id 3/3? A3

^^m •%

HARVARD UNIVERSITY.

A LIST OF THE

NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF LIVING ALUMNI

HAKVAKD COLLEGE.

1890,

Prepared by the Secretary of the University from material furnished by the class secretaries, the Editor of the Quinquennial Catalogue, the Librarian of the Law School, and numerous individual graduates.

(SKCOND YEAR.)

Cambridge, Mass., March 15. 1890.

V& ALUMNI OF .

\f *** Where no StateStat is named, the residence is in Mass. Class Secretaries are indicated by a

1817.

Hon. , Washington, D. C. ISIS.

Rev. F. A. Farley, 130 Pacific, Brooklyn, N. Y.

1819. George Salmon Bourne. Thomas L. Caldwell. George Henry Snelling, 42 Court, . 18SO,

Rev. William H. Furness, 1426 Pine, , Pa.

1831.

Hon. Edward G. Loring, 1512 K, Washington, D. C. Rev. William Withington, 1331 11th, Washington, D. C. 18SS. Chandler, 1511 Girard Ave., Philadelphia, Pa. 1823. George Peabody, Salem. William G. Prince, Dedham. 18S4. Rev. Artemas Bowers Muzzey, Cambridge. George Wheatland, Salem. 18S5. Francis O. Dorr, 21 Watkyn's Block, Troy, N. Y. Rev. F. H. Hedge, North Ave., Cambridge. 18S6. Julian Abbott, 87 Central, Lowell. Dr. Henry Dyer, 37 Fifth Ave., , N. Y. Rev. A. P. Peabody, Cambridge. Dr. W. L. Russell, Barre. 18S7.

lyEpes S. Dixwell, 58 Garden, Cambridge. William P. Perkins, Wa}dand. George H. Whitman, Billerica. Rev. Horatio Wood, 124 Liberty, Lowell. 1828] 1838. Rev. Charles Babbidge, Pepperell. Arthur H. H. Bernard. Fredericksburg, Va. §3PDr. Henry Ingersoll Bowditch, 113 Boylston, Boston. Rev. Joseph W. Cross, West Boylston. Patrick Grant, 3D Court, Boston. Oliver Prescott, New Bedford. John P. Tarbell, 31 Brimmer, Boston. Benjamin D. Whitney, Cambridge. Hon. Robert C. Winthrop, 90 Marlborough, Boston. 1829.

Edwin Conant, 12 State, Worcester. Dr. Edward L. Cunningham, Newport, R. I. Rev. Samuel A. Devens, 13 Chester Sq., Boston. Hon. Wm. Gray, 20 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Charles Lowell Hancock, 26 N. Clark, , 111. Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes, 296 Beacon, Boston. |y Rev. Samuel May, Leicester. Rev. Samuel F. Smith, Newton Centre. Charles S. Storrow, 192 Beacon, Boston. Hon. John J. Taylor, Owego, Tioga Co., N. Y. 1830.

Nathaniel Austin, State Asylum, Worcester. Dr. Jonathan W. Bemis, Walker, Cambridge. James Dana, 34 Glendale, Dorchester. Rev. Nathaniel W. Munroe, Greenfield, lyjohn O. Sargent, 28 E. 35th, New York, N. Y. 1831.

Francis Boott, care of Mrs. H. Greenough, Cambridge. Rev. Edgar Buckingham, Deerfield. Masillon Farley. Benjamin Goddard, Walnut, Brookline. Nathaniel Goddard, Walnut, Brookline. John Granbery Hastings. Rev. Frederick West Holland, Cambridge. Joseph Warren Mansur, Duxbury. Rey.'John H. Morison, 26 Marlborough, Boston. rletiry W. Pickering, 249 Beacon, Boston. Rev. John T. Pierce, Geneseo, Henry Co., 111. jy Dr. George C. Shattuck, 6 Newbury, Boston. Dr. Warren J. Whitney, U. S. Hotel, Boston. 1833.

Hon. Josiah G. Abbott, 28 State, Boston. William Channing Appleton, 62 Clifford, Roxbury. Dr. Charles F. Barnard, Lawrence. [1835

Hon. George. Ticknor Curtis, 30 W. 34th, New York, N. Y. Rev. , Cambridge. Dr. Horace Dupee, 156 Cottage, Dorchester. HPJohn Sullivan Dwight, 11 Park Sq., Boston. Dr. John Warren Gorham, Westerly, R. I. John Holmes. Appian Way, Cambridge. Col. Cyrus Leland, Troy, Doniphan Co., Kan. John Torrey Morse, 153 Beacon, Boston. John Henry Silsbee, Salem. Dr. William Williamson Wellington, Cambridgeport. Dr. Henry Wheatland, Salem. David Worcester, Albion, Iowa. 1833. Samuel P. Andrews, Salem. G. Inglis Crafts, Charleston, S. C. Charles Draper, Pontiac, Mich. Rev. George E. Ellis, 110 Marlborough, Boston. Charles W. Hartshorn, Taunton. jjyWaldo Higginson, Boston, P. O. Box 2027. Rev. Abiel A. Livermore, Meadville, Pa. Prof. Joseph Lovering, Cambridge. Rev. Robert J. T. Lowell, Schenectady, N. Y. Dr. William Mack, Salem. Dr. William D. Peck, Sterling. William M. Prichard, 7 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Rev. Edward J. Stearns, Easton, Md. Prof. Henry W. Torrey, Cambridge. Charles A. Welch, 9 Tremont, Boston. Thomas Wigglesworth, 1 Park, Boston. Dr. Morrill Wyman, 77 Sparks, Cambridge. 1834. William Leroy Annin, Leroy, Genesee Co., N. Y. Dr. Henry Blanchard, Neponset. Edward D. Boit, Newport, R. I. Dr. Benjamin E. Cotting, 76 Bartlett, Roxbury. fyThomas Cushing, 170 Newbury, Boston. Charles Mason, Fitchburg. John W. Randall, 35 Dennis, Roxbury. Samuel W. Rodman, 174 Beacon, Boston. Hon. Roy all Tyler, Brattleborough, Vt. Hiram Wellington, Walnut Ave., corner of Seaver, Roxbury. Nathaniel West, Kentland, Newton Co., Indiana. Hon. Joseph H. Williams, Augusta, Me. 1835.

William H. Allen, Grafton, 111. Edward Appleton, Reading. Dr. Charles V. Bemis, Medford. H. G. O. Blake, 52 Elm, Worcester. 1835] 4

John Carr, Upperville, Va. John Henry Elliot, Keene, N. H. William F. Frick, 51 Lexington, , Md. Charles H. Gates, 2 Grenville PL or 120 Tremont, Boston. James L. Goodridge, 4 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Hon. E. , Concord. Dr. William Ingalls, 556 Tremont, Boston. Dr. Frederick Jones, New Ipswich, N. H. John A. King, Great Neck, Queen's Co., N. Y. Hon. Edward Lander, Washington, D. C. Dr. Henry Lyon, Charlestown. Charles W. Palfray, Salem. ^yCharles Henry Parker, 47 Tremont, Boston. William R. Robeson, 212 Beacon, Boston. Prof. Charles C. Shackford, Brookline. Prof. Lemuel Stevens, Philadelphia, Pa. Charles W. Storey, Brookline. Dr. Benjamin H. West, Glide, corner Chickatawbnt, Neponset. 1836. James M. Ballard, 11 Bromfield, Boston. Rev. Samuel B. Cruft, 433 Shawmut Ave., Boston. Dr. Herman E. Davidson. John T. Gray, 1242 1st, Louisville, Ky. William N. Habersham, Savannah, Ga. Rev. John H. Heywood, Louisville, Ky. Henry Lee, 40 State, Boston. George W. Minns, Newton. William Minot, 39 Court, Boston. Rev. William O. Moseley, Newburyport. Rev. John T. G. Nichols, 33 Kirkland, Cambridge. Hon. William E. Parmenter, 7 Court-House, Boston. ISPHon. F. O. Prince, 54 Devonshire, Boston. Daniel S. Richardson, P. 0. Box 254, Lowell. John Ruggles, Chapel Station, Brookline. Israel M. Spelman, 31 Milk, Boston. Samuel G. Ward, Washington, D. C. George A. Wheelock, Main St., Keene, N. H. 1837.

William Allen, East Bridgewater. Dr. Henry J. Bigelow, 52 Beacon, Boston. Dr. William J. Dale, North Andover. Dr. William A. Davis. William W. Greenough, 229 Marlborough, Boston. Horatio Hale, Clinton, Ontario, Canada. Rev. David Greene Haskins, Cambridge. Hon. Nathaniel Holmes, 7 Holyoke PL, Cambridge. Samuel A. Kendall, 142 Schermerhorn, Brooklyn, N. Y. Benjamin G. Kimball, Edgartown. Amos Perry, Providence, R. I. 5 [1839

Francis Phelps, 15 Allston, Boston. Hon. Charles Theodore Russell, 27 State, Boston. Hon. Samuel Treat, Geneseo, Livingston Co., N. Y. Rev. Daniel Wight, Natick. |yHenry Williams, 18 Concord Sq., Boston. 1838.

Dr. Samuel L. Abbot, 90 Mt. Vernon, Boston. William Aspinwall, Boston or Brookline. ty William I. Bowditch, 28 State, Boston. Rev. J. I. T. Coolidge, Cambridge. Abner L. Cushing. Hon. , Court-House, Boston. Dr. William P. Dexter. Care F. G. Dexter, 2 Pemberton Sq., Boston. P. T. Jackson, P. O. Box 2035, Boston. Charles P. James, Washington, D. C. , , O. Rev. George W. Lippitt, Vienna, Austria. Hon. George B. Loring, Lisbon, Portugal. Hon. , Elmwood, Cambridge. Rev. Edward A. Renouf, Keene, N. H. W. J. Rotch, New Bedford. Elijah W. Stearns, Bedford. H. O. Stone. William W. Story, , Italy. William C. Tenney, 720 Delaware or 222 W. 5th, Kansas City, Mo. Dr. James L. Wellington, Swansea. William E. Worthen, 63 Bleeker, New York, N. Y. 1839. Loring H. Austin, Concord. C. E. Bell. George W. Christy, 9 Union, , La. Dr. William S. Coffin, . Rev. , Brewster. Joseph S. Eckley, Buffalo, N. Y. Samuel Eliot, 44 Brimmer, Boston. Prof. Ellicott Evans, Hamilton Coll., Clinton, N. Y. William Furniss, P. O. Box 560, New York, N. Y. Ezekiel Gilman, Carrituck Court House, N. C. Rev. Edward E. Hale, 39 Highland, Roxbury. Dr. George Hayward, 381 Beacon, Boston. Bela F. Jacobs, Cambridge. Samuel Jennison, 42 Pinckney, Boston. John King, Boone, Boone Co., Iowa. Edward W. Lincoln, Worcester. Rev. Samuel Longfellow, Cambridge. |yCaleb W. Loring, 22 Congress, Boston. Nathaniel H. Morison, 20 W. Madison, Baltimore, Md. Edmund L. Rogers, 31 McCulloch, Baltimore, Md. Cornelius M. Vinson, Jamaica Plain. 1839] 6

Alexander C. Washburn, 40 State, Boston. Benjamin M. Watson, Plymouth. Bernard B. Whittemore, Nashua, N. H. 1840.

Rev. Joseph H. Allen, 5 Garden, Cambridge. Rev. Henry F. Bond, Blakely, Custer Station, Montana (orW. Newton).

J. Elliot Cabot, Brookline. , John Capen, 5 Worcester Sq., Boston. William A. Crafts, 20 Beacon, Boston. Charles G. Davis, Plymouth. Hon. J. C. , Washington, D. C. John B. Henck, Montecito, Santa Barbara Co., Cal. Frederick Hussey, 74 Wall, New York, N. Y. Henry C. Kimball, Stoughton. Archibald G. King, New York, N. Y. Dr. Charles W. Parsons, Providence, R. I. William G. Russell, 50 State, Boston. Hon. George P. Sanger, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Sabin Smith, 259 Adams, Chicago, 111. William Sohier, 265 Washington, Boston. Rev. Edward H.Welch, Georgetown College, Georgetown, D.C. |^Dr. Moses W. Weld, 23 Worcester, Boston. Rev. William Orne White, Brookline.

Rev. W. G. Babcock, Clark, Dorchester. William B. Bacon, 10 Tremont, Boston. Samuel C. Donaldson, Free Library, Baltimore, Md. C. B. Farnsworth, Pawtucket, R. I. Dr. E. A. W. Harlow, Quincy Point. Rev. R. H. Harlow, Quincy Point. John Haven, Washington Heights, New York, N. Y. Col. T. Wentworth Higginson, 25 Buckingham, Cambridge. Wickham Hoffmann, American Legation, Copenhagen, Denmark. John S. Keyes, Concord. S. F. McCleary, Brookline, or 23 Equitable Building, Boston. |yDr. F. Minot, 65 Marlborough, Boston. Ephraim Otis, Scituate. Edward N. Perkins, Jamaica Plain. William H. Rollins, Portsmouth, N. H. E. W. Rollins, 93 Pinckney, Boston. Gen. Thomas C. H. Smith, Nordhoff, . William S. Stearns, Salem and 244 Washington, Boston. Dr. W. H. Thayer, 171 Livingston, Brooklyn, N. Y. Dr. Robt. O. Treadwell. Care Perier Frere & Cie, , France. Ambrose Wellington, Ellsworth, Kansas. 7 [1843 1843. jyBenjamin Barstow, Salem. Dr. Andrew D. Blanchard, Lawrence. Charles P. Braynard, Red Bluff, Zebama Co., Cal. Francis A. Brooks, 31 Milk, Boston. Edward Capen, Public Library, Haverhill. Lendall P. Cazeaux. Dr. Benjamin Cushing, Percival Ave., Dorchester. William T. Davis, Plymouth. Rev. George Ford, DuPage, 111. Edward Dorsey Freeman, Baltimore, Md. James J. French, Toledo, O. David R. Jaques, 38 Park Row, New York, N. Y. Nathan Lincoln, Cambridgeport. George T. Lyman, Bellport, Suffolk Co., N. Y. William Midclleton, Charleston, S. C. Rev. John F. Moors, Greenfield. Benjamin W. Nichols, 40 State, Boston. Rev. Andrew Oliver, 405 W. 20th, New York, N. Y. Henry Tuke Parker, 3 Ladbroke Gardens, W., . Stephen H. Phillips, Salem. Frederick Ray, Anclover. Frederick Sheldon, 193 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Charles F. Shimmin, Pemberton Sq., Boston. Dr. George J. Townsend, Natick. Thornton K. Ware, Fitchburg. John P. Wyman, Arlington. 1843.

James W. Boyden, Chicago, 111. Moses G. Cobb, 103 Montgomery, , Cal. Rev. Leonard Cox, Smithville, Charlotte Co., Va. Charles A. Dana, Editor " Sun," New York, N. Y. Rev. O. B. Frothingham, 118 Marlboro', Boston. Edward Gasset, Hyde Park. Thomas B. Hall, 75 State, Boston. Dr. Charles F. Heywood. Rev. Thomas Hill, Portland, Me. Dr. Howland Holmes, Lexington. Rev. Henry J. Hudson, Plattsburgh, N. Y. Hon. J. W. Kingman. Francis B. Knapp, Plymouth. John A. Loring, 3 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Hon. John Lowell, Chestnut Hill. Rev. Farrington Mclntire, 7 Exchange PI., Boston. Henry B. Maglathlin, Silver Lake. Rev. James H. Means, Dorchester. Robert G. Pike, Middletown, Conn.

William B. Rice, 17 W. 16th, New York, N. Y. ' tyHon. William A. Richardson, Washington, D. C. John J. Russell, Plymouth. 1843] 8

Thomas Hastings Russell, Boston. Gen. Horace B. Sargent, Los Angeles, Cal. Frederick R. Sears, 51 Beacon, Boston. Henry D. Sedgwick, 345 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. William A. Smith, Worcester. Eben C. Sprague, Buffalo, N. Y. Hon. Eben F. Stone, Newburyport. Henry N. Stone, 132 Commercial, Boston. Alexander W. Thayer, Trieste, Austria. Josiah Wheelwright, 1£ Rowe's Wharf, Boston. Rev. Francis C. Williams, 28 Highland Park Ave., Boston. 1844. George W. Baker, Willcox, Cochise Co., Arizona. Isaac V. Bemis, Watertown. Thomas S. Blair, Huntingdon Furnace, Spruce Creek P. 0.,Pa. Richard Magruder Bradford. Hon. George M. Brooks, Concord. Charles J. Capen, Dedham. Henry C. Chauncey, Garden City, Long Island, N. Y. James G. Clarke, in Europe. Robert Codman, 27 Kilby, Boston. Edmund Dwight, 191 Marlborough, or 50 State, Boston. Amos H. Farnsworth, Troy, N. Y. Dr. George Faulkner, Jamaica Plain. Dr. T. E. Francis, Brookline. Dr. Benjamin A. Gould, 29 Kirkland, Cambridge. Samuel S. Greeley, 60 Bellevue PL, Chicago, 111. George S. Hale, 10 Tremont, Boston. Shattuck Hartwell, Littleton. Edward S. Hoar, Concord. Henry A. Johnson, 27 Kilby, Boston. George H. Lord. Samuel B. Noyes, Canton. George F. Parkman, 33 Beacon, Boston. , 50 Chestnut, Boston. Joseph Peabody, The Victoria, Boston. Horatio J. Perry, Paco d'Arcos, Portugal. William G. Prescott, 84 Beacon, Boston. Rev. Robert P. Rogers, Canton. Hon. Leverett Saltonstall, Chestnut Hill. Hon. Frederick A. Sawyer, Tazewell, Tenn. Philip H. Sears, 85 Mt. Yernon, Boston. Edmund Q. Sewall, Watertown, N. Y. Dr. Daniel D. Slade, Chestnut Hill. Fayette Smith, Cincinnati, O. Warren Tilton, Hotel Winthrop, Bowdoin, Boston. George Walker, Portland, Me. Stephen G. Wheatland, Salem. lyEdward Wheelwright, 22 Chestnut, Boston. Henry B. Wheelwright, Taunton. Dr. Edward A. Wild. Care Edward Atkinson, 31 Milk, Boston. [1846 1^4^ Henry Belknap. Care Hon. F. O. Prince, 54 Devonshire, Boston. Timothy Bigelow, 3 Hancock, Boston. Charles M. S. Churchill, Milton. Dr. Samuel F. Coues, 14 Ash, Cambridge. Charles P. Curtis, 27 Kilby, Boston. Thomas J. Davidson, Ponce, Porto Rico. George A. Davis, Supt's office, Boston & Prov. R. R. Station, Boston. William H. Davison, Pensacola, Fla. Edward Dexter, 2 Pemberton Sq., Boston. William G. Dix, 39 Main, Peabody. S. F. Dunlap, 18 W. 22d, New York, N. Y. |yC. W. Folsom, 19 Berkeley, Cambridge. Gen. M. F. Force, Cincinnati, O. Frank B. Goodrich, 112 E. 18th, New York, N. Y. Hon. , Washington, D. C. John R. Habersham, Savannah, Ga. Lemuel Hayward, Keene, N. H. Augustus F. Hinchman, 26 Montgomery, San Francisco, Cal. Rev. R. O. Page, 318 Union, Brooklyn, N. Y. William Plumer, Lexington. Edward J. Pringle, 522 Montgomery, San Francisco, Cal. Dr. J. P. Reynolds, 236 Clarendon, Boston. H. Ritchie. Care Munroe & Co., 7 Rue Scribe, Paris, France. Edward W. Seabrook. Quincy A. Shaw, P. O. Box 3075, Boston. Dr. N. E. Soule, 22 Lincoln Sq., Worcester. F. H. Story, 40 State, Boston. William S. Tiffany. George P. Upham, 122 Beacon, Boston. P. O. Box 3395. Dr. James Waldock, 76 Alleghany, Roxbury. Thomas A. Watson, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Moultrie Weston. 1846.

Edward Bangs, 31 Pemberton Sq.. Boston. Edwin M. Bigelow, Niles Block, Room 17, Boston. Rev. William F. Bridge, Foster's, Warren Co., O. Prof. Francis J. Child, Cambridge. Dr. George C. S. Choate, Pleasantville, Westchester Co., N. Y. Horace Cunningham, 46 Central, Boston. Daniel S. Curtis, 66 State, Boston, or Palazzo Barbaro, Venice, Italy. William S. Dexter, 40 State, Boston. Dr. Edmund T. Eastman, 293 Shawmut Ave., Boston. tdPCharles E. Guild, 27 Kilby, Boston. Fitzedward Hall, Marlesford, Wickham Market, Eng. Hon. George F. Hoar, Worcester, or Washington, D. C. Nathaniel L. Hooper, 56 Chestnut, Boston. Charles H. Hudson, Somerville. John P. Johnson, Highland, Kan. Prof. George M. Lane, Cambridge. Abner L. Merrill, Exeter, N. H. 1846] 10

Rev. Walter Mitchell, 254 W. 100th, New York, N. Y. George Morrill, 54 Devonshire, Room 10, Boston. George B. Neal, Monument Sq., Charlestown. Prof. Charles Eliot Norton, Irving, Cambridge. Hon. Joseph B. F. Osgood, Salem. Rev. Charles M. Parkman, Rahway, N. J, Thomas R. Rodman, New Bedford. Rev. William L. Ropes, Andover. Rev. Davis Smith, Vineyard Haven. Dr. John Stearns, 2il7 G N. W., Washington, D. C. Hon. Richard Stebbins, 532 S. Twenty-fifth Ave., Omaha, Neb- Rev. Daniel W. Stevens, Vineyard Haven. John Austin Stevens, 73 Ave., Newport, R. I.

Charles F. Thayer, 246 Washington, Room 4 r Boston. Edward P. Tucke, Ocala, Marion Co., Fla. Hon. Nathan Webb, Portland, Me. 1847. Hon. , 10 Court House, Boston. Col. Alexander Bliss, 820 Connecticut Ave., Washington, D. C. Thomas Breese, Newport, R. I. Charles Bruce, Coles Ferry, Charlotte Co., Va. Dr. Augustus P. Chamberlaine, Concord. Dr. Charles T. Chase. Austin J. Coolidge, 31 Haverhill, Boston. Hon. William C. Endicott, Salem. Dr. J. F. Gardner, Montreal, Nelson Co., Va. John Glenn, 12 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. S. J. Gordon, 833 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Hon. Henry L. Hallett, U. S. Court House, Boston. Augustine Heard, The Oxford, Boston. John Andrew Henshaw, 23 Craigie, Cambridge. Dr. Richard M. Hodges, 408 Beacon, Boston. Rev. Charles W. Homer, 73 St. James PL, Brooklyn, N. Y. William Henry Hurlbut, New York, N. Y. Charles G. Kendall, Port Royal, S. C. James M. Lea, Philadelphia, Pa. Rev. Marsters, North Cambridge. Rev. Charles W. Munroe, Francis Ave., Cambridge. William A. Neil, Columbus, O. George William Phillips, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Hon. James W. Savage, Omaha, Neb. Edmund Q. Sewall, St. Paul, Minn. tyDr. Benjamin S. Shaw, 28 Marlborough, Boston. Dr. Charles G. Smith, 2220 Calumet Ave., Chicago, 111. Rev. Francis Tiffany, 8 Hilliard, Cambridge. John A. Tison, Brighton, S. C. William M. Tison, Tarborou«h, S. C. Rev. Francis M. Tower, Cornwall-on-the-Hudson, N. Y. Andrew C. Wheelwright, Warren, Brookline. 11 [1849 1W48.

Joseph P. Alston, Charleston, S. C. Rev. Horatio Q. Butterfield, Olivet College, Olivet, Mich. lyProf. Thomas H. Chandler, 161 Newbury, Boston. Thomas Chase, 60 Barnes, Providence, R. I. Thomas C. Clarke, Union Bridge Co., 18 Broadway, New York. Prof. Josiah P. Cooke, 12 Ware, Cambridge. Rev. Asa Dalton, Portland, Me. Edwin Davenport, 37 Poplar, Chelsea. Rev. William B. Edson, Phelps, Ontario Co., N. Y. Francis P. Fisher, Chicago, 111. Charles French, B. Y. M. C. Assoe. Building, Boston. Stephen Gilman, 11 Court, Boston. Horace Harding, Tuskaloosa, Ala. George Heywood, Concord. Rev. Eugene A. Hoffman, New York, N. Y. Rev. Thomas D. Howard, Charlestown, N. H. Charles E. Huse, Insane Hospital, Napa, Cal. Rev. William L. Jenkins, Bernardston. Rev. Benjamin Judkins, Dedham. Charles G. Loring, 1 Mt. Vernon PL, Boston. J. C. D. Parker, 149a Tremont, Boston. Elliott Russell, 405 Marlborough, Boston. Henry Saltonstall, 26 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Simon G. Sanger, Chicago, 111. Rev. Horatio Stebbins, 1609 Larkin, San Francisco, Cal. James S. Thornclike. Care of Charles Thorndike, 47 State, Boston. Walter P. Tillman, Troy, N. Y. Charles S. Weyman, 18 W. 33d, New York, N. Y. David R. Whitney, 68 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Jefferson Wiley, Detroit, Mich. Rev. Edward J. Young, 519 Main, Waltham. Ephraim W. Young, Baraboo, Sauk Co., Wis. 1849. James M. Allen, Milwaukee, Wis. Hon. James W. Austin, 9 Arlington, Boston. Lodowick F. Billings, 20 E. 24th, New York, N. Y. Gamaliel Bradford, 68 Devonshire, Boston. Hon. Martin Brimmer, 47 Beacon, Boston. Charles E. Brown, Yarmouth, Nova Scotia. Charles F. Choate, Old Colony R. R., Boston. Hon. Charles R. Codman, 57 Marlborough, Boston. Clarence C. Cook, 137 W. 15th, New York, N. Y. Joshua Crane, 10 Tremont, Boston. Caleb A. Curtis, 282 Beacon, Boston. President , University of Cal., Berkeley, Cal. Henry E. Dotterer, 17 Centre, Fernandina, Fla. John W. Draper, The Buckingham, Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. William A. Everett, 23 Berkeley, Cambridge. Rev. Charles C. Fiske, 149 E. 46th, New York, N. Y. Rev. Frederick Frothiugham, Milton. 1850] 12

George A. Gardner, 51 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. James A. Gillis, Salem. James D. Green, 37 William, Ann Arbor, Mich. George F. Harding, 170 Madison, Chicago, 111. Francis Hathaway, New Bedford. Augustus L. Hayes, South Berwick, Me. James A. Hervey, Medford. Dr. Edward L. Holmes, 530 W. Adams, Chicago, III. Francis Howland, 167 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Edward Jackson, 191 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. George Johnson. Josiah L. Johnston, Baltimore, Md. Artemas W. Lamson, 33 School, Boston. , 5 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Francis Leathe. |yThornton K. Lothrop, 8 Congress, Boston. Charles F. McDonald, P. O. Dept., Washington, D. C. Frederick S. Nichols, 2 Joy, Boston. Prof. James E. Oliver, Cornell Univ., Ithaca, N. Y. Robert B. Rhett, Huntsville, Ala. Dr. Nathan P. Rice, Harvard Club, 11 W. 22d, New York, N. Y. Dr. Albert F. Sawyer, 302 Stockton, San Francisco, Cal. Rev. William Sewall, Charlton. George S. Shaw, 10 Kirkland PI., Cambridge. Thomas G. Sparks, Fordoche P. O., Pointe Couple Parish, La. Thomas M. Stetson, 38 N. Water, New Bedford. John D. Taylor, 145 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Francis Tufts, Somerville. George B. Upton, 68 Devonshire, Boston. 1850. Alonzo W. Boardman, 209 Washington, Boston. Dr. Charles C. Bombaugh, P. O. Box 498, Baltimore, Md. Simeon Borden, Fall River. John H. Cabot, Brookline. Walter C. Cabot, P. O. Box 444, Brookline. James C. Carter, 44 Wall, New York, N. Y. Charles E. Clifford, West Falmouth, Me. T. Jefferson Coolidge, 60 State, Boston. Francis C. Foster, 8 Congress, Boston. Edward Frost, 209 Washington, Boston. Robert B. Fuller, Beaufort, S. C. Frederick A. Gibbs, 33 Fremont, San Francisco, Cal. Horatio Hathaway, New Bedford. Dr. Gustavus Hay, 91 Charles, Boston. George M. Hobbs, 34 School. Boston. Rev. Samuel D. Hosmer, 22 Woodland, Worcester. John King, Russellville, Ky. Samuel Kirkman, Florence, Ala. Charles S. Lincoln, 209 Washington, Boston. Augustus Lowell, 60 State, Boston. James F. Lyman, 29 Wall, New York, N. Y. 13 [1851

John Noble, Court House, Boston. Rev. Dr. Howard Osgood, Rochester, N. Y. Rev. Dr. W. Stevens Parker, Stonington, Conn. Josiah P. Quincy, Quincy, or 82 Charles, Boston. George F. Richardson, Lowell. Joseph H. Robinson, 28 State, Boston. iyDr. Joel Seaverns, 2 Dudley PL, Roxbury. Dr. Horatio R. Storer, Newport, R. I. Hales W. Suter, 58 Sears Building, Boston. Prof. Joseph H. Thayer, 67 Sparks, Cambridge. Rev. L. G. Ware, Burlington, Vt. John Ware. Care Munroe & Co., Rue Scribe, Paris, France. H. J. Warner. Care F. W. Welsh, 5 Tremont, Boston. Dr. John S. Whiting, Charlestown. F. D. Williams, 23 Irvington, Boston. Cornelius E. Wood, Depot. Nathaniel Jarvis Wyeth, New Dorp P. O., Staten Island, N. Y.

John A. Bailey. Care A. C. Washburn, 40 State, Boston. Robert Bickford, 13 Temple PL, Boston. George Bliss, 160 Broadway, New York, N. Y. William C. Bradley, Brattleborough, Vt. Edward W. Brown, Belmont. Francis C. Browne, Framingham. Dr. Stanford E. Chaille, New Orleans, La. James M. Codman, Brookline. Col. Herbert P. Curtis, West Point, N. Y. Arthur Dexter, Somerset Club, Boston. Charles Dexter. Prof. Charles F. Dunbar, Cambridge. Edward F. Eaton, 251 Madison, Chicago. Franklin E. Felton, St. Vincent Hospital, Baltimore, Md. Prof. W. W. Goodwin, Cambridge. Joseph H. Gray, 71 Wall, New York, N. Y. Hon. Samuel A. Green, M.D., 72 Harrison Ave., Boston. Benjamin H. Hall, Troy, N. Y. Rev. Edward H. Hall, Ash, Cambridge. t3PHenry W. Haynes, 239 Beacon, Boston. Frederick H. Hedge, Jr., Lawrence. J. K. G. Kittredge, Albemarle P. O., Assumption Parish, La. Thomas P. C. Lane, Mattoon, 111. Prof. C. C. Langdell, Cambridge. C. C. Mitchell. Care J. E. Mitchell, 1 Pemberton Sq«, Boston. George D. Noyes, 60 Congress, Boston. George S. J. Oliver, Santa Barbara, Cal. Rev. Joshua R. Peirce, 49 Cottage, Dorchester. Augustus T. Perkins, 112 Beacon, Boston. George O. Shattuck, 35 Court, Boston. Justus Smith, Morristown, N. J. Joseph H. Sprague, Hartford, Conn. Joseph Warren Towle, Exeter, N. H. 1852] 14

1852. Horatio Alger, 36 W. 33d, New York, N. Y. E. Ellery Anderson, 54 Wall, New York, N. Y. Howard P. Arnold, 156 Beacon, Boston. Charles T. Bonney, New Bedford. Rev. Caleb D. Bradlee, Station A, P. O. Box 33, Boston. Peter C. Brooks, 7 Arlington, Boston. Addison Brown. Rev. Henry W. Brown, Worcester. Edward K. Buttrick, Stetsonville, Wis. Rev. Charles T. Canfleld, Charity Building, Boston. Prof. George L. Cary, Meadville, Pa. Dr. David W. Cheever, 239 Boylston, Boston. Joseph H. Choate, 52 Wall, New York, N. Y. William G. Choate, 35 William, New York, N. Y. Hon. Horace H. Coolidge, 162 Newbury, Boston. John C. Crowley. Thomas J. Curtis, 24 Exchange PL, Boston. |yHenry G. Denny, 66 Pearl, Boston. Jonathan Dwight, 2 E. 34th, New York, N. Y. W. M. Este, 60 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Edwin H. Fay, Gayden, La. George H. Fisher, 89 Broadway, Brooklyn E. D., N. Y. Edwin S. Gregory, Hudson, O. Maj. Geo. E. Head, 3d Inf. U. S. A., Fort Meade, S. Dakota. Rev. Francis W. Hilliard, Belleville, Prince George Co., Md. John Emory Hoar, Brookline. James Huntington, Cambridge. Dr. Samuel H. Hurd, Skaneateles, N. Y. Hon. Francis W. Hurd, 5 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Jerome B. Kimball, Providence, R. I. Rev. William C. Leverett, Bloomsburg, Pa. Dr. Henry K. Oliver, 12 Ashburton PL, Boston. George A. Peabody, Salem. John T. Perry, Exeter, N. H. William H.Phipps. Care Ells, Phipps & Co., 51 Exchange PL, New Josiah Porter, 24 Park PL, New York, N. Y. [York, N. Y. E. Ellerton Pratt, 49 Sears Building, Boston. Dr. Horace Richardson. Care W. C.Williamson, 1 Pember-ton Sq., Edwin A. Rogers. Sonora, TuolumneCo., Cal. [Boston. Knyvett W. Sears, 132 Beacon, Boston. Nathaniel D. Silsbee, 153 Milk, Boston. Almou Spencer, Winchester, Ky. Jos. W. Sprague, Jefferson ville, Ind., or care Brown, Shipley & Co., London, England. Dr. C. Ellery Stedman, Monadnock, Dorchester. Prof. Austin Stickney, 35 W. 17th, New York, N. Y. Elijah Swift, Eau Claire, Wis. Prof. James B. Thayer, 5 Phillips PL, Cambridge. S. Lothrop Thorndike, 2 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Rev. Charles C. Vinal, Kennebunk, Me. >

15 [1853

Rev. John S. Wallace, U. S. N., Harvard Club, New York, N. Y. Hon. Darwin E. Ware, 53 Devonshire, Boston. Prof. William R. Ware, Columbia College, New York, N. Y. Andrew Washburn, ELvde Park. William F. Wheeler. R. M. Williams, White Cloud, Kansas. William C. Williamson, 1 Pemberton Sq., Boston.

John Quincy Adams, 23 Court, Bostou. Edward H. Ammidown, 60 Worth, New York, N. Y. Edward R. Andrews, 22 Equitable Building, Boston. Dr. Charles E. Briggs, 2747 Oliver, St. Louis, Mo. Joseph M. Brown, 23 The Portland, Washington, D. C. Albert G. Browne, 121 Devonshire, Boston. John D. Bryant, Boston. ., Rev. Nathaniel Henry Chamberlain, Monument-BeachSSo u^M-^g- M^^^ - Theodore Chase, Somerset Club, Boston. Benjamin C. Clark, 55 Kilb}', Boston. Uriel H. Crocker, 19 Milk, Boston. George R. Dwelley, Watertown. Pres. Charles W. Eliot, , Cambridge. John Erving, 49 Exchange PI., New York, N. Y. Cornelius Fiske, Room 20, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Rev. Edward C. Guild, Brunswick, Me. William P. Harding, 68 Cornhill, Boston. Prof. Adams S. Hill, Cambridge. Hamilton A. Hill, 156 Oliver, Boston. Dr. A. Hosmer, Watertown. *-— • Dr. Andrew J. Howe, Cincinnati, O. . v g /Edward Howland, Topolobampo Sinaloa, . cLiCs^ i°&& J _Dr. John W. Hutchings, 384 W. Adams, Chicago. Dr. George S. Hyde, 72 West Newton, Boston. Charles Jacobs, Groton. Charles E. Johnson, 116 Summer, Boston, and Newton. Dr. A. H. Johnson, Salem. Joshua Kendall, 123 Inman, Cambridgeport. Edward King, Care Union Trust Co. or 73 Broadway, New York, JJ. Y. AJjl Charles Frederick Livermore, Detroit, Mich. JZ-e^it^sfr&c^y &XZ± *-t/r Arthur T. Lyman, 95 Milk, Boston. P. O. Box 1717. George F. Meacham, Newton. Charles A. Miles, Brattleboro, Vt. Raymond Moulton, Dinard, France. Henry S. Nourse, South Lancaster. Rev. George S. Paine, 122 Lincoln, Worcester. Charles J. Paine, 87 Mt. Vernon, Boston. John C. Palfrey, 87 Milk, Boston. Edward Pearce, cor. Benefit and Benevolent, Providence, R. I. Prof. William H. Peck, Cocoa, Fla. Prof. James Mills Peirce, Cambridge. Prof. Ellis Peterson, School Committee Rooms, Mason, Boston. 1854] 16

Charles C. Pomeroy, 34 Pine, New York, N. Y. Robert S. Rantoul, P. O. Box 295, Salem. Francis H. Russell, 85 Devonshire, Boston. Rev. W. W. Sever, Central Falls. R. I. I3PSamuel S. Shaw, 19 Milk, Boston. Wm. I. Shreve, 31 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Care Lloyd & McKean. Dr. Edward S. Smith, 12 Bowdoin, Boston. George Smith. Francis W. Vaughan, Social Law Library, Court House, Boston. David H. Ward, Oakland, Cal. George S. Wardwell, Buffalo, N. Y. Hon. John D. Washburn, U. S. Legation, Berne, Switzerland. Prof. Sylvester Waterhouse, Washington Univ., St. Louis, Mo A. Davis Weld, 127 State, Boston. Dr. James C. White, 259 Marlborough, Boston. Rev. Pelham Williams, Brooklyn, N. Y. Davies Wilson, 1719 14th, Washington, D. C. Justin Winsor, Librarian Harvard College, Cambridge. William P. Wright. 1854.

John P. Allison, Sioux City, Iowa. Frederick L. Ames, 47 Equitable Building, Boston. Rev. Benjamin H. Bailey, Faulkner. John C. Bancroft, 61 Mt. Vernon, Boston. George L. Bennet. Frank W. Bigelow, 35 Mt. Vernon, Charlestown. William G. Binney, 222 E. Union, Burlington, N. J. Atherton Blight. Julius J. Carrie re. Edward W. Codman, 53 Marlborough, Boston, Charles G. Conner, Exeter, N. H. jyDavid H. Coolidge, 32 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Dr. Hall Curtis, 2 Spruce, Boston. George E. Dana, 32 Wyoming, Syracuse, N. Y. Edward G. Daves, 821 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. Daniel Denny. Horace H. Furness, 222 W. Washington Sq., Philadelphia, Pa. John G. Gaillard, Eutauville, S. C. Amory T. Gibbs, 104 Henry, Cambridgeport. Francis H. Griggs, Davenport, Iowa. Richard F. Hall, Troy, N. Y. William S. Haseltine, Artists' Building, New York, N. Y. Hon. Edward D. Hayden, Woburn. Joseph A. Holmes, Kingston. Dr. B. Joy Jeffries, 15 Chestuut, Boston. Dr. John G. Johnson, 153 Joralemon, Brooklyn, N. Y. James C. Johnston, Louisville, Ky. William Johnston, Louisville, Ky. Theodore Lang, Memphis, Tenn. Thomas J. Lothrop, Taunton. 17 [1855

Marcus C. McLemore, Galveston, Texas. Gorham Parks, Court of Appeals, Albany, N. Y. Rt. Rev. William S. Perry. Cor. 11th & Brady, Davenport, Iowa. Rev. William J. Potter, 523 County, New Bedford. Dr. Henry C. Prentiss, Board of Charities, State House, Boston. William A. Preston, New Ipswich, N. H. Thomas P. Proctor, 32 Pemberton Sq., Boston. George Putnam, 50 State, Boston. Robert H. Renshaw, Boyce, Clark Co., Va. Prof. Truman H. Safford, Williamstown. George W. Sewall. Edward L. Sherman. William D. Slack, 146 2d Ave., Pittsburg, Pa. William S. Slater, Webster. George W. Soren, University Building, New York, N. Y. Charles E. Stetson, Braintree. Hiram E. Talmage, 145 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Charles Thorndike, 66 State, Boston. T. S. Tredick, Portsmouth, N. H. Payson E. Tucker, 82 Devonshire, Boston. Henry Van Brunt, 1214 Main, Kansas City, Mo. Dr. Joseph R. Webster, 17 Dix, Dorchester. Rev. John D. Wells, Cambridge. Eugene L. White, San Rafael, Cal. Robert C. Winthrop, Jr., 10 Walnut, Boston. Leonard J. Wyeth, 8 Wall, New York, N. Y. 1»55. lyEdwin H. Abbot, 50 State, Boston. Alexander Agassiz, Cambridge. William Allison. Louis Arnold, Park, W. Roxbury. William Whittlesey Badger, 178 Broadway, New York, N. Y. John Balch. Hon. Francis C. Barlow, 206 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Samuel P. Blake, Jr., 19 Exchange PL, Boston. Willard F. Bliss, Dorchester, 111. Rev. , 233 Clarendon, Boston. Edward J. Brown, 80 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Edward I. Browne, 47 State, Boston. William C. Burns. Care U. S. Morgage Co., Paris, France. Edward H. Chace. Charles A. Chase, Worcester. Channing Clapp, 8 Chestnut, Boston. James B. Clarke, Bonham, Fannin Co., Texas. Thomas W. Clarke, 29 Pemberton Sq., Boston. George G. Crocker, Portsmouth, R. I. Joseph M. Cushing, Baltimore, Md. Charles A. Cutter, Boston Athenaeum, Boston. George Dexter, 30 Kilby, Boston. P. O. Box 5075. John W. Edgerly, Ottumwa, Iowa. Rev. William Henry Evans, Littleton Common. 1855] 18

H. Sidney Everett, State Department, Washington, D. C. Edwin A. Gibbens, 6th. Ave., corner 42d St., New York, N. Y. Dr. John Green, 2670, Washington Ave., St. Louis, Mo. Charles A. Gregory, Chicago, 111. George H. Hampson. Joseph Hayes. Joseph C. Heywood. Charles C. Hobbs, South Berwick, Me. Prof. James K. Hosmer, Washington University, St. Louis, Mo. Leonard A. Jones, 33 Rogers Building, Washington, Boston. Samuel C. Lawrence, 127 Broad, Boston. William P. P. Longfellow, Art Museum, Boston. Benjamin Smith Lyman, 708 Locust, Philadelphia, Pa. Theodore Lyman, Brookline. William Mackay, 49 North Ave., Cambridge. Rev. William S. McKenzie, Tremont Temple, Boston. George F. McLellan, Los Augeles, Cal. Christopher B. Marsh, Cincinnati, O. Hon. James T. Mitchell, Philadelphia, Pa. Edwin Morton, Plymouth. Robert T. Paine, Jr., corner Mt. Vernon and Joy, Boston. William D. Philbrick, Newton Centre. Willard Q. Phillips, Cambridge. Edward S. Rand. Rev. James Reed, 12 Louisburg Sq., Boston. William W. Richards, Hackensack, N. J. William Q. Riddle, 33 Wall, New York, N. Y. Nathaniel Ropes, Salem. Dr. Antoine Ruppaner, Hoffman House, New York, N. Y. Franklin B. Sanborn, Concord. George C. Sawyer, Utica, N. Y. James M. Seawell, San Francisco, Cal. Charles F. Stone, 3 Broad, New York, N. Y. Rev. Edward P. Thwing, Brooklyn, N. Y. John B. Tileston, Matappan. Rev. William H. S. Ventres. Col. Henry Walker, Boston. H. F. G. Waters, Salem. Care N. E. Hist. & Gen. Soc, Boston. Joseph Willard, 33 School, Boston. Smith Wright, 198 Washington, Boston.

Charles Francis Adams, 23 Court, Boston. George Z. Adams, 30 Court, Boston. Francis R. Arnold, 56 Murray, New York, N. Y. Robert E. Babson, English High School, Boston. Nehemiah Ball. George Bancroft. George C. Barrett, 40 Water, Boston. George B. Bigelow, 34 School, Boston. George Blagden, 24 Pine, New York, N. Y. 19 [1856

5 ohu Brooks, 19 Exchange PL, Boston. Allen A. Brown, 30 Kilby, Boston. P. O. Box 1802. Walter H. Burns, 22 Old Broad, London, England. fyWilliam W. Burrage, 27 School, Boston. David Casares, Merida, Yucatan. Prof. James M. Cassety, Buffalo, N. Y. George B. Chase, 234 Beacon, Boston. Edward F. Daland, 27 Kilby, Boston. P. O. Box 1267. Raymond Egerton, 52 Wall, New York, N. Y. Thomas Emerson, Newton ville. Prof. Edward T. Fisher, Berkshire. Judge William E. Fuller, Taunton. John C. Gage, Kansas City, Mo. John E. Gardner, Exeter, N. H. Edward L. Giddings, 105 Devonshire, Boston. Hon. Daniel A. Gleason, Fitchburg R. R. Depot, Boston. Prof. James B. Greenough, Cambridge. Rowland M. Hall, 32 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Thomas Halstead, 69 Wall, New York, N. Y. B. Morgan Harrod, 40 Camp, New Orleans, La. Rev. Augustus M. Haskell, West Roxbury. Edgar B. Holden. George O. Holyoke, New Brighton, Staten Island, N. Y. Charles T. Howard, 13 Pearl, Boston. Hon. Carleton Hunt, 37 Carondelet, New Orleans, La. Prof. Benjamin B. Huntoon, Louisville, Ky. Dr. Edward C. Huso, Rockford, 111. John J. Jacobsen, 303 Linden Ave., Baltimore, Md. Edward P. Jeffries, Santa Monica, Cal. Rev. Francis H. Johnson, Andover. Rev. Jesse H. Jones, North Abington. David P. Kimball, 35 Congress, Boston. P. O. Box 2133. George C. Little. Care Drexel, Harjes & Co., Paris, France. W. Powell Mason, 211 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Dr. Joseph W. Merriam, U. S. Consulate, Iquique, Chili. Moses Merrill, 404 Columbus Ave., Boston. Washington H. Merritt, 220 Devonshire, Boston. Hon. Thomas J. Morris, U. S. Court House, Baltimore, Md. Prof. Bennett H. Nash, 252 Beacon, Boston. Prof. Francis P. Nash, Hobart College, , N. Y. Rev. Charles Noyes, North Andover. William Parsons. Francis B. Rice, Worcester. John H. Rice, Leominster. Peter Ripley, 107 Milk, Boston. Edmund R. Robinson, 150 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Hon. George D. Robinson, Chicopee. G. P. Russell, Monksfield, Brinstead Parish, Isle of Wight, Eug. Stephen Salisbury, Worcester. Prof. Arthur Searle, 41 Concord Ave., Cambridge. Hon. Jeremiah Smith, Dover, N. H. Howard M. Ticknor, Jamaica Plain, and 175 Tremont, Boston. 1856] 20

Dr. Charles C. Tower, South Weymouth. William P. Upham, Newtouville. ,Dr. Charles E. Vaughan, 8 Garden, Cambridge. George W. Weissinger, Louisville, Ky. Richard H. Weld, 127 State, Boston. Henry G. Wheelock, 66 Wall, New York, N. Y. Hon. Daniel W. Wilder, Topeka, Kan. Dalrymple Williams, 382 Park Ave., Baltimore, McL Samuel B. Wyman, Lowell.

Grenville Bacon, 5 Winthrop PL, Roxbury. George M. Barnard, Somerset Club, Boston. Francis Bartlett, 13 Exchange, Boston. Shepherd Brooks, 92 Beacon, Boston. fS^Dr. Francis H. Brown, 75 Westland Ave., Boston. Joseph H. Clark, U. S. District Court, St. Louis, Mo. Rev. John H. Converse. John L. Dearborn, Harrison Sq., Dorchester. Samuel Dorr, 414 West Oak, Louisville, Ky. Dr. William H. Elliott, 129 Jones, Savannah, Ga. A. E. Fisher. Care George Morrill, 54 Devonshire, Boston. Col. Horace N. Fisher, 35 High, Charlestown. Francis O. French, 33 W. 37th, New York, N. Y. William G. Goldsmith, Andover. Charles P. Gorely, 10 Tremont, Boston. George Gorham, Buffalo, N. Y. Franklin Haven, Jr., 28 State, Boston. Augustus A. Hayes, University Club, New York, N. Y. James J. Higginson, 24 Pine, New York, N. Y. Thorndike D. Hodges, 160 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Dr. Jacob F. Holt, 1935 Poplar, Philadelphia, Pa. Charles P. Horton, 60 Congress, Boston. Solomon Lincoln, 8 Congress, Boston. Hon. John D. Long, Hingham. Charles V. Mapes, 158 Front, New York, N. Y. Rev. Joseph May, 913 Pine, Philadelphia, Pa. Robert M. Morse, Jr., Equitable Building, Boston. Samuel Newell, Great Barrington. David D. Ranlett, St. Albans, Vt. Eben Richards, St. Louis, Mo. John C. Ropes, 50 State, Boston. Jacob G. Runkle, Cobleskill, N. Y. Rev. G. M. Searle, St. Paul's Ch., 9th Ave. & 59th, New York. A. J. C. Sowdon, Union Club, or 9 Tremont PL, Boston. J. Lewis Stackpole, 24 Exchange PL, Boston. Henry J. Stevens, 19 Congress, Boston. Livingston Stone, Charlestown, N. H. James J. Storrow, 40 State, Boston. Samuel Wells, 31 Pemberton Sq., Boston. George L. Whitman, 40 Leonard, New York, N. Y. Horatio Wood, Jr., 124 Liberty, Lowell. 21 [1858

Otis P. Abercrorabie, Lunenburg. Henry Adams, 1603 H, Washington, D. C. Rev. Charles A. Allen, Needham. Gideon Allen, Jr., New Bedford. , 14 Beacon, Boston. Nicholas L. Anderson, 1530 K, Washington, D. C. Joshua G. Beals, 328 Dartmouth, Boston. Eugene F. Bliss, 122 E. 5th, Cincinnati, O. Josiah Bradlee, 247 Marlborough, Boston. Hon. Frederick G. Bromberg, Mobile, Ala. Prof. Benjamin G. Brown, College Hill. George C. Burgess, 55 Atlantic, Portland, Me. Dr. John O. Burt, 46 Warren, Syracuse, N. Y.

Louis Cabot, Brookline. » Bradbury L. Cilley, Exeter, N. H. Dr. Jonathan L. Cilley, 411 Broadway, Cincinnati, O. George W. Crosby, 518 Washington, Boston. Benjamin W. Crowninshield, 22 Congress, Boston. lyjames C. Davis, 70 Kilby, Boston. Dr. Robert T. Edes, 1216 18th, Washington, D. C. Charles Fairchild, 44 State, Boston. William E. Fette, 11 Walnut, Boston. Hon. William H. Fox, Taunton. Dr. George E. Francis, 79 Elm, Worcester. Henry W. Frost, 40 State, Boston. Horatio J. Gilbert, Milton. W. G. Gordon, Treasurer's office, C.,B. &Q. R.R., Chicago, 111. Samuel S. Green, Worcester. James S. Hall, Troy, N. Y. Hon. Alfred S. Hartwell, 259 Newbury, Boston. Dr. Alfred H. Haven, Portsmouth, N. H. Daniel Holbrook, Port Jervis, N. Y. Dr. John Homans, 161 Beacon, Boston. William A. Kilbourn, South Lancaster. Rev. Charles H. Learoyd, Taunton. Thatcher Magoun, 15 Doane, Boston. William F. Milton, Coltsville, Berkshire Co. Seth M. Murdock, 33 Garden PL, Brooklyn, N. Y. George W. C. Noble, 21 Concord Ave., Cambridge. John B. Noyes, 103 Produce Exchange, New York, N. Y.

Dr. John G. Park, Worcester. ., Hon. Samuel Pasco, U. S. Senate, Washington, D. C. George E. Pond, Army and Navy Journal, New York, N. Y. Rev. Edward G. Porter, Lexington. Joseph A. Shaw, Highland Military Academy, Worcester. John T. Stoddard, Plymouth. John P. Swinerton, Taunton. James D. Thurber, Plymouth. Gerard C. Tobey, 160 High, Boston. Horace P. Tobey, 160 High, Boston. Robert N. Toppan, 10 Highland, Cambridge. 1858] „ 22

James P. Townsend, Adj. -General's office, Washington, D. C. John P. Treadwell, 7 Sears Building, Boston. Dr. Henry P. Walcott, Waterhouse, Cambridge. Winslow Warren, 39 Court, Boston. George A. Wentworth, Exeter, N. H. Samuel H. Wentworth, 209 Washington, Boston. Sydney A. Williams, 30 Kilby, Boston. 1859. Dr. Francis E. Abbot, Larch, Cambridge. Pelham W. Ames, San Francisco, Cal. Prof. Loring W. Bailey, Freclerickton, N. B. Francis V. Balch, 39 Court, Boston. William Barney, North Ashburnham. Andrew T. Bates, Santa Barbara, Cal. Clayton F. Becker, Central City, Colo. William S. Bond, 200 Federal, Boston. Rev. George L. Chaney, Atlanta, Ga. Charles Chauncey, 269 South 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. Dr. Edward Curtis, 27 Washington PL, New York, N. Y. Charles A. Daniels, Maiden. George Draper, 604 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Henry T. Duncan, Lexington, Ky. James H. Ellison, 20 Broad, Boston. Oscar Ely, Holyoke. Dr. , Quincy. James H. Fay, 11 Pine, New York, N. Y. Dr. Henry J\l. Field, Newton. Daniel F. Fitz. James M. Freeman. Dr. George F. French, Minneapolis, Minn. Prof. John C. Gray, 50 State, Boston. Dr. Francis B. Greenough, 10 Charles, Boston. F. S. G. D'Hauteville, Union Club, New York, N. Y. Dr. David H. Hayden, Newport, R. I. Rev. Samuel Haven Hilliard, 205 W. Chester Park, Boston. Rev. Frederick M. Holland, P. O. Box 61, Concord. Amor L. Hollingsworth, 64 Federal, Boston. Edward W. Hooper, 50 State, Boston. Henry P. Hoppin, St. Paul, Minn. Charles W. Home. Rev. William R. Huntington, Grace Church Rectory, New York. Wm. Eliot Lamb. Dr. Samuel W. Langmaid, 129 Boylston, Boston. Andrew J. Lathrop, Waltham. Edwin C. Lewis, Laconia, N. H. Rev. George L. Locke, Bristol, R. I. Francis W. Loring, Florence, Italy. Edward G. Low, Shanghai, China. Rev. Alexander McKenzie, Cambridge. Rev. Robert W. Memminger, Flat Rock, N. C. George B. Merrill, 430 California, San Francisco, Cal. 23 [1860

Eliab W. Metcalf, Courier Office, Boston. Ellis L. Motte, 60 Congress, Boston. William W. Newell, Cambridge. Rev. Cyrus P. Osborne, Fayetteville, New York, N. Y. Charles S. Pierce, Milford, Pa. William H. Perry, Greenville, S. C. Daniel S. Preston. Care B. C. Clarke, 55 Kilby, Boston. John H. Ricketson, Pittsburg, Pa. James A. Rumrill, Springfield. James A. Sawtell, 6 South Market, Boston. James Schouler, 60 Congress, Boston. Rev. Daniel A. W. Smith, Rangoon, Burmah. Albert Stickney, 31 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Francis H. Swan, Paymaster U. S. N., Walnut, Brookline. William W. Swan, 8 Pemberton Sq., Boston. George A. Torrey, 17 State, Boston. Robert Tower. Henshaw B. Walley, P. O. Box 3417, Boston. Edward S. Waters. Care E. P. Cutter, 329 Broadway, New York. U^ipProf. Charles Joyce White, Cambridge. Abel T. Winn, 330 Herman, San Francisco, Cal. Dr.. John Winslow, 17 West Seneca, Ithaca, N. Y. James A. Winslow, 71 Susquehanna, Binghamton, N. Y. I860. George E. H. Abbot, Groton. Dr. Benjamin F. D. Adams, Colorado Springs, Col.

' Hon. George E. Adams, 19 Bryan Block, Chicago, 111. Rev. Henry F. Allen, Church of Messiah, Boston. William S. Appleton, 39 Beacon, Boston. Henry D. Atwood, Taunton. Frederic W. Batchelder, Manchester, N. H. Hon. Selwyn Z. Bowman, Somerville. Frederic W. Bradlee, 107 Beacon, Boston. Lane W. Brandon, Bayou Tunica, West Feliciana Parish, La. Henry Burclick. Thomas Burgess. Edward Carter. Henry A. Clapp, Court House, Boston. Rev. W. Ellery Copeland, Omaha, Neb. Gen. , Dublin, N. H. Hon. Julius Dexter, 132 E. 5th, Cincinnati, O. Charles H. Doe, Worcester. Dr. Stephen W. Driver, Cambridge. Edward F. Everett, 1 Liberty Sq., Boston. Rev. James C. Fern aid. Charles H. Fiske, 60 Congress, Boston. W. Eliot Furness, 107 Dearborn, Chicago, 111. Rev. William C. Gannett, Rochester, N. Y. Frank Haseltine, 1825 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Dr. Audley Haslett, 115 Clinton, Brooklyn, N. Y. Rev. James Haug-hton, Yonkers, N. Y. 1860] 24

Horace J. Hayden, Grand Central Station, New York, N, Y. Rev. Henry Hinckley, Lynn. Rev. Wesley O. Holway, 219 Shurtleff, Chelsea. Charles A. Home, 174 Elm, Albany, N. Y. Edwin J. Horton, 45 Broadwaj- New York, N. Y. Horace Howland, 70 W. 11th, New York, N. Y. Rev. Charles A. Humphreys, Framingham. " Francis W. Hunnewell. c Care H. H. Hunnewell & Sons, Boston. John W . Hunnewell. Edward C. Johnson, 33 Summer, Boston. Rev. Arthur M. Knapp, American Mission, Tokio, Japan. Daniel T. S. Leland. Henry S. Mackintosh. Care Prof. G. M. Lane, Cambridge. John T. Morse, Jr., 9 Fairfield, Boston. Rev. Myron A. Munson, Huntington. Charles A. Nelson, Harv. Memorial Library, New Orleans, La. Dr. Franklin Nickerson, Lowell. George E. Niles, 33 School, Boston. Dr. George S. Osborne, Peabody. Hersey G. Palfrey, Bradford. % Charles C. Parsons, 66 Water, Brooklyn, N. Y. Daniel W. Paul. Dr. Silas D. Presbrey, Taunton. Gen. Hemy S. Russell, Milton. Col. Henry B. Scott, Burlington, Iowa. Gen. Thomas Sherwin, 95 Milk, Boston. Joseph Shippen, Meadville, Pa. Rev. Henry G. Spaulding, 25 Beacon, Boston. Pres. John W. Stearns, Madison, Wis. Dr. Charles W. Stevens, Charlestown. Dr. Charles W. Swan, 32 Worcester, Boston. Lewis W. Tappan, P. O. Box 1267, Boston. James B. F. Thomas, 46 Court, Boston. Prof. James A. Towle, Ripon, Wis. Lewis W. C. Wade, Portland, Me. Alexander F. Wadsworth, Boston. Dr. Oliver F. Wadsworth, 139 Boylston, Boston. Dr. Samuel G. Webber, Jamaica Plain. Joseph D. Weed, Savannah, Ga. t^Dr. Francis M. Weld, Storey Place, Jamaica Plain. George W. Weld, Liberty Sq., Boston. Gen. Stephen M. Weld, 50 State, Boston. Edmund Wetmore, 45 William, New York, N. Y. Dr. Albert B. Weymouth, Los Angeles, Cal. Rev. Nelson J. Wheeler, Kalamazoo, Mich. Dr. George G. Wheelock, 75 Park Ave., New York, N. Y. Rev. George H. Whittemore, 329 Harvard, Cambridge. Gen. Charles A. Whittier, 44 State, Boston. Dr. Robert Willard, 120 Charles, Boston. James H. Wilson, Keene, N. H. Rev. William C. Wood, Scituate. Prof. C. M. Woodward, Washington Univ., St. Louis, Mo. Hon. George B. Young, St. Paul, Minn. 25 [1861

1861.

Charles C. Beaman, 52 Wall, New York, N. Y. John Bigelow, "The Jansen," 13 Waverly PL, New York, N. Y. Charles Lee Bixby, Foxboro. Allen F. Boone, Winchester. Prof. Henry P. Bowditch, Jamaica Plain. Herman F. Brashear, 33 Wiggins Block, Cincinnati, O. John P. Brown, 227 Border, East Boston. John L. Bullard, 119 Maiden Lane, New York, N. Y. Elihu Chauncey, 22 E. 22d, New York, N. Y. John D. Cobb, Dedham. Charles A. Cooper. Dr. S. G. Cowdrey, Asst. Surg. U.S.A., Fort Bliss, El Paso, Tex. Lewis S. Dabney, 30 Court, Boston. Charles T. Dunklee, 5 Tremont, Boston. Samuel F. Emmons, U. S. Geol. Surv., Washington, D. C. Joseph E. Fiske, Wellesley Hills. Col. William H. Forbes, Milton. Rev. Minot G. Gage, Nashua, N. H. Wendell P. Garrison, P. O. Box 794, New York, N. Y. James F. Giffen, U. S. Appraiser's Office, New Orleans, La. Dr. Daniel D. Gilbert, Boston Ave., Dorchester. Rev. Ezra P. Gould. Frank W. Hackett, 486 Louisiana Ave., Washington, D. C. Albert Hale, Dedham. Col. Norwood P. Hallowell, West Medford. Joseph B. Hardon, 32 Franklin, Boston. Alpheus H. Hardy, 35 Brimmer, Boston. Rev. William A. Holbrook. Hon. Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., Court House, Boston. John P. Hopkinson, Craigie, Cambridge. Dr. Charles E. Inches, 88 Charles, Boston. Rev. Alfred P. Johnson, Springfield, Mo. Thomas H. Knowles, 24 Union, New Bedford. Prof. David F. Lincoln, Geneva, N. Y. Prof. Joseph H. McDaniels, Hobart College, Geneva, N. Y. Dr. James R. May, Portsmouth, N. H. Dr. Scollay Parker, Oregon City, Oregon. Prof. William H. Pettee, Michigan Univ., Ann Arbor, Mich. Henry Pickering, 1 Otis PL, Boston. Dr. George H. Powers, 215 Geary, San Francisco, Cal. Hon. James H. Rice, P. O. Box 381, Hartford, Conn. John Ritchie, 10 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Edward W. Sanborn, 9 State, Boston. Prof. Wesley C. Sawyer, San Jos6, Cal. J. Herbert Senter, , New York, N. Y. Hiram S. Shurtleff, 20 Wales, Dorchester. Prof. Albert Stetson. Rev. Fidelis Stone, Padres Passionistas, Casilla 648, Buenos Ayres, Richard Stone, 50 State, Boston. [Repub. Argentine. Charles Storrow, 186 Devonshire, Boston. 1861] 26

Flavel C. Stratton, 10 Bigelow, Cambridgeport. Sidney AY. Thaxter, 2 and 3 Gait Block, Portland, Me. Prof. Leslie Waggener, Univ. of Texas, Austin, Texas. Joseph H. Wales, Boston. P. 0. Box 3458. James P. Walker, Bangor, Me. Franklin Weld. Care Jacob Seaver & Co., 30 Kilby, Boston. Stephen W. Whitney, 68 Washington PL, New York, N. Y. Dr. Edward Wigglesworth, 188 Beacon, Boston. George F. Works, Fitchburg. |3P Rev. J. Edward Wright^ Montpelier, Vt.

Arthur Amory, 48 Franklin or 133 Marlborough, Boston. Murray R. Ballou, 51 State or 15 Pinckney, Boston. Rev. L. G. Barrett, 70 3d, Lowell. Rev. Ithamar W. Beard, 11 Spring, Dover, N. H. Rev. J. Vila Blake, 21 Laflin, Chicago, 111. Prof. Solomon H. Brackett, St. Johnsbury, Vt. W. T. Brigham. Rev. Clark Carter, 26 Andover, Lawrence. W. H. Chadbourn, 307 Harnett, Wilmington, N. C. T. L. Chadbourne. Houghton, Houghton Co., Mich. James G. Cole, Ladies Island, Beaufort Co., S. C. Charles J. Coleman, 22 College Building, Cincinnati, O. Benjamin M. Davenport, St. James Hotel, Chicago,' III. Prof. J. H. Dillingham, 1616 Cherry, or 140 N. 16th, Philadelphia, Pa. A. AY. Edmands, Bunker Hill Nat. , Charlestown. Rev. H. W. Fay, Westborough. George A. Fiske, Jr., 43 Franklin, Boston. George A. Fletcher, Highland, Milton. Dr. Charles F. Folsom, 15 Marlborough, Boston. Shepard D. Gilbert, P. O. Box 116, Salem. Dr. Francis W. Goss, Hotel Eliot, Roxbury. James Green, 61 Elm, Worcester. Prof. Charles E. Greene, 37 William, Ann Arbor, Mich. ftyCharles E. Grinnell, 30 Court, Boston. Mayo W. Hazeltine, Castleton Corners, Staten Island, N. Y. William Hedge, 27 Globe Building, Boston. Rev. F. L. Hosmer, 176 Euclid Ave., Cleveland, O. John E. Hudson, 95 Milk, Boston. F. W. Huidekoper, 1409 16th, Washington, D. C. Henry S. Huidekoper, Philadelphia. Pa. Henry U. Jeffries. Care Douglas, Lapraik & Co., Hong Kong, China. Dermot W. Keegan, University Club, New York, N. Y. Dr. Charles P. Kemp, Rugby, Tenn. Prof. E. D. Lindsey, Consold. Ex. Building, New York, N. Y. J. M. Loring, 804£ Chestnut, or 4107 Belle Ave., St. Louis, Mo. Henrv Mathes, Asylum, Concord, N. H. Edward D. McCarthy, 50 Wall, New York, N. Y. Dr. Arthur H. Nichols. 55 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Charles H. Noves. Care J. S. Brewer, 156 Lake, Chicago, 111. 27 [1863

Francis C. Nye, Delamotee Iron Works, New York, N. Y. Gilbert R. Pay son, 43 Avon, Boston. R. Singleton Peabody, Germantown, Pa. Dr. Charles B. Porter, 5 Arlington, Boston. N. A. Prentiss, 120 Broadway, or 131 E. 26th, New York, N. Y. George E. Priest, 35 Union, Boston. Edward D. Pritchard, 337 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Dr. Henry P. Qnincy, Declham, or 452 Beacon, Boston. John Read, 107 Washington, Boston. Arthur Reed, 66 State, Boston. Joseph S. Reed, Ladies Island, Beaufort Co., S. C. Frederick W. Rogers, 380 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Henry M. Rogers, 42 Court, Boston. Prof. Charles S. Sargent, Brookline. Edward B. Sawtell, Manchester, N. H. Arthur Sibley, 111 Arch, Boston, or Chelsea. Francis Skinner, 268 Beacon, Boston. Charles C. Soule, 15^ Beacon, Boston. James H. Stearns, Freeport, 111. Charles B. Stoddard, Plymouth. Dr. George G. Tarbell, 274 Marlborough, Boston. Benjamin H. Ticknor, 211 Tremont, Boston. Frederic W. Tilton, 10 Mt. Vernon PI., Newport, R. I. Rev. J. Nelson Trask, New Salem. John H. Treat, 617 Broadwav, Lawrence. Edward M. Tucke, 41 10th, Lowell. J. Langdon Ward, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

. Charles P. Ware, Box 66, Milton. W.T.Washburn, 50 & 141 B' way or 1219 Lexington Ave., New York. John E. Whiting, 136 Gravier, New Orleans, La. William G. Wilson, 48 Wall, or 33 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. 1863.

Charles W. Amory, 50 State, Boston. Dr. Robert Amory, 279 Beacon, Boston. , 28 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Marshall Ayres. Lombard, Ayres & Co., 12 B'way, New York. Dr. Charles H. Bagley, 1132 15th, Denver, Colo. Andrew J. Bailey, 14 Beacon, Boston. George L. Baxter, Somerville. Rev. Thomas W. Bishop, Salem. Albert Blair, 506 Olive, St. Louis, Mo. E. D. Boit. Care Hottinguer & Co., Paris, France. Charles P. Bowditch, 28 State, Boston. John M. Brown, 254 Washington, Boston. Melvin Brown, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Haswell C. Clarke, Kankakee, 111. Frederick Cobb, 179 Montague, Brooklyn, N. Y. Auguste Comte, 534J California, San Francisco, Cal. Frederic Cromwell, Mutual Life Ins. Co., 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. T. M. B. Cross, 280 St. Nicholas Ave, New York, N. Y. 1863] 28

J. Curtin, Smithsonian Institution,-Washington, D. C. George S. Dabney, 136 Congress, Boston. Moses Grant Daniell, 11 Schuyler, Roxbury. Clarence H. Denny, 36 Bedford, Boston. Edward B. Drew, West Newton. Henderson J. Edwards, 247 Washington, Boston. Charles Emerson, Concord. Rev. Samuel E. Evans, Duxbury. Charles S. Fairchild, 264 Fourth Ave., New York, N. Y. W. Gibson Field, 394 Clifton PL, Brooklyn, N. Y. , 22 Berkeley, Cambridge. Charles M. Foster, Topeka, Kans. John W. Freeman. Care Mrs. Walter Tillman, Troy, N. Y. J. D. W. French, 160 State, Boston. Benjamin T. Frothingham, 74 Broad, New York, N. Y. William Frothingham, 258 Beacon, Boston. Charles E. Furness. Care Dawes E. Furness, Foxburg, Pa. James A. Gillet, 109 E. 76th, New York, N. Y. Frank Goodwin, 28 State, Boston. Adolphus W. Green, 161 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Dr. J. Orne Green, 182 Marlborough, Boston. Frederick T. Greeuhalge, Lowell. William Greenough, Jr., 41 Worth, New York, N. Y. Edward S. Grew, 185 Marlborough, Boston. Dr. John D. Hall, Surgeon U.S.A., Fort Townsend, Wash. Rev. Walter W. Hammond. Rev. Thomas R. Harris, 1446 Washington Ave., New York, N. Y. A. C. Haseltine. Care M. Geo. Petit, 12 Rue Gadot de Mauroy, Paris, John T. Hassam, 47 Court, Boston. [France. Alexander L. Hayes, Elmwood Ave., Cambridge. Francis L. Higginson, 7 Exchange. PL, Boston. Samuel S. Higginson, Boston Herald, Boston. John M. Horton, N. Y. L. E. & W. RcL, Rochester, N. Y. William M. Howland, 9 Clinton PL, New York, N. Y. Edgar A. Hutchins, Tribune Building, New York, N. Y. Charles C. Jackson, 24 Congress. Boston. Rev. Henry F. Jenks, Canton. George S. Jones, 1623 Montgomery Ave., Philadelphia, Pa. Edward H. Kidder, 10 Warren, New York, N. Y. James T. Kilbreth, 230 E. 18th, New York, N. Y. Arthur M. Knapp, 52 Montgomery, Boston. Dr. Francis E. Langdon, Portsmouth, N. H. Dr. William H. Lathrop, 15 1st. Lowell. Rev. Arthur Lawrence, Stockbriclge. 13^ Arthur Lincoln, 8 Congress, Boston. Josiah Lombard, 12 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Francis A. Marden, 239 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Francis Marsh, 178 Devonshire, Boston, and Declham. E. Hutchins Marston, Phillips School, Boston. Dr. A. Lawrence Mason, 265 Clarendon, Boston. George Mixter, 28 State, Boston. George S. Morison, 35 Wall, New York, N. Y. 29 [1864

James H. Morse, 423 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. William Nichols, 10 Rutland Sq., Boston. Roscoe P. Owen, 14 Beacon, Boston. William H. Palmer, 12 Broadway, New York, N. Y. James L. Pearce, 3205 Washington Ave., St. Louis, Mo. Thomas B. Peck, Walpole, N. H. James L. Perry, 79 W. 47th, New York, N. Y. William L. Pillsbury, Champaign, 111. David Pingree, Salem. Dr. Herbert J. Pratt, Plymouth. W lliam H. Putnam, Lunenberg. John H. Rand, St. Cloud Hotel, B'y and 42d, New York, N. Y. Dr. George B. Shattuck, 24 Marlborough, Boston. Henry N. Sheldon, Advertiser Building, Boston. Dr. O. B. Shreve, Salem. Prof. Clement L. Smith, Cambridge. William Stackpole, 7 Fairfield, Boston. Edward G-. Stetson, 508 California, San Francisco, Cal. George S. Tomlinson, 3 Central Wharf, Boston. Dr. Henry E. Townsend, 101 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Dr. Henry Tuck, 346 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Robert N. Verplanck, Fishkill, N. Y. B. Read Wales, 177 State, Boston. H. W. Warren, Everett St., or P. O. Box 33, Jamaica Plain. Dr. J. Collins Warren, 58 Beacon, Boston. Clifford C. Waters, Pingree, North Dakota. Stuart F. Weld, Hyde Park. Edmund S. Wheeler, Canal Co., 44 Wall, New York. Moses D. Wheeler, P. O. Box 539 Stapleton, N. Y. William A. White, P. O. Box 619, New York, N. Y. , Stockbriclge. 1864. George Abbot, Concord Ave., Cambridge. Dr. Frederick P. Anderson, 650 Jefferson Ave., Detroit, Mich. Prof. William H. Appleton, Swarthmore, Pa. Rev. John P. Barrett, Normal, 111. James E. Bates, 27 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Rev. Loring E. Beckwith, Ashville, N. C. Rev. Russell N. Bellows, 109 E. loth, New York, N. Y. Prof. John Binney, Middletown, Conn. Rev. James T. Bixby, 159 Warburton Ave., Yonkers, N. Y. George C. Brackett, 227 Clinton, Brooklyn, N. Y. Rev. Franklin L. Bush, Pittsborough, N. C. William H. Chadsey, 906 Opera House Buildidg, Chicago, 111. Horace P. Chandler, 53 Devonshire, Boston. D. L. F. Chase, 50 Chardon, Boston. Joseph L. Cilley, 76 Gold, New York, N. Y. Richard Codman, 149a Tremont, Boston. Dr. Edward R. Cogswell, 61 Kirkland, Cambridge. E. P. Couch, Mystic Bridge, Conn. 1864] 30

William M. Courtis, 449 4th Ave., Detroit, Mich. Charles H. Coxe, University Club, Philadelphia, Pa. Hon. George G-. Crocker, 19 Milk, Boston. Prentiss Cummings, West End Railroad Co., 81 Milk, Boston. Rev. Marshall M. Cutter, 87 Milk, Boston. Dr. Richard H. Derby, 9 W. 35th, New York, N. Y. John A. Dillon, 1523 Hickory, St. Louis, Mo. Jonathan Dorr, 33 School, Boston. John L. Eldridge, 10 Tremont, Boston. James H. Elliot, 31 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Woodward Emery, 54 Sears Building, Boston. William C. Fabens, Lynn. George H. Fales, 48 Maverick Sq., E. Boston. Prof. O. M. Fernald, Williamstown. Dr. Reginald H. Fitz, 18 Arlington, Boston. Prof. Isaac Flagg. Care Prof. Peck, New Haven, Conn. Dr. Charles W. Fox, 1822 S. Rittenhouse Sq., Philadelphia, Pa. W. M. R. French, Art Institute, Chicago, 111. Arthur Gorham, Kinsley, Kan. La Roy S. Gove, 132 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Horace Graves, 16 Court, Brooklyn, N. Y. Charles P. Greenough, 39 Court, Boston. Almon D. Hodges, Jr., P. O. Box 1857, Boston. Edwin T. Horn, Tileston PL, Dorchester. Samuel D. Horton. Care E. J. Horton, 45 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Chas. L. Howe, 227 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

Edw. R. Howe. Care of Actors Fund, 145 Fifth Ave. , NewYork, N. Y. Rev. George P. Huntington, Ashfield. R. C. Johnson. Care Bank of the Republic, Boston. Dr. George G. Kennedy, Readville. Channing Lilly, 105 Bedford, Boston. Hon. Robert T. Lincoln, American Legation, London, England. William McFadon, Quincy, 111. George B. Morris, 37 Wall, New York, N. Y. William A. Monroe, 35 Court, Boston. Samuel B. Neal, Box 133, Kittery, Me. Peter B. Olney, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. John Owen, Boston. William R. Page, 22 Howland Block, Chicago, 111. Prof. George H. Palmer, Cambridge. Rev. Henry A. Parker, 6 Mason, Cambridge. George W. Pierce, Equitable Building, Boston. Henry M. Prentiss, Bangor, Me. Charles C. Read, 27 State, Boston. William Reed, Gazette Office, Taunton. lyDr. William L. Richardson, 225 Commonwealth Ave. , Boston, William R. Robeson, Jr., Albany, N. Y. Edward B. Robins, P. O. Box 2855, Boston. Nathaniel C. Scoville, Lee Summit, Jackson Co., Mo. Edwiu P. Seaver, Newton Highlands. Arthur G. Sedgwick, 115 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Albert T. Sinclair, 82 Devonshire, Boston. 31 [1865

Henry H. Sprague, 19 Milk, Boston. George B. Thayer, 164 High, Boston. William P. Walley, 40 State, Boston. John T. Ward, 204 California, San Francisco, Cal. Dr. Thomas Waterman, Hotel llkey, Cumberland, Boston. Dr. Frank Wells, Hawes, Brookline. Frank W. Wildes, 70 Washington, Boston. Henry T. Wing, 45 William, New York, N. Y. 1865,

Francis J. Alison, 216 South 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. Ludlow Apjones, Bee Branch, Van Buren Co., Ark. Robert H. Bancroft, 247 Beacon, Boston. Dr. William E. Boardman, 233 Marlborough, Boston. Hon. John Q. A. Brackett, 48 Congress, Boston. John H. Bradford, Somerset Club, Boston. tyT. Frank Brownell, 26 Broad, New York, N. Y. Albert C. Buzell, Exeter, N. H. Dr. James R. Chadwick, 270 Clarendon, Boston. Albro E. Chase, P. O. Box 737, Portland, Me. Prof. John W. Churchill, Andover. Charles W. Clifford, New Bedford. Rev. Joseph Cook, 28 Beacon, Boston. Horatio G. Curtis, 8 Congress, and 179 Marlborough, Boston. Walter Dabney, 33 Federal and 331 Beacon, Boston. George W. Dillaway, 18 Wall, New York, N. Y. Lewis A. Dodge, Custom House, Boston. Dr. Orlando W. Doe, 150 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. William B. Dnrant, 19 Congress, Boston. Charles J. Ellis, Los Angeles, Cal. Rev. William H. Fish, Jr., 7 Tremont PL, Boston. George A. Fisher, 47 Devonshire, Boston. William A. French, 89 Franklin, Boston. George S. Frost, Dover, N. H. George A. Goddard, 10 Tremont, Boston. Rev. William J. Gold, West. Theol. Sem., Chicago, 111. Francis B. Greene, P. O. Box 452, New Bedford,

David S. Greenough, 89 Franklin, Boston. . . John Greenough, 34 Wall, New York, N. Y. George A. Hill, Cambridge. Frank M. Hollister, Commercial Advertiser, Buffalo, N. Y. Dr. Henry Hooper, 215 Dearborn Ave., Chicago, 111. Edward D. Hosmer, 79 Clark, Chicago, 111. James O. Hoyt, 158 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Walter Hunnewell, 87 Milk, Boston. Patrick T.Jackson, Jr., 178 Devonshire, Boston. Prof. Albert R. Leeds, Stevens Institute, Hoboken, N. J. Louis C. Lewis, 109 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Charles J. Lincoln, Brookline. Roland C. Lincoln, 82 Devonshire, Boston. Rev. Robert C. Mcllwain, Keokuk, Lee Co., Iowa. 1865] 32

George H. Mifflin, 85 Marlborough, Boston. L. H. Mitchell. Care Rev. R. C. Mcllwain, '6o. Albert M. Moore, Lowell. George F. Osgood, Peabody. Rev. Frederick Pasco, Jacksonville, Fla. John W. Perkins, Dummar Academy, So. Byfield. Henry W. Poor, 34 Wall, New York, N. Y. Jesse W. Potts, 342 State, Albany, N. Y. Dr. Charles P. Putnam, 63 Marlborough, Boston. James S. Rogers, Rockport. William Rotch, 289 Beacon, Boston. Prof. Marshall S. Snow, Washington Universit}', St. Louis, Mo. Charles E. Souther, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. George A. Stearns, 63 Fulton, New York, N. Y. Thomas E. Symmes, Granite ville. John K. Tiffany, corner 5th and Oliver, St. Louis, Mo. Lawrence Tucker, 9 Charles, Boston. Charles H. Tweed, Mills Building, New York, N. Y. Rev. William H. Warren, Central Cong. Church, Cincinnati, O. Enos Wilder, 81 Beaver, New York, N. Y. Dr. Edward T. Williams, 2298 Washington, Roxbury. Gorham D. Williams, 30 Court, Boston. Henry B. Williams, 113 Devonshire, Boston. 1866.

Samuel A. B. Abbott, 28 State, Boston. Daniel P. Abercrombie, Turner's Falls. Frank B. Arnold, 125 Front, New York, N. Y. E. D. Bangs, 88 State, Boston. Benson B. Banker, City Hospital, Boston. Rev. George Batchelor, Lowell. George C. Bent, 7 South Front, Harrisburg, Pa. William Blaikie, 206 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Henry G. Blair, 1428 Arch, Philadelphia, Pa. William P. Blake, 2 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Dr. Henry T. Boutwell, Manchester, N. H. Holder B. Bowen, Borden & Bowen, Providence, R. I. Dr. Charles B. Brigham, 2202 Broadway, San Francisco, Cal. Frederick J. Brown, 40 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. Henry F. Buswell, 4 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Rev. Edward A. Capen, Watertown. Albertson Case, Southold, Suffolk Co., N. Y. Albion Cate, 78 La Salle, Chicago, 111. George F. Chace, P. O. Box 244, Taunton. Theodore M. Clark, 22 Congress, Boston. John H. Coppenhagen, 675 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Frederic Crowninshield, 42 W. 18th, New York, N. Y. Dr. John G. Curtis, 127 E. 35th, New York, N. Y. Frederick Dabney, Boston. Allen Danforth, 50 State, Boston. Prof. Samuel C. Derby, State University, Columbus, O. 33 [1866

Dr. Lewis S. Dixon, 232 Clarendon, Boston. Eaton S. Drone, N. Y. Herald Office, New York, N. Y. Alexander D. Dunbar, Peekskill, N. Y. Dr. Thomas Dwight, 235 Beacon, Boston. Dr. Edward W. Emerson, Concord. Prof. William G. Farlow, Cambridge. Dr. Edwin Farnham, Cambridge. Edward N. Fenno, 96 Mt. Vernon, or 117 Federal, Boston. A. K. Fisk, N. Y. Times Office, New York, N. Y. George A. Flagg, Millbury. Justin E. Gale, Cambridge. James S. Garland, Concord. W. Austin Goodman, 8 W. 3d, Cincinnati, O. Francis C. Gray, 7 Mt. Vernon PL, or 85 Devonshire, Boston. Eugene D. Greenleaf, 41 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Richard C. Greenleaf. Care of C. F. Hovey, 7 Rue Scribe, Paris, Rev. James B. Gregg, Colorado Springs, Colo. [France. Dr. Francis A. Harris, 59 Chambers, Boston. Dr. William A. Haskell, Alton, 111. David G. Haskins, Jr., 83 Devonshire, Boston. James W. Hawes, 140 Nassau, New York, N. Y. William A. Hayes, 2d, 58 Sears Building, Boston. Dr. Claudius M. Jones, 51 Chambers, Boston. George A. Kettell, 39 Chestnut, Charlestown. Amos M. Leonard, U. S. Hotel, Boston. [Sweden. Rev. Otis L. Leonard, E. Marshfield, or 44 Skepparegarten, Stockholm, George E. Littlefield, 67 Cornhill, Boston. Dr. Morris Longstreth, 1416 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. John J. Loud, Weymouth. James W. Lovering, 228 Brattle, Cambridge. Dr. Charles McBurney, 40 W. 36th, New York, N. Y. Rev. Haslett McKim, 34 Hillhouse Ave., New Haven, Conn. Dr. John J. Mason. Rev. Henry C. Mayer, Pass Christian, Miss. Lewis C. Murdock, 313 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Thomas Nelson, 4 Exchange PL, Boston. John L. Norton, Memphis, Tenn. George L. Osgood, 149a Tremont, Boston. James 0. Parker. Robert S. Peabodj^, 60 Devonshire, Boston. Edward F. Peirce, West Yarmouth. Edward C. Perkins, Milton, or 44 Sears Building, Boston. Thomas S. Perry, 312 Marlborough, Boston. George G. Pratt, 28 School, Boston. Dr. James J. Putnam, 106 Marlborough, Boston. George F. Robinson, Kennebunk, Me. Henrv Rolfe, City, Nev. Dr. Thomas P. Shaw, 164 Pine, Lowell. Swithin C. Shortlidge, Media, Pa. William E. Skillings, Bethel, Oxford Co., Me. Marshall P. Stafford, 140 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Francis R. Stoddard, City Hall, Boston. 1866] 34

William P. Stoddard, Plymouth. Moorfield Storey, 131 Devonshire, Boston. |yCharles E. Stratton, 68 Devonshire, Boston. John W. Taylor, corner Market and First, San Francisco, Cal. John L. Thorndike, 131 Devonshire, Boston. W. G. Tiffany, Paris, London & Amer. Bank, San Francisco, Cal. Melvin A. Underwood, Custom House, Boston. Alfred C. Vinton, 23 Milk, Boston. Rev. John H. Watson, 56 Wethersfield Ave., Hartford, Conn. George D. Welles. Care of E. I. Browne, 47 State, Boston. Dr. Leonard Wheeler, 6 Elm, Worcester. John M. Whittemore, Jr., 15 Follen, Cambridge. John D. Williams, 160 State, Boston. Edmund W. Wright, Kendallville, Ind. Frank Wright, Mt. Royal, Fla. Rev. Theodore F. Wright, Bridgewater. 1867. Theodore P. Adams, 16 Ashburton PL, Boston. Samuel P. Allen, Globe Building, Boston. Amos Prescott Baker, Newport, R. I. Clement Bates, 32 Carlisle Building, Cincinnati, O. Dr. James T. Boutelle, Hampton, Va. Rev. Arthur Brooks, 209 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Frederick E. C. Bryant, West Superior, Wis. William A. Bunton, 43 Milk, Boston. James R. Carret, 39 Court, Boston. Heman W. Chaplin, 87 Milk, Boston. Winthrop L. Chenery, Belmont. Joseph R. Churchill, 82 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Herbert C. Clapp, 11 Columbus Sq., Boston. Frank J. Clark, 50 Rutland Sq., Boston. Eliot C. Clarke, 15 Brimmer, Boston. J. Houghton Clarke, Cotton Plant, Marion Co., Fla. Dr. Clement Cleveland, 59 W. 38th, New York, N. Y. Rev. Silas P. Cook, Chelsea. Dr. Ernest W. Gushing, 168 Newbury, Boston. Leonard F. Cutter, 210 Commercial, Boston. Dr. Bennett F. Davenport, 161 Tremont, Boston. Rev. William F. Davis, Mt. Washington, Chelsea. Frederick Dodge, 87 Milk, Boston. Sanford H. Dudley, 95 Milk, Boston. Thomas S Edmands, 40 Water, Boston. Theodore Ellis, Belcaro, Enfield, Middlesex, England, William R. Ellis, Cambridge. William E. Ellison, P. O. Box 1371, Nashua, N. H. James S. English, 68 Cornhill, Boston. Clement K. Fa}', 5 Tremont, Boston. Charles S. Gage, Hopkinton, N. H. Frank C. Garbutt, P. O. Box 156, Los Angeles, Cal. T. Herbert Gray, Walpole. 35 [1868

Silas W. Hale, Hudson. Rev. Alfred H. Hall, Meriden, Conn. Meldon L. Hanscom, West Berkeley, Alameda Co., Cal. , Concord. Prof. Charles L. Jackson, Harvard College, Cambridge. John C. Jackson, 163 Randolph, Chicago, 111. Arthur E. Jones, 60 Devonshire, Boston. William B. Lambert, 53 Brattle, Boston. Henry Y. Leavitt, Great Barrington. George V. Leverett, 47 Devonshire, Boston. fgr'Francis H. Lincoln, 60 Devonshire, Boston. John Lindsley, Yokohama, Japan. Edward J. Lowell, 50 State, Boston. George C. Mann, Glen Road, Jamaica Plain. Edward W. Mealey, U. S. Consulate, Munich, Bavaria, Germ. George H. Miller, Baring Bros. & Co., London, England. Henry G. Monks, 35 Congress, Boston. William Montgomery, 69 Wall, New York, N. Y. Dr. William J. Morton, 36 W. 56th, New York, N. Y. Henry B. Parker, Baldwinsville. William G. Peckham, 88 Trinity Building, New York, N. Y. George F. Piper, 48 Congress, Boston. Jerome B. Poole, Rockland. Joseph W. Reed, Maynard. Henry A. Rice, Jr., 610 Atlantic Ave., Boston. Dr. George E. Richards, Hotel Kempton, Boston. Charles G. Saunders, 95 Milk, Boston. William E. Silsbee, Somerset Club, Boston. Dr. J. Winthrop Spooner, Hingham. Melville Stacy, 28 School, Boston. Charles O. Stearns,. 161 Franklin, Boston. Frank P. Stearns, College Hill. Bellamy Storer, corner 4th and Main, Cincinnati, O. James B. Taylor, Berkeley School, Boston. , 28 Brimmer, Boston. Charles D. Wadsworth, 44 New, New York, N. Y. Elwyn Waller, School of Mines, 130 E. 24th, New York, N. Y. Horace E. Ware, 33 School, Boston. Edward L. Wood, 31 Bedford, Boston. Prof. Edward S. Wood, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Hon. William Worthington, 27 Wiggins Block, Cincinnati, O. Charles Wyman. Care Henry Whitman, 7 Chestnut, Boston. 1868.

Talbot J. Albert, 29 N. Liberty, Baltimore, Md. William B. Allen, Allston. Prof. James B. Ames, Cambridge. Albert H. Ammidown, 206 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Horace Bacon. Care Kessler & Co., 54 Wall, New Yrork, N. Y. George F. Becker, U. S. Geological Survey, Washington, D. C. William F. Bennett, Marietta, Cobb Co., Georgia. William L. Boalt. 1868] 36

Robert A. Boit, 40 Kilby, Boston, Frederick Brooks, 31 Milk, Boston. Augustus G. Bullock, Worcester. John T. Busiel, Laconia, N. H. John F. Casey, 84 W. Rutland Sq., Boston. |yAlfred D. Chandler, 50 Equitable Building, Boston. Dr. Elbridge G. Cutler, 275 Clarendon, Boston. John W. Denny, 20 Bedford, Boston, and Hyde Park. Rev. Charles F. Dole, Jamaica Plain. Charles W. Durham, Rock Island, 111. Prof. Aaron M. Elliott, Univ. Baltimore, McL Edward C. Ellis, Somerset Club, Boston. Frank I. Eustis, Cambridge. Charles G. Fall, Rogers Building, Boston. James P. Farley, Jr., 23 Court, Boston. Alden B. Farnham, 421 Milwaukee, Milwaukee, Wis. Dr. Charles O. Files, 11 Brown, Portland, Me. Dawes E. Furness, Foxburgh, Clarion Co., Pa. Malcolm S. Greenough, 24 West, Boston. James Grier, P. 0. Box 463, Pittsburg. Pa. Frederic R. Halsey, Union Club, New York, N. Y. John Hillis, 28 School, Boston. Charles F. Hinckle, 508 Girard Building, Philadelphia, Pa. Edgar Huidekoper, Meadville, Pa. Arthur Hunnewell, 87 Milk, Boston. Frederic G. Ireland, University Club, New York, N. Y. Henry F. King, West Newton. Dr. Francis P. Kinnicutt, 42 W. 37th, New York, N. Y. Dr. Charles A. Lovejoy, 62 Broad, Lynn. Charles T. Lovering, 23 Court, Boston. John P. Lyman, 25 Mt. Vernon, Boston. E. Sumner Mansfield, 42 Court, Boston. Rev. Chas A. Morrill, Trinity Hall, Washington, Pa. William H. Nash, P. O. Box 496, Leadville, Colo. Charles D. Palmer, Lowell, Mass. C. H. Phelps, Thatched House Club, St. James's, London, Eng. Otis L. Prescott, 70 Kilby, Boston. J. Pickering Putnam, The Langham, Boston. Milton Reed, Fall River. William T. Reid, Belmont, Cal. William W. Richards, P. O. Box 194, New York, N. Y. Edwin L. Sargent, 126 North Ave., Cambridge. Rev. Josiah L. Seward, Waterville, Me. Dr. Frederic C. Shattuck, 135 Marlborough, Boston. Prof. William C. Simmons, 6 E. 44th, New York, N. Y. Douglas Smyth, 48 Exchange PL, New York, N. Y. Edward E. Sprague, 192 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Isaac H. Sweetser, Boston, and 19 Monument Sq., Charlestown. William L Swift, Millbrook, Dutchess Co., N. Y. Henry P. Talmadge, 68 William, New York, N. Y. or Box 2966. Dexter Tiffany, 4th and Market, St. Louis, Mo. John W. Tilton, Haverhill. John Todhunter. 37 [1869

George Hill, 206 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Prof. Henry B. Hill, Cambridge. Edward F. 'Hoffman, 502 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Leverett S. Tuckerman, Salem. Moses J. Wentworth, 45 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Paul Wentworth, Sandwich, N. H. Jesse F. Wheeler, 23 Court, Boston. Moses Williams, 18 P. O. Sq., Boston. Walter Wood, 400 Chestnut, Philadelphia, Pa. 1869. Francis H. Appleton, Lynnfield. William F. Apthorp, 14 Otis PL, Boston. Henry G. Atwater, 160 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Dr. James B. Ayer, 53 Mt. Vernon, Boston. George H. Ball, 40 State, Boston. Franklin Bartlett, 168 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Josiah C. Bartlett, C .B. & Q. Office, Chicago, 111. §yThomas P. Beal, Second National Bank, Boston. Joseph S. Bigelow, 246 Washington, Boston. George E. Bird, 38 Exchange, Portland, Me. Charles J. Blaney, Marblehead. Edward Bowditch, Albany, N. Y. James H. Bowditch, 60 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Edward H. Bradford, 149 Newbury, Boston. Joseph D. Brannan, 30 W. 4th, Cincinnati, O. Henry Brett, Calumet, Mich. Rev. John K. Browne, Harpoot, Eastern Turkey, Asia. Dr. William T. Bull, 35 W. 35th, New York, N. Y. Henry F. Burt, Taunton. Prescott H. Butler, 52 Wall, New York, N. Y. Charles L. Capen, Bloomington, 111. Nathaniel Chilcls. Care Boston Press Club, Boston. Capt. EdwardT. Comegys, U.S.A. Care Surg. -Gen. U.S. A., Washing- Walter Cook, 55 Broadway, New York, N. Y. [ton, D. C. Rufus C. Cushman, 36 Central, Boston. Herbert D. Cutler, Station A, Kansas City, Mo. William E. Cutter, Box 447, Worcester. James A. Dodge, University, Minneapolis, Minn. Charles N. Fay, Chicago Telephone Co., Chicago, 111. Arthur I. Fiske, 238 W. Canton, Boston. Austen G. Fox, 41 Wall, New York, N. Y. William Gallagher, Easthampton. Sydney K. Gold, Faribault, Rice Co., Minn. GustavusGoward, 1231 Ave., Washington, D.C. Willard W. Grant, 166 E. Michigan, Indianapolis, Ind. Russell Gray, 50 State, Boston. Horace D. Green, Brier Cliff, Sing Sing, N. Y. Lev^is B. Hall, 89 State, Albany, N. Y. William S. Hall, 8 Congress, Boston. Harris C. Hartwell, 140 Main, Fitchburg. Charles L. Hayward, Jr., 165 Highland, Roxbury. 1869] 38

Oscar R. Houghton. Care Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston. Archibald M. Howe, 10 Tremont, Room 65, Boston. Henry M. Howe, Hotel Oxford, Boston. Henry S. Howe, 68 Chauncy, Boston. Eugene M. Johnson, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Alfred G. Lamson, 20 P. O. Building, Lowell. Warren A. Locke, 10 Putnam Ave., Cambridge. Alden P. Loring, B. & Mo. Riv. R. R., Lincoln, Neb. William D. Mackintosh, Arlington Heights. Edward H. Mason, 70 Kilby, Boston. John R. Mason, Bangor, Me. Rev. George E. Merrill, Colorado Springs, Col. Royal W. Merrill, Mail and Express Office, New York, N. Y. Frank D. Millett, 92 Clinton PL, New York, N. Y. William P. Montague, Treasury Dept., Washington, D. C. Robert S. Morison, 34 Shepard, Cambridge. James J. Myers, 39 Court, Boston. William H. Orcutt, 869 Delaware Ave., Buffalo, N. Y. Rev. Frederic Palmer, Andover. Rev. Francis G. Peabody, Cambridge. Henry G. Pickering, 10 Tremont, Boston. Charles E. Pope, 132 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Thomas E. Pope, Mass. Inst, of Technology, Boston. Rev. John M. W. Pratt, Tyngsborough. Henry W. Putnam, 85 Devonshire, Boston. Francis Rawle, 402 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Edward Read, 107 Washington, Boston. Heniy Richards, Gardiner. Me. Charles W. Richardson, 71 Washington, Salem. Dr. Frederick W. Russell, Winchenclon. Nathaniel Morton Safford, Milton. William M. Sargent, 34 Exchange, Portland, Me. Mark Sibley Severance, Salt Lake, Utah. George R. Shaw, 9 Park, Boston. Robert G. Shaw, 87 Milk, Boston. Joseph L. Silsbee, 53 Lakeside Building, Chicago, 111. Dr. William H. Simmons, Bangor, Me. Nathaniel S. Smith, 95 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Rev. L. G. Stevens, St. Luke's Church, Portland, St. John, N. B. Benjamin L. M. Tower, 40 Water, Boston. George C. Travis, Globe Building, 244 Washington, Boston. Dr. W. Lewis Tucker, 96 Charles, Boston. Samuel Epes Turner, Cambridge. Joseph B. Warner, 39 Court, Boston. Robert Watson, Milton. Dr. William S. Whitwell, 620 Folsom, San Francisco, Cal. Joseph W. Wilder. Gardner G. Willard, 87 Washington, Chicago, 111. Augustus E. Willson, 516 W. Jefferson, Louisville, Ky. William S. Windle, W. Chester, Pa. Frank Woodman, Charleston, Kanawha Co., W. Va. Rev. Horace W. Wright, Abington. Gerald Wjmoan, Box 3588, Boston. 39 [1870

1870. Brooks Adams, 23 Court, Boston. George H. Adams, 35 Wall, New York, N. Y. Walter Adams, 42 Court, Boston. William P. Alexander, 152 E. 86th, New York, N. Y. Angier Ames. Care William L. Ames, St. Paul, Minn. Henry C. Andrews, 2 Wall, New York, N. Y. William B. Buckminster, P. O. Box 2843, Boston. George W. Bunton, 32 Bedford, Boston. Arthur Burnham. William W. Chamberlin. Dr. Frederic W. Chapin, Springfield. N. C. Chapman. Care Eau Claire Lumber Co., St. Louis, Mo. Henry L. Clapp, 70 W. Cottage, Roxbury. Zorester B. Coes, Niles Tools Works, Hamilton, O. John H. Cole, 35 Wall, New York, N. Y. , 24 Congress, Boston. Louis Curtis, 66 State, Boston. Rest F. Curtis, 146 Falmouth, Boston. Louis T. Cushing, Cohasset. Arthur H. Cutler, 20 W. 43d, New York, N. Y. Walter Deane, 5 Brewster PL, Cambridge. Newton Dexter. A. J. Dallas Dixon, 206 S. 5th, Philadelphia, Pa. Dr. John Dixwell, 52 West Cedar, Boston. William W. Dodge, 85 Milk, Boston, or Sparks, Cambridge. Charles A. Drew, 62 Devonshire, Boston. Edward Dudley, 35 N. 2d, Camden, N. J. John F. Dwight, Weymouth. Charles C. Emott, 104 W. 69th, New York, N. Y. B. Marvin Fernald, 28 State, Boston. Andrew Fitz, P. O. Box 235, Salem. Laurens N. Francis, Room 4, Crocker Building, Taunton. Theo. Frothingham, Solicitors' Trust Co., 142 S. 4th, Phila., Pa. Frederick T. Fuller, Weston. James B. Galloway, 605 Rialto Building, Chicago, 111. Prof. Richard T. Greener, 146 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Dr. Herman J. Groesbeck, Cincinnati, O. Prof. William G. Hale, Cornell University, Ithaca, N. Y. George Harrison. John E. Hill, 22 High, Boston. Charles E. Hoar, San Fernando, Los Angeles Co., Cal. Artemas H. Holmes, 35 Wall, New York, N. Y. Rev. Raymond F. Holway, Dorchester. William G. Hosea, Johnston Building, Cincinnati, O. Arthur L. Huntington, 256£ Essex, Salem. Dr. Leonard Huntress, Jr., Lowell. James C. Jordan, 62 Beacon, Boston. Charles W. Kettell, Brewster PL, Cambridge. Frederic Kidder, Wilmington, N. C. Babson S. Ladd, 10 Tremont, Boston. .

1870] 40

Amory A. Lawrence, 68 Chauncy, Boston. Waldo Lincoln, Worcester. George S. Littlefield, 28 State, Boston. Horace G-. Lunt, Colorado Springs, Colo. Harry W. McCall, GerrnantowD, Pa. Charles B. McMichael, 132 S. 3d, Philadelphia, Pa. B. Pickman Mann, 1918 Sunderland PI., Washington, D. C. Charles L. Mitchell, 4th and Main, Cincinnati, O. P. O. Box 188. Charles Monroe, Topeka, Kan. Ernest N. Morison, South and German, Baltimore, Md. Godfrey Morse, 40 Water, Boston. Otis Norcross, 35 Congress, Boston. Franklin Nourse, York Manufacturing Co., Saco, Me. Charles F. Nye, Champlain, N. Y. Hemy Parkman, 209 Washington, Boston. Samuel L. Parrish, 80 Broadway, New York, N. Y. , 31 Milk, Boston. George Pearson, Harrisburg, Pa. Frank K. Pendleton, 80 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Rev. Willard T. Perrin, 34 Kirk, Lowell. Edward Rawson, Rawson & Sons, Cincinnati, O. J. Rogers Rich, 167 Tremont, Boston. Frank W. Robinson. Otis G. Robinson. Alfred Rodman, Bay State Trust Co., 87 Boylston, Boston. Dr. Thomas M. Rotch, 197 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. John W. Sanger, Cambridge. Joseph Sargent, Jr., Worcester. Lucius M. Sargent, 60 State, Boston. Winthrop S. Scudder, Riverside Press, Cambridge. Oscar Seavey, Auburn, Cal. Dr. Chauncey C. Sheldon, 49 North Common, Lynn. Walter Shepard, Arion, Dorchester. Barker B. Sherman. S. Sydney Smith, 59 Wall, New York, N. Y. W. Bugbee Smith, 119 S. 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. Prof. James R. Sole}', Naval Library, Washington, D. C. Richard H. Soule, Englewood, N. J. William M. Spackman, 32 Nassau, and 820 Madison Ave., New York. Dr. Charles P. Spalding, Lowell. Henry K. Spaulding, 20 W. 43d, New York, N. Y. Richard H. Stone, 381 Main, Cincinnati, O. Charles H. Swan, 82 Devonshire, Boston. Stephen S. Taft, Palmer. K^'Thomas B. Ticknor, Jamaica Plain Alfred Tuckerman, 175 W. 47th, New York, N. Y. Box 606. William W. Vaughan, 354 Beacon, Boston. Frederic H. Viaux, Transcript Building, Boston. W. Austin Wadsworth, Geneseo, Livingston Co., N. Y. Prof. Lucien A. Wait, Cornell Univ., Ithaca, N. Y. Charles H. Walcott, Concord. B. M. Watson, Jr., Bussey Institution, Jamaica Plain. 41 [1871

Henry Wells, Cairo, 111. Melville M. Weston, 13 Exchange, Boston. Hon. William F. Wharton, State Dept., Washington, D. C. John S. White, 6 E. 44th, New York, N. Y. Charles B. Wilby, 218 Main, Cincinnati, O.

Grinnell Willis. Care Lewis Bros. & Co. , 86 Worth, New York. Walter T. Winsor. Care Alfred Winsor & Son, Boston. Roger Wolcott, 53 Tremont, Boston. Charles F. Woodard, Bangor, Me. Francis J. Worcester, 280 Broadway, New York, N. Y. J. B. Noel Wyatt, 1900 Ave., Baltimore, Md.

1871,

Francis I. Amory, 23 Court, Boston. Amory Austin, Newport, R. I. Henry C. Backus, 489 W. 22d, New York, N. Y. |yAlbert M. Barnes, 38 Central, Boston. P. O. Box 1925. Nelson S. Bartlett, 6 Mason Building, Boston. George Bass, 97 Clark, Chicago, 111. Francis Bassett. Dr. William S. Bigelow, 60 Beacon, Boston. Edward C. Boardman, 155 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Charles J. Bonaparte, 1 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. Dr. Edward C. Booth, Somerville. Charles S. Bowen, 9 Follen, Cambridge. Rev. William W. Boyd, Newark, N. J. Dudley H. Bradlee, 110 Oliver, Boston. Jesse Brown, 1801 I, Washington, D. C. Rufns A. Bullock, 28 School, Boston. Edward Burgess, 24 Congress, Boston. Hon. , Deerfoot Farm, Southborough. Samuel Dacre Bush, 7 Exchange PL, Boston. Prof. William E. Byerly, Cambridge. Michael J. Canavan, 55 Sears Building, Boston.

F. B. Chadwick. Care Munroe & Co. , Rue Scribe, Paris, France. Herbert A. Chapin, 10 Tremont, Boston. Horace D. Chapin, 50 State, Boston. Dr. Herbert A. Chase, 772 Main, Cambridgeport. Hon. Walter Clifford, New Bedford. George F. Comstock, Jr., Syracuse, N. Y. Virgil R. Connor, Fairfield, Me. Arthur T. Cutler, 50 Madison, Chicago, 111. Alfred S. Dabney, 7 Chestnut, Boston. I. Putnam Dana, Kansas City, Mo. Francis B. Daniels, Dubuque, Iowa. Dearborn. Horace E. Deming, Mills Building, 36 Wall, New York, N. Y. N. W. Eayrs, St. Louis Bridge & Tunnel Co., St. Louis, Mo. Richard Ela, 13 Ash, Cambridge. Dr. Walter Ela, Cambridge. Prof. Ephraim Emerton, Chauncey, Cambridge. 1871] . 42

George A. 0. Ernst, 76 Equitable Building, Boston. William E. C. Eustis, 4 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Walter Faxon, Cambridge. Jabez Fox, 50 State, Boston. Alfred N. Fuller, 574 5th Ave., New York, N. Y. Dr. George M. Garland, Hotel Aubrey, Boston. John B. Gerrish, 224 Henry, Brooklyn, N. Y. Rev. Theodore C. Gleason. Harry Godey, 1841 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. Eugene B. Hagar, 53 Sears Building, or 33 Temple, Boston. Dr. William B. Hills, 54 Langdon, Cambridge. Samuel Parker Hinckley, Lawrence Station, L. I. Dr. Edward F. Hodges, Indianapolis, Ind. Dr. Charles D. Hunking, 210 W. 34th, New York, N. Y. Frank Jackson, 24 Congress, Boston. Henry C. James. Lampey & James, St. Paul, Minn. Augustus Jay, Knickerbocker Club, 249 5th Ave., New York. Charles W. Jenks, Bedford. Treby Johnson, Augusta, Me. George I. Jones, 151 Washington, Chicago, 111. Charles W. Kimball. John L. King, 6 Granger Block, Syracuse, N. Y. William N. King, San Diego, Cal. Dr. William H. Klapp, 2132 Pine, Philadelphia, Pa. Horatio A. Lamb, 69 Chauncy, Boston. Walter C. Earned, 205 La Salle, Chicago, 111. John S. Lawrence, 47 Monroe, Grand Rapids, Mich. Rev. William Lawrence, Cambridge. Francis N. Lincoln, 254 Washington, Boston. Hon. , 65 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Dr. Phillips A. Lovering, Navy Yard, Brooklyn, N. Y. Francis O. Lyman, 1206 Tacoma Building, Chicago, 111. James S. McCobb, Mills Building, New York, N. Y. James McManus, Natick. Rev. Wilmot M. Mayhew, Whiting, Vt. Frank Merriam, 62 Devonshire, Boston. George R. Minot, 18 Kingston, Boston. Geo. P. Montague, Mare Island, Navy Yard, San Francisco, Cal. John W. Munroe, 7 Rue Scribe, Paris, France. Thomas Nesmith, Box 346, Lowell. Rev. Harry P. Nichols, New Haven, Conn. Simon Obermeyer, 319 N. 3d, St. Louis, Mo. Theodore M. Osborne, 54 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Edward O. Otis, 62 Chestnut, Boston. Charles L. Palmer, Cottonwood, Idaho. Edward D. Pearce, 157 Hope, Providence, R. I. Robert F. Pennell, Buffalo, N. Y. N. G. Read. CareWm. Read & Sons, 107 Washington, Boston. James Russell Reed, Lexington. John Reynolds, 7 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Wallace E. Rhodes. Sylvester W. Rice, Portland, Multnomah Co., Oregon. 43 [1872

Arthur Rotch, 85 Devonshire, Boston. Hon. Morgan Rotch, New Bedford. Junius Sampson, New Iberia, Parish of Iberia, La. William D. Sanborn, 152 Federal, Boston. William T. Sanger, Harrisburg, Pa. James P. Scott, 2124 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Charles F. Seybold, 203 Walnut, Cincinnati, O. Harvey N. Shepard, 10 Tremont, Boston. Theophilus G. Smith, 54 Devonshire, Boston. James C. Sproat, Taunton. Henry P. Starbuck, 62 Wall, New York, N. Y. Dr. George Stedman, Park Sq., Boston. Henry Rust Stedman, Roslindale. Charles C. Stein, Pueblo, Colo. Prof. W. E. Story, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md. Rev. George L. Stowell, Lexington. Theodore Sutro, 292 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Henry W. Swift, 50 State, Boston. Nathaniel Thayer, 21 Sears Building, Boston. Lendall Titcomb, Augusta, Me. Benjamin B. Townsend, 218 W. 46th, New York, N. Y. Henry C. Townsend, 234 Broadway, New York, N. Y. James M. Troutt, Phelan Building, San Francisco, Cal. , Boston. Hamilton McK. Twombly, 691 5th Ave., New York, N. Y. Timothy B. Walker, Ashland, Ky. Joseph R. Walter, Wilmington, Del. William Rotch Ware, 211 Tremont, Boston. Dr. Joseph W. Warren, 119 Bojdston, Boston. James B. Wells, Helena, Montana. William P. Wentworth. Henry N. Wheeler, 4 Park, Boston. Charles L. B. Whitney, 28 School, Boston. Edward F. Whitney, Whitney Bros. & Co., Calcutta, . Dr. William F. Whitney, 228 Marlborough, Boston. Judson B. Wildes, 55 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Almadus Wilkinson, Johnsonville, Rens. Co., N. Y. Byron C. Williams, Newark, Wayne Co., N. Y. Dr. Charles H. Williams. Care C, B. & Q. R. R., Chicago, 111. John S. Williamson, 7 Nassau, New York, N. Y. George C. Wing, Cleveland, O. William R. Winslow, 132 Nassau, New York, N. Y. 1872.

Charles Almy, 50 State, Boston. Nicola Altrocchi. Hon. John F. Andrew, 246 Washington, Boston. John C. Avery, 274 Race, Cincinnati O. Geo. F. Babbitt, 32 Pemberton Sq., Boston.

Charles F. Baker, Fitchburg. , ...... ^q cj George S. Bates, Los Angeles Times, Los Angeles, Cal. 1872] U

William S. Beaman, 140 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Hod. Perry Belmont, 109 5th Ave., New York, N. Y. Arthur S. Bird, Stockton, Me. Charles R. Brickett. Care B. F. Briekett, Haverhill.

Rev. John C. Brooks T Christ Church Rectory, Springfield. John F. Brown, 42 Court, Boston. Arthur Burgess. Care Walter Burgess, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Walter Burgess, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Arthur T. Cabot, 3 Marlborough, Boston. Edward B. Callencler, 1 Pemberton Sq., Boston. William W. Carter, Englewood, Cook Co., 111. Charles W. Chase. Albert W. Cobb, 25 Wabash Ave., Chicago, III. John S. Cram, 56 Wall, New York, N. Y. Otis H. Currier, 117 State, Boston. Eden R. Donohue, 91 Auburn, Cincinnati, O. William H. Elliot, Keene, N. H. Charles N. Fessenden, 312 Chicago Ave., Chicago, III. or care Board Cornelius C. Felton, Cambridge. [of Education. Dr. Henry M. Fisher, 919 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. George Fiske, Room 5, 60 Congress, Boston. Prof. Thomas French, Ridgeway Ave., Avondale, Cincinnati, (X William C. French, 97 Newbury, Boston. George A. Gibson, 182 Tremont, Boston. Frank A. Gooch, , New Haven, Conn. Allen W. Gould, Manistee, Mich. George H. Gould, P. O. Box 231, Santa Barbara, Cal. Edward Gray, 293 Beacon, Boston. Samuel E. Guild, 60 Devonshire, Boston. P. O. Box 1861. Frank R. Hall, 39 Court, Boston. Robert S. Hall, 57 High, Charlestown. Asa G. Hapgood, 34 Equitable Building, Boston. Frank Hasbrouck, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. Ralph W. Hickox, Cleveland, O. Edwin N. Hill, 30 Court, Boston. Henry E. Hill, Worcester. Leander Holbrook, Jr., Milford. Arthur Holland, Pittsburgh, Pa. Lucius L. Hubbard, 142 Huntington Ave., Boston. Peter Hulme, 46 Market, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. Edward W. Hutchins, 39 Sears Building, Boston. Dr. Marcello Hutchinson, Lunatic Hospital, Taunton. Merton S. Keith, Quincv. Camillus G. Kidder, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Charles R. Lawrence, 44 High, Charlestown. Lewis C. Ledyard, 6Q Wall, New York, N. Y. f3PAlbert L. Lincoln, Jr., 209 Washington, Boston. Arthur Lord, Plymouth. William B. Lord, 607 Louisiana Ave., Washington, D. C, William C. Loring, 50 State, Boston. Dr. Ernest P. Miller, Fitchbur^ f * Arthur Mills, B. & A. R. R. General .Traffic Manager, Boston. 45 [1873

R. W. Montague, White Sulphur Springs, Greenbrier Co., W. Va. Henry A. Muhlenberg, 520 Washington, Reading, Pa. Dr. Joseph W. Palmer, Fitchburg. L. H. Parkhurst, 152 Tremont, Boston. Chickering Piano Co. Charles F. Pouslaud, Revere Sugar Refinery, East Cambridge. Joseph Rawson, Jr., Cincinnati, O. John F. Richardson. Lawrence D. Rumsey, Buffalo, N. Y. Charles H. Russell, 2 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Edward B. Russell, 81 Milk, Boston. Frank H. Sawyer, Bulletin Editorial Rooms, San Francisco, Cal. Pierre C. Severance, 53 Brattle, Boston. Prof. Edward S. Sheldon, 27 Hurlburt, Cambridge. Edward C. Sherburne, 20 Canal, Boston. Henry St. J. Smith, 75 Spring, Portland, Me. Philip S. Stone, 95 Milk, Boston. Ralph Stone, 24 West Seneca, Buffalo, N. Y. Herman F. Straw, Manchester, N. H. Jeremiah J. Sullivan, Watertown. Charles S. Thornton, 143 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Dr. George H. Tilden, 122 Marlborough, Boston. Charles H. Titus, 147 Power, Providence, R. I. P. O. Box 1544. Rev. Floyd W. Tomkins, Jr., Christ Church, Hartford, Conn. Charlemagne Tower, Jr., 243 S. 18th, Philadelphia, Pa. Eugene Treadwell, 335 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Alanson Tucker, 48 Franklin, Boston. P. O. Box 3402. Prof. John F. Tufts, Wolfville, N. S. Sidney F. Tyler, 201 S. 15th, Philadelphia, Pa. Edward E. Waters, Sandwich. Rev. Thomas F. Waters, Ipswich. Dr. George W. West, 70 Chestnut, Boston. Frank S. Wheeler, Union Club, Chicago, 111. Moses P. White, 47 Devonshire, Boston. Charles A. Williams, 18 Post-Office Sq., Boston. Louis A. Wyman, 36 Tudor, Lynn. James H. Young, 38 Sears Building, Boston.

Charles D. Adams, 23 Court, Boston. Lowell D. Allen, Manchester, N. H. Elgin A. Angell, Mercantile Bank B'ld., Cleveland, O. Frederick F. Ayer, Mills Building, New York, N. Y. L. H. Babcock, 15 Broad, New York, N. Y. Thomas W. Baldwin, 1 Exchange Block, Bangor, Me. William T. Barker, 220 Devonshire, Boston. Charles E. Batchelder, Portsmouth, N. H. James A. Beatley, 57 Shurtleff, or 11 Wabon, Roxbury. Dr. William A. Bell, Somerville. Edward D. Bettens, 30 Broad, New York, N. Y. F. H. Bigelow, Naut. Almanac Office, Washington, D. C. or Concord. Edward P. Bliss, 86 Franklin, Boston. 1873] 46

Dr. John Bryant, Cohasset. C. P. E. Burgwyn, 905£ E. Main, Richmond, Ya. Harry Burnett, 27 Central, Boston. Charles P. Button, Greene & Button Co., Milwaukee, Wis. Rev. William F. Cheney, Dedham. Alfred G. Church, Meadville, Pa. Henry S. Cram, Knickerbocker Club, New York, N. Y. James G. Crosswell, 1280 Park Ave., New York, N. Y. Tucker Daland, 27 Kilby, Boston. R. A. B. Dayton, 322 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Edward S. Dodge, 87 Milk, Boston. J. C. Dodge, 37 Rue Thiers, Rouen, France. W. B. H. Dowse, 87 Milk, Boston. William L. Eaton, Concord. John A. Estabrooks, 180 Federal, Boston. Dr. Oliver H. Everett, 51 Pearl, Worcester. Frederick G. Fincke. Lyman B. Fiske, 58 Chestnut, Charlestown. Dr. W. J. G. Fogg, 481 Broadway, South Boston. Frederick P. Forster, 58 Wall, New York, N. Y. Alfred D. Foster, 87 Milk, Boston. Rev. Francis H. Foster, Theological Sem., Oberlin, O. Dr. Samuel W. French, 1216 Grand Ave., Milwaukee, Wis. Dr. Jos. E. Garland, Gloucester. Frank E. Gavin. Care Miller & Gavin, Greensburg, Ind. Charles N. Goodrich, 75 State, Room 12, Boston. Robert Grant, 54 Devonshire, Boston. Rev. William M. Groton, Westerly, R. I. Elisha Gunn, Jr., Springfield. Rev. Henry H. Haynes, 36 Wallace, Cambridge. Walter C. Hill, 38 E. 10th, New York, N. Y. Dr. O. T. Howe, Lawrence. Frank A. Hubbard, 14 Main, Taunton. Henry G. Hubbard, Crescent City, Fla. Rev. Edmund C. Ingalls, Saco, Me. James F. Jackson, Fall River. Rev. George H. Johnson, Georgetown. John W. Johnson, 194 Main, Woburn. F. P. Jones. Care Pickering & Co., 8 Exchange PL, Boston. Frederick Kebler, 1 Masonic Temple, Cincinnati, O. Clarence E. Kelley, P. O. Box 854, Haverhill. Dr. Henry S. Kilby, North Attleboro'. W. A. Kingsbury, South Framingham. James L. Laughlin, 626 Chestnut, Philadelphia, Pa. William C. Lawton, 28 Mellen, Cambridge. Isaac N. Lewis, 87 Devonshire, Boston. Charles K. Lexow, 39 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Rev. James Otis Lincoln, St. Luke's Rectory, Troy, N. Y. Rev. William J. Lloyd, 130 Spring, Sing Sing, N. Y. Rev. Arthur H. Locke. Care U. S. Consul, Hankow, China. Eliot Lord, Advertiser office, Boston. George H. Lyman, Jr., 50 State, Boston. 47 [1874

Prof. Silas M. Macvane, Cambridge. Austin A. Martin, 27 Dudley, Roxbury. Thomas S. Miller, Dallas, Texas. Prof. Charles S. Moore, Garden City, N. Y. Clarence B. Moore, Phila. Club, 1301 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Samuel L. Morison, 88 Liberty, New York, N. Y. John Murdoch, Smithsonian Inst., Washington, D. C. Rufus W. Nason, Great Falls, N. H. E. B. Nelson, Inst, for Deaf Mutes, Rome, Oneida Co., N. Y. James Olmsteacl, 85 Devonshire, Boston. Herbert I. Ordway, 60 Franklin, Boston. Rev. Louis S. Osborne, Trinity Rectory, Chicago, 111. Charles H. Otis, 189 Montague, Brooklyn, N. Y. J. Frank Paul, 17 State, Boston. H. R. Penclery, Leadville, Colo. Gilbert A. A. Pevy, 5 Tremont, Boston. Dudley L. Pickman, 10 Tremont, Boston. Charles A. Pitkin, South Braintree. Joseph Vila Prichard. Charles A. Prince, 13 Exchange, Boston. William A. Purrington, 63 Wall, New York, N. Y. Elbridge D. Rancl, Burlington, Iowa. Walter Raymond, 296 Washington, Boston. Ambrose C. Richardson, 213 Allen, Buffalo, N. Y. Dr. M. H. Richardson, corner of Charles and Beacon, Boston. Charles Theodore Russell, Jr., 27 State, Boston. J. O. Shaw, Jr., 27 State, Boston. Dr. J. M. Shehan, Quincy. Frank B. Shepley, Fitchburg R. R. Office, Boston. George L. Shorey, Lynn. John F. Simmons, Abington. Freeman Snow, Cambridge. Dr. Frederick D. Stackpole, 118 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Henry B. Stone, Office C. B. & Q. R. R., Chicago, 111. Frederick W. Story, 215 North Charles, Baltimore, Md. Rev. Joseph S. Swaim, 225 Front, Binghampton, N. Y. M. H. Swett, Court Square, Boston, Thomas N. Swift, University Club, New York, N. Y. Charles F. Tarbell, Lincoln. William Thomas, 206 Sansome, San Francisco, Cal. A. H. Thompson, University Club, New York, N. Y. Frederick B. Townsend, 145 La Salle, Chicago. Edward P. Usher, 23 Court, Boston. George G. Walbach, Scituate. Grant Walker, 17 Merchants' Row, Boston. iyArthur L. Ware, Milton. Thomas B. Warren, P. O. Box 1164, Springfield. Rev. Alfred F. Washburn, 766 Fourth, South Boston. Thomas R. Watson, Plainville, Rooks Co., Kan. Edward R. Wharton, 127 Beacon, Boston. George R. Wheelock, 209 Washington, Boston. Prof. H. S. White, Cornell University, Ithaca, N. Y. 1873] 48

Henry Whittemore, University Club, New York, N. Y. George D. Wildes, 19 Doane, Boston. David W. Williams, 42 Court, Boston. Dr. R. W. Willson, 64 Brattle, Cambridge. 1874.

James L. Abbot, Jr., Dorgan & Abbot, Mobile, Ala. William F. Abbot, 26 William, Worcester. Richard M. Allen, Ames, Nebraska. Francis E. Babcock, 10 E. Brookline, Boston. Rev. Walter Baker, 321 Garrard, Covington, Ky. Dr. Charles P. Bancroft, Concord, N. H. Harry H. Barrett, P. O. Box 383, Maiden. George Bendelari, Cambridge. Thomas S. Bettens, 112 E. 57th, New York, N. Y. Woodbury Blair, 39 Corcoran Building, Washington, D. C. George Andrew Blaney, 209 Washington, Boston. Erastus Brainerd. Care The Press, Philadelphia, Pa. Dr. John W. Brannan, 54 W. 11th, New York, N. Y. George R. Briggs, Plymouth. John C. Brinsmade, Washington, Litchfield Co., Conn. Alexander P. Browne, 82 Water, Boston. Dr. Charles T. Buffum, 12 E. 28th, New York, N. Y. Henry M. Burdett, Ellsworth, Kansas. William A. Burnham, 40 Water, Boston. William Burry, 218 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Thomas Cary, 184 Delaware Ave., Buffalo, N. Y. Edward W. Cate, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Rev. George H. Cate, Cheboygan, Mich. Henry A. Chisholm, 142 Huntington, Cleveland, O. Arthur B. Clapp. Care Dr. H. C. Clapp, 11 Columbus Sq., Boston. Henry A. Clark, 704 State, Erie, Pa. Louis C. Clark, Clark, Dodge & Co., 51 Wall, New York, N. Y.

C. C. Clarke. Care Comm'r of Customs Serv., Shanghai, China, o: 35 Concord Ave., Cambridge. Samuel B. Clarke, Root & Clark, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. George O. G. Coale, 85 Water, Boston. Frederic K. Collins, 626 Euclid Ave., Cleveland, O. Thomas Corlies, 90 Joralemon, Brooklyn, N. Y. Henry H. Crocker, Jr., 51 W^all, New York, N. Y. Frederic Cunningham, 30 Court, Boston. Frederick S. Cutter, 273 Harvard, Cambridgeport. Paul Dana, The Sun, 168 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Richard H. Dana, 30 Court, Boston. A. Lithgow Devens, 4 Post-Office Sq., Boston. N. H. Dole. Care T. Y. Crowell & Co., 65 Kingston, Boston. George B. Dorr, 18 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Dr. James Dwight, 225 Beacon, Boston. Louis Dyer. Care G. M. Carnothan, 19 Nassau, New York. Dr. John W. Elliot, 75 Marlborough, Boston. F. W. Elwood, 25 Elwood Memorial Building, Rochester, N. Y. Dr. John W. Farlow, 234 Clarendon, Boston. 49 [1874

J. Hamilton Farrar, 45 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Gen. Francis C. Faulkner, Lock Box Q, Keene, N. H. Prof. Ernest F. Fenollosa, Imperial Univ., Tokio, Japan. Dr. Edward M. Ferris, Longwood Ave., Brookline. Dr. George R. Fessenden, Ashfield, Franklin Co. Prof. B. W. Flagg, Pierce Christ. Coll., College City, Colusa Co., Cal. Dr. Frank B. Flanders, 283 Essex, Lawrence. Arthur W. Foote, 2 W. Cedar, Boston. H. Waldo Forster. Care Heury Forster & Co., Pernambuco, Brazil. Dr. William W. Gannett, 274 Marlborough, Boston. Arthur L. Goodrich, 6 Linden, Salem. W. Goodwin, Kings Co. Elev. R'y, 15 Broad, New York, N. Y. Henry R. Grant, 5 Mt. Yernon PL, Boston. r Ulysses S. Grant, Salem Centre, Westchester Co., N. Y . Dr. Charles M. Green, 78 Marlborough, Boston. Samuel B. Griffith, Mercer, Pa. Herbert L. Harding, 89 State, Boston. George I. Haven, Avondale, Cincinnati, O. W. D. Haynie, Rapid City, S. Dakota. Edward Higgiuson, Fall River. Edward B. Hill, 58 Wall, New York, N. Y. A. G. Hodges, Frederic Taylor 4 Co., 84 Broadway, New York. N. D. C. Hodges, 47 Lafayette PL, New York, N. Y. Thomas M. Honeywell, Oil City, Pa. Rev. Adoniran J. Hopkins, Georgetown. William D. Hunt, 308 Beacon, Boston. Jesse C. Ivy, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Walter I. Jones, Union Club, Boston. • A. M. Keith, Keith & Thompson, Minneapolis, Minn. Box 290. James Lawrence, Groton. Frederick Lawton, 45 Central, Lowell. William S. Leland, 27 School, Boston. Rev. Joel M. Leonard, 10 North, Salem. James D. Lowell, Schenectedy, N. Y. Herbert W. Lull, Milford. Frank Lyman, 50 Remsen, Brooklyn. Michael J. McCann, 246 W. 22d, New York, N. Y. Gifford H. G. McGrew, 11^ Wallace, Cambridge. Wm. G. McMillan. Care J. W. Carson, 121 Dodge, Cleveland, O. William S. Marston, 1021 N. Calvert, Baltimore, Md. Dr. William, C. Mason, 132 Hammond, Bangor, Me. Edwin G. Merriam, Equitable Building, St. Louis, Mo. H. F. Merrill. Care Comm'r of Customs Serv., Shanghai, China. Henry C. Merwin, 40 Water, Boston. Ethelbert S. Mills, 150 Montague, Brooklyn, N. Y. Dr. James J. Minot, 188 Marlborough, Boston. Dr. Henry L. Morse, 112 Malborongh, Boston.

H. B. Morse. Care Comm'r of Customs Serv. , Shanghai, China. William L. Morse, 207-213 Lincoln, Marlborough. Theodore W. Moses. The Benedick, 80 Washington Sq. E., New York. Henry S. Mudge. Care William Minot, Jr., 39 Court, Boston. Dr. Richard C. Newton, Fullerton Ave., Montclair, N. J. Rev. Wm. I. Nichols, 1920 Mt. Vernon, Philadelphia, Pa. 1874] 50

John Parsons, 1121 17th, Denver, Colo. John S. Pattou, 31 School, Boston. Charles S. Penhallow, 32 Sears Building, Boston. William M. Perkins, 50 Sever, Charlestown. Marshall L. Perrin, Wellesley Hills. Edward G. Peters. Care E. D. Peters, 19 Central, Boston, Arthur H. Pickering, 61 Dudley, Roxbury. William T. Piper, 179 Brattle, Cambridge. Dr. Sylvester Primer, Friends School, Providence, R. I. F. E. Randall, Aldrich Ct., 11-15 Broadway, New York, N. Y. r Dr. Huntington Richards, The Allston, 19 E. 38th, New Y ork. William R. Richards, 27 State, Boston. George C. Richardson, 69 Mitchell Building, Milwaukee, Wis. Rev. William Richmond, Orange Valley, N. J. George Riddle, 6 Arrow, Cambridge. Arthur L. Rives, 1723 I, Washington, D. C. Rev. Henry B. Roberts, West Hartford, Conn. Calvin P. Sampson, 27 School, Boston. lyGeorge P. Sanger, Jr., 201 Beacon, or 113 Devonshire, Boston. William Gary Sanger, 10 Montague Terrace, Brooklyn, N. Y. Robert W. Sawyer, Bangor, Me. David Sears, 86 Beacon, Boston. Edmund H. Sears, 233 Marlborough,' Boston. Theodore L. Sewatl, 343 No. Penn., Indianapolis, Ind. Dr. George C. Shepard, El Cajon, San Diego Co., CaL George S. Silsbee, 10 Water, Boston. Edward E. Simmons. Care Prof. James B. Thayer, Cambridge. Robert A. South worth, 48 Congress, Boston. W. F. Spinney. CareComm'r of Customs Serv., Shanghai, China. Charles W. Stone, 68 Chestnut, Boston. Edwin P. Stone, 33 High, Boston. Frederick J. Stone, 32 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Henry Straus, 7 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. Frederick Swift, New Bedford. C. S. Tnckerman, office A. T. & S. F. R. R. Co., 95 Milk, Boston. Columbus T. Tyler, 121 Boylston, Boston. H. Blake Tyler, 201 S. 15th, Philadelphia, Pa. AVilliam R. Tyler, Adams Academy, Quiney. Frederick O. Vaille, Lexington. G. Willett Van Nest, 62 Wall, New York, N. Y". Dr. Edward W. Walker, 96 W. 8tb, Cincinnati, O. William P. Warner, 35 Congress, Boston. E. W. Wellington, Wellington & Brunclage, Ellsworth, Kan. Frank T. Wendell, Wendell, Fay & Co., 37 Franklin, Boston. Dr. W. A. Wheeler, Room 25, P. O. Building, Buffalo, N. Y. George W. White. 48 Congress, Boston. Edward L. Whitehouse, Augusta, Me. George Wigglesworth, 89 State, Boston. Dr. Charles F. Withington. 255 Warren, Roxbury. David L.Withington, 26-29 Pierce-Morse Block, San Diego, CaL Dr. Samuel B. Woodward, 58 Pearl, Worcester. John P. Wyman, Jr., 30 Court, Boston. Dr. S. Edwin Wyman, 2 Mt. Auburn, Cambridge. 51 [1875

Alpheus B. Alger, Mt. Vernon, Cambridge. Francis R. Appleton, 5 Bond, New York, N. Y. John H. Appleton, 23 Court, Boston. Dr. Gorharn Bacon, 63 W. 54th, New York, N. Y. Dr. Jonas E. Bacon, Brockton. Edward D. Baldwin, Newton. Rev. Arthur H. Barrington, Watutum, Dakota. Charles F. Barstow, 79 Worcester, Boston. Joseph N. Baxter, 40 King Block, Denver, Colo. Edward R. Benton, Newton Centre, Rev. George H. Bird, P. O. Box 40, So. Chicago, 111. Dr. Vincent Y. Bowclitch, 113 Boylston, Boston. Prof. Le Baron R. Briggs, Cambridge. Dr. Henry W. Broughton, 94 Green, Jamaica Plain. Willard Brown, 195 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Henry G. Browne, Columbus, Ga. Henry H. Buck, Boston. Dr. William N. Bullard, 89 Marlborough, Boston. Paul Butler. Care B. F. Butler, Lowell. W. T. Campbell Adams Academy, Quincy. George F. Canfielcl, 48 Wall, New York, N. Y. Edwin L. Carney, Leavenworth, Kan. Frank Carter, North Woburn. Lester W. Clark, New Brighton, Staten Island, N. Y. Charles W. Coffin, Jamaica Plain. Frederick R. Comee, Music Hall, Boston. Rev. John W. Craig, St. John's Military School, Manlius, N. Y, Simon G. Croswell, 40 Water, Boston. Hon. Benjamin R. Curtis, 34 Newbury, or Court House, Boston. James Dana, Jr., Topeka, Kan. Francis Dumaresq, 223 Beacon, Boston. Frank H. Eaton, Truro, N. S. Dr. Edward P. Elliot, Danvers Lunatic Hospital. Arthur B. Ellis, 106 Marlborough, Boston. Ellius A. Emerson, Haverhill. Dr. William C. Emerson, 5 Somerset, Boston. Gorham P. Faucon, Lincoln, Neb. Thomas C. Felton, 92 Brattle, Cambridge, William S. Fenollosa. Jesse W. Fewkes, Museum of Comp. Zoology, Cambridge. Frederick P. Fish, 40 Water, Boston. Andrew Fiske, 10 Tremont, Boston. Albert S. Flint, Washburn Observatory, Madison, Wis. Franklin P. Foulkes. Nathaniel L. Frothingham, 5 Tremont, Boston. George G. Gammans, Portland, Ore. Frank Scott Gerrish, 6 Deering PL, Portland, Me. Dr. Frederick S. Gould. Reginald Gray, 1 Beacon Hill PL, or 60 Devonshire, Boston. William M. Griswold, 25 Craigie, Cambridge. 1875] 52

Francis B. Gummere, Haverforcl College P. 0., Pa. Frederick J. Ham, 295 Dudley, Roxbury. Nathauiel S. Hart, Fitchburg. Walker Hartwell, corner 3d and Maine, Cincinnati, 0. Augustus Hemenway, 10 Tremont, Boston. Edward E. Hobart, Plymouth. George B. Hobart, Plymouth. John W. Holcombe, Indianapolis, Ind. Rev. William H. Holman, Southport, Conn. Franklin W. Hooper, 71 St. James PL, Brooklyn, N. Y. Sewall H. Hooper, 28 State, Boston. Henry S. Hunuewell, 9 Park, Boston. Rev. James O. S. Huntington, cor. Ave. C and 4th, New York. W. Lkyyd Jeffries, 78 Devonshire, Boston. William A. Jeffries, 78 Devonshire, Boston. Charles R. Johnson, P. O. Box 492, Worcester. Lyman C. Josephs, P. O. Box 1011, Newport, R. I. Charles R. Judson, Oswego, N. Y. John F. Kent, Concord, N. H. Rev. Reuben Kidner, 16 Brimmer, Boston. Wallace L. Kimball, Bradford. W. Frederick Kimball, 70 Bellingham, Chelsea. Frederick G. King, Messrs James G. King's Sons, New York. E. M. Kingsbury, N. Y. Sun, Nassau and Frankfort, New York. Herbert D. Kingsbury, Newtonville. John C. Lane, 28 State, Boston. Charles F. Lighthipe, Orange, N. J. Joseph P. Livermore, 11 Everett, Cambridge. Woodbury Lowery, 637 F, Washington, D. C. Nathan Matthews, Jr., 23 Court, Boston. William H. Melville, San Francisco, Cal. Henry S. Milton, 32 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Dr. Clifford Mitchell, 70 State, Chicago, 111. P. O. Box 578. Dr. George H. Monks, 143 Boylston, Boston. Rev. Richard Montague, Colorado Springs, Col. Joseph D. Morgan, 2 W. 62d, New York, N. Y. Grenville H. Norcross, 9 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. James S. O'Callaghau. Rev. Edmund Q. S. Osgood, Grafton. Rev. Theodore C. Pease, Maiden. Dr. Lewis H. Plimpton, Norwood. William L. Porter, Adirondack, AVarren Co., N. Y. Puvau Poultney, 801 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. Henry Preble. Care Dr. Wallace Preble, Cambridge. William P. Preble, Jr., 237 Broadway, N. Y. Dr. Morton H. Prince, 71 Marlborough, Boston. Manley A. Raymond, 156 Broadway, New York, N. Y. fyWarren A. Reed, Brockton. Homer B. Richardson, 29 Thomas, New York, N. Y. George R. R. Rivers, 53 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Frank R. Rix, 32 P. O. Building, Lowell. Denman W* Ross, 24 Craigie, Cambridge. 53 [1876

Frederic R. Sears, 122 Beacon, Boston. Thomas E. Secor. Francis Shaw, New Braintree, or 1 Joy, Boston. Arthur B. Silsbee, 68 Chauncey, Boston. Hamilton I. Smith, 146 Brooks, East Boston. Nathaniel H. Stone, 30 Sears Building, Boston. Rev. Charles E. Stowe, Hartford, Conn. Francis S. Sturgis, 70 St. James Ave., Boston.

T Ernest Szemelen} i, Patent-Office Library, Washington, D. C. Nelson Taylor, Jr., 740 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Thomas F. Taylor, 31 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Albert S. Thayer, 62 Wall. New York, N. Y. Charles A. Tomes. Dr. William W. Townsend, Patent-Office, Washington, D. C. Henry S. Van Duzer, 31 Nassau, New York, N. Y. William H. Wadsworth, Jr., Maysville, Ky. Dr. George L. Walton, 6 Beacon, Boston. Samuel D. Warren, Jr., 60 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Frank S. Watson, Milton. Henry B. Wenzell, St. Paul, Minn. Charles W. Wetmore, 206 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Joseph Wilby, 22 Carlisle Building, Cincinnati, O. Dr. Harold Williams, 225 Marlborough, Boston. William H. Williamson, Delhi, Hamilton Co., O. Edmund R. Willson, 65 Westminster, Providence, R. I. Rev. Charles J. Wood, Lockhaven, Pa. Walter Woodman, 106 State, Portland, Me.

Daniel W. Abercrombie, Worcester. Harcourt Amory, 40 Water, Boston. Daniel C. Bacon, Laramie City, Wyoming Ter. Thurlow Weed Barnes, 4 Park, Boston. Charles H. Barrows, Springfield. Charles J. Bell, Johns Hopkins Univ., Baltimore, Md. Marcus P. Bennett, Placerville, El Dorado Co., Cal. John K. Berry, 51 Sears Building, Boston. Edward Bicknell, 43 Somerset, Boston. Rev. Samuel McCully Black, Amherst, N. S. Joel C. Bolan, 23 Monument, Charlestown. John F. Botume, 175 Tremont, Boston. Henry S. Boutell, First National Bank Building, Chicago, 111. Alfred Bowditch, 28 State, Boston. Robert S. Bradley, 27 Kilby, Boston. William M. Bradley, 48 Exchange, Portland, Me. Henry H. Brown, 1805 Pine, Philadelphia, Pa. William A. Brownlow, 14 Perry, Cambridgeport. Dr. James H. Billiard, Anaheim, Cal. Rev. William H. Burbank, Brunswick, Me. Frank W. Burnham, Chiloway, Delaware Co., N. Y. Dr. Frank W. Chapin, Health Department, New York, N. Y. 1876] 54

Frank E. Chase, P. O. Box 2846, Boston. jyWilliam L. Chase, 233 State, Boston. Dr. James E. Cleaves, Medford. William B. S. Clymer, Channing, Cambridge. Walter Stow Collins, 171 B'way, New York, N.Y., orEnglewood, N. J. Richard S. Culbreth, 551 Entaw PI., Baltimore, Md. George M. Gumming, 1605 Dodge, Omaha, Neb. Ralph W. Curtis, Munroe & Co., Paris. Simon Davis, 277 Beacon, Boston. Dr. William Davis, 409 Laurel Ave., St. Paul, Minn. Lafayette H. DeFriese, 205 Gresham House, Old Broad, London, Eng. Rev. Charles A. Dickinson, Boston. Loren G. Du Bois, Room 5, 68 Devonshire, Boston. William F. Duff, 56 Equitable Building, Boston, or Auburndale. A. J. Eaton. Arthur S. Eddy, Gorham Rogers & Co., 20 Federal, Boston. George H. Eldridge, U. S. Geological Survey, Washington, D. C. Dr. Harold C. Ernst, Greenough Ave, Jamaica Plain. Henry T. Finck. Care N. Y. Evening Post, New York, N. Y. Samuel T. Fisher, 1415 N, N. W., Washington, D. C. James H. Flint, 28 State, Boston. Robert H. Gardiner, 40 State, Boston, or Chestnut Hill. J. Edward Giles, 127 E. 16th, New York, N. Y. John G. Gopsill, Jersey City, N. J. William H. Gove, Post-Office Building, Salem. Dr. Egbert H. Grandin, 109 E. 54th, New York, N. Y. George W. Green, 11 Pine, New York, N. Y. Herbert Green, 123 Livingston, Brooklyn, N. Y. Frederick L. Greene, Greenfield. Emor H. Harding, 4 Post-Office Sq., Boston. Azariah B. Harris, Connecticut River R. R., Springfield. Edmund P. Harrison, 139 Walnut, Cincinnati, O. Roe Hasbrouck. Holmes Hinkley, 19 Ware, Cambridge. D. Blakely Hoar, Brookline. Rockwood Hoar, Worcester. Henry D. B. Hobson, Wiscasset, Me. John C. Holman. Horace Nathaniel Hooper, Boston. Charles Isham, 93 Gold, New York, N. Y. George B. Ives, Salem. Oscar R. Jackson, Repanno Chemical Works, Chester, Pa. George £). Jacobs, 28 State, Room 27, Boston. Dr. Henry P. Jaques, Milton. Steven H. Jecko, General Land Office, Washington, D. C. Glidden W. Joy, 461 West Newton. W. M. Kendall. Care McKinn, Mead & White, 57 B'way, New York, Frederic H. Kidder, 82 Devonshire, Bostou. William F. Kip, 298 Main, Buffalo, N. Y. Samuel D. Kittredge, Peekskill, N. Y. Elliot Cabot Lee, 40 State, Boston. Rev. Willis D. Lelancl, North Wevmouth. 55 [1876

Frank S. Livingood, 536 Court, Reading, Pa. George A. Long. Care Florida Southern R. R., Interlacken, Fla. Alexander W. Longfellow, 6 Beacon, Boston. Francis C. Lowell, 35 Congress, Boston. Percival Lowell, 40 Water, Boston. Frederick C. McDuffie, Everett Mills, Lawrence. Daniel C. McMartin, Des Moines, la. Leonard J. Manning, College Hill. Philippe B. Marcou, Wilhelmstrass 118, Berlin, Germany. William Mason, Taunton. Hiram R. Mills, P. O. Box 474, Hartford, Conn. William H. Moody, Haverhill. Frank H. Morgan, LeRoy, N. Y. William R. Morse, 94 High, Charlestown. Arthur St. John Newbury, 113 Superior, Cleveland, O. George A. Nickerson, 85 Milk, Boston. John B. Olmsted, Pitts Agric. Works, Buffalo, N. Y. Drawer 164. William R. Page, Rutland, Vt. Dr. Cyrus T. Peckham, Memphis, Tenn. Prof. B. O. Peirce, 38 Jefferson Phys. Lab., Cambridge. Rev. George S. Pine, Marlborough. Rev. S. Allen Potter, 259 Warren, Roxbury. David J. Richards, E. Steuben, N. Y. William P. Richards, 44 Court, Boston. William C. Riggs, 29 Wall, New York, N. Y. Alden Sampson, University Club, New York, N. Y. George A. Sargent, 46 Chestnut, Boston. Henry Sargent, Pakachoas; Mill, Worcester. David T. Seligman, 2 E. 46th, New York, N. Y. Samuel Sherwood. Thomas H. Silver, Wellsville, O. Frank H. Sleeper, 12 S. Market, Boston. Edward Stetson, 55 W. Market Sq., Bangor, Me. Milan F. Stevens, 62 Devonshire, Boston. Charles W. Stickney. Sumner B. Stiles, 71 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Frederick J. Stimson, Dedham. Dr. Charles P. Strong, 1 Exeter, Boston. Thomas L. Talbot, 48^ Exchange, Portland, Me. Nathan A. Taylor, 47 Faneuil Hall Market, Boston. Newell A. Thompson, 70 Kilby, Boston. Alonzo L. Thomsen, P. O. Box 557, Baltimore, Md. Rev. Charles F. Thwing, Minneapolis, Minn. Arthur B. Twombly, 33 E. 55th, New York, N. Y. James A. Tyng, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Eugene Wambaugh, Iowa City, Iowa. S. G. Ward. Care Kidder, Peabody & Co., New York, N. Y. Charles E. Ware, Jr., Fitchburg. William F.'Weld, 81 Mason Building, Boston. Francis L. Wellman, 2 Tyron Row, New York, N. Y. Alfred A. AYheeler, Lakeport, Lake Co., Cal, Edmund M. Wheelwright, 6 Beacon, Boston. 1876] 56

John T. Wheelwright, 39 Court, Boston. Rev. Theodore C. Williams, 117 E. 36th, New York, N. Y. John F. Win slow, University Club, Cincinnati, 0. Dr. Charles B. Witherlee, 553 Washington, St. Paul, Minn.

Grafton St. L. Abbott, 28 State, Boston. Dr. Gardner W. Allen, 92 Charles, Boston. Francis G. Allinson, 2127 Maryland Ave., Baltimore, Md. Rev. Augustine H. Amory, Lawrence. Walter S. Andrews, University Club, Madison Sq., New York. William H. Annan. \ Robert S. Avann, Albion, Mich. David M. Babcock, 7 Haynes Park, Roxbury. Hollis R. Bailey, 30 Court, or 47 Mt. Vernon, Boston. J. A. Baldwin. Care East River Nat. Bank, New York,"N. Y. John R. Baldwin, 10 Curve, Lynn. Charles M. Barnes, 89 State, Boston. Milton H. Barton, Manchester, N. H. Frank A. Bates, Carneiro, Ellsworth Co., Kan. William C. Bates, Canton. Charles J. Berryhill, 104 E. 3d, St. Paul, Minn. Charles S. Bird, East Walpole. Lawrence Bond, 40 Water, Boston, or West Newton. Rev. Alexander T. Bowser, Toronto, Canada. Rev. Charles R. Brown, Newton Theol. Sch., Newton Centre. Dr. F. Tilden Brown, 40 E. 31st, New York, N. Y. Edward P. Bruce, P. O. Box 9, Salem. Melville Bull, Newport, R. I. Hon. Heman M. Burr, 23 Court, Boston. Henry S. Butler, Superior, Wis. Sigourne}r Butler, Quincy, or 23 Court, Boston. James Byrne, 280 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Richard T. Cadbury, 409 Chestnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Henry C. Carney, Leavenworth, Kan. Martin L. Cate, 99 Crawford, Roxbury. Egbert M. Chesley, Bangor, Me. Stedman Willard Clary, Mattapan, or care D. C. Heath & Co., Boston. Charles K. Cobb, 40 Water, Boston. Henry W. B. Cotton, 10 Baldwin, or 15 City Sq., Charlestown. Stanley Cunningham, P. O. Box 1702, Boston. Charles G. Currier, University Club, New York, N. Y. Dr. Hayward W. Gushing, 143 Boylston, Boston. Marshall Cutler, West Medford. Samuel N. Cutler, 567 Atlantic Ave., Boston, or Somerville. Dr. Edward J. Cutter, Leominster. Henry G. Danforth, Rochester, N. Y. Samuel W. Davis, West Newton. Arthur B. Denny, Chestnut Hill. George Dimmock, 61 Sacramento, Cambridge. Frederick F Doggett, 805 Broadway, S. Boston. 57 • [1877

Herbert H. Drake, 3 Broad, New York, N. Y. John L. Du Fais, 400 W. 57th, New York, N. Y. Rev. H, C. Dunham, 9 Farrington PL, Portland, Me., or Denver, Colo. Richard J. Dwyer, Medford. Charles S. Eaton, 99 W. 4th, Cincinnati, O. Howard P. Eells, 167 Kennard, Cleveland, O. Amor}7 Eliot, 70 Kilby, Boston. William Farnsworth, 118 Federal, Boston. Dr. Henry B. Fay, 109 Washington Ave., Minneapolis, Minn. Rev. Matthew J. Fergusson. Arthur O. Fuller, Exeter, N. H. George P. Gardner, 22 Congress, Boston. Rev. James W. Gilman, P. O. Box 116, Hastings, Neb. Rev. Alfred Gooding, Portsmouth, N. H. Hemy Goodrich, Illawara Post-Office, East Carroll Parish, La. James W. Goodwin, Haverhill. Morris Gray, 62 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Robert W. Greenleaf, 241 Boylston, Boston. William F. Hapgood, 154 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Rev. Nathan H. Harriman, Newton Highlands. Robert O. Harris, East Bridgewater. Herbert J. Harwood, 91 Summer, Boston. Robert P. Hastings, Union Club, San Francisco, Cal. Truman Herainway, 70 Broadwa}', New York, N. Y. James R. W. Hitchcock, 19 W. 24th, New York, N. Y. Dr. William D. Hodges, 6 Gloucester, Boston. H. O. Houghton, Jr., Riverside Press, Cambridge. William L. Humason, New Britain, Conn. Freeman Hunt. 3 Pemberton Sq., Boston. George W. Huse, 101 Exchange, Lynn. Anselm H. Jayne, Jackson, Hinds Co., Miss. Thomas W. Kenefick, Palmer. John B. Kevs, Woodburn, Cincinnati, O. ElbridgeG." Kimball. Gardner S. Lamson, 155 Franklin, Boston. Aaron H. Latham, 5 Tremont, Boston. Burton J. Legate, 20 Boylston PL, Boston. Samuel Leland, 2101 Indiana Ave., Chicago, 111. Francis J. LeMoyne, 121 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Edwin N. Lovering, Randolph. A. Lawrence Lowell, 73 Marlborough, or 50 State, Boston. John Lowell, Jr., Chestnut Hill. Samuel A. Lynde, 94 Washington, Chicago, 111. Thomas Macauley, 378 Washington Ave., Newark, N. J. Edward S. Martin, Rochester, N. Y. Robert J. Melledge, Cambridge. James M6tivier, 16 Shepard, Cambridge. Josiah B. Millet, 150 Charles, Boston. Robert S. Minot, 39 Court, Boston. George D. Morrell, 408 S. 2 2d, Philadelphia, Pa. William R. Morris, Neb. Nat. Bank Building. Omaha, Neb. Albert G. Morse, 23 Court, Boston. 1877] 58

George M. Nash, Everett. Henry G. Nichols, 40 Water, Boston. Daniel J. M. O'Callaghan, 32 Liberty, New York, N. Y. George B. Ogden, 7 AY. 28th, or 43 Wall, New York, N. Y. Parker W. Page, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Edmund M. Parker, 5 Craigie, Cambridge. William E. Parmenter, Orange Park, Clay Co., Fla. Jacob C. Patton, Cambridge. Arthur Perrin, 37 Chauncy, Cambridge. Dr. Matthew V. Pierce, Milton. Charles E. Prior, Holbrook. John K. Richards, Ironton, O. Clifford Richardson, Dept. of Agriculture, Washington, D. C. Walter H. Roberts, 48 Congress, Boston. E. Willard Roby, 55 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Frank W. Rollins, Journal of Commerce, New York, N. Y. George Rountree, Kinston, N. C. Frank T. Rusk, Journal of Commerce, New York, N. Y. |yHon. William E. Russell, 174 Brattle, Cambridge. Dr. Godfre}T Ryder, Maiden. Franklin H. Sargent, 42 E. 11th, New York, N. Y. Robert S. Sauzade, 70 Broadway, New York, N. Y. George A. Sawyer, 54 North Ave., Cambridge. Dr. William S. Seamans, 71 E. 55th, New York, N. Y. Thomas F. Sherman, 25 Rutland Sq., Boston. Carroll C. Shippen, 139 N. Charles, Baltimore, Md. Thomas M. Sloane, Sandusky, Erie Co., O. William H. Smiley, New Salem, Franklin Co., or Denver, Colo. Abbot E. Smith. Rev. Daniel E. Smith, 404 N. 38th, W. Philadelphia. Pa. Frank W. Smith, Westfield. Benjamin C. Starr, 8 Blackstone, Cleveland, O. James A. Stiles, P. O. Box 1626, Fitchburg. Maynard F. Stiles, Irwin, Gunnison Co., Colo. Dexter L. Stone, 18 E. 28th, New York, N. Y. Irving Stringham, P. O. Box 100, Berkeley, Cal. Edward H. Strobel, U. S. Legation, Madrid, Spain. Lindsay Swift, Public Library, Boston. Dr. William N. Swift, New Bedford. Gerritt S. Sykes, Walnut Hills, Cincinnati, O. Frank H. Taylor, 4150 Elm Ave., Philadelphia, Pa. William R. Taylor. Edward F. Thomas, Fredouia, Mercer Co., Pa. Francis B. Tiffany, N. Y. Life Ins. Building, St. Paul, Minn. William H. Tillinghast, Harvard College Library, Cambridge. A. Clifford Tower. Care E. Swett & Co., 38 Broad, New York. Rev. William L. D. Twomblv, Brookline. John F. Tj'ler, 5 Tremont, Boston. Charles J. Underwood, Jr., 119 Newbury, Boston. Dr. James W. Walker, Elm, Jamaica Plain, Boston. Herbert I. Wallace, Fitchburg. Dr. Edward W. Warren, 288 Marlborough, Boston. 59 [1878

Edward Wellington, P. O. Box 451, Waltham. Benjamin W. Wells. Care Baring Bros., London, England. Prof. Barrett AYendell, 358 Marlborough, Boston. Dr. Edward G. West, 630 Warren, Roxbury. Sidney Wetmore. Fred. G. Wheeler. Care Gen'l Land Com'r U. P. R. R., Omaha, Neb. Harold Wheeler, 621 Clay, San Francisco, Cal. Joseph E. White, Walnut Hills, Cincinnati, O. Harold Whiting, Waterhouse, Cambridge. W. Austin Whiting, Honolulu, Sandwich Islands. Dr. Herbert B. Whitney. J. Bertram Williams, 787 Main, Cambridge. Jasper N. Willison, Cumberland, Md. Charles H. Wis well, Cambridge. George E. Woodberry, Beverly. Edward Woodman, 85 Exchange, Portland, Me. Andrew Woods. Care Roger Foster, 206 Broadway, New York. Robert H. Worthington, 43 W. 31st, New York, N. Y. Reginald Young, 34 Thomas, New York, N. Y. 1878.

Charles T. Adams, 7 Beekman, New York, N. Y. Richard S. Albert, 310 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. Andrew H. Allen. Care Julian Allen, StatesAdlle, N. C. William E. Allen, P. O. Box 43, Worcester. William Hall Allen. Care Juilliard & Co., 66 Worth, New York. Willis B. Allen, 38 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Edward R. Bacon, Wright's Grove P. O., Chicago, 111. Edwin S. Balch, 1412 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. William A. Bancroft, 5 Putnam Ave., Cambridge. Charles F. Batchelder, 7 Kirkland, Cambridge. William Z. Bennett, Wooster, Wayne Co., O. Frederick O. de Billier, Uva, Wyoming Ter. Charles C. Binney, 218 S. 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. Emmons Blaine, Maryland Club, Baltimore, Md. Lafayette G. Blair, Norwood Park, E. Watertown. Warren K. Blodgett, Jr., Acacia, Cambridge. George K. Boutelle, Waterville, Me. Frank E. Bradish, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Arthur H. Brown, George H. Browne, 8 Garden, Cambridge. William H. Brune, 232 St. Paul, Baltimore, Md. Dr. Howard M. Buck, 127 Marlborough, Boston. Stephen Bullard, 89 Marlborough, Boston. Herbert C. Burdett, 89 White Building, Buffalo, N. Y. Charles A. Catlin. Eugene T. Chamberlain, Argus Office, Albany, N. Y. Charles F. Chamberlayne, 60 Devonshire, Boston. Prof. Edward Channing, 1 Brewster PL, Cambridge. George L. Cheney, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Herbert M. Clarke, Nashotah, Wis. 1878] 60

Edward H. Cobb, 38 Concord Sq., Boston.

7 Charles R. Come} , 577 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Osborne S. Curtis, Isthmian Club, London W., England. Arthur P. Cushing, 12 Haviland, and 5 Court, Boston. Charles Daniels. Howard F. Doane, Crete, Neb. Benjamin H. Dorr, 76 Commercial, Boston. Dr. Franklin A. Dunbar, 14 Highland, Cambridge. Irving Elting, 5& Market, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. Philip V. R. Ely, 60 Devonshire, Bos; on. Zebina A. Gleason, Hazleton, Kan. Henry Goldmark, 32 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Augustus C. Gurnee, 7 Nassau. New York, N. Y. Charles A. Hamilton, Mills Building, New York, N. Y. Lewis Hancock, Austin, Texas. Benjamin F. Harding, Belmont School, Belmont. Rev. J. B. Harding, Broadway and McElderry, Baltimore, Md. Dr. Charles Harrington, 399 Boylston, Boston. Edward R. Hastings, South Weymouth. Rev. Henry C. Hay, Avondale, Cincinnati, O. Rev. Andrew D. Heffern, 1836 Poplar, Philadelphia, Pa. Dr. Parke W. Hewins, Taunton. John R. Holmes, 216 Main, Cincinnati, O. Dr. John Homans, 2d, 184 Marlborough, Boston. Charles W. Hubbard, 284 Devonshire, Boston. Edward B. Hunt, Boston Public Library, Boston. Ernest Jackson. Care P. T. Jackson, Mt. Vernon PL, Boston. Lawrence Jacob, University Club, New York, N. Y. Benjamin N. Johnson, Lynn. Edward F. Johnson, Woburn. Joseph F. Johnson, 291 North Ave., Aurora, 111. Walter Kessler, Dr. Philip C. Knapp, 157 Boylston, Boston. Rosewell B. Lawrence, Medford, or 23 Court, Boston. Rev. John C. Lee, Lombard University, Galesburg, III. Lucius N. Littauer. 578 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. George A. Littlefield, Newport, R. I. Dr. Warren P. Lombard, 49 W. 32d, New York, N. Y. Augustus P. Loring, 22 Congress, Boston. Clinton W. Lucas, 40 Wall, New York, N. Y. Prof. Frederick Lutz, Albion, Mich. Henry B. McDowell, Robert D. McFadon, 183 Rush, Chicago, 111. Dr. Henry G. MacKaye, 128 Mill, Newport, R. I. Harry W. Mason. 31 Milk, Boston. Dr. Julian A. Mead, Watertown. James W. Mercur, 715 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. William S. Miller, 39 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Ogden Mills, 15 Broad, New York, N. Y. Henry W. Montague, 97 Milk, Boston. Charles Moore. Care Detroit Journal, Detroit, Mich. Edward C. Moore, Jr., 293 N. Broadway. Yonkers, N. Y. 61 [1878

John H. Morison, 40 Water, Boston. Edwin W. Morse, 743 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Herbert F. W. Morse, 179 Pearl, Portland, Me. John A. Murray, 238 W. 52d, New York, N. Y. Dr. George W. Nash, Santa Fe Hospital, Ottawa, Kan. Rev. Henry S. Nash, 9 Acacia, Cambridge. Dr. Samuel N. Nelson, 17 St. James Ave., Boston. Edgar H. Nichols, 57 Brattle, Cambridge. Rev. William J. Oliver, Fairbury, Jefferson Co., Neb. Henry B. Osgood, 2 Guild, Roxbury. William S. Otis, 131 Devonshire, Boston. Henry D. Page, 119 Milk, Boston. James Parker, Somerset Club, Boston. Robert F. Patterson, Stoyestown, Somerset Co., Pa. Daniel E. Paullin. George H. Perley, Ottawa, Canada. Edward E. Phillips, Marietta, O. William M. Phillips, John Pickering, 18 Broad, Salem. George M. Pinney, Jr., 55 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Dr. William H. Potter, 254 Warren, Roxbury. Robert J. Hare Powell, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. George H. Preston, Seattle, Washington Ter. George S. Raymer, 63 7th Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. Herbert H. Roberts, 148 Blackstone, Boston. Warren M. Robinson. Care of B. F. Spinney, Lynn. Alfied H. Rogers, Bank of Springfield, Springfield, Mo. Dr. Barney Sachs, 30 W. 59th, New York, N. Y. Thomas J. Sauzade, Englewood, N. J. William H. Scoffer, Charleston High Sch., Charleston, S. C. Rev. Samuel Shepherd, Paul Shorey. Care D. L. Shorey, Portland Block, Chicago, 111. Herbert W. Smyth, Bryn Mawr College, Bryn Mawr, Pa. Edward E. Sparhawk, 142 Seaver, Roxbury. William A. Spinney, West Newton. George H. Stearns, 83 Mason Building, Boston. Rev. William O. Stearns, Cazenovia, N. Y. Dr. Russell Sturgis, 190 Marlborough, Boston. George E. Sturtevant, Accounting Dep'tB. & M. R. R., Bostou. William Sullivan, 5 Pemberton Sq., Boston. David A. Taggart, Manchester, N. H. Dr. Frederick W. Taylor, 141 North Ave., Cambridge. Henry O. Taylor, P. O. Box 203, New York, N. Y. H. PL Teschemacher, Uva, Wyoming Ter. Frederick W. Thayer, 118 Federal, Boston. Nathaniel N. Thayer, 32 India, Boston. Charles B. Trail, Frederick, Md. Bayard Tuckerman, 106 E. 36th, New York, N. Y. Paul Tuckerman, Tuxedo, Orange Co., N. Y. Prof. James A. Tufts, Exeter, N. H. Dr. Herman F. Vickery, 37 Hancock, Boston. Charles H. Vinton, 192 Dartmouth, Boston. 1878] 62

Henry P. Warden, Kingston. Benjamin Welles, Union Club, New York, N. Y. Henry Wheeler, 40 Sears' Building, Boston. &yJoseph C. Whitney, P. O. Box 3573, Boston. Charles K. Williams, Sioux City, Iowa. Dr. Henry A. Wood, Waltham. Dr. Alfred Worcester, Waltham. Gilbert M. Yates, Minneapolis, Minn. Theodore T. Young, Saco, Me. 1879.

Dr. Albert C. Aldrich, 330 Broadway, Somerville. Horace C. Alger, Sheridan, Wyoming Ter.. BF3 Francis Almy, Buffalo, N. Y. Harlan P. Amen, Riverview Academy, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. Clement W. Andrews, 36 Rutland Sq., Boston. Francis W. Anthony, Bradford. H. O. Apthorp, Milton Academy, Milton. Edward H. Atherton, 2 Howland, Roxbur}\ William R. Austin, 21 Pemberton Sq., Boston. George D. Ayers, 56 Sears' Building, Boston. Charles W. Bacon, Natick. Henry Baily. Newton Centre, Box 24. P. T. Barlow, 35 William, New York, N. Y. Waldron Bates, 5 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Edmund L. Baylies, 20 W. 36th, and 66 Wall, New York, N. Y. Samuel C. Bennett, 10 Tremont, Boston. Amos Binney, Walpole. George A. Black, 27 W. 104th, New York, N. Y. Charles H. Blood, 8 Congress, Boston. A. H. Bowen, 44 Pierrepont, Brooklyn, N. Y. Dr. John T. Bowen, 14 Marlborough, Boston. Albert S. Brandeis, 306 3d Ave., Louisville, Ky. Charles O. Brewster, 261 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Frank Brewster, 80 Walnut Ave., Roxbury. Dr. Frederick M. Briggs, 15 Charles, Boston. Rev. Arthur A. Brooks, Greenfield. Arthur C. Brown. Howard K. Brown, Framingham. John A. Brown, Exeter, N. H. Charles C. Burlingham, 45 William, New York, N. Y. 1. Tucker Burr, Jr., 35 Congress, Boston. Rev. George H. Burrill, New Lebanon, Col. Co., N. Y. Middleton S. Burrill, 9 E. 56th, New York, N. Y. Harry Butler, 160 Park, Portland, Me. Arthur A. Carey, Cambridge. Walter Cary, 184 Delaware Ave., Buffalo, N. Y. William B. de las Casas, 40 Water, Boston. William W. Case, 34 Montauk Bank, Chicago, 111. Herman Chapin, 27 Congress, Boston. John M. B. Churchill, 82 Devonshire, Boston. 63 [1879

Robert P. Clapp, 40 Water, Boston. Dr. Joseph P. Cobb, 207 31st, Chicago, 111. Dr. William M. Conant, 252 Newbury, Boston. George F. Cook, Breckenridge, Wilkin Co., Minn. J. T. Cooliclge, 3d, 114 Beacon, Boston. William W. Coolidge, Salem. George T. Coverly, Jr., Maiden. John E. Cowdin, 14 W. 21st, New York, N. Y. Wilmot T. Cox, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Frank L. Crawford, 229 Broadway, New York, N. Y. , Fitchburg. Charles 8. Crosman, Haverford College P. O., Pa. Dr. Francis G. Curtis, Newton Centre. Livingston Cushing, 10 Tremont, Boston. John W. Dalzell, 15 Appian Way, Cambridge. Dr. F. H. Daniels, 126 W. 126th, New York, N.Y. Dr. Samuel Delano, West Medford. Walter D. Denegre, 35 Carondelet, New Orleans, La.

Dr. Frank Donaldson, Jr., 108 Park Ave , Baltimore, Md. Herbert B. Dow, Woburn. Francis De M. Dunn, Needham. M. Grant Edmands, 70 Kilby, Boston, and Marion, Brookline. Frederick H. Ellis, Framingham. Ralph W. Ellis, Springfield. George Faunce, Mansfield VahVy, Allegheny Co., Pa. Edgar C. Felton, Steelton, Dauphin Co., Pa. Dr. J. Arthur Gage, 48 Central, Lowell. Dr. Charles W. Galloupe, 1 Park, Lynn. Warren N. Goddard, 516 Broadway, New York, N. Y. H. W. Grannis. Care Franklin MacVeagh & Co., Chicago, 111. Rev. Edward Hale, 60 W. Rutland Sq., Boston. Charles S. Hanks, 387 Harvard, Cambridge. Louis Harding, 110 Federal, Boston. William B. Harlow, Syracuse, N. Y. Richard Heard, Allerton, Brookline. Samuel Hill, P. O. Box 513, Minneapolis, Minn. Rev. William Bancroft Hill, Athens, N. Y. George Hoadly, Jr., P. O. Box 633, Cincinnati, O. Dr. Andrew H. Hodgdon, Dedham. George Clarendon Hodges, P. O. Box 1907, Boston. Jabish Holmes, Jr., 280 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Thomas J. Homer, 59 Winthrop. Roxbury. Abram Duane Hopkins, Somerville. Samuel H. Hoppin, P. O. Box 3712, New York, N. Y. Rev. Edward L. Houghton, Springfield. Frank A. Houston, 50 Pearl, Boston. William D. Howard, 1355 Wabash Ave., Chicago, 111. William H. Hubbard, 438 La Salle Ave., Chicago, 111. Woodward Hudson, Concord, and 15 State, Boston. Austin Huntington, 165 Broadway, New York, N. Y. AVilliam E. Hutchins. 6 White, North Cambrdge. Rev. Wm. DeW. Hvde, Pres't Bowdoin Coll., Brunswick, Me. 1879] 64

David O. Ives, Rialto Building, Chicago. 111. George W. Jackson, 84 Dudley, Roxbnry, and 31 Milk, Boston. Martin R. Jacobs, 220 Rialto Building, Chicago, 111. Dr. Henry W. Johnson', Berlin Falls, N. H. Webster Kelley, 37 Springfield, Boston. Prescott Keyes, Concord. Charles A. Kidder, P. O. Box 7, Boston. Edward P. Kingsbury, Washington, D. C. Rev. Henry N. Kinney, Winsted, Conn. Walter M. Lancaster, " Spy" Editorial Rooms, Worcester. William B. Lawrence, Med ford. Arthur H. Lee, P. O. Box 481, Scranton, Pa. Tlioinas Lee, 44 State, Boston. Frederick M. Leonard, 119 S. 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. Herman S. LeRoy, Union Club, New York, N. Y. Wallace Macfarlane, 261 Broad wa}', New York, N. Y. Dr. Charles S. Mack, Ann Arbor, Mich. Frank V. McDonald. Care Pacific Bank, San Francisco. Cal. Francis McLennan, 317 Drummond, Montreal, Canada. Edgar H. Madden, 172 La Salle, Chicago. 111. Dr. Francis C. Martin, 27 Dudley, Roxbuiy. Dr. Atherton P. Mason, Fitchburg. Rev. Charles J. Mason, 1630 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Henry C. Mercer, Doylestown, Bucks Co., Pa. George von L. Meyer, Somerset Club, Boston. Dr. George N. Miller, Jr., 39 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. James W. Mitchell, 2 Ashburton PL, Boston. William I. Monroe, 73 Walnut Ave., Roxbury. Dr. John G. Morris, 1474 Washington, Boston. George S. Motley, Lowell. Henry C. Mulligan, Natick. Dr. Herbert W. Newhall, 46 Broad, Lynn. John L. Niehols, 144 State, Boston. J. R. Norton, Ironton, O. C. P. Nunn, 185 Summer, Boston. Charles N. Osgood, 59 Chamber of Com., Minneapolis, Minn. Francis B. Patten, 23 Milk, Boston.

7 Edward C. Perkins, 115 Broadwa} , New York, N. Y. Frederick G. Perry, 6 Hamilton PL, Bo^tou. Albert Poor, 42 Court, Boston. Frank L. Porter, Lawrence. H. W. Hare Powell, 708 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Dr. Wallace Preble, 404 Harvard, Cambridge. Walter C. Prescott, 36 Harvard, Charlestown. T. Webb Preston, 2439 Ogden, Denver, Colo. Earl B. Putnam, P. O. Box 12, Rochester, N. Y. Benjamin Rand, 13 Remington, Cambridge. William M. Richardson, 57 Equitable Building, Boston. Edward Robinson, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Rev. Edward A. Robinson, Hingham Centre. Hiram H. Rose, 162 Washington, Chicago, 111. Thomas Russell, 50 State, Boston. . 65 [1880

Rev. Charles E. St. John, Northampton. Rev. Henry R. Sargent, 226 N. Eutaw, Baltimore, Mel. William Schotield, 10 Tremont, Boston. Edward W. Shannon, 523 Delaware, Kansas City, Mo. William Sheafe, Jr., 383 Washington, Boston. George R. Sheldon, P. O. Box 2062, New York, N. Y. Henry A. Shute, Exeter, N. H. Frank E. Simpson, 7\ Beacon, Boston. Frederick W. Smith, 91 Oliver, Boston, and Dorchester. Dr. Willard Everett Smith, 21 Concord Sq., Boston. Rev. Samuel Snelling, Amherst. Samuel E. Somerby, 138 W. Chester Park, Boston. Charles F. Sprague, 20 Ashburton PL, Boston. Dr. Hayward Stetson, 43 Broadway, Bangor, Me. Marion Story, Knickerbocker Club, 55 W. 26th, New York, N. Y. Francis J. Swayze, Newton, N. J. Jireh Swift, Jr., New Bedford. William H. Sylvester, P. O. Box 15, Newtonville. Herbert Tappan. Prof. Frank W. Taussig, Cambridge. Frederick H. Temple, 234 Bunker Hill, Charlestown. John A. Thayer, Oread Academy, Worcester. James E. Thomas, English High School, Boston. W. B. Thomas, 24 Broad, Boston. John J. Thompson, 2024 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. Joseph G. Thorp, Jr., Brattle, Cambridge. John J. Townsencl, Jr., 131 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. AValter Trimble, 59 E. 25th, New Yrork, N. Y. Larkin T. Trull, 25 Church, Lowell. Alfred S. Tubbs, 613 Front, San Francisco, Cal. William G. Twombley, 3 Rue Tilsitt, Paris, France. Henry O. Underwood, Belmont. David Urquhart. P. Lorrillard & Co., 141 Water, New York, William Bayard Van Rensselaer, 25 North Pearl, Albany, N. Y. John Vaughn, 13 Kendall, Boston. Henry C. W^arren, 67 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Rev. Charles L. Wells, Gardiner, Me. J. Walter Wells. Charles H. Whiting. 32 Bromfielcl, Boston. Rev. Richard T. Wilton, Rindge, N. H. John Eliot Wolff, Story, Cambridge. Stephen B. Wood, 30 Court, Boston. James A. Wright, Jr., 6 Bowling Green, New York, N. Y. 1880. Frederick H. Allen, Knickerbocker Club, New York, N. Y. Russell C. Allen, El Cajon, San Diego Co., Cal. William H. Alley, Sullivan, Ind. fyp^recleric Almy, 24 Law Exchange, Buffalo, N. Y. William S. Andrews, Syracuse, N. Y. Charles E. Atwood, Exeter, N. H. 1880] 66

Egbert Bacon, 28 State, Boston. Dr. Henry C. Baldwin, 172 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Morton Barrows, 126 E. 3d, St. Paul, Minn. Dr. Henry T. Barstow, 62 Bowdoin, Boston. Nathaniel C. Bartlett, Academy of Music, Haverhill. Charles F. T. Beale, Hudson, Columbia Co., N. Y. Gerard Bement, 34 School, Boston. Charles H. Benton, 127 Water, Cleveland, O. Eev. Sherard Billings, Groton. Eobert E. Bishop, Jr., Newton Centre. Herbert P. Bissell, 284 Main, Buffalo, N. Y. Charles B. Blair, Grand Eapids, Mich. William T. Blodgett, Stanton, Neb., or 11 E. 12th, New York. H. L. Bond, Jr., Park Ave., B. & O. Cent. B'ld., Baltimore, Md. Frank H. Brackett. Care Wash. National Bank, Boston. Eussell Bradford, 375 Harvard, Cambridge. A. F. Breed, Jr., Lynn. Clifford Brigham, Salem. Nat. M. Brigham, Omaha, Neb. Louis M. Brown, Glen Falls, N. Y. Dr. Philip T. Buckley, 416 Broadway, South Boston. George M. Butler, Northampton. F. Elliot Cabot, Brookline. Frank 0. Carpenter, 43 Concord Sq., or English High School. Boston. Henry B. Chapin, Boston & Albanj^ E. E., Boston. C. H. Chapman. Hewlett & Shea, Louisiana Ave., AYashington, D. C. Dr. George T. Chase, 269 W. 127th. New York, N. Y. Walter Cole, 87 West Monument, Baltimore, Md. Harvey N. Collison, 5 Tremont, Boston. William H. Cook, 401 California, San Francisco, Cal. Charles S. Davis, Plymouth. Eev. John Doane, 422 Prospect, Cleveland, O. Edwin M. Dodd, 6 \ Exchange PL. Providence, E. I. Frank F. Dodge, Woburn. Jonathan Dwight, Jr., 2 E. 34th, New York, N. Y. Eev. A. W. Eaton, 38 E. 10th, New York, N. Y. Ralph N. Ellis, 20 W. 57th, New York, N. Y. Herbert H. Eustis, East. Elec. Cable Co., 61 Hampshire, Boston. James D. Fessenden, Jr., 38 Park Eow, New York, N. Y. Dr. James B. Field, 243 Westford, Lowell. Charles E. Fish, 66 West, Worcester. Dr. Charles C. Foster, Cambridge. Harold N. Fowler, Exeter, N. H. Henry G. French, P. O. Box 1601, Boston. Dr. Eugene Fuller, 62 W. 35th, New York, N. Y. Eev. Frederic Gardiner. Care W. M. Yaughan, Cragie. Cambridge. William A. Gaston, 177 Marlborough, or 28 School, Boston. James Geddes, Jr., Brookline. J. Henry Gest, Cincinnati. O. Frank M. Gilley, 100 Clark Ave.. Chelsea. Eev. John B. Gilman. Concord. N. H. William W. Gooch. 178 Walnut Ave., Boston Highlands. ,

67 [1880

Louis M. Greely, 116 La Salle, Chicago, 111. George Griswold, Jr., Union Club, 1 W. 21st, New York, N. Y. Arthur Hale, Penn. R. R., 233 S. 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. Arthur L. Hall, Revere. Frederic B. Hall, 57 High, Charlestown. Dr. William Dudley Hall, 11 Park Sq., Boston. Arthur L. Hanscom, South Eliot, Me. Mitchell Harrison, 101 S. Front, Philadelphia, Pa. Prof. Albert B. Hart, Cambridge. Rev. George B. Hatch, Jewett City, Conn. Edward S. Hawes, Garden City, Long Island, New York. Harold G. Henderson, 5 Beekman, New York, N. Y. George A. Hibbard, Buffalo, N. Y. William H. Hills, The Writer, Box 1905, Boston. Fletcher S. Hines, Malott Park, Marion Co., Ind. Charles A. Hobbs, 81 W. River, Wilkes Barre, Pa. William Hooper, 87 Milk, Boston. P. O. Box 5090. John W. Houston. Carter, Hughes & Cravath, 346 Broadway, New James T. Howe, Kenosha, Wis. [York, N. Y. Frank C. Huidekoper, 13 Pearl, Worcester. Arthur Hurst, 385 Clinton Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. Dr. Henry Jackson, 309 Marlborough, Boston. L. H. H. Johnson, 27 Kilby, Boston. Henry C. Jones, , Boston. P^rederick D. Jordan. Francis B. Keene, 294 Greenbush, Milwaukee, Wis. George R. Kelly, 87-89 Portland, Boston. T. D. Kenneson. Carter, Hornblower & B}7 rne, 346 Broadway, New Percy Kent, 60 Front, New York, N. Y. [York, N. Y. Dr. Henry W. Kilburn, 136 Marlborough, Boston. John L. Lamson, 46 Wall, New York, N. Y. Arthur H. Lea, 706 Sansom, Philadelphia, Pa. William P. Learned, Pittstield. James L. Lester, West Newton. Edward H. Lum, 900 Chestnut, Philadelphia, Pa. George W. Merrill, 404 Columbus Ave., Boston. George P. Messervy, 60 State, Boston, or Salem. Andrew Miller, 1155 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Arthur W. Moors. Care J. B. Moors & Co., Boston. Charles Morgan, New Warlaby, Bordentown, N. J.

Sanford Morison. Care K. C. & M. R. R. & Bridge Co. , or 2 Va. Ave. Charles H. Morss, Portsmouth, N. H. [Memphis, Tenn. David Mould, Sioux City, Iowa. Austin K. Muzzey, 639 Main, Buffalo, N. Y. Rev. Thomas W. Nickerson, Jr., Paterson, N. J. Charles P. Norton, Buffalo, N. Y. W. F. O'Callaghan, Grammar School 74, E. 63d, New York. John A. O'Keefe, Lynn. Leonard E. Opdycke, University Club, New York, N. Y. Charles A. Parker, P. O. Box 1368, Boston. George Pellew, Canton. James L. Pennypacker, 1540 N. 15th, Philadelphia, Pa. 1880] 68

Arthur Perry, Westerly, R. I. George M. Perry, 79 E. 124th, New York, N. Y. Herbert M. Perry, New Ipswich, N. H. William A. Pew, Jr., Salem. Ernest H. Pilsbuiy, 154 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Rev. W. F. Price, Madison Ave. Cong. Church, New York. N. Y. Jcsiah Quincy, 66 State, Boston. Frederick J. Ranlett, 34 School, Room 45, Boston. Walter H. Rhett, Atlanta, Ga. William K. Richardson, 40 Water, Boston. , 6 W. 57th, New York, N. Y. Eugene D. Russell, Wakefield. Richard M. Saltonstall, Chestnut Hill. Chester F. Sanger, 23 Court, Boston. Henry W. Savage, 63 Court, Boston. William B. Sharp, 1728 Tyler, San Francisco, Cal. Henry R. Shaw, 1 Joy, Boston.

7 Samuel W. Skinner, 110 Broadwa} , Cincinnati, O. Frederick M. Smith, 90 South Market, Boston. Dr. William S. Stevens, 7 East Newton, Boston. Yandcrlynn Stow, 222 Sutter, San Francisco, Cal. Frank O. Suire, 25 Wiggins Block, Cincinnati, O. William H. Talbott, Talbott Block, Indianapolis, Ind. Arthur Taylor, 209 Washington, Boston. William G. Taylor, 3 Rue Pre aux Clercs, Paris, France. John S. Tebbets, Union Pacific Railway, Omaha, Neb. John J. Thomsen, Jr., 16 German, Baltimore, Md. Howard Townsend. 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Richard Trimble, Cheyenne Club, Cheyenne, Wyoming Ter. Frederic A. Tupper, Shelburne Falls. Bradford S. Turpin, West Yarmouth. John L. Wakefield, 23 Milk, Boston. Dr. Charles Ware, 67 E. 52d, New York, N. Y. Dr. Charles E. Warren, 51 Union Park, Boston. Charles G. Washburn, Worcester. H. Randall Webb, 406 Fifth, Washington, D. C. Albert B. Weimer, 512 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. C. M. Weld, 131 Devonshire, Boston. R. W. G. Welling, University Club, New York, N. Y. Fairfax H. Wheelan, Santa Barbara, Cal. S. Merrick Whitcomb, Tarpan Springs, Fla. F. D. White, Milton. William H. White, 34 School, Room 45, Boston. Frederick E. Whiting. Care of the Boston Herald, Boston. Alfred Wilkinson, Syracuse, N. Y. Otho H. Williams, Jr., 609 Park Ave., Baltimore, Md. William C. Winlock, Smithsonian Inst., Washington, D. C. Robert Winsor, Weston. John Woodbury, 10 Tremont, Boston. 69 [1881

1881.

Dr. Alanson J. Abbe, 106 N. Main, Fall River. J. H. Adams, 107 Washington, Paterson, N. J. Francis B. Allen, 341 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Charles H. Atkins, Lynn. Edward W. Atkinson, 152 Congress, Boston. Parker N. Bailey, War Dept., Washington, D. C. E. Henry Baker, 44 State, Boston. Rev. Frank W. Baker, 321 Garrard, Covington, Ky. F. O. Barton. White, Payson & Co., Box 2993, New York. J. Stuart Bell, Falls City Bank, Louisville, Ky. W. V. R. Berry, 1512 H, Washington, D. C. James Bliss, 465 Main, Springfield. Benjamin M. Borland, 3024 Locust, St. Louis, Mo. William H. Bradbury, 369 Harvard, Cambridge. Edward D. Branclegee, Utica, N. Y. Edward W. Brewer, 34 School, Boston. William Brewster, 10 Tremont, Boston. L. J. Bridgman. A. D. Blanchard, 57 Broadway, Lawrence. William G. Brinsmade, Washington, Conn. Henry R. AY. Browne, 35 Congress, Boston. George A. Burdett, 28 State, Boston. John F. Carleton, East Sandwich. Louis B. Carr, 419 Broadwa}-, New York, N. Y. Harry W. Chase, Haverhill. William Choate, 54 Devonshire, Boston. Louis M. Clark, 30 Kilby, Boston. E. Yr ancey Cohen, 2b W. 18th, New York, N. Y. Dr. Algernon Coolidge, 81 Marlborough, Boston. Charles A. Coolidge, 114 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. William H. Coolidge, Boston & L. R. R., Boston, or 40 Water. Dr. F. J. B. Cordeiro, IT. S. N., 10 Kearsarge Ave., Roxbury. Frederick E. Crawford, Watertown. John F. Davis, 2323 Sacramento, San Francisco, Cal. Charles T. Dazey, Lima, Adams Co., 111. Charles H. L. Delano, New Bedford. Heyliger A. DeWindt. Care C. H. Fargo & Co., Chicago, 111. George T. Dexter, 4 Exchange PL, Boston. Robert H. Driscoll, Deadwood, Dakota. Richard Edwards, 140 W. 15th, New York, N. Y. Rev. Prescott Evarts, 231 Second Ave., New Y'ork, N. Y. John P. Farnsworth, P. O. Box 1131, Providence, R. I. George C. Fisher. F. A. P. Fiske, corner Cherry and Summer, Somerville. William H. Folsom, Exeter, N. H. Charles H. W. Foster, Brookline. William Freeland, 578 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Joseph M. Gibbons, P. O. Box 145, Boston. Dr. Farley B. Goddard, Maiden. r Lawrence Godkin, 115 E. 25th, New Y ork, N. Y". Rev. George A. Gordon, Old South Church, Boston. 1881] 70

Herbert E. Greene, Garden City, Long Island, N Y. Almon W. Griswold, Jr., 11 Pine, New York, N. Y. Curtis Guild, Jr., 26 Mt. Vernon, or Com. Bulletin, Boston. Emerson Haclley, St. Paul, Minn. Howard P. Haines, Saeo, Me. Samuel Hammond, Jr., 8 Congress, Boston. Frederic W. Hardy, Lahaina, Maui, Hawaiian Islands. Alexander Harvey. Care Detrick & Harvey, Baltimore, Md. Eugene D. Hawkins, 111 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Charles M. Hemenway, Somerville. Frederic B. Holder, 288 Beacon, Boston. Dr. Garry de N. Hough, 95 Elm, New Bedford. Jared S. How. Care Clark, Eller & How, St. Paul, Minn. Dr. Herbert B. Howard, Tewkesbury. Dr. Oliver W. Huntington, 12 Ware, Cambridge. Godfrey M. Hyams, 716 Washington, Boston. Rev. Thomas A. Hyde, Westport, Conn. Rev. William Hyde, Weymouth. Thomas P. Ivy, Hogansville, Ga. Charles H. Jackson, 426 California, San Francisco, Cal. Alfred Jaretzki, 3 Broad, New York, N. Y. Dr. John Amory Jeffries, 3 Exeter, Boston. Dr. Arthur C. Jelly, 123 Boylston, Boston. Dr. J. Norton Johnson, 159 York, New Haven, Conn. Henry Dixon Jones, Cambridge. Henry O. Jones. Frederick Joy, 53 Equitable Building, Boston, or Winchester. George F. Joyce, Brookline. Moses King, Boston. Frederick T. Knight, 29 Auburn, Charlestown. Arthur J. Knowles, 291 Shawmut Ave., Boston. [III. William A. Lamson. Care E. F. Lawrence, First Nat. Bank, Chicago. Dr. Edward B. Lane, Retreat for Insane, Dorchester. Gardiner M. Lane, Quincy, Cambridge. William C. Lane, Harvard College Library, Cambridge. Ernest Lovering, Lyman Mills, Holyoke. Dr. Robert W. Lovett. 133 Boylston, Boston. James B. Ludlow, 49 Exchange PL, New York, N. Y. George Lyon, Jr., Nelson, Nuckollo Co., Neb. Robert H. McCurdy, P. O. Box 37, New York, N. Y. Charles MacVeagh, 45 William, New York, N. Y. George D. Markham, 2703 Washington Ave., St. Louis, Mo. John L. Martin, Morganton, N. C. Edward P. Mason, 46 E. 14th, New York, N. Y. Lieut. Joseph E. Maxfield, San Francisco, Cal. Henry F. May, 54 Devonshire, Boston. Alanson H. Mavers, 57 Green, Charlestown. John S. Melcher, 30 W. 21st, New York, N. Y. J. Harold Melledge, Lawrence Dye Works, Lawrence. Dr. Edward R. Merrill, 822 J, Sacramento, Cal. Abbot L. Mills, Perkins & Mills, Colfax, Washington Ter. Charles A. Mitchell, St. Paul's School, Concord, N. H. 71 [1881

Dr. Morris H. Morgan, Cambridge. Philip S. Morse. Dr. Otto Mueller, 620 Lorain, Cleveland, O. Dr. John C. Munro, 127 Boylston, Boston. Joseph A. Nesmith, Lowell. Henry Norman. Dr. William Noyes, McLean Asylum, Somerville. Dr. John W. O'Callaghan, 104 E. 89th, New York, N. Y. Charles M. Osborn, Jr., 94 Washington, Chicago, 111. James Otis. James L. Paine, 48 Canal, Boston., James P. Parmenter, 39 Court, Boston. Boies Penrose, 1331 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. Dr. Charles B. Penrose, 1331 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. G. Gorham Peters, 70 Kilby, Boston. William Y. Peters. Care E. D. Peters, 22 Central, Boston. Rev. Edward C. Porter, Watertown. Edward L. Rand, 27 State, Boston. Chester A. Reed, North Attleboro. Frederick Reed, Talladega, Ala.

Dr. Edward Reynolds, 15 Charles, Boston. . Dr. A. W. Roberts, Wm. Peim Charter Sen., Philadelphia, Pa. Nelson L. Robinson, Canton, N. Y. Rev. William H. Robinson, Riverside, Cal. Dr. De Lancey Rochester, 85 W. Huron, Buffalo, N. Y. Isaac L. Rogers, 423 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Dr. John C. Rolfe, 405 Broadway, Cambridge. JdPDr. Charles R. Sanger, Annapolis, Md. T W illiam T. Sawyer, 422 Battery, San Francisco, Cal. Henry E. Scott, 40 Shepard, Cambridge. Henry E. Seaver, 16 Monument Sq., Charlestown. Joel H. Seaverns, Leadenhall House, London, England. Frederick W. Sharon, Palace Hotel, San Francisco, Cal. Marshall P. Slade, 11 W. 10th, New York, N. Y. William A. Slater, Norwich, Conn. R. Paul Snelling, 53 Mason Building, Boston. Dr. Samuel H. Spalding, Wilton, N. H. Carleton Sprague, The Pitts Agricultural Works, Buffalo, N. Y. Dr. Richard Sprague, 20 Ashburton PL, Boston. Charles F. Squibb, 36 Doughty, Brooklyn, N. Y. Irving G. Stanton, 196 Grinnell, New Bedford. Dr. George A. Staples, Dubuque, Iowa. Merritt Starr, 35 Portland Block, Chicago, 111. George A. Stearns, Jr., 29 Gold St. Court, Worcester. Rev. Roderick Stebbins, Milton. Nelson J. Stephens. Care J. W. Green, Lawrence, Kan. Dr. Frederic W. Stuart, 530 Broadway, South Boston. John B. Studley, Concord Junction. John H. Sturgis, Keokuk, Iowa. R. ClipstOn Sturgis, 19 Exchange PL, Boston. Robert Sturgis, 68 Wall, New York, N. Y. Rev. John W. Suter, Winchester. 1881] 72

Dr. William D. Swan, 167 Brattle, Cambridge. Dr. G. K. Swinburne, The Millburne, 836 7th Ave., New York. Dr. Charles H. Taft, 15 Brattle Sq., Cambridge. Dr. Ambrose Talbot, Times Building. Kansas City, Mo. Dr. Addison S. Thayer, 639 Congress, Portland, Me. William R. Thayer, 15 Ware, Cambridge. H. Trail Thomsen, 23 W. Baltimore, Baltimore, Md. Albert Thorndike, 22 Garden, Cambridge. Walter C. Tiffany, 41 Loan and Trust B'ld., Minneapolis. Minn. Marmaduke Tilden, 285 Lexington Ave., New York, N. Y. Dr. Charles W. Townsend, 61 Chestnut, Boston. George P. Upham, Jr., 29 Thomas, New York, N. Y. Eugene C. Upton, 87 Milk, Boston. Winthrop H. Wade, 10 Tremont, Boston. Mars E. Wagar, York and Carroll, Cleveland, O. Dr. Edward J. Ware, 65 AY. 92d, New York, N. Y. Frank B. Washburn, P. O. Box 1636, Boston. Paul Barron Watson, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Dr. Willis Watson, Tremont, Me. Warren B. P. Weeks, 434 Marlborough, or 20 Water, Boston. Rev. Horace L. Wheeler, P. O. Box 222, Newton Centre. Edmund A. Whitman, 36 Trowbridge, Cambridge. Frank S. Williams, 1 William, New York, N. Y. G. Henrj- Williams, 342 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Rev. Henry W. Winkley, Saco, Me. Joseph V. Witherbee, 100 Keap, Brooklyn. John G. Wood. Care Goulds & Austin, Chicago, 111. Rev. William L. Worcester, 3502 Hamilton, Philadelphia, Pa. John A. Collier Wright, Rochester. N. Y. Rev. Merle St. C. Wright, 247 W. 125th, New York, N. Y. Samuel Wylie, Ballston, Saratoga Co., N. Y.

Alfred M. Allen, Glendale, Hamilton Co., O. L. S. Anderson, U. P. R. R. Office, Boston. C. W. Andrews, 110 James, Syracuse, N. Y. A. P. Averill, Townsend. Dr. James W. Babcock, McLean Asylum, Somerville. Robert T. Babson, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Charles F. Bacon, Lock Box 23, Newton. James H. Bacon, St. Augustine, Fla. Chambers Baird, Ripley, O. Edward W. Baker, Brookline. C. A. Baldwin. Care C. A. Lowe & Co., San Francisco. Cal. Clarence Bancroft, Manchester Mills, Manchester, N. H. George F. Barlow, 140 Nassau, New York, N. Y. J. H. Beale, Jr., 5 Tremont, Boston. J. Remsen Bishop, Princeton, N. J. W. A. Blair, AVinston, N. C. William A. Blodgett, 24 Merchants Row, Boston. J. AY. Bowen, 14 Marlborough, Boston. 73 [1882

Alexander Boyd, 14 N. 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. C. E. Boynton, 29 White, Haverhill. Richards M. Bradley, 113 Devonshire, Boston. Charles J. Brown, 100 Mulberry, Worcester. John S. Bryant, 236 Niagara, Buffalo, N. Y. George C. Buell, Jr., Rochester, N. Y. John Eliot Ballard, 149 Beacon, Boston. William H. Burnham, Dunbarton, N. H. Charles D. Burt, Fall River. F. R. Burton, N. Y. Sun, New York, N. Y. Walter N. Bush, 1514 Pine, San Francisco, Cal. Godfrey L. Cabot, Worthington, Armstrong Co., Pa. Henry G. Chapin, Chapin & Gould, Springfield. Dr. H. Lincoln Chase, Park St., Brookline.

Walter G. Chase, 12 Central, Boston ; and Brookline. Edwards Cheney, P. O. Box 218, Lowell. Dr. J. Payson Clark, 385 Marlborough, Boston. H. Clement, 51 Gloucester, Boston. Dr. J. M. Cochrane, 4 Temple. Boston. Robert Codman, Jr., 17 Brimmer, Boston.

F. N. Cole, 29 N.. University Ave., Ann Arbor, Mich. ; also Marlborough, Mass. Prof. Arthur M. Comey, Tufts College, College Hill.

Frank G. Cook, 4 Pemberton Sq., Boston ; and Cambridge. J. A. Coolidge. Coolidge Ave., Cambridge. C. T. Copeland, Boston Post, Boston. F. L. Creesy, Brookline. M. S. Crehore. Care H. G. Jordan & Co., 82 Water, Boston. Dr. M. A. Crockett, 180 Hodge Ave., Buffalo, N. Y. Robert Gumming. Care Lysson Gordon, P. O. Box 1 123, Boston. GgPHenry W". Cunningham, 31 St. James Ave., Boston. W. de L. Cunningham. Care J. W. Cunningham & Bro., New York. Charles F. Cutler, 89 Broad, Boston. R. P. Dabne}\ Care C. W. Dabney & Sons, Fayal, Azores. Franklin A. Dakin, St. Johnsbury, Vt. William H. Danforth, 19 Leicester, Worcester. W. P. Davis, 744 Broaclwav, New York, N. Y. C. R. Dean, 115 Broadway^ New York, N. Y. Richard Delaney, Woodville. George W. Dickerman, 173 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Charles D. Dickey, Jr., 59 Wall, New York, N. Y. George B. Dunbar, St. Joseph, Mo. AVilliam H. Dunbar, 220 Devonshire, Boston. George H. Eaton, Lawrence. Charles Eliot. 50 State, Boston. A. D. Elliot, P. O. Box 679, Salt Lake City. Utah. Frederick W. P^merson, Newton. William G. Fellows, 584 5th Ave., New York, N. Y. Fred A. Fernald, 3 Bond, New York, N. Y. Burton M. Firman, Boston Post, Boston. Dr. William B. Fiske, 751 Main, Cambridgeport. Rev. J. M. Foster, Bangor, Me. 1882] 74

Dr. George H. Francis, Brookline. H. C. French, French & Potter Co., Chicago, III. F. E. Fuller, Boston Post, Boston. Dr. Homer Gage, Worcester. Rev. D. C. Garrett, Davenport, Iowa. Dr. John Gillespie, 316 Warren, Roxbury. Henry H. Gilman, Haverhill. F. Norton Gocldard, 516 Broadway, New York, N. Y. C. H. Goldthwaite, Bigelow Hill, Brighton. X. H. Goodnough, Brookline. Lysson Gordon, P. O. Box 1123, Boston. James J. Greenough, Brewster PL, Cambridge. Asaph Hall, Jr., Naval Observatory, Washington, D. C. Frederick S. Hall, 37 Cedar, Taunton. H. W. Hardon. Care Evarts, Choate &Beaman, New York, N. Y. G. T. Hartshorn. Care C. W. Hartshorn, Taunton. F. S. Haupt, 715 Holly Ave., St. Paul, Minn. Frank E. Heywood, Worcester.

Sherman Hoar, Waltham ; and 113 Devonshire, Boston. James H. Hopkins, Provincetown. Albert A. Howard, University of California, Berkeley, Cal. H. R. Hoyt, 44 Wall, New York, N. Y. H. M. Hubbard, 387 La Salle Ave., Chicago, 111. Frederick T. Hunt, Weymouth. Dr. C. G. R. Jennings, Bennington, Vt. William Jones, 9 E. 41st, New York, N. Y. Charles H. Keep, Almy & Keep, Buffalo, N. Y. W. W. Kent, 621 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. A. B. Kingsbury, Jr., lt The World," New York, N. Y. B. R. Kittredge, 1 Front, New York, N. Y. G. L. Kittredge, Cambridge. C. F. S. Knowles, Yarmouthport. A. F. Lane, Parkersburg, W. Va. George H. Leatherbee, Parkersburg, W. Va. H. G. Leavitt, 1 E. 40th, New York, N. Y. Arthur P. Lothrop, Pioneer Press Building, St. Paul, Minn. , 103 Milk, Boston. Thomas W. Ludlow, Cottage Lawn, Yonkers, N. Y. John P. Lyons, Montrose, Pa. A. F. McArthur, 275 Ashland Ave., Chicago, 111. Walter I. McCoy, 111 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Dr. Edward V. McDonald, State and 31st, Chicago, 111. R. H. McDonald, Jr., Pacific Bank, San Francisco, Cal. W. H. McKendry. Care Palmer Fuller & Co., Chicago, 111. Charles F. Mason, Bursar Harvard College, Cambridge. John W. Mason, Northampton. Albert Matthews, 145 Beacon, Boston. G. L. May berry, Waltham. E. P. Merritt. Care Adams, Blodget & Co., Boston. Sam. Henry Morrill, Salina, Kansas. (). A. Olmsted, Lincoln, Neb. Henry T. Oxnard, Grand Island, Neb. 75 [1882

W. E. Page, 87 Washington, Newport, R. I. R. T. Paine, 113 Devonshire, Boston. I. N. Panin, Grafton. Elliott H. Pendleton, Jr., Cincinnati, O. Dr. George W. Perkins, U. P. R. R. Hospital, Ogden, Utah.

Dr. John W. Perkins, U . P. R. R. Hospital, Kansas City, Mo. Ernest N. Perrin, 70 William, New York, N. Y. M. J. Pickering, 71 Magazine, Cambridge. W. N. Potter, Jr., Standard Cordage Co., Boston. Box 2718. John Preston, New Ipswich, N. H. William L. Putnam. Care George Putnam, 50 State, Boston. F. W. Rhinelander, Jr., M. L. S. & W. R. R. Co., Milwaukee, Wis. CM. Rice. Care W. W. Rice, Worcester. G. M. Richardson, University of California, Berkeley, Cal. H. A. Richardson, So. Framingham. Rev. L. M. Robinson, 1706 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. W. A. Rogers, 19 Temple Bar, Cincinnati, O.

W. J. Rushmore, Athol. # John Russell, Woburn. Harold M. Sewall, Bath, Me., or Apia, Samoan Islands. H. H. Sherwood, 214 Market, San Francisco, Cal. Box 2494. Horace E. Smith, Room 11, Cohen Block, Indianapolis, Ind. Charles A. Snow, 34 School, Boston. George F. Spalding, Danbury, Conn. Eliot D. Stetson, New Bedford. C H. Stevens, 304 Harvard, Cambridge. E. K. Stevens, Newport, R. I. Box 82. F. M. Stone, 46 Fiske Building, Boston. W. E. Stone, Greensboro', N. C. John H. Storer, 113 Devonshire, Boston. T. C. Thacher, 16 Pearl, Boston. Roland Thaxter, New Haven, Conn. George W. Towne, So. Byfield. S. V. R. Townsend, 37 W. 37th, or 71 Wall, New York, N. Y. Rev. Gnstavus Tuckerman, Chicago, 111. Edward L. Underwood, Bernardston. William C. Wait. 23 Court, Boston. Guy Waring, 16 Pearl, Boston. Henry E. Warner, Cambridge. F. Warren, 18 P. O. Sq., Boston. F. L. Washburn, State College, Cornwallis, Oregon. Rev. Philip M. Washburn, Northampton. John S. Webb, 406 5th, N. W., Washington, D. C. J. Edward Weld, 160 Broadway, New York, N. Y. E. J. Wendell, 8 E. 38th, New York, N. Y. Elmer E. Wentworth, 16 Tremont, Chelsea. Isaac S. Whiting, Worcester. Russell Whitman, The Tacoma, Chicago, 111. Samuel Williston, Equitable Building, Boston. Owen Wister, Logan Station, Philadelphia, Pa. Herbert G. Woodw^orth, 28 Broad, Boston. J. R. Worcester, Waltham. 1883] 76

George H. H. Allen, New Bedford. Gwynne Murdoch Andrews, "University Club, New York, N. Y. Hugh Alexander Andrews, Dixon, Wyoming. William Henry Aspinwall, Brookline. Luther Atwood, 36 Sachem, Lynn. Angell B. Babbitt, Media, Pa. Thomas Cogswell Bachelder, 19 Gleason, Dorchester. James Eliot Baker, Newton St., Brookline. Lucas Lee Baker, E. Templeton. David Nevins Baxter, Seattle, Wash. George William Beals, Puritan Club, Beacon, Boston. Charles Mortimer Belshaw, 1626 Jackson, San Francisco, Cal. Horace Binnev. Care Wilbur, Jackson & Co., Providence, R. I. Jeffrey R. Brackett, 106 North Ave., Baltimore, Md. Dr. Charles Poor Briggs, 15 Bradford, Lawrence. William W. Bryant. Care C. H. Bailey & Co., 15 Hare, Calcutta, India. James Merrill Burch* Necedah, Juneau Co., Wis. Albert Cameron Burrage, 8 Congress, Boston. George Dixwell Burrage, Chestnut Hill. Dr. Walter Lincoln Burrage, 282 Newbury, Boston. Edward Knowles Butler, Martin, Marion Co., Fla. Robert Gordon Butler, The kt Sun" Office, New York, N. Y. Edward Twisleton Cabot, Brookline. Henry Bromfield Cabot, Brookline. Charles Dexter Canterbury, E. Weymouth. , 18 P. O. Sq., Boston. Henry Grafton Chapman, 191 2d Ave., New York, N. Y. Henry Ernest Chase. Care H. L. Chase, Brookline. Francis Lewis Clark, Spokane Falls, Wash. Joseph Sill Clark. Care E. W. Clark, Germantown, Pa. Stephen Cutter Clark, W. Boxford. Mortimer Hall Clarke, New Bedford. Russell Sturgis Codman, 57 Marlborough, Boston. Robert Coit, Winchester. Charles D'U. M. Cole, 21 Broad, New York, N. Y. Joseph Randolph Coolidge, Chestnut Hill. Louis Arthur Coolidge, 2321 Pennsylvania Ave., Washington, D. C. Sumuer Coolidge, Mt. Auburn. Thomas AVashington Cowgill, Salina, Kan. Henry Howland Crapo, New Bedford. Edward Cummings, 150 Union, Lynn. Charles Pelham Curtis, 27 Kilby, Boston. Walter Curtis. Care B. R. Curtis, 28 School, Boston. Marshall Henry dishing. Daily Globe Office, Boston. Walter Reeves Dame, Clinton. Walter Elijah Damon, Bryantville. Dr. William Lawrence Dana, 660 Congress, Portland, Me. Gibson Mallory Davis. Care Standard Oil Co., Louisville, Ky. Joseph Edwin Davis, 234 Devonshire, Boston. Stanton Dav, 294 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. 77 [1883

Arthur Clark Denniston, 35 S. 3d, Philadelphia, Pa. George Badger Dewson, Quincy. Joseph Dorr, 12 Walnut, Boston. Dr. Edmond Scott Dow, 14 Harvard Ave., Allston. George Garrett Dunn, 51 S. 3d, Philadelphia, Pa. Morris Eatie. Care Walmsley & Co., 1016 Chestnut, Philadelphia, Pa. James H. B. Easton, Rochester, Minn. Dr. Percival James Eaton, Maplewood. John H. W. Edgerly, Jamal, San Diego Co., Cal. Harry R. Edwards, 137 Water, Cleveland, O. William Crowninshield Endicott, 365 Essex, Salem. Robert Berry Ennis, Las Vegas, New Mexico. George W. Evans, English High School, Montgomery, Boston. William Faxon, 62 Chester Sq., Boston. Francis Britain Fay, 24 Warland, Cambridgeport. Lynde Raymond Ferris, Brookline. John William Fox, Paris, Bourbon Co., Ky. Dr. Richard Pearce Francis, Montclair. N. J. Waldo Fuller, Telluride, Colo. W. H. Garrison. Care Rev. J. F. Garrison, Camden, N. J. Charles Walter Gerould, Stoughton. Clarence Getchell, P^xeter, N. H. B. F. Gooclnough. Care Xanthus Goodnough, Brookline. Charles Hall Grandgent, Cambridge. Percy Stickney Grant, St. Paul St., Brookline. Hale, Jr., 39 Highland, Roxbury. Henry Martyn Hall, Ellsworth, Me. James Milton Hall, 13 Exchange, Boston. Hamlin, 49 Winthrop, Roxbury.

Charles Miffln Hammond, ) Red Hill Ranch, Upper Lake,

Gardiner Greene Hammond, j Lake Co., Cal. Mellen Woodman Haskell, 23 Packard, Ann Arbor, Mich. Hammond Vinton Hayes, 22 Buckingham, Cambridge. Walter Edward Hayward, 179 Broadway, New York, N. Y. George Henry Heilbron, Seattle, Wash. Ernest Flagg Henderson, 109 Prince, New York, N. Y. George Ross Hewitt, 111 Vernon, Roxbury. Dr. George Heywood, Jr., 14 E. 34th, New York, N. Y. Archie Livingstone Hodges, P. O. Box 53, Stockbridge. Benjamin Blake Holmes, Worcester High School, Worcester. Charles Witherle Hooke. Franklin H. Hooper, Century Co., Union Sq., New York, N. Y. George Ebenezer Howe, 23 Court (Room 82), Boston. Edwin C. Howell. Charles J. Hubbard, 105 W. 6th, Kansas City, Mo. Dr. Ernest Sanford Jack, Melrose. Dr. Henry Barton Jacobs, W. Scituate. [Boston. Wm. C. Jennings. Care Dr. Packard, Hotel Chatham, W. Concord, Frank Elwoocl Jennison, 41 Wall, New York, N. Y. Louis Osborne Johnson, Salem. Paul Jones, Rochester, Minn. Frank Warton Kaan, 54 Devonshire (Room 19), Boston. 1883] 78

Patrick Michael Keating, 44 Court (Room 5), Boston. George P. Keith. Care Dunn, Green & Co., 30 South, Boston. Warren Franklin Kellogg, 95 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Edward Kent. Care F. A. Wilson, Bangor, Me. Chokichi Kikkawa. Care Japanese Legation, Berlin, Germany. Dr. Stephen Herrick Knight, 41 E. 12th, New York, N. Y. Alfred Church Lane, 623 Tremont, Boston. Joseph Lee, 40 State, Boston. Dr. Howard Lilienthal, 33 E. 31st, New York, N. Y. Herbert Marshall Lloyd, Montclair, N. J. Morris Loeb, P. O. Box 1193, New York, N. Y. William Alden Lombard, Sears Building (Room 13), Boston. Rev. Augustus Mendon Lord, Arlington. Arthur Lyman, 39 Beacon, Boston. Jose Antonio Machado, 33 E. 31st, New York, N. Y. Edwin Guthrie Mclnnes, 209 Washington, or 276 Newbury, Boston. Richard Crane McKay, 142 Marlborough, Boston. David Ives Mackie, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Arthur Richmond Marsh, 14 Mt. Vernon Court, Newport, R. I. Dr. Sollace Mitchell, cor. Forsyth, Julia & Adams, Jacksonville, Fla. Reuben B. Moffat, 17 Schemerhorn, Brooklyn, N. Y. John Farwell Moors. Care J. B. Moors, 111 Devonshire, Boston. George Buruap Morison, Puritan Club, Boston. Dr. George Patrick Morris, 561 8th, So. Boston. Dr. Charles Francis Morse, 77 Myrtle, Boston. Franklin Woodruff Moulton, 127 Water, New York, N. Y. Charles Corbett Nichols, Everett. Charles Prosser Nichols, 3 James, Lowell. |yFrederick Nichols, 2 Joy, Boston. George Hemy Nichols, 395 E. 5th, So. Boston. William Edgar Nies, St. George's Clergy-house, E. 16th, N. Y. Samuel Norris, Bristol, R. I. James Atkins Noyes, 62 Leonard, New York, N. Y. Robert Emmet O'Callaghan, 1133 Park Ave., New York, N.Y. George H}-de Page, 1940 Washiugton, Boston. William H. Page, 120 Broadway, Room 62, Sixth Floor, New York. Trenor Luther Park, Lotus Club, New York, N. Y. John Letcher Patterson, 48 Barr, Lexington, Ky. Dr. Walter Everard Paul, Auburn, Me., or Southbridge. Louis R. E. Paulin. Care F. Nichols, 2 Joy, Boston. Sumner Bass Pearmain, 28 State, Boston. John Downer Pennock, S}7 camore St., Somerville. Charles Page Perin. Care F. Nichols, 2 Joy, Boston. Charles Bruen Perkins, Puritan Club, Boston. Oscar Edward Perry. Care Holyoke Machine Co., Worcester. Alonzo Wilder Pollard, P. O. Box 2751, Boston. George Jonathan Porter, Medford. James Faulkner Preston, 13 Chestnut, Boston. Herbert Putnam, Atheneum Library, Minneapolis, Minn. Osgood Putnam, 1012 Washington, San Francisco, Cal. Charles Ranlet, Holyoke. Fletcher Ranney, 23 Court, Boston. 79 [1884

Daniel Merchant Richardson, Nesmith St., Lowell. Philip Richmond, 46 Angell, Providence, R. I. Charles Enoch Robinson, 21 Park, Somerville. Charles Randall Rockwell, Tarrytown, N. Y. Rev. Edmund S. Rousmaniere, 372 County, New Bedford. William Alvah Rublee, Milwaukee, Wis. Fletcher Ferris Ryer, 103 Montgomery, San Francisco, Cal.

Sabin Pond Sanger. Care Blake Bros. & Co., State St. , Boston. Everett Wyman Sawyer, Wolfville, N. S. Fred Leland Sawyer. Dr. Henry Francis Sears, 86 Beacon, Boston. Richard Dudley Sears, 51 Beacon, Boston. Archibald L. Sessions. Care John Sessions, 32 Pine, New York. Raymer Sharp, 1728 Golden Gate Ave., San Francisco, Cal. Joseph Henrj- Sheffield. John Dickinson Sherwood, Spokane Falls, W^ash. Charles Worcester Smith, 30 Elm, Worcester. Ormond Gerald Smith, 31 Rose, New York, N. Y. Walter E. C. Smith, 13 Warren Ave., Boston. Henry Lloyd Smyth, 22 Brinley, Newport, R. I. Walter Soren, 12 Humphreys, Dorchester. Frank Miller Sparrow, Mattapoisett. Horace Elmer Sprague, 1 Carrol, Worcester. Nathan Cushman Stevens, Willoughby, Lake Co., O. Dr. Arthur Kingsbury Stone, Framingham. William Dunning Sullivan, 20 Cherry, E. Somerville. Edward W. S. Tingle, Globe Office, St. Paul, Minn. Alfred Tonks. Edward P. Warren. Care S. D. Warren, 220 Devonshire, Boston. William Ross Warren, 81 Fulton, New York, N. Y. William Wadsworth Wentworth, Englewood, Cook Co., 111. Alfred J. Weston, Weston & Gray, 15-25 Whitehall, New York. Daniel Appleton White, 3921 Prarie Ave., Chicago, 111. Prof. John Henry Wigmore, Tokyo, Japan. Richard B. Wilcox, 916 New York Life Building, Kansas City, Mo. William Hall Williams, Wakefield. Ralph Denton Wilson. Care Peele, Hubbell & Co., Iloilo, Philippine Islands, via San Francisco and Manila. Charles E. L. Wingate, Boston Journal, Boston. George Scott Winslow, 113 Pinckney, Boston. Winthrop Church Winslow, 68 Rutland, Boston. Robert D. Winthrop, Knickerbocker Club, New York, N. Y. Joseph Meyer Witmer, Los Angeles, Cal. Arthur Henry Woodbury, Cabot St., Beverly. Dr. Charles Pomeroy Worcester, Newtonville. Alphonso Aclelbert Wyman, W. Acton.

1884.

Gordon Abbott, 35 Oliver, Boston. George Russell Agassiz, Cambridge. Charles Francis Aiken, 6 Charles, Somerville. 1884] 80

Charles Coleman Allen, Troy. O. Edward Ellis Allen, West Newton. Brainard Alger Andrews, 9 State House, Boston. Alfred Colburn Arnold, 10 Frisbie PL, Cambridge. Hartle}' Frederic Atwood, 414 Columbus Ave., Boston. Fraucis McNiel Bacon, Jr., P. O. Box 3134, New York. N. Y. Charles William Baker, 86 Kennard, Cleveland, O. Jacob Bancroft, 380 Harvard, Cambridge. Edward Appleton Bangs, 37 Pemberton Sq., Boston. Heniy E. Barnes. Care Washburn Mill Co., Minneapolis, Minn. Walter Saunders Barnes, 240 Highland Ave., Somerville. Benjamin , 54 Devonshire, Boston. Walter Cabot Baylies, 369 W. 28th, New York, N. Y. Edwin Upshur Berryman, P. O. Box 412, Lexington, Ky. Louis A. Biddle, 1307 Walnut. Philadelphia, Pa. Heinrich Conrad Bierwith, Meinerson, Hanover, Germany. Charles Towne Billings, Fitchburg. Herbert Wheeler Blanchard, corner State and Kilby, Boston. Henry Warren Bliss, 11 Marlborough, Boston. Leigh Bonsai, 1000 N. Charles, Baltimore. Md. John Ransom Bridge, 110 Tremont, Boston. Josiah Bridge, Foster's Crossing, Warren Co., O. George William Brown, Concord. Romeo Green Brown, Montpelier, Yt. William Sohier Bryant, 61 Beacon, Boston. Harry Archibald Buerk, 108 Pearl. New Albany, Ind. Dr. John Thornton Bullard, New Bedford. Frederic Story Bunker, Cambridge. Me: Winthrop Motley Burr, 30 Exeter, Boston. John Jay Chapman, 327 W. 82d, New York, N. Y. Clift Rogers Clapp, 55 Kilby, Boston. Frank Haven Clark, 214 Beacon, Boston. E. A. S. Clarke. Care Union Steel Co., 3179 Ashland Ave., Chicago. Frederic Codman Cobb, 94 Pinckney, Boston. [111. James Macmaster Codman, 35 Court, Boston. Joseph Ambrose Cogan, 35 Second, E. Cambridge. Ernest Lee Conant, Davies & Rapallo, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Henry Charles Converse, Newton. John Gardner Coolidge, 147 Beacon, Boston. Coolidge, Jr., Manchester. Henry Joseph Cox, Norwich University, Northfield. Yt. George Uriel Crocker, 19 Milk, Boston. Care Wm. T. Crocker. Thomas Kittredge Cummins, Jr., 76 Devonshire, Boston. Allen Curtis, 277 Clarendon, Boston. William Franklin Dana, 311 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Frederick Homer Darling, 34 Wall, New York, N. Y. Charles Bridge Davis, Lexington. Charles Thornton Davis. Myron Preston Denton, Saratoga, N. Y. John Worthington Dickinson. Newton ville. Harry Robinson Dow, Lawrence. Rev. E. S. Drown, Episc. Theol. School, Cambridge. N 81 [1884

Hulburd Dunlevy. Care J. C. Duo levy, Chicago, 111. Thomas Duraot,' 1624 19th, Washington, D. C. Rev. Samuel Atkins Eliot, 1957 Logan Ave., Denver, Colo. Silas Haynes Elliot, 6 Mt. Auburn, Cambridge. Bertram Ellis, Denver, Colo. Rev. William Wallace Fenn, Somerville. Charles Merritt Field, 158 Hicks, Brooklyn, N. Y. George Welton Fishback, 301 Pine, St. Louis, Mo. Jesse Fletcher, Atlas Engine Works, Indianapolis, Iod. M. W. Frederick. Edward Wheeler Frost, Milwaukee, Wis. Theodore Longfellow Frothingham, 52 Wall, New York, N. Y. James Grahame Gardiner, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. William Amory Gardner, 22 Congress, Boston. Lewis Edwards Gates, Cambridge.

Franklin Kent Gifford, 1 Sacramento PL, Cambridge. William Logan Rodman Gilford, New Bedford. Warren Randall Gilman, Medford. Horatio Nelson Glover, Milton. Philip Goepp, 1006 Clinton, Philadelphia, Pa. Joseph Arthur Willis Goodspeed, Hopkinton, N. H. William Hobbs Goodwin, Jr., Jamaica Plain. Charles Theodore Greve, 260 W. 8th, Cincinnati, O. Loren E. Griswold, 185 West Chester Park, Boston. Addison Hamlin, Bangor, Me. Charles Eugene Hamlin, The Tribune, New York, N. Y. Frank Hamlin, Bangor, Me. Charles Theodore Hardwick, Quincy. Frank Abram Harrington, Orangeport, Niagara Co., N. Y. Thaddeus William Harris, Cambridge. William Edwin Haskell, Minneapolis, Minn. Arthur Gillespie Hatch, 780 Main, Cambridgeport. Eugene Hamlin Hatch, Plainfield, N. J. Simeon Mills Hayes, Gilfillan Block, St. Paul, Minn. William Allen Hayes, 39 Court, Boston. SSjpEdward Andress Hibbard, 111 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Omri Ford Hibbard, 95 Third PL, Brooklyn, N. Y. Charles Andress Holmes, 362 W. 4th, Cincinnati, O. Frank William Holmes, Cambridgeport. Holmes, 526 N. 18th, Philadelphia, Pa. Charles Lewis Holt, 315 13th, N. W., Washington, D. C. John Edward Howe, 26 In man, Cambridgeport. Richard Flint Howe, Kenosha, Wis. Harry Hubbard, 191 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Nathaniel Stevens Hunting, 701 18th, Des Moines, Iowa. Samuel Ingersoll Hutchinson, Salem. Edwin Everett Jack, 159 Boylston, Boston. Wilbur Samuel Jackman, Winthrop, Pittsburgh, Pa. Charles Herbert Jennings, 17 Maple Ave., Cambridge. James Richard Jewett, 60 Buckingham, Cambridge. Walter Perry Johnson. Gilbert Norris Jones, 31 Ohio, Bangor, Me. 1884] 82

Wallace Irving Keep, Lockport, N. Y. George Kemp, 32 E. 70th, New York, N. Y. Henry Holton Kendall, Walpole. Walter Brackett Lancaster, Newton. Charles Sterrett Latham, Stockbriclge. G. H. Lecllie. Prof. J. B. Greenough, Riedesel Ave., Cambridge. Lonis Valconlon LeMoyne, 89 Madison, Chicago, 111. Albert H. Leyton. P. L. Livingston. Mrs. L. Livingston, 17 W. 26th, New York. Edward Haskell Lonnsbury, P. O. Box 213, Woburn. Jesse Lowman, 375 W. 7th, Cincinnati, O. Oscar Jonas Lowman, 66 W. 8th, Cincinnati, O. Louis Butler McCagg, 293 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. John McDuffie, Greenfield. James Henry Mcintosh, Omaha, Neb. William Lenhart McPherson, The Tribune, New York, N. Y. Henry Fauntleroy Mandell, Somerset Club, Boston. Charles Marsh Marvin, Allen Brothers' College, Elmira, N. Y. Frank Atlee Mason, Newton Centre. Robert Shaw Minturn, 45 William, New York, N. Y. J. L. Mitchell, 50 E. 70th, New York, N. Y. Frazer Livingston Montague, 6 Beacon, Room 27, Boston. George Dunning Moore, P. O. Box 544, or 25 Catharine, Worcester. John Wells Morss, 323 Marlborough, Boston. T. A. Mullen, 13 B, South Boston. William Woolsey Mumford, Rochester, N. Y. Nathaniel dishing Nash, 13 Craigie, Cambridge.

John Ulric Nef , Housatonic. Henry David Nelson, Milford. John Thomas Nichols, Freetown. William Whiting Nolen, Cambridge. John Andrew Noonan, 160 K, South Boston. Thomas Mott Osborne, Auburn, N. Y. Prof. James Morton Paton, Middebury, Vt. Edward Lawrence Peirson, 13 Benton Sq., Salem. Nathaniel Greene Pendleton, 100 E. 4th, Cincinnati, O. Arthur Lincoln Penhallow. Richard A. F. Penrose, 1331 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. Albert Sanborn Perkins, 37 Nixon Ave., Dorchester. Geo. H. Perkins, Mich. Mining School, Houghton, Mich. Robert Patterson Perkins, 102 S. Front, Philadelphia, Pa. Hardy Phippen, Salem. Edwin Martin Pickop. Thomas Rodman Plummer, New Bedford. Frank Gustiue Pratt, Keene, N. H. John Prentiss, Keene, N. H. Bartow Bee Ramage, Newberry, S. C. Francis James Riley, Holyoke. Herbert Daniel Robbins, 91 Fulton, New York, N. Y. Walter Currier Rose, Fitchburg. Conrad John Rueter, Jamaica Plain. William Osborne Safford, Salem. S3 [1885

Charles Robertson Saunders', 50 North Ave., Cambridge. L. E. Sexton, The Benedict, 80 Washington Sq., New York. Harry Clay Shaw, Rockland. Shaw, Chestnut Hill. Thomas Stanley Simonds, Beverly. Dunlap Smith, 112 Pine, Chicago. Henry Munson Spelman, 62 Sparks, Cambridge. Squire, Arlington. George Andrew Stewart, 363 Dorchester, South Boston." Roger Faxon Sturgis. Care Robert Sturgis, '81. William Cod man Sturgis, Manchester. Robert Heberton Terrell, 1531 Madison, Washington, D. C. Augustus Thorndike, Brookline. Paul Thorndike, 506 Milwaukee, Milwaukee, Wis. Edward Mitchell Townsend, 19 E. 22d, New York, N. Y. Henry Trail, Frederick, Md. William Ball Turner, Mason Building, Boston. William Orison Underwood, 113 Devonshire, Boston. John Baldwin Walker, Spencer. C. M. Walsh. Care W. A. Cook, 245 Broadway, New York. Fiske Warren, 67 Mount Vernon. Boston. Gerrit Elias Hambleton Weaver, Swarthmore College, Pa. Hollis Webster, 17 Dix, Dorchester. Benjamin Williams Wells, 95 Newbury, Boston. Wm. Fessenden Wesselhoeft, 176 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Greenough White, 6 Phillips PL, Cambridge. John Allison White, 847 W. 4th, Williamsport, Pa. Schuyler Sampson White, Exeter, N. H. Frederick Augustus Whitney. Frederick Silsbee Whitwell, 41 Tremont, Boston. James Edward Wilkinson, Lawrence. Hemy Jules Williams, 1225-1227 Spruce, St. Louis, Mo. John Brainerd Wilson, Freeport, Me. Edward Mumford Winston, Forrestown, 111. E. H. Woodruff. Care Mrs. D. C. Ha}mes, St. Catherine's, Ont. Stuart Wyeth, 1511 Locust, Philadelphia, Pa. Charles Calvin Ziegler, Rebersburg, Pa.

Victor Clifton Alderson, Englewood, Cook Co., 111. Richard Aldrich, 101 Congdon, Providence, R. I.

Arthur Lincoln Allen, 89 State, Boston ; and Arlington. Horace D. Arnold, Church, Newton. Charles Heath Atkinson, Heath Hill, Brookline.

Clarence Walter Ayer, C. 56, Cambridge ; and Haverhill. William Francis Bacon, Newton. Stephen A. Bailey, Trenton, Mo. William Henry Baldwin. Jr. Care U. P. R. R., Omaha, Neb. Henry Bartlett, Deny, Westmoreland Co., Pa. Stephen S. Bartlett, 291 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Ferdinand W. Batchelder, 26 India Sq., Boston. 1885] 84

Loring W. Batten, corner Gist and Hazel Ave., Philadelphia, Pa. Harry Clayton Bearnan. John Wheeler Bemis. Care Hottinguer et Cie, Paris, France. Robert Sloan Bickford, 7 Exchange PL, Boston. Franklin Swift Billings, 108 Water, New York, N. Y. Charles Wesley Birtwell, 37 Temple, Boston.

George Richard Blinn, 30 Court. Boston ; and Bedford. Alva Zaza Bowen, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Frank Josiah Bowman, Sterling, 111. Roland William Boyden, Beverly. Carleton Brabrook, Taunton. Charles Franklin Brandt, 140 Nassau, New York, N. Y. William Frederick Bridge, Foster's, Warren Co., 0. F. H. Briggs. Care San Francisco Examiner, San Francisco, Cal. Hugh Henry Brogan, 48 Lawrence Corporation, Lowell. Arthur Laugmaicl Calhoun. Care The Traveller, Boston. Frederic Ives Carpenter, Menomanie, Mich. Charles Frederic Carrier. Royal Phelps Carroll, Knickerbocker Club, New York, N. Y. John Derthick Cary, Richfield Springs, N. Y. Dr. Arthur P. Chadbourne, Mercer Circle, Cambridge. Allen H. Chamberlain, Mass. Char. Eye and Ear Inf., Boston. Winthrop Astor Chanler, Barrytown. N. Y. Thomas Herbert Chase, 714 Water, New York, N. Y. Horace Clark, Newton. Leonard Brown Clark, Waverley. John Codman, 40 Kilby, Boston. Nathan E. Coffin, Iowa Loan & Trust Bldg., Des Moines, Iowa. Allaniah Davis Cole, Maysville, Ky. Edward Lyon Collins, AY. Newton. John Joslin Colony, 104 West, Keene, N. H. Winthrop Cowdiu, 67 E. 54th, New York. N. Y. Henry Brinton Coxe, 109 So. 21st, Philadelphia, Pa. George Arthur Craigin, 1 Cedar Park, Roxbury. Adams Crocker, Fitchburg. Hamilton Rowan Curtis, 195 Beacon, Boston. Grafton Dulany' Cushing. 168 Beacon, Boston. George Fauntleroy Davidson, 1117 Hyde, San Francisco, Cal.

Bancroft Gherardi Davis, 23 Court, Boston ; and Cambridge. Frederick A. Delano, Gen'l Offices, C. B. & Q. R. R., Chicago, 111. Paul Shipman Drane, Frankfort, Ky. William Kinnicutt Draper, 19 E. 47th, New York, N. Y.

Theo. Dunham, Irvington-ou-Hudson, N. Y. ; and Bellevue Hospital. New York, N. Y. Percy David D wight, 473 Jefferson Ave., Detroit, Mich. Edward Tyler Edgerly, Ottumwa, Iowa. James Lyman Fisk, 32 Quincy. Cambridge. Francis Briuley Fogg, 50 N. High, Nashville, Tenu. George Edmond Foss, 409 The Rookery, Chicago, 111. Samuel Lynde Foster, 434 Bartlett, San Francisco. Cal. Amos Tuck French. 10 Wall, New York, N. Y. John Hays Gardiner, Hawes, Brookline. 85 [1885

Charles Freeman Oilman, Brown Ave., Roslindale. Charles Bertie Gleason, Natick. [York, N. Y. John McGregor Goodale, Hitchcock & Harvey, 120 Broadway, New Robert S. Gorham. Care Ropes, Gray & Loring, 50 State, Boston. Rev. Walter Folger Greenraan, 150 W. Wabasha, Winona, Minn. Fred Sumner Haines, 468 Gray, Elmira, N. Y. Walter Allen Halbert, 20 W. 9th, Kansas City, Mo. William A. Hammond. Otto Rein hard Hansen, 649 Cass, Milwaukee, Wis. Charles M. Harrington, White Bldg., 298 Main, Buffalo, N. Y. James Mott Hartshorne, 300 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Daniel Lyman Hazard, Narragansett Pier, R. I. William Henry Hidden, 210 Washington, Boston. Henry Theodore Hildreth, 10 Remington, Cambridge. Joseph Adna Hill. Care Johns Hopkins Univ., Baltimore, Md. Harry Raymond Hilliard, 378 Penn, Pittsburg, Pa.

Marland C. Hobbs, 82 Devonshire, Boston ; and Brookline. Harry Holden. Care D. W. Holden, Haverhill. John Francis Holland. Care Marshall Field, Chicago, 111. William Parmelee Homans, P. O. Box 437, Baltimore, Md. Edwin Howard, 74 Waltham, Boston. [Cal. Oscar S. Howard. Care C. W. Howard, 510 California, San Francisco, Alfred William Hoyt, 934 5th Ave., New York, N. Y.

John La Monte Hurst, 1 7 Tritch Block, Denver, Col. Cyrus Wendell Irish, 126. Moore, Lowell. Louis Lincoln Jackson, Brighton District, Boston. Arthur Stoddard Johnson, 7 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Harry Walter Jones, 276 Harvard, Cambridge. Edward Kirk Keep, Buffalo, N. Y. Arthur Keith. Care U. S. Geol. Survey, Washington, D. C. Daniel Kelleher. Care Thomas Emory, Syracuse, N. Y. Rev. Maximilian Lindsay Kellner, Lawrence 17, Cambridge. Charles Carroll King, Kingman Block, Campello, Brockton. Ralph Martin Lane, 3806 Delmar Ave., St. Louis, Mo. John Lawrence, 4 Garden, Cambridge. Eugene Lent, 566 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. William Leverett, Bloomsburgh, Columbia Co., Pa. Henry Foster Lewis, 56 47th, Chicago, 111. Lawrence Litchfield, Belle vue Hospital, New York, N. Y. Joseph Mansfield Long, Canton, Me. Daniel William Lotham, 93 Greenwood, Cleveland, O.

John R. McArthur, Harv. Law Sch. ; and 11 Mason, Cambridge. Robert Latimer McCook, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. William Morrow Mclunes, 39 Court, Boston. John Francis Mahoney, 182 Chestnut, Chelsea. Edward Dudley Marsh, 165 Huntington Ave., Boston. Manton Maverick. Edmund Smith Middleton, 17 Irving, Worcester. Ezra Palmer Mills, 160 Broadway, New York, N. Y. J. P. Miner, 127 E. 3d, St. Paul, Minn. Alfred H. Morris, Westchester P. ()., Westchester Co., N. Y. James Gregory Mumford, 139 Troup, Rochester, N. Y. 1885] 8$

William Stanislaus Murphy, Custom House, Boston. John Breed Newhall, 209 Washington, Boston. Seth Nichols, 143 Front, New York, N. Y. John Hawks Noble. Care G. W. C. Noble, Cambridge.

William Belden Noble, Mason, Cambridge. . Eliot Norton. Care Evarts, Choate & Beaman, 52 Wall, N. Y. Edward Isaac Kimball Noyes, 46 Congress, Boston. George R. Nutter, 220 Devonshire, Boston. Jose V. Onativia, Union Club, New York, N. Y. Chauncey Goodrich Parker, 800 Broad, Newark, N. J.

George Fairbanks Partridge. 36 Temple PL, Boston ; and Caryville. . Care N. Y. Herald, New York, N. Y. Horatio Perry Peirson, 13 Barton Sq., Salem. Charles A. Peterson. Reuben Peterson, 171 Princeton, E. Boston. John Sanborn Phillips, Tribune Building, New York, N. Y. Palmer E. Presbrey. Care Nat. Bank of Redemption, Boston. Frederic Eugene Puffer, W. Newton.

Sheridan P. Read. Care Russell & Co. , 60 Wall, New York, N. Y. Waters Dewees Roberts, Hotel Bristol, Boylston, Boston. Charles Prosser Robinson, Bakewell Law Blclg., Pittsburg. Pa. Edward Drake Roe, 61 Oxford, Cambridge. George William Rolfe, 405 Broadway, Cambridge. Theophilus Huntington Root, Framingham. William Noble Roundy, 614 Congress, Chicago, 111. Edward T. Sanford, 125 Prince, Knoxville, Tenn. Charles Austin Sawin, 73 Brattle, Cambridge. Arthur Brown Sawyer, 287 Washington Ave., Chelsea. William Munro Seavey, 93 Winthrop, Roxbury.

Arthur Wesley Sim, 53 Devonshire, Boston ; and Peabody. Robert Fields Simes, 30 Court, Boston.

John Simpkins, Yarmouthport ; and New York, N. Y. Harry Williams Simpson, 120 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Alfred Percival Smith, 608 Chestnut, Philadelphia, Pa.

Edward Irving Smith, Lincoln ; and AValtham. William Christopher Smith, 39 Court, Boston. William W. Smith, 4717 Germantown Ave., Philadelphia, Pa. George Andrew Snow, 714 Cambridge, Cambridge. Malcolm Storer, 182 Boylston, Boston. James Jackson Storrow, Jr., 40 Water, Boston. Charles Augustus Strong. Care J. D. Rockefeller, New York, N. Y Eben Sutton, N. Audover. Henry Kirkland Swinscoe, Clinton. Alfred William Taussig, 509 Olive, St. Louis, Mo. Frederick Spaulding Ta}T lor, 231 Marlborough, Boston. Howard Augustus Tavlor, P. O. Box 203, New York, N. Y. Edward Claflin Thaye"r, P. O. Box 2000, New York. N. Y. Ernest Lawrence Thayer, Worcester. John Eliot Thayer, Lancaster. William Sidney Thayer, 5 Phillips PL, Cambridge. Edward James Tilton, Andover. William Ropes Trask. 99 Mt. Vernon, Boston. 87 [1886

George Sidney Tylor, 5 W. 4th and Avondale, Cincinnati, O. Frank Louis Van Cleef, Wellington, O. Hiram Warren Wads worth, 84 Washington, Boston. Hancke Frederick Wagener, 58 St. Phillips, Charleston, S. C. Andrew Henshaw Ward, 60 Linden, Allston. Samuel Smart Watson, 9th and Wyandotte, Kansas City, Mo. Arthur Gordon Webster, P. O. Box 125, Newton Centre. Albion Otis Wetherbee, Flushing Institute, Flushing, N. Y. Charles Chapin Wheelwright, 9 Ellis, Roxbury. Francis W. White. Care Warren-Scharf Asphalt Paving Co.,

81 Fulton, New York ; and University Club, Cincinnati, O. McDonald Ellis White, 259 Marlborough, and 4 Park, Boston. Julian Lincoln Whiteside, 491 Stevens, Lowell. Edson Leone Whitney, 5 St. Charles, Boston. Charles Alexander Whittemore, 23 Court, Boston. |3PHenry Morland Williams, 39 Court, Boston. George Lane Winlock, 47 Langdon, Cambridge. Samuel Ellsworth Winslow, Worcester. William Warren Winslow, Punxutawney, Pa. Egerton Leigh Winthrop, 48 Wall, New York, N. Y. Edward Franklin Woods, 32 Kilby, Boston. James Reed Yocom, Richmond, Staten Island, N. Y. Edward Blake Young, P. O. Box 2248, St. Paul, Minn. 1886. Everett Vergnies Abbot, 31 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Harry Stephens Abbot, Calumet Club, New York, N. Y. Henry Ward Abbot, 11 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Benjamin Rush Abbott, Cambridge. George Caspar Adams, 23 Court, Boston. Herbert Tufts Allen, Somerville. William Lothrop Allen, 72 High, Boston. Oliver Ames, 2d, North Easton. Frederic William Atherton, 144 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Francis Boylston Austin, 58 High, Charlestown. Henry Morton Ayars, 90 Equitable Building, Boston. James Cook Ayer, Lowell. Dean Richmond Babbitt, 330 Madison, Milwaukee, Wis. Eugene Howard Babbitt, Cambridge. Charles Samuel Babcock, 2701 Michigan Ave., Chicago, 111. Wendell Baker, 22 Thomas, New York, N. Y. Thomas Tileston Baldwin, Chestnut Hill Ave., Chestnut Hill. William Woodward Baldwin, Club, New York, N. Y. AVilliam Sanford Barnes, 426 California, San Francisco, Cal. Walter Knox Barton, 1334 Vermont Ave., Washington, D. C. Boylston A. Beal. Care T. P. Beal, Second Nat. B'k, Boston. Charles F. Bigelow. Care J. F. Bigelow, 561 Broadway, N. Y. Ralph Waldo Black, West Gardner. Percy Gardner Bolster, 10 Cobden, Roxbury. William Gibson Borland, Somerset Club, Boston. William Cowper Boyden, Room 601, 225 Dearborn, Chicago, 111. 1886] 88

George Gardner Bradford. 38 Sumner, Dorchester. John Dorr Bradley, 122 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Wm. D. Brewer. Care W. H. Chard & Co., 36 So. Market, Boston. Charles Albert Brown, 61 Leonard, New York. N. Y. Crawford Richmond Brown, 16 Fairview, Dorchester. William Woodworth Bruner, 217 Geary, San Francisco, Cal. George Butler Bryant, 74 Chester Sq., Boston. Francis Billiard, 5 Mt. Vernon, Boston.

Charles C. Burnett, Keokuk, Jowa. ' Thomas Handasyd Cabot, Brookliue. Henry Lorillard Cammann, P. O. Box, 391 New York, N. Y. Prince Lucian Campbell, Monmouth, Ore. Gouverneur Morris Carnochan. Care Kidder, Peabody & Co., 1 Nassau, New York, N. Y. George Rice Carpenter, Andover. Seward Cary, 615 Delaware Ave., Buffalo, N. Y. David Blaisdell Chamberlain, West Hingham. Harold Taylor Chase, 49 S. River, Wilkes Barre, Pa. Stephen Chase, 234 Beacon, Boston. Frank Spooner Churchill, Milton. Adams Davenport Clafln, 105 Summer, Boston. David Crawford Clark, 51 Wall, New York, N. Y. Walter Thomas Cfark, 88 Windsor, Cambridge. George Wadsworth Cobb, 85 Washington, Chicago, 111. Edmund D wight Codman, 17 Brimmer, Boston. Frederic Coggeshall, 17 Story, Cambridge. Clinton Collins, 64 W. 3d, Cincinnati, O. Robert G. Cook. Care T. Hawks, 11 Grove PL, Rochester, N. Y. David Hill Cooliclge, 114 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Frederic Taber Cooper, 72 W. 48th, New York, N. Y. Arthur Deloraine Corey, Maiden. Lysander William Cushman, Newville, Cal. Arthur Kehew Day, 25 N. Main, Concord, N. H. William Richardson Dewey, P. O. Box 1571, Boston. Frank Elliot Dickerman, 85 Central, Somerville. Hugh Thompson Dickey, Jr., 473 Fifth Ave., New York. N. Y. Harrison Dike, 30 Remsen, Brooklyn, N. Y. Henry Hyde Dwight, Cambridge. Walter Howard Eclgerly, 28 State, Boston. Arthur Faulkner, Wichita, Kan. John Charles Faulkner, Keene, N. H. Irving Weatherbee Fay, Belmont, Cal. S. M. Fechheimer, SQ Garfield PL, Cincinnati, O. Ebenezer Hayward Ferry, 87 Boylston, Boston. Sewall H. Fesseuden, Jr. Care Moseley & Co., 28 State. Boston.

7 Frederic Daniell Fisk, 32 Quinc} , Cambridge. Charles Ruel Fletcher, Newton Centre. Robert Dumont Foote, Morristowu, N. J. Henry Edward Fraser, 110 Meridian, E. Boston. Frank Raven el Frost, Charleston, S. C. Lewis Pierce Frost, Arlington. Frothingham, Jamaica Plain. 89 [1886

William Morton Fullerton, Waltham. James A. Frye. Thomas Hovey Gage, Jr., Worcester. , 22 Congress, Boston. Charles Langdon Gibson, St. Luke's Hospital, 5th Ave., N. Y. Albert Augustus Gleason, Milford. Edward Borden Gray. Care Gray Bros., New Bedford. Henry Arthur Griffin. Care Harvard Club, New York, N. Y. Courtenay Guild, 26 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Binne}T Gunnison, 5 Schuyler, Boston. Frank Raymond Haley, Free Academy, Norwich, Conn. Edward Everett Hamlin, 256 Federal, Boston. George B. Harris. Care Blake Bros., P. O. Box 2148, Boston. Charles Learner Harrison, E. Walnut Hills, Cincinnati, O. Bertram Curtis Henry, 82 Summer, Boston. Henry Arnold Henshaw, Montvale. Le Roy Lincoln Hight, 503 Cumberland, Portland, Me. Benjamin Thomas Hill, Worcester. George Pepperell Frost Hobson, Wiscasset, Me. Robert Wortley Hogg, 50 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Wm. H. Holliday, Southern California Nat. Bank, Los Angeles^ Cal. Frederic Clark Hood, Boston Rubber Co., Boston. Alanson Bigelow Houghton, Corning. N. Y. Percival Spurr Howe, 132 Federal, Boston. AValter Henry Howe, Lowell. George Edwin Howes, 86 Ellery, Cambridge. |3PJohn Henry Huddleston, 1451 Tremont, Boston. Charles Otis Hurd, Haverhill. Frank Edward Hurley, Farmington, N. H. Herbert Bacon Hutchins, 446 Willoughby Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. Edward Borden Jennings, Fall River. George Frank Jewett, New Brunswick, N. J.

7 Samuel Cleaves Jones, 4 Hawthorn, Roxburj . Frank Alexander Kendall, Framingham. Nehemiah Samuel Kenison, Allenstown, N. H. Kimball, 325 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Charles E. Lamb, 206 Angell, Providence, R. I. Hammond Lamont, Albany Morning Express, Albany, N. Y. George Fortune Lapeyre, 183 St. Ann, New Orleans, La. Milton Slocum Latham, Stockb ridge. Edward T. Lee, Hartford, Conn. Charles Lester Leonard, 119 S. 4th, Philadelphia, Pa. Lowell Lincoln, 55 W. 37th, New York, N. Y. William Littauer, 578 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Alfred Henry Lloyd, Montclair, N. J. Charles Alexander Loeser, Brooklyn, N. Y. Edward Clark Lunt, Maiden. Frank Anthony Luques, Biddeford, Me. Herbert Lyman, 39 Beacon, Boston. Hall McAllister, 328 Montgomery, San Francisco, Cal. John Franklin McClure, Tribune Building, New York, N. Y. Loren Benjamin Macdonald, Wolfeboro', N. H. 1886] 90

Henry Waters Magill. Care Phoenix Ins. Co., Cincinnati, O. Frank Burr Mallory, 353 Franklin Ave., Cleveland, O. Alan Gregory Mason, 116 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. John McKinstr}T Merriam, So. Framingham. Henry Cowes Miller, Melrose. William Horatio Miller, 85 Birch, Cleveland, O. Charles Lewis Mills, Corning, N. Y. Francis Joseph Moors, 111 Devonshire, Boston. Johnson Morton, 12 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Otis Angelo Mygatt, 26 Court, Brooklyn, N. Y. Edward Hall Nichols, Reading. Gilbert C. Noble. Care A. Hinds, Cooper Union, Fourth Ave., New William Fogg Osgood, Milton. [York, N. Y. Jesse Maxwell Overton, Nashville, Tenn. Henry Ernest Oxnard, 91 Winter, Portland, Me. Franklin S. Palmer, Brookline. J. N. Palmer, Jamaica Pond Ice Co., 2389 Washington, Boston. James Henry Payne, 342 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. George Lee Peabody. Care Lee, Higginson & Co., Boston. Wilmot Grant Peirce, West Chester, Pa. Spencer Penrose, 1331 Spruce, Philadelphia, Pa. Gilman Nichols Perkins. Care Union Bank, Rochester, N. Y. Luis James Phelps, 40 W. 32d, New York, N. Y. Walter Brigham Phillips, 398 Beacon, Boston. Charles Philip Pinckard, Cincinnati, O. Horton Pope, 417 Olive, St. Louis, Mo. Charles Dudley Porter, Berlin Falls, N. H. Charles Augustus Pratt, 20 Lincoln, E. Somerville. Gustave Adolph Pudor, 134 Free, Portland, Me. Edward Everett Rankin, Washington Univ., St. Louis, Mo. John Henry Rathbone. Rathbone, Sard & Co., Chicago, 111. Thomas Walter Reynolds, 374 Pacific, Brooklyn, N. Y. Eben Richards, 315 Olive, St. Louis, Mo. Heniy Augustus Richards, Weymouth. Theodore William Richards, Cambridge. Hazen Kimball Richardson, Middleton. Jacob William Richardson, Hyde Park. Myron Wallace Richardson. Omaha, Neb. Sumner Dow Richardson, 430 Greene Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. Odin Barnes Roberts, 81 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Robert Fletcher Rogers. Care Henry C. Rogers, Washington, D. C. Edward Cavender Rowse, 30 Benton PL, St. Louis, Mo. H. E. Salisbury. Care Whiting M'f'g Co., 31 Union Sq., N. Y. George Santayana, 26 Millmont, Roxbury. Adolph Thurner Scholle, 13 E. 49th, New York, N. Y. Samuel M. Scott, 429 Washington Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. , Stockbridge. Daniel William Shea, Greenland, N. H. Walter Willard Simmons, 39 N. Harvard, Allston. Joseph Edward Sinnott, University Club, Philadelphia, Pa. William Henry Slocum, Jamaica Plain. Clarence Wright Smith, 86 Prospect, Cambridge. 91 [1887

Frank Eulkeley Smith, P. O. Box 876, Worcester. Frank Warren Smith, Mill St., Dorchester. William Lord Smith, P. O. Box 876, Worcester. Arthur Lincoln Snell, Lawrence. Shirley Robinson Snow, Auburn, N. Y. Edmund Nathaniel Snyder, 64 5th Ave., Cleveland, O. George Burbank Somers, 1034 Mission, San Francisco, Cal. Charles G. H. Stevens, Cambridge, Pa. Charles Brooks Stevens, 13 Whitfield Court, Newport, R. I. George Blanchard Stevens, Gloucester. William Abbott Stone, P. O. Box 705, Exeter, N. H. Percy Hayes Taylor, 18 Sumner, Cambridge. Charles Miner Thompson, Montpelier, Vt. John McQuaid Thompson, 1330 Washington, Boston, or 29 Hollis. Charles Hitchcock Tylor, Winchester. Frank Hamilton Underwood, Gardner St., Allston. Augustus Hugo Vogel, 83 Buffalo, Milwaukee, Wis. Camillo Von Klenze, Hofstadt 10, Marburg, Germany. Hugh Campbell Ward, Kansas City, Mo. John Bell Washburn, Plymouth. Walter B. Waterman. Care D. S. Waterman, Boylst. Nat. B'k, Boston. William G. Webster, Gen. Land Office, Washington, D. C. George Marston Weed, Newton. George Standish Weed, Plattsburgh, Clinton Co., N. Y. Frederic Coffin Weld, 127 State, Boston. Stiles Gannett Wells, 155 Boylston, Boston. Robert D. Weston-Smith, 13 Exchange, Boston. Charles N. B. Wheeler, Duxbury. George Rantoul White, Exeter, N. H. [Paris, France. Crosby C. Whitman. Care Hottinguer et Cie, 38 Rue de Provence, Hubert Granville Wilbur, City Hospital, Boston. William Rejmolds Wilson, 1517 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Irvah Lester Winter, Orchard Lake, Mich. Grenville Lindall Winthrop, Knickerbocker Club, New York, N. Y. George Whittemore Woodbury, Gloucester. , 16 W. 52d, New York, N. Y. Edward Clarence Wright, 13 Dunster, Cambridge.

1887.

Edward Stanley Abbot, 6 Larch, Cambridge. Walter Alexander, St. Charles, Mo. James Ekin Allison, Nashville, Tenn. John Lincoln Ames, Waltham. Randolph M. Appleton, Ipswich. William Channing Appleton, 64 Pleasant, Dorchester. AV alter Austin, 9 Arlington, Boston. Charles Fanning Ayer, 151 Pawtucket, Lowell. Edward Bacon, 135 E. 21st, New York, N. Y. Frederick Harold Bailey, Cambridge. George Pierce Baker, Jr., 342 Broad, Providence, R. I. Wakefield Baker, 1882 Washington, San Francisco, Cal. 1887] 92

Charles Sumner Balcombe, 24 Grove, Salem. Henry Blanchard Barber, Meaclville, Pa. Nelson Macy Barrett, Fort Payne, Ala. Charles Edmund Barrow, Skaneateles, N. Y. John M. W. Bartol, 92 Charles, Boston. Henry Willard Bean, H. 27, Cambridge. Harry Haskel Bemis, 20 Congress, Boston. Bernhard Berenson. Howard H. C. Bingham, 484 Farmington Ave., Hartford, Conn. Eldon Bisbee, 1714 N, N. W., Washington, D. C. William Holmes Black, 49 Ackley, Alleghany City, Pa. John Bapst Blake, 1330 Washington, Boston. Edward Everett Blodgett, 880 Main, Cambridge. Herbert Clifton Bourne, 48 Brenton, Cleveland, O. William Jackson Bowen, Davenport, Lincoln Co., Wash. Dwight Whitney Bowles, Springfield. Walter Lincoln Boyden, Beverly. Homer Worthington Brainard, 23 Townley, Hartford, Conn. Henry Gaw Brengle. Care H. L. Gaw & Co., Philadelphia, Pa. Richard Briggs, Jr., 445 Beacon, Boston. Elliott Bright, 33 Lee, Cambridge. Clarence Arthur Brodeur. William Allen Brooks, 27 Park, Haverhill. George Morgan Browne, 206 Beacon, Boston. Henry G. Bruce, 14 Ashland, Boston. George Faunce Buck, Stockton, Cal. Henry Augustus Buck, 101 Chambers, New York, N. Y. Edgar Buckingham, 69 Brattle, Cambridge. Julian Gerard Buckley, 54 Williams, New York, N. Y. Walter Channing Burbank, 23 Allston, Boston. Theodore Phillips Burgess, Dedham. •James McCormick Cameron, Harrisburg, Pa. Charles Churchill Carmalt, Friendsville, Susquehana Co., Pa. Charles Chollet. Bertram Fiske Clark, 106 Wabash Ave., Chicago, 111. Herbert Lincoln Clark, School Lane, Germantown, Pa. , Chestnut Hill. Frederic Shurtleff Coolidge, 114 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Daniel Thomas Costello, 709 12th, Washington, D. C. John Jerome Cotter, H. 6, Cambridge. Benjamin Francis Cox, 285 Beacon, Boston. Timothy Currier Craig, Andover Theol. Seminary, Andover. Arthur Mark Cummings, Maplewood. Guy Cunningham, 12 Hovey Gloucester. Chas. Francis Adams Currier. Care Baring Bros., London, Eng. Wilton Lincoln Currier, Jamaica Plain. John Newmarch Gushing, Jr., Newburyport. Charles Allerton Cushman, 801 Main, Cambridge. Eugene Vincent Daly, 272 Madison Ave., Albany, N. Y. Frederic Alva Dean, Petoskey, Mich. Charles Joseph Delone, Hanover, York Co., Pa. Daniel Denny, 36 Bedford, Boston. 93 [1887

Frederic Clinton DeVeau, 37 W. 127th, New York, N. Y. Gordon Dexter, Somerset Club, Boston. , 826 Beacon, Boston. Garritt Droppers, 500 10th, Milwaukee, Wis. Albertus True Dudley, Exeter, N. H. James Willard Dudley, Warsaw, N. Y. Herman Le Roy Edgar, 35 Beach, Newport, R. I. Charles Stanford Elg utter, Omaha, Neb. Edward Stanley Emeiy, 100 Pearl, Boston. William Enclicott, 3d, 165 Beacon, Boston. William Edward Faulkner, Keene, N. H. Edward Fiske, Weston. Robert Francis Fiske, Brookline. Elisha Flagg, 147 Boylston, Boston. Jefferson B. Fletcher, Hotel Bristol, 42d St. & Fifth Ave., New York. Walter Forchheimer, 125 W. 9th, Cincinnati, O. Chauncey Charles Foster, Station J, New York, N. Y. George Waldo Foster, 7 Evergreen Ave., Somerville. Ditlev G. M. Frederiksen, 357 E. Ohio, Chicago, 111. Robert Warner Frost, Oakland, Brighton. Albert Fuller, 68 Winthrop, Taunton. |yGeorge Pope Furber, 446 Shawmut Ave., Boston. W. F. Ganong, 646 Cambridge, Cambridge. Alfred Augustus Gardner, 160 Broadway, New York, N. Y. Edgar Malcolm Garnett, 35 Essex, San Francisco, Cal. Carl August de Gersdorff, 50 W. 47th, New York, N. Y. Charles Ingalls Giddings, Beverly. Bancroft Lane Goodwin, P. O. Box 333, Newton. John Henry Gray, 22 Karlstr. II, Halle a. Saale, Germany. William Travers Gray, 31 Washington Sq., New York, N. Y. Harris Grafton Hale, Andover Theol. Seminary, Andover. Franklin E. E. Hamilton. Care Rev. J. W. Hamilton, 85 Lexington, Alpheus Sumner Hardy, 4£ Sears Building, Boston. [E. Boston. Augustus Story Haskell, W. Roxbury. Maurice Heckscher, 260 S. 18th, Philadelphia, Pa. William Collins Herron, 19 Pike, Cincinnati, O. William Andrew Hervey, "Eagle" Office, Brooklyn, N. Y. Louis Hicks, 209 W. 14th, New York, N. Y. George Higginson, 3d, Lenox. Joseph Baker Hileman, Altoona, Blair Co., Pa. William Charles Hille brand, 16 Clark, Cincinnati, O. Charles Frank Hoover, Miamisburg, Montgomery Co., O. Silas Arnold Houghton, 12 Cordis, Charlestown. M. A. de W. Howe. Care Perry Mason & Co., Boston. Willard Bean Howe, 54 Methuen, Lowell. Gorhain Hubbard, 210 Beacon, Boston. Charles Hudson. Care E. T. V. & G. R'y, Knoxville, Tenn. Frederick Everett Hughes, 129 Perkins, Somerville. Atherton Nash Hunt, Weymouth. Thomas Hunt, 94 Prescott, Cambridge. Francis Cleaveland Huntington, Cambridge. Byron Satterlee Hurlbut, Cambridge. 1887] 94

Louis Fiske Hyde, Brookfield. Janies Marsh Jackson, 84 Dudley, Roxbury. Lesly A. Johnson. Care H. A. Johnson, 27 Kilby, Boston. Lewis Jerome Johnson, 24 S. Bow, Milford. Francis Richard Jones, 273 Newbury, Boston. Lombard Carter Jones, 314 Columbus Ave., Boston. Frank Edge Kavanagh, Hawley, Pa. Hiram Gillett Keays, Elkhart, Logan Co., 111. Roger Wolcott Keep, Lockport, N. Y. Christian Kestner, Reading, Pa. Henry Wilder Kej'es, 88 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Kimball, P. O. Box 467, Maynard. George Perkins Knapp, Hartford Theol. Sem., Hartford, Conn. John Holly Knapp, Jr., Menomonie, Wis. Augustus Smith Knight, 5 Dexter Row, Charlestown. John Webster Knowles, P. O. Box 64, New Bedford. Hamilton Kuhn, 64 Beacon, Boston. George Edgar Ladd, corner Pleasant and Chadwick, Bradford. William Walton Linn, Decatur, 111. Everett Starr Litchfield, Wollaston. Henry Jarvis Livermore, 24 North Ave., Cambridge. Myron Augustus Lochman, 34 Wendell, Cambridge. Howard Augustus Lothrop, Sharon. Charles Elliot Loud, 135 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Linn Luce. Edward Manley, Illinois State Normal University, Normal. 111. Frederic Hubbell Marvin. Fred Sumner Mead, 284 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Edwin Joseph Meeks, 50 E. 83d, New York, N. Y. Francis Michael, 1371 Gough, San Francisco, Cal. Morton D. Mitchell, " Herald " Office, Boston. George Austin Morrison, Jr., 691 5th Ave., New York, N. Y. John Lovett Morse, P. O. Box 151, Taunton. George Saltonstall Mumford, Rochester, N. Y. Frank Nelson Nay, 8 Warren, Roxbury.

Frank Walter Nicolson, S. 19, Cambridge ; Spring Hill, N. S. Walter Oakes, Otis Briggs Oakman, Cambridge. Arthur Henry Osgood, Highland Ave., Somerville. Robert Treadwell Osgood, 15 Lancaster, Cambridge.

Edward Christopher Palmer, Jr. , 393 Dearborn Ave. , Chicago, 111. Francis Sterne Palmer, P. O. Box 21, Plattsburgh, N. Y. Frank Claflin Parmenter, Gloucester. Charles S. Pastorius, P. 0. Box 27, Colorado Springs, Colo.

T Harry E. Peabod} , Yale Divinity School, New Haven, Conn. Lincoln Rea Peabody, 19 Chestnut, Salem. Joseph Hall Pearl, 1~29 Main, Bradford. Albert Thompson Perkins, C, B. & Q. R. R., Chicago, 111. Henry Grover Perkins, 39 Hartford, Dorchester. Samuel Welsh Perkins, 41 Wall, New York, N. Y. Walter Samuel Pinkham, Wollaston. Alfred Arthur Poey, 7 E. 31st, New York, N. Y. 95 [1887

William Sears Poppleton, 1560 Sherman Ave., Omaha, Neb. Albert Bailey Potter, Newton. Milford Seward Power, 583 Broadway, So. Boston. Whitrnore Preston, Faulkner Manufacturing Co., N. Billerica. Charles Seward Proctor, 197 Central, Lowell. Frank Iugersoll Proctor, 369 Marlborough, Boston. George Jacob Putnam, 273 Beacon, Boston. George Totten Quinby, 27 E. 38th, New York, N. Y. Augustus Neal Rantoul, Salem. Charles William Rantoul, Jr., Abbot St., Beverly. Franklin Remiugton, Cazenovia, N. Y. Paul Revere Reynolds, 236 Clarendon, Boston. Thomas N. Rhinelander, 10 W. 28th, New York, N. Y. Fred Ball Rice, Quincy. Edgar Judson Rich, 2 Durfee, Fall River. John Wallace Riddle. Royal Robbius, 44 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Alfred Brookes Robinson, 53 W. 48th, New York, N. Y. Benjamin Lincoln Robinson, P. O. Box 1066, Bloomington, 111. James Harvey Robinson, Bloomington, 111. Thomas Johns Robinson, E. Taunton. William Sanford Robinson, Cambridge. Emery Herman Rogers, D.Webster King Glue Co., Chicago, 111. Russell, Milton. Philip Sidney Rust, 254 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Robert de Wolfe Sampson, 2 W. 51st, New York, N. Y. William Saulsbury, Dover, Del. Henry Schofield, Dudley. George Martin Seeley, 31 E. 39th, New York, N. Y. Charles Edward Shattuck, Winchester. Eugene Rodman Shippen, D. 21, Cambridge. Arthur C. Smith, corner 1st Ave. and 8th, Council Bluffs, Iowa. Charles Gaston Smith, 2482 Washington, Roxbury. Horace Eugene Smith, 1213 Walnut, Philadelphia, Pa. Samuel Herbert Smith, Arlington. William K. Smith, 351 3d, Portland, Ore. John Linzee Snelling, Dedham. Frank Chester Southworth, Harvard Divinity School, Cambridge. Walter Raymond Spalding, 13 Follen, Cambridge. Stephen Berrien Stanton, 330 E. 17th, New York, N. Y. Livingston Boyd Stedman, H'ke 33, Cambridge. Pearl Lambert Sternbergh, Reading, Pa. Albert Eugene Sterne, 48 and 50 E. 2d, Cincinnati, O. Samuel Storrow, 417 Beacon, Boston. Frank Caleb Stowell, Somerville. John Osborne Sumner, Cedar Sq., corner Thornton, Roxbury. Winthrop Tisdale Talbot, 66 Marlborough, Boston. Elwood Gardner Tewksbury, 34 Pinckney, E. Somerville. Aaron Claflin Thaj'er, Milford. Henry Adams Thayer, Haworth, North Park, Col. Charles Sproull Thompson, 111. Cent. R. R., Chicago, 111. Ernest Alexander Thomson, 298 Madison Ave., N. Y. 1887] 96

Barclay Tilton, 255 Newbury, Boston. Robert Truslow, 96 Brooklyn Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. Joseph B. T. Tuthill, Riverview Academy, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. George Herman Tuttle, Acton. Alfred Lee Tyler, Anniston, . Frank Vogel, 53 B, So. Boston. Theodore C. Von Storch, 1609 N. Main Ave., Scranton, Pa. Frank Lawson Walker, Beverly. Joseph Eugene Walker, Media, Pa. Eugene Carroll Webster, Maiden. Alonzo Rogers Weed, Newton. Winthrop Wetherbee, 146 Marlborough, Boston. Arthur William Wheelright, 129 Beacon, Boston. Sumner Wheeler White, 27 W. 55th, New York, N. Y. George Gill Whitelaw, 2627 Park Ave., St. Louis, Mo. Benjamin Whitney, 8 Bosworth, Boston. Frank Beecher Wiestling, P. O. Box 115, Harrisburg, Pa. Waldo Wickham Willard, 100 Bellingham, Chelsea. Harry Johnson Wood. Care C. B. Woods & Co., 28 Reeds Block,

James Haughton Woods, 2 Chestnut, Boston. . [Thayer, Boston. Richard Augustus Zerega, 38 W. 48th, New York, N. Y. Oscar Theodore Zinkeisen, 317 Powell, San Francisco, Cal. 1888. Walter Abbott, 35 Oliver, Boston. Charles Francis Adams, Jr., Quincy. George Lockhart Allen, Salem. William Sylvester Allen, Greenfield. Copley Arnory, Somerset Club, Boston. Larz Anderson, 1530 K, N. W. Washington, D. C. James Waldingfield Appleton, Ipswich. Gaston Meares Ashe, 2315 Sacramento, San Francisco, Cal. James Walker Austin, Charlestown. James Alderson Bailey, Jr., Arlington. Franklin Greene Balch, Jamaica Plain. Charles Handy Baldwin, 53 W. 3d, Cincinnati, O. Wilder Dwight Bancroft, , Cambridge. William Barnes, Jr., 229 State, Albany, N. Y. John Daniel Barry, 855 E. 5th, So. Boston. Nathaniel Edward Bartlett, Wakefield. William Beals, Jr., 125 Newbury, Boston. Joseph Irving Bennett, Chestnut Hill Ave., Brighton. William Bayard de Billier, Yonkers, N. Y. William J. A. Bliss, 820 Connecticut Ave., Washington, D. C. Edward Ludlam Blossom, 440 Henry, Brooklyn, N. Y. Melvin Edward Boas. Maxime Bdcher, 12 Holyoke PL, Cambridge. Charles Bohlen. Care R. C. McMurtrie, Bullitt B'lcl'g, Phila. Wilfred Bolster, 10 Cobden, Roxbury. Fordyce Huntington Bottum, New Haven, Vt. Joseph Henry Bowen, Fall River. 97 [1888

Frederic Josiah Bradlee, 247 Marlborough, Boston. Graham Hunting Brewer, So. Orange, N. J. George Atwood Brock, Yale Divinity School, New Haven, Conn. Causten Brown, Jr., Salt Lake City, Utah. Thomas Q. Brown, Jr. Care Brown, Be£die & Co., Valparaiso, So. Walter Franklin Brush, Tarrytown, N. J. [America. Myron Luther Bruuer, Wilbraham. Cyril Herbert Burdett, Wakefield. Arthur Fierce Butler, San Francisco, Cal. Charles Mills Cabot, Brookline. George Albert Carpenter, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Benjamin French Carpenter, Chicago, 111. Percy Chase, 47 Baltimore, Lynn. Harry Durant Cheever, New York, N. Y. Richard Percy Chittenden, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Charles Francis Choate, Jr., Southboro'. Asaph Churchill, Alban St., Dorchester. Charles Worcester Clark, W. Roxbur}-. Henry M. Clark, Jr. Care Warren & Co., Devonshire, Boston. Marshall Bidwell Clarke, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Frederic Percival Clement, Rutland, Vt. Marshall Hill Clyde. | Care W. P. Clyde & Co., 35 Broadway, Thomas Clyde, 3d. f New York, N. Y. Stephen R. H. Codman, 17 Brimmer, Boston. Charles Northend Cogswell, -^ to ) m &• i ^ i n u ' .-, . ,, y 61 Kirkland, Cambridge. T3 n ' & George Proctor Cogswell, j George Washington Cram, 209 Adams, Chicago, 111. Kendall Fox Crocker, 84 Prescott, Fitchburg. Alan Cuningham. Curtis, Jr., 8 Joy, Boston. Francis Bryden Dana, 788 Broadway, So. Boston. John Dane, 451 Marlborough, Boston. William Peck Daniels, 73 E. 127, New York, N. Y. Walter Dorsey Davidge, Jr., 1624 H, N. W. Washington, D. C. Thomas Drummoncl Davidson, 1117 Hyde, San Francisco, Cal. Chandler Davis. Care G. Davis, 52 Wall, New York, N. Y. Frank Lincoln Dean, 14 Cedar, Worcester. F. H. Dewart. David Taggart Dickinson, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Henry Beekman Drake, 16 Ash, Cambridge. Russell Duane, 115 N. 34th, Philadelphia, Pa. Carroll Everett Edson, 249 Warren, Roxbury. Henry Edwards, Quincy. John Rice Eldridge, Barton Vineyard, Fresno, Cal. Wendell Phillips Elkins, Andover. N. H. Carl Adolf Ewald, Deckertown, N. J. Frank Lewis Fales. Charles Ernest Farnum, P. O. Box 336, Quincy. Herbert Haviland Field, 8 Harris, Cambridge. Grover Flint, 418 5th Ave., New York, N. Y. Walter Greenwood Forsyth, Weymouth. William Everett Fowler, Sandersonville. 1888] 98

Carleton Shurtleff Francis. Brookline. Charles Friend, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Robert Higginson Fuller, Deerfield.

Horace Howard Furness, Jr., ) 222 W. Washington Sq., Phila-

William Henry Furness, 3d. j delphia, Pa. Herbert Elbridge Gale, 36 Summer, Haverhill. William Wakefield Gale. Exeter, N. H. James Gallivan, Ambrose r 3/ Bolton, So. Boston. Gallivan, William Joseph j Lloyd McKirn Garrison, Llewellyn Park, Orange, N. J. Marshall John Gasquet, 617 Charles Ave., New Orleans, La. Arthur Park Gay. P. O. Box 1602, Boston. George Bruno de Gersdorff, Stockbridge. H. B. Gibson, Agricul. Experiment Station, Middletown, Conn. Henry Lathrop Gilbert, Gilberts ville, Otsego Co., N. Y. Clarence Willard Gleason, Roxbury Latin School, Roxbury. Sidney Gleason, W. Medford. Gustavus A. Goebel, Chicago, 111. Samuel Amory Goodhue, Salem. Josiah Ferdinand Gooding. 96 Prescott, Cambridge. Ernest Barron Gordon, 1#2 W. Brookline, Boston. Perley William Graham. Chateaugay, Franklin Co., X. Y. Charles Lamson Griffin. Keene, N. H. Herbert Dudley Hale, 39 Highland, Roxbury. George Gilman Hall. 690 Broadway, Chelsea. Samuel Stickney Hall, 2715 N, N."W. Washington, D. C. James Mott Hallowell, W. Medford. Cosmond Rose Hammerslough, The Dakota, New York, N. Y. Philip Melancthon Hammett. Horace Ware Hanson, Salem. James Francis Harlow, Quincy. Edward Avery Harriman, Framingham. Edward Bristol Harvey, 433 Lin wood Ave., Buffalo, N. Y. Charles Hamant Harwood, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Gustavus Hay, Jr., 91 Charles. Boston. Henry Edgar Hayes, 3 Columbia Sq., Boston. William Pride Henderson, Linden Ave., Roxbury. Homer Winthrop Hervey, Hawthorn, Xew Bedford. Norman Francis Hesseltine. Melrose. Albert Fairchild Holden, Salt Lake City, L'tah. Daniel Curtis Holder, Jr.. 123 Milk, Boston. Oscar Howe Holder, 288 Beacon, Boston. Robert Afton Holland, Jr., Lawrence Hall 17, Cambridge. Lockwood Honore, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. [Boston. Walter Gregg Horton, P. O. Box 1862, or 41 Commonwealth Ave., Edward Sturges Hosmer, 1330 L, N. W. Washington, D. C. Arthur Lincoln Howard, 826 Main, Cambridge. Arthur Cornelius Jackson, 364 Genesee, Utica, N. Y. Herbert Keightley Job, So. Walpole. Arthur Treadway Johnson, Littleton. Charles Francis Kahnweiler. 170 AY. 47th, New York, N. Y. Francis Demetrius Kalopothakes, Athens, Greece. 99 [1888

Lindley Miller Keasbey, 20 Stratford PL, Newark, N. J. Fred. Keffer Kelham, Cambridge. Michael Edward Kelley, 21 Tremout, Cambridge. Ralph Averill Kellogg^ Plattsburg, N. Y. Frederic Hedge Kermard, Brookline. Edward Hamilton Kidder, St. Mark's School, Soivthboro'. Willard Robert Kimball, 4132 Indiana Ave., Chicago, 111. Frank Wallace Knowles, The Alcline, Newark, N. J.

7 Perry Lawton, Quincj . William Augustine Leahy, 53 G, So. Boston. George Bridge Leighton, 204 N. 31, St. Louis, Mo. Robert Hamilton Leland, Sherborn. George Heydenfeldt Lent, 699 Polk, San Francisco, Cal.' Robert Coleman Le Roy, 105 E. 18th, New York, N. Y. Leo R. Lewis. Charles J. Livingood, Reading, Pa. James Loeb, 37 E 38th, New York, N. Y. Fred Bates Lund, Harvard Medical School, Boston. John White McCammon, 18 Trowbridge PL, Cambridge. Samuel Foster McCleary, Jr., Harvard, Brookline. Rowland Blennerhassett Mahany, Buffalo, N. Y. Richard Clarke Manning, Jr., Salem. Francis Skiddy Marden, 640 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Alexander Beckwith Marks, Natchez, Miss. George Edward Marsh, Jr., 362 Harvard, Cambridge. Edward Campbell Mason, Arlington. Harry Lowell Mason, 39 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. George Herbert Mead. Frederick H. Means, Yale Divinity School, New Haven, Conn. William Stetson Merrill, Newberry Library, Chicago, 111. Henry Fessenden Meserve, 616 3d, Seattle, Wash. [Conn.

Harry Roberts Miles, Racine,Wis. , or 76 W. Divinity Hall, New Haven, Sidney Roby Miner, 130 S. Franklin, Wilkes Barre, Pa. William Mitchell, Kendall ville, Ind. Charles De Vercl Musaus, Cambridge. William Nelson, Nashville, Tenn. William Kimball Norton, Lawrence. Peter Joseph O'Callaghan, 104 E. 89th, New York, N. Y. Robert Lee Overton, Nashville, Tenn. Herman Page, Episcopal Theological School, Cambridge. , Jr., 6 Joy, Boston. Bradley Webster Palmer, 125 S. Franklin, Wilkes Barre, Pa. Frank Dixon Peale, Lockhaven, Pa. Edward Allen Pease, 291 W. Chester Park, Boston. Henry Pennypacker, 71 St. James PL, Brooklyn, N. Y. Valentine Mott Pierce, 663 Maine, Buffalo, N. Y. Edmund Piatt, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. Frederic Plummer, Auburndale. Henry M. Plummer, New Bedford. Henry Temple Pope, Fort Paine, Ala. Charles Allen Porter, 5 Arlingtou, Boston. Edward Bigley Pratt, Hingham Centre. 1888] 100

Henry Allston Pulsford, So. Orange, N. J. George Royal Pulsifer, Auburndale, or Herald Building, Boston. AVilliain Henry Rand, 96 Prescott, Cambridge. Albert Wood Rantoul, Beverley. John Earle Reynolds, Meadville, Pa. George Joseph Richards, Weymouth. Charles Butler Rogers, 291 Genesee, Utica, N. Y. William Ropes, 28 Remsen, Brooklyn, N. Y. Henry W. Sampson, New York, N. Y. W. S. Sanford, Sanford, Fla. Edward Hosmer Savary, 381 Dorchester, Boston. James Alfred Saxe, ) ^ xr v lr°y *' Xm John Walter Saxe, } ' Bernard Turner Schermerhorn, Dedham. John Hunter Sedgwick, 160 W. 59th, New York, N. Y. Thomas Taylor Seelye, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. John Merwine Seip. Charles Tildon Sempers, D. 16, Cambridge. Jeremiah M. Shahan, 23 Irving, Cambridge. Herman Thyng Shepard, W. Epping, N. H. Thomas Osborne Shepard, Salem. Ferdinand Shoninger, P. O. Box 5321, Boston. Allan Thacher Simpkins, 3820 Washington Ave., St. Louis, Mo. Chauncey Smith, Jr., 121 Brattle, Cambridge. Eugene Sondheim, 119 W. 130th, New York, N. Y. Edward William Spalding, Cambridge. William Stuart Spaulding, 23 Broad, Boston. Frederick Dudley Stetson, New Bedford. Edmund Channing Stowell, Roxbury. Lynde Sullivan, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. William Lawson Sumrall, Danville, Ky. Harold Swain, 32 Nassau, New York, N. Y. Solomon Louis Swarts, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Edward Wyllys Taylor, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Ezra Ripley Thayer, 5 Phillips PL, Cambridge. Lucian S. Thayer. William Goodrich Thompson, 62 Buckingham, Cambridge. Harvey Parker Towle, Somerville. Edward Warren Trull, Tewksbury. George E. W. Ullrich, 587 La Salle, Chicago, 111. Ralph Henry Van Deman, Delaware, O. John W. H. Walden, 13 Mt. Auburn, Cambridge. Ervin Wardman. Care N. Y. Tribune, New York, N. Y. Henry S. Wardner, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Edward R. Warren, Brookline. Farrington Hasham Whipple, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Walter Marinus Willett, 207-209 Federal, Boston. Frank Backus Williams, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. Frank Beverly Williams, H'ke 12, Cambridge. John Walter Wood, Jr., So. Orange, N. J. Francis Call Woodman, 15 E. 16th, New York, N. Y. AVilliam McMichael Woodworth, 147 Brattle, Cambridge. Julius Freiberg AVorkum, Harvard Law School, Cambridge. 101 [1889

1889.

S. R. Albee, 30 Essex, Cambridgeport. B. McV. Allison. O. M. Anderson. Care of A. J. Anderson, Neligh, Neb. Herbert F. Atkins. Charles C. Ayer, 318 Shawmut Ave., or 44 Concord Sq., Boston. Irving Babbitt, Locust, Cincinnati, O. H. L. Bailey, 5 Elmer, Cambridge. Robert S. Baldwin, 81 Chatham, Worcester. Alexander G. Barrett, 1334 4th, Louisville, Ky. Paul Bartholow, 1525 Locust, Philadelphia, Pa. R. W. E. Bassett, Salem, N. J. Charles C. Batchelder, 50 Globe Building, Boston. Edward C. Bates, Westborough. Arthur C. Bent, Taunton. Frederick H. Bent, Taunton. W. B. Bentley, Maple Valley, N. Y. William R. Bigelow, Nntick. G. H. Black, Washington, D. C. A. G. Brodhead, Wilkes-Barre, Pa. G. W. W. Brewster, 70 Kilby, Boston. Care of J. F. F. Brewster. Frederick M. Brooks, 158 W. Newton, Boston. Frederick M. Brown. Clarence A. Bunker, 10 Juniper, Roxbury. J. C. B. Burbank, Henderson, K}\ W. F. Burdett, 143 Main, Marlborough. Allston Burr, Newton. George T. Burrows, Madison, Wis. Robert W. Bush, West Newton. George P. Butters, 74 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. W. H. Butters, 74 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Alfred P.* Butterworth, Station C, Cincinnati, O. Richard C. Cabot, Brookline. Harrison K. Caner, 315 S. 17th, Philadelphia, Pa. G. D. Chase, 79 Agricultural Ave., Taunton. J. B. Chittenden, 140 Mt. Auburn, Cambridge. Walter D. Clark, New York, N. Y. Collier Cobb, Wilson, N. C. Philip Cod man, Brookline. Charles F. Cogswell, 347 Main, Charlestown. Charles Copeland, 331 Walnut Ave., Roxbmy. Andrew F. Craven, 42 Mt. Auburn, Cambridge. H. B. Crowl, 113 Clinton, Cleveland, O. Richard L. Curran, 33 Genesee, Utica, N. Y. Herbert H. Darling, M. 14, Cambridge. Charles B. Davenport, 11 Garden PL, Brooklyn, N. Y. John T. Davis Jr. Care of Samuel C. Davis & Co., St. Louis, Mo. George L. Deblois, 253 Beacon, Boston. Philip Dexter, 18 Exeter, Boston. R. E. N. Dodge, South, Brookline. C. Downer, W. 21, Cambridge. 1889] 102

Edward M. Duff, Waterloo, N. Y. S. R. Dunham, 549 Pleasant, Maiden. Charles B. Dunlap, Indian Creek, AY. Ya. Randall N. Durfee, Fall River. Ernest W. Dustan, 45 Chestnut, Boston. Francis G. Eaton, 1621 Olive, St. Louis, Mo. "William S. Ellis, Bryn Mawr, Montgomery Co., Pa. John Endicott, Beverly. Frederick W. Faxon, 100 School, Roxbury. L. E. Frank, 17 E. 61st, New York, N. Y. Alfred C. Garrett, Logan Sta., Philadelphia, Pa. Marcus L. Gerstle, 1517 Yan Ness Ave., San Francisco, Cal. William F. Giese, 405 AYashington, Somerville. Henry S. Glazier, 17 E. 67th, New York, N. Y. Joseph L. Goodale. Care Prof. G. L. Goodale, Cambridge. Frederick Green, 48 Buckingham, Cambridge. Walter C. Green, 73 Middle, Gloucester. Carleton Greene. Care G. S. Greene, Jr., Dept. of Docks, Pier A, Edward W. Grew, 89 Beacon, Boston. [New York, N. Y. Leon S. Griswold, 238 Boston, Dorchester. Bernard G. Gunther, 184 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Eisner C. Gunther, 184 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. Prescott F. Hall, Brookline. Victor M. Harding, 2536 Indiana Ave., Chicago, 111. Gilman S. Harvey, Gloucester. Thomas S. Hathaway, New Bedford. E. W. Hawley, 521 Eight Ave., S. E. Minneapolis, Minn. John Russell Hayes, West Chester, Pa. Fred E. Havnes, Marlborough. A. P. Hebard, 1618 Olive, St. Louis, Mo. A. Henshaw, 235 McMillan St., Walnut Hills, Cincinnati, O. C. A. Hight, Portland, Me. Samuel D. Hildreth, Gloucester. Edward Hobart, E. Bridge water. Almon D. Hodges, 26 Perrin, Roxbuiy. Guy H. Holliday, 26 Fountain, Roxbuiy. Alexander Holmes, Kingston. James E. Homans, Irvington-on-Hudson, N. Y. Louis L. Hooper, Washington, D. C, or H'ke 45, Cambridge. G. S. Howe. Haverhill. Morton D. Hull, 69 Metropolitan Building. Chicago. 111. L. Hulley, Lewisburg, Pa. Carleton Hunneman, 7 Perrin, Roxbuiy. George L. Hunter, Cambridge. F. E. Huntress, 318 Elm, Somerville. Walter P. Hutchinson. 25 Brooks, Somerville. Frederick B. Jacobs. W. Scituate. Edward L. Jellinek, Buffalo, N. Y. Walter L. Jennings, 17 Maple Ave.. Cambridgeport. H. P. Johnson, Everett. Olin C. Joliue, Tottenville. N. Y. Henry T. Kellogg. Plattsburg, N. Y. 103 [1889

G. T. Keyes, 88 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. M. D. Kimball, 325 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. James G. King, 7 University- PL, New York, N. Y. E. N. Kirby, Cambridge. A. H. Knapp, 25 W. 24th, New York, N. Y. Frank E. Lane, Arlington. Prof. H. B. Lathrop, 46 North Ave., Cambridge, or Geneva, N. Y. George D. Latimer, 366 40th, Chicago, 111. Robert G. Leavitt, DeVeaux College, Suspension Bridge, N. Y. G. W. Lee, Brookline. William A. Lefavour, 16 Washington St., Beverly. Frederick B. Lord, S. 19, Cambridge. Rev. C. W. Luck, Topsfield. Philip M. Lydig, 58 Wall, New York, N. Y. C. C. McGehee, 497 Peachtree, Atlanta, Ga. Walter W. Mackay, Englewood, N. J. Walter W. Magee, 201 Seymour, S}T racuse, N. Y. G. H. Mairs, 15 E. 57th, New York, N. Y. J. T. Malone, 136 W. 126th, New York, N. Y. G. S. Mandell, 324 Washington, Boston. Samuel C. Mauley, Augusta, Me. Milton M. Marble, Marshall, Mich. Philip Marquand, Newbuiyport. W. R. Marsh, 60 Front, Weymouth. James M. Marvin, 3 Franklin Sq., Saratoga Springs, N. Y. G. H. Maynadier, 9 Plympton, Cambridge. H. E. Meeker, 1 Broadway, New York, N. Y. J. D. Merrirl, Lawrence. J. W. Merrill, Cambridge. William L. Monro, 13 S. 14th, Pittsburg, Pa. Clifford H. Moore, Belmont, Cal. J. P. Morgan, Jr., 219 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. L. H. Morgan, Scott Circle, Washington, D. C. Walter Naumburg, 657 Broaclwa}-, New York, N. Y. James M. Newell, 241 Walnut Ave., Roxbury. Joseph Nickerson, 10 Mason, Cambridge. A. A. W. Niedermann, 548 Scott, Milwaukee, Wis. J. P. Nielcls, Wilmington, Del. G. H. Norman, Jr., 343 Beacon, Boston. William R. Odell, 560 Dearborn Ave., Chicago, 111. S. D. Oppenheim, New York, N. Y. Henry W. Packard, 98 Lafayette, Salem. G. B. Painter, Pittsburg, Pa. F. E. Parker. Care of Addison Gage & Co., State, Boston. Lasell E. Partridge, Orland, Me. Wesley Paul, E. Saugus. John S. Phelps, 768 Boston, Lynn. William F. Pillsbury, Champaign, 111. Alfred C. Potter, College Library, Cambridge. Oliver Prescott, Jr., New Bedford. James D. Prindle, Jr., 179 Summer, Somerville. James H. Proctor, 327 Beacon, Boston. 1889] 104

"William G. Rantoul, Salem. F. O. Raymond, 86 Main, Haverhill. George Reisner, 241 N. Tennessee, Indianapolis, Ind. Philip M. Reynolds, 236 Clarendon, Boston. Charles A. Rich, Canton, N. Y. "William Francis Richards, Newport, N. H. M. W. Richardson. Care of Dr. E. P. Miller, Fitchburg. James H. Ropes, Andover. Irving A. Ruland. 292 Greene Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. H. L. Russell, Norway. Me. "William R. Salisbury, 4 E. 58th, New York, N. Y. P. L. Saltonstall Chestnut Hill. Ambrose C. Saunders, 169 Cambridge, E. Cambrido-e. Caleb M. SaviUe, Medford. H. M. Sears, 51 Beacon, Boston. Joseph H. Sears. Care of J. Henry Sears & Co.. 92 State, Boston. Philip S. Sears, 51 Beacon, Boston. George H. Shattuck, "Winchester. Frank P. Sheldon, 1001 Golden Gate Ave., San Francisco. Cal. E. E. Shoemaker, Dalton, Pa. W. H. Siebert, 299 S. Front, Columbus, O. Charles H. Slattery. 176 7th, S. Boston James "W. Smith, 374 Essex, Salem. John R. Smith, Salem. Louis F. Snow, 14 Trowbridge PL, Cambridge. James S. Stone, 131 Vernon, Newton. Edward C. Storrow. Brookline. Henry P. Strong, "Washington, D. C. Randolph C. Surbridge, Denver, Col. T. S. Tailer, 11 Washington Sq. N., New York, N. Y. T. Talbot, N. Billerica. M. Allison Taylor, Haverhill. Charles M. Thayer. "Worcester. Frank "W. Thayer, 79 Summer, Lowell. "William H. Thayer, 205 Newbury, Boston. Albert W. Tolman, Brunswick, Me. Robert E. Townsend. 101 Mt. Vernon, Boston. Perry D. Trafford, 75 Rock, Fall River. Arthur Trail, Frederick. Md. George E. Turnure, 417 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y. A. W. Vorse, "Wellesley Hills. Clarence Allen Wait, Decatur. 111. R. V. DeW. Walsh. 7 S. Hawk, Albany, N. Y. R. DeC. Ward, 21 Chestnut, Boston. Charles Warren, Dedham. William H. Warren, 34^ Shepard, Cambridge. Benjamin Weaver, Everett House, New York, N. Y. Bernard C. Weld, Jamaica Plain. Elmer L. Wengren, Mellen. Portland, Me. Charles D. Wetmore, Jamestown. N. Y. Henry R. White, Arlington Heights. James E. Whitney, Jr., Box 3566. Boston. 105 [1889

Morris Whitridge, Baltimore, Mel. Raymond S. Wilder, 13 Lancaster, N. Cambridge. M. Winkler, 97 Dayton St., Cincinnati, O. Thornton Woodbury, 16 W. 52d, New York, N. Y. George E. Wright, Town send. Frank E. Zinkeisen, 406 Keene, Milwaukee, Wis. A LIST OF THE NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF SURVIVING MASTERS OF ARTS OF HARVARD UNIVERSITY, including Doctors of Philosophy, and persons who received the degree of a.m. with that of b.d., ll.b., or m.d., but excluding Masters and Doctors who are also Bachelors of Arts of Harvard College.

*** The arrangement is chronological.

1874 James Olney Averill. Care the Registrar of Amherst College, Amherst. Prof. Marshman Edward Wadsworth, Houghton, Mich. 1877 Stephen Perry Sturges, 55 Liberty, New York, N. Y. Prof. John Williams White, 18 Concord Ave., Cambridge. 1878 Prof. Edward Asahel Birge, University of Wis., Madison, Wis. Pres. Granville Stanley Hall, Clark University, Worcester. Rufus Phillips Williams. Care the Registrar of Dartmouth College, Hanover, N. H. 1879 Melville Madison Bigelow, 63 Sparks, Cambridge. 1881 Edwin Howard Lord, Wolfeborough, N. H. 1883 Henry Churchill King, Oberlin, O. Duren James Henderson Ward, 109 W. 54th, New York, N. Y.

1884 Prof. Horace Addison Hoffmann, Ind. Univ. , Bloomington, Ind. Harry W. Mack, 120 Broadway, New Y'ork, N. Y. Henry Melville, 32 Nassau, New lr ork, N. Y. Walter Ferris Price, Haverford College Grammar Sch., Haver- ford College P. O., Pa. Theodore Lyman Wright. Care the Registrar of Beloit College, Beloit, Wis. 1885 Alexander George McAdie, Clark University, Worcester. Prof. James Rignall Wheeler, University of Vt., Burlington, Vt. George Reavis Hughes, 112 W. Markham, Little Rock, Arkan. 1886 Alexander Tison, Imperial University, Tokyo, Japan. Rev. Edward Ernest Atkinson. Care Epis. Theol. School, Rev. William Albert Buxton, Pierre, S. Dakota. [Cambridge. Prof. Orrin Benner Clark, Ind. University, Bloomington, Ind. James Thorne Fairchild. Care Oberlin College, Oberlin, O. Eugene Hiawatha Foster. Care the Registrar of Antioch Coll., Y'ellow Springs, O. Rev. Alfred Wilhelm Martin, Chelsea. Dr. Charles Schram, 344 E. 84th, New York, N. Y. 1887 Edward Chenery Gale, Minneapolis, Minn. Frank Avrin Houghton, Chicago Lawn, 111. Thomas Spencer Jerome, Detroit, Mich. Joseph Lybrand Markley, Grays 43, Cambridge. George Richard Rodemann, 33 Broad, Elizabeth, N. J. Frederic Morse Smith, Hartford, Conn. Dr. George Otis Ward, Worcester. 107

Rev. Henry Arthur Whitman, Charleston, S. C. Philip Green Wright, Med ford. John Jay McKelvey, 10 Wall, New York, N. Y. 1888 Solon Irving Bailey, 38 Chester, Somerville. William Hamilton Cowles. Care Rossington, Smith & Dallas, Topeka, Kan. August Frederic Foerste, 9 Story, Cambridge. Herman Wadsworth Haley, 46 North Ave., Cambridge. Albert Walker Hinds, West Boylston. Carl Friedrich Richard Hochclorfer, 19 Ware, Cambridge. Homer Hosea Johnson, 236 Superior, Cleveland, O. Blewett Harrison Lee, U. S. Supreme Court Room, Washing- Adolph Caspar Miller, Weld 7, Cambridge. [ton, D. C. Wallace Clement Sabine, 53 Trowbridge, Cambridge. William Albert Setchell, Shepherd 1, Cambridge. Rev. Ernest Charles Smith, Seattle, Wash. William Henry Snyder, Alfred, Me. 1889 Frederick Anderegg, Gray St., Cambridge. Prof. William Herbert Carruth, Univ. of Kansas, Lawrence, Kan. Charles William Colby, 467 Broadway, Cambridge. Edmund Burke Delabarre, 14 Trowbridge PI., Cambridge. Henry Lexington Everett. Worcester. Hendrixson, Divinity 6, Cambridge. James Gibson Hume, 29 Mellen, Cambridge. John Matthews Manly, 54 Trowbridge, Cambridge. Walter Maxwell, Agricultural Dept., Washington, D. C. John Martin Pierce, 3 Wallace Terrace, Cambridge. Henry Lewis Stimson. Weld 45, Cambridge. Charles Mancleville Ludden, 83 Equitable Building, Boston. Frank Dugan Swope, 209 5th, Louisville, Ky. A LIST OF THE NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF SURVIVING HOLDERS OF HONORARY DEGREES FROM HARVARD UNIVERSITY,

WHO ARE NOT ALSO GRADUATES OF HARVARD COLLEGE.

*** The arrangement is chronological. Frederick H. Davis. George A. F. Dawson. Henry Watson, Northampton. Rev. Edwards A. Park, Andover. Rev. R. C. Waterston, 71 Chester Sq., Boston. E. N. Horsford, Cambridge.

Thomas T. Bouve, 18 Post-Offlce Sq., Boston. . Rev. Lucius R. Paige, Cambridgeport. Rev. Thomas J. Sawyer, Tufts College. Hon. George S. Boutwell, 1408 H, N. TV., Washington, D. C. Jonathan Kimball, Chelsea. Prof. John D. Runkle, Brookline. James Rhoads. Henry Barnard, Hartford, Conn. B. F. Tweed, Cambridgeport. T. S terry Hunt, Montreal, Can. Rev. George W. Briggs, Brattle, Cambridge. Rev. George D. Wildes, Riverdale, New York, N. Y. Rev. Daniel C. Eddy. Hon. Henry J. Gardner, 31 Milk, Boston. Hon. F. W. Lincoln, 126 Commercial, Boston. Luigi Monti, 107 E. 45th, New York, N. Y. Prof. W. S. Tyler, Amherst College, Amherst. Hon. N. P. , U. S. House of Representatives, Washington. D. C. James B. Francis, Lowell. The Rt. Hon. Lord Ettrick, of Thirlestane, Selkirk, Scotland. Rev. Howard Crosby, 116 E. 19th, New York, N. Y. Rev. Cyrus A. Bartol, 17 Chestnut, Boston. R. S. Greenough. Care C. H. Parker, Suffolk Savings BaDk, Boston. Albert Pike, 433 3d, N. W., Washington, D. C. Wm. J. Rolfe, Broadway, Cambridge. Rev. John C. Stockbridge, Registrar Brown Univ., Providence, R. I. Rev. Richard S. Stores, Brooklyn, N. Y. George A. Schmitt, Brookline. John G. Whittier, Amesbuiy. Rev. Joseph Cummings, Pres. Northwestern Univ., Evanston. 111. Rev. Cyrus Hamlin, Middlebury College, Vt. Richard Edwards, Springfield, 111. Rev. A. A. Miner, 528 Columbus Ave., Boston. Marshall T. Bigelow, Channing, Cambridge. Frederick L. Olmstead, Brookline. J. A. Page, 1940 Washington. Boston. 109

Rev. William P. Tilclen, Milton. Prof. M. Perkins, Schenectady, N. Y. George W. Bunnell. Wm. D. Howells. Care Harper & Bros., New York, N. Y. Charles G-. Lelancl. Care Gypsy Lore Society, Edinburgh, Scotland. Henry Mitchell, U. S. Coast and Geod. Survey, Washington, D. C. Wm. H. Whitmore, 17 Common, Boston. Dr. Henry W. Williams, 15 Arlington, Boston. Rev. James McCosh, Princeton College, Princeton, N. J. H. P. Tuttle, U. S. Geol. Survey, Washington, D. C. Hon. , Newtonville. Prof. J. K. Paine, Hawthorn, Cambridge. Wm. C. Collar, Roxbury Latin School, Roxbury. Hon. Wm. M. Evarts, 52 Wall, New York, N. Y. John Bartlett, Brattle, Cambridge. Hon. Hamilton Fish, 251 E. 17th, New York, N. Y. E. L. Godkin, Office of the " Nation," New York, N. Y. The Most Hon. the Marquis of Ripon, No. 1 Carleton Gardens, London, S.W., England. Prof. Ferdinand Bdcher, Cambridge. Rev. James Martineau, London, England. Tbomas Motley, Jamaica Plain. George W. Bond, 2.00 Federal, Boston. James H. Trumbull, Hartford, Conn. Hon. Wm. Gaston, 177 Marlborough, Boston. George W. Wales, 142 Beacon, Boston. Pres. Daniel C. Gilman, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md. Hon. A. H. Rice, 91 Federal, Boston. Hon. Charles Schurz, New York, N. Y. Prof. William D. Whitney, New Haven, Conn. Hon. Thomas F. Bayard, Wilmington, Del. The Rt. Hon. the Earl of Dufferin, Foreign Office, London, England. Asaph Hall, Naval Observatory, Washington, D. C.

Nathanael W. Hawes, 6 Park Sq., Boston ; and Wrentham. L. D. Shepard, 100 Boylston, Boston. Sir Edward Thornton, Foreign Office, London, England. Hon. Rutherford B. Hayes, Fremont, O. Samuel James Bridge, Norfolk House, Roxbury. Prof. Edward Charles Pickering, Harvard Observatory, Cambridge Geo. Wm. Curtis, New Brighton, N. Y. Francis Cogswell, 123 Prospect, Cambridgeport. Hon. Marcus Morton, Andover. Horatio Emmons Hale, Clinton, Ontario, Can. Henry Lee Higginson, 191 Commonwealth Ave., Boston. Pres. Francis A. Walker, 237 Beacon, Boston. Prof. , Naval Observatory, Washington, D. C. Prof. Richard Claverhouse Jebb, Trinity College, Cambridge, Eng Hon. Lucius Q. C. Lamar, Supreme Court, Washington, D. C. Rev. Dr. Charles Taylor, Cambridge, Eng. Rev. Dr. Mandell Creighton, University of Cambridge, Eng. Rt. Hon. Sir Lyon Playfair, Nat. Lib. Club, London, Eng.

7 Pres. Timothy Dwight, Yale Universitj , New Haven, Conn, 110

Rev. Dr. Ezekiel G. Robinson, Providence, R. I. Prof. Joseph Leidy, 1302 Filbert, Philadelphia, Pa. Pres. Charles K. Adams, Ithaca, N. Y. Prof. Edward E. Salisbuiy, Yale University, New Haven, Conn. Prof. James D. Dana, Yale University, New Haven, Conn. Prof. Henry Drisler, Columbia College, or 48 W. 46th, New York, Hon. Lincoln Flagg Brigham, Court House, Boston. [N.Y. Hon. Thos. M. Cooley, Ann Arbor, Mich. Rev. Prof. Geo. P. Fisher, Yale University, New Haven, Conn. Rev. Prof. Egbert C. Smyth, Andover. Prof. Basil L. G-ilclersleeve, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md. Dr. S. Weir Mitchell, Jefferson Medical College, Philadelphia, Pa. Gen. Henry L. Abbot, U. S. Engineer Corps, New York, N.Y. Prof. George J. Brush, Yale University, New Haven, Conn. Prof. Samuel P. Langley, Smithsonian Inst., Washington. D. C. Maj. John W. Powell. U. S. Geol. Survey, Washington, D. C. Hon. Walbridge A. Field, Court House, Boston. Dr. John S. Billings, Library of the Surg. -General's Office, 3027 N., N. W., Washington, D. C. Prof. Rodolfo Lanciani, Rome, Italy. Prof. Othniel C. Marsh, Yale University, New Haven. Conn. Rev. Prof. Alex. V. G. Allen, 2 Phillips PL, Cambridge. Prof. James Hall, Albany, N.Y. Prof. H. A. Hagen, 7 Putman Ave., Cambridge. Charles C. Smith, 286 Marlborough, Boston. Wolcott Gibbs, Newport, R. I. William Endicott, Jr., 32 Beacon, Boston. Hon. Edward J. Phelps, Brattleboro', Vt. Gen. Samuel C. Armstrong, Hampton, Va. Hon. David A. Wells, Norwich, Conn. Pres. Francis L. Patton, Princeton College, Princeton, N. J. Rev. Thomas L. Eliot, Portland, Oregon. George Wallis Haven, Portsmouth, N. H. Jonathan B. Harrison, Franklin, N. H. Hiram Francis Mills, Lawrence.

1III1I11I1IN1IIIIIII1111II 019 757 933

LIBRPRY OF CONGRESS

II II IM. Illl llllll II

019 757 933 p