Annex 6 Report of the Working Group on Ecosystem
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Annex 6 Report of the Working Group on Ecosystem Monitoring and Management (Bologna, Italy, 4 to 15 July 2016) Contents Page Opening of the meeting ...................................................................... 201 Adoption of the agenda and organisation of the meeting ............................... 201 The krill-centric ecosystem and issues related to management of the krill fishery ................................................................................ 202 Fishing activities ............................................................................ 202 Krill fishery notifications ............................................................... 203 Escape mortality ......................................................................... 204 Reporting interval for the continuous fishing system ................................ 204 Use of net monitoring cables ........................................................... 205 CPUE and fishery performance ........................................................ 206 Fishing season ........................................................................... 207 SG-ASAM report ........................................................................... 207 Scientific observation ...................................................................... 208 Observer coverage ...................................................................... 208 Krill biology, ecology and ecosystem interactions ...................................... 210 Krill ...................................................................................... 210 Ecosystem monitoring and observation ............................................... 215 Ecosystem interactions ................................................................. 216 CEMP and WG-EMM STAPP ............................................................ 222 CEMP data ............................................................................... 222 Predator consumption ................................................................... 226 Predator trends and dynamics .......................................................... 228 Krill integrated assessment model ........................................................ 229 Acoustic surveys ............................................................................ 229 Feedback management ..................................................................... 234 Stage 1 ................................................................................... 234 Background material considered by the Working Group ......................... 234 Subarea-scale exploitation rates ................................................. 234 Concentration of fishing effort .................................................. 236 Physical and ecological conditions in areas where krill fishing effort has concentrated .................................... 237 Methods to evaluate the risks associated with changing the spatial distribution of krill fishing ......................................... 240 Move-on rules for krill fishing vessels ......................................... 243 Advice to the Scientific Committee ................................................ 243 Stage 1–2 Subarea 48.1 ................................................................. 245 Stage 1–2 Subarea 48.2 ................................................................. 247 Stage 1–2 General recommendations .................................................. 248 Spatial management .......................................................................... 252 Marine protected areas (MPAs) ........................................................... 252 MPA Planning Domains 3 and 4 – Weddell Sea ..................................... 252 197 MPA Domain 1 .......................................................................... 254 MPA Planning Domain 1 (Western Antarctic Peninsula and Southern Scotia Sea) .......................................................... 254 South Orkney Islands ................................................................... 255 MPA Planning Domains 5 (Crozet – del Cano) and 6 (Kerguelen Plateau) ........ 256 Ross Sea krill research zone ............................................................ 257 Vulnerable marine ecosystems ............................................................ 259 Other issues for spatial management ...................................................... 260 Ross Sea symposium ......................................................................... 261 Advice to the Scientific Committee and its working groups............................ 263 Future work ................................................................................... 264 Third International Krill Symposium ..................................................... 264 Joint CCAMLR–IWC Workshop ......................................................... 264 Joint CEP–SC-CAMLR Workshop ....................................................... 266 ICED ......................................................................................... 266 Developing links with SCAR and other programs ....................................... 267 Data and information exchange ........................................................... 268 Development of priority questions relating to climate change .......................... 268 Scientific Committee Symposium and prioritisation of future work ................... 270 Other business ................................................................................ 271 Consideration of papers under Other business ........................................... 271 Global Environment Facility proposal .................................................... 271 CCAMLR Science ........................................................................... 271 CCAMLR Scientific Scholarship Scheme ................................................ 271 CEMP Special Fund ........................................................................ 272 Antarctic Wildlife Research Fund ......................................................... 272 Next meeting of WG-EMM ............................................................... 272 Adoption of the report and close of the meeting ......................................... 273 References ..................................................................................... 273 Tables ........................................................................................... 275 Figures ......................................................................................... 282 Appendix A: List of Participants ...................................................... 284 Appendix B: Agenda .................................................................. 291 Appendix C: List of Documents....................................................... 293 Appendix D: Recommendations to the Conservation Measure 51-07 WG-EMM Review e-group in respect of initial risk assessments to review Conservation Measure 51-07 ................. 304 198 Appendix E: Details of how the US AMLR Program has addressed the advice from WG-EMM-15 in relation to the feedback management (FBM) approach for Subarea 48.1 ...................... 306 Appendix F: Symposium on the Ross Sea Ecosystem (Available in English only) ............................................. 317 199 Report of the Working Group on Ecosystem Monitoring and Management (Bologna, Italy, 4 to 15 July 2016) Opening of the meeting 1.1 The 2016 meeting of WG-EMM was held at the National Research Council (CNR), Bologna, Italy, from 4 to 15 July. The meeting was opened by the Convener, Dr S. Kawaguchi (Australia), who welcomed participants (Appendix A) including Dr J. Zuzunaga from Peru (Acceding State; see also SC CIRC 16/39). Dr Kawaguchi thanked CNR for hosting the meeting. The Working Group was warmly welcomed by Dr A.M. Fioretti (Institute of Geosciences and Earth Resources, CNR). 1.2 Dr Kawaguchi reviewed the current work of WG-EMM and recalled that in 2015 the Scientific Committee indicated that the development of feedback management (FBM) of the krill fishery and the evaluation of candidate decision rules could be advanced by holding a workshop in 2016, perhaps associated with WG-EMM (SC-CAMLR-XXXIV, paragraph 3.44). Dr Kawaguchi advised that it had not been possible to hold such a workshop during WG-EMM-16. The Working Group’s work remained focused on the krill-centric ecosystem and issues related to the development of FBM. Adoption of the agenda and organisation of the meeting 1.3 The Working Group discussed the provisional agenda and agreed to add an item on general issues for spatial management (Subitem 3.3). The agenda was adopted (Appendix B), and subgroups were formed to address detailed aspects of the agenda. A one-day symposium on the Ross Sea ecosystem was held during the meeting (Item 4). 1.4 Documents submitted to the meeting are listed in Appendix C. While the report has few references to the contributions of individuals and co-authors, the Working Group thanked all authors of papers for their valuable contributions to the work presented to the meeting. 1.5 In this report, paragraphs that provide advice to the Scientific Committee and its other working groups have been highlighted; these paragraphs are listed in Item 5. 1.6 The report was prepared by M. Belchier (UK), T. Brey (Germany), R. Cavanagh (UK), A. Constable (Australia), R. Currey (New Zealand), C. Darby (UK), K. Demianenko (Ukraine), S. Fielding (UK),