Title of Thesis

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Title of Thesis Perplexities of the Personal and the Political How Women’s Liberation Became Women’s Human Rights Valgerður Pálmadóttir Department of Historical, Philosophical and Religious Studies Umeå 2018 This work is protected by the Swedish Copyright Legislation (Act 1960:729) Dissertation for PhD ISBN: 978-91-7601-947-4. Cover illustrations: “When the photographer arrived, these women were undermining the patriarchy” and “Everywhere she went, there was a conference” by Björg Sveinbjörnsdóttir. Composition: In house Umeå University. Electronic version available at: http://umu.diva-portal.org/ Printed by: Umeå University Printing Service Umeå, Sweden 2018 To my family Table of Contents Abstract ......................................................................................... iii Acknowledgements ......................................................................... v 1. Introduction ................................................................................ 1 Subversive Stories ...................................................................................................... 1 UN Conference on Women Provokes a Grassroots Response .................................4 New Strategies: Advocating for Women’s Human Rights at the UN .....................6 From Anger to Compassion .......................................................................................9 Aims of the Study and Research Questions ................................................................... 13 Selection of sources ........................................................................................................ 15 Dissertation Outline ...................................................................................................... 20 Methodological Perspectives .......................................................................................... 21 History of Ideas and Genealogy .............................................................................. 21 Narratives and Threads.......................................................................................... 23 Theoretical Perspectives .................................................................................................25 Conflict or Consensus ...............................................................................................25 Politics and Human Rights ..................................................................................... 28 The Janus face of Justice.......................................................................................... 31 Testimony and Politics .............................................................................................33 Testimonies, Stories and Politics ............................................................................ 36 The Narrated Self and Politics................................................................................ 38 Research Context ........................................................................................................... 39 Human Rights Critique ........................................................................................... 40 Conflicting Narratives about the ‘Second Wave’ .................................................... 47 2. Genealogies and the Search for Commonalities .......................... 53 The Russell Tribunal....................................................................................................... 53 The Virtue of the Powerless ..................................................................................... 55 Global Consciousness at the Turn of the 20th Century................................................. 60 Infrastructure: Facilitating International Activism and Lobbyism ..................... 61 Universalism and the Search for Common Denominators .................................. 64 White Slavery and Storytelling .............................................................................. 66 The Human Rights Turn: A Common Language ........................................................... 73 3. The Brussels Tribunal: “The Start of a Radical Decolonization of Women” ....................................................................................... 81 Ideas and Organization ................................................................................................. 82 Global Speak-Out .................................................................................................... 86 Women’s Liberation as de-Colonization ................................................................ 89 Testimonies and Authenticity .................................................................................. 91 Discussing Power .................................................................................................... 93 Controversies over Method ......................................................................................95 Notions of the Political and the Personal at the Brussels Tribunal ............................. 99 Transcending Politics .............................................................................................. 99 Political Awakening and Empowerment .............................................................. 101 i Politics as Structural Violence ............................................................................... 103 From Self-Blame to Anger ..................................................................................... 105 The ‘Personal’ as Private and Authentic ............................................................... 107 Mexico – “Where Governments spoke, not Individuals” .....................................108 4. Women’s Liberation Theoretically Contextualized .................... 111 Feminist Politics and the Private-Public Distinction ................................................... 111 Politics and Therapy ..................................................................................................... 113 Thinking about Feminist Politics with Arendt ............................................................ 118 5. The Vienna Tribunal: “They have the Power to be heard” ..........122 Demanding Accountability from the International Community ................................ 122 Background: Leadership and Strategizing in New Brunswick .......................... 124 Translating Feminism into a Human Rights Language ..................................... 125 Raising Public Awareness ..................................................................................... 127 The Vienna Tribunal on Women’s Human Rights ............................................... 131 The Double-edge of Right(s) Strategies ....................................................................... 133 6. The Human Rights Turn of Global Feminism Theoretically Contextualized .............................................................................136 Literature, Empathy and Human Rights Consciousness ............................................ 136 Gaining a Voice in Something Larger: Memoirs from an Activist ........................... 138 A Coming of Age Story ........................................................................................... 139 “Remold Feminism and Make it More Viable” ..................................................... 140 Bunch’s Ideas on Women’s Abuse, Human Rights and Politics ........................... 142 MacKinnon and the Question of Humanity ................................................................ 144 Compassion and Poetic Justice .................................................................................... 146 Women’s Human Rights and the United Nations ....................................................... 151 7. Consciousness raising Theoretically Contextualized .................. 154 People’s Tribunals as Consciousness-raising practices............................................... 154 Conflicts Concerning the ‘Politics of the Self’ .............................................................. 156 Gender: An Ideological Consent ............................................................................ 161 Gender: The Objectifying Look.............................................................................. 162 Consciousness raising as a Search for Identity .................................................... 164 Against Theory .............................................................................................................. 166 The Pro-Woman Line – Women are not Brainwashed ....................................... 167 8. Concluding Discussion ............................................................. 171 Politics of People’s Tribunals: “We are Not Judges, We are Witnesses” .....................171 Contexts: A change of Scene demands a Change of Script .................................. 173 Witnesses and Political Subjects .................................................................................. 175 Crisis in the Relationship between Theory and Practice? ................................... 177 Feminist Success Stories and the Risk of Co-optation ......................................... 181 Was Feminism Hijacked? ...................................................................................... 185 The Affective Power of the Personal Story ........................................................... 187 Enkel sammanfattning på svenska .............................................. 190 References ...................................................................................193
Recommended publications
  • 1 GOV 1029 Feminist Political Thought TIMES to BE CONFIRMED
    GOV 1029 Feminist Political Thought TIMES TO BE CONFIRMED: provisionally, Tuesday 1:30-2:45, Thursday TBC Fall Semester 2020 Professor Katrina Forrester Office Hours: TBC E-mail: [email protected] Teaching Fellows: Celia Eckert, Soren Dudley, Kierstan Carter, Eve O’Connor Course Description: What is feminism? What is patriarchy? What and who is a woman? How does gender relate to sexuality, and to class and race? Should housework be waged, should sex be for sale, and should feminists trust the state? This course is an introduction to feminist political thought since the mid-twentieth century. It introduces students to classic texts of late twentieth-century feminism, explores the key arguments that have preoccupied radical, socialist, liberal, Black, postcolonial and queer feminists, examines how these arguments have changed over time, and asks how debates about equality, work, and identity matter today. We will proceed chronologically, reading texts mostly written during feminism’s so-called ‘second wave’, by a range of influential thinkers including Simone de Beauvoir, Shulamith Firestone, bell hooks and Catharine MacKinnon. We will examine how feminists theorized patriarchy, capitalism, labor, property and the state; the relationship of claims of sex, gender, race, and class; the development of contemporary ideas about sexuality, identity, and gender; and how and whether these ideas change how fundamental problems in political theory are understood. 1 Course Requirements: Undergraduate students: 1. Participation (25%): a. Class Participation (15%) Class Participation is an essential part of making a section work. Participation means more than just attendance. You are expected to come to each class ready to discuss the assigned material.
    [Show full text]
  • Remarks by Redstockings Speaker Marisa Figueiredo Shulamith Firestone Memorial September 23, 2012
    Remarks by Redstockings speaker Marisa Figueiredo Shulamith Firestone Memorial September 23, 2012 In 1978, at the age of 16, while In high school, I lived in Akron, Ohio. I went to to the public library on weekends and on one shelf were three books in a row that changed my life forever and are the reason I am here today: Simone de Beauvoir's The Second Sex, Shulamith Firestone's The Dialectic of Sex The Case for Feminist Revolution, and Redstockings' Feminist Revolution. With my consciousness raised to the point of passionately identifying myself as a radical feminist in the tradition each book represented, I ardently wanted to connect with Shulamith Firestone and Redstockings , so I wrote to both. I heard back from Redstockings, not Shulamith, and since 1984, I have been active in Redstockings. On May Day in 1986, Redstockings organized a Memorial for Simone de Beauvoir and I felt deeply honored when asked by Kathie Sarachild to read Shulamith's Firestone's tribute she had sent to the Memorial. It was several sentences in Shulamith's beautiful handwriting saying that Simone de Beauvoir had fired her youthful ambitions at age 16 and my heart was pounding as I read it, because Shulamith had fired my youthful ambitions at age 16, too! In the early 1990s, Kathie Sarachild introduced me to Shulamith Firestone, and I remember immediately feeling Shulamith's intensity of observation and perception of details unnoticed by others. All this despite her physical vulnerability that overwhelmed me, which I soon learned from her, resulted from side effects of her medication and a recent hospitalization.
    [Show full text]
  • The Literacy Practices of Feminist Consciousness- Raising: an Argument for Remembering and Recitation
    LEUSCHEN, KATHLEEN T., Ph.D. The Literacy Practices of Feminist Consciousness- Raising: An Argument for Remembering and Recitation. (2016) Directed by Dr. Nancy Myers. 169 pp. Protesting the 1968 Miss America Pageant in Atlantic City, NJ, second-wave feminists targeted racism, militarism, excessive consumerism, and sexism. Yet nearly fifty years after this protest, popular memory recalls these activists as bra-burners— employing a widespread, derogatory image of feminist activists as trivial and laughably misguided. Contemporary academics, too, have critiqued second-wave feminism as a largely white, middle-class, and essentialist movement, dismissing second-wave practices in favor of more recent, more “progressive” waves of feminism. Following recent rhetorical scholarly investigations into public acts of remembering and forgetting, my dissertation project contests the derogatory characterizations of second-wave feminist activism. I use archival research on consciousness-raising groups to challenge the pejorative representations of these activists within academic and popular memory, and ultimately, to critique telic narratives of feminist progress. In my dissertation, I analyze a rich collection of archival documents— promotional materials, consciousness-raising guidelines, photographs, newsletters, and reflective essays—to demonstrate that consciousness-raising groups were collectives of women engaging in literacy practices—reading, writing, speaking, and listening—to make personal and political material and discursive change, between and across differences among women. As I demonstrate, consciousness-raising, the central practice of second-wave feminism across the 1960s and 1970s, developed out of a collective rhetorical theory that not only linked personal identity to political discourses, but also 1 linked the emotional to the rational in the production of knowledge.
    [Show full text]
  • The Radical Feminist Manifesto As Generic Appropriation: Gender, Genre, and Second Wave Resistance
    Southern Journal of Communication ISSN: 1041-794X (Print) 1930-3203 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/rsjc20 The radical feminist manifesto as generic appropriation: Gender, genre, and second wave resistance Kimber Charles Pearce To cite this article: Kimber Charles Pearce (1999) The radical feminist manifesto as generic appropriation: Gender, genre, and second wave resistance, Southern Journal of Communication, 64:4, 307-315, DOI: 10.1080/10417949909373145 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/10417949909373145 Published online: 01 Apr 2009. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 578 View related articles Citing articles: 4 View citing articles Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=rsjc20 The Radical Feminist Manifesto as Generic Appropriation: Gender, Genre, And Second Wave Resistance Kimber Charles Pearce n June of 1968, self-styled feminist revolutionary Valerie Solanis discovered herself at the heart of a media spectacle after she shot pop artist Andy Warhol, whom she I accused of plagiarizing her ideas. While incarcerated for the attack, she penned the "S.C.U.M. Manifesto"—"The Society for Cutting Up Men." By doing so, Solanis appropriated the traditionally masculine manifesto genre, which had evolved from sov- ereign proclamations of the 1600s into a form of radical protest of the 1960s. Feminist appropriation of the manifesto genre can be traced as far back as the 1848 Seneca Falls Woman's Rights Convention, at which suffragists Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Lucretia Coffin Mott, Martha Coffin, and Mary Ann McClintock parodied the Declara- tion of Independence with their "Declaration of Sentiments" (Campbell, 1989).
    [Show full text]
  • 13 White Woman Listen! Black Feminism and the Boundaries of Sisterhood
    13 White Woman Listen! Black Feminism and the Boundaries of Sisterhood Hazel V. Carby I'm leaving evidence. And you got to leave evidence too. And your children got to leave evidence.... They burned all the documents.... We got to burn out what they put in our minds, like you burn out a wound. Except we got to keep what we need to bear witness. That scar that's left to bear witness. We got to keep it as visible as our blood. (Jones 1975) The black women's critique of history has not only involved us in coming to terms with "absences"; we have also been outraged by the ways in which it has made us visible, when it has chosen to see us. History has constructed our sexuality and our femininity as deviating from those qualities with which white women, as the prize objects of the Western world, have been endowed. We have also been defined in less than human terms (Jordon 1969). Our continuing struggle with History began with its "discovery" of us. However, this chapter will be concerned with herstory rather than history. We wish to address questions to the feminist theories that have been developed during the last decade; a decade in which black women have been fighting, in the streets, in the schools, through the courts, inside and outside the wage relation. The significance of these struggles ought to inform the writing of the herstory of women in Britain. It is fundamental to the development of a feminist theory and practice that is meaningful for black women.
    [Show full text]
  • Carol Hanisch, June 1, 2006
    Reflections on the 1960s Women's Liberation Movement as "racist," post by Carol Hanisch, June 1, 2006 An exerpt from: Carol Hanisch, “The Personal is Political”, Attacking Women, Carnival of Feminists 17, and What the Heck Posted by Heart ⋅ June 22, 2006 ⋅ 22 Comments http://womensspace.wordpress.com/ I came across a really interesting and recent feminist forum on the subject of the political being personal entitled, Hanisch Forum on the Personal is Political held from May 26 through June 11, 2006, and described as follows: From May 26 through June 11, 2006, "The 'Second Wave' and Beyond" hosted a special forum among scholars and activists led by Carol Hanish and inspired by her article "The Personal is Political" and the new introduction published below. Please read the discussion in the archives (with comments by Carol Hanisch, Judith Ezekiel, Chude [Pam] Allen, Ariel Dougherty, [Margaret] Rivka Polatnick, Kimberly Springer, Stephanie Gilmore, and Cathy Cade). Here is an example of one of Hanisch's comments in the forum, dated June 1, 2006 (note: "WL" and "WLM" are acronyms for "Women's Liberation" and "Women's Liberation Movement"): I have to admit to being a bit flabbergasted by the direction of this discussion of "The Personal Is Political" as racist and/or excluding Black women. I have been aware of many attacks on the what is called "Second Wave Feminism" by the ensuing "Waves" (particularly in Women's Studies) as white and middle class, but I wasn't aware that it was now going after some of the cornerstone ideas of our movement.
    [Show full text]
  • Susan Faludi How Shulamith Firestone Shaped Feminism The
    AMERICAN CHRONICLES DEATH OF A REVOLUTIONARY Shulamith Firestone helped to create a new society. But she couldn’t live in it. by Susan Faludi APRIL 15, 2013 Print More Share Close Reddit Linked In Email StumbleUpon hen Shulamith Firestone’s body was found Wlate last August, in her studio apartment on the fifth floor of a tenement walkup on East Tenth Street, she had been dead for some days. She was sixty­seven, and she had battled schizophrenia for decades, surviving on public assistance. There was no food in the apartment, and one theory is that Firestone starved, though no autopsy was conducted, by preference of her Orthodox Jewish family. Such a solitary demise would have been unimaginable to anyone who knew Firestone in the late nineteen­sixties, when she was at the epicenter of the radical­feminist movement, Firestone, top left, in 1970, at the beach, surrounded by some of the same women who, a reading “The Second Sex”; center left, with month after her death, gathered in St. Mark’s Gloria Steinem, in 2000; and bottom right, Church In­the­Bowery, to pay their respects. in 1997. Best known for her writings, Firestone also launched the first major The memorial service verged on radical­ radical­feminist groups in the country, feminist revival. Women distributed flyers on which made headlines in the late nineteen­ consciousness­raising, and displayed copies of sixties and early seventies with confrontational protests and street theatre. texts published by the Redstockings, a New York group that Firestone co­founded. The WBAI radio host Fran Luck called for the Tenth Street studio to be named the Shulamith Firestone Memorial Apartment, and rented “in perpetuity” to “an older and meaningful feminist.” Kathie Sarachild, who had pioneered consciousness­raising and coined the slogan “Sisterhood Is Powerful,” in 1968, proposed convening a Shulamith Firestone Women’s Liberation Memorial Conference on What Is to Be Done.
    [Show full text]
  • GOV 1029 Feminist Political Thought
    GOV 1029 Feminist Political Thought Tuesday, Thursday 12-1.15 Fall Semester 2018 Professor Katrina Forrester Office Hours: Tuesday, Thursday 2-3 Office: CGIS K437 E-mail: [email protected] Teaching Fellow: Leah Downey E-mail: [email protected] Course Description: What is feminism? What is patriarchy? What and who is a woman? How does gender relate to sexuality, and to class and race? Should housework be waged, should sex be for sale, and should feminists trust the state? This course is an introduction to feminist political thought since the mid-twentieth century. It introduces students to classic texts of late twentieth-century feminism, explores the key arguments that have preoccupied radical, socialist, liberal, Black, postcolonial and queer feminists, examines how these arguments have changed over time, and asks how debates about equality, work, and identity matter today. We will proceed chronologically, reading texts mostly written during feminism’s so-called ‘second wave’, by a range of influential thinkers including Simone de Beauvoir, Shulamith Firestone, bell hooks and Catharine MacKinnon. We will examine how feminists theorized patriarchy, capitalism, labor, property and the state; the relationship of claims of sex, gender, race, and class; the development of contemporary ideas about sexuality, identity, and gender; and how and whether these ideas change how fundamental problems in political theory are understood. 1 Course Requirements: Participation (25%) includes (a) active participation in discussion (15%); and (b) weekly responses: each week you will send 2-3 brief questions/ comments about the reading to your TF by 5pm the day before section (10%) Paper 1 (25%) 5-6 pages due October 18 4pm.
    [Show full text]
  • Emma Domínguez-Rué Universitat De Lleida [email protected]
    TRACES OF HERSTORY: REINVENTING WOMANHOOD IN THE KATE FANSLER MYSTERY SERIES BY AMANDA CROSS Emma Domínguez-Rué Universitat de Lleida [email protected] Although the American writer and Columbia professor Carolyn Gold Heilbrun (1926-2003) is best known for her best-selling mystery novels, published under the pseudonym of Amanda Cross, she also authored remarkable pieces of non-fiction in which she asserted her long-standing commitment to feminism. Taking Heilbrun’s essays in feminism and literary criticism as a basis and her 1990 novel The Players Come Again as substantiation to my argument, this paper will illustrate the ways in which her detective novels became an instrument to reach a mass audience of female readers who might not have read her theoretical work, but who were perhaps finding it difficult to reach fulfillment as women under patriarchy. My aim is to reveal the extent to which Heilbrun’s seemingly more superficial and much more commercial novels were used a catalyst that informed her feminist principles while vindicating the need to repair women’s historical invisibility. Keywords: Amanda Cross, Carolyn Heilbrun, feminism, detective fiction, female readership “As long as women are isolated one from the other, not allowed to offer other women the most personal accounts of their lives, they will not be part of any narrative of their own” (Heilbrun 1988: 46). Although the American writer and Columbia Professor Carolyn Gold Heilbrun (1926-2003) is best known for her best-selling mystery novels, published under the pseudonym of Amanda Cross, she also authored remarkable pieces of non-fiction in which she asserted her long-standing commitment to feminism.
    [Show full text]
  • TOWARD a FEMINIST THEORY of the STATE Catharine A. Mackinnon
    TOWARD A FEMINIST THEORY OF THE STATE Catharine A. MacKinnon Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England K 644 M33 1989 ---- -- scoTT--- -- Copyright© 1989 Catharine A. MacKinnon All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America IO 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 First Harvard University Press paperback edition, 1991 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data MacKinnon, Catharine A. Toward a fe minist theory of the state I Catharine. A. MacKinnon. p. em. Bibliography: p. Includes index. ISBN o-674-89645-9 (alk. paper) (cloth) ISBN o-674-89646-7 (paper) I. Women-Legal status, laws, etc. 2. Women and socialism. I. Title. K644.M33 1989 346.0I I 34--dC20 [342.6134} 89-7540 CIP For Kent Harvey l I Contents Preface 1x I. Feminism and Marxism I I . The Problem of Marxism and Feminism 3 2. A Feminist Critique of Marx and Engels I 3 3· A Marxist Critique of Feminism 37 4· Attempts at Synthesis 6o II. Method 8 I - --t:i\Consciousness Raising �83 .r � Method and Politics - 106 -7. Sexuality 126 • III. The State I 55 -8. The Liberal State r 57 Rape: On Coercion and Consent I7 I Abortion: On Public and Private I 84 Pornography: On Morality and Politics I95 _I2. Sex Equality: Q .J:.diff�_re11c::e and Dominance 2I 5 !l ·- ····-' -� &3· · Toward Feminist Jurisprudence 237 ' Notes 25I Credits 32I Index 323 I I 'li Preface. Writing a book over an eighteen-year period becomes, eventually, much like coauthoring it with one's previous selves. The results in this case are at once a collaborative intellectual odyssey and a sustained theoretical argument.
    [Show full text]
  • “Herstory” Challenging Gender Stereotypes in Israeli Girls’ Perfect Love Stories
    “HerStory” Challenging Gender Stereotypes in Israeli Girls’ Perfect Love Stories Shiri Reznik This study explores the love stories written by 77 Israeli girls, aged 11-12 years old, in order to examine the possible influence of the media on their romantic narratives and the gender roles embedded within them. The girls were asked to write their own perfect love story and then participated in focus groups during which they explained the stories they wrote. The stories have been analyzed with the method of discourse analysis. Although many girls chose to express their imaginary romantic world by using popular media characters, plot lines and idioms, others offered a new and even revolutionary perspective on what a perfect love story can be, and especially the gender roles it can depict. Stories about female protagonists who make the first romantic move, perform sisterhood as an act of resistance, or prefer to be an assertive non-stereotypical princess, are analyzed in light of the girls’ socioeconomic backgrounds and role models. If you had to imagine the perfect love story what would it be? This study aims to find out how tween Israeli girls perceive the concept of romantic love, what are their expectations regarding gender roles in the romantic sphere, and how do they imagine an ideal love story when given the opportunity to write their own romantic narrative. Another goal of the current study is to examine the possible influence of the media on girls’ romantic perceptions and dreams, since numerous studies have found that mediated representations of love are meaningful sources of identification, social learn- ing, and internalization of romantic narratives and behaviors among children, teens and adults as well (Bachen & Illouz, 1996; Hefner & Wilson, 2013).
    [Show full text]
  • Campaign Summary
    Profile Team Name : Baguette - The French Magic Touch Campaign name anotherstory Campaign background anotherstory is a campaign that aims to open the eyes of European citizens on women's rights history and to involve them while they feel little concerned by the cause. The strategy adopted is the "wrapping technique". The principle is to embody the history of women's rights and the cause in a package that looks like what our targets want or at least that does not look like the idea they most have of feminism. This campaign meets current wishes expressed by citizens (Ipsos Trends, 2016): - The positive. Citizens are asking for positive inspirations and they increasingly reject news and subjects causing anxiety. - The personal bubble. Individuals are looking for establish a deeper relationship with themselves by learning more about the history of their family for instance. Therefore, we are convinced that to engage citizens, they need to be positively connected to women's history through their personal story. So we ask ourselves what event concerns us individually, also unifying and most of the time positive? The birthday! The birth date is the central point of the campaign where citizens will understand that since that date, the history of women's rights became their history too and consequently they have to involve themselves for this cause. A website entitled "anotherstory.eu" is at the heart of our campaign. It uses a positive and personal tonality to talk about equality between men and women and it constitutes a new opportunity to discover another story of your birth date.
    [Show full text]