Feminist Environmental Justice
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FEMINIST ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE: CONFRONTING LEGACIES OF RACIAL SEGREGATION IN JUPITER, FLORIDA by Britni M Hiatt A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of The Wilkes Honors College in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts in Liberal Arts and Sciences with a Concentration in Women’s Studies Wilkes Honors College of Florida Atlantic University Jupiter, Florida April 2013 FEMINIST ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE: CONFRONTING LEGACIES OF RACIAL SEGREGATION IN JUPITER, FLORIDA by Britni M Hiatt This thesis was prepared under the direction of the candidate’s thesis advisor, Dr. Wairimũ Njambi, and has been approved by the members of her supervisory committee. It was submitted to the faculty of The Honors College and was accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Arts in Liberal Arts and Sciences. SUPERVISORY COMMITTEEE: _____________________________ Dr. Wairimũ Njambi _____________________________ Dr. William O’Brien _____________________________ Dean Jeffrey Buller, Wilkes Honors College __________________ Date ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This thesis is dedicated to the brave and vibrant Limestone Creek community. Dr. Wairimũ Njambi—thank you for your leadership, wisdom, book lists, high standards, and everything I’ve learned about social justice with you in Women’s Studies. I am forever grateful and humbled. My Women’s Studies classmates—thank you. I treasure the academic triumphs and personal revelations we share. My family—thank you for supporting and inspiring my greatest accomplishments. Dr. William O’Brien—thank you for your dedicated second readership and for everything I’ve learned in your classes. Shout-outs: Professor Dorotha Lemeh, Lake Worth activists, Feminist Student Union, Stop Owlcatraz! Coalition, FAU community, and my cat Linus. iii ABSTRACT Author: Britni M Hiatt Title: Feminist Environmental Justice: Confronting Legacies of Racial Segregation in Jupiter, Florida Institution: Wilkes Honors College of Florida Atlantic University Thesis Advisor: Dr. Wairimũ Njambi Degree: Bachelor of Arts in Liberal Arts and Sciences Concentration: Women’s Studies Year: 2013 Despite pervasive claims that the United States is a ‘post-racial’ society, racial segregation did not end after Jim Crow and the Civil Rights movement. Today, environmentally hazardous zoning and biotechnology land developments continue to determine which families are most exposed to risks of pollution and displacement, and which families are not. Utilizing documentation of local history and research in Women’s Studies, Eco-Feminism, and Critical Race Studies, I examine the legacy of racial segregation in Jupiter, Florida, by charting the biotechnology ‘cluster’ encroaching upon the historical Limestone Creek community. In this feminist analysis are challenges to assumptions about race, gender, class, and the environment. In solidarity with residents of color, I emphasize accountability on the part of those who have benefited from unjust racial legacies in order to prevent further racial segregation and land exploitation of the Limestone Creek community. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION…………………………………….……………................ 1 CHAPTER 1: HISTORIES AND LEGACIES I ENVIRONMENTALISM…………………………………….…...….. 4 II ECO-FEMINISM………………………………………….…..…...…. 5 III RACE AND ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE………..………....….… 9 IV CONFRONTING WHITE PRIVILEGE IN ACTIVISM...…….....… 18 CHAPTER 2: LIMESTONE CREEK I HISTORY…………………………………………..........…........…... 21 II BIOTECHNOLOGY EXPANSION INTO LIMESTONE CREEK… 23 CONCLUSION………………………………..….…………………....…..… 29 BIBLOGRAPHY……………………………………….…………....……..... 30 v INTRODUCTION My implications within power/privilege dynamics act as a conduit for historical oppressive systems. These systems include but are never limited to capitalism, racism, patriarchy, white supremacy, imperialism, ableism, homophobia and heteronormativity. My actions within systems of hierarchical oppression are always ‘aware/unaware,’ ‘covert/blatant,’ and ‘unintentional/self-righteous’ in varying combinations therein (Yamato 1990, 20). While I critique and actively engage in organizing against exploitations including environmental racism in Palm Beach County, I am living out and often perpetuating the privileges of capitalist white supremacist structures because I am white. I am a white heterosexual woman by standards I did not set and privileging I did not earn. None of us are so pure as to escape implication within these systems, and I embrace these complexities. Yes, I am oppressed as a womb-wielding woman within the patriarchy. No, I won’t stop there as many liberal white feminists have. Beautifully, I am not alone in mobilization toward justice. My implication with the Limestone Creek community is that I share a town with the residents. My involvement began when Palm Beach County environmentalists and I joined the community in solidarity to fight a proposed road extending into the Limestone Creek community’s historic land dating back over one hundred years, and biotechnology development in Jupiter’s Briger Forest. Though I am not an authority on the Limestone Creek community, nor do I claim a part in it, I have done due diligence by researching the history, attending Palm Beach County commission meetings, and communicating with residents. The road would link the Hawkeye property slated for biotechnology 1 development to Indiantown Road, providing relatively easy automobile access to the site from the nearby exit from Interstate 95. Located on both the north and south side of Indiantown Road, the Limestone Creek community is connected ‘socially, culturally, historically, and by blood relation, the two neighborhoods are one and consider themselves so” (Fire Ant 2012). The main neighborhoods that make up the historic community are called Limestone Creek on the north side of Indiantown Road, and Kennedy Estates and Baker’s Park on the south. Island Way Road is proposed to run adjacent to Kennedy Estates—directly through the neighborhood of Baker’s Park—to the Hawkeye property. The proposed road had three alternatives, and “all four of the alternate road plans presented to the County include increasing traffic exponentially—in [Kennedy Estates and Baker’s Park] which currently has no through-traffic—within 50 feet of a park and playground” (Stop Scripps in Palm Beach County 2012). Allen Ciklin, the attorney for Hawkeye Unlimited, which plans to construct the biotech facility, “said the road would not run through Limestone Creek but would be ‘built adjacent to Kennedy Estates’” (Fire Ant 2012). Residents at the September 11, 2012, Palm Beach County Commission hearing “responded loud and clear that the Kennedy Estates neighborhood is part of the 100+ year old Limestone Creek community. It has only become so severed from the northern remnant of this historic community as a result of the racist road-building plans and real estate speculation schemes that now define modern Jupiter” (Stop Scripps in Palm Beach County 2012). Through the years, “white Jupiter's luxurious homes and gated communities sprang up,” along with a recent multi-million dollar investment in biotechnology expansion (Fire Ant 2012). 2 The Scripps Research Institute is located on the Florida Atlantic University MacArthur Campus in Jupiter, Florida. The subsequent biotech developments such as the neighboring research facility, the Max Planck Institute, are accredited to Scripps’ arrival in Palm Beach County. As a “consequence of the arrival of Scripps Research Institute in northern Palm Beach County, a line of development dominoes threatens to collapse on Kennedy Estates” (Fire Ant 2012). I study at the Honors College at Florida Atlantic University in Jupiter. My dorm room looked out to the tall, spiraling Scripps Research Institute building, and I would fall asleep to the sound of its generator churning from across the student parking lot and an empty field. My university has a vested interest in the expansion of biotechnology facilities onto the Hawkeye property across from Indiantown Road because of its affiliation with Scripps. For my Environmental Art class during the fall semester in 2012, I produced a short documentary of my walk through the Kennedy Estates and Baker’s Park, which I transposed with audio and video footage from the Palm Beach County Commission meetings (Hiatt 2012, Part I-III). I met community members at Palm Beach County Commission meetings regarding the proposed road and listened to their testimonies of ongoing resistance. I am taking my initiative with the documentary a step forward with this thesis. Utilizing documentation of local history and research in Women’s Studies, Eco-Feminism, and Critical Race Studies, I examine one legacy of white privilege in Jupiter, Florida by charting biotechnology development encroaching upon the historical Limestone Creek community. 3 CHAPTER ONE: HISTORIES AND LEGACIES In a few decades, the relationship between the environment, resources and conflict may seem almost as obvious as the connection we see today between human rights, democracy and peace. -Wangari Maathai I. ENVIRONMENTALISM The Island Way road expansion through the Limestone Creek community is focally about the families directly impacted and it is simultaneously an environmental concern. Environmental justice maintains that people and environment are integral. Environmental movements in the U.S., however, have never been a unified cause. In 1913, conservationists such as Gifford Pinchot, who advocated for more careful resource use, were pitted