DOCSLIB.ORG

Open Diefendorf Msthesis.Pdf

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Open Diefendorf Msthesis.Pdf The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School College of Education STUDENTS’ WRITTEN ARGUMENTATION STRUCTURE FROM AN INTRODUCTORY OCEANOGRAPHY COURSE: ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION A Thesis in Curriculum and Instruction by Emily Jane Diefendorf © 2008 Emily Jane Diefendorf Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science May 2008 The thesis of Emily Jane Diefendorf was reviewed and approved* by the following: Gregory J. Kelly Professor of Education Thesis Advisor Head of the Department of Curriculum and Instruction Scott McDonald Assistant Professor of Education Carla Zembal-Saul Associate Professor of Education *Signatures are on file in the Graduate School. ii ABSTRACT Students’ written argumentation structure from an introductory oceanography course: Analysis and Evaluation The purpose of this study was to examine ways that students create arguments derived from inscriptions, expertise, and data. The context of this study was an introductory oceanography course with an emphasis on writing that was mainly composed of non- science majors. During the course, students wrote evidence-based arguments on such issues as plate tectonics, monsoons of India, climate change, and fishery health. A random sample of fifteen students’ papers for each of the four written arguments was analyzed to evaluate the students’ construction of evidence and the overall quality of the arguments, which was used to compare across students and assignments. Results reveal students were only partially able to write plausible arguments in the scientific genre. Students used inscriptions, data, and expertise to introduce lines of reasoning, but were often unable to engage in the theoretical aspects of constructing valid scientific arguments. Additionally, average quality scores for each of the assignments improved throughout the time of the class, suggesting students were better able to construct arguments with time. Writing to learn science provides students opportunities to engage in scientific inquiry; however, more opportunities need to exist for students to practice creating arguments. An emphasis should be placed on including argumentation in schools to further the students’ development of scientific reasoning. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES ..............................................................................................................................................vi LIST OF FIGURES ...........................................................................................................................................vii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS...............................................................................................................................ix CHAPTER I ..........................................................................................................................................................1 INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................................................1 RESEARCH QUESTIONS ......................................................................................................................................4 LITERATURE REVIEW.........................................................................................................................................6 Previous Written Argumentation in Introductory University Oceanography Studies .............................6 Previous K-12 Written Argumentation Studies ..........................................................................................9 Previous Discourse Studies .......................................................................................................................12 CHAPTER II ......................................................................................................................................................14 THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK............................................................................................................................14 Scientific Inquiry & Inquiry Learning ......................................................................................................15 Scientific Writing........................................................................................................................................16 Scientific Literacy.......................................................................................................................................17 CHAPTER III.....................................................................................................................................................19 BACKGROUND ..................................................................................................................................................19 Educational Setting ....................................................................................................................................19 Course Assignments ...................................................................................................................................20 METHODS FOR ANALYSIS ................................................................................................................................23 Analysis of the Students’ Work..................................................................................................................24 1) Pose Solvable Research Question .......................................................................................................................34 2) Within Lines of Reasoning ..................................................................................................................................35 (a)Use Data Inscriptions or Data from Secondary Sources ..............................................................................35 (b) Articulate Multiple Lines of Reasoning........................................................................................................36 3) Across Lines of Reasoning ..................................................................................................................................36 (a) Use Models to Support Conclusions.............................................................................................................36 (b) Coherence Across Lines of Reasoning .........................................................................................................37 (c) Sufficiency of Lines of Reasoning ................................................................................................................37 4) Quality of Argument.............................................................................................................................................38 PROCEDURE......................................................................................................................................................38 CONSTRAINTS...................................................................................................................................................40 CHAPTER IV .....................................................................................................................................................41 FINDINGS ..........................................................................................................................................................41 iv 1) Pose Solvable Research Question..........................................................................................................45 2) Within the Lines of Reasoning ................................................................................................................45 3) Across Lines of Reasoning ......................................................................................................................52 4) Quality of Argument ................................................................................................................................54 ON RESEARCH DESIGN ....................................................................................................................................57 CHAPTER V.......................................................................................................................................................59 DISCUSSION......................................................................................................................................................59 IMPLICATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS .......................................................................................................61 APPENDIX A: Anatomy of a Science Paper .................................................................................................64 APPENDIX B: Plate Tectonics Assignment ..................................................................................................76 APPENDIX C: Peer Review Rubric ...............................................................................................................77 APPENDIX D: Monsoons Assignment ...........................................................................................................84 APPENDIX E: Oceans & Climate Assignment.............................................................................................85 APPENDIX F: Fishery Health Assignment ...................................................................................................87 APPENDIX G: Student Scores
Load more

Recommended publications
  • PLATE TECTONICS.Docx
    GTheory of Plate Tectonics Critique and interpret major types of evidence supporting the Theory of Plate Tectonics. Plate tectonics is the most important concept in modern geology. This section will introduce you to the concept of plate tectonics, how it works, why it is important and how it is shaping the world today. WHAT YOU’LL LEARN TO DO · Describe and compare different types of plate motions, rates of motion and the driving mechanisms and forces involved with each. · Know the role of technology in Plate Tectonics. Theory of Plate Tectonics When the concept of seafloor spreading came along, scientists recognized that it was the mechanism to explain how continents could move around Earth’s surface. Like the scientists before us, we will now merge the ideas of continental drift and seafloor spreading into the theory of plate tectonics. Earth’s Tectonic Plates Seafloor and continents move around on Earth’s surface, but what is actually moving? What portion of the Earth makes up the “plates” in plate tectonics? This question was also answered because of technology developed during war times – in this case, the Cold War. The plates are made up of the lithosphere. Figure 1. Earthquakes outline the plates. During the 1950s and early 1960s, scientists set up seismograph networks to see if enemy nations were testing atomic bombs. These seismographs also recorded all of the earthquakes around the planet. The seismic records could be used to locate an earthquake’s epicentre, the point on Earth’s surface directly above the place where the earthquake occurs. Earthquake epicentres outline the plates.
    [Show full text]
  • Plate Tectonics Says That Earth’S Plates Move Because of Convection Currents in the Mantle
    Bellringer Which ocean is getting smaller and which ocean is getting bigger due to subduction and sea floor spreading? Plate Tectonic Theory Notes How Plates Move • Earth’s crust is broken into many jagged pieces. The surface is like the shell of a hard-boiled egg that has been rolled. The pieces of Earth’s crust are called plates. Plates carry continents, oceans floors, or both. How Plates Move • The theory of plate tectonics says that Earth’s plates move because of convection currents in the mantle. Currents in the mantle carry plates on Earth’s surface, like currents in water carry boats on a river, or Cheerios in milk. How Plates Move • Plates can meet in three different ways. Plates may pull apart, push together, or slide past each other. Wherever plates meet, you usually get volcanoes, mountain ranges, or ocean trenches. Plate Boundaries • A plate boundary is where two plates meet. Faults form along plate boundaries. A fault is a break in Earth’s crust where blocks of rock have slipped past each other. Plate Boundaries • Where two plates move apart, the boundary is called a divergent boundary. • A divergent boundary between two oceanic plates will result in a mid-ocean ridge AND rift valley. (SEE: Sea-Floor Spreading) • A divergent boundary between two continental plates will result in only a rift valley. This is currently happening at the Great Rift Valley in east Africa. Eventually, the Indian Ocean will pour into the lowered valley and a new ocean will form. Plate Boundaries • Where two plates push together, the boundary is called a convergent boundary.
    [Show full text]
  • What's the Difference?
    2005 Submarine Ring of Fire Expedition What’s the Difference? FOCUS SEATING ARRANGEMENT Volcanic processes at convergent and divergent tec- Classroom style if students are working individually, tonic plate boundaries or groups of two to four students GRADE LEVEL MAXIMUM NUMBER OF STUDENTS 9-12 (Earth Science) 30 FOCUS QUESTION KEY WORDS How do volcanic processes differ at convergent Volcano and divergent tectonic plate boundaries? Caldera Hot spot LEARNING OBJECTIVES Ring of Fire Students will be able to compare and contrast volca- Asthenosphere noes at convergent and divergent plate boundaries. Lithosphere Magma Students will be able to identify three geologic fea- Fault tures that are associated with most volcanoes on Transform boundary Earth. Convergent boundary Divergent boundary Students will be able to explain why some volca- Subduction noes erupt explosively while others do not. Tectonic plate MATERIALS BACKGROUND INFORMATION Copies of “Submarine Volcanism Worksheet,” one The Ring of Fire is an arc of active volcanoes and copy for each student or student group earthquake sites that partially encircles the Pacific Ocean Basin.The location of the Ring of Fire coin- AUDIO/VISUAL MATERIALS cides with the location of oceanic trenches and (Optional) computer projection equipment to show volcanic island arcs that result from the motion of downloaded video materials large pieces of the Earth’s crust (tectonic plates). Tectonic plates consist of portions of the Earth’s TEACHING TIME outer crust (the lithosphere) about 5 km thick, as One 45-minute class period, plus time for student well as the upper 60 - 75 km of the underlying research mantle. The plates move on a hot flowing mantle layer called the asthenosphere, which is several hundred kilometers thick.
    [Show full text]
  • Notes: Plate Tectonics
    Notes: Plate Tectonics There are three types of plate boundaries: divergent, convergent, and transform 1. Divergent Boundary: occurs between plates that are separating most divergent boundaries are between 2 oceanic plates and occur at the mid-ocean ridge; some geographic examples of places where this is happening are the Mid-Atlantic Ridge and the East Pacific Rise The Great Rift Valley in Africa is a geographic example of a continental-continental divergent boundary where the African continent is being broken into smaller plates 2. Convergent Boundary: occurs between two plates that are coming together; there are 2 kinds of convergent boundaries – subduction and collision A. Subduction Possible plate combinations are oceanic-continental or oceanic-oceanic the denser and thinner plate buckles down under the less dense plate, plunges down (gets subducted) into the mantle and melts; a trench forms at the place where the plates meet and one goes under the other Volcanoes usually form on the overriding plate (sometimes mountains form) Geographic examples are the Mariana Trench and the Aleutian Trench B. Collision Occurs where 2 continental plates come together Forms high mountain ranges Geographic examples are the Himalayas and the Appalachians 3. Transform Boundary: occurs where plates slide past each other, usually in opposite directions but can be in the same direction but at different rates This type of boundary causes lots of earthquakes and faults A geographic example is the San Andreas Fault in California .
    [Show full text]
  • Plate Tectonics Passport
    What is plate tectonics? The Earth is made up of four layers: inner core, outer core, mantle and crust (the outermost layer where we are!). The Earth’s crust is made up of oceanic crust and continental crust. The crust and uppermost part of the mantle are broken up into pieces called plates, which slowly move around on top of the rest of the mantle. The meeting points between the plates are called plate boundaries and there are three main types: Divergent boundaries (constructive) are where plates are moving away from each other. New crust is created between the two plates. Convergent boundaries (destructive) are where plates are moving towards each other. Old crust is either dragged down into the mantle at a subduction zone or pushed upwards to form mountain ranges. Transform boundaries (conservative) are where are plates are moving past each other. Can you find an example of each type of tectonic plate boundary on the map? Divergent boundary: Convergent boundary: Transform boundary: What do you notice about the location of most of the Earth’s volcanoes? P.1 Iceland Iceland lies on the Mid Atlantic Ridge, a divergent plate boundary where the North American Plate and the Eurasian Plate are moving away from each other. As the plates pull apart, molten rock or magma rises up and erupts as lava creating new ocean crust. Volcanic activity formed the island about 16 million years ago and volcanoes continue to form, erupt and shape Iceland’s landscape today. The island is covered with more than 100 volcanoes - some are extinct, but about 30 are currently active.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Tectonics and Geohazards Courtesy of Jim Peaco/Yellowston National Park
    © Jones & Bartlett Learning, LLC. NOT FOR SALE OR DISTRIBUTION Number © iStockphoto/Thinkstock. Technologies/AbleStock.com/Thinkstock. © Hemera Background Chapter Global Tectonics and Geohazards Courtesy of Jim Peaco/Yellowston National Park. Jim Peaco/Yellowston of Courtesy Chapter Outline Introduction Summary of the Earth’s Interior The Concept of the Model Radioactive Decay and Interior Heat • An Analogy: A Model of an Aircraft Heat Transfer A Very Brief Review of the Scientific Method • Conduction Modeling the Earth’s Interior • Convection • The Importance of Earthquake Waves Global Tectonics and the Dynamic Earth Model • Summary of Evidence Used to Model the • Plate Tectonics as a Unifying Theory of Geology Earth’s Interior • Continental Drift and Seafloor Spreading The Interior: Lithosphere, Asthenosphere, Crust, • Plates and Plate Boundaries Mantle, and Core • Continent–Continent Collisions 70 9780763764456_CH04_0070.indd 70 8/15/13 11:44 AM © Jones & Bartlett Learning, LLC. NOT FOR SALE OR DISTRIBUTION • Mantle Plumes and Hot Spots Chapter Summary • Volcanoes and Plate Tectonics Key Terms Case Study: An Island Arc, a Subduction Zone, Review Questions and a Great Tragedy: The 2004 Sumatra-Andaman Footnotes Earthquake and Its Aftermath ■ Introduction n this chapter, we introduce material that you must learn if you are to under- stand, among other important concepts, why and where earthquakes and vol- canoes occur, and, therefore, the origin of the many geological hazards they generate. First, we will discuss the concept of the geological model. Then we will review the scientific method and continue with a brief look at the history of recent scientific thought on the nature of the Earth’s interior.
    [Show full text]
  • Presentation on Pacific Plate and Associated Boundaries
    PACIFIC PLATE AND ASSOCIATED BOUNDARIES The Pacific Plate • Pacific Plate is the largest plate and an oceanic plate. • It shares its boundaries with numerous plates namely; North American Plate.(Convergent and transform fault) Philippine Plate.(Convergent) Juan de Fuca Plate.(Convergent) Indo – Australian Plate.(Convergent, Transform Fault) Cocos Plate.(Divergent) Nazca Plate.(Divergent) Antarctic Plate.(Divergent,Transform Fault) Types of Plate Boundaries • Convergent Boundary: Subduction zones where two plates converges. Eg; Aleutian Islands(Alaska) • Divergent Boundary: Spreading centres where two plates move away from each other. Eg; East Pacific Rise (MOR, Pacific Ocean). • Transform Faults: Boundary where two plates slide past each other. For Eg. ; San Andreas Fault. BOUNDARY WITH ANTARCTIC PLATE DIVERGENT BOUNDARY • Pacific – Antarctic Ridge TRANSFORM FAULT • Louisville Seamount Chain Pacific – Antarctic Ridge Pacific – Antarctic Ridge(PAR) is located on the seafloor of the South Pacific Ocean. It is driven by the interaction of a mid oceanic ridge and deep mantle plumes located in the eastern portion of East Pacific Ridge. Louisville Seamount Chain It is the longest line of seamount chain in the Pacific Ocean of about 4,300 km, formed along the transform boundary in the western side between Pacific plate and Antarctic plate. It was formed from the Pacific Plate sliding over a long – lived centre of upwelling magma called the Louisville hotspot. BOUNDARY WITH PHILIPPINE PLATE CONVERGENT BOUNDARY • Izu – Ogasawara Trench • Mariana Trench Izu – Ogasawara Trench It is an oceanic trench in the western Pacific Ocean. It stretches from Japan to northern most section of Mariana Trench. Here, the Pacific Plate is being subducted beneath the Philippine Sea Plate.
    [Show full text]
  • 3 Types of Plate Boundaries Main Types of Plate Motion PANGAEA
    Partial melting occurs when some minerals melt Continental Rifting Trench Spreading while others remain solid because their melting point has not been reached The Crust Center continental Subduction Basalt Volcanic rifting Granite Arc Accretionary process Oceanic Prism Crust a Granite q The role of partial melting Basalt Kk 3 Types of Plate Boundaries MODERN CONTINENTS EVOLVED FROM PANGAEA DIVERGENT CONVERGENT New lithosphere forms as plates pull apart. One plate dives beneath another (subduction) or two Convergent Divergent TRANSFORM plates collide without either Main Types of Plate Motion Plates grind past each other. subducting. Transform No change in Lithosphere Divergent Boundary Mid-Ocean Ridge Seafloor spreading leads to Spreading Center the formation of new crust that, compared to continental crust, is relatively enriched in iron and magnesium and depleted in silica (SiO2) (because it reflects the chemistry of the mantle). As two plates continue to move apart, the rock in the seafloor grows older as its distance from the rift zone increases, and as it ages, it cools and becomes denser and is buried under marine sediments that are deposited on the seafloor. 1 TRANSFORM Transform Boundaries Connect OCEANIC FRACTURE ZONE BOUNDARY Two Spreading Transform Boundary with INACTIVE (FRACTURE ZONE) (side-to-side plate Centers and ACTIVE (TRANSFORM FAULT) portions. movement) Occur where two plates slide past each other. Motion called shearing. Connect two spreading centers (less commonly, two subduction zones). Probably the most FAULT famous transform “a place where the crust is broken and the broken edges boundary in the are offset relative to each other world is the San Andreas Fault.
    [Show full text]
  • Lecture-Tutorials
    Lecture-Tutorials For Introductory Geoscience By: Karen Kortz Jessica Smay Full Table of Contents Plate Tectonics and Earth’s Interior 1. Tectonic Plates and Boundaries……………………………………………… 1 2. Seafloor Ages………………………………………………………………….. 3 3. Subduction at Convergent Plate Boundaries…..…………………………… 5 4. Plate Boundaries in Oceans..………………………………………………… 9 5. History of an Ocean………………………………………………………….. 11 6. Features on the Ocean Floor……………………………………...…….….. 13 7. Melting Rocks and Plate Tectonics………………………………………….. 15 8. The Outer Core………………………………………..……………………….. 19 9. Magma Source Depth…..……………………………..………………………. 21 Rocks and Their Formation 10. Mineral Groups……………………………………………………………….. 23 11. The Rock Cycle……………………………………………………………….. 25 12. Rock Types on Other Planets...………………………………….……..…... 27 13. Identifying Igneous Rocks.………………………..…….………….…….…. 29 14. Igneous Rock Mineral Size………………………..……………….………... 31 15. Explosive and Peaceful Volcanoes…..…………..………………..…......... 33 16. Volcanoes on Other Planets ………………..……...……………....………. 35 17. Sediments and Sedimentary Rocks………………………………………… 39 18. Sedimentary Depositional Environments………………………………….. 41 19. Sedimentary Facies.................................................................................. 43 20. Metamorphic Rocks………………………………………………………….. 45 21. The History of Metamorphic Rocks.………..….………….…...…….…….. 47 Geologic Landforms and Processes 22. Topographic Profiles…………………………………………………………. 49 23. Planet Surface Features…......…………………………………...……….… 51 24. Earthquake Intensity and Magnitude……………………………………….
    [Show full text]
  • This Dynamic Earth in January of 1992
    View of the planet Earth from the Apollo spacecraft. The Red Sea, which separates Saudi Arabia from the continent of Africa, is clearly visible at the top. (Photograph courtesy of NASA.) Contents Preface Historical perspective Developing the theory Understanding plate motions "Hotspots": Mantle Some unanswered questions Plate tectonics and people Endnotes thermal plumes 1 of 77 2002-01-01 11:52 This pdf-version was edited by Peter Lindeberg in December 2001. Any deviation from the original text is non-intentional. This book was originally published in paper form in February 1996 (design and coordination by Martha Kiger; illustrations and production by Jane Russell). It is for sale for $7 from: U.S. Government Printing Office Superintendent of Documents, Mail Stop SSOP Washington, DC 20402-9328 or it can be ordered directly from the U.S. Geological Survey: Call toll-free 1-888-ASK-USGS Or write to USGS Information Services Box 25286, Building 810 Denver Federal Center Denver, CO 80225 303-202-4700; Fax 303-202-4693 ISBN 0-16-048220-8 Version 1.08 The online edition contains all text from the original book in its entirety. Some figures have been modified to enhance legibility at screen resolutions. Many of the images in this book are available in high resolution from the USGS Media for Science page. USGS Home Page URL: http://pubs.usgs.gov/publications/text/dynamic.html Last updated: 01.29.01 Contact: [email protected] 2 of 77 2002-01-01 11:52 In the early 1960s, the emergence of the theory of plate tectonics started a revolution in the earth sciences.
    [Show full text]
  • What's the Difference?
    New Zealand American Submarine Ring of Fire 2007 What’s The Difference? FOCUS SEATING ARRANGEMENT Volcanic processes at convergent and divergent Classroom style if students are working individu- tectonic plate boundaries ally, or groups of two to four students GRADE LEVEL MAXIMUM NUMBER OF STUDENTS 9-12 (Earth Science) 30 FOCUS QUESTION KEY WORDS How do volcanic processes differ at convergent Volcano and divergent tectonic plate boundaries? Caldera Hot spot LEARNING OBJECTIVES Ring of Fire Students will be able to compare and contrast Asthenosphere volcanoes at convergent and divergent plate Lithosphere boundaries. Magma Fault Students will be able to identify three geologic Transform boundary features that are associated with most volcanoes Convergent boundary on Earth. Divergent boundary Subduction Students will be able to explain why some volca- Tectonic plate noes erupt explosively while others do not. BACKGROUND INFORMATION MATERIALS The Submarine Ring of Fire is an arc of active vol- Copies of “Submarine Volcanism Worksheet,” canoes that partially encircles the Pacific Ocean one copy for each student or student group Basin, including the Kermadec and Mariana Islands in the western Pacific, the Aleutian Islands AUDIO/VISUAL MATERIALS between the Pacific and Bering Sea, the Cascade (Optional) Computer projection equipment to Mountains in western North America, and numer- show downloaded video materials ous volcanoes on the western coasts of Central America and South America. These volcanoes TEACHING TIME result from the motion of
    [Show full text]
  • Plate Tectonics
    Plate Tectonics Introduction Continental Drift Seafloor Spreading Plate Tectonics Divergent Plate Boundaries Convergent Plate Boundaries Transform Plate Boundaries Summary This curious world we inhabit is more wonderful than convenient; more beautiful than it is useful; it is more to be admired and enjoyed than used. Henry David Thoreau Introduction • Earth's lithosphere is divided into mobile plates. • Plate tectonics describes the distribution and motion of the plates. • The theory of plate tectonics grew out of earlier hypotheses and observations collected during exploration of the rocks of the ocean floor. You will recall from a previous chapter that there are three major layers (crust, mantle, core) within the earth that are identified on the basis of their different compositions (Fig. 1). The uppermost mantle and crust can be subdivided vertically into two layers with contrasting mechanical (physical) properties. The outer layer, the lithosphere, is composed of the crust and uppermost mantle and forms a rigid outer shell down to a depth of approximately 100 km (63 miles). The underlying asthenosphere is composed of partially melted rocks in the upper mantle that acts in a plastic manner on long time scales. Figure 1. The The asthenosphere extends from about 100 to 300 km (63-189 outermost part of miles) depth. The theory of plate tectonics proposes that the Earth is divided lithosphere is divided into a series of plates that fit together like into two the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. mechanical layers, the lithosphere and Although plate tectonics is a relatively young idea in asthenosphere. comparison with unifying theories from other sciences (e.g., law of gravity, theory of evolution), some of the basic observations that represent the foundation of the theory were made many centuries ago when the first maps of the Atlantic Ocean were drawn.
    [Show full text]