DOCSLIB.ORG

Rekindle Kashmir's Lost and Real Connect

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Rekindle Kashmir's Lost and Real Connect Rekindle Kashmir’s lost and real connect 05 August, 2020 | GS-I | Modern History | GS PAPER 1 | MODERN INDIA | J&K ISSUE Rekindle Kashmir’s lost and real connect By, Amitabh Mattoo is Professor, School of International Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University Context This article talks about the contributions of various Kashmiris who aspired for a united nation with J&K as an integral part of India due to ot shared cultural and social values. Foiling ‘Operation Gibraltar’ It was on August 5, 1965 that two Kashmiri Gujjars helped to thwart one of Pakistan’s most devious conspiracies in the Valley. Mohammed Din, and Wazir Mohammed at Galuthi in the Mendhar sector, reported the Pakistani infiltration (to, respectively, the Thana at Tangmarg and the headquarters of the infantry brigade at Poonch) that was intended to spark an uprising in Kashmir, as part of its insidious ‘Operation Gibraltar’ relying on a ready-to-rebel fifth column within the Valley. In short, ‘Operation Gibraltar’ failed, as did every other attempt by Pakistan because of the fundamental belief of Kashmiris in the goodness and greatness of India. Baramullah’s Maqbool Sherwani Consider, for instance, the story of Baramullah’s Maqbool Sherwani. It was Sherwani, in 1947, who helped delay the Pakistan-backed tribal invaders march to Srinagar from Baramulla before the arrival of the Indian armed forces. The tribal invaders eventually found him out; tortured him, shot him and crucified him, but not, as I wrote once earlier, before he cried out one last time, “Muslim Sikh Etihad, Zindabad (Victory for the unity of Sikhs, Hindus and Muslims). This, said Mahatma Gandhi at his prayer meeting, later, “was a martyrdom of which anyone, Hindu, Sikh, Muslim or any other, would be proud.” A principal with principles A legendary principal of the local women’s college, Ms. Mehmooda Ali Shah, who faced a minor act of rebellion. She heard that one of her students had shouted “Pakistan Zindabad!” on the college grounds. Dressed as always in a handloom sari, Ms. Shah (both a Gandhian and a Fellow Traveller) marched down the grounds, with hundreds of students and staff watching her, and confronted the student. The legendary principal slapped the delinquent student hard, admonished her and went back to her office amidst pindrop silence. For nearly two decades as principal, Ms. Shah exemplified through her personality, and through her word and deed, not just the quest for the empowerment of Kashmiri women but her ability to stand up for the ideas that endeared India to the Kashmiris. The power of the Soviet bond At the height of the Cold War, in 1955, when the Anglo-American bloc (it is often conveniently forgotten these days) was arm-twisting New Delhi to hold a plebiscite in Jammu and Kashmir, the First Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, Nikita Sergeyevich Khrushchev and the Premier Nikolai Bulganin, visited India. Nehru insisted that they visited Srinagar where they watched the genius, Dina Nath Nadim’s opera: ‘Bombur Taa Yemberzal (The Narcissus and the Bumble bee’), an allegorical reference to the clash between Imperialism and Socialism. So deeply inspired were they by the visit that Khrushchev and the Soviet Union recognised Jammu and Kashmir as an integral part of India soon thereafter, and continued to cast its veto to block any attempt by the United Nations Security Council to intervene in Kashmir. If it was Nadim who brought the plight of Kashmir to the world, and the justness of India’s cause. It was the extraordinary art of Ghulam Rasool Santosh that revealed Kashmir’s unique syncretic culture. Santosh’s paintings reflected not just the unity of the cosmos, but also the glories of Sufi and Tantric thought. The larger fusion of the diversity of India within Kashmir’s multiple streams is reflected in Santosh’s art. Steps needed The most effective police chief in the history of Jammu and Kashmir, was the barely school-educated Kashmiri, Peer Ghulam Hassan Shah, who broke the back of the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front and the Kashmir Al-Fatah. Way forward In the legacy of leaders such as Peer Ghulam Hassan Shah and Ms. Mehmooda lies the future of New Delhi in Kashmir and the future basis of Kashmir’s faith in India. Executive decisions and even constitutional amendments are not the challenge; Article 370 had lost much of its potency even before the decisions made last year. The real challenge has remained the emotional integration of Kashmir within the national mainstream. Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org).
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Borderlands and Borders of the Indian Subcontinent, New Delhi: Aryan Books International, 2018, Pp 232
    Book Discussion Dilip K Chakrabarti: The Borderlands and Borders of the Indian Subcontinent, New Delhi: Aryan Books International, 2018, pp 232 Understanding Indian Borderlands Dilip K Chakrabarti he Indian subcontinent shares borders with Iran, Afghanistan, the plateau of Tibet Tand Myanmar. The sub-continent’s influence extends beyond these borders, creating distinct ‘borderlands’ which are basically geographical, political, economic and religious interaction zones. It is these ‘borderlands’ which historically constitute the subcontinent’s ‘area of influence’ and underlines its civilizational role in the Asian landmass. A clear understanding of this civilizational role may be useful in strengthening India’s perception of her own geo-strategic position. Iran One may begin with Iran at the western limit of these borderland. There are two main mountain ranges in Iran : the Zagros which separates Iran from Iraq and has to its south the plain of Khuzestan giving access to south Iraq ; and the Elburz which separates the inland Iran from the Caspian belt, Turkmenistan and (to a limited extent , Azerbaijan). The Caspian shores form a well-wooded verdant belt which poses a strong contrast to the dry Iranian plateau. There are two deserts inside the Iranian plateau -- dasht-i-lut and dasht-i-kevir, which do not encourage human habitation. The population concentration of Iran is along the margins of the mountain belt and also in Khuzestan. The following facts are noteworthy. The eastern rim of Iran carries an imprint of the subcontinent. There is a ready access to Iranian Baluchistan through the Kej valley in Pakistani Baluchistan. At its eastern edge this valley leads both to lower Sindh and Kalat.
    [Show full text]
  • Conclusion: Afterword---A Clarion Call
    Conclusion: Afterword---A Clarion Call Tahir Abbas In the shadows of the Himalayas stands the forgotten struggle of Jammu and Kashmir (Kashmir for short), whose plight remains precarious as India tightens its grip, placing the future of the territory in even more uncertainty and insecurity. The region of Kashmir is one of the most contested in the world. However, the vast majority of commentators, analysts, and social thinkers in the West routinely omit a careful anal- ysis while those in the region face immense pressures on their freedom to report and write on the issue. For too many, the matter is a bilat- eral question between India and Pakistan when the reality is an urgent and necessary need for the self-determination of the people of Kashmir. In presenting some closing arguments to this vital collection of scholarly input on the topic of social and political life in Jammu and Kashmir, I outline some distinct sociological concerns. I also take this opportunity to issue a clarion call to activists, scholars, and thinkers to place the needs and wants of Kashmir first and foremost, even if either neighbor—India or Pakistan—remains somewhat limited in its perspectives, whether this is by design or an accident of history. T. Abbas Leiden University, Leiden, Netherlands e-mail: [email protected] © The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive 299 license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2021 S. Hussain (ed.), Society and Politics of Jammu and Kashmir, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-56481-0 300 T.
    [Show full text]
  • Arrest of Arnab
    6 Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world. — Nelson Mandela EDITORIAL z Tuesday z November 10, 2020 ARREST OF ARNAB For Nehru they were 'raiders', for Sherwani & Motivation with better ntolerance over the criticisms of political parties and learning necessary for Ithe policies and programmes of government by the Mehjoor 'cannibals' media has been reaching its crescendo. Arnab Goswami, IIT JEE the Editor-in-Chief, Republic TV Channel and a senior AHMED ALI FAYYAZ in Srinagar as also on celluloid in several villages", the nightingales. They threw stones at crystal VIJAY GARG and respected journalist, started to be in the eye of mong all Kashmiris, the historic failure of Taing told STATE TIMES. shops. Had you been armed they wouldn't have t's will be a 100% correct statement to say storm of the government since the time he became vocif- Pakistan's 'Operation Gulmarg' is attrib- Taing has served as Secretary J&K Academy dared to attack. Ithat, Joint Entrance Examination (JEE) is erous at the assassination of Sadhus in Palghar. The Auted to the National Conference (NC) of Art, Culture and Languages, Director General In another poem titled 'Ahad-o-Paiman-e- one of the toughest exams for getting admission protagonists of media freedom have been maintaining activist Maqbool Sherwani of Baramulla. Seized of Information, Archives and Museums, a mem- Hazratbal', Mehjoor crafts a poetic version of into the top engineering institute of India- the loud silence despite physical attack in April and now and punished for 'treason' by the Pakistani tribal ber of J&K State Public Service Commission and Sheikh Abdullah's address to a huge gathering on Indian Institute of Technology(IIT).
    [Show full text]
  • A Novelist, Short Story Writer As Well As an Art Critic, Mulk Raj Anand (1905
    A novelist, short story writer as well as an art critic, Mulk Raj Anand (1905-2004) was among the first few Indian writers in English who gained international recognition early in his life. His novels Untouchable (1935) and Coolie (1936) impressively articulate the abuses of an exploited class. A dynamic personality, impeccably dressed Anand befriended great writers like E.M. Forster, Herbert Read and George Orwell. Till 1947, he spent half his time in London and half in India. It was therefore inevitable for him to be drawn to India’s struggle for independence. The most important influence upon Anand was that of Gandhi who shaped his social conscience. With success, Anand came to firmly believe that a writer’s work is an illustration of a ‘fiery voice of those people who through his own torments...transmutes in art all feeling...thus becoming the seer of new vision...’ Anand was proactively associated with the Progressive Writers’ movement of India and was one of the moving spirits behind the drafting of its first manifesto. Equally noteworthy was his passion for the arts whose best expression were the issues of Marg which he founded and edited for a quarter century. Even after he withdrew from its editorship, it continued to be the leading art journal of India. This book is the first ever attempt to put together the biography of such a vibrant personality who left no stone unturned to realise his dreams. With Raja Rao and R.K. Narayan, Anand is regarded as one of the founding fathers of the Indian English novel.
    [Show full text]
  • From the Pages of History
    FROM THE PAGES OF HISTORY BY PANDIT JANKI NATH KACHROO FROM THE PAGES OF HISTORY BY PANDIT JANKI NATH KACHROO SOURCE : MILCHAR , KPA, MUMBAI , INDIA EDITOR : MAHARAJ K. RAINA Copyright © 2011 by Milchar, a Kashmiri Pandit Association (KPA), Mumbai publication (http://iKashmir.net/milchar) All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in whole or in part, or stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without written permission of Kashmir News Network. For permission regarding publication, send an e-mail to [email protected] TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 BRIBE DISCOVERED .................................................................................... 1 2.0 AFGHAN RULE IN KASHMIR ........................................................................ 3 3.0 SELECTING A SUCCESSOR ......................................................................... 10 4.0 KASHMIR - JUNE 1947 TO OCTOBER 1947 ................................................ 12 4.1 THE STATE AS ON 15 TH AUGUST 1947 ........................................................... 12 4.2 EVENTS JUNE 1947 ONWARDS ..................................................................... 12 5.0 GARDEN TRADITION AND THE MUGHAL CONTRIBUTION .......................... 16 5.1 SHALIMAR GARDEN ................................................................................... 16 6.0 FANATICISM NOT HEREDITARY ................................................................ 18 6.1
    [Show full text]
  • Gandhi on Kashmir Introduced and Compiled by Kannan T! Ebook Published by Kannan T, Coimbatore August, 2020 Contents
    ! ! ! War and Ahimsa! Gandhi on Kashmir! ! ! ! Introduced and Compiled by Kannan T! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Ebook Published By Kannan T, Coimbatore August, 2020 ! Contents! i. Introduction………………….2! ii. Part I: Before the Raids…….18! iii. Part II: After the Raids……….28! ! ! War and Ahimsa: Gandhi on Kashmir Introduction! [This introduction to Gandhi’s writings on Kashmir was written on 1st September 2019 and was published in Tamizhini magazine. The book was published in Tamil by Yaavarum Publishers in October, 2019. It has almost been one year since the ushering in of an unproclaimed emergency in Kashmir. Not much has changed during the last year. I am publishing this introduction, along with Gandhi’s utterances on Kashmir, as an ebook in English without too many changes now, in the hope that this will help in bringing about a better understanding of the historical circumstances of accession of Kashmir to India, especially the role of Gandhi in it. ! - Kannan T, 2-August-2020 ] ! Jammu and Kashmir has faced many wars, terrorism and people’s protests ever since India gained independence. Today, this land is encountering another major political challenge. A state, which was given special status, has lost its special status, and moreover, has lost the status of a state, being split into two Union Territories. The political leaders of Kashmir and a few thousand people have been imprisoned. More armed forces have been sent to Kashmir, which was already one of the most militarised zones in the world. Opposition leaders have been prevented from entering Kashmir. Most shops have been shut for almost two months.
    [Show full text]
  • Negotiating Necrophilia: an Afterword Ashis Nandy
    Negotiating Necrophilia: An Afterword Ashis Nandy Kashmir overwrites almost everything that is written about it. Not because of its unique culture, its geopolitical significance, or its breathtaking natural beauty but because of its pain. Like Palestine and Northern Ireland, Kashmir is a typically twentieth century prob- lem that has gate-crashed into the twenty-first century. All three places are beneficiaries of partitions mindlessly implemented by a tired imperial power and all are associated with gory, repetitious, gratuitous violence that wear out outside observers and analysts, but not those who participate in the violence. State formation and nation building have an ugly record the world over. The subsequent humanization of many states and nations can- not wipe off that record, for the earlier memories are immortalized as part of a myth of origin that includes the idea of an unavoidable birth trauma. The sufferings experienced and the sufferings inflicted blend in that myth. Under the lofty rhetoric of today lie the persistent fears, bitterness, and anxieties of the past, even when the past has become distant. Every nation-state, thus, is permanently on guard. So are its detractors, enemies, and critics. That is because the myth of origin never fades or dates. Each generation rediscovers it, sometimes with even more passion than the earlier generation did. Sadly, Kashmir has been captive, during the past sixty years, in the making of the myths of origin of India and Pakistan. Even more sadly, it now seems unable to resist the birth of a new creation myth of its own, which promises to replicate the efforts of its tormentors faithfully.
    [Show full text]
  • 'GULAB GAATHA'- an Unforgettable Theatrical Venture Aarushi Thakur Possession
    BOOKING OPEN 2BHK/3BHK FLATS at Gurgaon, Noida, Noida Extension, Greater Noida Cont: 9419101229, 94191-76665 ENTRUST REALTORS & CONSULTANTS SUNDAY, OCTOBER 27, 2013 INTERNET EDITION : www.dailyexcelsior.com/magazine www.jammuproperty.com THE SAVIORS OF KASHMIR Shiban Khaibri a paltry number of 150 men and marched to Baramulla which by that time, had fallen and The Greek epic poet Homer says: "Without the town of Dhumal 112 kms far from Srinagar a sign, his sword the brave man draws, and too was lost. His first action was at Garhi on asks no omen, but his country's cause." We Oct23, 1947, the second one at Uri on Oct 24th have heard sagas of bravery, the gritting deter- and third at Mahura on Oct 25. He succeeded mination, impeccable resolve and feats of war- in destroying a vital bridge at Uri to halt the riors but they all appear not above the extreme advancement of Qabalies. One by one his men bravery and patriotism shown by the proud son offered the supreme sacrifice and the Brigadier of the soil, Brigadier Rajinder Singh who fought leading from the front, single handedly, kept the swarm of Afridees, Mahsuds, Wazirs, fighting for hours together even in the condi- Swathis and others known as Qabaliyees, tion of being profusely wounded. He kept on those were inspired, aided armed and pushed fighting till the enemy surrounded him in over- into Kashmir by Pakistan along with its regular whelming numbers and rained bullets on him soldiers attired as tribesmen under the overall making him attain martyrdom. The Brigadier command of Colonel Akbar Khan under his won the decisive battle while the nitwit enemy nom de gurre of "General Tariq." They were won a mere local fight.
    [Show full text]
  • By Andrew Whitehead
    University of Warwick institutional repository: http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap/58396 This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. 1 2 The Kashmir Conflict of 1947: Testimonies of a Contested History Andrew Whitehead A critical overview submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy by published works in History Supervisor: Professor David Hardiman University of Warwick, Department of History May 2013 3 Table of Contents Introduction 1. Context of the research 5 2. Personal history 8 3. Research method and argument 15 4. Original contribution to knowledge 19 5. Critical reception 28 6. Subsequent writing on Kashmir’s modern history 35 Conclusion 44 Appendix: Personal bibliography relating to Partition and Kashmir in 1947 Accompanying the critical overview are two articles being put forward for this Ph D, the details of which follow. The book A Mission in Kashmir is submitted separately. 4 Introduction The published works that I am putting forward for this PhD are as follows: Andrew Whitehead, A Mission in Kashmir, New Delhi: Viking Penguin, 2007, xii + 244pp, ISBN-13: 978-0-67008-127-1, ISBN-10: 0-67008-127-2 Andrew Whitehead, ‘The People’s Militia: Communists and Kashmiri nationalism in the 1940s’, Twentieth Century Communism: a journal of international history, 2, 2010, pp.141-68 Andrew Whitehead, ‘Kashmir’s Conflicting Identities’ [review essay], History Workshop Journal, 58, 2004, pp.335-40 This critical overview will explain how these works came to be written and the methodology of the underlying research.
    [Show full text]
  • Recalling a Pakistan Misadventure: What Happened on October 22, 1947?
    Recalling a Pakistan misadventure: What happened on October 22, 1947? 22 October, 2020 | GS-I | Post consolidation India | GS PAPER 1 | J&K ISSUE | MODERN INDIA Recalling a Pakistan misadventure: What happened on October 22, 1947? Context Kashmiris have traditionally observed October 27 as a Black Day to mark the first landing of Indian troops in the Valley in 1947 to push back Pakistan-backed tribal invaders. But this year, in what appears to be an effort by the government to change that narrative, the Ministry of Culture is marking October 22 — the day the Pakistani invasion began and set the stage for the first India-Pakistan war — with a string of events, including a symposium in Srinagar on the events of that day. The lead-up to Oct 22 By October 1947, Kashmir was in high ferment. For months before the independence of India and the creation of Pakistan, Hari Singh, the Hindu ruler of Muslim-majority Kashmir, was facing a rebellion in Poonch by Muslim subjects who refused to pay taxes and launched an armed insurgency. Hari Singh deployed the Kashmir state forces to crack down. At the same time, with Partition nearing, Hindus and Sikhs had been crossing into Jammu, bringing with them stories of harrowing violence in Rawalpindi and other areas. Jammu had turned into a communal cauldron by the time anti-Muslim clashes broke out. There are varying versions of how many Muslims were killed, but most accounts speak of the riots as a massacre. At Independence, Hari Singh decided that Kashmir would not accede to either India or Pakistan.
    [Show full text]
  • Militancy Has Gone Down in Kashmir
    www.thenorthlines.com www.epaper.northlines.com 3 DAYS’ FORECAST JAMMU Date Min Temp Max Temp Weather 08-Nov 13.0 26.0 Mainly Clear sky 09-Nov 13.0 26.0 Mainly Clear sky 10-Nov 13.0 26.0 Mainly Clear sky 3 DAYS’ FORECAST SRINAGAR 08-Nov 2.0 20.0 Partly cloudy sky 09-Nov 2.0 20.0 Partly cloudy sky 10-Nov 3.0 20.0 Partly cloudy sky Contractual Lecturers' hunger strike northlinesMLA from Bhaderwah campaign for the NFHS reports improvement enters day 266 Himachal elections in Child Sex ratio in Samba After the completion of 265 days and Member Legislative Assembly District Development Commissioner , the begin of 266th day today on the Bhaderwah Daleep Singh Parihar Sheetal Nanda today visited District eve of the opening of Darbar at Civil campaigned for BJP candidates in Hospital and met families of new born 3 Secretariat, Jammu. The 10+2 4 Chamba constituencies who are girls to congratulate and felicitate 5 them on the occasion .... Contractual Lecturers ... contesting Assembly .... INSIDE Vol No: XXII Issue No. 266 08.11.2017 (Wednesday) Daily Jammu Tawi Price 3/- Pages-12 Regd. No. JK|306|2017-19 Day two - 30 delegations meet Centre's Interlocutor; main players missing Valley lacks enthusiasm on Sharma's arrival It’s official now - militancy has Congress to meet tomorrow, NC yet to be invited gone down in Kashmir: Army NL CORRESPONDENT will decide tomorrow," he Gupkar. SRINAGAR, NOV 07 said. Meanwhile, former Masood Azhar’s nephew among 3 JeM militants killed in Pulwama The NC leader said that in spymaster and RAW chief A NL CORRESPONDENT While the Government of valley the spirit about S Dulat has said that SRINAGAR, NOV 07 India's representative, dialogue is missing as BJP dialogue without Hurriyat Dineshwar Sharma, is in created mess after Sharma's will be meaningless.
    [Show full text]
  • Building a New Kashmir: Bakshi Ghulam Muhammad and the Politics of State-Formation in a Disputed Territory (1953-1963)
    Building a New Kashmir: Bakshi Ghulam Muhammad and the Politics of State-Formation in a Disputed Territory (1953-1963) by Hafsa Kanjwal A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (History and Women’s Studies) in The University of Michigan 2017 Doctoral Committee: Professor Farina Mir, Co-Chair Professor Mrinalini Sinha, Co-Chair Professor Kathryn Babayan Professor Fatma Muge Gocek © Hafsa Kanjwal 2017 [email protected] ORCID ID: 0000-0002-5879-9906 Table of Contents Abstract iii Introduction 1 Chapter One: State-led Developmentalism and the Pursuit of Progress 44 Chapter Two: Creating a Modern Kashmiri Subject: Education, Secularization and its Discontents 97 Chapter Three: Jashn-e-Kashmir: Patronage and the Institutionalization of a Cultural Intelligentsia 159 Chapter Four: The State of Emergency: State Repression, Political Dissent and the Struggle for Self-Determination 205 Chapter Five: Remembering Naya Kashmir in Post Militancy Srinagar 249 Conclusion 304 Bibliography 310 ii Abstract This dissertation is a historical study of the early postcolonial period in the Indian- administered state of Jammu and Kashmir (1953-63). It traces the trajectory of “Naya [New] Kashmir,” a leftist manifesto of the National Conference (NC). The NC was a secular nationalist Kashmiri political party that came to power in the state in 1947, in the aftermath of Partition and the accession of Kashmir to India. This dissertation recuperates the relevance of Naya Kashmir during the rule of Bakshi Ghulam Mohammed (1953-63), the second Prime Minister of the state. Naya Kashmir originated as a progressive project of state and socio-cultural reform, emanating from the particular context of the Jammu and Kashmir princely state in the late colonial period.
    [Show full text]