DOCSLIB.ORG

Copyright Statement This Copy of the Thesis Has Been Supplied On

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Copyright Statement This Copy of the Thesis Has Been Supplied On University of Plymouth PEARL https://pearl.plymouth.ac.uk 04 University of Plymouth Research Theses 01 Research Theses Main Collection 2014 Blackshirts and White Wigs: Reflections on Public Order Law and the Political Activism of the British Union of Fascists Channing, Iain Christopher Edward http://hdl.handle.net/10026.1/2897 University of Plymouth All content in PEARL is protected by copyright law. Author manuscripts are made available in accordance with publisher policies. Please cite only the published version using the details provided on the item record or document. In the absence of an open licence (e.g. Creative Commons), permissions for further reuse of content should be sought from the publisher or author. Copyright Statement This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognise that its copyright rests with its author and that no quotation from the thesis and no information derived from it may be published without the author’s prior consent. 1 2 Blackshirts and White Wigs: Reflections on Public Order Law and the Political Activism of the British Union of Fascists by Iain Christopher Edward Channing A thesis submitted to Plymouth University in Partial fulfilment for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Plymouth Law School March 2013 3 4 Abstract While domestic fascism within the United Kingdom has never critically challenged Parliamentary sovereignty, it has decisively disrupted public order since its roots were established in the inter-war political scene. The violence provoked by Sir Oswald Mosley’s British Union of Fascists (BUF) was one of the stimulating factors behind the enactment of the Public Order Act 1936. This Act significantly strengthened the powers of the police to regulate or proscribe varies forms of political activism. This thesis analyses the legal responses of Parliament, the police and the judiciary to interwar British fascism. In addition, by analysing the legal responses to public disorder from before and after the 1930s, it positions the BUF within their wider historical context which enables this thesis to assess and evaluate consistencies and discrepancies within the application of the law. By enhancing the historical contextualisation of the period with a critical legal lens, the principal forms of fascist propaganda are evaluated, including public processions, public meetings and the wearing of political uniform. It is argued that the application of a historico-legal methodology challenges the perception that the authorities were inherently politically biased. This thesis explores alternative factors which explain why the responses of the legal authorities appeared inconsistent in their approach to the far-Right and the far-Left. In order to critically analyse the police’s decision making process when monitoring political activism, the limitations of public order law and the nature of police discretion itself become fundamental components which offer a more balanced explanation for the appearance of political partiality within the police force. 5 Contents Table of Statutes .................................................................................................... 10 Table of Cases ........................................................................................................ 11 Illustrations ............................................................................................................. 13 Abbreviations ......................................................................................................... 14 Acknowledgements ................................................................................................ 15 Author’s Declaration .............................................................................................. 16 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 17 1) Fascism and the Law ............................................................................................ 17 2) Public Order and the Common Law: Definitions .................................................... 22 2.1) The Breach of the Peace Doctrine ........................................................................ 22 2.2) Police Discretion ................................................................................................... 25 2.3) Human Rights and Residual Freedom .................................................................. 28 2.4) Unlawful Assembly, Rout, Riot and Affray ............................................................. 31 3) Aims and Methodology ......................................................................................... 33 4) Chapter Synopsis ................................................................................................. 36 Chapter 1 ................................................................................................................. 40 The British Union of Fascists and Public Order 1) Introduction ........................................................................................................... 40 2) The BUF in Historical Context ............................................................................... 41 2.1) The Predecessors of the BUF ............................................................................... 41 2.2) Patterns of BUF Support in Relation to Incidents of Disorder ................................ 43 2.3) Anti-Semitism in British Society ......................................................................... 45 3) The Historiography of the BUF .............................................................................. 47 4.1) Major contributions to the History of British Fascism ............................................. 48 4.2) Looking Back: Fascism, Society and Culture in Interwar Britain ............................ 51 4.3) The BUF and Political Violence ............................................................................. 52 4.4) Policing and Public Order Law .............................................................................. 61 4) Applying a Legal Lens to Research on British Fascism ......................................... 69 Chapter 2 ................................................................................................................. 72 No Pasaran – “They shall not pass”: Legal Responses to Public Processions 6 1) Introduction ........................................................................................................... 72 2) Legal Definitions ................................................................................................... 74 2.1) Public Assembly ................................................................................................... 74 2.3) Public Procession ................................................................................................. 75 3) Beatty v Gillbanks: A Common Law Solution to Regulating Processions? ............ 77 4) Obstruction of the Highway: The use of Existing Legislation to Regulate Processions ..................................................................................................................... 83 5) Responses to the Processions of the Far-Left ....................................................... 85 5.1) The Emergency Powers Act 1920 ......................................................................... 85 5.2) The Hunger Marchers ........................................................................................... 86 5.3) The Processions (Regulations) Bill 1932 ............................................................... 89 6) The Marching Blackshirts ...................................................................................... 96 6.1) The ‘Battle of Stockton’ in 1933............................................................................. 98 6.2) The Debate on the use of the Unlawful Drilling Act 1819 ..................................... 100 6.3) The Blackshirts March to the Albert Hall, 1934 .................................................... 103 6.4) The Public Order Bill 1934 .................................................................................. 106 7) The Resurgence of Disorder and the Battle of Cable Street ................................ 108 8) The Debate on Clause 3 Public Order Bill 1936 .................................................. 118 9) The Application of s3 from 1937-1939................................................................. 123 10) Post-War Legacy of s3 ........................................................................................ 129 11) Conclusion .......................................................................................................... 134 Chapter 3 ............................................................................................................... 138 The "Englishman's right of Free Speech": Public Meetings in Public Places 1) Introduction ......................................................................................................... 138 2) Legal Definitions: Public Meetings and Freedom of Speech ................................ 140 3) The Historic Claim to the ‘Right’ of Public Meeting .............................................. 143 3.1) Public Meetings at Trafalgar Square 1886-88 ..................................................... 143 3.2) The Unemployed Manchester Marchers 1908 ..................................................... 151 4)
Load more

Recommended publications
  • From Chicken Soup to Denial and Beyond: Fifty Years of Arnold
    1 From Chicken Soup to Denial and Beyond: Fifty Years of Arnold Wesker. Kelly McCloy, B.A. (Hons), MRes. A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, Faculty of Arts, Ulster University. January 2021 I can confirm that the word count of the thesis is less than 100,000 words 2 Contents Acknowledgements 4 Abstract 5 Introduction 7 Chapter One: Food (i) Wesker’s depiction of food in the Anglo-Jewish domestic space. 33 (ii) Pigs and Capitalism in The Kitchen. 47 (iii) Wesker’s Roots and the Battle between Potatoes and Victoria Sponge Cake. 51 (iv) The Search for Strawberries and Dreams in I’m Talking About Jerusalem. 61 (v) The King’s Daughters: Wesker and an Anti-Tale made for Foodies. 68 (vi) “She promised herself many things…to stop drinking, to cut out chocolates…” Wesker and eating alone. 70 (vii) “Pools:” Mrs Hyams the Jewish Everywoman. 78 Conclusion to Chapter One. 82 Chapter Two: Women (i) “Centre of power:” Wesker’s early women. 85 (ii) “Preserving the mask of a busy, uncommunicative housewife:” Wesker’s invisible women in Chicken Soup with Barley and Love Letters on Blue Paper. 96 (iii) “Daughters of Eve:” Wesker’s Women from the 1980s-2000s. 125 (iv) “O, these men, these men!” Love against all odds in Lady Othello. 139 (v) “I have no distorted, rosy image of them.” Wesker as an authentic writer of women. 162 Conclusion to Chapter Two 180 Chapter Three: Denial (i) Supposedly “false accusations of child abuse:” Denial. 183 (ii) “There has to be a reason:” A Torn Family Portrait.
    [Show full text]
  • Poverty and Philanthropy in the East
    KATHARINE MARIE BRADLEY POVERTY AND PHILANTHROPY IN EAST LONDON 1918 – 1959: THE UNIVERSITY SETTLEMENTS AND THE URBAN WORKING CLASSES UNIVERSITY OF LONDON PhD IN HISTORY CENTRE FOR CONTEMPORARY BRITISH HISTORY INSTITUTE OF HISTORICAL RESEARCH UNIVERSITY OF LONDON The copyright of this thesis rests with the author and no quotation from it or information derived from it may be published without the prior written consent of the author. ABSTRACT This thesis explores the relationship between the university settlements and the East London communities through an analysis their key areas of work during the period: healthcare, youth work, juvenile courts, adult education and the arts. The university settlements, which brought young graduates to live and work in impoverished areas, had a fundamental influence of the development of the welfare state. This occurred through their alumni going on to enter the Civil Service and politics, and through the settlements’ ability to powerfully convey the practical experience of voluntary work in the East End to policy makers. The period 1918 – 1959 marks a significant phase in this relationship, with the economic depression, the Second World War and formative welfare state having a significant impact upon the settlements and the communities around them. This thesis draws together the history of these charities with an exploration of the complex networking relationships between local and national politicians, philanthropists, social researchers and the voluntary sector in the period. This thesis argues that work on the ground, an influential dissemination network and the settlements’ experience of both enabled them to influence the formation of national social policy in the period.
    [Show full text]
  • Pakistanis, Irish, and the Shaping of Multiethnic West Yorkshire, 1845-1985
    “Black” Strangers in the White Rose County: Pakistanis, Irish, and the Shaping of Multiethnic West Yorkshire, 1845-1985 An honors thesis for the Department of History Sarah Merritt Mass Tufts University, 2009 Table of Contents Introduction 1 Section One – The Macrocosm and Microcosm of Immigration 9 Section Two – The Dialogue Between “Race” and “Class” 28 Section Three – The Realization of Social and Cultural Difference 47 Section Four – “Multicultural Britain” in Action 69 Conclusion 90 Bibliography 99 ii Introduction Jess Bhamra – the protagonist in the 2002 film Bend It Like Beckham about a Hounslow- born, football-playing Punjabi Sikh girl – is ejected from an important match after shoving an opposing player on the pitch. When her coach, Joe, berates her for this action, Jess retorts with, “She called me a Paki, but I guess you wouldn’t understand what that feels like, would you?” After letting the weight of Jess’s frustration and anger sink in, Joe responds, “Jess, I’m Irish. Of course I understand what that feels like.” This exchange highlights the shared experiences of immigrants from Ireland and those from the Subcontinent in contemporary Britain. Bend It Like Beckham is not the only film to join explicitly these two ethnic groups in the British popular imagination. Two years later, Ken Loach’s Ae Fond Kiss confronted the harsh realities of the possibility of marriage between a man of Pakistani heritage and an Irish woman, using the importance of religion in both cases as a hindrance to their relationship. Ae Fond Kiss recognizes the centrality of Catholicism and Islam to both of these ethnic groups, and in turn how religion defined their identity in the eyes of the British community as a whole.
    [Show full text]
  • 'The Left's Views on Israel: from the Establishment of the Jewish State To
    ‘The Left’s Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada’ Thesis submitted by June Edmunds for PhD examination at the London School of Economics and Political Science 1 UMI Number: U615796 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U615796 Published by ProQuest LLC 2014. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 F 7377 POLITI 58^S8i ABSTRACT The British left has confronted a dilemma in forming its attitude towards Israel in the postwar period. The establishment of the Jewish state seemed to force people on the left to choose between competing nationalisms - Israeli, Arab and later, Palestinian. Over time, a number of key developments sharpened the dilemma. My central focus is the evolution of thinking about Israel and the Middle East in the British Labour Party. I examine four critical periods: the creation of Israel in 1948; the Suez war in 1956; the Arab-Israeli war of 1967 and the 1980s, covering mainly the Israeli invasion of Lebanon but also the intifada. In each case, entrenched attitudes were called into question and longer-term shifts were triggered in the aftermath.
    [Show full text]
  • ISCHE 2014 Book of Abstracts
    i Published 2014 by ISCHE. ISSN 2313-1837 These abstracts are set in Baskerville Old Face, designed in 1757 by John Baskerville in Birmingham, UK. A writing master, businessman, printer and type designer, he conducted experiments to improve legibility which also included paper making and ink manufacturing. In 1758, he was appointed printer to Cambridge University Press, and despite his personal Atheism, printed a folio Bible in 1763. His typefaces were greatly admired for their simplicity and refinement by Pierre Simon Fournier, and Giambattista Bodoni. Benjamin Franklin, printer and fellow member of the Royal Society of Arts, took the designs to the US, where they were adopted for most federal Government publishing. Baskerville type was revived in 1917 by Harvard University Press and may nowadays be found in Microsoft Word. ii Contents Welcome p. iii Acknowledgements p. viii Conference theme p. x Keynotes: biographies and abstracts p. xi Early career bursaries p. xiv Brian Simon bursaries p. xv Guide to using abstract book p. xvi Abstracts of papers p. 1 (In alphabetical order of authors) Synopses of panels p. 385 (In order of sessions presented at conference) Name index / list of presenters p. 422 iii Welcome To all delegates at ISCHE 36 – a very warm welcome to London! We are looking forward very much indeed to hosting this great event, exploring the immense theme of education, war and peace. My thanks go first of all to the ISCHE executive committee for supporting this event, to the UK History of Education Society as the national hosts, and to the Institute of Education at the University of London for the use of its extensive facilities for the conference.
    [Show full text]
  • South Kensington Around Station Development Addendum to the Heritage Statement
    January 2021 South Kensington Around Station Development Addendum to the Heritage Statement Prepared by Alan Baxter South Kensington Underground Station Around Station Development Amendment Addendum December 2020 100 Design and Access Statement | South Kensington Around Station Development South Kensington Around Station Development South East Aerial View Around Station Development Complete delivery of step-free access to the District and Circle lines Provision of 35% high quality affordable housing on site Contextual architectural response A renewed sense of arrival for c.34 million visitors and residents per year Regeneration - a greatly improved sense of place Heritage-led restoration Local skills, apprenticeships and education Repair of the damage caused by the railway works in 1860 High quality, small retail units Improved pedestrian experience Alan Baxter Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners South Kensington Underground Station Around Station Development Amendment Addendum December 2020 Contents Executive Summary ..........................................................................................................................................1 1.0 Introduction ...............................................................................................................................................2 2.0 Summary history of South Kensington .........................................................................................5 3.0 Assessment of Significance .................................................................................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • South Kensington
    SOUTH KENSINGTON SW7 An outstanding eight bedroom townhouse, ideally positioned at the quiet end of the terrace, with superb garden views from the front rooms and an open aspect to the rear. There is a quite simply unique library at first floor level to the rear, making this house larger than most and allowing for an elevated second floor roof terrace with open views, above. On the market for the first time since 1972, this is a once in a generation opportunity to acquire what is quite possibly the best house on Thurloe Square THURLOE SQUARE HISTORY Thurloe Square lies like a densely There are also copious references to embroidered green mat at the foot the day-to-day upkeep of the square of the lofty front of the Victoria and garden – including lopping, sowing, Albert Museum. It is one of hundreds raking, the laying of gravel paths, of leafy lesser lungs which contrib- cleaning drains, and the supervision ute to the airiness, convenience and of the gardeners who were sometimes charm of the metropolis. Laid out and obstructive and bloody- minded, or developed from 1840 by George Basevi prone to crankiness or lethargy. Most in collaboration with the Alexander of the Minutes, however, deal with the family, and named rather tenuously in proper conduct of the garden users, honour of John Thurloe (d.1668) - ‘little which were set out in the Code of Rules secretary’ to Cromwell’s protectorate for the Guidance of the Committee and - the square was regarded by Victorian Subscribers of the Garden. Dogs and topographers as ‘too modern a growth children were the source of greatest to have historic associations’.
    [Show full text]
  • Shirt Movements in Interwar Europe: a Totalitarian Fashion
    Ler História | 72 | 2018 | pp. 151-173 SHIRT MOVEMENTS IN INTERWAR EUROPE: A TOTALITARIAN FASHION Juan Francisco Fuentes 151 Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Spain [email protected] The article deals with a typical phenomenon of the interwar period: the proliferation of socio-political movements expressing their “mood” and identity via a paramilitary uniform mainly composed of a coloured shirt. The analysis of 34 European shirt movements reveals some common features in terms of colour, ideology and chronology. Most of them were consistent with the logic and imagery of interwar totalitarianisms, which emerged as an alleged alternative to the decaying bourgeois society and its main political creation: the Parliamentary system. Unlike liBeral pluralism and its institutional expression, shirt move- ments embody the idea of a homogeneous community, based on a racial, social or cultural identity, and defend the streets, not the Ballot Boxes, as a new source of legitimacy. They perfectly mirror the overwhelming presence of the “brutalization of politics” (Mosse) and “senso-propaganda” (Chakhotin) in interwar Europe. Keywords: fascism, Nazism, totalitarianism, shirt movements, interwar period. Resumo (PT) no final do artigo. Résumé (FR) en fin d’article. “Of all items of clothing, shirts are the most important from a politi- cal point of view”, Eugenio Xammar, Berlin correspondent of the Spanish newspaper Ahora, wrote in 1932 (2005b, 74). The ability of the body and clothing to sublimate, to conceal or to express the intentions of a political actor was by no means a discovery of interwar totalitarianisms. Antoine de Baecque studied the political dimension of the body as metaphor in eighteenth-century France, paying special attention to the three specific func- tions that it played in the transition from the Ancien Régime to revolutionary France: embodying the state, narrating history and peopling ceremonies.
    [Show full text]
  • The Local Impact of Falling Agricultural Prices and the Looming Prospect Of
    CHAPTER SIX `BARLEY AND PEACE': THE BRITISH UNION OF FASCISTS IN NORFOLK, SUFFOLK AND ESSEX, 1938-1940 1. Introduction The local impact of falling agricultural prices and the looming prospectof war with Germany dominated Blackshirt political activity in Norfolk, Suffolk and Essex from 1938. Growing resentment within the East Anglian farming community at diminishing returns for barley and the government's agricultural policy offered the B. U. F. its most promising opportunity to garner rural support in the eastern counties since the `tithe war' of 1933-1934. Furthermore, deteriorating Anglo-German relations induced the Blackshirt movement to embark on a high-profile `Peace Campaign', initially to avert war, and, then, after 3 September 1939, to negotiate a settlement to end hostilities. As part of the Blackshirts' national peace drive, B. U. F. Districts in the area pursued a range of propaganda activities, which were designed to mobilise local anti-war sentiment. Once again though, the conjunctural occurrence of a range of critical external and internal constraints thwarted B. U. F. efforts to open up political space in the region on a `barley and peace' platform. 2. The B. U. F., the `Barley Crisis' and the Farmers' March, 1938-1939 In the second half of 1938, falling agricultural prices provoked a fresh wave of rural agitation in the eastern counties. Although the Ministry of Agriculture's price index recorded a small overall reduction from 89.0 to 87.5 during 1937-1938, cereals due heavy from 1938 and farm crops were particularly affected to the yields the harvests. ' Compared with 1937 levels, wheat prices (excluding the subsidy) dropped by fourteen 2 Malting barley, by 35 per cent, barley by 23 per cent, and oats per cent.
    [Show full text]
  • London SW7 0 22 Empire House, R180215 266
    London SW7 0 22 Empire House, R180215 266 9 Thurloe Place, PA: LA South Kensington 1 1ST PAGE T SW7 2RW O L • A Well Located Long Leasehold First Floor Self-Contained Purpose Built Mansion Flat • Providing Three Bedroom Accommodation • Extending GIA to Approximately 142.91 sq m (1,538 sq ft) • Possible potential for Re- configuration, subject to obtaining all necessary consents • 24 Hour Porterage Vacant Possession Tenure Description Long Leasehold. The property is held on a lease expiring 25th The property comprises a self-contained first floor flat situated within December 2175 (thus having approximately 157 years unexpired) at a an attractive purpose built mansion block arranged over ground and peppercorn ground rent. four upper floors beneath a part mansard roof. The property benefits from a passenger lift, 24 hour porterage and access to a communal Location roof terrace. The property is situated on the south side of Thurloe Place, between Brompton Road and Thurloe Square. The property is accessed via an Accommodation First Floor entrance on North Terrace. The local amenities of South Kensington Reception Room, Master Bedroom with En-Suite Bathroom with include a variety of restaurants, boutiques and shops. The extensive Shower, WC and double wash basin, Two Further Bedrooms, Kitchen, To View shopping facilities of Knightsbridge, which include the world famous Bathroom with WC and wash basin, Cloak Room Harrods and Harvey Nichols stores, are within walking distance to the The property will be open for viewing every GIA Approximately 142.91 sq m (1,538 sq ft ) Tues day and Thurs day before the Auction south.
    [Show full text]
  • Home Office Appraisal Report 1953-2016
    Appraisal Report HOME OFFICE 1953 - 2016 Home Office Appraisal report CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................... 4 BACKGROUND INFORMATION .................................................................................................. 6 1.2 Type of agency ............................................................................................................... 11 1.3 Annual budget ................................................................................................................. 11 1.4 Number of employees ..................................................................................................... 11 1.5 History of organisation .................................................................................................... 12 1.6 Functions, activities, and recordkeeping ......................................................................... 25 1.7 Name of the parent or sponsoring department) .............................................................. 30 1.8 Relationship with parent department .............................................................................. 30 1.9 Relationship with other organisations ............................................................................. 30 SELECTION DECISIONS ............................................................................................................ 32 2.1 Areas of Policy Work undertaken in the organisation ....................................................
    [Show full text]
  • East End Immigrants and the Battle for Housing Sarah Glynn 2004
    East End Immigrants and the Battle for Housing Sarah Glynn 2004 East End Immigrants and the Battle for Housing: a comparative study of political mobilisation in the Jewish and Bengali communities The final version of this paper was published in the Journal of Historical Geography 31 pp 528­ 545 (2005) Abstract Twice in the recent history of the East End of London, the fight for decent housing has become part of a bigger political battle. These two very different struggles are representative of two important periods in radical politics – the class politics, tempered by popular­frontism that operated in the 1930s, and the new social movement politics of the seventies. In the rent strikes of the 1930s the ultimate goal was Communism. Although the local Party was disproportionately Jewish, Communist theory required an outward looking orientation that embraced the whole of the working class. In the squatting movement of the 1970s political organisers attempted to steer the Bengalis onto the path of Black Radicalism, championing separate organisation and turning the community inwards. An examination of the implementation and consequences of these different movements can help us to understand the possibilities and problems for the transformation of grass­roots activism into a broader political force, and the processes of political mobilisation of ethnic minority groups. Key Words Tower Hamlets, political mobilisation, oral history, Bengalis, Jews, housing In London’s East End, housing crises are endemic. The fight for adequate and decent housing is fundamental, but for most of those taking part its goals do not extend beyond the satisfaction of housing needs.
    [Show full text]