-setting preference to help consumers with automated setback/setup schedules. These devices have also been shown in other studies in other regions to produce cooling energy savings. For example, the Nest thermostats have been shown to provide savings of 1.16 kWh/day or 11.3% in a very large sample of homes in Southern California (Nest 2014). However, there are reasons to believe savings may differ in Florida, with different demographics, construction practices, and intense cooling consumption. Thus, this paper aims to evaluate the energy savings and peak demand impacts of smart thermostats in a highly metered field project in Florida. Installation Campaign The Phased Deep Retrofit project (PDR) in Florida installed a series of energy efficiency improvements in 56 homes over a three year period to estimate individual and combined technology impacts. Study sites for Nest or Lyric “smart” thermostat were chosen based on homeowner acceptance, compatibility, and the proviso that no confounding measures be installed in the home over the two year evaluation period Among the 38 smart thermostats installed in the PDR project, nine sites received Nests within the deep retrofits, 22 received a Nest or Lyric in 2014, and seven sites a Nest in 2015. Within the analysis, we carefully reduced confounding influences by removing sites from analysis with issues that would bias results. Three sites had the evaluation time periods limited due to a change out of the air conditioning equipment (very visible within the sub-metered data). 8-2 ©2016 ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings The nine homes that had Nest thermostats installed in the summer of 2013 as part of the deep retrofits are also not included in this analysis because the thermostats were installed as a part of a much larger group of retrofit measures. This left 25 Nest sites and two Lyric sites for the final evaluation. A subset of three Nest installs installed in 2015 in homes with supplemental mini- split heat pumps operating and controlled independently were evaluated, but are not considered part of the main sample. Site characteristics for the installations are summarized in Table 1; HVAC characteristics are provided in Table 2. Table 1. Smart thermostat general site characteristics Yea Liv- House Year r ing No. Wall Air- of AC Site Bui Area of Ceiling Cons- tightness AHU/ Size AC # City lt (ft2) Occu. Stories Insulation truction (ACH50) Comp (tons) SEER 4 Melbourne 1971 1,166 2 1 R-19 CMU 11.5 2000 2.5 14.0 6 Palm Bay 1981 1,542 2 1 R-25 CMU 8.9 2006 3.0 13.0 1998/ 11 Cocoa Beach 1958 1,672 3 1 R-6 CMU 10.9 3.0 < 12 2002 12 Port Orange 1984 1,594 3 1 R-6 CMU 12.0 2000 3.0 < 12 16 Indialantic 1982 2,231 3 1 R38 Frame 12.7 2002 4.0 13.5 Melbourne 15 1975 1,359 2 1 R-15 CMU 8.2 1997 3.0 13.5 Beach 17 Indialantic 1964 1,456 2 1 R-30 CMU 8.4 2002 3.0 19.0 18 Cocoa 1995 1,802 2 1 R-21 CMU 6.2 2008 3.0 14.0 21 Cocoa Beach 1981 1,628 2 1 R-30 CMU 6.9 2013 3.5 13.0 22 Cocoa Beach 1955 1,743 2 1 R-19 CMU 11.0 2001 2.5 12.0 24 Cocoa 1986 1,978 3 2 R-25 Frame 9.5 2010 3.5 15.0 27 Palm Bay 1995 2,050 2 1 R-30 Frame 8.0 2008 5.0 12.0 28 Merritt Island 1966 2,622 2 1 R-16 CMU 8.9 1999 5.0 10.0 29 Cocoa 1985 1,215 2 1 R-30 Frame 10.2 1985 2.5 < 10 Pembroke 34 1978 1,651 2 1 R-8 CMU 9.3 2011 3.0 15.0 Pines CMU/ 1993/ 35 Plantation 1993 1,625 2 2 R-19 6.6 3.5 < 10 Frame 1998 42 Naples 2001 1,666 3 2 R-30 Frame 6.1 2002 3.0 10.0 45 Davie 1987 1,299 2 1 R-19 CMU 9.1 2006 2.5 13.0 1999/ 47 Fort Myers 1990 1,088 4 1 R-15 Frame 5.5 2.5 < 10 2004 48 Naples 1973 1,436 4 1 R-38 CMU 13.2 2006 3.0 13.0 50 Melbourne 1958 2,168 4 1 R-30 CMU 5.5 2005 4.0 14.0 52 Cocoa 2000 1,696 2 1 R-30 Frame 7.0 2012 3.0 13.0 56 Merritt Island 1963 1,000 3 1 R-19 CMU 13.5 2005 2.5 10.0 58 Rockledge 1979 2,020 2 1 R13 CMU 13.3 2003 3.5 13.0 Melbourne 59 1985 2,298 2 1 R-19 Frame 7.1 2005 4.0 14.0 Beach 43 Fort Myers 2000 1,383 2 1 R-25 CMU 6.5 1999 2.5 10.0 44 Naples 1998 1,627 2 1 R-19 CMU 4.7 1998 4.0 10.0 ©2016 ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings 8-3 Table 2.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Smart Buildings: Using Smart Technology to Save Energy in Existing Buildings
    Smart Buildings: Using Smart Technology to Save Energy in Existing Buildings Jennifer King and Christopher Perry February 2017 Report A1701 © American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy 529 14th Street NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20045 Phone: (202) 507-4000 • Twitter: @ACEEEDC Facebook.com/myACEEE • aceee.org SMART BUILDINGS © ACEEE Contents About the Authors ..............................................................................................................................iii Acknowledgments ..............................................................................................................................iii Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................... iv Introduction .......................................................................................................................................... 1 Methodology and Scope of This Study ............................................................................................ 1 Smart Building Technologies ............................................................................................................. 3 HVAC Systems ......................................................................................................................... 4 Plug Loads ................................................................................................................................. 9 Lighting ..................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Icomfort S30 Smart Thermostat Installation and Setup Guide
    iComfort® S30 Smart Thermostat Installation and Setup Guide Color Touchscreen Programmable Wi-Fi Communicating Thermostat (12U67) 507536-02 5/2017 Supersedes 10/2016 Software Version 3.2 TABLE OF CONTENTS SHIPPING AND PACKING LIST ............................................. 3 Mag-Mount....................................................... 33 GENERAL ................................................................. 3 Add / Remove Equipment........................................... 33 INSTALLING CONTROL SYSTEM COMPONENTS ............................. 4 Reset ............................................................ 33 Smart Hub Installation................................................... 4 Notifications ........................................................... 33 Mag-Mount Installation.................................................. 5 Tests ................................................................. 33 HD Display External Components......................................... 6 Diagnostics ............................................................ 33 HD Display Installation.................................................. 6 Installation Report...................................................... 33 WIRING FOR CONTROL SYSTEM COMPONENTS............................. 7 Information ............................................................ 34 CONFIGURATING HEAT SECTIONS ON AIR HANDLER CONTROL.............. 12 Dealer — Information............................................... 34 SMART HUB OPERATIONS................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Lennox Standard of Excellence. Merit® Series Is the Introductory
    Residential Products AIR CONDITIONERS & HEAT PUMPS GAS FURNACES OIL FURNACES AIR HANDLERS THERMOSTATS AIR PURIFICATION SL28XCV/XP25 AIR CONDITIONER AND HEAT PUMP XC21/XP21 AIR CONDITIONER AND HEAT PUMP SLP99V GAS FURNACE SL297NV ULTRA-LOW EMISSIONS GAS FURNACE SLO185V OIL FURNACE8 CBA38MV AIR HANDLER ICOMFORT® S30 ULTRA SMART THERMOSTAT LENNOX PUREAIR™ S The most precise and efficient air conditioner The most efficient two-stage central air The quietest and most efficient furnace you can buy!5 • 97.5% AFUE The quietest and most efficient air handler you can buy!9 • Wi-Fi-enabled ultra-smart thermostat for iComfort- 1 4 AIR PURIFICATION SYSTEM and heat pump you can buy conditioner and heat pump you can buy • Up to 99% AFUE • Meets new ultra-low emissions standards in California • Variable-speed motor for even temperatures enabled equipment Senses and communicates, and cleans • SL28XCV up to 28.00 SEER • XC21 up to 21.00 SEER • Variable-capacity heating operation the air in your home better than any • Two-stage heating operation and quiet operation • Precise Comfort – Holds the home’s temperature to within 11 • XP25 up to 23.50 SEER and 10.20 HSPF • XP21 up to 19.20 SEER and 9.80 HSPF • High-efficiency variable-speed blower 0.5 degrees or less when used with Lennox modulating other single system you can buy! ® • High-efficiency variable-speed blower • Antimicrobial drain pan for improved indoor • Precise Comfort design with a variable-capacity • SilentComfort fan motor minimizes sound while • Precise Comfort design air quality equipment
    [Show full text]
  • Smart Home Air Filtering System: a Randomized Controlled Trial for Performance Evaluation
    Smart Home Air Filtering System: A Randomized Controlled Trial for Performance Evaluation Kyeong T. Mina, Philip Lundriganb, Katherine Swardc, Scott C. Collingwoodd, Neal Patwaria aElectrical and Computer Engineering, University of Utah, United States bSchool of Computing, University of Utah, United States cCollege of Nursing, University of Utah, United States dSchool of Medicine, University of Utah, United States Abstract Airborne particulate matter (PM) exposure exacerbates asthma and other respiratory and cardiovascular conditions. Using an indoor air purifier or furnace fan can reduce the PM concentration, however, these devices consume sig- nificant energy. We designed and built an air quality automation system called SmartAir that uses measurements from PM sensors to control a home’s furnace fan. When PM is high, SmartAir turns on the furnace fan, pulling air through a filter to reduce the air pollutant concentration. When the PM is low, the fan is off to conserve energy. We describe an architecture we introduce to automatically perform a repeated measurement randomized controlled trial (RCT) to evaluate SmartAir. We argue this is an appropriate scientific method to use to evaluate a variety of IoT systems that purport to improve our living conditions but whose performance is complicated by individual differences and confounding variables. We deployed SmartAir in four homes for 350 days in which each day has a randomly chosen experimental condition. The results demonstrate that SmartAir achieves air quality approximately as good 3 3 as when the fan is always on (average PM2:5 = 6:13 µg/m SmartAir vs. 5.71 µg/m On) while using 58% less energy.
    [Show full text]
  • Deep Energy Retrofits Market in the Greater Boston Area
    DEEP ENERGY RETROFITS MARKET IN THE GREATER BOSTON AREA Commissioned by the Netherlands Enterprise Agency Final Report DEEP ENERGY RETROFITS MARKET IN THE GREATER BOSTON AREA Submitted: 13 October 2020 Prepared for: The Netherlands Innovation Network This report was commissioned by the Netherlands Enterprise Agency RVO. InnovationQuarter served as an advisor on the project. Contents I. Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 3 II. Overview of Policy Drivers ........................................................................................................... 5 III. Economic Opportunity Assessment .............................................................................................. 9 IV. Market Snapshot ....................................................................................................................... 11 V. Actor Profiles ............................................................................................................................. 24 VI. Appendix ................................................................................................................................... 33 2 I. Introduction Cadmus is supporting the Netherlands Innovation Network (NIN) by providing an overview of the deep energy retrofit market in the Greater Boston Area. This report is intended to help Dutch companies in identify strategic opportunities to enter or expand their business opportunities in the Greater
    [Show full text]
  • Smart Thermostats Can Do for You (301) December 15, 2016 Call Slides and Discussion Summary Agenda
    2_Title Slide Better Buildings Residential Network Peer Exchange Call Series: Hibernation Mode: What Smart Thermostats Can Do for You (301) December 15, 2016 Call Slides and Discussion Summary Agenda . Agenda Review and Ground Rules . Opening Polls . Brief Residential Network Overview and Upcoming Call Schedule . Featured Speakers . Mark Jerome, Senior Building Science Consultant, CLEAResult (Network Member) . Michael Blasnik, Senior Building Scientist, Nest Labs . Nick Lange, Senior Consultant, Emerging Savings Opportunities, Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) (Network Member) . Discussion . How has your energy efficiency program used connected thermostats or other smart home technologies? . What are challenges in deploying smart thermostats and how can they be addressed? . Has your program used smart thermostat data to improve service for customers? . Other questions, best practices, or lessons learned related to smart thermostats? . Closing Poll 2 Better Buildings Residential Network Better Buildings Residential Network: Connects energy efficiency programs and partners to share best practices and learn from one another to increase the number of homes that are energy efficient. Membership: Open to organizations committed to accelerating the pace of home energy upgrades. Benefits: . Peer Exchange Calls 4x/month . Updates on latest trends . Tools, templates, & resources . Voluntary member initiatives . Recognition in media, materials . Residential Program Solution . Speaking opportunities Center guided tours Commitment: Provide
    [Show full text]
  • 0917-ATMOS-RES-917996- Smart Thermostat
    Install a Programmable Thermostat and Save Money A programmable thermostat lets you choose specific temperatures and times of day for your furnace or air conditioner to run. The following programmable thermostats are eligible for a $25 rebate to Atmos Energy customers in Mississippi. Most models of the following brands are eligible for the rebate. Allure Trane and American Standard Aprilaire Iris Bryant/Carrier Lennox ecobee LockState Emerson Morrison Honeywell Nest Ingersoll-Rand Venstar Note: Used or rebuilt equipment does not qualify for rebates. Only new smart thermostat products are eligible. Atmos Energy provides this list as a courtesy to its customers. The list of product can change without notice. Visit ATMOSENERGY.COM/SmartChoiceMS or call 877-616-6267 for details. Join the conversation about natural gas at: Install a Smart Thermostat and Save Money A smart thermostat is a WiFi-enabled device that allows you to adjust the temperature of your home from a mobile device or web app. Some smart thermostats can also learn and adapt to your behavior, using local factors like weather conditions. The following Smart Thermostat models are eligible for a $100 rebate to Atmos Energy customers. Make Model (Wi-Fi Enabled Only) Make Model (Wi-Fi Enabled Only) Allure Energy EverSense RTH9580WF (Wi-Fi9000) RTH9590WF Aprilaire Communicating Touchscreen 8800 Honeywell TH873WF5018 SYSTXCCITW01 OR SYSTXBBECCO1-A (Evolution Connex control with WiFi) Lyric Bryant/ Carrier WEMO1 Ingersoll- ComforLink II XI 950 Control Rand Trane TZEMT400BB3NK T2WHS01 - Trane - American AccuLink Platinum Azone 950 (ZV Control) Smart SI Standard ecobee ecobee3 Iris CT-101-L ecobee 4 Lennox iComfort WiFi Sensi LockState Connect LS-90i Emerson EE542-1Z Morrison CyberStat CY 1201 Nest All models Venstar ColorTouch Series T5800 or T5900 Note: Used or rebuilt equipment does not qualify for rebates.
    [Show full text]
  • Overview - UK Smart Thermostat Market
    Overview - UK Smart Thermostat Market 1 The market for smart thermostats in the United Kingdom is driven by five key factors The growth of the market can be attributed to a new housing construction trend with an increased adoption rate PREDICTED STRONG of smart thermostats. Another supporting driver is the UK legislature for energy efficiency. Combined with MARKET GROWTH technological improvements and increasing energy prices, the market for smart thermostats is predicted to grow. GROWING Consumers are increasingly interested in efficient energy consumption, with the main reasons being increased CONSUMER control and an opportunity to save money. They are also increasingly interested in the possibilities of the Smart ACCEPTANCE Home, and the convenience and comfort it offers. PUBLIC AND PRIVATE The UK government are encouraging consumers through initiatives for a smarter energy utilisation. Additionally, SECTORS the “Big 6” energy companies in the UK are actively working with energy efficiency and smart thermostats to COMMITTING keep up with the market trend. IMMATURE MARKET The market penetration of smart thermostats in the UK is currently low, but the competition is increasing through WITH INCREASING new emerging technologies. Service and maintenance in the sector are at low levels. COMPETITION SUBSTITUTE Substitute solutions such as insulation of properties and metering is a trend driven by UK regulations. Other SOLUTIONS substitute solutions include traditional heating control. #%$#%$# BUSINESS SWEDEN 2 A glance at established players on the UK smart thermostat market, and where to find their products tado° makes smart thermostats and smart Hive makes smart connected thermostats In their heating and cooling product AC controls for heating and cooling.
    [Show full text]
  • Using Building Energy and Smart Thermostat Data To
    pubs.acs.org/estengg Article Using Building Energy and Smart Thermostat Data to Evaluate Indoor Ultrafine Particle Source and Loss Processes in a Net-Zero Energy House Jinglin Jiang, Nusrat Jung, and Brandon E. Boor* Cite This: ACS EST Engg. 2021, 1, 780−793 Read Online ACCESS Metrics & More Article Recommendations *sı Supporting Information ABSTRACT: The integration of Internet of Things (IoT)-enabled sensors and building energy management systems (BEMS) into smart buildings offers a platform for real-time monitoring of myriad factors that shape indoor air quality. This study explores the application of building energy and smart thermostat data to evaluate indoor ultrafine particle dynamics (UFP, diameter ≤ 100 nm). A new framework is developed whereby a cloud-based BEMS and smart thermostats are integrated with real time UFP sensing and a material balance model to characterize UFP source and loss processes. The data-driven framework was evaluated through a field campaign conducted in an occupied net-zero energy buildingthe Purdue Retrofit Net-zero: Energy, Water, and Waste (ReNEWW) House. Indoor UFP source events were identified through time-resolved electrical kitchen appliance energy use profiles derived from BEMS data. This enabled determination of kitchen appliance-resolved UFP source rates and time-averaged concentrations and size distributions. BEMS and smart thermostat data were used to identify the operational mode and runtime profiles of the air handling unit and energy recovery ventilator, from which UFP source and loss rates were estimated for each mode. The framework demonstrates that equipment-level energy use data can be used to understand how occupant activities and building systems affect indoor air quality.
    [Show full text]
  • “Smart” Residential Thermostats: Capabilities, Operability and Potential Energy Savings
    “Smart” Residential Thermostats: Capabilities, Operability and Potential Energy Savings December 2012 Gilbert A. McCoy, PE Energy Systems Engineer 905 Plum Street SE Olympia, WA 98504-3165 www.energy.wsu.edu (360) 956-2086 Copyright © 2012 Washington State University Energy Program WSUEEP12-080 ii Contents Overview ............................................................................................................................... 1 Heating and Cooling System Types ............................................................................................. 1 Heating and Cooling System Setpoints ....................................................................................... 2 Benefits of Using Programmable Thermostats ....................................................................... 3 Approaches to Influence Consumer Behavior ............................................................................ 4 Smart Thermostat Capabilities ............................................................................................... 5 Dashboard Home Energy Displays (HEDs) .................................................................................. 6 Interview-Based Programming.................................................................................................... 6 Built-In Energy Optimization or Adaptive Learning Capabilities of Available Products.............. 7 ecobee ....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 Smart Thermostat Evaluation
    Impact Evaluation of Smart Thermostats Residential Sector - Program Year 2019 EM&V Group A CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION CALMAC ID: x May 10, 2021 DNV GL - ENERGY DNV GL - ENERGY SAFER, SMARTER, GREENER Information Details Sector Lead Gomathi Sadhasivan Project Manager Lullit Getachew Telephone Number 510-891-0461 Mailing Address 155 Grand Avenue, Suite 500, Oakland, CA 94612 Email Address [email protected], [email protected] Report Location http://www.calmac.org LEGAL NOTICE This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by the California Public Utilities Commission. It does not necessarily represent the views of the Commission or any of its employees except to the extent, if any, that it has formally been approved by the Commission at a public meeting. For information regarding any such action, communicate directly with the Commission at 505 Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, California 94102. Neither the Commission nor the State of California, nor any officer, employee, or any of its contractors or subcontractors makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability whatsoever for the contents of this document. DNV GL Energy Insights USA, Inc. Page i Table of contents 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Background 1 1.2 Research questions and objectives 1 1.3 Study approach 2 1.4 Key findings 3 1.5 Recommendations 9 2 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Energy Saving Potential with Smart Thermostats in Low-Energy Homes in Cold Climate
    172 E3S Web of Conferences , 0 9009 (2020) http://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2020172099 00 NSB 2020 Energy saving potential with smart thermostats in low-energy homes in cold climate Tuule Mall Kull1,*, Karl-Rihard Penu1, Martin Thalfeldt1, and Jarek Kurnitski1,2 1Nearly Zero Energy Buildings Research Group, Tallinn University of Technology, Ehitajate tee 5, 19086 Tallinn, Estonia 2Department of Civil Engineering, Rakentajanaukio 4 A, Aalto University, FI-02150 Espoo, Finland Abstract. Smart home systems with smart thermostats have been used for years. Although initially mostly installed for improving comfort, their energy saving potential has become a renowned topic. The main potential lies in temperature reduction during the times people are not home, which can be detected by positioning their phones. Even if the locating is precise, the maximum time people are away from home is short in comparison to the buildings’ time constants. The gaps are shortened by the smart thermostats, which start to heat up hours before occupancy to ensure comfort temperatures at arrival, and low losses through high insulation and heat-recovery ventilation in new buildings, which slow down the cool-down process additional to the thermal mass. Therefore, it is not clear how high the actual savings can be for smart thermostats in new buildings. In this work, a smart radiator valve was installed for a radiator in a test building. Temperature setback measurements were used to calibrate a simulation model in IDA ICE. A simulation analysis was carried out for estimating the energy saving potential in a cold climate for different usage profiles. 1 Introduction larger when lower temperatures are allowed during nighttime.
    [Show full text]