The Salem Witch Trials [Type Text] Elise Forte the Many Faces of The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Salem Witch Trials [Type text] Elise Forte The Many Faces of the Salem Witchcraft Trials of 1692 By: Elise Forte Dr. Sheila O’Hare LI861 Current Issues in Information Transfer Salem Witch Trials [Type text] Forte 2 Introduction The Salem Witch Trials of 1692 are cause for great speculation and mystery. It appears to have occurred suddenly, causing mass hysteria not just locally but regionally as well. After the executions of 20 individuals, the accusations and convictions ended and life, for all intents and purposes, continued on. The Salem Witch Trials are of historical significance for nothing like it has happened in early American history, in that extreme, before. “It lasted longer, jailed more suspects, condemned and executed more people, ranged over more territory, and afterwards was quickly repudiated by the government as a colossal mistake” (Ray, 2010). The 16th and 17th centuries acknowledged the existence of witches and witchcraft, but few executions ever happened, and nothing to the extreme of Salem. Europe was an ocean away and the trials and tribulations experienced on the continent had no meaning for those who lived in pre-Colonial America. The closest event that has happened that is similar to the panic and fear similar to the Salem Witch Trials is the era of McCarthy and Communism. Many scholars have taken an in- depth look at the who, why, and how of the incidents that transpired in 1692. The Salem Witch Trials were so intense for a short duration of time that the incidents has even entered the world of pop culture with Arthur Miller’s award-winning play The Crucible, and inspiring movies such as the 1958 film Bell, Book, and Candle and 1992’s Hocus Pocus. The following paper will look at a few more modern theories that have tried to decipher and make sense of the Salem Witch Trials. The different fields of study that have been used to decipher the mystery include economics, geography, sociology, and psychology. Paul Boyer and Stephen Nissenbaum, Mary Beth Norton, and Jamies West Davidson and Mark Hamilton Lytle are included to explain not just what happened in Salem, Massachusetts 300 years ago, but why. First the paper will begin with a synopsis of the events of 1692 followed by a brief commentary of how the Salem Witch Trials have been studied in the past. The paper will then conclude with how the Salem Trials are currently being viewed and studied. In 1692 the Reverend Parris came to Salem Village to be pastor of the new church established by the local village people. These people were far removed from the more populated, bigger, and more established Salem Town. Many were complaining that it was too far to travel for church every Sunday, and Salem Village was becoming big enough to support their own pastor and congregation. After three former, and unsuccessful, pastors, Reverend Samuel Parris accepted the position. In the winter of 1691-1692, several local girls and young women had met to divine what kind of husbands they would each marry. In the middle of the proceedings one of the girls claims to have seen a figure in the shape like a coffin. Parris’s daughter and niece, 8/9 year old Betty Parris and 11 year old Abigail Williams, came down with a mysterious illness. The two girls were saying that they were being “bitten and pinched by invisible agents…” (Davidson, Lytle, 2010). Soon after, other local girls and young women were claiming that they, too, were Salem Witch Trials [Type text] Forte 3 suffering from the same afflictions. After bringing in several other doctors and ministers, Reverend Parris was convinced that the girls suffered from witchcraft. It would soon turn out that the “invisible agents” torturing the young women were all too visible. A local woman, Mary Sibley, with the best of intentions, decided to have Parris’ two slaves, John and Tituba Indian, bake a witch cake to determine whether the girls were really being bewitched. A cake was fed to a dog, containing the girl’s urine and rye meal, and if the dog suffered the same afflictions as the girls, dark magic was indeed at work. (It was thought that when a witch was tormenting someone, part of her essence was passed to the abused and stayed with them, hence the urine from the afflicted girls. Also, some interpretations say that a witch cake will bring out a name of the witch doing the tormenting). The witch cake did not work, as the girls symptoms got worse. The girls were claiming that spectral images of certain individuals were tormenting them and, pressured by the adults, the girls named three local women. These local women just happened to be local outcasts, not well liked by the majority of the villagers. In February formal charges were drawn up and arrests were made. Parris’ slave Tituba was charged and admitted to being a witch. Here is where the Salem episode takes a dramatic turn. Not only did Tituba confess to being a witch, she claimed that five other individuals, one of them a man, were in league with the devil. Tituba’s confession laid the groundwork for not only how the trial was to proceed in upcoming months, but the drama that was to unfold from both accusers and accused. One of the things that previously did not happen in witchcraft trials was that the accused were questioned separate from the accusers. After several more afflictions and other individuals were named, a court was established in June to deal exclusively with the accusations and trials. This court was the Court of Oyer and Terminer, which features prominently in several of the articles. The pressure was great to confess, for your life would be spared and you would be forgiven. However, those that confessed were expected to name others who had dealings with the devil and present details of their crimes. The list of those being accused of witchcraft grew and by September of 1692 eight more people were hanged. During the summer pressure had been building to stop the trials. The accusations had grown beyond Salem Village and things were getting out of hand. Several ministers had been cautioning magistrates to put things to an end and in October Increase Mather, a respected preacher in the colony, published a sermon condemning spectral evidence, and it was signed by fourteen other pastors. The sermon was enough evidence to convince the governor that things had gone too far, and he forbade any more arrests and dismissed the court that was established the previous summer. The following January a new court met and released the remaining 100 people who were arrested and in jail. Ten months and 20 executions later, the accusations ended and life resumed. The sudden end to what some have called an epidemic continues to baffle historians. Few witchcraft crises in the late 17th century ever reached the courts, and the ones that did were Salem Witch Trials [Type text] Forte 4 dealt with quickly. What made Salem so different? Several historians have taken different avenues to interpret not only what happened in Salem, but why. Tituba and Ethnohistory Several papers have been written trying to explain what happened over 300 years ago. Most of them focus on religious, economic, and geographic theories for why the Salem Witch Trials happened, when they did, and where they occurred. Even some studies have taken a gender specific approach discussing the afflicted girls and the older women who were accused. Even fewer mention the slave woman Tituba, but it is Tituba’s story and confession that sets the tone for the upcoming witch-hunt. In her paper Tituba’s Confession: The Multicultural Dimensions of the 1692 Salem Witch-Hunt Elaine G. Breslaw tries to shed some light on the looked over importance of Tituba. Her article is a great benefit to researchers or curious students who want to find out more about the Salem Witch Trials. The article takes an ethnic, post-modern approach by making Tituba and her confession the sole thesis of her paper. Tituba’s Confession lays the groundwork for the drama that would soon unfold in the village of Salem. Breslaw acknowledges that not a lot is known about Tituba, but “part of her credibility to her Salem audience was enhanced by her identification as an American Indian whose culture had long been associated with demonic power” (Breslaw, 1997). Despite the lack of information of Tituba’s background, Breslaw makes a compelling case that Tituba “*blended+ elements from English, African, and American Indian notions of the occult” (Breslaw, 1997). She postulates that Tituba’s confession “was not merely the frightened response of a slave woman but a sophisticated manipulation of her interrogators’ deepest fears” (Breslaw, 1997). In other words, Tituba took her knowledge of what she knew of the Puritans concept of evil, and told the magistrates what they wanted to hear, in the way they wanted to hear it. Breslaw’s sources for her article were the court records that have survived as well as Tituba’s confession found in the Salem Witch Papers, currently apart of the Essex archives. Religion Benjamin C. Ray takes a theological approach to explain how and why the Salem Witch Trials happened. Ray is Professor of Religious Studies at the University of Virginia and is an editor of the Record of the Salem Witch-Hunt, which is a new transcription of the Salem witch trial court records. The original court records and maps were his primary sources to defend and highlight his argument. He did look at contemporary sermons and publications of Puritanism of the time period, such as Cotton Mather.