DOCSLIB.ORG

Department of Transport: Freight Facilities Grants in England

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Department of Transport: Freight Facilities Grants in England NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL Department of Transport: Freight Facilities Grants in England ORDERED BY THE HOUSE OF COMMONS TO BE PRINTED 18 JULY 1996 LONDON: HMSO HC 632 Session 1995-96 Published 2 August 1996 E8.15 DEPARTMENT OF TWSPORT: FREIGHT FACILITIES GWTS IN ENGLAND This report has been prepared under Section 6 of the National Au&t Act, 1983 for presentation to the House of Commons in accordance tith Section 9 of the Act. John Bourn National Audit Office Comp&oUer and Auditor General 16 Jtiy 1996 The ComptroUer and Auditor General is the head of the National Audit Office employing some 750 staff. He, and the NAO, are totaUy independent of Government. He certifies the accounts of all Government departments and a wide range of other pubhc sector bodies; and he has statutory autiori@ to report to Parhament on the economy, efficiency and effectiveness tith which departments and other bodies have used their resources. DEPWTMENT OF TWSPORT: FREIGHT FACILITIES GWTS IN ENGWD Contents Page S-ary and conclusions 1 Part 1: htroduction 6 Background 6 Freight facfities grant 7 Other measures 8 Targets 11 Scope of the National Audit Office examination 13 Part 2: The performance of schemes awarded grant 15 Assessment of traffic forecasts 15 Freight carried by grant-aided schemes 16 Part 3: Valuing the benefits of transferring freight from roads 22 Values attrtiuted to lorry ties 22 Impact of lorry tie values 24 Part 4: The potential for achieving greater impact 26 Interest in the grants 26 Reasons why grant is not taken up 27 Appendices 1. An overtiew of the rafl height industry in England 34 2. An example Nustrating the key elements in the Department’s 35 assessment of the eHgibfi@ of an apphcation for freight facfities grant 3. Examples of measures to encourage the use of rafl or water freight 38 transport in other European Union countries 4. Company interviews 39 DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT: FREIGHT FACIUTIES GWTS IN ENGWD Photograph1: Railfreight alongside ihe Oxford canal Source:Dave McA/orre Frtightfati[fiesgrantsareintendedtoencouragefreighttramcofiroadsandontortilorinland watemayswhere this is in the public interest. DEP~TMENT OF TRANSPORT: FREIGHT FACILITIES GWTS IN ENGLAND Summary and conclusions 1 Freight facihties grant was introduced tn the Railways Act 1974 to encourage the transfer of freight traffic off roads and onto railways, where this was in the interests of the locah~ or its inhabitants. The grant was extended to inland watemay schemes by the Transport Act 1981. Both these provisions were re-enacted with amendments in the Railways Act 1993. The grants meet part of the capital costs of providing rail and inland watemay freight facihties. The Department of Transport administer the grants in England, and have made 155 awards tota~ng E72.3 mi~on since the grants were estabhshed. BeWeen April 1985 and March 1996 the Department paid grants totaMng E32 miWon, out of the E70 mi~on protided for them from monies voted by Parhament. 2 Freight traffic in the United Ringdom, measured in terms of tonnage and the distance over which it has been carried, has doubled in the last thirty years. But in 1994 rail and inland watemays together accounted for only seven per cent of aUfreight traffic. In that year freight carried in England using facihties funded by grants accounted for some 12 per cent by weight of aUrailway freight, and less than one per cent of inland wateway traffic. Construction aggregates have accounted for the majority of the traffic carried by schemes funded by grants. 3 The Department award grant after assessing a scheme’s ehgibihty and value for money using three criteria. These are the efigibihty of the capital items; a quantification of the environmental benefits gained from removing the freight from the roads; and an assessment of the amount of grant needed to make the scheme EnanciaUy viable compared to the cheaper road alternative. Out of 80 companies approaching the Department about the grants in the three years to September 1995, nine per cent pursued an apphcation through to the award of grant, 4 The National Audit Office examined the Department of Transport’s appraisal and award of freight facihties grants in England, and their impact on the freight industry. The report considers: . whether the grants have secured the anticipated traffic flows on rail or inland wateways (Part 2); . whether the Department have adopted a dependable and consistent approach to val~ng the environmental benefits of proposed schemes (Part 3); and . whether there is potential for the grants to have greater impact (Part 4), This summary draws together the findings and makes recommendations for enhancing the administration and effectiveness of the grants. 1 DEPARTMENT OF TWSPORT: FREIGHT FACIUTIES GWTS IN ENGWD g;g:tig 5 Since 1974 the Department have taken action to recover grant in three cases, where the facilities have been closed or sold. The Department have not sought forecasts repayment where they considered that traff]c had fallen short of forecast levels, due to events beyond the company’s control. With the most recent grants awarded at more than 50 per cent of the cost of the facihties the Department have borne an increased share of the risk of forecast benefits not being achieved. To reduce tbe risk, the Department have scrutinised applicants’ traffic forecasts and sought confirmation of tbe proposed freight movements from their customers and, where practicable, the rail freight operating companies (paragraphs 2.1, 2.3, 2.7, 2.12 and 4.11). 6 The Railways Act 1993 enables the Department to require evidence from the apphcant on, amongst other things, the amount and destination of goods which are to use the facilities. The Department normally use a five to ten year period to assess traffic forecasts in grant apphcations but companies have found it difficult in a number of cases to provide the Department with the assurance they required. Companies considered that forecasting traffic flows over a long period was not appropriate to the nature of their business, and many had been holding back from entering into contracts with the rail freight operating companies pending their privatisation (paragraphs 2.4 and 2.6). 7 Some potential applicants have found it particdarly difficult to specify traffic flows where they have proposals to build inland waterway or rail freight terminals, which would be used by many companies. The Department have generally encouraged combined road and rail transport (intermodal freight), but they have reservations about apphcations for grant for vehicles capable of use on road and rail. This is because of the risk that such vehicles might he used primarily for road trafic (paragraphs 1.9, 2.6 and 4.12-4.14). 8 Thirty schemes, 79 per cent of the 38 schemes awarded grant since 1985 and operational in the period up to the end of 1995, have carried less traff]c than forecast for that period. In total the 38 schemes carried 72 per cent of the traffic forecast. A few schemes involving the movement of bulk freight within the company have been particularly successful and carried up to 156 per cent of forecast traffic. Companies cited business downturn and the withdrawal of British Rail services as the principal reasons for traffic shortfalls (paragraphs 2.9-2.11). 9 The Department should clarify the circumstances in which they will re@re repayment of grant due to shortfalls in traffic. Greater clarity should enable companies to take more account of this in their plans, and reduce the risk of non-recovery of grant where “trafficis below expectations. The Department might also consider accepting, so far as this is consistent with the legislation, evidence of estimated future traffic flows, based on an appraisal of the atip~cant’s business case for the investment. This may encourage apphcations from more flexible and less predictable areas of the freight market which may be deterred, currently, by the requirement to provide detailed evidence of committed traffic flows. To have confidence in companies’ figures for actual 2 DEPARTMENT OF TMNSPORT: FREIGHT FACILITIES GWS IN ENGLAND traffic flows, for the purposes of recovering grant, the Department would need more comprehensive information on the sources of the data; and access to these records for the purpose of checking them on a sample basis. 10 In some cases, however, re~ance on later repayment of grant might represent an undue risk to public funds, especially where future traffic flows could be more than usua~y affected by circumstances beyond tbe apphcant’s control. As an alternative to payment of grant as construction of the facilities progresses or as equipment is purchased, the Department might consider offering a proportion of the eligible grant in this way and tbe remainder in annual instahnents. The payment of annual inslahueuts could be according to actual traffic flows, as confirmed by the Department. Again, this may diminish tbe need to obtain detailed evidence on committed future traffic flows, thus speeding up the award of grant and making it more responsive to the freight market. Valtig 11 The Department pay grant up to an amount not exceeding the projected value of environmental environmental benefits offered by the scheme. The value is calculated using benefits rates for each lorry mile removed from different classes of ro~d. The rates have been changed up and down over time, and have been extended to cover more classes of road. The Department reco~ised in their 1990 review of the grants that there has been no rigorous justification for the various rates. But the level of the lorry mile rate may significantly affect whether the grant will make a scheme financially viable, compared to the alternative of using road transport (paragraphs 3.1, and 3.4-3.12).
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Railfreight in Colour for the Modeller and Historian Free
    FREE RAILFREIGHT IN COLOUR FOR THE MODELLER AND HISTORIAN PDF David Cable | 96 pages | 02 May 2009 | Ian Allan Publishing | 9780711033641 | English | Surrey, United Kingdom PDF Br Ac Electric Locomotives In Colour Download Book – Best File Book The book also includes a historical examination of the development of electric locomotives, allied to hundreds of color illustrations with detailed captions. An outstanding collection of photographs revealing the life and times of BR-liveried locomotives and rolling stock at a when they could be seen Railfreight in Colour for the Modeller and Historian across the network. The AL6 or Class 86 fleet of ac locomotives represents the BRB ' s second generation of main - line electric traction. After introduction of the various new business sectorsInterCity colours appeared in various guiseswith the ' Swallow ' livery being applied from Also in Cab superstructure — Light grey colour aluminium paint considered initially. The crest originally proposed was like that used on the AC electric locomotives then being deliveredbut whether of cast aluminium or a transfer is not quite International Railway Congress at Munich 60 years of age and over should be given the B. Multiple - aspect colour - light signalling has option of retiring on an adequate pension to Consideration had been given to AC Locomotive Group reports activity on various fronts in connection with its comprehensive collection of ac electric locos. Some of the production modelshoweverwill be 25 kV ac electric trains designed to work on BR ' s expanding electrified network. Headlight circuits for locomotives used in multiple - unit operation may be run through the end jumpers to a special selector switch remote Under the tower's jurisdiction are 4 color -light signals and subsidiary signals for Railfreight in Colour for the Modeller and Historian movements.
    [Show full text]
  • Eprints.Whiterose.Ac.Uk/2271
    This is a repository copy of New Inter-Modal Freight Technology and Cost Comparisons. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/2271/ Monograph: Fowkes, A.S., Nash, C.A. and Tweddle, G. (1989) New Inter-Modal Freight Technology and Cost Comparisons. Working Paper. Institute of Transport Studies, University of Leeds , Leeds, UK. Working Paper 285 Reuse See Attached Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request. [email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ White Rose Research Online http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ Institute of Transport Studies University of Leeds This is an ITS Working Paper produced and published by the University of Leeds. ITS Working Papers are intended to provide information and encourage discussion on a topic in advance of formal publication. They represent only the views of the authors, and do not necessarily reflect the views or approval of the sponsors. White Rose Repository URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/2271/ Published paper Fowkes, A.S., Nash, C.A., Tweddle, G. (1989) New Inter-Modal Freight Technology and Cost Comparisons. Institute of Transport Studies, University of Leeds. Working Paper 285 White Rose Consortium ePrints Repository [email protected] Working Paper 285 December 1989 NEW INTER-MODAL FREIGHT TECHNOLOGY AND COST COMPARISONS AS Fowkes CA Nash G Tweddle ITS Working Papers are intended to provide information and encourage discussion on a topic in advance of formal publication.
    [Show full text]
  • 2-Stroke Diesels on Britain's Rail Network
    2-Stroke Diesels on Britain’s Rail Network Rodger Bradley Back in the 1950s, when British Railways was beginning work on the “Modernisation & Re-Equipment Programme” – effectively the changeover from steam to diesel and electric traction – the focus in the diesel world was mainly between high and medium speed engines. On top of which, there was a practical argument to support hydraulic versus electric transmission technology – for main line use, mechanical transmission was never a serious contender. The first main line diesels had appeared in the very last days before nationalisation, and the choice of prime mover was shaped to a great extent by the experience of private industry, and English Electric in particular. The railway workshops had little or no experience in The prototype main-line 2-stroke powered loco for the field, and the better known steam locomotive express passenger service on BR was never repeated. builders had had some less than successful attempts to Photo: Thomas's Pics CC BY 2.0, offer examples of the new diesel locomotives. That https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=50662416 said, some of the smaller companies, who had worked with the railways pre-WW2 to supply small shunting Pilot Scheme & Modernisation In the first flush of enthusiasm for the new technology, British Railways announced three types of diesel locomotive to be trialled for main line use; diesel shunters had already been in use for a number of years. The shunting types were a mix of electric and mechanical transmission, paired with 4-stroke diesel engines, and not surprisingly the first main line designs included electric transmission and 4-stroke, medium speed engines.
    [Show full text]
  • Competition Act 1998
    Competition Act 1998 Decision of the Office of Rail Regulation* English Welsh and Scottish Railway Limited Relating to a finding by the Office of Rail Regulation (ORR) of an infringement of the prohibition imposed by section 18 of the Competition Act 1998 (the Act) and Article 82 of the EC Treaty in respect of conduct by English Welsh and Scottish Railway Limited. Introduction 1. This decision relates to conduct by English Welsh and Scottish Railway Limited (EWS) in the carriage of coal by rail in Great Britain. 2. The case results from two complaints. 3. On 1 February 2001 Enron Coal Services Limited (ECSL)1 submitted a complaint to the Director of Fair Trading2. Jointly with ECSL, Freightliner Limited (Freightliner) also, within the same complaint, alleged an infringement of the Chapter II prohibition in respect of a locomotive supply agreement between EWS and General Motors Corporation of the United States (General Motors). Together these are referred to as the Complaint. The Complaint alleges: “[…] that English, Welsh and Scottish Railways Limited (‘EWS’), the dominant supplier of rail freight services in England, Wales and Scotland, has systematically and persistently acted to foreclose, deter or limit Enron Coal Services Limited’s (‘ECSL’) participation in the market for the supply of coal to UK industrial users, particularly in the power sector, to the serious detriment of competition in that market. The complaint concerns abusive conduct on the part of EWS as follows. • Discriminatory pricing as between purchasers of coal rail freight services so as to disadvantage ECSL. *Certain information has been excluded from this document in order to comply with the provisions of section 56 of the Competition Act 1998 (confidentiality and disclosure of information) and the general restrictions on disclosure contained at Part 9 of the Enterprise Act 2002.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of British Railways 1909-2009
    The Evolution of British Railways 1909-2009 Britain’s Railways and The Railway Study Association 1909-2009 previously published in 2009 as part of A Century of Change 2019 Introduction to Second Edition Mike Horne FCILT MIRO This book was originally published by the name of ‘A Century of Change’ to commemorate the centenary of the Railway Study Association (RSA) in 1909; the Association is now the Railway Study Forum of the Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport. Plenty has already been written about the railways of Britain. When the time came to celebrate the activities of the RSA, it occurred to this author that there was something missing. I felt that although it is self-evident that the railway today is very different to that of a century ago, the real point was that railways have been in a state of constant evolution, in part to respond to the changing conditions of the country and in part because of technological change. More importantly, this change will continue. Few people entering the in- dustry today can have much conception of what these changes will be, but change there will be: big changes too. What I wanted to highlight is the huge way the railway has altered, particularly in its technology and operational practices. This has happened, with great success, under diffi cult political and fi nancial conditions. Although the railway has lost much of its market share, the numbers of people carried today have recovered dramatically, and the fact this has been done on a much smaller system is an in- credible achievement that needs to be promoted.
    [Show full text]
  • Heljan 2020 Catalogue Posted
    2020 UK MODEL RAILWAY PRODUCTS www.heljan.dk OO9 GAUGE Welcome …to the 2020 HELJAN UK catalogue. Over the coming pages we’ll introduce you to our superb range of British outline locomotives and rolling stock in OO9, OO and O gauge, covering many classic 6 steam, diesel and electric types. As well as new versions of existing PIN LYNTON & BARNSTAPLE RAILWAY products, we’ve got some exciting new announcements and updates DCC MANNING, WARDLE 2-6-2T READY on a few projects that you’ll see in shops in 2020/21. Class Profile: A trio of 2-6-2T locomotives built VERSION 1 - YEO, EXE & TAW NEM for the 1ft 11½in gauge Lynton & Barnstaple COUPLERS 9953 SR dark green E760 Exe New additions to the range since last year include the Railway in North Devon, joined by a fourth locomotive, Lew, in 1925 and used until the 9955 L&BR green Exe much-requested OO gauge Class 45s and retooled OO Class 47s, the SPRUNG railway closed in 1935. A replica locomotive, BUFFERS 9956 L&BR green Taw GWR ‘Collett Goods’, our updated O gauge Class 31s, 37s and 40s, the Lyd, is based at the Ffestiniog Railway in Wales. ubiquitous Mk1 CCT van and some old favourites such as the O gauge Built by: Manning, Wardle of Leeds VERSION 2 - LEW & LYD Number built: 4 9960 SR green E188 Lew Class 35 and split headcode Class 37. We’re also expanding our rolling Number series: Yeo, Exe & Taw (SR E759-761), stock range with a new family of early Mk2 coaches.
    [Show full text]
  • Privatised Railway
    The Privatised Railway Research Paper 97/71 30 May 1997 This Research Paper summarises the present structure of the rail industry introduced in April 1994 following the passing of the Railways Act 1993. More detail of the legal framework is given in earlier Library papers (Rail Privatisation: a Progress Report (Research Paper 95/96), The Privatisation of Railtrack (Research Paper 96/54) and Rail Passenger Franchises (Research Paper 96/85)). For convenience the names and addresses of all the main organisations are included and the addresses and telephone numbers of the train operating companies and of the companies who now run them are listed in the accompanying Research Paper 97/72 The Railway Passenger Companies. Fiona Poole Business & Transport Section House of Commons Library Library Research Papers are compiled for the benefit of Members of Parliament and their personal staff. Authors are available to discuss the contents of these papers with Members and their staff but cannot advise members of the general public. Summary The Railways Act 1993 provided the legal framework for the privatisation of British Rail and the introduction of a new structure for the rail industry. The Act received Royal Assent in November 1993 and many of the principal changes were brought into effect on 1 April 1994. Two new statutory officers, the Rail Regulator and the Franchising Director, were established to oversee the industry. Railtrack became a separate Government owned company and was sold to the private sector in May 1996. British Rail was split into about 100 companies, almost all of which have been sold to the private sector or closed down.
    [Show full text]
  • English Welsh & Scottish Railway
    Durham E-Theses Railway and grade: the historical construction of contemporary Strangleman, Tim How to cite: Strangleman, Tim (1998) Railway and grade: the historical construction of contemporary, Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/4870/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk Tim Strangleman Railway and Grade: The Historical Construction of Contemporary Identities The copyright of this thesis rests with tlie author. No quotation from it should be published PhD. Thesis without the written consent of tlie autlior and information derived from it should be acknowledged. University of Durham o 1998 Thesis Abstract This thesis attempts to understand the role and meaning of occupational identity in the contemporary British railway industry. It examines the way in which culture change initiatives and prograrrmies have explicitly targeted an older 'railroad culture'.
    [Show full text]
  • HS2 Must Deliver Its Promises on Rail Freight Vital Capacity Potential Must Not Get Overlooked by ‘Speed’ Debate
    140 March 2020 NEWS www.rfg.org.uk Helping ensure a sustainable future for UK rail freight HS2 must deliver its promises on rail freight Vital capacity potential must not get overlooked by ‘speed’ debate. P.3 RFG welcomes On 11 February, Rail Freight Group (RFG) network where HS2 trains will operate. This is Joe O’Donnell as its strongly welcomed the Government essential to allow freight operators and custom- announcement that HS2 is to be delivered ers to develop their future plans, and to ensure new Head of Policy in full, with work on Phases 1 and 2A that the benefits of HS2 can now be delivered given the green light to commence immedi- in practice.” ately and Phase 2B to be developed towards implementation. Views from the sector: HS2 has the potential to deliver significant ben- DB Cargo CEO Hans-Georg Werner said HS2 efits for rail freight by releasing capacity for new represented a “once in a generation” opportu- services on the existing network. With each nity to massively bolster rail capacity, providing freight train producing 76% less CO2 than the significant economic and environmental bene- equivalent road journey, HS2 can also help fits for freight operators. decarbonise freight transport by allowing new P.4 services to operate, taking more HGVs off the “This is fantastic news for the rail freight in- East Midlands congested road network. However, to date, dustry and its customers. We are pleased the Gateway opens for the Government has not confirmed how much Government has recognised the strength of the business capacity will be made available for freight once many arguments the industry made for build- the new line is open.
    [Show full text]
  • Best Methods of Railway Restructuring and Privatization
    CFS Discussion Paper Series, Number 111 Best Methods of Railway Restructuring and Privatization Ron Kopicki Louis S. Thompson with Koichiro Fukui Murray King Jorge C. Kohon Jan-Eric Nilsson Brian Wadsworth For additional copies, please contact the CFS Information Office, tel: (202) 473-7594, fax: (202) 477-3045. ii BEST METHODS OF RAILWAY RESTRUCTURING AND PRIVATIZATION TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS X ACKOWLEDGMENTS XII FOREWORD XIII EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 1. Introduction 1 2. Case Study Experiences 2 3. Alternative Railway Structures 3 4. Alternative Asset Restructuring Mechanisms 4 5. Design of Intermediate Institutional Mechanisms 5 6. Managing the Railway Restructuring Process 6 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION 9 1. Scope of the Study 9 2. Importance of Railway Restructuring 10 3. Economic Features of Railways 10 4. “Best Methods” Approach 12 5. Railway Case Studies 13 6. Organization of the Study 17 CHAPTER TWO: STRUCTURAL OPTIONS 19 1. Introduction 19 2. Restructuring a Railway: General Design Considerations 19 3. Asset Restructuring: Structural Forms 21 4. Asset Restructuring: Mechanisms 24 5. Liability Restructuring 29 6. Work Force Restructuring 32 7. Management Restructuring 36 8. Strategic Refocusing 37 9. Best Methods 39 CHAPTER THREE: INTERMEDIATE INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISMS 41 1. Introduction 41 2. The Need for Intermediation 41 3. Relationship between the Intermediary and the Railway 43 4. Essential Functions Performed by Restructuring Intermediaries 44 5. Larger Transport Policy Context and the Need to Rebalance Policy Principles 48 6. Alternative Organizational Forms 49 7. Prerequisites for Effective Intermediation Operations 52 8. Best Methods 52 CHAPTER FOUR: MANAGING THE RESTRUCTURING PROCESS 55 1. Introduction 55 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Development of Rail Freight in Europe: What Regulation Can and Cannot Do
    Development of rail freight in Europe: What regulation can and cannot do United Kingdom Case Study Professor Allan Woodburn (University of Westminster) Brussels, 11 December 2014 141211_CERRE_RailFreight_UK_Case_Study_Final 1/43 Table of Contents 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 3 2. The demand side.................................................................................................................... 3 2.1 Key bulk freight markets ................................................................................................ 3 2.2 Other freight markets .................................................................................................... 4 2.3 Summary ........................................................................................................................ 5 3. The supply side ...................................................................................................................... 8 3.1 Trends in rail freight activity .......................................................................................... 8 3.2 Structure of the rail freight market .............................................................................. 14 3.3 Key characteristics of the rail freight operators .......................................................... 18 4. Rail freight regulation .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • This Essay Will Look at the Midland Railways Services to from Heysham
    British Railway Shipping 1948-1984 A Nationalised Success Story Jeremy Hartill MA by Research University of York Railway Studies November 2014 ABSTRACT This dissertation will look at British Railways shipping activities under the British Transport Commission (BTC) and British Railways Board British (BRB). At the time of nationalisation in 1948 the BTC took control of the extensive shipping activities of the British railway companies. The research done for this dissertation suggests the BTC was the largest operator of passenger ships in Europe in the early post-war years. Academic research in this field is very limited, indeed the whole coastal shipping scene has been somewhat neglected. What has been done suggests that the “railway ships” were outdated, inefficient and unprofitable. Richard Pryke in the Journal of Fiscal Studies considered the BRB shipping activities as a failure compared to Townsend, a private enterprise operation. A number of commentators also highlight the advent of the Townsend car ferries in leading the way forward for ferry services from the UK. What this dissertation will show by looking at a number of aspects of this sector is that this was not the case. Most of the studies and commentator’s have not compared like for like and that will be highlighted. The financial performance of the shipping sector will be examined to show that overall it was a very profitable operation. The equipment used in terms of the fleet and harbour facilities will show that over the period under consideration the BTC/BRB fleet moved forward in a manner comparable with other operators in the similar circumstances.
    [Show full text]