UPPSALA UNIVERSITET Teologiska institutionen History of Religions and Social Sciences of Religion C, 15hp HT, 17 Supervisor: Gabriella Beer Examinator: Lena Roos The successor of the Prophet. – A historical analysis of the early political differences between the Sunni and Shi’a Islamic school of thoughts. Suliman Khalid 199208251596
[email protected] 1 Abstract The early split of Islam is regarded as one of the most profound and complex events in Islamic history, not only would it lay the foundation of two predominant branches of Islam, but it would also be one of the oldest arguments in Islamic his- tory. Who is the rightful successor to the Prophet Muhammed? This essay aims to explore the deep root behind the initial schism of Islam and understand the argu- ments both schools use to legitimize their position. What do the Sunnis and Shi’as say about the event of Ghadir, the hadith of the two weighty things and the inci- dent of Saqifa, and how do each school of Islam interpret these events? The source material consists of Hadiths and scholastic literatures from both Sunni Is- lam, Shi’a Islam, as well as literatures from Secular sources. By basing the analy- sis on Wilfred Madelung and Ali Asghar’s theory of disserting Orientalist under- standing of a monolith perspective on Islamic history, the essay aims to under- stand and broaden the reality of the schism of Islam and to bring emphasis on the events that often goes ignored throughout history. Finally, the results prove that both Sunnis and Shi’as differ regarding the caliphate, and the assertions for these lay in their respective interpretations.