REPUBLIC OF THE Department of Transportation and Communications PUNONGHIMPILAN TANOD BAYBAYIN NG PILIPINAS (HEADQUARTERS PHILIPPINE COAST GUARD ) BOARD OF MARINE INQUIRY TH 139 25 STREET , PORT AREA , MANILA

MARINE ACCIDENTS FROM 1972-PRESENT

NO. VESSEL’s CASE NO. & PLACE OF DATE OF BMI NO. OF SURVI- BMI & SBMI DATE NAME NATURE INCIDENT INCIDENT F & R CASUALTIES VOR FINDINGS FORWARDED TO (dated) DEAD/MISSIN AND LEGAL G RECOMMENDATION S 450 M/V Baleno SBMI Off Isla Verde, 26 Dec 09 6 Dead 73 Owner/shipmaster & Officer Owner/shipmaster 9 Capsizing Batangas 44 Survivors violate PPA Administrative & Officer violate Order No. 03-2006 on Guidelines Implementing PPA Missing VTMS, violate Memo Cir N0 Administrative 170, Human error. Order No. 03-2006 on Guidelines Implementing VTMS, violate Memo Cir N0 170, Human error. 449 M/V Catalyn SBMI 3 NM from 24 Dec 09 10 Dead B Collision Limbones 17 46 Ongoing Investigation VS. Island off Survivors F/V Anatalia Maragondon, Missing Cavite 448 M/V SBMI-03-06 At the vicinity in bet 11 Mar 06 Human error For review Premship X Collision/ the sec to the last red buoy and last Vs. Sinking red buoy, Tagud M/V Mihara II Consolascion side. 447 M/V Super BMI-942-09 Coastal waters off 06 Sept 2009 20 Nov 09 10 Dead 958 Human error Forwarded to CPCG Ferry 9 Capsizing/Sinking Zamboanga Survivors Decision dtd Dec 07, 2009 (ATSC) Peninsula

1 446 M/Bca SBMI-001-09 Vicinity waters of 231300H May 7 Jul 09 43 Human error Forwarded to CPCG Commandos-6 Capsizing Malahibomanok, 2009 12 Dead Survivors Decision dtd Batangas Bay, Oct 28, 2009 Batangas City 445 M/Bca Mae SBMI-01-08 Vicinity of Linao, 14 Dec 08 23 Mar 09 47 30 45 The proximate and Forwarded to CPCG Jan Capsizing Aparri, Cagayan Dead Survivors immediate cause of Decision dtd capsizing is the breaking of Nov. 13, 2009 the outrigger. Carrying of passengers in excess of its capacity and bad weather condition are contributory causes of capsizing. 444 M/Bca Roliv SBMI-005-08 Brgy 12 Nov 08 17 Sep 09 14 30 The proximate cause of the Forwarded to CPCG Capsizing Bagongong, Dead Survivors capsizing was the Decision dtd indubitable fact that she was Dec 29, 2009 Coneption, not seaworthy. The immediate cause of capsizing is the breaking of the outrigger. The contributory causes would be strong winds and big waves and failed engine. 443 M/Bca Don SBMI-005-08 Vicinity of 04 Nov. 08 20 Nov 08 42 10 105 The proximate and Dexter Capsizing Macaraguit Dead Survivors immediate cause of Forwarded to CPCG capsizing is the breaking of Decision dtd Island , the outrigger. May 20, 2009 Dimasalang, The manner of how the Masbate captain maneuvered the vessel is a contributory factor and that the vessel is top heavy (fully loaded on the upper deck without any weight below to counter. 442 M/V Lake SBMI-002- At the Coast of 21 June 2008 None None Officers The Company Manger did Paoay 2008 Carles, Iloilo & crews not appear for the investigation. Sinking Survive d M/V Ocean SBMI-001- Vicinity of 21 June 2008 2 2 24 Negligence of the Officer, 441 Papa 2008 Maralison Dead Survivors Crews and the Port Forwarded to CPCG Captain’s failure to monitor Sinking Island Antique the PSWS.

2 440 M/V Princess BMI 941-08 Vicinity 1NM 21 June 2008 18 Aug 08 437 605 32 Failure of the company and Forwarded to DOTC of the Stars Capsizing SW of Dead Survivors its senior officers in ensuring last 27 Aug 2008 the safety of MV Princess of SLI Cabitangahan, (inclusive the Stars, its passengers Brgy Taclobo, dates of and cargo. Other findings Sibuyan Island investigation are likewise reflected on the 25 June- 18 probable lapses of government agencies. Aug 08) Omissions of individual officers are likewise indicated. 439 LCT Don SBMI Bicol Vicinity of Brgy. February NA Wilfredo 002-08 Buhang, 2008 Hearing on going Capsized Bulusan, Sorsogon 438 M/V Accord SBMI Bicol South Eastern 17 January NA 001-07 portion Brgy. 2007 Hearing on going Grounding Baybay, Malinao, Albay 437 M/V Baleno- SBMI-02-07 Admin 1 NA 5 Death of Case/SBMI Hearing on going Passenger on STL 02-07 Board 436 M/V Blue SBMI-03-007 Vicinity of 12 July 2007 11 126 Subj vessel overloaded and Water Capsizing Bondoc Point Dead has not complied w/ the other conditions of Princess San seaworthiness; intentionally Francisco,Quez beached by the master on 435 M/V SBMI-STL- Vicinity of 10 June 2007 5 12 282 CATALYN-D 001-2007 Calintugan, Survivors Hearing on going Burning/ Calavite point Sinking 434 M/T Solar-I SBMI-936-06 Vicinity of 11 August 14 Board finds several factors Forwarded to Sec. Sinking Guimaras 2006 September 2 16 as follows: Loss of reserved DOTC on September buoyancy, loss of residual 26, 2006 Island on 2006 Survivors stability and Master’s incompetence. 433 M/V GMVI SBMI STL 04- Wharf of 13 May 2006 NA Swallow Vs. 07 Collision Mainaga, Ongoing Hearing LCT Clara Mabini Dioresa Batangas 432 M/V Uni- BMI 935-06 Pier 5, Manila 04 Apr 2006 NA On going hearing crown Collision

3 431 M/V Princess SBMI-SWM- Vicinity of 07 July 2005 On going NA of the World 002-05 Fire on Dulongin Pt., hearing Ongoing Hearing SLI Board Zamboanga Peninsula 430 M/V Doña SBMI-SWM- Vic. Of Kulaybato 280700H 31 January 1 died 29 Explosion on board caused Forwarded to Sec. Ramona 001-05 Fire on Wharf located on August 2005 2006 injured by an improvised explosive DOTC on March 22, device. Board strictly direct 2006 Board Brgy Kulaybato, Lamitan, Basilan the ARMM to adopt the ISPS Code. 429 F/B Anita BMI 934-06 1 NA For resolution by Board Deejay Death of Bernard Sasi 428 F/B Paul BMI 933-06 Vicinity of 15 Dec 2005 1 NA For resolution by Board Gerald Death of Dakula, Jolo Agustin Sulu Bacongan Jr 427 Maria Isabel BMI 932-05 Sta Clara, 06 Apr 2005 1 NA For resolution by Board Death of Batangas Apprenticemate 426 M/T Eric & BMI 931-05 Vicinity of 10 Jun 2005 NA For resolution by Board Barge Kaela Alleged hitting harbor terminal 425 Tugboat BMI 930-05 Vicinity of 26 Mar 2005 NA For resolution by Board harbour Alleged hitting EADPC Area challenger kuching & Barge harbor dolphin 424 M/V Maria SBMI 001- Pier Aduana 10 April 2004 NA Ongoing Hearing Beatriz Vs. 2004 Muelle Loney MBCA Little Allision St., Iloilo City Star 423 M/V Super SBMI-001-04 Off El Fraile at 27 Feb 2004 April 94 24 781 For resolution by DOTC Forwarded to Sec Ferry 14 Fire on Board Lat 14 deg 19.4 2004 Survivors DOTC April 2004 mins N, Long 120 deg 37.4 mins E 422 M/V Prince BMI 929-05 Lamay, limay, 07 Mar 2004 None None None For resolution by Board of Akhristian Alleged hitting Bataan Albert-V 421 M/V Princess BMI 928-05 Port of Allen, 06, Dec 2004 NA For resolution by Board of Mayon Alleged hitting Northern Samar

4 420 M/V Kingston BMI 927-04 Danish Waters 29 Nov 2003 NA For resolution by Board Trader Violation of TSS 419 M/V Super SBMI-01-03 Vicnity of 1 NM 25 May 2003 06 June 43 21 182 For resolution by DOTC Forwarded to Sec. Ferry 12 Vs Collision Limbones 2003 Survivors DOTC 06 June 2003 M/V San Island Nicholas 418 M/V Mahlia BMI 926-03 Vicinity of Board find no fault in the Sinking Northeast of 24 Feb 2003 17 Sept 03 7 1 action of the officer & crew 18 Sept 03 w/c would warrant any Amani Survivor admin. Sanction after Kagoshima, conducting this Inquiry Japan 417 M/B Nilode – SBMI-0402 Vicinity of Bgy. 11 May 2002 12 June 19 79 Operator and Patron found 09 Sept 2002 A Sinking Antipolo, Naval, 2002 Survivors negligent Samar 416 M/V Maria SBMI-01-02 Vicinity of 11 Apr 2002 02 May & 39 6 95 SBMI Board found Owner Forward to SOTC 10 Carmela Burning Pagbilao, 03 Jun crew injured officer and crew negligent May 2002 Quezon 2002 s Hospital, 176 not injured 371 person 415 M/S Philports BMI 924-01 Moored at berth 14 Feb 2001 None None NA D-II Fire on Board 5, pier 13, South harbor 414 BRP Teotimo BMI 923-00 Entrance of 26 Feb 2000 None None NA Figuracio Near Collision Manila Yatch (PCG 389) Club Basin vs M/V Kristen 413 M/V Nol BMI 922-00 Vic of Lingayen 23 Jan 2000 None None NA Schedar Grounding Gulf 412 M/V ACX SBMI-111- Lat. 14 deg. 02 Sept 2000 09 Mar 4 2 Navigating officer and 04 Apr 2001 Lilac Vs 2000 Collision 26.7 min N, 2001 Master negligence of M/V ACX Lilac Barge Long 12.0 deg. Cargolift – III 41.7 min. NE 411 M/V BMI 921-00 Currimao port, 21 Dec 1999 None None NA Forlavida Damage to Ilocos Norte fender cluster 410 M/V Asia SBMI-04-99 Coast of 23 Dec. 1999 15 Aug 58 0 699 Negligence of Captain and South Korea Sinking Bantayan Bay 2000 Survivors navigating officer

5 409 F/B Ross BMI 920-99 Vic of twin rock NA ann 10 vs Ramming Don Eugenio 408 M/T Flagship BMI 919-99 31 Jul 1999 NA Maginoo vs Bumping M/T Ocean Pride 407 M/V Blue BMI 918-99 Brgy. Mainaga, 15 Jul 1999 NA Falcon Fire on board Mabini, Batangas City 406 F/B Nilen II BMI 917-99 1CGD None 1 NA Falling transferred to overboard SBMI 405 F/B Lady BMI 916-99 Dalahican bay, 15 Oct 1999 None 4 NA Debbie vs Ramming/ Lucena M/V Viva Sto hitting Niño 404 M/T Master From Subic to NA Capt Jenifer Villaflor be Lawrence & BMI 915-99 Nvotas, M.M. 13 Sep 99 20 Dec 01 None None reprimanded for being 20 Dec 01 remiss in his duties. Sludge Sinking Barge 403 M/T BMI 914-99 Pasig river near 22 Apr 1999 None None NA Margaret vs Collision LRET bridge M/T Angat 402 F/B Jeshale BMI 913-99 Vic of Navotas 13 Aug 1999 None None NA & Jay Anne Hitting River vs M/T Elfa & M/T Shogun 401 M/T Mary BMI-912-99 vicinity of NA Master has not valid license, Anne Sinking Munga 22 July 99 15 Dec 00 None None Officer & crew be absolved 14 Apr 01 Lighthouse 400 M/V Ok ka BMI 911-99 Roxas 22 Jul 1999 None None NA ferry 2 Struck the sea boulevard, wall Manila 399 M/V Super BMI 910-99 North harbor 05 Jun 1999 None None NA Ferry 8 Grounding entrance buoys, Manila Bay

6 398 F/B Lady Lita BMI 909-99 Off Libucan NA Master & App. Abella of M/V III & M/V Collision Island Samar 26 Sep 99 20 Jan 03 None None Doña Maria Belinda 13 Feb 03 negligent & responsible of Doña Maria the collision, suspended for Belinda (2) yrs to practice his profession in any vessel 397 M/T Sea BMI 908-99 Entrance of 19 Mar 1999 None None NA Brothers-1 Sinking south harbor, Manila Bay 396 M/V Gen Del BMI 907-99 Pier 2 North 12 Feb 1999 None None NA Pilar vs M/T Allision Harbor, Manila Movers-2 395 M/T Obando BMI 906-99 Vic of CTC 04 Feb 1999 None None NA vs Barge Hitting Slipway, Pasig Siment III river 394 NA Wilhelm Granada M/T Diwal Vs Bmi-818-94 EBW South 08 Nov 94 17 Oct 01 None None Unlicensed Patron of S/B Subflo denied renewal of 17 Oct 01 S/B Sub-Flo Collision Harbor SP, Maj Patron Marciano Manila Marco MT Diwal be exonerated from any administrative liability 393 M/T Tiburon BMI-856-97 South Harbor, Order NA Case Closed for all legal Swiped by Manila 31 July 97 14 June 01 1 None intents 14 June 01 Line Overboard 392 F/B Cel-A BMI-881-98 Sapatos, Balud, NA Patron of F/B Charito Vs. F/B Ramming Masbate 27 July 98 18 May 01 None None suspended for 5 yrs. Owner 24 May01 liable Charito 391 M/T SBMI-26-93 NA M/T Southern Star-S at fault Southern Collision Pasig River 15 Oct 93 14 July 00 1 None Human error 14 July 00 Star-S Vs. M/T Crsvill 390 Barge BMI-869-98 Along Pasig NA Patron M/T Petrochem 8 be Siment IV Hitting river 15 May 98 25 Oct 99 None None suspended for 1 yr 25 Oct 99 Vs. M/T Petrochem 8 389 M/V Master, C/M and C/E be Guernsey BMI-842-96 50 miles 10 Nov 96 20 May 99 Un- 2 suspended for 5 yrs upon 25 May 99 finality of the decision CPC Express Sinking off Guam Island know 16

7 388 M/V Manta BMI-844-97 Daanbantayan, NA Vs Napocor Damage to Cebu to 10 Apr 97 20 Nov 98 None None NPC be deem to have at 20 Nov 98 fault and to blame Submarine Southward of cable Liloan 387 M/T Crane BMI-845-97 Batangas Bay NA C/E suspended for 3 yrs North Explosion Anchorage 19 July 97 31 Aug 98 2 1 negligent in proper 31 Aug 98 maintenance 386 M/V Master be suspended for 5 Kimelody BMI-839-95 Off of Fortune 03 Dec 95 15 May 98 24 100 yrs. other officer were not 15 May 98 allowed to work aboard ship Cristy Burning Island 13 385 Legaspi Oil Co. NA M/V Filipinos BMI-832-95 wharf Arimbay 06 Jul 95 14 Feb 97 None None Master to gross negligent 14 Feb 97 Damage Legaspi City 384 Barge TM NA 2001 towed BMI-P-179-97 Dasul Bay, 11 Jan 97 30 Apr 98 None None Barge Patron be absolved 30 Apr 98 by M/T Brokeout Pangasinan Ranger 383 Yacht Pia BMI-P-181-97 NA Patron of M/T Rock Maria Vs. Damage to TACOMA,Pier 15 Mar 96 05 Mar 98 None None suspended for 3 Years. 05 Mar 98 M/T Rock yacht 382 Barge BMI-741 Lat 11 deg NA Umalad Sinking 40’00” N, Long 06 Nov 89 13 Feb 97 None None Force Majeure 13 Feb 97 towed by 120 deg 19.5’ E M/T Trident 381 Barge LB Vicinity of NA 1011 towed BMI-808-94 Campomanes 05 Apr 94 06 Jun 97 None None Tugmaster, Officers & crew 06 Jun 97 be exonerated by M/T Grounding Bay Maricolum Trident Negros Occ. 380 M/V Menina BMI-797-93 Port of NA Master and C/E are Elisa Pollution at Hamburg, West 21 Jan 93 5 Mar 97 None None admonished to careful 5 Mar 97 sea by oil Germany 379 M/V Gold BMI-803-94 Officers and crew be Faith Engine Off Palawan 24 Nov 93 02 Feb 95 Un- 18 6 oxenerated from explosion 02 Feb 95 and sinking incident Explosion Sea, Phil. known Sinking 378 M/V Lurcon The court of justice has Luzon Vs BMI-786-93 Makr Wharf 20 Mar 93 24 July 97 None None NA exclusive jurisdiction. Over 24 July 97 operator of Lorcon Luzon Napocor Rammed Gen Santos shall be liable Power Barge City 104

8 377 M/V Sto Nino BMI-834-95 Vicinity of Master of M/V Sto Nino be Vs Barge Hitting Tabangao 29 Jan 95 27 Jan 97 None None 2 suspended for 2 yrs & 27 Jan 97 Owner will fine Jimmel IV Shore Batangas City 376 M/V Ruby I BMI-834-94 Vicinity of NA Master of M/V Ruby I be Vs M/V Ace I Near Collision Matuko Pt. 07 July 95 10 Jan 97 None None reprimanded and warned for 10 Jan 97 overtaking Batangas City 375 M/V General BMI-775-91 Dover Strait, NA Master be warned for Vargas Rule 1072 United Kingdom 02 Jul 91 10 Jan 97 None None violation 10 Jan97 374 M/V Solid BMI-807-94 Pier 8 Berth 5, NA Duty officer and Master Dos Burning North Harbor, 09 May 94 09 Dec 96 None None guilty of negligent 09 Dec 96 Manila 373 M/V Manila BMI-764-90 Dover Strait, NA Master be warned for careful Progress Rule 1072 United Kingdom 06 Aug 90 10 Jan 97 None None future 10 Jan 97 372 M/V Myson BMI-828-95 Pier 13, Manila 27 Apr 95 04 Sept 96 1 None NA Master, Chiefmate and Hitting Bay Boatwain negligent 07 Sept 96 371 M/V Viva BMI-829-95 Vicinity of NA Owner/Operator, Antipolo VII Burning/ Dalahigan 16 May 95 25 Aug 95 None None Master/Patron of M/V Viva 25 Aug 95 Antipolo VIII negligent Sinking Fishport, (Human error) Lucena City 370 M/V Federal BMI-783-92 NA Master reprimanded and Fraser Oil Pollution New found land 22 Apr 92 20 Jan 87 None None warned 20 Jan 97 369 M/V Sta BMI-836-95 Berth 8, NA Penafrancia Rammed Batangas City 29 Sept 95 14 Nov 96 None None Master reprimanded 14 Nov 96 VI Pier 368 M/L Octopus BMI-626-87 Vicinity of Iloilo Patron M/L Octopus Vs M/V Collision River 29 Oct 87 01 Aug 96 None None 12 negligent, suspended for 1 01 Aug 96 year Wilcon V 367 M/V Fellow BMI-662-87 Strait of 08 Nov 87 15 Nov 96 None None NA Master be reprimanded 14 Nov 96 Rule 1072 Hormuz 366 M/V Salud BMI-782-92 Dover Strait, 31 Dec 91 15 Nov 96 None None NA Master be reprimanded 15 Nov 96 Ace Rule 1072 France 365 RP-RB- BMI-791-93 25 Nov 87 12 Nov 96 None None NA Master Exonerated or 12 Nov 96 RIFTV Dragged absolved 364 M/V Aboitiz NA Harbor Pilot Capt. Lampis Mega Carrier BMI-816-94 MICP 24 Aug 93 15 Nov 96 None None and Capt. Cayanong, Master 15 Nov 96 reprimanded 2 Vs Tango Hitting

9 363 M/V Promex BMI-825-95 NA Officers and Crew of M/V Aman Vs 1Lt Collison Manila Bay 15 Feb 95 09 Aug 96 None None 1LT Jack Lummus Negligent 09 Aug 96 Jack Lummus 362 M/T Mahal BMI-821-95 Vicinity of NA Owner/operator Master of Sinking Batbatan 14 Jan 95 23 Feb 96 None None M/T Mahal negligent 23 Feb 96 Island, Culasi, Antique 361 M/T Petro Outside NA Master of M/V Guardi Queen Vs BMI-815-94 breakwater, 08 Aug 94 22 Mar 95 None None Ludowa negligent (Human 23 Mar 95 error) M/V Guardia Manila Bay Ludowa 360 M/V BMI-802-94 Enroute from NA Case closed for all legal Maynilad Disappearanc Davao to Aklan 15 Sep 93 12 Oct 94 None 1 intent 12 Oct 94 e 359 M/V Our BMI-171-93 Dumaguit, New NA Lady of Ramming Washington, 17 Jan 93 11 Oct 94 None None Master negligent 11 Oct 94 Fatima Aklan 358 M/S Sta NA Master of M/S Florentina be Florintina Vs BMI-745-89 Pier 2 North 22 Oct 89 21 Jul 94 None None reprimanded for negligent 21 JUL 94 M/V San Allision Harbor, Manila Sebastian

10 357 MV Cebu City Lat. 14 degrees Master Miraflor suspended Decision dtd 09 William BMI-819-94 24’-02” North 02 Dec 1994 05 Jan 1995 73 41 525 and disallowed to board any January 1995 Shipping (Collision) Long 120 degrees vessel on his capacity as Company 07’ master for 4years. Second officer Baiyu found Vs MV Kota negligent and disallowed to Suria board any vessel in his Pacific Int’l capacity as merchant marine Line Ltd. officer for 3years. Singapore Chief mateBolodo Registry suspended and disallowed to board any vessel on his capacity as merchant marine officer for 1year and to undergo refresher and re- training on STCW courses. Chief officer Baiyu found negligent and primarily responsible for the collision and therefore calls for maximum imposable sanction of revocation/cancellation of his licence and banned from travelling to the Phil.teritory on board any vessel as merchant marine officer 356 MV Viva BMI-829-95 Vicinity of Antipolo VII (Burning/Sin Dalahican Fish 16 May 1995 25 Aug 1995 62 10 142 Viva Shipping king) Port, Lucena Inc. 355 MV Kimelody BMI-839-95 5 Miles off Fortune 13 Dec 1995 15 May 1998 Cristy (Burning) Island 24 13 171 Moreta Shipping Company 354 MV Princess of Negligent in preventing the the Orient BMI_880-98 Vicinity of Fortune 18 Sept 1998 27 Jan1999 70 80 355 allision between the two 21 Jul 94 ( Sulpicio Lines (Sinking) Island vessels Inc) 353 ML Gretchen I SBMI-01-96 Owner/Operator and Patron (Mr. Noe and (Grounding) Cadiz City 18 Feb 1996 29 Nov 1996 51 145 negligent (Human error) 11 Jul 94 Mrs. Clarita CGD WV Quiamco )

352 M/L Ainon BMI-08-83 Maluso, Basilan 07 Dec 82 15 Feb 84 None None NA Patron and Crew found to 15 Feb 84 Jaira Sinking Province be negligent

11 351 M/T BMI-578-84 Caltex Oil NA Chief Mate suspended for Masdelco Explosion/ Wharf 25 Aug 84 17 Aug 90 None None Five (5) years 23 Aug 90 Fire 350 M/V Sulcon NA Master of M/V Aboitiz Con XI Vs M/V BMI-717-89 North Harbor, 29 July 89 15 Jan 93 None None Carrier VIII suspended for 1 20 Jan 93 year Aboitiz Con Collision Manila Carrier VIII 349 M/V Palawan BMI-752 Vicinity of Pasig NA Master fine 500.00 C/M Princess Grounding Shoal, Roxas 10 Apr 90 29 Nov 93 None None suspended for 2 yrs. 29 Nov 93 SLI Palawan 348 MV Diamond BMI-784-93 Lanang, Davao 31 Dec 92 5 Nov 93 None None NA CPCG directed to transfer 5 Nov 93 Grayhorse Dragged City the case to 8CGD, Davao drifted 347 BRP Mactan BMI-755-90 Pier 13, South 22 Jun 90 4 Nov 93 None None NA Master MV Buffalo 28 Oct 93 (AC-90) Vs Allision Harbor Manila suspended 2 yrs Human error MV Buffalo 346 MV Lady BMI-787-93 On board Japan 18 Nov 92 7 Sep 93 None None NA Chief Mate negligent 7 Sep 93 Dona Complaint 345 MT Jasaan BMI-704-89 Brooks Pt., 5 Nov 88 31 Aug 93 None None NA Human error 30 Aug 93 w/ Barge Vs Allision Palawan Barge 609, B-1001 344 MV Ruth Riis BMI-768-91 vicnity of 18 Jul 91 28 Jul 93 None None NA PCG has no jurisdiction to 26 Jul 93 Sinking Basilan Strait, impose penalty to Master & Officers held liable Zamboanga 343 MV Mearsk BMI-P-163- 93 MICT 2 feb 93 28 Jul 93 None None NA Case closed for all legal 23 Jul 93 Asia Damage intent 342 MV BMI-788-93 On board 20 May 91 28 Jul 93 None None NA Case closed for all legal 23 Jul 93 California In-competency intent Zeus 341 MV Annie V BMI-700-91 Vicinity of 22 Dec 91 7 May 93 47 3 Owner/Operator, Officers & 6 May 93 Sinking Quinoloban perso persons Crew be absolved Island, Palawan ns 340 MV RP BMI-720-89 Maas, West 25 Feb89 10 Feb 92 None None NA Board warned the Master 16 Jun 92 Cayman Rule 10’72 Netherland 339 MBca The BMI-758-90 Vicinity of 20 Jul 90 4 Jul 91 None None NA Case closed for all legal 4 Jul 91 Return of Ramming Lubang Island intent Commodore Vs MV TPJ Scout IV

12 338 MVPenguin BMI-735-90 Ferry Terminal 19 Apr 90 4 Jul 91 None None NA Case closed for all legal 4 Jul 91 Twinnie Vs Allision south Harbor, intent MV Madrigal Manila Surigao 337 MV Aboitiz BMI-697 MICP, Manila 8 Oct 88 4 Jul 91 None None NA Case closed for all legal 4 Jul 91 Con CarrierX Allision intent Vs President Jefferson 336 MV OK Dos BMI-714 Pinamanukan, 17 May 89 29 May 91 None None NA Settled amicably 29 May 91 Rammed Batangas 335 LCT BMI-654-87 Vicinity of 16 Dec 87 12 Dec 90 None None 15 Case closed for all legal 12 Dec 90 Barangay Capsized Florante, persons intent Eastern Samar 334 Barge towed BMI-699-89 Vicinity of 7n Feb 89 8 Nov 90 None None NA Case closed for all legal 27 Nov 90 by MT Loss Guam and intent Hurecane II Kauching, Tiawan 333 LCT Bataan BMI-761-90 San Roque, 16 Aug 90 27 Nov 90 None None NA Case closed for all legal 27 Nov 90 Grounding San Jose, Occ intent Mindoro 332 MV Reyna BMI-663-87 Strait of Hus 15 Nov 87 20 Nov 90 None None NA Master be reprimanded 20 Nov 90 Rule 10’72 331 MT Dakila BMI-631-87 In shore Traffic 11 Jun 87 8 Nov 90 None None NA Master be reprimanded 8 Nov 90 Rule 10’72 Zone, Hormuz starait 330 MV Madrigal BMI-750-90 Pier 13, Berth 6 12 Feb 90 29 Oct 90 None None NA Case closed for all legal 29 Oct 90 Surigao Vs Hitting south Harbor intent MV Fengle Manila 329 MV Banaue BMI-653-87 Quessant traffic 21 Sep 87 10 Oct 90 None None NA Master & 2 nd Mate be 10 Oct 90 Rule 10’72 Separation reprimanded Scheme France 328 MV DONA Findings dtd 22 March 1988 Findings dtd 22 march PAZ (Sulpicio BMI-653-87 Tablas Strait 20 Dec. 1987 22 Mar 1988 1,827 Paz- - 24 Owners and operators gross 1988 Lines Inc) (Collision ) bet.Marinduque 13 - 2 negligence and total lack of Vs and Mindoro 1,840 Vector 26 cares MT VECTOR - - (Vector Shipping Total Company)

13 327 SBMI-08-88 Vicinity bet. Capt Eliodoro Salgado Jr be Finding and Dona Marilyn (2CGD) Tanguigui Island 24 Oct 1988 28 Mar 1989 77 2 300 suspended for period of recommendation review (Sulpicio Lines (Sinking) Manok-Manok 5years from practice of his dtd 04 August 1989 Inc.) Island profession. Officers and crew absolved from administrative liability 326 MT Petron III BMI-696-86 Caltex Pier, 3 Feb 86 11 Sep 90 None None NA Case closed for all legal 11 Sep 90 Rammed Batangas intent 325 FB Jeannie- BMI-616-86 Six miles of 2 May 86 14 Jul 90 None None NA Master of FB Doña Aurea 22 Aug 90 M vs FB Allision Guntrao Island suspended 5 yrs violation expired C.I. Doña Aurea 8 324 MV Efago 3 BMI-665-88 Pier 6, North 16 Mar 88 30 Jul 90 None None NA Case closed for all legal 17 Jul 90 Vs MV Bumped Harbor, Manila intent Kapalaran 323 MT Blue BMI-711-89 Vicinity of 27 May 89 29 Jun 90 None None NA Case closed for all legal 29 Jun 90 Marlin w/ Allision Balayan Bay & intent Barge Vs F/B Sombrero Oasis Island 322 MVCarrier BMI-674-88 Gen Malling NA Case closed for all legal SA NA16 Allision Pier, Gen 19 Apr 88 16 Feb 90 None None intent 16 Feb 90 Bariles Santos Pier 321 M/V Singa BMI-739-89 200 NM West of Case closed for all legal Sea Sinking Banbury 04 Jul 88 15 Jun 90 Un- Un- 6 intent 15 Jun 90 Australia known know n 320 M/V EDGO-1 BMI-739-89 Batangas Bay NA Case closed for all legal 10 May 90 Vs M/V JQ Allision Government 21 oct 89 09 May 90 None None intent Bay IV Pier 319 M/T PNOC Vicinity of NA Petro Parcel BMI-622-86 Veradoro Bay, 19 Oct 86 08 Mar 90 None None Case closed for all legal 08 Mar 90 intent Vs M/T Dona Bumping Mindoro Susana 318 M/V BMI-611-86 Off Minanga NA Master and Chief Mate be Maharlika I Grounding Point, Dalupiri 10 Jan 86 07 Mar 90 None None reprimanded 08 Mar 90 Island 317 M/B Rosy BMI-708-89 Vicinity of Bulos CGD Maconalon remiss in Cristy-VI Capsizing Point 01 Apr 89 04 May 90 2 2 22 performance of duty 08 May 90 Maconacon Island

14 316 M/T PNOC BMI-742-89 Vicinity of NA Case closed for all legal Petro Parcel Engine Batangas Bay 31 Oct 89 28 Feb 89 1 None intent 28 Feb 89 Explosion 315 M/V Rodolfo BMI-227-89 Vicinity of City NA 31 Jr Grounding Pecados Island, 08 Jul 89 22 Feb 89 None None Dismissed 22 Feb 89 Guimaras 314 Barge Towell BMI-617-86 South west of Tug Master suspended for towed by Sinking Dumali Island, 16 Jul 86 15 Feb 89 None None 3 two (2) years negligent 15 Feb 89 M/T Red Guimaras Horse 313 M/V Ake BMI-706-89 Vicinity of 19 Feb 89 28 Feb 89 1 None NA Case closed for all legal 28 Nov 89 Paoay Death Tablas Island intent 312 M/T Don BMI-724-89 Dapdap, Beach NA Case closed for all legal Victor Grounding Sta Cruz, 12 Aug 89 28 Nov 89 None None intent 28 Nov 89 Marinduque 311 M/T PSTC-1 NA Vs Barge BMI-574-84 Hospicio de 13 Jun 84 19 Oct 89 None None Case closed for all legal 17 oct 89 intent ESC-2 and Allision San Jose, ESC-3 Pasig River 310 Barge S- BMI-71-89 Tefasco Pier, 07 Jul 89 17 oct 89 None None NA Case closed for all legal 17 Oct 89 2011 Vs M/V Collision Davao City intent Solid Uno 309 MSCI-1515 Near NA Vs M/V Dona BMI-637-87 breakwater 01 Jul 87 06 Oct 89 None None Case closed for all legal 06 Oct 89 intent Susana Ramming North Harbor, Manila 308 M/S Crazy BMI-606-85 Pasacao Port, 17 Oct 85 29 Sep 89 None None NA Case closed for all legal 02 Oct 89 Horse Grounding Camarines Sur intent 307 M/V BMI-693-88 Vicinity of NA Case closed for all legal Woodstar-A Grounding Sangco Point, 30 Nov 88 None None intent Bislig Surigao del Sur 306 M/T Andrea BMI-703-89 Batangas 25 Mar 89 03 Jul 89 None None NA Case closed for all legal 03 Jul 89 Allision Anchorage intent 305 B-CLC 1001 Baseco NA Towel Mr BMI-705-89 Engineering 07 Apr 89 08 Aug 89 None None Case closed for all legal 09 Jul 89 intent Harpon Vs Allision Island B-Labray 5

15 304 F/B Noemi NA Patron of Prabal Floating Cristina Vs BMI-623-87 Navotas Fish 07 Apr 89 08 Aug 89 None None Station suspended for two 08 Aug 89 (2) years M/T Prabal Allision Port Pier Floating Station 303 M/V Aboitiz BMI-675-88 Pier of Makar 03 Jun 88 26 Apr 89 None None NA Case closed for all legal 26 Apr 89 Con Carrier I Bumped Wharf intent 302 Aroroy NA M/T Taclobo BMI-702-89 anchorage to 03 Jun 88 26 Apr 89 None None Case closed for all legal 26 Apr 89 intent Grounding Atlas Mining Wharf 301 M/T Med BMI-P-141-88 NA Guilty of the Admin charges Heron Complaint On board 24 Nov 88 27 Jan 89 None None 27 Jan 89 300 Vicinity Master suspended for one M/V Don BMI-640-87 between Tablas 19 Jul 87 09 Feb 89 None 12 13 (1) year and negligent 09 Feb 89 Tony Sinking and Simarara Island 299 M/S Philsport Vicinity of NA Major Patron and 3 rd Mate SD-11 Vs BMI-569-84 entrance buoy 22 May 84 28 Sep 88 None None Philsport D11 suspended 1 28 Sep 88 year and Master of M/V M/V Misamis Allision North Harbor Misamis Occident absolved Occidental 298 LCT Vicinity of Cawit NA Peatheray BMI-646-87 Point Cortez, 03 Mar 87 28 Sep 88 None None Force majuere 28 Sep 88 Patrick G Capsizing Surigao del Sur 297 BMI-P-135-87 NA Case closed for all legal M/V Abeer 8 Misconduct On board 22 Jul 87 19 Apr 88 None None intent 19 Apr 88 296 Sasa Wharf, NA Harbor Pilot Capt A. Casia M/V Lorcon BMI-634-81 Davao City 10 Jun 87 18 Apr 88 None None suspended for one (1) year 19 Apr 88 XI Damage 295 BMI-501-82 Off Pier South NA Harbor Pilot Capt C. Calulo M/T Timonel Sinking Harbor,Manila 28 Jul 82 22 Nov 88 None None be suspended for one (1) 19 Apr 88 year 294 F/B BMI-677-88 Caminauit Pier, NA Emmanuel Allision San Jose, Occ. 15 Jun 88 23 Nov 88 None None Dismissed 23 Nov 88 Vs M/V Mindoro Edward 293 M/V BMI-P-139 North Harbor, 17 Jun 87 22 Nov 88 None None NA Case closed for all legal 22 Nov 88 Greymound Complaint Manila intent

16 292 BMI-678-88 From San Jose, NA M/V Sta Ana Jettisoning of Occ. Mindoro to 28 Jun 88 27 Jul 89 None None Dismissed 27 Jul 89 Cargoes Batangas City 291 Master suspended for 5 M/V Lorcon BMI-698-89 Vicinity of 10 Mar 89 03 Jul 92 9 None 12 years owner/operator 03 Jul 92 negligent V Sinking Maricalum Bay 290 M/V Qu BMI-633-87 Port of San NA Case closed for all legal Jiang Damage to Fernando, La 04 Jun 87 24 Dec 87 None None intent 24 Dec 87 Pier Union 289 M/B Sta Vicinity of NA Maria Vs BMI-609-86 Tuluran Point, 05 Dec 86 24 Dec 87 None None Case closed for all legal 24 Dec 87 intent M/B Villaflor Collision San Jose Rasalita Taytay, Palawan 288 F/B Eda-2 BMI-649-87 Vicinity of NA Sinking Malapacan and 17 Mar 87 18 Jan 88 None None Case closed for all legal 18 Jan 88 intent Triple Sema Island 287 M/S BMI-644-87 Veterans Wharf 15 Mar 87 08 Dec 87 None None NA Case closed for all legal 08 Dec 87 Ambassador Bumping intent 286 M/V Lorson BMI-628-86 Sasa Wharf, NA Case closed for all legal XI Vs M/V Bumping Davao City 05 Nov 86 07 Dec 87 None None intent 07 Dec 87 Dolorico II 285 F/B Tricia BMI-642-87 Dalahigan Fish Officers and Crew and Eneyja Burning Port, Lucena 23 Jul 87 21 Oct 87 None None 23 Fishermen absolved 21 Oct 87 City 284 M/T Don BMI-591-85 Vicinity of Prieto NA Victor Grounding Diaz Point, 23 Jan 85 15 Oct 87 None None Case closed for all legal 15 Oct 87 intent Sorsogon 283 M/V Queen BMI-564-84 NA Annie III Vs Allision Batangas City 04 Jan 84 15 Oct 87 None None Dismissed 15 Oct 87 M/V Papago Pier 282 BMI-559-84 Lat. 1627.5 NA M/T Tanggigi Sinking North Long 119 09 Nov 83 15 Oct 87 None None Dismissed 15 Oct 87 52.2 East 281 Vicinity of Brgy. M/V BMI-621-86 Pandan, 19 Oct 86 04 Dec 87 4 5 20 Force majuere due to 04 Dec 87 typhoon Ruping Kalayaan Sinking Sablayan, Occ. Mindoro

17 280 M/V Queen BMI-643-87 Mamburao, NA Annie III Sinking Occidental 18 Aug 87 13 Nov 87 None None Force Majuere due to 12 Nov 87 typhoon Mindoro 279 M/S BMI-118-85 On board 22 Jan 85 12 Nov 87 None None NA Case closed for all legal 12 Nov 87 Mindanao Misdoncuct intent 278 M/V BMI-645-87 Picop Port NA Case closed for all legal Maligaya Bumped Tabon, Bislig, 03 Sep 87 12 Nov 87 None None intent 12 Nov 87

Surigao del Sur 277 M/S Mount BMI-608-85 Port of NA Master and Chief Engineer Data Vs M/T Allision Chittagong, 18 Oct 85 21 Aug 87 None None suspended for one (1) year 21 Aug 87 negligent Sunny Bangladesh 276 M/V Sovonita BMI-630-87 USA to France 12 Dec 86 12 Aug 87 None None NA Master reprimanded Human 12 Aug 87 Rule 10-72 error 275 BMI-130-86 NA M/V Robert Vio-traffic Strait of Hormz 17 May 86 07 Aug 87 None None Master admit violation 27 Jul 87 negligent separation 274 M/V BMI-122-86 On board 21 Dec 85 10 Jun 87 None None NA Case closed for all legal 10 Jun 87 Abubasma intent 273 Barge LC- BMI-468-82 Quinluban and Tug Master suspended for 2 1702 Sinking Ilin Island 29 Oct 81 20 Feb 87 None None 3 years negligent 02 Mar 87 272 Barge LC- BMI-581-84 Del Monte NA 7702 Sinking Point, Mindoro 29 Jul 84 03 Apr 87 None None Dismissed 02 Apr 87

271 M/V Marcos BMI-605-85 Balintang 14 Oct 85 31 Aug 87 3 24 68 Chief Mate suspended for 2 31 Aug 87 Faberes Sinking Channel years 270 South of Master, Officers and Crew M/V Beatriz BMI-618-86 Santiago Point, 01 Aug 86 23 Jan 87 3 8 152 be absolved Force Majure 23 Jan 87 Sinking Camotes Island, Cebu 269 M/V Asia BMI-172-74 South Harbor, NA Case closed for all legal Star Vs Collision Manila 27 May 74 16 Jan 87 None None intent 16 Jan 87 Barge Michelle 268 M/V Amihan BMI-267-75 Vicinity of Naris NA Case closed for all legal Express Sinking Point, Palawan 28 Dec 75 15 Jan 87 None None intent 16 Jan 87

267 F/B Nonette BMI-614-84 Off Fortune 15 May 86 30 Jul 86 None 1 NA Dismissed 30 Jul 86 Falling Island 266 M/V Don BMI-592-85 Vicinity of 27 Jan 85 28 Jul 86 None None NA Case closed for all legal 28 Jul 86 Rodolfo Agrounding Tanao Island intent

18 265 F/B Mary BMI-607-85 Vicinity of 12 Oct 85 28 Jul 86 None None NA Case closed for all legal 28 Jul 86 Grace I Agrounding Nagalaw Island intent 264 M/T BMI-603-85 NA Seaborne Death of Crew On board 18 Mar 85 23 Jul 86 1 None Dismissed 23 Jul 86 263 M/V Dang BMI-P-125-86 NA Zarina Complaint On board 14 Jun 86 16 Jul 86 None None Dismissed 16 Jul 86 262 BMI-579-84 Vicinity of Force Majeure M/V Loreto Sinking Mangsoaqui 18 Aug 84 11 Jun 86 None None Un- Owner/Operator, Officer and 10 Jun 86 Crew absolved III Point Ilin Island known 261 M/V Vicinity bet. NA Ildefonso VI BMI-135-73 Galo Island and 12 Sep 73 14 May 86 None None Case closed for all legal 16 May 86 intent Vs M/T Collision Cape Calavite Sterling 260 Vicinity of Cape NA LCT-7 Bros BMI-182-74 Calavite 10 Jun 74 07 May 86 None None Case closed for all legal 08 May 86 intent Sinking Lighthouse Point 259 Vicinity of Lubic Force Majeure F/B Ruthsan BMI-509-82 Island, Palawan 08 Jun 82 29 Apr 86 None None 23 Owner/Operator, Officer and 29 Apr 86 Crew absolved III Sinking 258 M/V Prince BMI-P-121-85 NA Case closed for all legal intnt of Tokyo Complaint 03 Oct 85 10 Mar 86 None None 10 Mar 86 257 M/V BMI-P-113-84 NA Case closed for all legal Universal Complaint 13 Jun 84 18 Feb 86 None None intent 20 Feb 86 Frontier 256 M/V Sweet BMI-601-85 North Harbor, NA Case closed for all legal Sail Vs M/V Allision Manila 06 Mar 85 19 Feb 86 None None intent 14 Feb 86 Aboitiz 255 M/V Victor Jr BMI-270 Occ. Mindoro 16 Dec 74 13 Feb 86 None None NA Case closed for all legal 14 Feb 86 Agrounding intent 254 M/B Lady BMI-270-74 Palawan 16 Dec 74 13 Feb 86 None None NA Case closed for all 14 Feb 86 Marte T-9 Agrounding legal intent 253 M/B Antraco BMI-361-78 Engineering 17 Oct 78 14 Feb 86 None None NA Case closed for all 14 Feb 86 Ramming Island legal intent 252 M/V Marie BMI-361-78 Lat 08 37.5” NA Case closed for all Ann Sinking North Long. 13 Apr 85 10 Feb 86 None None legal intent 10 Feb 86 120” 11.8” East 251 M/T BMI-589-84 Nadulao Point 15 Oct 84 04 Feb 86 None None NA Case closed for all 04 Feb 86 Hiawatha Agrounding legal intent

19 250 M/B Saint BMI-249-75 Pasig River 12 May 75 03 Feb 86 None None NA Case closed for all 03 Feb 86 John Ramming legal intent 249 M/T Albert BMI-597-85 Calatagan, 11 May 85 07 Jan 86 None None NA Case closed for all 07 Jan 86 Agrounding Batangas legal intent 248 M/V Del Star BMI-596-85 Surigao del Sur 04 Jan 85 06 Jan 86 None None NA Case closed for all 06 Jan 86 Agrounding legal intent 247 M/V Antipolo BMI-590-85 Virac, 21 Jun 85 07 Jan 86 None None NA Case closed for all 07 Jan 86 V Capsizing Catanduanes legal intent 246 M/V BMI-P-119-85 NA Brodeverett Complaint 08 May 85 15 Nov 85 None None Closed for all legal 15 Nov 85 intents 245 F/B Belen S- BMI-271-75 Palawan 29 Dec 75 09 Oct 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 09 Oct 85 5 Total Wreck intents 244 Barge BSC-3 BMI-588-85 07 Jan 85 13 Sep 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 13 Sep 85 Sinking intents 243 M/V BMI-188-74 San Nicolas 09 Jul 74 09 Sep 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 09 Sep 85 Mangarin Agrounding Shoal intents 242 M/V Sulcon BMI-567-84 North Harbor, NA IV Vs M/V Collision Manila 08 Mar 84 02 Aug 85 None None Closed for all legal 02 Aug 85 Aboitiz CCI intents 241 M/V Noli BMI-587-84 Verac reef 29 Dec 84 26 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 26 Jul 85 Agrounding intents 240 MB BMI-69-73 Calavite 27 Mar 73 29 Jul 85 None None NA Patron suspended 29 Jul 85 YOLANDA Sinking 239 MV KOTA BMI-P-59-79 NA Closed for legal intents MANIS Complaint 06 Mar 79 29 Jul 85 None None 29 Jul 85 238 MV BMI-409-79 Crew NA BERNADET Loss/Disappe Palawan to 14 Dec 79 25 Jul Vesse None Closed for all legal 25 Jul 85 TE arance Cebu l intents disapp earan ce 237 MT AIKANE BMI-319-76 /cakatagab 19 Sep 76 17 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 17 Jul 85 Agrounding Reef, Batangas intents 236 MV DON BMI-P-81-81 NA Closed for all legal GERARDO Complaint 03 Oct 81 17 Jul 85 None None intents 17 Jul 85 235 MT BMI-296-76 Sandoval Pt. 18 May 76 17 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 17 Jul 85 CHARGER Agrounding Tayabas intents

20 234 MV ANIAH BMI-P-115-84 NA Closed for all legal Complaint 01 Aug 84 Jun 85 None None intents Jun 85 233 M/S San BMI-316-76 12 Nov 76 27 May 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 27 May 85 Vicente Complaint intents 232 M/V El BMI-349-78 Oriental 21 Apr 78 28 May 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 28 May 85 Apollo Sinking Mindoro intents 231 M/V BMI-426-A-79 NA Masaganang Damage Sablaya Pier 13 Oct 79 28 May 85 None None Closed for all legal 28 May 85 Ani intents 230 M/T Fuffalo BMI-380-79 Vicinity of NA Sinking Scarborough 02 Apr 79 24 May 85 None None Closed for all legal 24 May 84 Lagoon intents 229 Barge Vic- BMI-368-79 Vicinity of 21 Oct 79 23 May 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 23 May 85 702 Sinking Puego Point intents 228 Vicinity of NA M/T Ranger BMI-494-81 Nauhan, 26 Dec 81 20 May 85 None None Closed for all legal 20 May 85 II Agrounding Oriental intents Mindoro 227 Vicinity of NA F/B Don BMI-585-84 Oring-Oring, 23 Oct 84 02 May 85 None None Closed for all legal 02 May 85 Antonio-B Agrounding Brooke’s Point, intents Palawan 226 M/T BMI-355-77 Vicinity of San NA Closed for all legal Kangaroo Sinking Vicente, 07 Nov 77 13 May 85 None None intents 09 May 85 Cagayan 225 Barge Maria BMI-341-78 Vicinity of NA Closed for all legal Leticia Sinking Cabulanan 10 Jan 78 13 May 85 None None intents 08 May 85 Island, Palawan 224 M/V Maria BMI-337-77 Vicinity of 03 Dec 77 13 May 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 08 May 85 Epifania II Sinking Caliavite Point intents 223 Barge Manila BMI-339-78 From Hongkong NA Bay Floating Sinking to Philippines 03 Jan 78 30 Apr 85 None None Closed for all legal 30 Apr 85 Restaurant intents 222 M/V Belinda BMI-563-83 Vicinity of 12 Dec 83 30 Apr 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 30 Apr 85 IV Agrounding Lusay Bay intents 221 M/V Julieta BMI-340-78 Pier 12 North 30 Jun 78 30 Aug 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 30 Aug 85 Burning Harbor, Manila intents 220 M/V Queen BMI-553-83 NA Amy II Vs Allision Kuyo Wharf 24 Sep 83 26 Apr 85 None None Closed for all legal 26 Apr 85 BRP SAR 99 intents

21 219 Vicinity of Rita NA M/T Toots BMI-488-82 Island, Bahili, 14 Feb 82 27 Apr 85 None None Closed for all legal 27 Apr 85 Capsizing Puerto intents Princesa, Palawan 218 Vicinity of NA F/B Theresa BMI-335-77 Binatican, 11 Sep 77 27 Apr 85 None None Closed for all legal 27 Apr 85 Sinking Taytay, intents Palawan 217 FV BB8-II Vs BMI-598-84 Vicinity of NA Closed for all legal F/B Genger Allision Capas 02 Oct 84 27 Apr 85 None None intents 25 Apr 85 Pagbilao, Quezon 216 M/L Peaceful BMI-429-80 Vicinity of 12 Sep 80 24 Apr 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 24 Apr 85 Sinking Bancuan Island intents 215 M/V Euney BMI-418-80 Pier 12 North NA Vs M/V Allision Harbor, Manila 12 Jun 80 24 Apr 85 None None Closed for all legal 24 Apr 84 Panama II intents 214 LC-1705 Vs BMI-524-83 Caminauit NA M/V Allision North, San 11 Apr 83 26 Mar 85 None None Closed for all legal 26 Mar 85 Francisco Jose, Occ. intents Mindoro 213 BMI-577-84 NA M/V Mersk Damaged to MICP, Berth 2 02 Jul 84 25 Mar 85 None None Closed for all legal 25 Mar 85 Timpo ship and pier intents 212 BMI-536-83 One mile NA LB 1006 Lost approaching None 22 Mar 85 None None Closed for all Legal 22 Mar 85 South arbor intents 211 LC 1009 and BMI-565-84 Shore of 14 Dec 84 15 Mar 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 15 Mar 85 LC 1021 Agrounding Danjugan Intents Island 210 M/T BMI-395-79 Pandacan NA Closed for all legal 04 Mar 85 Pearhead Vs Collision Terminal, Pasig 28 Aug 79 04 Mar 85 None None intents M/T Ronald River 209 M/V Eugenio BMI-505-82 North Harbor, 30 Jul 82 01 Mar 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 01 Mar 85 Bump Manila intents

22 208 Barge BMI-435-80 Vicinity of NA Patherey G-4 Collision Hospicio de 14 Nov 80 06 Mar 85 None None Dismissed without 06 Mar 85 Vs SSS- San Jose, prejudice 15=G Pasig River 207 M/T Malitam BMI-424-80 Enroute from NA Vs M/V Collision Bataan to 31 Jul 80 25 Feb 85 None None Closed for all legal 25 Feb 85 Susana Batangas intents

206 F/B World BMI-511-82 Vicinity of NA Marine 77 Sinking Babuyan 11 Aug 82 18 Feb 85 None None Closed for all legal 18 Feb 85 Channel, Aparri intents 205 M/V Sweet BMI-558-83 Vicinity of NA Roro Vs M/T Collision Fuego Point 01 Oct 83 15 Feb 85 None None Closed for all legal 15 Feb 85 Delsan Glory intents 243 BMI-473 Vicinity of NA Closed for all legal LC-3001 Agrounding Naujan, Or. 26 Dec 81 13 Feb 85 None None intent 13 Feb 85 Mindoro 203 SMB BMI-479-80 Vicinity of Apo 21 Dec 79 12 Feb 85 1 None NA Closed for all legal 12 Feb 85 Filomena Sinking reef intent 202 M/V Don BMI-476 Jump Vicinity of NA Closed for all legal Enrique over board Simerara Island 12 Sep 81 11 Feb 85 None 1 intent 12 Feb 85 201 M/V Five BMI-437-81 Pasig river 22 Jan 81 21 Jan 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 17 Jan85 Bros. Submerge intent 200 M/T Daranak BMI-422 NA Closed for all legal Vs Barge Collision Pasig river 16 Jul 80 8 Jan 85 None None intent 8 Jan 85 Stephen 199 M/V Milagros BMI-546 Desdecado 31 Jul 83 8 Jan 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 8 Jan 85 Sinking Island, Masbate intent 198 M/V Aries II BMI-508 Culion wharf 10 Apr 83 4 Dec 84 None None NA Closed for all legal 4 Dec 84 Burning Palawan intent 197 F/B Angela BMI-533 NA Closed for all legal Death of Crew Palawan 25 Jun 83 5 Dec 84 1 None intent 5 Dec 84 196 M/V P BMI-466 South China 31 Oct 83 12 Sep 84 None None NA Force Majeure 12 Sep 84 Aboitiz Sinking Sea 195 M/T Bowoon BMI-463 NA Closed for all legal ` Damage to Legaspi City 4 Nov 81 2 Aug 84 None None intent 12 Sep 84 Legaspi Oil wharf

23 194 Barge BMI-485 South Harbor NA Closed for all legal Cagayan Vs Collision Manila 11 Oct 79 27 Mar 84 None None intent 27 Mar 84 M/V Cresta 3 193 M/V Penhills South Harbor NA Closed for all legal Vs M/V BMI-397 Manila 11 Oct 79 27 Mar 84 None None intent 27 Mar 84 Pacific Collision Queen 192 M/T BMI-408 South Harbor, NA Silverhead Collision Manila 22 Jan 80 23 Mar 84 None None Closed for all legal 23 Mar 84 VS Tanker intent JSR-1 191 M/V Renee BMI-547 Camiguin Island 6 Sep 83 15 Dec 83 None None NA Force Majeure 15 Dec 83 Agounding 190 M/V Alivia BMI-P-109 West Germany 10 Aug 83 15 Mar 84 None None NA Closed for all legal 15 Mar 84 Compaint intent 189 M/V Puerto NA Elizabeth Vs BMI- 450 Princessa, 17 Apr 81 15 Mar 84 None None Complaint conduct 15 Mar 84 M/V White Collision Palawan unbecoming Master III 188 M/S Cresta BMI-453 South Harbor, NA Complaint conduct Vs M/S Allision Manila 12 Jun 81 8 Mar 84 None None unbecoming 8 Mar 84 Virginia 187 BMI-P-105-83 NA Complaint conduct M/V Irene Complaint None 6 Jun 83 8 Mar 84 None None unbecoming 8 Mar 84 186 M/V Ever BMI-550-83 NA Complaint conduct Pioneer Damage to South Harbor 27 Aug 83 22 Feb 84 None None unbecoming 31 Jan 84 Ramp 185 M/T Shipyard BMI-404-79 Pasig River 20 Dec 79 10 Jan 84 None None NA Case closed for all 10 Jan 84 Hitting legal intents 184 M/T Delsan BMI-484-79 Tanquiqui 06 Aug 79 22 Dec 83 None None NA Force Majeure 22 Dec 83 IV Agrounding Island, Cebu 183 M/T Delsan BMI-525-79 Tandog, 14 Dec 79 12 Dec 83 None None NA Force Majeure 13 Dec 83 Hitting Surigao 182 M/T Sea BMI-539-83 Lamtio, Limay, NA Petro Vs F/B Bataan 18 Jul 83 29 Nov 83 None None Case closed for all 29 Nov 83 Villaflor legal intents 181 NSC-001 Vs BMI-487-81 NA M/V Don Collision North Harbor 17 Dec 81 16 Nov 83 None None Case closed for all 16 Nov 83 Allision legal intents

24 180 F/B Aqua BMI-455-81 Puerto Princesa 01 Jun 81 08 Nov 83 None None NA Case closed for all 08 Nov 83 Venture Burning legal intents 179 M/V Empire I BMI-460-81 Enroute NA Engine Bioligto, Mla. 30 Sep 81 25 Oct 83 None None Case closed for all 25 Oct 83 Trouble legal intents 178 BMI-532-83 NA LCT San Failing Semirana, 02 May 83 06 Oct 83 1 None Case closed for all 25 Oct 83 Cristobal Overboard of Antique legal intents Chief Mate 177 BMI-538-83 NA MT Sitting Breakage of South Harbor 27 Jun 83 21 Sep 83 None None Closed for all legal 27 Sep 83 Pull Stanchion Port intents 176 BRP Tawi- BMI-523 Puerto Princesa 14 Feb 83 14 Sep 83 None None NA Closed for all legal 14 Sep 83 Twi Allision intent M/T Blue BMI-537 Dapdap NA 175 Marlin Damage to Semerara 15 Jul 83 9 Sep 83 None None Closed for all legal 9 Sep 83 Tugboat & intent Dolphin 174 M/V Queen BMI-530 Coron wharf 22 Apr 83 6 Sep 83 None None NA Closed for all legal 6 Sep 83 Annie 1 Burning intent 173 M/V Plipo BMI-529 Zamboanga del 13 Mar 83 Order date None None NA Closed for all legal 2 Aug 83 Hitting Norte 2 Aug 83 intent 172 M/V Cresta BMI-400 Lat 51-25 N 19 Aug 83 25 Apr 83 None None NA Closed for all legal 29 Jul 83 III Agrounding Long 47.6 E intent 171 M/V Rose BMI-P-27 None 18 Jul 76 7 Jul 83 NA Everett Professional None None Closed for all legal 11 Jul 83 Misconduct intent 170 M/V Angelina BMI-495 Surigao 30 Nov 77 Order date NA Star Professional 27 Jun 83 None None Closed for all legal 27 Jun83 Misconduct intent 169 LCT Nelly BMI528 Araculi, 4 Mar 83 24 Jun 83 NA International Palawan None None Closed for all legal 24 Jun 83 Beaching intent 168 M/T Toidalo BMI-446 France 28 Nov 80 24 Dec 81 NA Viol of Art XI None None Closed for all legal 21 Jun 83 Pollution intent 167 Barge L-655 BMI-27 Hitting Mandaluyong, 13 May 72 26 May 83 None None NA Due to force majeure 6 Jun 83 Pasig river

25 166 LCC 704 BMI-517 North Harbor 24 Jul 79 26 Apr 83 None None NA Incident was 26 Apr 83 Hitting accidentally Officer & crew absolved 165 M/V Sweet BMI-342 North Harbor 10 Jan 78 Order date 1 None NA Closed for all legal 27 Apr 83 Grace Falling 27 Apr 83 intent 164 M/V Glofki BMI-P-96 Kiel Germany 1983 Order date None None NA Closed for all legal 28 Apr 83 Complaint 27 Apr 83 intent 163 M/V Ana BMI-510 Western 25 Jun 82 25 Apr 83 None None NA Closed for all legal 25 Apr 83 Marie Agrounding Palawan intent 162 M/T Golden BMI-P-34 None 24 Sep 86 25 Mar 83 None None NA Closed for all legal 25 Mar 83 Ports Complaint intent 161 M/V Mars II BMI-515 Palawan 21 Sep 82 Order date None None NA Closed for all legal 6 Apr 83 Agrounding 8 Apr 83 intent 160 Tugboat BMI-414 Mc .Arthur 31 Dec 76 5 Apr 83 NA Barge water Sinking Bridge, Pasig None None Closed for all legal 5 Apr 83 II river intent 159 MT Marcelo BMI-P-29 Tacloban 10 Jun 76 Order date NA Steel Professional 22 Mar 83 None None Closed for all legal 22 Mar 83 Misconduct intent 158 M/V Thomas BMI-391 None 12 Mar 77 Order date NA Everet Dereliction of 21 Mar 83 None None Closed for all legal 21 Mar 83 duty intent 157 M/V Loreto V BMI-520-83 Bauan, 5 Mar 82 Order date None None NA Closed for all legal 24 Mar 83 Agrounding Batangas 21 Mar 83 intent 156 M/S Dragon I BMI-108 None None 05 Oct 73 None None NA Closed for all legal 23 Mar 83 Complaint intent 155 M/V Loreto 3 BMI-512 Iling Island Aug 82 Order date None None NA Closed for all legal 01 Mar 83 Agrounding 21 Apr 83 intent 154 M/B de Dios BMI-132-73 Sangley Point 14 Dec 73 11 Feb 83 None None NA Closed for all legal 11 Feb 83 Ramming intent 153 M/B Saint BMI-86-73 Vicinity of Apo NA Jude Agrounding Reef Light 05 Jul 73 12 May 81 None None Closed for all legal 12 May 81 Thaddeds V Station intent 152 M/V NA Mercedes BMI-106-73 Manila Bay 07 Oct 73 07 May 81 None None Closed for all legal 07 May 81 Star Vs RPS Ramming intent Cebu (PS- 28)

26 151 M/T Ramos BMI-370-79 Vicinity of South NA Vs LF-2001 Rammed Harbor, Manila 05 Jan 79 05 May 81 None None Closed for all legal 05 May 81 intent 150 M/V Don BMI-402-79 Vicinity of NA Julio Jump Caballo Point 30 Oct 79 14 Apr 81 None 1 Closed for all legal 20 Apr 81 Overboard Guimaras intent Island 149 M/TPSTC II BMI-583-84 Pasig River 08 Nov 84 05 Dec 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 05 Dec 85 Vs BSC I Allision intent 148 M/V BMI-P-119-85 NA Brodeverett Complaint 08 May 85 15 Nov 85 None None Closed for all legal 15 Nov 85 intent 147 F/B Belen S- BMI-271-75 Palawan 29 Dec 75 09 Oct 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 09 Oct 85 5 Total Wreck intent 146 Barge BSC-3 BMI-588-85 Panay 07 Jan 85 13 Sep 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 13 Sep 85 Sinking intent 145 M/V BMI-188-74 San Nicolas 09 Jul 74 09 Sep 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 09 Sep 85 Mangarin Agrounding Shoal intent 144 M/V Sulcon BMI-567-84 NA IV SLI Vs Collision North Harbor 08 Mar 84 02 Aug 85 None None Closed for all legal 02 Aug 85 M/V Aboitiz intent CCI 143 M/V Noli BMI-587-84 Virac Reef 29 Dec 84 26 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 26 Jul 85 Agrounding intent 142 M/B Yolanda BMI-69-73 Calavite 27 Mar 73 29 Jul 85 None None NA Patron suspended 29 Jul 85 Sinking 141 M/V Kota BMI-P-59-79 06 Mar 79 29 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 29 Jul 85 Manis Complaint intent 140 M/V BMI-409-79 Palawan to 14 Dec 79 25 Jul 85 Crew NA Bernadette Loss/ Dis- Cebu vessel None Closed for all legal 25 Jul 85 appearance disapp intent earan ce 139 M/T Alkane BMI-319-76 Calatagan 19 Sep 76 17 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 17 Jul 85 Agrounding Reef, Batangas intent 138 M/V Don BMI-P-81 03 Oct 81 17 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 17 Jul 85 Gerardo Complaint intent 137 M/T Charger BMI-296-76 Sandoval Point, 18 May 76 17 Jul 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 17 Jul 85 Agrounding Tayabas intent

27 136 M/V Aniah BMI-P-115 01 Aug 84 Jun 85 None None NA Closed for all legal Jun 85 Complaint intent 135 M/S San BMI-316-76 12 Nov 76 27 May 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 27 May 85 Vicente Complaint intent 134 MV El Apollo BMI-349-78 Oriental 21 Apr 78 28 May 85 None None NA Closed for all legal 28 May 85 Sinking Mindoro intent 133 M/V BMI-426-A-79 Sablayan Pier 13 Oct 79 28 May 85 NA Masaganang Damage None None Closed for all legal 28 May 85 Ani intent 132 M/B Bopeep- BMI-04-72 NA S Vs. Gayem (Hitting) Manila Bay 12 Aug 72 20 Dec 82 None None Dismissed 17 Jan 83 I 131 M/V Phil BMI-117-73 San Fernando, 09 Sep 73 09 Apr 81 None None NA Closed for all legal 20 Apr 81 Rizal Damage La Union intent 130 M/V BMI-P-71-80 On board 20 Nov 80 30 Mar 81 NA Southern Complaint None None Closed for all legal 30 Mar 81 Ace intent 129 M/T Blue BMI-440-81 From Roxas, NA Marlin Agrounding Palawan to 14 Jan 81 30 Mar 81 None None Closed for all legal 30 Mar 81 Manila intent 128 M/T Oil BMI-428-80 Vicinity of NA Queen VIII Agrounding Caltex Depot, 24 Jul 80 11 Feb 81 None None Closed for all legal 30 Mar 81 Puerto intent Princesa, Palawan 127 M/B Dalisay BMI-309-76 San Pascual, 12 Aug 76 11 Feb 81 None None NA Closed for all legal 13 Feb 81 Sinking Batangas intent 126 M/V Dynamic BMI-394-79 Pier 3 South 15 Aug 79 10 Feb 81 None None NA Closed for all legal 13 Feb 81 Ace Bumped Harbor intent 125 M/V Parciso BMI-P-69-80 On board 26 Sep 80 30 Jan 81 None None NA Dismissed 30 Jan 81 124 M/T Sea Lion Vicinity of Sta NA W/ Barge Vs BMI-427-80 Ana Bridge, 08 Oct 80 23 Jan 81 None None Dismissed 23 Jan 81 M/T Gimini Collision Pasig River W/ Barge 123 M/T BMI-P-40-76 NA Prosperity Abandonment On board 17 Aug 76 23 Jan 81 None None Dismissed 23 Jan 81 Queen 122 M/V Maria BMI-39-72 Nagoya, Japan 16 Sep 72 22 Aug 79 None None NA Offices and crew 22 Aug 79 Rosello Agrounding absolved

28 121 Vicinity of Brgy. NA M/V Marfina I BMI-302-76 Adela, Rizal, 25 Jul 76 30 Mar 79 None None Force majeure 02 Apr 79 Hitting Occ. Mindoro 120 M/T Oil BMI-374-79 Pasig River 15 Oct 78 08 Dec 80 None None NA Closed for all legal 08 Dec 80 Queen 7 Hitting intent 119 M/T Rajah BMI-360-78 BRC, Limay 18 Jul 79 19 Feb 80 None None NA Dismissed 19 Feb 80 Sulayman Hitting Bataan 118 F/B Gerald BMI-387-79 Vicinity of 15 Jul 79 19 Feb 80 None None NA Closed for all legal 22 Feb 80 Missing Cabra Island intent 117 M/V Sweet BMI-P-76-79 NA Bliss Prof- On board 06 Feb 79 06 Oct 80 None None Dismissed 06 Oct 80 Misconduct 116 M/T Delbros- BMI-333-77 South Harbor 05 Oct 79 17 Dec 80 None None NA Closed for all legal 17 Dec 80 24 Damage intents 115 LCT Tristar BMI-372-79 Vicinity of San NA Master, Chief Mate Vs M/V Lolita Collision Nicolas Shoals, 11 Apr 79 20 Nov 79 8 None and Engineers were 22 Nov 79 Manila Bay suspended for 2 years 114 M/V BMI-419-80 NA Closed for all legal Emprise-1 Collision Pier 8 Barth 5 05 Jun 80 03 Oct 80 None None intents 03 Oct 80 Vs M/V Samar 113 M/S Sweet Vicinity of San NA Faith Vs M/V BMI-419-80 Nicolas Shoals, 25 Mar 77 03 Oct 80 None None Closed for all legal 03 Oct 80 Seven Collision Cavite intents Golden Stars 112 M/B Mar BMI-320-77 Vicinity Off Hen Closed for all legal Efigenia Sinking & Chicken 22 Feb 77 16 Dec 80 None None 3 intents 06 Dec 80 Island 111 M/V Pacific BMI-348-78 Vicinity of NA Master suspended for Vs LSCO Sinking/ Dumali Point, 12 May 78 12 Dec 80 1 1 4 years, third mate 18 Dec 80 Petro Parcel Collision Orr. Mindoro suspended for 2 years 110 M/B Intriped BMI-52-73 Vicinity of Bat- 19 Jan 73 20 May 80 None None NA Closed for all legal 10 Jul 80 Sinking batan Island intents 109 Barge II & BMI-265-75 Enroute from NA Barge III M/T Sinking Taronpita to 19 Dec 75 23 Feb 79 None 6 Patron suspended for 01 Mar 79 Joan Paluan Bay 2 years 108 M/S Claveria BMI-336-78 Enroute from Force Majeure officers Clipper Sinking Cagayan to 12 Dec 78 22 Feb 79 7 None 22 and crew absolved 22 Feb 79 Hong Kong

29 107 M/V Henry BMI-338-77 Vicinity of El 07 Dec 77 07 Jul 78 None None NA Closed for all legal 01 Sep 78 Vs LCT Nelly Collision Fraile, Manila intents 106 M/B Maria BMI-332-74 Vicinity of NA Efigenia XV Sinking Fortune Island 21 Sep 74 12 May 78 None None Closed for all legal 01 Sep 78 intents 105 CBCI Barge BMI-279-76 Vicinity of Closed for all legal 505 Sinking Dalanganen 17 Feb 76 12 May 78 None None 2 intents 12 May 78 Island 104 M/V BMI-279-76 Lat. 0600 North, NA Guardian Sinking Long. 121’ 55’ 02 Mar 76 31 Aug 78 None None Closed for all legal 05 Sep 78 East intents 103 M/T Vergara BMI-322-77 Off Sablayan NA Dis- Sea, Occ. 27 Mar 77 15 Aug 78 None None Master absolved 16 Aug 78 appearance Mindoro 102 M/V BMI-198-74 NA Tanawan Professional On board 31 Mar 74 17 May 78 None None Closed for all legal 17 May 78 Misconduct intents 101 BMI-165 Jump Enroute from NA MV Milofred Overboard Cuyo to Puerto 13 Mar 74 17 May 78 None 1 Closed for all legal 17 May 78 Princesa, intents Palawan 100 MV Cristo BMI-301 Vicinity of NA Mar VS MV Ramming Manila Bay 02 Aug 77 12 Jul 78 None None Dismissed 13 Jul 78 Lityia MV Antonia BMI-191 Port of NA 99 VS Barge Hitting Mangarin, San 02 Jul 74 12 Jul 78 None None Dismissed 15 Jul 78 Maria Jose, Occ. Cristina Mindoro

MT Rizal II BMI-P-28 Lambingan 5 May 78 None None NA Closed for all legal 05 May 78 98 and MT Ramming Bridge Pasig 02 Aug 76 intents Alkane River MT Amex II BMI-315 Napindan, 5 Sep 76 5 Sep 77 None None NA Patron suspended for 06 Feb 77 97 Rammed Binangonan, six (6) months Rizal MB Lady BMI-P-32 Vicinity of 28 Oct 76 16 Jan 77 None None NA Closed for all legal 01 Feb 78 96 Lorie-R VS Rammed Capipisa, intents MB Imisin Tanza, Cavite

30 MB Winky-III BMI-P-31 Vicinity 09 Sep 76 14 Jan 77 None None NA Closed for all legal 01 Feb 78 95 VS MB Rammed between intents Pagasa Bataan Cavite MV Viva BMI-110 Enroute from 17 Oct 73 05 May 78 None None NA Closed for all legal 05 May 78 94 Penafrancia Death of Batangas to intents IV Pasgr. Mindoro MV Wilfredo BMI-225 Pasig River 09 Dec 75 05 May 78 None None NA Closed for all legal 05 May 78 93 Burning intents MB St. John BMI-331 Pasig River 09 Dec 75 05 May 78 None None NA Close dfor all legal 05 May 78 92 Burning intents MS Irene BMI-P-39 On board 05 Jul 74 09 Mar 78 None None NA Closed for all legal 22 Mar 78 91 Conduct intents unbecoming MV Vlasons I BMI-536 Vicinity of 02 Dec 77 28 Feb 78 3 7 NA Force Majeure 27 Feb 78 90 Sinking Appari Point MV Sweet BMI-167 North Harbor 3 May 74 17 Feb 78 None None NA Complaint Conduct 01 Mar 78 89 Home Snapping of Manila Unbecoming anchor chain MV Sweet BMI-156 On board 18 Jul 73 None None None NA Closed for all legal 01 Mar 78 88 Grace Conduct intents unbecoming MT Islander BMI-126 Caltex service 4 Nov 74 15 Feb 78 6 None NA Master suspended for 15 Feb 78 87 Exploded Wharf in San 2 yrs and Chief Mate Pascual, suspended for 3 Batangas months MV Winky-1 BMI-155 Vicinity of 24 Feb 74 25 Jan 78 None None NA Complaint conduct 1 Mar 78 86 Agrounding Sapatos Island Unbecoming MB Maria BMI-184 Vicinity of 18 Jun 74 23 Jan 78 None None NA Case closed for all 1 Mar 78 85 Efigenia II collision Flecher, legal intents VS MB Mindoro Princess of Mindoro LCU BMI-150 Vicinity bet. 13 Feb 74 5 Dec 77 None 9 6 Master suspended for 7 Dec 77 84 Loadstar Sinking Cape Calavite 7 one year Golo Island M/B Sierra BMI-125 Didadungan 6 Oct 73 23 Nov 77 None None NA Closed for all legal 23 Nov 77 83 Madre Sinking Wharf, Palanan, intents Isabela

31 Barge Maria BMI-240 Salvacion 31 Jan 75 01 Dec 77 None None NA Dismissed 1 Dec 77 82 Belinda IV Burning Shipyard, Tobacco, Albay M/V BMI-P-43 Colombo, Sri 23 Jul 77 2 Dec 77 None None NA Dismissed 2 Dec 77 81 Nalexporte D Professional Lanka Misconduct M/V Viva BMI-P-44 Onboard 4 Jul 77 18 Nov 77 None None NA Dismissed lost of 22 Nov 77 80 Penafrancia Moral Act interest V M/V Trans BMI-40 Hitting Port of Naisuru 16 Sep 72 16 Nov 77 1 None NA Dismissed lack of 16 Nov 77 79 Ocean Japan interest Merchant M/V Bagong BMI-171 Onboard 22 Jul 74 15 Nov 77 None None NA Dismissed 22 Nov 77 78 Conducting Unbecoming M/V Sea BMI-299 Dolphin of 25 Jul 76 11 Nov 77 None None NA Dismissed 22 Nov 77 77 Express 101 Hitting Corrigidor Pier F/B Naka BMI-238 Pier Tuscani 8 Dec 74 24 Aug 77 None None NA Case closed for all 26 Aug 77 76 Damage Mariveles, legal intent Bataan M/V Japan BMI-207 Onboard 9 Feb 74 17 Aug 77 None None NA Case closed for all 17 Aug 77 75 Professional legal intent Misconduct MV ORCHID BMI-107 On board 5 Oct 73 10 Aug 77 None None NA Case closed for all 11 Aug 77 74 VENTURE Disobedience legal intent S/B BMI 202 Port of 29 Aug 74 18 Jul 77 None None NA Case closed for all 15 Aug 77 73 PINAGARAL Sinking Batangas legal intent A N MT BONITA BMI-122 Abeam Sangley 8 Oct 73 8 Jul 77 None None NA Force Majaure 8 Jul 77 72 Sinking Point MB NIRA BMI-129 Vicinity of 19 Nov 75 5 Jul 77 None None NA Case closed for all 5 Jul 77 71 Lost Limay Bataan legal intent Barge Ben BMI-59 East of 30 Jan 73 27 May 77 None None 3 Officer & Crew 27 May 77 70 Michael I Sinking Bongabong absolved Mindoro Motorized BMI-224 Vicinity of 16 Oct 74 27 May 77 None 6 1 Case closed for all 27 May 77 69 Banca Sinking Buyayaw Orr. legal intent Mindioro

32 Pilot Motor BMI-28 Near Legaspi 24 Jan 75 26 May 77 None None NA Case closed for all 9 Jul 77 68 Launch Vs Bumping pier legal intent Mt Marlin M/V Ricsan I BMI-284 Vicinity of 24 Dec 75 6 May 77 None None NA Case closed for all 6 May 77 67 Agrounding Silang Island legal intent M/V Venus BMI-158 Vicinity of 23 Dec 73 27 Apr 77 None None NA Master absolved 17 May 77 66 Agrounding Laoag entrance channel Northern Samar M/V Don BMI-237 Route from 23 Jan 75 25 Mar 77 None None NA Master & C/Mate 25 Mar 77 65 Tomas Agrounding Cuyo to suspended for six Caramay, Pal. month M/V Arben I BMI- Onboard 18 Feb 76 17 Mar 77 None None NA Case closed for all 17 Mar 77 64 Professional legal intent Misconduct M/S Ocean BMI-313 Bislig Pier 23 Aug 76 11 Mar 77 None None NA Duty Harbor Pilot 11 Mar 77 63 Ranger Damage to suspended for One (1) pier year M/T Apeco II BMI-54 Onboard 15 Jan 73 2 Mar 77 None None NA Dismissed 2 Mar 77 62 Professional Misconduct Barge San BMI-295 Bagumbayan, 19 Jun 76 28 Feb 77 None None NA Patron and Crew 2 Mar 77 61 Pablo City Sinking Puerto absolved Princessa M/V Nercode BMI-248 On board 8 Mar 75 7 Feb 77 None None NA Case closed for all 7 Feb 77 60 5 Star Damage to legal intent engine M/V Viva BMI-297 Jump Vicinity bet. 3 Feb 76 4 Feb 77 None 1 NA Master absolved 4 Feb 76 59 Penafrancia overboard Batangas and Calapan F/B Sir BMI-244 Vicinity South 26 May 75 4 Feb77 None None NA Case closed for all 4 Feb 86 58 Rommel Vs Collision West Calaviti legal intent F/B Celia – Point N-1 M/S Arrow BMI-190 On board 25 Jun 74 22 Dec 76 None None NA 2nd Engineer 9 Dec 76 57 Ace Professional Suspended for One (1) Misconduct year M/V St. BMI-49 Sandakan, 17 Dec 72 25 Nov 76 None 1 NA Master absolved 26 Nov 76 56 Isidoro Fall overboard Sabah

33 M/V Sweet BMI-179 Fuego Point 30 May 74 15 Nov 76 None 1 NA Master absolved 15 Nov 76 55 Rose Jump Overboard M/B BMI-247 Manila Bay 5 May 75 27 Oct 76 None None NA Dismissed 26 Nov 76 54 Nonerissa Vs (Ramming) M/B Resty-t NA Patron Rodolfo 53 M/T Rizal 2 BMI-29-72 Del Pan, Pasig 23 Sep 72 21 Sep 76 None None Sarmiento of M/T Rizal 11 Nov 76 Vs Barge (Bumped) River 2 suspended for six (6) Edna months M/B BMI-247-75 NA Dismissed pursuant to 52 Nonerissa Vs (Ramming) Manila Bay 05 May 75 27 Oct 76 None None the Provision of 26 Nov 76 M/B Resty-T Section 1 (h) F/B Miss BMI-280-75 Vicinity of NA Officers and Crew 51 Brown (Fell- Taguiti Water 16 Nov 75 20 Aug 76 None One exonerated for the 08 Sep 76 Overboard) death of Mr. Rafael Naquita M/V Viva BMI-21-72 Pier 2, North NA Harbor Pilot Capt. 50 Penafrancia I (Ramming) Harbor, Manila 27 Jul 72 23 Jul 76 None None Enrique Mora and 23 Jul 76 by M/S Don Master of M/V Don Juan Juan due to negligent. LSCO Kabibi BMI-126-73 Shell Jetty 13 Nov 73 13 Jul 76 None None NA Hit and damage of 13 Jul 76 49 (Hitting) Berthing Shell Jetty Berthing BMI-243-75 NA Officers and crew be 48 M/V (Burning/ Rapu-Rapu 05 Mar 75 09 Jul 76 None None exonerated for 09 Jul 76 administrative liability arising Sorsogon Sinking) Island, Albay out of this subject incident Vicinity of San NA Patron Nicasio Villamar 47 F/B Darna BMI-160-74 Nicolas 1 Mar 74 08 Jun 76 None None of M/V Gregorio-S given 08 Jun 76 Vs M/V (Rumming) Lighthouse, stern warning in order to Gregorio-S Manila Bay be more careful navigation. NA Committed error or 46 M/V Inocecia BMI-159-74 Intutulo Island, 19 an 74 08 Jun 76 None None mistake in docketing 08 Jan 76 I Vs M/V (Collision) Masbate and scheduling the Basilan subject case M/T Alkane Docked NA 45 Barge L-763 BMI-73-73 alongside Esso 23 Apr 73 15 May 76 3 0 Negligence which 15 May 76 and Barge L- (Burning) Wharf, Barrio resulted to the subject 1000 Ugong, Pasig, incident Rizal

34 BMI-234-75 Vicinity of NA Closed for all legal 44 M/V Zeus (Burning) Calapan, 24 Jan 75 06 Apr 76 None None intent 06 Apr 76 Mindoro The sinking of F/B 43 F/B Lilia BMI-212-74 Vicinity of 19 Jul 74 06 Apr 76 10 7 2 Lilia, owned and 06 Apr 76 (Sinking) Jomalig, operated by Quezon Donaciano Llamas resulting to the death of 10, missing 7 and 2 survivors

M/B Fishing BMI-215-74 Naic, Cavite NA 42 Gilbert Vs (Ramming) fishing ground 19 Oct 74 26 Jan 76 None None Dismissed 26 Jan 76 F/B Winky III M/B uestra NA Master license, Capt. De 41 Sra de Guia BMI-196-74 Vicinity of 18 Ju 74 13 an 76 None None Jesus, Master of M/B 13 Jan 76 Vs M/V (Hitting) Limbones Nono be revoked his Nonoo Island license; Mr. Manalo, Patron of F/B Nuestra Transport, Sra de Guia and Mr. M/V Paz Cezon, Patron of M/V Paz.

BMI-163-74 4 miles off NA Captain, Officers and 40 M/V (Burning) Silonay Island 09 Apr 74 19 Nov 75 None None crew be exonerated 19 Nov 75 Romblon from any responsibility M/V BMI-194-74 Rome, Italy 26 May 74 23 Oct 75 None None NA Dismissed 28 Oct 75 39 Loussios (Complaint) Vicinity of NA Patron negligence and 38 M/B Dona BMI-139-75 Decabaito 22 Sep 75 06 Oct 75 None None suspended for one (1) 08 Oct 75 Lolita (Hit a Rock) Island, Palawan year

BMI-145-73 NA 37 M/S (Mis-Conduct) Singapore 20 Sep 73 08 Sep 75 None None Parties lack of interest 08 Sep 75 Makeverett BMI-88-75 Magudgud, Officers and Crew and 36 M/V Mactan (Sinking) Cocepcion, 16 Jul 75 21 Aug75 5 22 663 Owner/Operator 21 Aug 75 Romblon negligent BMI-186-74 NA 35 M/V Erwin (Mis-conduct) Japan 16 May 74 31 Jul 75 None None Dismissed 27 Aug 75 Dus

35 F/B Boy BMI-214-74 NA 34 Wilcon Vs (Ramming) Manila Bay 05 Nov 74 19 Jun 75 None None Amicable settlement 19 Jun 75 F/B Saint Peter M/V Federico BMI-145-74 6 miles off NA 33 Vs M/Bca. (Hitting) Rosario, Cavite 15 Jan 74 18 Jun 75 None None Dismissed 18 Jun 75 Bagong Sikat F/B Don BMI-245-75 Vicinity of NA 32 Arsenio Vs (Collision) Buayan Island 22 Jan 75 28 Aug 75 None None Amicable settlement 28 Aug 75 M/B Rica F/B Minerva BMI-233-74 1 mile East of NA 31 RJL Vs M/B (Collision) Verde Island 01 Dec 74 02 Jun 75 None None Dismissed for lack of 16 Jun 75 Edgardo D-III interest BMI-223-74 Vicinity of Cawit NA 19 May 75 30 M/V Halcon (Grounding) Boac, 27 Nov 74 19 May 75 None None Force Majeure Marinduque F/B Randy BMI-227-74 Manila Bay 06 Dec 74 20 Apr 75 None None NA Closed for all legal 30 Apr 75 29 Vs M/B (Rammed) intent Masipag F/B Lady E BMI-199-74 Manila Bay 30 Aug 74 11 Feb 75 None None NA Closed for all legal 11 Feb 75 28 (Rammed) intent F/B Diana-R BMI-200-74 Manila Bay 30 Aug 74 07 Feb 75 None None NA Closed for all legal 07 Feb 75 27 (Rammed) intent F/B Eric Jr BMI-185-74 Vicinity of 27 Jun 74 06 Feb 75 None None NA 26 Vs F/B (Hitting) Tanza, Cavite Closed for all legal 06 Feb 75 Villaflor-I intent F/B Shirley BMI-213-74 Manila Bay 08 Oct 74 06 Feb 75 None None NA 25 (Rammed) Closed for all legal 06 Feb 75 intent N-2 Banca BMI-75-74 Manila Bay NA 24 Vs M/T (Ramming) Quarantine 06 April 73 31 Jul 74 None None Closed for all legal 31 Jul 74 Snakehead anchorage intent Yacht BMI-123-73 Navotas – NA 23 Dorarado I (Rammed) Malabon River 16 Oct 73 29 Jul 74 None None Force Majeure 29 Jul 74 Vs M/B Celeste F/Bca. 1CGD NA 22 CV-3395 and BMI-153-74 Manila Bay 10 Mar 74 25 Jul 74 None None Closed for all legal 25 Jul 74 F/B Maria (Ramming) intent Cynthia II

36 M/T BMI-70-73 NA 21 Hammerhea (Collided) Pasig River 14 Mar 73 25 Jul 74 None None Closed for all legal 25 Jul 74 d Vs M/B intent Sinta BMI-85-73 Pier 12 North NA 20 M/V (Hitting a Harbor, Manila 01 May 73 28 Jun 74 None None Closed for all legal 28 Jun 74 Seahorse submerged intent object) M/V Carmen BMI-80-73 Bataan Wharf 28 Apr 73 13 Jun 74 None None NA Human Error 13 Jun 74 19 (Sinking) M/B Dona NA 18 Andrea II Vs BMI-34-72 Navotas 08 Oct 72 17 May 74 None None Human Error 17 May 74 M/B Golden (Bumping) Sea II M/V Alexia BMI-61-73 Shell Pandacan ` NA Cause of death was 17 (Hitting) Installation, 23 Jan 73 05 Mar 74 One None asphyxia due to 05 Mar 74 Jetty drowning F/B BMI-61-73 Between NA 16 Zorahayda (Hitting) and 03 Dec 73 05 Mar 74 None None Human Error 05 Mar 74 SL Vs F/B Bayas Island Dan Antonio Dos PCF 84 and BMI-44-72 NA 15 Fishing (Ramming) Sangley Point 03 Dec 72 19 Feb 74 None None Closed for all legal 19 Feb 74 Paraw No. intent CV-2832 S/BM BMI-33-72 Vicinity of Itbu NA 14 Nuestra Sra. (Collision/ Point, Calavite, 11 Oct 72 25 Jan 74 None None Human Error 25 Jan 74 Del Pilar-M Sinking) Paluan, Occ. and S/BM Mindoro Esperanza C- 1 M/T Kim- BMI-41-72 Vicinity of 05 Nov 72 09 Nov 73 4 NA The incident was due 09 Nov 73 13 Mee I Mindoro Island to force majeure M/V BMI-23-72 Berth 4, Pier 4, NA 12 Mindanao (Bumping) North Harbor, 26 Jul 72 19 Oct 73 None None Closed for all legal 19 Oct 73 Sea and M/S Manila intent Don Julio

37 Vicinity of NA Found the sinking of 11 M/B J & V BMI-48-72 Guilutagan Is. 05 Nov 72 17 Oct 73 None None M/V J&V Alonso was 17 Oct 73 Alonso (Sinking) Milagros, due to force majeure Masbate 10 F/B Filipinas BMI-46-72 Vicinity NA Closed for all legal (Ramming) between 30 Nov 72 11 Sep 73 None None intent 11 Sep 73 Bataan and Cavite M/S Roswell BMI-105-67 NA 9 Victory Vs (Collision) Manila Bay 18 Dec 67 11 Sep 73 None None Force Majeure 11 Sep 73 M/V Panay Barge BMI-22-72 Vicinity of NA 8 Maguet (Sinking) Caballo Island 20 Jul 72 23 Apr 73 None None Force Majeure 23 Apr 73 towed by M/T JML M/V Don BMI-13-72 Enroute from NA 7 Sulpicio (Death on Tacloban to 27 Jun 72 26 Mar 73 1 None Closed for all legal 26 Mar 73 SLI Board) Manila intent BMI-15-72 NA Patron Roge;io F/B (Capsizing) Manila Bay 25 Jun 72 21 Feb 73 1 1 Alvarez be absolved 21 Feb 73 6 Gumamela from liabilities M/S Don BMI-01-72 Pier 2 North NA Mr. Alkwright Orquia 5 Juan Vs. M/V (Ramming) Harbor, Manila 21 Apr 72 05 Feb 73 None None liable for the incident 05 Feb 73 Don Jose –1 BMI-11-72 Pier 7, South NA Closed for all legal 4 Barge Emily (Damage of Harbor, Manila 24 Jun 72 17 Nov 72 None None intent 17 Nov 72 Cargoes) M/B De BMI-30-72 Vicinity bet. El NA Patron Nicasio Medina 3 Colores (Sinking) Fraile and 13 Jul 72 15 Nov 72 None None be reprimanded for 15 Nov 72 Corregidor overloading his vessel BMI-06-72 Enroute from NA Ship’s personnel be 2 M/V Panay (Death on Iloilo to Manila 14 May 72 12 Sep 72 1 None cleared of his incident 12 Sep 72 Board and case closed 1 M/S Dona BMI-05-72 Enroute from 19 May 72 11 Jul 72 Capt. Dominador Florentina (Death on Bacolod to 1 NA Hortillosa & his officers 11 Jul 72 Board) Manila absolved from any responsibility

38

NHEA VICTORIA M SULIT LT PCG Admin Officer, BMI

39