A Suggestion for Naming Faces of Ring Compounds (Stereochemistry/Ring Faces/Receptor Sites) IRWIN A

Proc. Nati. Acad. Sci. USA Vol. 77, No. 5, pp. 2439-2441, May 1980 Biochemistry A suggestion for naming faces of ring compounds (stereochemistry/ring faces/receptor sites) IRWIN A. ROSE*, KENNETH R. HANSONt, KEITH D. WILKINSON*, AND MARY J. WIMMER*I *The Institute for Cancer Research, The Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19111; and tConnecticut Agricultural Experimental Station, New Haven, Connecticut 06504 Contributed by Irwin A. Rose, January 18, 1980 ABSTRACr Discussion of the topology of interaction of ring PROPOSED RULES compounds with macromolecules and receptors requires a system for naming the faces of the cyclic compound. An Rule 1 a/#-face nomenclature is suggested that is based on the clockwise/counterclockwise direction of ascending numbering in If the compound contains only one ring or if a ring in a com- the ring with the lowest numbered unshared ring atom. This pound is not fused to another, the faces are designated as a if system is applicable to a very broad range of compounds: sugars, a clockwise progression around each ring leads from the lowest cyclic bases, steroids, cyclitols, porphyrins, etc., and molecules numbered ring atom to the next higher numbered atom of the with a single ring, fused rings, encompassing rings, and rings ring by the shortest route. If the progression is counterclockwise, formed by head-to-tail polymerization. the face designation is /3. The ring is examined as a plane regular Many compounds of biological interest owe their special polygon-i.e., conformation properties are ignored. When, as properties to the chemistry and the shape of cyclic components occurs rarely, alternate number symbols are used, the pair of of their structures. Particular orientations of nucleotides, numbered ring atoms used in application of the rule should coenzymes, hormones, and sugars with respect to receptor sites, follow these priorities: 1 and 2 precede la or 1'; and la and 2a enzymes, and other cyclic compounds may result from specific precede 1'. interactions at one or the other ring face. It is therefore important to have a concise and generally applicable method for naming these faces. No such method exists. Furthermore, it seems that there has been no discussion of the characteristics that would be desirable in such a nomenclature. A partial solution to the above problem is available in the Re/Si system for naming the faces of trigonal atoms [refs. 1, 2 (p. 317)]. This can be applied to aromatic systems but it is un- suitable for extension to saturated rings. Because the assignments are sensitive to sequence-rule priorities, faces that to the chemist or biochemist seem obviously related may receive opposite names. A different model is provided by the steroid class of compounds. The terms front, B-face, and /3-face are widely used as alternate designations for the observed face of the steroid skeleton when it is drawn in the recommended way-e.g., structure I, 5-a-pregnane (3). The "/-face" in this usage is the face that lies behind the substituents officially said to be in the "/-orientation" (3). The other is the a-face (structure I). In this paper we wish to propose a simple a//3 convention that can be applied to many classes of cyclic molecules and when applied to the steroids leads to the same designations already employed by steroid chemists. The proposal is based on the numbering of the atoms in molecules and therefore should give characteristic designations for all members of each family of compounds for which a convention of numbering exists (4, 5). This includes not only steroids but all purines and pyrimidines, pteridines and isoal- loxazines, all sugar rings, and many others in which a specific numbering scheme is recognized and is essential to scientific communication about a class of compounds. These numbering schemes are usually found in the primary literature, in text- books, and in reports on nomenclature. The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked "ad- vertisement" in accordance with 18 U. S. C. §1734 solely to indicate * Present address: Department of Biochemistry, School of Medicine, this fact. West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV 26506. 2439 Downloaded by guest on September 25, 2021 2440 Biochemistry: Rose et al. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 77 (1980) Extensions of Rule 1. (i) The numbering of monomer units (ii) When the substrate for lysozyme fits into the active site that are combined in a "head-to-tail" fashion to give cyclic crevice, Asp-52 lies near the (-face and Gln-35 lies near the structures could be used to define the numbering direction of a-face of the N-acetyl-D-muramic acid pyranose ring, the a cyclic polymer unless an independent numbering system is glycosidic linkage of which is cleaved (7). specified. An example would be valinomycin, in which amino (iii) The finding that substitution at C-1, -3, or -5 did not acids and esters are the units. (ii) If a polygon can be drawn to alter the inhibitory effect of a-D-glucopyranose 6-phosphate encompass all of the unfused rings of a structure in an unam- for hexokinase (8) suggests that the (3-face of the pyranose ring biguous way, as in the case of the porphyrins (e.g., structure II), is free of important interactions with the enzyme. the common surface may be given the face designation of the (iv) The NAD+-malate dehydrogenase crystal structure (9) lowest numbered member ring. (Mii) If a pair of unfused rings shows the (-face of the nicotinamide ring directed toward an are joined by an exocyclic double bond, the common surface anion binding site, presumably the substrate binding site. This may be given the face designations of the lower numbered is consistent with the stereochemistry established for hydrogen ring. addition to the C-4 of the nicotinamide. (V) 02 binds to hemoglobin and myoglobin at the (-face of Rule 2 the heme (10, 11), the encompassing ring of which is shown by If the compound is made up of "ortho-fused" rings only, face heavy lines in structure II. designations of the entire system of rings are derived from the ring containing the lowest numbered unshared atom as speci- DISCUSSION fied in standard numbering for the compound. The system proposed offers the following advantages: A single NOTE: This rule ensures a correlation between the proposed procedure is available for aliphatic and aromatic rings and for face names and the a/(3 designations presently in use for steroid ortho-fused systems containing both types of ring. Because the ring substituents. For structure I the substituents above the system is based on ring numbering it should be endowed with plane of the paper are (3and by virtue of the counterclockwise the uniformity and durability built into such numbering in the ordering of the ring containing C-1 they project from the development of local systems of nomenclature. Face designa- (-face. If instead Rule 1 were applied to each ring, the faces tions should therefore be insensitive to substituent changes or of ring C would be given opposite names to those of rings A, B, minor structural changes. This allows one to easily generalize and D. Likewise, in the purines the smaller and larger rings in discussing the action of the enzyme on a series of structurally would have contrary face names. related compounds or on their binding to a receptor site-e.g., "the (-face is bound in all the related analogs that were Rule 3 tested." Ring structures that are modifications of molecules that are Our choice to identify a with clockwise seems natural and recognized by name or numbering as members of a particular leads to symbols compatible with the rules for steroids and class relate to the a/d3-face assignments of that class as fol- terpenes. On the other hand, a-D-glucopyranose has its ano- lows: meric -OH projecting from the (-face (in the L-series a-a- Rule 3.1. Rings that are added assume the a/13-face assign- nomeric substituents project from the a-face). Also, the so-called ments of the class if they are fused through adjacent atoms of 4A proton of NADH-i.e., the (pro-4R)-H of the pyridoxamide a ring of the basic class structure-i.e., are ortho-fused (e.g., the ring-projects from the face that would be named: in the six-membered phosphorus-containing ring in 3',5'-cyclic ade- present system. These lapses in mnemonic simplicity are un- nylic acid that is ortho-fused to the 3',4' atoms of the ribose fortunate and could be avoided by developing local systems for ring). face designation for each class of compounds. This suffers from Rule 3.2. Chemical changes in the lowest numbered ring, problems other than nonuniversality; the topology of a face will such as fission or change in ring size, do not alter the a/(3 sense usually have more to identify it than the orientation of one ring of the molecule as long as numbering of atoms and the name substituent. Ring atom numbering is more closely associated indicates that the molecule is a member of a standard class of with face topology. compounds. [In steroid nomenclature (3) the prefixes nor, The most frequent objection that has been raised to this homo, seco, and abeo (e.g., formula 98 in ref. 3) are used to proposal concerns the choice of the terms a and (l and the indicate the class relationship of such compounds, which pro- possibility of confusion with other usages of these symbols.

Load more