Dimensional Analysis and Modeling
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
cen72367_ch07.qxd 10/29/04 2:27 PM Page 269 CHAPTER DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS 7 AND MODELING n this chapter, we first review the concepts of dimensions and units. We then review the fundamental principle of dimensional homogeneity, and OBJECTIVES Ishow how it is applied to equations in order to nondimensionalize them When you finish reading this chapter, you and to identify dimensionless groups. We discuss the concept of similarity should be able to between a model and a prototype. We also describe a powerful tool for engi- I Develop a better understanding neers and scientists called dimensional analysis, in which the combination of dimensions, units, and of dimensional variables, nondimensional variables, and dimensional con- dimensional homogeneity of equations stants into nondimensional parameters reduces the number of necessary I Understand the numerous independent parameters in a problem. We present a step-by-step method for benefits of dimensional analysis obtaining these nondimensional parameters, called the method of repeating I Know how to use the method of variables, which is based solely on the dimensions of the variables and con- repeating variables to identify stants. Finally, we apply this technique to several practical problems to illus- nondimensional parameters trate both its utility and its limitations. I Understand the concept of dynamic similarity and how to apply it to experimental modeling 269 cen72367_ch07.qxd 10/29/04 2:27 PM Page 270 270 FLUID MECHANICS Length 7–1 I DIMENSIONS AND UNITS 3.2 cm A dimension is a measure of a physical quantity (without numerical val- ues), while a unit is a way to assign a number to that dimension. For exam- ple, length is a dimension that is measured in units such as microns (m), feet (ft), centimeters (cm), meters (m), kilometers (km), etc. (Fig. 7–1). cm 123 There are seven primary dimensions (also called fundamental or basic dimensions)—mass, length, time, temperature, electric current, amount of FIGURE 7–1 light, and amount of matter. A dimension is a measure of a All nonprimary dimensions can be formed by some combination of the seven physical quantity without numerical primary dimensions. values, while a unit is a way to assign a number to the dimension. For For example, force has the same dimensions as mass times acceleration (by example, length is a dimension, Newton’s second law). Thus, in terms of primary dimensions, but centimeter is a unit. Length Dimensions of force: {Force} ϭ Mass ϭ {mL/t2} (7–1) e Time2 f where the brackets indicate “the dimensions of” and the abbreviations are taken from Table 7–1. You should be aware that some authors prefer force instead of mass as a primary dimension—we do not follow that practice. TABLE 7–1 Primary dimensions and their associated primary SI and English units Dimension Symbol* SI Unit English Unit Mass m kg (kilogram) lbm (pound-mass) Length L m (meter) ft (foot) Time† t s (second) s (second) Temperature T K (kelvin) R (rankine) Electric current I A (ampere) A (ampere) Amount of light C cd (candela) cd (candela) Amount of matter N mol (mole) mol (mole) * We italicize symbols for variables, but not symbols for dimensions. † Note that some authors use the symbol T for the time dimension and the symbol u for the temperature dimension. We do not follow this convention to avoid confusion between time and temperature. EXAMPLE 7–1 Primary Dimensions of Surface Tension An engineer is studying how some insects are able to walk on water (Fig. 7–2). A fluid property of importance in this problem is surface tension (ss), which has dimensions of force per unit length. Write the dimensions of sur- face tension in terms of primary dimensions. SOLUTION The primary dimensions of surface tension are to be determined. Analysis From Eq. 7–1, force has dimensions of mass times acceleration, or {mL/t2}. Thus, Force m и L/t2 Dimensions of surface tension: {s } ϭ ϭ ϭ {m/t2} (1) s eLengthf e L f FIGURE 7–2 Discussion The usefulness of expressing the dimensions of a variable or The water strider is an insect that can constant in terms of primary dimensions will become clearer in the walk on water due to surface tension. discussion of the method of repeating variables in Section 7–4. © Dennis Drenner/Visuals Unlimited. cen72367_ch07.qxd 10/29/04 2:27 PM Page 271 271 CHAPTER 7 7–2 I DIMENSIONAL HOMOGENEITY We’ve all heard the old saying, You can’t add apples and oranges (Fig. 7–3). + + = ? This is actually a simplified expression of a far more global and fundamen- tal mathematical law for equations, the law of dimensional homogeneity, stated as FIGURE 7–3 You can’t add apples and oranges! Every additive term in an equation must have the same dimensions. Consider, for example, the change in total energy of a simple compressible closed system from one state and/or time (1) to another (2), as illustrated in Fig. 7–4. The change in total energy of the system (⌬E) is given by System at state 2 Change of total energy of a system: ⌬E ϭ⌬U ϩ⌬KE ϩ⌬PE (7–2) E2 = U2 + KE2 + PE2 where E has three components: internal energy (U), kinetic energy (KE), and potential energy (PE). These components can be written in terms of the system mass (m); measurable quantities and thermodynamic properties at each of the two states, such as speed (V), elevation (z), and specific internal energy (u); and the known gravitational acceleration constant (g), System at state 1 E1 = U1 + KE1 + PE1 1 ⌬U ϭ m(u Ϫ u ) ⌬KE ϭ m(V 2 Ϫ V 2) ⌬PE ϭ mg(z Ϫ z ) (7–3) 2 1 2 2 1 2 1 It is straightforward to verify that the left side of Eq. 7–2 and all three addi- FIGURE 7–4 tive terms on the right side of Eq. 7–2 have the same dimensions—energy. Using the definitions of Eq. 7–3, we write the primary dimensions of each Total energy of a system at state 1 and at state 2. term, { ⌬E} ϭ {Energy} ϭ {Force и Length} → {⌬E} ϭ {mL2/t2} Energy CAUTION! { ⌬U} ϭ Mass ϭ {Energy} → { ⌬U} ϭ {mL2/t2} e Mass f WATCHOUT FOR Length2 NONHOMOGENEOUS { ⌬KE} ϭ Mass → { ⌬KE} ϭ {mL2/t2} e Time2 f EQUATIONS Length { ⌬PE} ϭ Mass Length → { ⌬PE} ϭ {mL2/t2} e Time2 f If at some stage of an analysis we find ourselves in a position in which two additive terms in an equation have different dimensions, this would be a clear indication that we have made an error at some earlier stage in the analysis (Fig. 7–5). In addition to dimensional homogeneity, calculations are valid only when the units are also homogeneous in each additive term. For example, units of energy in the above terms may be J, N · m, or kg · m2/s2, all of which are equivalent. Suppose, however, that kJ were used in place of J for one of the terms. This term would be off by a factor of 1000 FIGURE 7–5 compared to the other terms. It is wise to write out all units when perform- An equation that is not dimensionally ing mathematical calculations in order to avoid such errors. homogeneous is a sure sign of an error. cen72367_ch07.qxd 10/29/04 2:27 PM Page 272 272 FLUID MECHANICS EXAMPLE 7–2 Dimensional Homogeneity of the Bernoulli Equation Equation of the Day Probably the most well-known (and most misused) equation in fluid mechanics is the Bernoulli equation (Fig. 7–6), discussed in Chap. 5. The standard form of the Bernoulli equation for incompressible irrotational fluid The Bernoulli equation = C flow is 1 2 ϩ rgz ϩ rV P 2 1 Bernoulli equation: P ϩ rV 2 ϩ rgz ϭ C (1) 2 (a) Verify that each additive term in the Bernoulli equation has the same dimensions. (b) What are the dimensions of the constant C? SOLUTION We are to verify that the primary dimensions of each additive FIGURE 7–6 term in Eq. 1 are the same, and we are to determine the dimensions of The Bernoulli equation is a good constant C. example of a dimensionally Analysis (a) Each term is written in terms of primary dimensions, homogeneous equation. All additive Force Length 1 m {P} ϭ {Pressure} ϭ ϭ Mass ϭ terms, including the constant, have e Area f e Time2 Length2f et2Lf the same dimensions, namely that 1 Mass Length 2 Mass ϫ Length2 m of pressure. In terms of primary rV 2 ϭ ϭ ϭ dimensions, each term has dimensions e2 f eVolume a Time b f eLength3 ϫ Time2f et2Lf {m/(t2L)}. Mass Length Mass ϫ Length2 m {rgz} ϭ Length ϭ ϭ eVolume Time2 f eLength3 ϫ Time2f et2Lf Indeed, all three additive terms have the same dimensions. (b) From the law of dimensional homogeneity, the constant must have the same dimensions as the other additive terms in the equation. Thus, m Primary dimensions of the Bernoulli constant: {C} ϭ The nondimensionalized Bernoulli equation et2Lf P rV2 rgz C ++= Discussion If the dimensions of any of the terms were different from the P 2P P P ϱ ϱ ϱ ϱ others, it would indicate that an error was made somewhere in the analysis. {1} {1} {1} {1} Nondimensionalization of Equations The law of dimensional homogeneity guarantees that every additive term in an equation has the same dimensions. It follows that if we divide each term in the equation by a collection of variables and constants whose product has those same dimensions, the equation is rendered nondimensional (Fig.