The Effects of Cold Acclimation upon the Oxygen Consumption of Two Species of Free-Living l SUSAN C. COOPER and J. HOMER FERGUSON2

Abstract: Two species of free-living nematodes, and Turbatrix aceti, were cultured axenicaUy at control (20 C) and cold (10 C) temperatures. Oxygen consumption of worms from each population was measured manometrically on days 2 through 8 after exposure to these temperatures. In both species, the slope of the oxygen consumption curve for the controls was greater than that of the worms exposed to the cold on day 2. The slope of the curve of the cold-exposed worms gradually increased until day 7. At this time, the slope of the oxygen consumption curve from the cold-exposed worms exceeded or equaled that of the controls. This is taken as an indication of the onset of the cold-acclimated state in both species of worms by day 7.

For many years, a number of parameters stoppered with cotton balls wrapped in cheese have been used to denote the onset of the cloth (6). At weekly intervals, the worms were acclimation of a poikilothermal organism to subcultured aseptically by draining the worms various environmental conditions, particularly and the old medium from each funnel and to temperature (1, 9, 10). Among the criteria adding them to another funnel containing fresh utilized have been such rate functions as heart medium. beat (20), ciliary gill movements (19) and The worms were exposed to a temperature metabolic rate; e.g., rate of an enzymatic of 20 C until use in this experiment. They were reaction (7, 10, 11). subjected to a photoperiod of 12 hr of light and In most species of poikilothermic , 12 hr of dark throughout the study. exposure to a cold but nonlethal temperature The basic medium consisted of an will result in an initial decrease in metabolic autoclaved aqueous solution of 4% soya rate according to Van't Hoff's principle (1). peptone and 3% yeast extract (2) to which However, after a certain period of time during heated liver extract (17) was added to make up which the organism has been exposed to cold, it 10% of the volume of the medium (2). This often responds by acclimating to the new medium was used for P. redivivus. For T. aceti, temperature. This is frequently manifested as glacial acetic acid was added to make up 3% of an increased metabolic rate (10). the basic medium (14). In the present study, two species of The cultures were checked periodically for free-living nematodes were acclimated to cold. signs of bacterial or fungal contamination by Metabolic rates of acclimated and control using agar plates of brain-heart infusion or worms were compared, and rates of acclimation thioglycollate medium incubated at room were determined in both species. temperature for 1 week. Contamination in a culture was readily apparent, however, because MATERIALS AND METHODS it caused a subsequent discoloration of the Culture methods: Axenic cultures of medium. Panagrellus redivivus and Turbatrix aceti were Cold acclimation: Each population of maintained continuously in 50-ml cylindrical worms harvested from the funnels received separatory funnels lined with glass wool and approximately 5 ml of fresh medium. The medium of each species was divided evenly between two sterile 125-ml Erlenmeyer flasks, Received for publication 13 April 1972. which then were covered with aluminum foil. 1 This work is part of a doctoral dissertation by the One flask was .returned to the control (20 C) senior author supported in part from a NASA predoctoral fellowship during part of the temperature, whereas the second was investigation. introduced to'the cold (10 C). 2 Susan C. Cooper, Department of Biological Sciences, On days 2-8 following the initiation of the University of Idaho, Moscow 83843; and J. Homer treatment, two 0.5-ml aliquots of each Ferguson, Professor of Biology, Division of Earth and Life Sciences, The University of Texas at San worm-medium mixture were removed, each of Antonio, 4242 Piedras Drive, East, San Antonio which was pipetted into the main compartment 78284. The authors thank Morton Rothsteln (State University of New York at Buffalo) who g~aciously of a Warburg reaction vessel for manometric supplied cultures of axenic Panagrellus redivivus and studies. From time to time, aliquots were Turhatrix aceti. extracted and counted to verify accuracy of the 241 242 Journal ofNematology, Vol. 5, No. 4, October 1973 procedure. There were no significant changes in oxygen per unit time by day 4 and much more number of worms over the time period studied by days 5 and 6; oxygen consumption by when compared on a statistical basis. control worms decreased again by day 7. Each reaction flask also contained 1.5 ml of Enzyme accumulation apparently peaks after 1 M phosphate buffer (pH 8) in the main day 4, hence the notable increase in oxygen compartment, 1 ml of 10% glucose in the consumption on day 5. sidearm, and a piece of fluted filter paper Whereas little oxygen was consumed by soaked with 0.2 ml of 20% KOH in the center cold-exposed T. aceti (Fig. I-B) on days 2-4, well (22). After equilibration of the reaction uptake increased slightly on day 5 and vessel in the Warburg apparatus for 15 min, the considerably more on days 6 and 7. By day 7, substrate was tipped into the main the rate of oxygen consumption by worms compartment, and oxygen consumption was exposed to the cold was appreciably greater measured for 105 min. than that of the controls. Again, no further Originally, the rate of oxygen uptake was difference was detected on day 8. measured at 37 C. However, T. aceti failed to Unlike the linear curves obtained for P. consume detectable quantities of oxygen at this redivivus (Fig. l-A) which are typical of oxygen temperature. Therefore, all subsequent oxygen consumption curves, those obtained by plotting consumption measurements were made at 30 C oxygen uptake of T. aceti versus time often for both species. showed a distinct plateau in the first few days The experiment subsequently was repeated after the initiation of the experiment (control: using worms obtained from a second day 2; cold: days 2-5). Subsequently, however, subculture. the more conventional, linear pattern gradually replaced the horizontal nature of the lines, the RESULTS slopes becoming greater and greater with time (with the exception of that of the day 7 The control of P. redivivus consumed control, where the slope decreased with respect considerably greater amounts of oxygen than to that of day 6). did the worms exposed to the cold (Fig. l-A). The difference between oxygen consumption of the two groups decreased gradually until very DISCUSSION little difference appeared by day 5. On day 6, Typically, the amount of oxygen although the difference was very slight between consumption increased in the control worms of the two groups, the cold-exposed worms both species shortly after the initiation of the consumed more oxygen per unit time than did experiment (P. redivivus: days 2-4; T. aceti: the controls. This trend was accentuated by day days 2-5). Gradually, the slopes obtained from 7. No further difference was detected by day 8. the worms subjected to the cold increased with A lag in oxygen consumption following the time until they clearly exceeded those of the addition of exogenous glucose was evident in control worms by day 7. This is the classic some of the curves (Fig. I-A). In the control picture of cold acclimation as presented by worms, this lag either was not apparent (days many authors, in which some rate function 2-4) or persisted for only 5-10 min after glucose (usually rate of oxygen uptake) increases at a supplementation (days 5-7). On the other hand, given temperature in a cold-acclimated relatively long lag periods of 45 rain (day 2), with respect to that of a control. Precht (9) approximately 30 rain (day 3-4) and 10 min described five patterns of temperature (day 5) were revealed in the curves obtained acclimation, ranging from supra-optimal from the cold-exposed worms. No lag period compensation (type 1) to inverse compensation appeared after 6 or 7 days of cold exposure. (type 5). The most common pattern is one in The results obtained from T. aceti are not as which the normal rate is greater in cold- than in clear-cut as are the data from P. redivivus. At warm-acclimated animals (9). This pattern was days 2 and 3 (Fig. I-B) little difference was observed in this experiment for both P. observed between the oxygen consumption of redivivus and T. aceti. Most frequently, partial the control and that of the cold-exposed compensation (type 3) is observed (9, 10), but worms. In both cold-acclimated and control often the rate function approaches perfect groups, oxygen uptake, although greater after the compensation (type 2) (10). Bullock (1) addition of exogenous glucose, was very low. pointed out that this type of compensation to The control worms consumed slightly more temperature by various rate functions has the Cold Acclimation: Cooper, Ferguson 243 over-all effect of conferring relative homeostasis from the control and the cold-exposed worms. to poikilotherms that can acclimate to changing In both species, the curve obtained from the temperatures over a nonlethal temperature cold-exposed worms increased with time until range. day 7, when the rate of oxygen consumption In the oxygen consumption-time plots for was appreciably greater than that of the both P. redivivus and T. aceti, a change controls. Since no further difference was noted occurred in the relative positions of the curves between the two curves on day 8, we assumed A B 400" 80- Day2 200 Day2 40- ....@ - (/) + - I,,,,. 0 ~'--.-o~.~'.":~--,":',r '-- , . , , 0 ~ i .,I,,- Day 3

0 i,,,,,. 200 . " 40 o E v O~ 4 ...... Z 0 I-- a°° I 13. °°0 t.~'~q~,, '*.+, ...... 77) JDay5 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' (/) .4 Z 40 ...... 0 0 Z ILl >.-(.9 200 t ./ 4O X 0 ,,, I Ouy7 ' ,~ .-* '

O~ .... ,, O~ , 0 20 40 60 80 100 0 20 40 60 80 100 TIME (minutes) FIG. 1. A. Rate of oxygen consumption by Panagrellus redivivus from day 2 through day 7 following exposure to experimental conditions. Control: o o. Cold-exposed: + o. Arrows indicate addition of glucose. B. Rate of oxygen consumption by Turbatrix aceti from day 2 through day 7 following exposure to experimental conditions. Control: o o. Cold-exposed: • •. Arrows indicate addition of glucose. 244 Journal of Nematology, Vol. 5, No. 4, October 1973 that both species had acclimated to 10 C in 7 the plateau originally observed disappears and is days. replaced by a linear curve that indicates The length of time required for the onset of gradually increasing oxygen consumption after the cold-acclimated state is a species-specific day 2 and 5 in the control and cold-exposed character, which may be subject to seasonal worms, respectively. All of these factors, the variation and/or physiological state of the low level of oxygen consumption forming a organism (3, 8). The blowfly, C~lliphora plateau which is replaced by a linear curve of erythrocephala, acclimates to 10, 20 or 30 C in increasing slope, could indicate a change from 8 days (21); the crayfish, Orconectes virilis, to one predominant metabolic pathway (A), in 5 C in 1-3 weeks (8); Ascaris suum to 25 or 30 which glucose is not used directly, to another C in 11 days (23); and the American cockroach, (B), in which glucose is freely metabolized. Periplaneta americana, within 3 weeks (3); all Thus, the low plateaus of oxygen uptake may of these data are based on measurements of represent the presence of a small amount of oxygen uptake. In view of these data, a 7-day enzyme(s) capable of metabolizing glucose but period for acclimation of P. redivivus and T. rather insignificant with respect to the enzyme aceti to 10 C is not surprising. It is reasonable systems currently being utilized. This initially to assume, however, that a different time minor pathway would gain importance as the period might have been found had the worms substrate(s) necessary for pathway A disappears been maintained at a temperature other than from the medium. the one used (20 C) prior to exposure to the The apparent failure of T. aceti to cold. metabolize exogenous glucose in relatively fresh The lag period observed in some of the medium is of interest in itself and is curves could be explained by a requirement for paradigmatic of the atypical nature of the enzyme synthesis induced by adding the metabolism of many species of free-living exogenous glucose. In the worms subjected to nematodes. For example, Ells and Read (5) the cold for only 2 days, the rate of metabolic found evidence for an incomplete tricarboxylic processes had been decreased as a direct acid (TCA) cycle in T. aceti. The free-living consequence of the cold; therefore, the rate of nematode Caenorhabditis briggsae does not protein synthesis would also be reduced seem to utilize carbohydrates completely, considerably. However, as the metabolic rate thereby suggesting either the total absence or a accelerates with the onset of cold acclimation, limited functioning of the TCA cycle (18). the rate of enzyme synthesis also increases. It is These two species also appear to have an possible that no lag period is evident at day 7 electron transport system that is different from due to the presence of sufficient enzymes in the that of most animals (12, 18). Rothstein and system at this time to accommodate the his co-workers have demonstrated the enzymes exogenous glucose. isocitrate lyase and malate synthetase in C. A very different picture arises in the case of briggsae (15) and in P. redivivus, T. aceti and T. aceti. Here, no oxygen consumption was Rhabditis anomala (see 18), thus suggesting the observed when measured at 37 C and only a presence of the glyoxylate cycle in these small amount of oxygen was taken up on day 2 nematodes. The synthesis of certain "essential" at 30 C. According to these data, the amino acids (valine, lysine, threonine, tyrosine, assumption made by Ells (4) and Read leucine, isoleucine and histidine) has also been (personal communication) that T. aceti is shown to occur in C. briggsae (l 6). unable to metabolize glucose is substantiated It is possible that the failure of T. aceti to under the conditions which these authors utilize exogenous glucose reflects a dependence utilized. This lower capacity (or absence of it) upon an alternate carbon source such as acetate to metabolize glucose might also explain the or other short-chain fatty acids. In this respect, low consumption of oxygen by T. aceti in it has been suggested that short-chain fatty comparison to P. redivivus. It is probable that acids rather than carbohydrates are indeed the the enzymes capable of breaking down glucose major energy-yielding substrates in this species are in low concentration in T. aceti and, (12). Moreover, incubation of T. aceti with therefore, the organism cannot respond readily 14C-acetate in whole medium results in the to glucose administration. However, as the formation of radioactive glycerol (13). When medium is depleted of nutrients with time, the these worms are incubated with labeled acetate rate of oxygen consumption rises appreciably in in water, however, the predominant product is both control and cold worms. Concomitantly, glucose rather than glycerol. This dichotomy in Nematode Cold Acclimation: Cooper, Ferguson 245 metabofic products formed resulting from a poikilotherms, p. 98-112. In A. S. Throshin difference in the composition of the medium, [ed.]. The cell and environmental temperature. Pergamon Press, N.Y. may substantiate the observation made in the 12. READ, C. P. 1961. The carbohydrate metabolism present paper that glucose utilization increases of worms, p. 3-34. In A. W. Martin [ed.]. as the medium is depleted of nutrients Comparative physiology of carbohydrate presumably necessary for the maintenance of metabolism in heterothermic animals. Univ. of type A metabolism. Wash. Press, Seattle. 13.ROTHSTEIN, M. 1969. Nematode biochemistry X. LITERATURE C ITED Excretion of glycerol by free-living nematodes. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 30:641-648. I.BULLOCK, T. H. 1955. Compensation for 14.ROTHSTEIN, M. and E. COOK. 1966. Nematode temperature in the metabolism and activity of biochemistry VI. Conditions for axenic culture poikilotherms. Biol. Rev. 30:311-342. of Turbatrix aceti, Panagrellus redivivus, 2.CRYAN, W. S., E. HANSEN, M. MARTIN, F. W. Rhabditis anomala and Caenorhabditis briggsae. SAYRE and E. A. YARWOOD. 1963. Axenic Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 17:683-692. cultivation of the dioecious nematode 15.ROTHSTEIN, M. and H. MAYOH. 1964. Glycine Panagrellus redivivus. Nematologica 9: 313=319. synthesis and isocitrate lyase in the nematode, 3.DEHNEL, P. A. and E. SEGAL. 1956. Acclimation Caenorhabditis briggsae. Biochem. Biophys. of oxygen consumption to temperature in the Res. Commun. 14:43-47. American cockroach (Periplaneta americana). 16.ROTHSTEIN, M. and G. TOMLINSON. 1962. Biol. Bull. 111:53-61. Nematode biochemistry. IL Biosynthesis of 4.ELLS, H. A. 1969. Physiology of the eel, amino acids. Biochim. Biophys. Acta Turbatrix aceti (Nematoda). 1I. Enzymes of the 63:471-480. glycolylic sequence. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 17.SAYRE, F. W., E. L. HANSEN and E. A. 29: 689-701. YARWOOD. 1963. Biochemical aspects of the 5. ELLS, H. A. and C. P. READ. 1961. Physiology of nutrition of Caenorhabditis briggsae. Exp. the vinegar eel, Turbatrix aceti (Nematoda). !. Parasitol. 13:98-107. Observations on respiratory metabolism. Biol. 18.SAZ, H. J. 1969. Carbohydrate and energy Bull. 120:326-336. metabolism of nematodes and Acanthocephala. 6.HANSEN, E. L. and W. S. CRYAN. 1966. p. 329-360. In M. Florkin and B. T. Scheer Continuous axenic culture of free-living led.]. Chemical zoology. Vol. III. Academic nematodes. Nematologica 12:138-142. Press, N.Y. 7.HOCHACHKA, P. W. 1967. Organization of 19. SCHLIEPPER, C. 1967. Cellular ecological metabolism during temperature compensation. adaptations and reactions demonstrated by p. 177-203. In C. L. Prosser [ed.]. Molecular surviving isolated gill tissues of bivalves, p. mechanisms of temperature adaptation. AAAS, 191-199. In A. S. Troshin [ed.]. The ceil and Washington, D.C. environmental temperature. Pergamon Press, 8.MC WHINN1E, M. A. and J. D. O'CONNOR. 1967. N.Y. Metabolism and low temperature acclimation in 20.SEGAL, E. 1956. Microgeographic variation as the temperate crayfish, Orconectes virilis. thermal acclimation in an intertidal mollusc. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 20:131-145. Biol. Buff. 111:129-152. 9.PRECHT, H. 1958. Concepts of the temperature 21.TRIBE, M. A. and K. BOWLER. 1968. adaptation of unchanging reaction systems of Temperature dependence of "standard cold-blooded animals, p. 50-78. In C. L. Prosser metabolic rate" in a poikilotherm. Comp. [ed.]. Physiological adaptation. Amer. Physiol. Biochem. Physiol. 25:427-436. Soc., Washington, D.C. 22.UMBREIT, W. W., R. H. BURRIS and J. F. 10.PRECHT, H., J. CHRISTOPHERSEN and H. STAUFFER. 1964. Manometric techniques, HENSEL. 1955. Temperatur und Leben. 4tli ed. Burgess Publ. Co., Minneapolis, Minn. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. 514 p. 23.WILSON, P. A. G. 1967. Physiological adaptation 11.RAO, K. P. 1967. Some biochemical mechanisms and partial dormancy in Ascaris eggs. Nature of low temperature acclimation in tropical 213:715-717.