Table of Contents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Welcome from Rector........................................................................................................... 5 Welcome From Conference Chair...................................................................................... 7 Conference Program............................................................................................................ 9 Welcome to Ankara.............................................................................................................. 19 Oral Presentations................................................................................................................ 33 Poster Presentations............................................................................................................. 89 3 4 COMMITTEES SECRETARIAT Assoc. Prof. Ahmet ACIDUMAN, Dr. Önder ILGILI SCIENTIFIC ADVISORY COMMITTEE Berna ARDA, Turkey AliReza BAGHERI, Iran Leo de CASTRO, Philippines/Singapore Bahaa DARWISH, Egypt Christophe DIKENOU, Togo Anne- Marie DUGUET, France Dafna FEINHOLZ, Mexico/France Volnei GARRAFA, Brazil Bert GORDIJN, Ireland Henk ten HAVE, Netherlands/USA Amin KASHMEERY, Saudi Arabia Vugar MAMMADOV, Azerbaijan Paul NDEBELE, Botswana/Malawi ORGANIZING COMMITTEE Prof. Berna ARDA (Ankara University) Prof. Adnan ATAÇ (Gülhane Military Medical Academy) Prof. İnayet AYDIN (Ankara University) Prof. Pınar Aydın O’DWYER Prof. Hayriye ERBAŞ (Ankara University) Prof. Tuncay ERGENE (Hacettepe University) Prof. Şengül HABLEMITOĞLU(Ankara University) Prof. Gülbin ÖZÇELIKAY (Ankara University) Prof. Canan ÖZGEN (Middle East Technical University) Prof. Nurgün PLATIN Prof. Serap ŞAHINOĞLU (Ankara University) Prof. Sevgi ŞAR (Ankara University) Prof. Neyyire Yasemin YALIM (Ankara University) Assoc. Prof. Ahmet ACIDUMAN (Ankara University) Assoc. Prof. Tamay BAŞAĞAÇ GÜL (Ankara University) Assoc. Prof. Muharrem UCAR ( Gulhane Military Medical Academy) Assist. Prof. Atilla ÖZGÜR (Ankara University) Assist. Prof. M. Volkan KAVAS (Ankara University) Dr. Kumru ARAPGİRLİOĞLU (Bilkent University) Dr. Önder ILGILI (Ankara University) POSTER JURY Kerim MÜNİR Tamay BAŞAĞAÇ GÜL Muharrem UÇAR 5 6 Welcome to Ankara University I would like to welcome you -the esteemed delegates of the International Association for Education in Ethics and dear participants- to Ankara University for the Second International Conference on Ethics Education. I am delighted to express my honor and pleasure in Ankara University’s hosting this significant event. Ankara University has committed itself to enlighten the path of humanity always considering what the founder of our republic, the great Atatürk, had stated: “The truest guide in life is science.” To achieve this goal, our university puts all its effort into building an appropriate environment for original and qualified studies and raising individuals who are self-reliant, free thinking, unprejudiced, and respectful to social and universal values. Ankara University has set values like participation, transparency, justice, equality of opportunity, and competence as its principles and regards supporting initiatives in ethics and offering original contributions to the issue as a priority. Studies are being conducted and educational programs are being offered by many departments contributing to the field of bioethics through a multidisciplinary perspective at our university. The most striking examples account for the master’s and doctorate courses on ethics offered by our Graduate School of Health Sciences, Graduate School of Biotechnology, and Graduate School of Social Sciences within the last decade. As a physician and a scientist who considers the guidance of ethics both as a need and an anchor, I do acknowledge the necessity to enhance these efforts. Professor Arda (MD, PhD, MSpec), who led many international and national institutions and activities, has been working for the Department of Medical History and Ethics which was founded in 1946 and was one of the first departments of our Medical School. A pioneer in bioethics, Professor Arda is now organizing the second international conference following the “3rd International Conference on Islam and Bioethics” organized in 2010 by Ankara University in collaboration with Haifa University. I would like to congratulate her for this remarkable efforts. I hope that this intensive three-day academic program reveals the current situation in bioethics education and provides a medium for the sharing of experiences. I wish the conference proves to be a successful and efficient one for all participants. Yours sincerely Prof. Dr. Erkan İBİŞ Rector 7 8 Dear all Colleague, Welcome to Ankara and Turkey On behalf of the International Association for Education in Ethics (IAEE), it is really great honour to see you as distinguished participants of the 2nd International Conference on Ethics Education in Ankara, the capital city at the heart of Turkey. I have worked actively in the IAEE as one of the founding members and chair of the Board. After the inaugural conference in Duquesne University Pittsburgh- USA in May 2012, your valuable participation to the Ankara Conference would contribute to development of the IAEE. I would like to see you also as members of Association. My country attributes great importance to this unique and rapidly evolving academic disciplines of humanity, medicine and law intersect. There are medical ethics and medical law courses in all medical schools, as an indispensable part of undergraduate medical education in Turkey. This fact is based on the traditional approach in medical education since 19th century, and this huge potential background offered us a great opportunity to study, explore and shape modern ethics curriculum in medicine. This dynamic nature, necessitates depth and through assessments of medical practice from an ethico-legal standing point. Your participation has broader impact on the development of ethics education in all over the world. More than 150 abstracts from 32 different countries has been submitted. I am grateful to all colleagues who flight for hours to reach Ankara to share their academic experiences with us. I am proud of to be an academic staff of Ankara University and Ankara University School of Medicine, both of them always supported and encouraged me. I would also say cordially thanks to Turkish Cooperation and Coordination Agency (TIKA), The Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkiye (TUBİTAK), Turkish National Commission for Unesco and Gurkale Group for their support to the Conference. There will be 4 Key Note Speaker sessions and eight conferences in plenary, one panel with participation of our PhD students, 16 parallel sessions and two sessions for poster discussions. IAEE General Assembly will be held on the second day of conference and a short Ankara trip is waiting for us at the end of closing session, then an official group visit to Mosoleum and Anatolian Civilizations Museum. “The Journal of Medicine and Law”, official journal of World Association for Medical Law, has a call for paper for the accepted and presented studies here. The Journal has been aimed to publish a theme issue devoted to this conference; I am cordially propose you to submit your full text manuscripts till the end of June 2014. Wishing a fruitful conference in Ankara, “capital of ethics for three days” Sincerely Prof. Berna Arda (MD, Med Spec,PhD) IAEE Chair of the Board, Ankara University School of Medicine 9 10 CONFERENCE PROGRAMME 11 MAY 21, 2014 Hours MAIN HALL BLUE HALL YELLOW HALL PINK HALL 7:30 Registration 09:00-10:00 Opening Ceremony 10:00-10:30 Congress Photograph and Coffee Break 10:30-12:10 Keynote Speakers Session Chair : BERNA ARDA HENK ten HAVE The Principle of Vulnerability in Present-day Global Bio- ethics DAFNA FEINHOLZ Ethics Education From Unesco’s Point of View Questions and Discussions 12:10-13:00 Poster Discussion & Lunch P 1-P 10 13:00-14:15 Keynote Speakers Session Chair : VOLNEI GARRAFA BERT GORDIJN Tackling 21st Century Ethical Challenges: The Role of Education, Legislation and Moral Enhancement ALIREZA BAGHERI Medical Futility: The Importance of Public and Professional Education Questions and Discussion 14:15-14:30 Coffee Break 14:30-17:30 Paralel Sessions 1 Paralel Sessions 2 Paralel Sessions 3 Paralel Sessions 4 Chair : DAFNA FEINHOLZ Chair : CANAN ÖZGEN Chair : İNAYET AYDIN Chair : ŞENGÜL HABLEMİTOĞLU HAFIZE OZTÜRK TÜRKMEN JAMAL JARALLAH KELLY STUART, DAVID BELDE, JENNIFER BARTLETT RENZO PEGORARO, LUCIANA CAENAZZO Can The Ethics Education Suggestion of Haynes Be Valid in Teaching Medical Ethics: From Tradition to Innovation Survey Method for Assessment of Informed Consent Practices, First Experience of The Italian Master in Healthcare Ethics Consultation Medicine? Competencies and Educational Opportunities in Clinical Practice PIERRE MALLIA ANA PAULA FRANÇA, TERESA TOMé RIBEIRO LUCAS BLOUNT , LEA BRANDT, DAVID FLEMING, Models for bioethical reasoning and dialogue SILVIYA ALEKSANDROVA-YANKULOVSKA, TONI VEKOV Including The Unesco Bioethics Core Curriculum In Nursing Training: A JULIA HALSEY Traditional Versus Innovative Approaches of Teaching Bioethics in Running Project in Portugal Survey to Discover Medical Student Level of Understand- RICHARD ROBESON Medical University of Pleven ing as it Pertains to Ethical Concepts that are Key to Under- Discovering the Question ULANKUL TILEKEEVA graduate Medical Education Challenges of Bioethics Pedagogy with Students from the AIYUB M. F. ALWEHAIBI Innovative Approach in Teaching Bioethics