Structure of the Sun

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Structure of the Sun HELIOSEISMOLOGY (I) STRUCTURE OF THE SUN ² The Sun is the only star for which we can measure internal properties ! test of stellar structure theory ² acoustic mode Composition (heavy elements) from meteorites in the Sun ² (p mode Density, internal rotation from helioseismology n=14, l -20) ² Central conditions from neutrinos HELIOSEISMOLOGY ² The Sun acts as a resonant cavity, oscillating in mil- lions of (acoustic, gravity) modes (like a bell) ! can be used to reconstruct the internal density struc- ture (like earthquakes on Earth) full-disk ² oscillation modes are excited by convective eddies Dopplergram ² periods of typical modes: 1.5 min to 20 min ² velocity amplitudes: » 0:1 m/s ² need to measure Doppler shifts in spectral lines rela- tive to their width to an accuracy of 1:106 . possible with good spectrometers and long integra- tion times (to average out noise) Results ² density structure, sound speed ² depth of outer convective zone: » 0:28 R¯ velocity (km/s) ² rotation in the core is slow (almost like a solid-body) ! the core must have been spun-down with the enve- lope (e±cient core{envelope coupling) SOLAR NEUTRINOS ² Neutrinos, generated in solar core, escape from the Sun and carry away 2 ¡ 6 % of the energy released in H-burning reactions HELIOSEISMOLOGY (II) ² they can be observed in underground experiments ! direct probe of the solar core ² neutrino-emitting reactions (in the pp chains) 1 1 2 + max + ! + + = : H H D e E 0 42 Mev 7 ¡ 7 max + ! + = : Be e Li E 0 86 Mev 8 8 + max ! + + = : B Be e E 14 0 Mev ² The Davis experiment (starting around 1970) has shown that the neutrino flux is about a factor of 3 lower than predicted ! the solar neutrino problem The Homestake experiment (Davis) ² neutrino detector: underground tank ¯lled with 600 tons of Chlorine (C2 Cl4 : dry-cleaning fluid) ² some neutrinos react with Cl 37 37 ¡ e + Cl ! Ar + e ¡ 0:81 Mev ² rate of absorption » 3 £ 10¡35 s¡1 per 37Cl atom ² every 2 months each 37Ar atom is ¯ltered out of the rotation rate (nHz) tank (expected number: 54; observed number: 17) ² caveats convection zone . di±cult experiment, only a tiny number of the neu- r/R trinos can be detected . the experiment is only sensitive to the most en- ergetic neutrinos in the 8B reaction (only minor reaction in the Sun) The Davis Neutrino Experiment Proposed Solutions to the Solar Neutrino Problem ² dozens of solutions have been proposed Model Predictions 1) Astrophysical solutions . require a reduction in central temperature of about 5 % (standard model: 15:6 £ 106 K) . can be achieved if the solar core is mixed (due to convection, rotational mixing, etc.) . if there are no nuclear reactions in the centre (in- ert core: e.g. central black hole, iron core, degen- erate core) . if there are additional energy transport mecha- Homestake Mine nisms (e.g. by WIMPS = weakly interacting par- (with Cl tank) ticles) . most of these astrophysical solutions also change the density structure in the Sun ! can now be ruled out by helioseismology 2) Nuclear physics . errors in nuclear cross sections (cross sections sometimes need to be revised by factors up to » 100) . improved experiments have con¯rmed the nuclear cross sections for the key nuclear reactions Results 3) Particle physics Solar Neutrinos . all neutrinos generated in the Sun are electron neu- 12 10 trinos 1011 Solar Neutrino Spectrum pp Bahcall-Pinsonneault SSM 1010 . if neutrinos have a small mass (actually mass dif- 7Be 109 13 ferences), neutrinos may change type on their path N 108 /s/MeV) 15 between the centre of the Sun and Earth: 2 O 107 pep 17 neutrino oscillations, i.e. change from electron 106 F /s or /cm 2 5 7 ¡ neutrino to or neutrinos, and then cannot be 10 Be 8B 104 detected by the Davis experiment Flux (/cm 103 . vacuum oscillations: occur in vacuum hep 102 1 . 10 matter oscillations (MSW [Mikheyev-Smirnov-- 0.1 1.0 10.0 Neutrino Energy (MeV) Wolfenstein] e®ect): occur only in matter (i.e. as neutrinos pass through the Sun) 100 SNU RECENT EXPERIMENTS << Experiments >> SAGE GALLEX Combined ² resolution of the neutrino puzzle requires more sensi- << SSM >> SSM Bahcall-Pinsonneault SSM tive detectors that can also detect neutrinos from the Turck-Chieze-Lopes SSM << NonSSM >> main pp-reaction S17 = Kam 18 TC = Kam 18 TC = Kam (S17 = 1.3) S34 = Kam 1) The Kamiokande experiment Dar-Shaviv Model Low Opacity (-20%) Large S11 (Kam = 0.39) (also super-Kamiokande) Large S11 (Kam = 0.57) Mixing Model (Kam = 0.44) Mixing Model (Kam = 0.53) MSW (Kam+Cl) I . uses 3000 tons of ultra-pure water (680 tons active 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 medium) for Gallium Rate (SNU) ¡ ¡ + e ! + e (inelastic scattering) . about six times more likely for e than and ¡ . observed flux: half the predicted flux (energy de- pendence of neutrino interactions?) The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory 2) The Gallium experiments (GALLEX, SAGE) . uses Gallium to measure low-energy pp neutrinos 1000 tons of heavy water directly 71 71 ¡ e + Ga ! Ge + e ¡ 0:23 Mev . results: about 80 § 10 SNU vs. predicted 132 § 7 SNU (1 SNU: 10¡36 interactions per target atom/s) 3) The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO) . located in a deep mine (2070 m underground) . 1000 tons of pure, heavy water (D2O) . in acrylic plastic vessel with 9456 light sensors/photo- multiplier tubes . detect Cerenkov radiation of electrons and pho- tons from weak interactions and neutrino-electron scattering . results (June 2001): con¯rmation of neutrino os- cillations (MSW e®ect)?.
Recommended publications
  • Structure and Energy Transport of the Solar Convection Zone A
    Structure and Energy Transport of the Solar Convection Zone A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE DIVISION OF THE UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI'I IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN ASTRONOMY December 2004 By James D. Armstrong Dissertation Committee: Jeffery R. Kuhn, Chairperson Joshua E. Barnes Rolf-Peter Kudritzki Jing Li Haosheng Lin Michelle Teng © Copyright December 2004 by James Armstrong All Rights Reserved iii Acknowledgements The Ph.D. process is not a path that is taken alone. I greatly appreciate the support of my committee. In particular, Jeff Kuhn has been a friend as well as a mentor during this time. The author would also like to thank Frank Moss of the University of Missouri St. Louis. His advice has been quite helpful in making difficult decisions. Mark Rast, Haosheng Lin, and others at the HAO have assisted in obtaining data for this work. Jesper Schou provided the helioseismic rotation data. Jorgen Christiensen-Salsgaard provided the solar model. This work has been supported by NASA and the SOHOjMDI project (grant number NAG5-3077). Finally, the author would like to thank Makani for many interesting discussions. iv Abstract The solar irradiance cycle has been observed for over 30 years. This cycle has been shown to correlate with the solar magnetic cycle. Understanding the solar irradiance cycle can have broad impact on our society. The measured change in solar irradiance over the solar cycle, on order of0.1%is small, but a decrease of this size, ifmaintained over several solar cycles, would be sufficient to cause a global ice age on the earth.
    [Show full text]
  • Solar Radiation
    5 Solar Radiation In this chapter we discuss the aspects of solar radiation, which are important for solar en- ergy. After defining the most important radiometric properties in Section 5.2, we discuss blackbody radiation in Section 5.3 and the wave-particle duality in Section 5.4. Equipped with these instruments, we than investigate the different solar spectra in Section 5.5. How- ever, prior to these discussions we give a short introduction about the Sun. 5.1 The Sun The Sun is the central star of our solar system. It consists mainly of hydrogen and helium. Some basic facts are summarised in Table 5.1 and its structure is sketched in Fig. 5.1. The mass of the Sun is so large that it contributes 99.68% of the total mass of the solar system. In the center of the Sun the pressure-temperature conditions are such that nuclear fusion can Table 5.1: Some facts on the Sun Mean distance from the Earth 149 600 000 km (the astronomic unit, AU) Diameter 1392000km(109 × that of the Earth) Volume 1300000 × that of the Earth Mass 1.993 ×10 27 kg (332 000 times that of the Earth) Density(atitscenter) >10 5 kg m −3 (over 100 times that of water) Pressure (at its center) over 1 billion atmospheres Temperature (at its center) about 15 000 000 K Temperature (at the surface) 6 000 K Energy radiation 3.8 ×10 26 W TheEarthreceives 1.7 ×10 18 W 35 36 Solar Energy Internal structure: core Subsurface ows radiative zone convection zone Photosphere Sun spots Prominence Flare Coronal hole Chromosphere Corona Figure 5.1: The layer structure of the Sun (adapted from a figure obtained from NASA [ 28 ]).
    [Show full text]
  • The Sun and the Solar Corona
    SPACE PHYSICS ADVANCED STUDY OPTION HANDOUT The sun and the solar corona Introduction The Sun of our solar system is a typical star of intermediate size and luminosity. Its radius is about 696000 km, and it rotates with a period that increases with latitude from 25 days at the equator to 36 days at poles. For practical reasons, the period is often taken to be 27 days. Its mass is about 2 x 1030 kg, consisting mainly of hydrogen (90%) and helium (10%). The Sun emits radio waves, X-rays, and energetic particles in addition to visible light. The total energy output, solar constant, is about 3.8 x 1033 ergs/sec. For further details (and more accurate figures), see the table below. THE SOLAR INTERIOR VISIBLE SURFACE OF SUN: PHOTOSPHERE CORE: THERMONUCLEAR ENGINE RADIATIVE ZONE CONVECTIVE ZONE SCHEMATIC CONVECTION CELLS Figure 1: Schematic representation of the regions in the interior of the Sun. Physical characteristics Photospheric composition Property Value Element % mass % number Diameter 1,392,530 km Hydrogen 73.46 92.1 Radius 696,265 km Helium 24.85 7.8 Volume 1.41 x 1018 m3 Oxygen 0.77 Mass 1.9891 x 1030 kg Carbon 0.29 Solar radiation (entire Sun) 3.83 x 1023 kW Iron 0.16 Solar radiation per unit area 6.29 x 104 kW m-2 Neon 0.12 0.1 on the photosphere Solar radiation at the top of 1,368 W m-2 Nitrogen 0.09 the Earth's atmosphere Mean distance from Earth 149.60 x 106 km Silicon 0.07 Mean distance from Earth (in 214.86 Magnesium 0.05 units of solar radii) In the interior of the Sun, at the centre, nuclear reactions provide the Sun's energy.
    [Show full text]
  • The Solar Core As Never Seen Before
    The solar core as never seen before A. Eff-Darwich1;2, S.G. Korzennik3 1 Instituto de Astrof´ısicade Canarias (IAC), E-38200 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain 2 Dept. de Edafolog´ıay Geolog´ıa,Universidad de La Laguna (ULL), E-38206 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain 3 Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden St. Cambridge, MA,02138, USA E-mail: [email protected], [email protected] Abstract. One of the main drawbacks in the analysis of the dynamics of the solar core comes from the lack of consistent data sets that cover the low and intermediate degree range (` = 1; 200). It is usually necessary to merge data obtained from different instruments and/or fitting methodologies and hence one introduces undesired systematic errors. In contrast, we present the results of analyzing MDI rotational splittings derived by a single fitting methodology applied to 4608-, 2304-, etc..., down to 182-day long time series. The direct comparison of these data sets and the analysis of the numerical inversion results have allowed us to constrain the dynamics of the solar core and to establish the accuracy of these data as a function of the length of the time-series. 1. Introduction Ground-based helioseismic observations, e.g., GONG [5], and space-based ones, e.g., MDI [10] or GOLF [4], have allowed us to derive a good description of the dynamics of the solar interior [12], [2], [6]. Such helioseismic inferences have confirmed that the differential rotation observed at the surface persists throughout the convection zone. The outer radiative zone (0:3 < r=R < 0:7) appears to rotate approximately as a solid body at an almost constant rate (≈ 430 nHz), whereas the innermost core (0:19 < r=R < 0:3) rotates slightly faster than the rest of the radiative region.
    [Show full text]
  • The Solar System
    The Solar System Our automated spacecraft have traveled to the Moon and to all the planets beyond our world The Sun appears to have been active for 4.6 billion years and has enough fuel for another 5 except Pluto; they have observed moons as large as small planets, flown by comets, and billion years or so. At the end of its life, the Sun will start to fuse helium into heavier elements sampled the solar environment. The knowledge gained from our journeys through the solar and begin to swell up, ultimately growing so large that it will swallow Earth. After a billion years system has redefined traditional Earth sciences like geology and meteorology and spawned an as a "red giant," it will suddenly collapse into a "white dwarf" -- the final end product of a star like entirely new discipline called comparative planetology. By studying the geology of planets, ours. It may take a trillion years to cool off completely. moons, asteroids, and comets, and comparing differences and similarities, we are learning more about the origin and history of these bodies and the solar system as a whole. We are also Mercury gaining insight into Earth's complex weather systems. By seeing how weather is shaped on other worlds and by investigating the Sun's activity and its influence through the solar system, Obtaining the first close-up views of Mercury was the primary objective of the Mariner 10 we can better understand climatic conditions and processes on Earth. spacecraft, launched Nov 3, 1973. After a journey of nearly 5 months, including a flyby of Venus, the spacecraft passed within 703 km (437 mi) of the solar system's innermost planet on Mar 29, The Sun 1974.
    [Show full text]
  • Stellar Evolution
    AccessScience from McGraw-Hill Education Page 1 of 19 www.accessscience.com Stellar evolution Contributed by: James B. Kaler Publication year: 2014 The large-scale, systematic, and irreversible changes over time of the structure and composition of a star. Types of stars Dozens of different types of stars populate the Milky Way Galaxy. The most common are main-sequence dwarfs like the Sun that fuse hydrogen into helium within their cores (the core of the Sun occupies about half its mass). Dwarfs run the full gamut of stellar masses, from perhaps as much as 200 solar masses (200 M,⊙) down to the minimum of 0.075 solar mass (beneath which the full proton-proton chain does not operate). They occupy the spectral sequence from class O (maximum effective temperature nearly 50,000 K or 90,000◦F, maximum luminosity 5 × 10,6 solar), through classes B, A, F, G, K, and M, to the new class L (2400 K or 3860◦F and under, typical luminosity below 10,−4 solar). Within the main sequence, they break into two broad groups, those under 1.3 solar masses (class F5), whose luminosities derive from the proton-proton chain, and higher-mass stars that are supported principally by the carbon cycle. Below the end of the main sequence (masses less than 0.075 M,⊙) lie the brown dwarfs that occupy half of class L and all of class T (the latter under 1400 K or 2060◦F). These shine both from gravitational energy and from fusion of their natural deuterium. Their low-mass limit is unknown.
    [Show full text]
  • How Stars Work: • Basic Principles of Stellar Structure • Energy Production • the H-R Diagram
    Ay 122 - Fall 2004 - Lecture 7 How Stars Work: • Basic Principles of Stellar Structure • Energy Production • The H-R Diagram (Many slides today c/o P. Armitage) The Basic Principles: • Hydrostatic equilibrium: thermal pressure vs. gravity – Basics of stellar structure • Energy conservation: dEprod / dt = L – Possible energy sources and characteristic timescales – Thermonuclear reactions • Energy transfer: from core to surface – Radiative or convective – The role of opacity The H-R Diagram: a basic framework for stellar physics and evolution – The Main Sequence and other branches – Scaling laws for stars Hydrostatic Equilibrium: Stars as Self-Regulating Systems • Energy is generated in the star's hot core, then carried outward to the cooler surface. • Inside a star, the inward force of gravity is balanced by the outward force of pressure. • The star is stabilized (i.e., nuclear reactions are kept under control) by a pressure-temperature thermostat. Self-Regulation in Stars Suppose the fusion rate increases slightly. Then, • Temperature increases. (2) Pressure increases. (3) Core expands. (4) Density and temperature decrease. (5) Fusion rate decreases. So there's a feedback mechanism which prevents the fusion rate from skyrocketing upward. We can reverse this argument as well … Now suppose that there was no source of energy in stars (e.g., no nuclear reactions) Core Collapse in a Self-Gravitating System • Suppose that there was no energy generation in the core. The pressure would still be high, so the core would be hotter than the envelope. • Energy would escape (via radiation, convection…) and so the core would shrink a bit under the gravity • That would make it even hotter, and then even more energy would escape; and so on, in a feedback loop Ë Core collapse! Unless an energy source is present to compensate for the escaping energy.
    [Show full text]
  • UNDERSTANDING SPACE WEATHER Part III: the Sun’S Domain
    UNDERSTANDING SPACE WEATHER Part III: The Sun’s Domain KEITH STRONG, NICHOLEEN VIALL, JOAN SCHMELZ, AND JULIA SABA The solar wind is a continuous, varying outflow of high-temperature plasma, traveling at hundreds of kilometers per second and stretching to over 100 au from the Sun. his paper is the third in a series of five papers Our intention is to provide a basic context so that about understanding the phenomena that cause they can produce more informative and interesting T space weather and their impacts. These papers program content with respect to space weather. are a primer for meteorological and climatological Strong et al. (2012, hereafter Part I) described the students who may be interested in the outside forces production of solar energy and its tortuous journey that directly or indirectly affect Earth’s neutral at- from the solar core to the surface. That paper dealt mosphere. The series is also designed to provide with long-term variations of the solar output. Strong background information for the many media weather et al. (2017, hereafter Part II) addressed issues related forecasters who often refer to solar-related phenom- to short-term solar variability (primarily flares and ena such as flares, coronal mass ejections (CMEs), CMEs). This paper (Part III) deals with the variations coronal holes, and geomagnetic storms. Often those in the outflow of particles from the Sun throughout the presentations are misleading or definitively wrong. solar system to its outer boundaries: the Sun’s domain (see Fig. 1). The forthcoming Part IV (“The Sun–Earth Connection”) will deal with how the variable solar AFFILIATIONS: STRONG,* VIALL, AND SABA*—NASA Goddard radiation, magnetic field, and particle outputs inter- Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Maryland; SCHMELZ—Universities act with Earth’s magnetic field and atmosphere.
    [Show full text]
  • The Sun: Our Star (Chapter 14) Based on Chapter 14
    The Sun: Our Star (Chapter 14) Based on Chapter 14 • No subsequent chapters depend on the material in this lecture • Chapters 4, 5, and 8 on “Momentum, energy, and matter”, “Light”, and “Formation of the solar system” will be useful for understanding this chapter. Goals for Learning • What is the Sun’s structure? • How does the Sun produce energy? • How does energy escape from the Sun? • What is solar activity? What Makes the Sun Shine? • Sun’s size/distance known by 1850s • Some kind of burning, chemical reaction? – Can’t provide enough energy • Gravitational potential energy from contraction? – Sun doesn’t shrink very fast, shines for 25 million years • Physicists like this idea. Geologists don’t, because rocks/fossils suggest age of 100s of millions of years E=mc2 (1905, Einstein) • Massive Sun has enough energy to shine for billions of years, geologists are happy • But how does “m” become “E”? Sun is giant ball of plasma (ionized gas) Charged particles in plasma are affected by magnetic fields Magnetic fields are very important in the Sun Sun = 300,000 ME Sun >1000 MJ Radius = 700,000 km Radius > 100 RE 3.8 x 1026 Watts Rotation: 25 days (Equator) Rotation: 30 days (Poles) Surface T = 5,800 K Core T = 15 million K 70% Hydrogen, 28% Helium, 2% heavier elements Solar Wind • Stream of charged particles blown continually outwards from Sun • Shapes the magnetospheres of the planets today • Cleared away the gas of the solar nebula 4.5 billion years ago Corona • Low density outer layer of Sun’s atmosphere • Extends several million km high • T = 1 million K (why?) • Source of solar X-ray emissions – what wavelength? X-ray image of solar corona.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 15--Our
    2396_AWL_Bennett_Ch15/pt5 6/25/03 3:40 PM Page 495 PART V STELLAR ALCHEMY 2396_AWL_Bennett_Ch15/pt5 6/25/03 3:40 PM Page 496 15 Our Star LEARNING GOALS 15.1 Why Does the Sun Shine? • Why was the Sun dimmer in the distant past? • What process creates energy in the Sun? • How do we know what is happening inside the Sun? • Why does the Sun’s size remain stable? • What is the solar neutrino problem? Is it solved ? • How did the Sun become hot enough for fusion 15.4 From Core to Corona in the first place? • How long ago did fusion generate the energy we 15.2 Plunging to the Center of the Sun: now receive as sunlight? An Imaginary Journey • How are sunspots, prominences, and flares related • What are the major layers of the Sun, from the to magnetic fields? center out? • What is surprising about the temperature of the • What do we mean by the “surface” of the Sun? chromosphere and corona, and how do we explain it? • What is the Sun made of? 15.5 Solar Weather and Climate 15.3 The Cosmic Crucible • What is the sunspot cycle? • Why does fusion occur in the Sun’s core? • What effect does solar activity have on Earth and • Why is energy produced in the Sun at such its inhabitants? a steady rate? 496 2396_AWL_Bennett_Ch15/pt5 6/25/03 3:40 PM Page 497 I say Live, Live, because of the Sun, from some type of chemical burning similar to the burning The dream, the excitable gift.
    [Show full text]
  • Fingerprints of a Local Supernova
    To appear in Space Exploration Research, Editors: J. H. Denis, P. D. Aldridge Chapter 7 (Nova Science Publishers, Inc.) ISBN: 978-1-60692-264-4 Fingerprints of a Local Supernova Oliver Manuela and Hilton Ratcliffeb a Nuclear Chemistry, University of Missouri, Rolla, MO 65401 USA b Climate and Solar Science Institute, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701 USA ABSTRACT. The results of precise analysis of elements and isotopes in meteorites, comets, the Earth, the Moon, Mars, Jupiter, the solar wind, solar flares, and the solar photosphere since 1960 reveal the fingerprints of a local supernova (SN)—undiluted by interstellar material. Heterogeneous SN debris formed the planets. The Sun formed on the neutron (n) rich SN core. The ground-state masses of nuclei reveal repulsive n-n interactions that can trigger axial n-emission and a series of nuclear reactions that generate solar luminosity, the solar wind, and the measured flux of solar neutrinos. The location of the Sun's high-density core shifts relative to the solar surface as gravitational forces exerted by the major planets cause the Sun to experience abrupt acceleration and deceleration, like a yoyo on a string, in its orbit about the ever-changing centre-of-mass of the solar system. Solar cycles (surface magnetic activity, solar eruptions, and sunspots) and major climate changes arise from changes in the depth of the energetic SN core remnant in the interior of the Sun. Keywords: supernovae; stellar systems; supernova debris; supernova remnants; origin, formation, abundances of elements; planetary
    [Show full text]
  • The Sun: Its Structure and Energy Generation
    Sun, Stars and Planets J C Pickering 2014 Part 1: The Sun: its structure and energy generation Lecture 1. Basic properties of the Sun – an introduction 1.1 Setting the scene… 1.2 Definition of a star 1.3 Properties of the Sun 1.4 How are these properties quantified? 1.1 Setting the scene Earth- Sun distance = 1 AU (Astronomical Unit), or 8 minutes for light to reach us Distances: (in light years) Nearest star Proxima Centauri 4.2 Sirius 8.6 Orion Nebula 1500 Galactic Centre 28,000 Galactic Diameter 100,000 Andromeda galaxy 2,300,000 (biggest galaxy in our Local Group of 30 galaxies 6 million lys across) Virgo Cluster 50,000,000 (2000 galaxies, nearest other galactic cluster, and centre of our Local Supercluster – diameter 100,000,000) Most Distant Observed Object ~13,000,000,000 Number of stars and galaxies… Galaxies contain anything from between 100,000 up to 3,000,000,000,000 (3 thousand billion) stars! Our Galaxy contains 100 billion stars. Number of galaxies estimated in observable Universe – 200 - 300 billion… So, it is vital we understand the physics of stars! How do we go about describing the internal structure of stars and their evolution? Evolution of stars is very slow; for a typical ordinary star like our Sun a small change in the Sun’s properties would make the Earth uninhabitable for us, but we have been on Earth for hundreds of thousands of years. Geologists believe the Earth’s crust has been solid for several thousand million years, and that the Sun’s luminosity cannot have changed significantly during this time span.
    [Show full text]