by Andrew Jenson The next thing of importance connecting Clay County with the history of the Church was the impris- onment of , , , , Alexander McRae and Caleb Baldwin in the Liberty jail from November, 1838 to April 1839. El- der Lyman O. Littlefield, who at that time was learning the trade of a printer in the town of Liberty, gives in this connection the following graphic description of his youthful experience, in his interesting little work “Rem- iniscences of Latter-day Saints,” just published in Logan, Cache County:

“It must have been about the first of December when Church historian Andrew Jenson (on roof) visit- the prisoners assigned to the Liberty jail were conveyed ed the historic Liberty Jail on September 18, 1888. He to that place. was accompanied by Joseph S. Black (left) and Edward “It was the privilege of the writer—if it may be called Stevenson. Jenson recorded the dimensions and con- such—to witness their entrance into the place. They, struction of the jail where the Prophet Joseph Smith of course, traveled upon the main road leading from Jr., and other prisoners were incarcerated during the Richmond, and entered the town of Liberty on the east. winter of 1838 - 1839. Photograph by J. H. Hicks. They were all in one large, heavy wagon with a high box, During this trip Jenson visited with James Ford, which, as they were seated, hid from view all of their age 72, who had been the deputy sheriff of Clay Coun- forms, except from a little below the shoulders. They ty in 1838 - 1839. He had been placed in direct charge passed through the center of the town, across the public of the Mormon prisoners. During these times Ford square, in the center of which stood the court-house. had lengthy conversations with Joseph Smith, whom After crossing this square the wagon containing them he said was good-natured and even jocular in his was driven up the street northward about the distance manner. of two blocks, where, at the left hand side of the street, was a vacant piece of ground, upon which, close to the street, stood the Liberty jail, ever to be rendered famous one by one, the tall and well proportioned forms of the by the entrance into it of these illustrious prisoners. * prisoners entered. The Prophet Joseph was the last of the * * The inhabitants of Liberty, and many from the sur- number who lingered behind. He turned partly around, rounding country, were out to witness the entrance of with a slow and dignified movement, and looked upon the prisoners into the place, and many, on that occasion, the multitude. Then turning away, and lifting his hat, he in my hearing, expressed their disappointment that the said, in a distinct voice, ‘Good afternoon, gentlemen.’ strangers should so much resemble all other men of The next moment he had passed out of sight. The heavy prepossessing appearance. door swung upon its strong hinges, and the Prophet was “This large, clumsy built wagon—the box of which bid from the gaze of the curious populace who had so was highest at each end—finally halted close to the eagerly watched. platform in front of the jail, which platform had to be “Because Joseph used the term ‘good afternoon,’ reached by means of about a half a dozen steps, con- some of the people became excited and made various structed on the south and north sides of the same. The threats. The custom of a Missourian would have been to jail fronted the street at the east. say ‘good evening.’ They thought his expression implied “The prisoners left the wagon and immediately as- a covert meaning that he should make his escape be- cended the south steps to the platform, around which fore morning. Joseph being an eastern man, expressed no banisters were constructed. The door was open, and, himself after the custom of the eastern people. Finally

1 LIBERTY JAIL by Andrew Jenson the excitement subsided, the people dispersed, and the well known voices of my friends—and that of Joseph’s prisoners were left to seek the best rest their hard, dark, distinctly—asking in earnest tones for freedom. Also and cheerless prison quarters might afford them. the voice of Mr. Samuel Tillery, the jailer, was plainly “We, also, retired from the scene, full of anxiety and heard resolutely denying their petition. This struggle concern. In the Inquirer office, after that day, continued only for a brief period, when the jailer’s light ample opportunities were afforded for meditation, as shone at the outside of the jail walls, and the door lock the past and present came up for review. Joseph and his gave a clicking sound as the key turned in the heavy fellow prisoners were men whom I knew and loved— lock. Just then a man jumped from the platform, and men who with me possessed ‘like precious faith’ in the Mr. Tillery’s assistant, with an oath, fired a shot at him God of heaven. These men were actually, so to speak, as he ran a few rods north, sprang upon a horse that within a stone throw of the place of my employment. was hitched to a fence, and rode rapidly away. This was So very near, and yet so far were they beyond my power some friend of the prisoners’, who had tried to render to render them aid. For me or any others of our faith in assistance to his imprisoned brethren. I have heard that that place to have tried to aid them would have been use- it was Brother Cyrus Daniels, and that he was wounded less, if known to the people. There were those, however, in one of his arms by the shot of the assistant jailer, but who did aid them in a certain way. Just across the street, have no means of knowing as to the correctness of this. directly opposite the jail, lived a family of Latter-day “Mr. Tillery and his man then hastened past the Saints, who were full of sympathy for their imprisoned place where I was standing, and ran down the street into brethren. This family befriended them in the only way the town alarming the people with their cries for help, within their power. Having heard it whispered that their calling them to rally to the jail, as the prisoners were food was not, at all times, of a very good quality, they, trying to make their escape. as often as convenient, and when safe to do so, found “A large crowd gathered there, and every one was means to pass to them through the prison grates (which filled with the most intense excitement. Several de- could be reached by a person standing upon the ground manded of the jailer the keys, but he stoutly refused to from the outside) various articles of food, such as cakes, let them pass from his possession. He had wished the pies, etc., which they themselves prepared. This had to people to gather there lest the prisoners might make be done very cautiously, under the cover of night. their escape; but when he found that they were secure- “The names of those who performed these good Sa- ly locked within the walls and everything was all safely maritan-like deeds, were Samuel Kingsley and his wife arranged, he was satisfied for the prisoners to remain in Olive Martha; also his sisters Rachel, Eleanor and Flora. their secure quarters, and would not consent that they The doubtful character of the food sometimes placed should be delivered to the populace in their excited before the prisoners, by those to whom that duty had and enraged condition, knowing that the consequences been assigned (it is said that human flesh had actually would be fatal to the defenseless men. In this he filled been given them to eat) doubtless caused them to duly the requirements of the law. appreciate and relish those wholesome repasts, know- “Some time was spent around the jail in vain at- ing, as they did, that they had been carefully prepared tempts to get possession of the men to whom they de- by the hands of sympathizing friends. sired to do violence. Wicked profanations were freely “The prisoners had been some time confined in the Indulged in and a variety of threats made; but finally, Liberty jail when a circumstance occurred in which growing disheartened, they withdrew, and the precincts they were among the principal actors. I was just return- of the jail soon were made lonely in the still shadows of ing from supper on my way to the printing office and night. had reached a position in front of the jail, when sud- “The most orderly portion of the citizens repaired denly and unexpectedly was heard the sound of anxious to their homes, but the profligate and rowdy class re- voices and a quick rush as if made by a strong and de- sorted to the groceries and saloons and spent the night termined man. Above the tumult was distinguished the in drinking, gambling, and cursing ‘Joe Smith’ and the

2 LIBERTY JAIL by Andrew Jenson ‘Mormons.’ tained abundance of proof to counteract all the testimo- “The attempted escape was the topic of conversa- ny that is against us, so that if the judges do not grant tion, and the most exaggerated stories and rumors were us our liberty, they have got to act contrary to honor, told. Their imaginations were so wrought up that many evidence, law or justice, merely to please the mob, but of them believed there was a chain of ‘Mormon’ forc- we hope better things, and trust, before many days, God es all along the road to Far West, determined to effect will so order our case, that we shall be set at liberty and the release of their friends and carry them away in tri- enjoy the society of the Saints.” umph to some place of safety. But as time wore away, in Elder Littlefleld continues: a few days their excitement was allayed and they began “It is beyond my power to record but a small por- to breathe freely, so far as the terrible ‘Mormons’ were tion of the acts, the oaths and criminal threats of that concerned. angry crowd of men, who, doubtless, would have mur- “Some of those who attempted to rescue the prison- dered those innocent men could they by any means ers were shut into the jail, and they were taken before have gained possession of them. My poor prayer as- the court to answer to the charge of attempting to re- cended to the God of Israel for their preservation. For lease the prisoners.” that once I was rejoiced that the building was a strong The following is what Joseph, the Prophet, himself one, for although it was a prison, it was, under the cir- says in reference to this attempt to regain their freedom cumstances, a very ark of safety for them, when furious {Times and Seasons, Vol. 1, page 101): and wicked men were filled with rage and vengeance around its walls. Otherwise, had it been frail and vul- “We should have taken out a writ of habeas corpus nerable enough to yield to the attacks of assailants, their and escaped the mob in a summary way, but unfortu- lives would have been sacrificed—even as lambs that nately for us, the timber of the wall being very hard, our fall among ravenous wolves. And within its uninviting auger handles gave out, which hindered us longer than courts the Lord communed with the Prophet Joseph by we expected; we applied to a friend for assistance, and His Spirit, revealing unto him the counsel of His will a very slight uncautious act gave rise to suspicion, and concerning Joseph himself and also for the welfare and before we could fully succeed, our plan was discovered. safely of His people in their then scattered and forlorn We should have made our escape, and succeeded ad- condition. Section 121 of the mirably well, had it not been for a little imprudence or was written in that jail, by the Prophet, March 20, 1839, over-anxiety on the part of our friend. and Sections 122 and 123 were written by him a few “The sheriff and jailer did not blame us for our at- days later, while he was held a prisoner for his religion, tempt; it was a fine breech, and cost the county a round because he dared proclaim to the world that God lived sum. Public opinion says we ought to have been per- and had again spoken to man upon the earth. From this mitted to have made our escape, but then the disgrace jail Joseph also found means of writing and sending let- would have been on us; now it must come on the State. ters of counsel to his brethren who had arrived in the We know that there cannot be any charge sustained State of Illinois.” against us; and that the conduct of the mob, the committed at Haun’s Mill, the exterminating order of Finally, having secured a change of venue, the Governor Boggs, and the one-sided, rascally proceed- Prophet and his fellow-prisoners, were, on the 6th of ings of the legislature, has damned the State of Missouri April, 1839, taken jail and hurried on to- to all eternity. General Atchison has proved himself to ward Daviess County. A few days later they regained be as contemptible as any of our enemies. their freedom. “We have tried a long time to get our lawyers to The old Jail continued to be used as a prison until draw us some petitions to the supreme judges of this about the year 1856, when it was deemed unsafe, and State, but they have utterly refused. We have examined for a couple of years and more Clay County criminals the law, and drawn the petitions ourselves, and have ob- were sent to Platte City, in the neighboring county on

3 LIBERTY JAIL by Andrew Jenson the west, for safe-keeping. In 1858 the present Liberty square iron bar running horizontally through the mid- court-house was erected, with apartments for prisoners. dle, are two feet wide and six inches high. Above them For years afterwards the old jail was utilized as an ice- there are, near the roof, two larger openings, two feet in house, but has not been used for any purpose whatev- width and one foot in height, giving light and air to the er during the last decennium or more. The roof fell in upper story. In each of these two upper windows there years ago, and the rock wall is crumbling down more are five square iron bars standing perpendicularly and and more every season, to there is every reason to be- fastened very securely in the timbers of the building. In lieve that in a few years, even if permitted to stand as fact the whole structure is a double building, the inner it does now, there will be nothing but a heap of rocks being built of hewn oak logs about a foot square and the and rotten timber left to designate the place where this outside of rock. The floor and ceiling are constructed historic building stood. of the same material, thus making a huge wooden box. The writer of this article, accompanied by Elders E. The rock walls are two feet thick, and in building them Stevenson and Jos. S. Black, visited the ruins of the jail a space of about one foot was left between the rock and Sept. 18, 1888. By the assistance of a colored neighbor timber, which space was filled up with loose rock. Thus we succeeded in gaining an entrance to the interior of it will be seen that the prison walls are virtually four the half-tumble-down building, which we found very feet thick. Several loads of rock were also placed on top filthy indeed, filled with cobwebs and insects of numer- of the log ceiling in order to make escape through the ous kinds which had their abode in the rotten timbers. roof impossible. The outside dimensions of the building Mr. Theodore Shivley, who has charge of the property are: 22 ½ feet long, 22 feet wide and 12 feet high to the for the present owner (Mortimore Bearing, a wealthy square. The door is on the east end, facing the street, banker of Kansas city), told us that the jail had not been and is 5 ½ feet high and 2 ½ feet wide, and opens to opened and entered until that day for many years. The what was the upper apartment. The west gable and most smell from the decaying timber and dead insects was of the west wall has tumbled down, and also part of the something sickening, and a couple of minutes’ stay there north wall, thus leaving the timber or inside structure made us wish for the fresh air outside. How the Prophet partly exposed. The east wall and gable are in a good and his fellow-prisoners could endure life in such a hole state of preservation, and only one corner of the wall is for upwards of five months is more than we can compre- torn down. The building stands on the west side of what hend. Of course it was not so filthy then, but the open- is known as Main Street, one and a half blocks north of ings for ventilation and light seem to have been so small the northwest corner of the Liberty court-house square. that it cannot possibly have been a healthy abode for It stands back from the street about 20 feet, on an un- human beings at any time. We found the space inside to cultivated acre lot, which the owner has offered to sell measure about 14 ½ feet from east to west, and 14 feet for $2,500, but no one seems to care for purchasing the from north to south. From the basement floor to the property. To reach the building from the street we had ceiling we should judge it to be about 14 feet, two feet of to make a path through the thick growth of grass and which is under ground. The middle floor, which, while weeds. Some of the latter, being more than six feet high, Joseph and his fellow-prisoners were there, divided the partly hid the building from view. space into an upper and lower story, has been torn away, Source: but we could see where it had been, and should say that Church Chronology and Encyclopedic History of the cell or lower room at that time measured 6 ½ feet, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, by An- and the upper about 7 feet from floor to ceiling. drew Jenson, , Utah 1889, pages 667-671. Joseph and his fellow-prisoners were confined in the upper room. The only openings giving light and ventila- For more information of the two attempted jail tion to the cell part are two very small grated windows breaks, see Alexander McRae’s, Letters to the Editor, through the wall, one on the south and another on the , October 9, 1854 and November 1, 1854. north side. These openings, each of which has a heavy

4