Evaluating Skyscraper Design and Construction Technologies on an International Basis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EVALUATING SKYSCRAPER DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION TECHNOLOGIES ON AN INTERNATIONAL BASIS by Saad Allah Fathy Abo Moslim B.Sc., Mansoura University, Egypt, 1984 M.Eng., The University of British Columbia, Canada, 2000 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE AND POSTDOCTORAL STUDIES (Civil Engineering) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) November 2017 © Saad Allah Fathy Abo Moslim, 2017 Abstract Design and construction functions of skyscrapers tend to draw from the best practices and technologies available worldwide in order to meet their development, design, construction, and performance challenges. Given the availability of many alternative solutions for different facets of a building’s design and construction systems, the need exists for an evaluation framework that is comprehensive in scope, transparent as to the basis for decisions made, reliable in result, and practical in application. Findings from the literature reviewed combined with a deep understanding of the evaluation process of skyscraper systems were used to identify the components and their properties of such a framework, with emphasis on selection of categories, perspectives, criteria, and sub-criteria, completeness of these categories and perspectives, and clarity in the language, expression and level of detail used. The developed framework divided the evaluation process for candidate solutions into the application of three integrated filters. The first filter screens alternative solutions using two-comprehensive checklists of stakeholder acceptance and local feasibility criteria/sub-criteria on a pass-fail basis to eliminate the solutions that do not fit with local cultural norms, delivery capabilities, etc. The second filter treats criteria related to design, quality, production, logistics, installation, and in-use perspectives for assessing the technical performance of the first filter survivors in order to rank them. The third filter evaluates the financial performance expressed in terms of Net Present Value of a skyscraper project over its life cycle as a function of system solutions being considered, and involves treatment of all major cash flow streams (revenues and expenditures), and their timing. Product and process models are developed to provide the cash flow model with the required scope and time information. The most preferred solution is recommended on the basis of filter two and three results. Efficacy of the developed framework and each filter were assessed through their application to many case studies and through interviews with construction professionals. Findings show that the framework addresses the deficiencies identified in the existing literature and can improve the quality of the decision-making process when selecting preferred solutions for building a specific skyscraper in a specific geographic area. ii Lay Summary The research goal is to develop an evaluation framework for assessing skyscraper engineering and construction technologies in order to recommend the most preferred solution(s) for a specific skyscraper in a specific geographic area to the decision maker. This framework involves the use of three filters and reflects the informal thought processes applied in practice by design and construction personnel. This thesis is a manuscript-based document and has five chapters. Chapter 1 includes an extensive thesis overview given adoption of manuscript thesis format and describes the background, problem statement, proposed solution, methodologies, research motivations, summary of literature review, and contributions of the research. Chapters 2 through 4 describe the findings of filters 1 through 3 of the research work, respectively. Chapter 5 concludes the thesis through summarizing the research work and contributions, and suggests future work for tackling challenges/limitations encountered in this research endeavor. iii Preface The research reported in this thesis consists of: identification of research problems and questions, formulation of research methodologies in pursuing answers to the research questions, comprehensive and critical review for related literature, analysis of design guidelines and development methods of an evaluation framework, and implementation of the framework and its three filters. Case studies related to an iconic skyscraper and interviews with construction practitioners are used for validating and verifying the framework and each filter. The lessons learned from these applications as well as the received feedbacks from these interviews are incorporated in the current version of the framework. The topic of dissertation was proposed by the author who had the passion of conducting research on skyscrapers primarily because of the previous experience in the Middle East in the context of high rise buildings; and agreed by PhD program supervisor Dr. Alan Russell. Process modeling that forms part of filter 3 made use of a linear planning software system (Repcon) developed by Dr. Alan Russell. With the guidance from Dr. Alan Russell, the author was solely responsible for all components of this research including collecting data of the case study project, Abraj el-Bait, Makkah, Saudia Arabia. The content of this dissertation is in the form of three manuscripts prepared for publication, namely Chapters 2 to 4. For each of these, the dissertation author was the primary manuscript author, while the co-author provided guidance on the development and application of various aspects of the research as well as manuscript review and editing. The following peer-reviewed conference papers are incorporated in Chapter 2and have been published: i. AboMoslim, S. and Russell, A. (2005), “Evaluating Innovative Design and Construction Technologies for Super Hi-rise Buildings on an International Basis”, Proceedings-33rd CSCE Annual Conference 2005: 6th Construction Specialty Conference, pp CT-189-1-10. ii. AboMoslim, S. and Russell, A. (2005), “Innovative Design and Construction Technologies for Building Internal Partitions for Super Hi-Rise Buildings on an International Basis”, Sixth International Conference on Tall Buildings, Hong Kong, China, World Scientific Publishing Co, pp. 594 - 603. Similarly, the following journal paper is presented as Chapter 2 and has been published: iii. AboMoslim, S. and Russell, A. (2014), “Screening skyscraper design and construction technologies on an international basis”, Construction Innovation: Information, Process, Management, Vol. 14 No 3, pp. 307- 445. A version of each manuscript that represent Chapters 3 and 4 is ready for submission to a journal. iv Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................................. ii Lay Summary ............................................................................................................................................ iii Preface ............................................................................................................................................. iv Table of Content .............................................................................................................................................. v List of Tables ............................................................................................................................................. ix List of Figures ............................................................................................................................................. xi List of Abbreviations ...................................................................................................................................... xiii Glossary ............................................................................................................................................ xv Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................................................... xvi Dedication ......................................................................................................................................... xvii Chapter 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Chapter overview .................................................................................................................. 1 1.2 Problem statement ................................................................................................................. 1 1.3 Overview of the proposed framework for evaluating skyscraper technologies .................... 2 1.3.1 First filter .............................................................................................................................. 3 1.3.2 Second filter .......................................................................................................................... 3 1.3.3 Third filter............................................................................................................................. 4 1.4 Research motivations ............................................................................................................ 7 1.5 Research questions, objectives, and hypothesis .................................................................... 8 1.6 Research scope, limitations, and assumptions ...................................................................