DOCSLIB.ORG

An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past BOOKS FILMS & MEDIA THE PUBLIC HISTORIAN BLOG TEXAS OUR/STORIES STUDENTS ABOUT 15 MINUTE HISTORY "The past is never dead. It's not even past." William Faulkner NOT EVEN PAST Tweet 2 Like THE PUBLIC HISTORIAN An Apology for Propaganda By David Rahimi Making History: Houston’s “Spirit of the Confederacy” Writing in the middle of World War II, Freya Stark, a well-known British explorer and Arabist working for the Ministry of Information in the Middle East, penned an unpublished – and ultimately unfinished – twenty-five page essay, which she entitled Apology for Propaganda. When we think of government propaganda, we typically think of faceless bureaucrats churning out sensationalized banners, radio broadcasts, and reports about victories, the enemies’ lies, and various kinds of disinformation. Stark’s Apology, however, provides a unique glimpse into how propagandists justified and viewed their own work in a critically self-conscious manner. On a larger scale, the manuscript reflects on an intimate level the dynamics of British colonial thought, particularly a steadfast belief in the nobility of Britain’s colonial “civilizing mission.” Stark’s Apology not only reflects an available theory of propaganda discussed within May 06, 2020 the Ministry of Information, but also the persistent belief that, despite any shortcomings, imperialism was really benevolent for Arab colonial subjects. More from The Public Historian BOOKS America for Americans: A History of Xenophobia in the United States by Erika Lee (2019) April 20, 2020 More Books DIGITAL HISTORY Más de 72: Digital Archive Review https://notevenpast.org/freya-starks-apology-for-propaganda/[6/18/2020 12:08:49 PM] An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past Freya Stark (via Alchetron). By her thirties, Freya Stark (1893-1993), an impulsive British explorer of the Near East, developed a romanticized and idealistic obsession with the Arab world and Persia in the same vein as T.E. Lawrence, whom she much admired. She traveled among the Druze, explored Luristan and the hideout of the fabled Assassins at Alamut, and wrote extensively about her travels in Baghdad, Yemen, Arabia, and other parts March 16, 2020 of the Middle East. When WWII began, Stark volunteered to serve in the British war effort and she was assigned to the Ministry of Information where her linguistic and literary talents were well-suited. More from Digital History Stark likely wrote this piece sometime between October 1943 and May 1944, while traveling in America on an official diplomatic tour to clarify the British position on the Zionist question. Ultimately, it seems the FILMS & MEDIA decision was made not to publish the Apology because Stark’s boss, Stewart Perowne, thought it was too revealing about British intelligence efforts in Egypt and Iraq in the still ongoing war. Ayka (Dir: Sergei Dvortsevoy, 2018) https://notevenpast.org/freya-starks-apology-for-propaganda/[6/18/2020 12:08:49 PM] An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past October 02, 2019 More from Films & Media TEXAS A (Queer) Rebel Wife In Texas British WWII propaganda after Mussolini’s unsuccessful invasion of Egypt in 1942. The poster depicts captured Italian troops entering Cairo under British guard (via Wikimedia Commons). Stark begins the essay by arguing that propaganda fundamentally deals with the “originating and March 11, 2020 spreading of ideas.” However, propaganda has two distinct meanings: (1) the propagation of a “gospel” or firmly held set of beliefs, and (2) deceitful information. Both grew out of the Jesuit tradition, with the former More from Texas being an innocent form of “persuasion,” while the latter took form as people associated the Jesuits with “unscrupulous subtlety.” Persuasion meant simply to truthfully present one’s beliefs in a dialogue (“two- way traffic”) with the target audience, making use of slogans and positive statements. Stark firmly believed the government should wholeheartedly embrace this kind of propaganda, since ideas “are as potent as drugs.” Indeed, there is a “duty” to firmly explain the British and Allied cause when they feel confident of the justice and necessity to prevent others from heading over a “precipice.” For Stark, this was connected to her firm belief that the “British desire to encourage freedom in the Arab world is perfectly sincere.” Justifiable propaganda could only be that which worked for the good of the audience, in this case the Arabs. On the other hand, Stark thought that bribing and trickery were repugnant as well as ineffective means of persuasion, and cooperation with Arabs was necessary, since the most persuasive formulations of secular democratic ideals could only be expressed in Arabic by other Arabs and not through translation. https://notevenpast.org/freya-starks-apology-for-propaganda/[6/18/2020 12:08:49 PM] An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past North Africa and the Middle East in 1940 (via Wikimedia Commons). Stark then moved from these ideas to show how she tried to implement them in her Ikhwan al-Hurriya (Brotherhood of Freedom), an anti-fascist group in Egypt and Iraq. Based on the organizational examples set by the Bolsheviks and Muslim Brotherhood, this project consisted of a diffused network of loose cells, where British and Arab members could discuss the democratic principles that they shared. She writes that, despite some initial difficulties, the British-inspired Brotherhood garnered about 40,000 members throughout the Middle East at its peak. The British authorities were highly appreciative of this effort, though despite Stark’s high hopes, the organization was officially outlawed in Egypt in 1952. A chief reason for this was the contradiction within the Brotherhood about politics. Stark envisioned it as an apolitical group and so had to turn several “good men” away in Iraq because of their interest in politics. However, an organization that was ostensibly meant to promote democratic principles could not help but be political in a colonial environment. Stark was happy that there were young Arab men who were receptive to the British message, but she seemed to think that this could be conducted on British terms without raising political questions about Britain’s decidedly undemocratic role. Stark easily mistakes the friendships she formed and admiration for democratic ideas she found with an overall positive disposition to British colonialism. Furthermore, there is no mention of the popularity of Muslim Brotherhood’s anti- British efforts or how Ambassador Miles Lampson’s use of tanks on February 4, 1942 to compel King Farouk to accept the Egyptian nationalist Wafd Party into the government led to the discrediting of the king, the Wafd, and parliamentary democracy as mere British tools. The enormous popularity of Gamal Abdel Nasser’s nationalist and authoritarian government beginning in the 1950s also belies Stark’s overly enthusiastic tone in the manuscript. Unlike T.E. Lawrence, who had seen Britain renege on its promises at Versailles after WWI, Stark believed wholeheartedly in the goodness of the British imperial project and whatever did not fit in with this image she discounted as an aberration or simple mistake. https://notevenpast.org/freya-starks-apology-for-propaganda/[6/18/2020 12:08:49 PM] An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past Nasser and the Free Officers overthrew the Egyptian monarchy in 1952, marking the decline of British influence in Egypt (via Wikimedia Commons). Stark’s unpublished Apology shows us how some British propagandists in the Middle East theater of WWII conceived of their roles as good-natured persuaders. They were not oblivious to accusations of cynical propaganda and Stark’s essay shows a conscious effort to articulate a morally acceptable form of propaganda that could serve British and Arab interests, in that order. Stark reflects a strain of British colonial thought that, while sympathetic to Arabs, still thought that British dominance was a guiding hand that benevolently, yet condescendingly, treated colonial subjects as paternalistic clients. Freya Stark’s “Apology for Propaganda,” can be found in handwritten and typescript drafts, Container 1.3. Freya Stark Collection 1893-1993 (bulk 1920-1976). Harry Ransom Center, University of Texas-Austin. Additional sources: William Cleveland and Martin Bunton, A History of the Modern Middle East (2009) Jane Fletcher Geniesse, Passionate Nomad: The Life of Freya Stark (1999). Efraim Karsh and Rory Miller, “Freya Stark in America: Orientalism, Antisemitism and Political Propaganda,” Journal of Contemporary History 39, 3 (July, 2004): 315-332 Temple Wilcox, “Towards a Ministry of Information,” History 69, 227 (1984): 398-414 More by David Rahimi on Not Even Past: Modern Islamic Thought in a Radical Age, by Muhammad Qasim Zaman (2012) You may also like: Emily Whalen recommends A Prince of Our Disorder: The Life of T.E. Lawrence, by John E. Mack (1976). Ogechukwu Ezekwem reviews The Dual Mandate in British Tropical Africa, by Frederick John Dealtry Lugard (1965). Posted November 2, 2016 More 1800s, Blog, Empire, Europe, Ideas/Intellectual History, Middle East, Writers/Literature https://notevenpast.org/freya-starks-apology-for-propaganda/[6/18/2020 12:08:49 PM] An Apology for Propaganda - Not Even Past NOT EVEN PAST is produced by Sign up to receive bi-weekly email updates 19th century 20th Century The Department of History African American History american history Asia THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN Asia & Middle East book review Brazil British
Load more

Recommended publications
  • TABLE of CONTENTS Introduction
    Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................... 8 Akram Zaatari Excerpts from an Interview with Hashem El Madani ....................................................... 20 Charles Esche Sean Snyder .................................................................................. 28 Mira Keratová Les travailleurs n’ont pas de patrie ................................. 46 Michael Oppitz The Beauty of Exactitude. Talk about ethnographic film between Ahmad Alasti and Michael Oppitz ... 48 WORKS Mathilde ter Heijne Woman to go, 2005, 180 different postcards, 6 postcard racks, Edition 1/3, Thyssen-Bornemisza Collections ......................... 14 Akram Zaatari Hashem El Madani: Studio Practices, 2006, 76 silver prints taken between 1949 and the late 1970s by Hashem El Madani, each between 22 x 15 cm and 39.5 x 26.5 cm, Thyssen-Bornemisza Collections ...... 20 Sean Snyder Casio, Seiko, Sheraton, Toyota, Mars, 2004–2005, Single-channel video projection, 13 min 12 sec, color, sound, Edition 3/3 + 2 AP, Thyssen-Bornemisza Collections .................................................................. 28 Walid Raad (The Atlas Group) Let’s Be Honest. The Weather Helped, 1998/2006, Set of 7 plates (archival inkjet prints), each 46.4 x 71.8 cm, Edition 3/7 + 1 AP, Thyssen-Bornemisza Collections .............................. 32 Ai Weiwei Colored Vases, 2006, 10 pieces, Neolithic vases (5000–3500 b.c.), industrial paint, each approx. 30 x 20 cm, Thyssen-Bornemisza Collections ......... 36 Brad Kahlhamer Billy Jack, Jr., 2006, Graphite, ink, gouache and watercolor on paper, 157.5 x 208.3 cm, Thyssen-Bornemisza Collections ....... 40 Anetta Mona Chisa / Lucia Tkácová Uncomfortable Heritage, 2005, Performance Capital: Magical Recipes for Love, Happiness and Health, 2006, Single-channel video, 12 min 17 sec, color, sound, Courtesy of the artists ............. 44 Tanya Hamilton / Daniel F. Friedlaender / Michael W.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Lotito Lisa Freyastark.Pdf
    THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY SCHREYER HONORS COLLEGE DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY AND RELIGIOUS STUDIES PROGRAM FREYA STARK: A STUDY OF TRAVEL, GENDER, AND EMPIRE IN THE MIDDLE EAST FROM 1932-1950 LISA LOTITO Fall 2011 A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a baccalaureate degree in History with honors in History Reviewed and approved* by the following: Janina Safran Associate Professor Thesis Supervisor Catherine Wanner Professor Honors Adviser * Signatures are on file in the Schreyer Honors College. ABSTRACT Dame Freya Stark traveled to the Middle East and published The Valleys of the Assassins, The Southern Gates of Arabia, Baghdad Sketches, and East is West from 1932 until 1950, the year she penned the first volume of her autobiography. This thesis evaluates her travel writings for the way Stark employs travel, gender, and Empire in constructing her identity, the identity of both the British and Arabs with whom she comes into contact, and the larger relationships of the British Empire to the Middle East. Prior to 1932, Stark published an article entitled Women and the Service of the Empire. Shortly after she published this article, Freya received the prestigious Back Grant from the Royal Geographical Society and began a book deal with John Murray Publishers. From then on, Stark published thirty-two works for the British public about her travels. This thesis argues that prior to her fame, Freya viewed British women as a potential asset to the Empire because of their ability to aid in the relationship between the British and those they colonized. However, as Freya traveled, her conceptions of gender and Empire evolved.
    [Show full text]
  • What I Am Reading Right Now Is Bolded In
    What I am reading right now is bolded in red Scroll down to find out what it is (Books typed in white are what I regard as my favourites, although hopefully this list will constantly change; the 1000th book I read is in green) 1. Abélard and Héloïse — The Letters of Abélard and Héloïse 2. Mark Abley — Spoken Here: Travels Among Threatened Languages 3. Chinua Achebe — Things Fall Apart 4. Chinua Achebe — No Longer at Ease 5. Chinua Achebe — Anthills of the Savannah 6. James Agee — Death in the Family 7. Felipe Alfau — Locos: A Comedy of Gestures 8. Nelson Algren — A Walk on the Wild Side 9. Tariq Ali — Redemption 10. Cristina Ali Farah — Little Mother (“Madre Piccola”) 11. Dante Alighieri — The Inferno (“Il Inferno”) 12. Michael Allen, Sonya Patel Ellis [Eds.] — Nature Tales: Encounters with Britain’s Wildlife 13. Isabel Allende — The House of Spirits (“La Casa de los Espiritus”) 14. Julia Alvarez — In the Time of the Butterflies 15. Jorge Amado — Gabriela, Clove and Cinnamon (“Gabriela, Cravo e Canela”) 16. Jorge Amado — The Violent Land (“Terras do Sem Fim”) 17. Jorge Amado — Home is the Sailor (“Os Velhos Marinheiros”) 18. Jorge Amado — Dona Flor and her Two Husbands (“Dona Flor e seus Dois Maridos”) 19. Syed Amanuddin — Creativity and Reception: Toward a Theory of Third World Criticism 20. Samuel Amell — Literature, the Arts, and Democracy: Spain in the Eighties 21. Jonathan Ames — Wake up, Sir! 22. Kingsley Amis — Lucky Jim 23. Martin Amis — Success 24. Martin Amis — Money: A Suicide Note 25. Martin Amis — Time’s Arrow 26.
    [Show full text]
  • The Assassins of Alamut
    THE ASSASSINS OF ALAMUT THE ASSASSINS OF ALAMUT Anthony Campbell 1 Copyright © Iran Chamber Society THE ASSASSINS OF ALAMUT CONTENTS • Chapter 1: Prologue The background to the story and an account of a personal visit to the site of the castle at Alamut. • Chapter 2: Hasan-i-Sabbah Hasan-i-Sabbah captured the castle at Alamut and inaugurated the sect which became known in the West as the Assassins. • Chapter 3: The Resurrection at Alamut In 1164 the Grand Master of Alamut called his followers together and announced that the Muslim law was at an end; all his followers were now living in the Time of the Resurrection. • Chapter 4: The Assassins in Syria The Syrian offshoot of the Assassins was to some extent independent of Alamut under its talented and remarkable ruler, Sinan, who became known to the Crusaders as the "Old Man of the Mountains". • Chapter 5: Decline and Fall The Assassins gradually declined in power and influence and were finally destroyed by the Mongols. • Chapter 6: Epilogue The Assassins disappeared in Iran but continued in India as the Khojas. The Agha Khan is the lineal descendant of the Grand Masters of Alamut. • Appendix 1: Ismaili Theosophy A fuller account of the nature of the complex ideas that underlay Ismailism. • Appendix 2: Cyclical Time in Ismailism The Ismailis had an elaborate cosmological scheme based on numerical correspondences and the Platonic Great Year. This Appendix traces the origins of these ideas. • Appendix 3: The Nature and Role of the Ismaili Imam The role of the Imam was central in Ismailism.
    [Show full text]
  • Freya Stark Photographic Albums
    Freya Stark Photographic Albums Contents Aden 2 Turkey – North 100 Afghanistan I 4 Turkey – North East 103 Afghanistan II - Uzbekistan 8 Turkey – South (I) 106 Angkor see Far East Turkey – South II 109 China 15 Turkey – South III 112 Crete see Malta and Crete Turkey – South IV 115 Crusader Coast 18 Turkey – West (I) 117 Cyprus see Sicily and Cyprus Turkey – West II 120 Egypt 20 Turkey – West III 123 Far East 23 Greece I 26 Greece II 29 Greece III – Islands 32 Greece (IV) – Islands II 35 India 39 Iraq – Baghdad 42 Iraq – Mid 43 Jordania see Lebanon, Palestine, Jordania/ Syria: Druze, Palestine, Jordan Kuwait 49 Lebanon see Crusader Coast/ Lebanon, Palestine, Jordania Libya I – Cyrenaica 52 Libya II – Tripoli 55 Malta and Crete 57 Nepal I 59 Nepal II 62 Nepal III 36 Palestine see Crusader Coast/ Lebanon, Palestine, Jordania/ Syria: Druze, Palestine, Jordan Persia 65 Persia – Ancient 66 Persia – Central 68 Persia – North 71 Sicily and Cyprus 74 South Arabia – Buildings 77 South Arabia – Landscapes 79 South Arabia – People 81 Syria see Crusader Coast/Syria Syria: Druze, Palestine, Jordan 84 Syria: North 87 Syria: Villes Mortes 89 Tunisia 92 Turkey – 1969 95 Turkey – Istanbul 96 1 ©Middle East Centre, St Antony’s College, Oxford. OX2 6JF Aden 1938. 26/30 Huraidha 1940. VIII/12a Port Suakin 1940. VIII/7a Suakin 1935. 4 South Arab Coast - Wreckage 1935. 4/7 South Arab Coast 1938. 66/8 South Arab Coast 1934. 4/22 Government House - Aden - Looking to Little Aden 1934. 3/27 Little Aden 1934. 2/26 Little Aden 1934.
    [Show full text]
  • In Her Own Words: Works by Exceptional Women
    london Peter Harrington ININ HERHER OWN WORDS WORKS BY EXCEPTIONAL WOMEN ur first catalogue focussed on women spans the Others have been overlooked despite brilliant contributions Ocenturies from Sappho to Maya Angelou, showcasing the to their fields. Early works by Joan Robinson (122 and 123) and work of exceptional women in many different fields. Rosa Luxemburg (96) are well-known to economists, but less These were women who pushed legal, intellectual, and well-known are those by Helen Makower (97) and S. F. Porter physical boundaries. Millicent Fawcett Garrett signed our (118). Rosalind Franklin and Jocelyn Bell were both denied copy of Women’s Victory in July 1928, the same month the Equal Nobel prizes, despite playing crucial roles in the discovery of the Franchise Act gave British women electoral equality with men structure of DNA and radio pulsars respectively (70 and 22). In (item 66). Maria Gaetana Agnesi’s Analytical Institutions is the the suffrage movement, the works of Christabel (109) and Sylvia first advanced mathematics book by a woman (1). Trailblazers Pankhurst (110) sit alongside work by their exiled sister, Adela such as Fanny Parks, “characterized by remarkable physical (108), comparatively overlooked, yet no less fierce a Pankhurst stamina” (112), Amelia Edwards, who carried out the first for it. general archaeological survey of Egypt’s ruins (60), and Lady Within the catalogue, works on paper appear alongside items Hester Stanhope, “Queen of the Desert” (144), cleared the way in different media. Amelia Earhart’s Fun of It, inscribed (59), for later intrepid travellers such as Gertrude Bell (21) and Freya complements the pearl carried on the maiden voyage of the Stark (145).
    [Show full text]
  • Freya Stark (1893-1993) Was Famous As an Explorer of Remote Middle Eastern Areas, As a Travel Writer and Was Accredited with a Deep Understanding of the Arab Mind
    Library of the Australian Defence Force Academy w University College The University of New South Wales Donor: C.A. CAMPBELL UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES Thesis/Project Report Sheet Surname or Family name: Firstname: CHRI.S.TINE Othername/s: MN Abbreviation for degree as given in the University calendar: MA... .(.HONS.) School: Faculty: ENQLISH. Titfc: F.REXA...S.XARK Abstract 350 words maximum: (PLEASE TYPE) Dame Freya Stark (1893-1993) was famous as an explorer of remote Middle Eastern areas, as a travel writer and was accredited with a deep understanding of the Arab mind. She received many awards and distinctions, commonly reserved for men. She wrote an autobiography, detailing her achievements, which revealed a self-made writer and explorer. She depicted a delicate invalid, yet her reputation was as an intrepid explorer; her writing career was an immediate success; her views on the Arab mind were courted at the highest level. Three of her friends wrote biographies about her, but all were based upon her own autobiography. Throughout her biographies there was a thin thread of subversive comment. The dissonance required explanation. My examination of her later-published letters result in an alternative story. She was not self-made, there was an unsuspected network of relations, friends and circumstances which had contributed to her otherwise inexplicably successful travelling, writing and "political" career. Her actual exploration was found to amount to very little - very brief and the product of good advice as much as anything else. An exploration of her health problems revealed them to be largely illusory. After examination of Stark's attitude towards "Orientalism" is defined and examined in detail, it is revealed that she understood little and sympathized even less with middle class Arabs.
    [Show full text]
  • Freya Stark John C
    Santa Clara University Scholar Commons English College of Arts & Sciences 1998 Freya Stark John C. Hawley Santa Clara Univeristy, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarcommons.scu.edu/engl Part of the English Language and Literature Commons, and the Feminist, Gender, and Sexuality Studies Commons Recommended Citation Hawley, J. C. (1998). Freya Stark. In B. Brothers (Ed.), Dictionary of Literary Biography, Vol. 195, British Travel Writers 1910–39 (pp. 325-340). Gale Research. From . Dictionary of Literary Biography. © 1998 Gale, a part of Cengage, Inc. Reproduced by permission. www.cengage.com/permissions This Book Chapter is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Arts & Sciences at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in English by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Freya Stark (31 January 1893 - 9 May 1993) John C. Hawley Santa Clara University BOOKS: Baghdad Sketches (Baghdad: Times Press, 1932; enlarged edition, London: Murray, 1937; New York: Dutton, 1938); The Valleys of the Assassins and Other Persian Travels (London: Murray, 1934; New York: Dutton, 1934); The Southern Gates of Arabia: A Journey in the Hadhramaut (London: Murray, 1936; New York: Dutton, 1936); Seen in the Hadhramaut (London: Murray, 1938; New York: Dutton, 1939); A Winter in Arabia (London: Murray, 1940; New York: Dutton, 1940); Lettersfrom Syria (London: Murray, 1942) ; East Is West (London: Murray, 1945); republished as The Arab Island:
    [Show full text]
  • The Royal Geographical Society (With IBG) Inside the Archive
    The Royal Geographical Society (with IBG) inside the archive wileydigitalarchives.com/rgs Introduction Where we live. Where we work. Who we are. Our world as we know it today. Geography is, in The fundamental tenets of our society—people, cultures, places, environment—and how they interact and influence each other are the broadest sense, at the core of the geographic discipline. Those that came before us—the likes of Shackleton, of Livingstone, of Hillary, of Bell and many more—not only traced and discovered parts unknown, but an education for life they did not so much with the promise of success, but the incredible probability of failure. and for living. From the role of women to colonialism in Africa, this lookbook demonstrates the interdisciplinary scope of geographical research – Royal Geographical Society (with IBG) and provides a window into the foremost geographers and expeditions of our time. To learn more about the stories in the Royal Geographical Society (with IBG) Collection, visit wileydigitalarchives.com/rgs. 2 Colonialism in Africa FILE THIS UNDER Geography, African Studies, Colonial History, Cartography, Anthropology, International Relations, Economic History HISTORICAL CONTEXT Throughout the nineteenth century, maps of Africa became symbols of British missionary, scientific and imperial endeavour. No meeting concerning Africa – whether to promote missionary activity, to debate the location of rivers and lakes, or to contemplate imperial schemes – was complete without a large map of the continent. Founded in 1830, the Royal Geographical Society (with IBG) served as an information exchange for explorers, soldiers, administrators and naturalists, providing intelligence and advice for a range of government departments; its extensive map room was a frequent source of information for the military.
    [Show full text]
  • Freya Stark's Known Covert Activities in the Middle East, 1927–1943
    Appendix A: Freya Stark’s known covert activities in the Middle East, 1927–1943, compiled from various archival and published sources From To Region Visited Objective/product Client 1927–10 1928 Levant Beirut; Unknown. Probably debriefed SIS/ Damascus; regarding the Jebel Druze WO? Jebel Druze; Palestine; Cairo 1930–04 1930–06 Persia Elburz Cartographic survey (Valley of WO Mountains the Assassins) 1931–08 1931–10 Persia Elburz Cartographic and WO/ Mountains; archaeological surveys (Valley RGS Luristan of the Assassins; Luri graves); RGS reports 1931–10 1933–03 Baghdad – Baghdad Times (mostly) ? 1932–09 1933–02 Persia Luristan Cartographic survey (Pusht-i-­ WO Kuh [uncharted]) 1934–12 1935–04 Yemen Hadhramaut Probably no intelligence. RGS? Aborted (measles) 1937–10 1938–03 Yemen Hadhramaut Probably no intelligence; just RGS RGS reports. (Wakefield archaeological expedition leader) 1939–03 1939–07 Syria Hama, Probably no intelligence RGS? Orontes valley, Aleppo © The Author(s) 2019 261 A. O’Sullivan, The Baghdad Set, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-15183-6 262 APPENDIX A: FREYA STARK’S KNOWN COVERT ACTIVITIES IN THE MIDDLE EAST… From To Region Visited Objective/product Client 1939–10 1939–10 Cairo – Meetings in Cairo with various – intelligence personalities: Cawthorn (MEIC), Thornhill (SIS), Clayton (DDMI), et al. 1939–11 1940–02 Aden – Assistant Information Officer. MOI/ Ikhwan al-Hurriya. Bonzo FO scheme 1940–02 1940–03 Yemen Sana’a Political, military, economic MEIC/ intelligence. Persuasion FO 1940–07 1941–03 Cairo Ikhwan. Bonzo scheme MOI/ SOE 1941–03 1943–02 Baghdad Ikhwan MOI 1943–02 1943–03 Delhi Bonzo scheme GOC 1943–04 1943–08 Baghdad Ikhwan MOI Periods between travels spent in the UK and/or Italy.
    [Show full text]
  • An Imagological Study of Freya Stark's the Southern Gates of Arabia
    PEOPLE’S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF ALGERIA Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research University of Tlemcen Faculty of Letters and Foreign Languages Department of English An Imagological Study of Freya Stark’s The Southern Gates of Arabia A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirement for a Master’s Degree in Anglo-Saxon Literature and Civilization Presented by Supervised by Mr. Mounir Kaddouri Dr. Souad Berbar Board of Examiners Dr. Daoudi Frid Chairperson Dr. Souad Berbar Supervisor Mr. Omar Rahmoun Examiner Academic Year: 2016-2017 Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to my beloved parents, who have brought me up to be the man I am today. Thank you for everything. II Acknowledgements Above all, I am thankful to Allah for the healthiness and well-being that were indispensable for the accomplishment of this dissertation. I would like to convey my profound appreciation to my supervisor Dr. Berbar, who has been the ideal supervisor. Her wise advice, eye-opening criticism and uplifting encouragement helped me in writing this work. I could not have envisaged having a better mentor for my Master study. Besides my supervisor, I wish to thank the remaining members of the jury: Dr. Frid, and Mr. Rahmoun, for taking from their precious time to read and assess my work. I want also to render my gratitude to all of the department members for their help and support. Finally I thank everyone, who directly or indirectly, assisted me in accomplishing this task. III Abstract British travel writers were driven by an urge to find an elsewhere still unexplored, a place where a traveller could still become a pioneer, a heroic adventurer.
    [Show full text]
  • Orientalism and Three British Dames: De-Essentialization of the Other In
    Orientalism and Three British Dames: De-essentialization of the Other in the Work of Gertrude Bell, Freya Stark, and E.S. Drower A Thesis Submitted to The Faculty of the School of Communication In Candidacy for the Degree of Master of Arts in English By Lynn Massie Sawyer April 2012 Sawyer 2 Liberty University School of Communication Master of Arts in English Dr. Emily Heady, Thesis Chair Date Dr. Brenda Ayres, First Reader Date Dr. Yaw Adu-Gyamfi, Second Reader Date Sawyer 3 Abstract Although postcolonial criticism has run its course for thirty years, a fresh look at Edward Said’s Orientalism offers insight into how Orientalism functions in the writings of three British dames. Gertrude Bell in The Desert and the Sown, Freya Stark in The Southern Gates of Arabia, and E.S. Drower in The Mandaeans of Iraq and Iran, however, challenge Said’s theory. Their writing raises questions about how gender alters the discourse about the Other, and whether Said essentializes the Occident. Bell, Stark, and Drower serve as case studies in which to analyze the politically and rhetorically complex interactions between the West and the East at the end of the Colonial period. Over time, these women moved from approaching the Other with superior attitudes and a focus on otherness to developing a sympathetic understanding and greater appreciation of the similarities between the West and the East. Key Words: Said, Bell, Stark, Drower, Orientalism, Other, Postcolonialism Sawyer 4 Acknowledgements First of all, I would like to share my appreciation for the following people who helped me in this thesis process.
    [Show full text]