Download Legal Document
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Case 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 1 of 135 1 DROR LADIN* NOOR ZAFAR* 2 JONATHAN HAFETZ** HINA SHAMSI** 3 OMAR C. JADWAT** AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION 4 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor New York, NY 10004 5 Tel.: (212) 549-2500 Fax: (212) 549-2564 6 [email protected] [email protected] 7 [email protected] [email protected] 8 [email protected] 9 * Admitted pro hac vice **Application for admission pro hac vice forthcoming 10 CECILLIA D. WANG (SBN 187782) 11 AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION 39 Drumm Street 12 San Francisco, CA 94111 Tel.: (415) 343-0770 13 Fax: (415) 395-0950 [email protected] 14 Attorneys for Plaintiffs (Additional counsel listed on following page) 15 16 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 17 SAN FRANCISCO-OAKLAND DIVISION 18 SIERRA CLUB and SOUTHERN BORDER 19 COMMUNITIES COALITION, Case No.: 4:20-cv-01494-HSG 20 Plaintiffs, APPENDIX OF DECLARATIONS IN 21 v. SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY 22 DONALD J. TRUMP, President of the United JUDGMENT States, in his official capacity; MARK T. ESPER, 23 Secretary of Defense, in his official capacity; and CHAD F. WOLF, Acting Secretary of Homeland Judge: Hon. Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr. 24 Security, in his official capacity, Trial Date: None Set Action Filed: February 28, 2020 25 Defendants. 26 27 28 PLAINTIFFS’ APPENDIX OF DECLARATIONS ISO MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT CASE NO.: 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Case 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 2 of 135 1 Additional counsel for Plaintiffs: 2 SANJAY NARAYAN (SBN 183227)*** GLORIA D. SMITH (SBN 200824)*** 3 SIERRA CLUB ENVIRONMENTAL LAW PROGRAM 2101 Webster Street, Suite 1300 4 Oakland, CA 94612 Tel.: (415) 977-5772 5 [email protected] [email protected] 6 MOLLIE M. LEE (SBN 251404) 7 AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA, INC. 8 39 Drumm Street San Francisco, CA 94111 9 Tel.: (415) 621-2493 Fax: (415) 255-8437 10 [email protected] 11 DAVID DONATTI** ANDRE I. SEGURA (SBN 247681) 12 AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION OF TEXAS 13 P.O. Box 8306 Houston, TX 77288 14 Tel.: (713) 325-7011 Fax: (713) 942-8966 15 [email protected] [email protected] 16 **Application for admission pro hac vice forthcoming 17 ***Counsel for Plaintiff Sierra Club 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 ii PLAINTIFFS’ APPENDIX OF DECLARATIONS ISO MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT CASE NO.: 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Case 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 3 of 135 DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR 1 PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT 2 3 Title Exhibit 4 Declaration of Robert Ardovino 1 5 Declaration of Kevin Bixby 2 6 Declaration of Christie Brown 3 7 Declaration of Janay M. Brun 4 8 Declaration of Jo Ann Caruthers 5 9 Declaration of Laura Chamberlin 6 10 Declaration of Howard J. Dash 7 11 Declaration of Henry Nichols Ervin 8 12 Declaration of Edith G. Harmon 9 13 Declaration of Rick LoBello 10 14 Declaration of Juan Benito Mancias 11 15 Declaration of Melissa Owen 12 16 Declaration of Carmina Ramirez 13 17 Declaration of Sarah Roberts 14 18 Declaration of Gary W. Roemer 15 19 Declaration of Michael L. Rood 16 20 Declaration of Karlaireth Mendoza Terry 17 21 Declaration of Jerry D. Thompson 18 22 Declaration of Elizabeth J. Walsh 19 23 Declaration of Linda Whitaker 20 24 25 26 27 28 1 PLAINTIFFS’ APPENDIX OF DECLARATIONS ISO MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT CASE NO.: 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Case 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 4 of 135 Exhibit 1 Case 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 5 of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ase 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 6 of 135 ;<=>?;5<=@!A>!<B?5CA<!CDB!<DEF=A!G?HCDFAI!A>!J;>A<5A!CDB!;<=A>;<!AG<!K?CEFAI!>L!AG<!DCA?;CE!CDB! G?HCD!<D6F;>DH<DA@!CDB!A>!?=<!CEE!ECML?E!H<CD=!A>!5C;;I!>?A!AG<=<!>NO<5AF6<=P! 1P! )!J;<6F>?=EI!=?NHFAA<B!C!B<5EC;CAF>D!FD!AGF=!5C=<Q!1078456433RS2Q!>?AEFDFDT!HI!5>D5<;D=!MFAG! AG<!#E!UC=>!/<5A>;!7!MCEE!5>D=A;?5AF>D!J;>O<5AP!VI!LF;=A!B<5EC;CAF>D!MC=!CAAC5G<B!A>!AG<!/F<;;C! $E?N!CDB!/>?AG<;D!->;B<;!$>HH?DFAF<=!$>CEFAF>D!W?D<!72Q!2378!LFEFDT!AFAE<B!X&JJ<DBFY!>L! "<5EC;CAF>D=!FD!/?JJ>;A!>L!UECFDAFLL=Z!V>AF>D!L>;!UC;AFCE!/?HHC;I!W?BTH<DAP[!!)!=?NHFAA<B!CD! CBBFAF>DCE!B<5EC;CAF>DQ!$C=<!+>P0!1078456433R8249/:Q!N<5C?=<!>L!HI!5>D5<;D=!MFAG!AG<!#E! UC=>!2!CDB!#E!UC=>!R!J;>O<5A=P!! \P! )!CH!=?NHFAAFDT!AGF=!B<5EC;CAF>D!N<5C?=<!)!CH!5>D5<;D<B!AGCA!AG<!J;>J>=<B!(?5=>D!&Q!(?5=>D! -Q!#E!UC=>!-Q!CDB!#E!UC=>!$!J;>O<5A=!MFEE!=J<5FLF5CEEI!GC;H!H<!C<=AG<AF5CEEI!CDB! ;<5;<CAF>DCEEI!FD!CBBFAF>D!A>!GC6FDT!=FTDFLF5CDA!FHJC5A=!>D!B<=<;A!<5>=I=A<H=!CDB!CEE!CDFHCE! =J<5F<=P! ]P! )!GC6<!6F=FA<BQ!=A?BF<BQ!JG>A>T;CJG<BQ!CDB!;<5;<CA<B!FD!AG<!B<=<;A!ECDB=!>L!=>?AG<;D!+<M! V<YF5>!CDB!&;F^>DC!HI!<DAF;<!EFL<P!(GF=!FD5E?B<=!AG<!(?5=>D!-!U;>O<5A!&;<CQ!MG<;<!HI! ?DB<;=ACDBFDT!F=!AG<!"<JC;AH<DA!>L!9>H<ECDB!/<5?;FAI!JECD=!A>!N?FEB!D<M!J<B<=A;FCD!MCEE=! CDB!5>D6<;A!<YF=AFDT!6<GF5E<!NC;;F<;=!A>!J<B<=A;FCD!MCEE=P!)!5?;;<DAEI!6F=FA!AG<!(?5=>D!-! U;>O<5A!&;<C!CA!E<C=A!AM>!A>!AG;<<!AFH<=!C!I<C;!A>!GF_<Q!JG>A>T;CJGQ!CDB!T<D<;CEEI!;<5;<CA<Q! CDB!GC6<!B>D<!=>!C=!;<5<DAEI!C=!AGF=!JC=A!I<C;P! SP! )!>LA<D!=AC;A!6C5CAF>D=!CDB!>?AB>>;!;<5;<CAF>DCE!C5AF6FAF<=!FD!AG<!(?5=>D!-!U;>O<5A!&;<C! N<5C?=<!>L!AG<!T>;T<>?=!ECDB=5CJ<Q!DCA?;CE!N<C?AIQ!CDB!BF6<;=<!MFEBEFL<!>L!AG<!C;<CP!)!<DO>I! T>FDT!A>!AGF=!C;<C!N<5C?=<!>L!AG<!=<D=<!>L!>J<D!DCA?;<!FA!J;>6FB<=P!)D!AGF=!C;<CQ!)!>LA<D!=<<! BF6<;=<!B<=<;A!=J<5F<=Q!FD5E?BFDT!HCDI!AIJ<=!>L!=DC_<=Q!;CNNFA=Q!H?E<!B<<;Q!H>?DACFD!EF>D=Q! CDB!>AG<;!FD6<;A<N;CA<P! ! ! 2!! "#$%&'&()*+!*,!'*-#'(!&'"*.)+*! $&/#!+*0!102345643718149/:!49/:! Case 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 7 of 135 <=! )!>?6@!ABBC@D!?E!E>@!FBGD@G!H?AA!I@JK@LEI!E>?E!HMAA!F@!5BLIEGN5E@D!ML!E>@!(N5IBL!-!OGBP@5E! &G@?=!(>@!5NGG@LE!Q@L5MLJ!ML!E>MI!?G@?!?AABHI!QBG!HMADAMQ@!EB!EG?6@GI@!F@EH@@L!E>@!FBGD@G!A?LDI! ?LD!DB@I!LBE!MKR@D@!BL!KS!I@LI@!BQ!F@MLJ!ML!E>@!BR@L!HMAD@GL@II=!(>@!RGBRBI?A!EB!5BLIEGN5E! L@H!R@D@IEGM?L!Q@L5MLJT!G@RA?5@!E>@!RGMK?GS!R@D@IEGM?L!H?AAT!?LD!5BL6@GE!E>@!@UMIEMLJ!6@>M5A@! F?GGM@G!EB!?!R@D@IEGM?L!H?AA!HMAA!5>?LJ@!KS!?FMAMES!EB!G@5G@?E@!?LD!R>BEBJG?R>!E>@!BR@LL@II!BQ! E>@!?G@?T!H>M5>!MI!E>@!G@?IBL!)!>?6@!5BLEMLN@D!EB!G@ENGL=!(>@!5>?LJ@I!EB!E>@!FBGD@G!H?AA!HMAA! 5G@?E@!?!5BLIE?LE!F?GGM@G!?LD!E?C@!?H?S!KS!?FMAMES!EB!G@5G@?E@!ML!E>@!BR@L!HMAD@GL@II=!! 8=! (>@!L@H!H?AAIT!?LD!E>@!AMJ>EI!?LD!ML5G@?I@D!6@>M5NA?G!EG?QQM5!?IIB5M?E@D!HME>!E>@I@!H?AAIT!HMAA! RG@6@LE!HMADAMQ@!QGBK!EG?6@GIMLJ!?5GBII!E>@!FBGD@G!?LD!QGBK!F@MLJ!ML!E>MI!?G@?T!ML!J@L@G?A=!)! >?6@!5BLEMLN@D!EB!G@ENGL!EB!E>@!(N5IBL!-!OGBP@5E!&G@?!QBG!D@5?D@I!F@5?NI@!E>@!?G@?!RGB6MD@I! K@!?!H?S!EB!J@E!V?H?SW!?LD!F@!BNE!ML!E>@!BR@L=!)!HBNAD!LB!ABLJ@G!>?6@!?!G@?IBL!EB!G@ENGL!EB! E>@!(N5IBL!-!OGBP@5E!&G@?!MQ!?AA!E>@!G@?IBLI!)!>?6@!5BLEMLN@D!EB!G@ENGL!QBG!D@5?D@I!MI! D@6?IE?E@D!FS!?!FBGD@G!H?AA!?LD!E>@!@QQ@5EI!BQ!E>@!FBGD@G!H?AA=!! 73=!)!?AIB!QG@XN@LEAS!6MIME!E>@!#A!O?IB!-!?LD!(N5IBL!&!OGBP@5E!&G@?I!?LD!>?6@!DBL@!IB!QBG!K?LS! S@?GI=!(>MI!ML5AND@I!E>@!RGBP@5E!?G@?I!H>@G@T!EB!KS!NLD@GIE?LDMLJT!E>@!"@R?GEK@LE!BQ! 9BK@A?LD!/@5NGMES!RA?LI!EB!5BLIEGN5E!L@H!RGMK?GS!R@D@IEGM?L!H?AAI!?LD!G@RA?5@!I@5BLD?GS! Q@L5MLJ!ML!E>@!(N5IBL!&!OGBP@5E!&G@?=!)E!?AIB!ML5AND@I!E>@!?G@?I!H>@G@T!EB!KS!NLD@GIE?LDMLJT! E>@!"@R?GEK@LE!BQ!9BK@A?LD!/@5NGMES!RA?LI!EB!G@RA?5@!6@>M5A@!Q@L5MLJ!HME>!R@D@IEGM?L!H?AAI! ?LD!FNMAD!L@H!R@D@IEGM?L!H?AAI!ML!#A!O?IB!-!OGBP@5E!&G@?=! 77=!)!5NGG@LEAS!5?KRT!>MC@T!?LD!R>BEBJG?R>!ML!E>@!(N5IBL!&!?LD!#A!O?IB!-!OGBP@5E!&G@?I!?LD! >?6@!DBL@!IB!QBG!I@6@G?A!D@5?D@I=!)!J@L@G?AAS!JB!EB!E>@!(N5IBL!&!?LD!#A!O?IB!-!OGBP@5E!&G@?I! ?E!A@?IE!E@L!EB!EH@A6@!EMK@I!?!S@?GT!?LD!IBK@EMK@I!KBG@!QG@XN@LEAS=!)!6MIME!E>MI!G@JMBL!EB! @UR@GM@L5@!E>@!F@?NES!BQ!E>@!IBNE>@GL!FBGD@G!?LD!MEI!DM6@GI@!6?IEL@IIT!KBNLE?MLBNI!6MIE?IT! ! ! ;!! "#$%&'&()*+!*,!'*-#'(!&'"*.)+*! $&/#!+*0!102345643718149/:!49/:! Case 4:20-cv-01494-HSG Document 23-1 Filed 04/13/20 Page 8 of 135 ;<=!>?;<@!AB;<CD!EF!>G;DDB;<=DH!)!C<IEJ!@;K?<>!LJ!F;L?BJ!;<=!FG?C<=D!@E!@MCDC!;GC;D!@E!DMEN! @MCL!@MC!?LLC<DC!OC;P@J!@M;@!5;<!OC!FEP<=!@MCGCH!)!AB;<!@E!5E<@?<PC!>E?<>!@E!@MCDC!;GC;D!OJ! LJDCBF!;<=!N?@M!LJ!FG?C<=D!;<=!F;L?BJ!FEG!JC;GD!@E!5ELCH!