Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, Volume 4 William & Mary Law School

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, Volume 4 William & Mary Law School College of William & Mary Law School William & Mary Law School Scholarship Repository Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Law School Journals Journal 8-2015 Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, Volume 4 William & Mary Law School Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/propertyjournal Part of the International Law Commons, and the Property Law and Real Estate Commons Recommended Citation William & Mary Law School, "Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, Volume 4" (2015). Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal. 4. https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/propertyjournal/4 Copyright c 2015 by the authors. This article is brought to you by the William & Mary Law School Scholarship Repository. https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/propertyjournal ÞÎ×ÙØßÓóÕßÒÒÛÎ ÐÎÑÐÛÎÌÇ Î×ÙØÌÍ ÝÑÒÚÛÎÛÒÝÛ ÖÑËÎÒßÔ Ê±´«³» ì ß«¹«•¬ îðïë ÜÛÚ×Ò×ÒÙÌØÛ ÎÛßÝØ ÑÚ ÐÎÑÐÛÎÌÇ Ñ½¬±¾»® íðíïô îðïì ÝÑÒÚÛÎÛÒÝÛ ßËÌØÑÎÍ ÞÎ×ÙØßÓóÕßÒÒÛÎ ÐÎÑÐÛÎÌÇ Î×ÙØÌÍ ÐÎ×ÆÛ É×ÒÒÛÎÍ Ó·½¸¿»´ Óò Þ»®¹»® Ö¿³»•ÉòÛ´§ô Ö®ò η½¸¿®¼ ßò Û°•¬»·² ÐßÒÛÔ×ÍÌÍ Ü¿²¿ Þ»®´·²»® Ö¿³»• Íò Þ«®´·²¹ Ü¿ª·¼ Ôò Ý¿´´·»• ú ׿²É»•´»§óͳ·¬¸ ͬ»ª»² Öò Û¿¹´» Ö¿²»¬ Þ«•¸ Ø¿²¼§ ß ÐËÞÔ×ÝßÌ×ÑÒ ÑÚ ÌØÛ ÐÎÑÐÛÎÌÇ Î×ÙØÌÍ ÐÎÑÖÛÝÌ ÑÚ BRIGHAM-KANNER PROPERTY RIGHTS CONFERENCE JOURNAL Volume 4 2015 Cite as: 4 BRIGHAM-KANNER PROPERTY RIGHTS CONF. J. ___ (2015) A PUBLICATION OF THE PROPERTY RIGHTS PROJECT OF WILLIAM & MARY LAW SCHOOL COLLEGE OF WILLIAM & MARY POST OFFICE BOX 8795 WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA 23187-8795 The Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal [ISSN Number: 2326-7437] is published by the Property Rights Project of William & Mary Law School. Our mailing address is Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, William & Mary Law School, College of William & Mary, Post Office Box 8795, Williamsburg, Virginia 23187-8795. E-mail address: mnwyatt @wm.edu. The views expressed in the Journal are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the policies or opinions of the Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, its editors and staff, or the College of William & Mary. History of the William & Mary Law School Chartered in 1693 by Queen Mary II and King William III of England, the College of William & Mary is the second oldest insti- tution of higher learning in the United States. The Chair of Law at William & Mary was created in 1779 by the Board of Visitors at the request of Thomas Jefferson, and was the first established in the United States. The first occupant of the Chair was George Wythe, in whose offices studied Thomas Jefferson, John Marshall, James Monroe, and Henry Clay. The growth of the law school was halted by the beginning of the Civil War in 1861. Sixty years later, the study of law was revived in a modern program that attracts students from all regions of the nation. Copyright Notice The College of William & Mary retains the copyright to all issues of the Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, printed by Western Newspaper Publishing Co., Inc., Indianapolis, Indiana. Except as otherwise provided, the author of each article in this issue has granted permission for copies of that article to be made available for classroom use, provided that (1) copies are dis- tributed at or below cost, (2) the author and the Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal are identified, (3) proper notice of the copyright is affixed to each copy, and (4) the Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal is notified of the use. Subscriptions The Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal is published once a year by the Property Rights Project of William & Mary Law School. Subscriptions to the Journal are considered to be continuous and, absent receipt of notice to the contrary, will be renewed automatically each year. The subscription price is $15.00 per issue. Correspondence related to subscriptions should be addressed to: Megan Wyatt, Assistant Editor, Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Journal, William & Mary Law School, College of William & Mary, Post Office Box 8795, Williamsburg, Virginia 23187-8795. BRIGHAM-KANNER PROPERTY RIGHTS CONFERENCE JOURNAL VOLUME 4 AUGUST 2015 CONFERENCE JOURNAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE BOARD DEAN DAVISON M. DOUGLAS JOSHUA E. BAKER LYNDA L. BUTLER LYNDA L. BUTLER JOSEPH T. WALDO CHRISTI A. CASSEL JAMES W. ELY, JR. CONFERENCE ADVISORY BOARD ALAN T. ACKERMAN STEPHANIE H. AUTRY ANDREW P. BRIGHAM STEPHEN J. CLARKE MARK (THOR) HEARNE, II JEREMY P. HOPKINS JOSEPH V. SHERMAN ROBERT H. THOMAS JOURNAL STAFF Editor LYNDA L. BUTLER Assistant Editor MEGAN WYATT BRIGHAM-KANNER PROPERTY RIGHTS CONFERENCE JOURNAL VOLUME 4 AUGUST 2015 DEFINING THE REACH OF PROPERTY OCTOBER 3031, 2014 PANEL 1: THE ROLE OF THE ADVOCATE IN DEFINING PROPERTY STRONG AND INFORMED ADVOCACY CAN SHAPE THE LAW: A PERSONAL JOURNEY Michael M. Berger 1 MICHAEL M. BERGERA CAREER DEVOTED TO PROPERTY RIGHTS Dana Berliner 23 MICHAEL M. BERGERA PATH TO FAIRNESS Janet Bush Handy 31 PANEL 3: BALANCING PRIVATE PROPERTY AND COMMUNITY RIGHTS NOVEL TAKINGS THEORIES: TESTING THE BOUNDARIES OF PROPERTY RIGHTS CLAIMS James S. Burling 39 ON ENGINEERING URBAN DENSIFICATION Steven J. Eagle 73 THE BUNDLING PROBLEM IN TAKINGS LAW: WHERE THE EXACTION PROCESS GOES OFF THE RAILS Richard A. Epstein 133 PANEL 4: PROPERTY RIGHTS IN DEVELOPING AND TRANSITIONAL COUNTRIES BEYOND BLACKSTONE: THE MODERN EMERGENCE OF CUSTOMARY LAW David L. Callies Ian Wesley-Smith 151 THE CONTRACT CLAUSE: ORIGINS AND EARLY DEVELOPMENT James W. Ely, Jr. 199 PANEL 3 Q&A: DISCUSSION ON BALANCING PRIVATE PROPERTY AND COMMUNITY RIGHTS Dana Berliner James S. Burling Steven J. Eagle Richard A. Epstein Gideon Kanner James E. Krier Thomas W. Merrill Marc Poirier 229 STRONG AND INFORMED ADVOCACY CAN SHAPE THE LAW: A PERSONAL JOURNEY MICHAEL M. BERGER* INTRODUCTION Without advocacy, there are no rights. Nice words on paper, perhaps, but not rights. Rights need to be enforced to be meaning- ful. As the United States Supreme Court has said repeatedly, eco- nomic advantages do not become rights until they have the law back of them and when courts preclude others from interfering with those rights.1 Enforcement of such rights is done by advocates, because courts are not self-starters. Someone has to bring cases to themlawyers. In the realm of protected rights, the rights of property owners were for many years strangely orphaned creaturespoor relations, as the Supreme Court once noted.2 Ensconced in the Bill of Rights along- side the rights to life and liberty, property rights found few defend- ers. Those who were interested in property at all seemed to come at it from the other side. The Sierra Club, for example, has been around since 1892, but its interest in property is restraining private use, not enhancing or protecting it. And dont get me started on the ACLU either. Organizations with a dedication toward protecting the rights of private property owners did not come into being until quite a bit later. The Institute for Justice, for example, was founded in 1991; the Cato Institute and the Washington Legal Foundation were both estab- lished in 1977; the Pacific Legal Foundation came into being in 1973. And I graduated from law school in 1967. Thus, while it is not unusual today for us to see one or more of those recently formed organizations filing suit to protect the rights of private property owners, that occurrence is a current phenomenon. * Partner and co-Chair of the Appellate Practice Group, Manatt, Phelps & Phillips (Los Angeles office). 1. E.g., Kaiser Aetna v. United States, 444 U.S. 164, 178 (1979) (quoting with approval United States v. Willow River Power Co., 324 U.S. 499, 502 (1945)). 2. Dolan v. City of Tigard, 512 U.S. 374 (1994). 1 2 PROPERTY RIGHTS CONFERENCE JOURNAL [Vol. 4:001 In 1967, there was just me and the small firm I practiced law with and a few other hardy individuals, including some academics who were prior honorees at this conference. Specialized practice helps. It allows lawyers to become familiar with the ins and outs and complications of a particular field. Tak- ings has always been a complicated area of the law and a difficult one to fathom. As Justice Stevens once put it, even the wisest of lawyers would have to acknowledge great uncertainty about the scope of this Courts takings jurisprudence.3 When seeking to push and shape the contours of the law, it be- hooves one to actually have a firm grasp on the field. I have repeatedly urged that friends dont let friends file takings claims. I was not kid- ding. My concern is that too many lawyers tend to view a takings claim as simply some sort of catchall to add as a tag line at the end of a multicount complaint (which may or may not have a valid claim at its core ab initio). Bad idea. It leads to cases in which lawyers make all sorts of wild claims, irritating judges (who may, in any event, be hear- ing their first takings cases4) and making bad law by continuing to make judges think that takings law is not a legitimate subject. Claims like these: that a phone call made by a police officer during an arrest was a taking;5 that forcing exotic dancers to stay four feet away from customers was a taking of the bar owners interest in the four- foot circle of property surrounding each dancer;6 that precluding a murderer from collecting on a life insurance policy on his victim was 3. Nollan v. California Coastal Commn., 483 U.S. 825, 866 (1987) (Stevens, J., dissenting). That was actually putting it mildly. Professor Van Alstyne described takings law as a mass of obtuse decisional law. Arvo Van Alstyne, Modernizing Inverse Condemnation: A Legislative Prospectus, 8 SANTA CLARA L.
Recommended publications
  • Stone Wall Oct 11
    BRCWRT — Vol. XVIII, Issue 7, OCTOBER 2011 Page 1 The Newsletter of the Bull Run Civil War Round Table — Vol. XVIII, Issue 7, OCTOBER 2011 JIM MORGAN SPEAKS ON THE BATTLE OF BALL’S BLUFF MEMBERSHIP MEETING By Mark Trbovich THURSDAY, OCTOBER 13, 2011 7:00 P.M. Centreville Library GUEST SPEAKER: James A. Morgan, III TOPIC: Battle of Ball’s Bluff among others. His accounts of Ball’s Bluff appear on the Northern Virginia Regional Park Authority Web site (nvrpa.org) and the Journey Through Hallowed Ground Retreat of the Federalists after the fight at Ball’s Web site (hallowedground.org). Jim is currently re- Bluff, upper Potomac, Virginia searching the biography of Union Brig. Gen. Charles P. (Library of Congress) Stone. Jim holds a master's degree in political science We are so honored to have historian James A. from the University of West Florida and a master's in Morgan III, to discuss the Battle of Ball’s Bluff at our library science from Florida State University. He works Thursday, October 13, meeting. October marks the ses- as the acquisitions librarian for the State Department's quicentennial anniversary of that battle. Jim will also be Office of International Information Programs in Washing- one of the tour guides for our October 29th Ball’s Bluff ton, D.C. battlefield tour. You won't want to miss Jim's lecture and tour on Jim hails from New Orleans, LA, and was raised this hallowed ground in Leesburg. Meet Jim for dinner at in north Florida. He currently lives in Lovettsville, VA, in 5:00 p.m.
    [Show full text]
  • 96> ? SOLDIER in the SOUTHWEST: the CAREER of GENERAL AV
    Soldier in the Southwest: the career of General A. V. Kautz, 1869-1886 Item Type text; Dissertation-Reproduction (electronic) Authors Wallace, Andrew Publisher The University of Arizona. Rights Copyright © is held by the author. Digital access to this material is made possible by the University Libraries, University of Arizona. Further transmission, reproduction or presentation (such as public display or performance) of protected items is prohibited except with permission of the author. Download date 11/10/2021 12:35:25 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10150/552260 7?/ /96> ? zyz /, / {LOjO. >2y SOLDIER IN THE SOUTHWEST: THE CAREER OF GENERAL A. V. KAUTZ, 1869-1886 by ANDREW WALLACE Volume I A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY In The Graduate College THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA 1968 THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA GRADUATE COLLEGE I hereby recommend that this dissertation prepared under my direction by Andrew W h-U r c p __________________________________ entitled _________ Soldier in the Southwest:______________ The Career of General A. V. Kautz, 1869-1886 be accepted as fulfilling the dissertation requirement of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy_________________________ Dissertation Director Date After inspection of the final copy of the dissertation, the following members of the Final Examination Committee concur in its approval and recommend its acceptance:* This approval and acceptance is contingent on the candidate's adequate performance and defense of this dissertation at the final oral examination. The inclusion of this sheet bound into the library copy of the dissertation is evidence of satisfactory performance at the final examination.
    [Show full text]
  • The Battle of Williamsburg
    W&M ScholarWorks Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 1980 The Battle of Williamsburg Carol Kettenburg Dubbs College of William & Mary - Arts & Sciences Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/etd Part of the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Dubbs, Carol Kettenburg, "The Battle of Williamsburg" (1980). Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. Paper 1539625106. https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21220/s2-bjb5-9e76 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact scholarworks@wm.edu. THE BATTLE OF WILLIAMSBURG tf A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Department of History The College of William and Mary in Virginia In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts by Carol Ann Kettenburg 1980 APPROVAL SHEET This thesis is submitted in partial fulfillment the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Author Approved, May 1980 LudweXl H. 'John^Vn JLJJLA Mi Royer luoyne Edward' M. Riley DEDICATION To my mother and father iii TABLE OP CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ......................................... v LIST OP MAPS................................................ vi ABSTRACT................................................... vii CHAPTER I ...............................................
    [Show full text]
  • A Chronological History Oe Seattle from 1850 to 1897
    A CHRONOLOGICAL HISTORY OE SEATTLE FROM 1850 TO 1897 PREPARED IN 1900 AND 1901 BT THOMAS W. PROSCH * * * tlBLS OF COIfJI'tS mm FAOE M*E PASS Prior to 1350 1 1875 225 1850 17 1874 251 1351 22 1875 254 1852 27 1S76 259 1855 58 1877 245 1854 47 1878 251 1SSS 65 1879 256 1356 77 1830 262 1357 87 1831 270 1358 95 1882 278 1859 105 1383 295 1360 112 1884 508 1861 121 1385 520 1862 i52 1886 5S5 1865 153 1887 542 1364 147 1888 551 1365 153 1883 562 1366 168 1390 577 1867 178 1391 595 1368 186 1892 407 1369 192 1805 424 1370 193 1894 441 1871 207 1895 457 1872 214 1896 474 Apostolus Valerianus, a Greek navigator in tho service of the Viceroy of Mexico, is supposed in 1592, to have discov­ ered and sailed through the Strait of Fuca, Gulf of Georgia, and into the Pacific Ocean north of Vancouver1 s Island. He was known by the name of Juan de Fuca, and the name was subsequently given to a portion of the waters he discovered. As far as known he made no official report of his discoveries, but he told navi­ gators, and from these men has descended to us the knowledge thereof. Richard Hakluyt, in 1600, gave some account of Fuca and his voyages and discoveries. Michael Locke, in 1625, pub­ lished the following statement in England. "I met in Venice in 1596 an old Greek mariner called Juan de Fuca, but whose real name was Apostolus Valerianus, who detailed that in 1592 he sailed in a small caravel from Mexico in the service of Spain along the coast of Mexico and California, until he came to the latitude of 47 degrees, and there finding the land trended north and northeast, and also east and south east, with a broad inlet of seas between 47 and 48 degrees of latitude, he entered therein, sailing more than twenty days, and at the entrance of said strait there is on the northwest coast thereto a great headland or island, with an exceeding high pinacle or spiral rock, like a pillar thereon." Fuca also reported find­ ing various inlets and divers islands; describes the natives as dressed in skins, and as being so hostile that he was glad to get away.
    [Show full text]
  • RICHMOND National Battlefield Park Virginia
    RICHMOND National Battlefield Park Virginia by Joseph P. Cullen (cover of 1961 edition) National Park Service Historical Handbook Series No. 33 Washington, D.C. 1961 Contents a. Richmond b. The Army of the Potomac PART ONE THE PENINSULA CAMPAIGN, SUMMER 1862 c. On to Richmond d. Up the Peninsula e. Drewry's Bluff f. Seven Pines (Fair Oaks) g. Lee Takes Command h. The Seven Days Begins i. Beaver Dam Creek (Ellerson's Mill) j. Gaines' Mill k. Savage Station l. Glendale (Frayser's Farm) m. Malvern Hill n. End of Campaign o. The Years Between PART TWO THE FINAL STRUGGLE FOR RICHMOND, 1864-65 p. Lincoln's New Commander q. Cold Harbor r. Fort Harrison s. Richmond Fall's t. The Park u. Administration For additional information, visit the Web site for Richmond National Battlefield Park Historical Handbook Number Thirty-Three 1961 This publication is one of a series of handbooks describing the historical and archeological areas in the National Park System administered by the National Park Service of the United States Department of the Interior. It is printed by the Government Printing Office and may be purchased from the Superintendent of Documents, Washington 25, D.C. Price 25 cents The National Park System, of which Richmond National Battlefield Park is a unit, is dedicated to conserving the scenic, scientific, and historic heritage of the United States for the benefit and inspiration of its people. UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR Stewart L. Udall, Secretary NATIONAL PARK SERVICE Conrad L. Wirth, Director Richmond, 1858. From a contemporary sketch. THE AMERICAN CIVIL WAR was unique in many respects.
    [Show full text]
  • VOL. 1873 Fourth Annual Reunion of the Association of the Graduates of the United States Military Academy, at West Point, New Yo
    FOURTH ANNUAL REUNION OF THE OF THE UNITED STATES MILITARY ACADEMY, AT WEST SOIVT, JNEW YO(K, JUNE 1, 1873. NEW YORK: D. VAN NOSTRAND, PUBLISHER, 23 MURRAY AND 27 WARREN STREET. 1873. ANNUAL REUNION JUNE 12, 1873. MINUTES OF THE BUSINESS MEETING. WEST POINT, N. Y., June 12th, 1873. The Association met in the Chapel of the United States Military Academy, and was called to order by Judge R. P. Parrott, Class of 1824, Chairman of the Executive Committee. Prayer was offered by the Rev. C. C. Parsons, Class of 1861 (June). The roll of the Members of the Association was then called by the Secretary. ROLL OF MEMBERS. Those present are indicated by a *, and those deceased in italics. Class. Class. 1808 Sylvanus Thayer. (Dennis H. Mahan. 1824 \ *ROBERT P. PARROTT. *SIMON WILLARD. (JOHN M. FESSENDEN. James Munroe. 1815 THOMAS J. LESLIE. 1825 N. SAYRE HARRIS. CHARLES DAVIES. *WILLIAM H. C. BARTLETT. Horace Webster. *SAMUEL P. HEINTZELMAN. 1818 HARVEY BROWN. 1826 AUGUSTUS J. PLEASONTON. Hacrtman Bache. *NATHANIELX C. MACRAE. EDWIN B. BABBIT. EDWARD D. MANSFIELD. l *SILAS CASEY. HENRY BREWERTON. 1819 HENRY A. THOMPSON. ALEXANDER J. CENTER. *DANIEL TYLER. 1827 NATHANIEL J. EATON. WILLIAM H. SWIFT. Abraham Van Buren. 1820 RAWLINS LOWNDES. *ALBERT E. CHURCH. 1828 GUSTAVE S. ROUSSEAU. 1821 *SETH M. CAPRON. CRAFTS J. WRIGHT. *WILLIAM C. YOUNG. f CATH. P. BUCKINGHAM. David H. Vinton. SIDNEY BURBANK. 18 *BENJAMIN H. WRIGHT. WILLIAM HOFFMAN. DAVID HUNTER. THOMAS SWORDS. 1829 ALBEMARLE CADY. GEORGE S. GREENE. *THOMAS A. DAVIES. *HANNIBAL DAY. *CALEB C. SIBLEY. 8 GEORGE H. CROSMAN. JAMES CLARK.
    [Show full text]
  • Twenty-Second Annual Reunion of the Association of the Graduates of the United States Military Academy, at West Point, New York
    TWENTY-SECOND ANNUAL REUNION OF THE ASSOCIATION I GRADUATES OF THE UNITED STATES MILITARY ACADEMY, AT WEST POINT, NEW YORK, tJune I2t1/, 189l. SAGINAW, MICH. SEEMANN & PETERS, PRINTERS AND BINDERS, 1891. Annual Reunion, June I 2th, 89 I. MINUTES OF THE BUSINESS MEETING. WEST POINT, N. Y., JUNE 12th, 1891. The Association met in the Chapel of the United States Mili- tary Academy, at 2:30 o'clock, P. M., and was called to order by General Geo. W. Cullum, of the Executive Committee. The Chaplain of the Military Academy offered the customary prayer. The roll was then called by the Secretary. ROLL OF MEMBERS. Those present are indicated by a *, and those deceased in italic. 1808. 1820. Sylvanus Thayer. Edward G. W. Butler. Rawlins Lowndes. 1814. John AM.Tufts. Charles S. Merchant. 1821. 1815. Seth M. Capron. Simon Willard. 1822. James Monroe. WILLIAM C. YOUNG. Thomas J. Leslie. David H. Vinton. Charles Davies. Isaac R. Trimble. Benjamin H. Wright. 1818. 1823. Horace Webster. Harvey Brown. Alfred Mordecai. Hartman Bache. *GEORGE S. GREENE. Hannibal Day. 1819. George H. Crosman. Edmuned B. Alexander. Edward Mansfield. Henry Brewerton. 1824. Henry A. Thompson. Dennis Mahan. Joshua Baker. Robert P. Parrott. Daniel Tyler. John King Findlay. William H. Swift. John M. Fessenden. 4 ANNUAL REUNION, JUNE 12TH, 1891. 1825. Ward B. Burnett. Washington Seawell. James H. Simpson. N. Sayre Harris. Alfred Brush. Randolph B. Marcy. 1826. ALBERT G. EDWARDS. WILLIAM H. C. BARTLETT. 1833. Samuel P. Heintzelman. John AUGUSTUS J. PLEASANTON. G. Barnard. Edwin B. Babbit. *GEORGE W. CULLUM. Nathaniel Rufus King. C. Macrae.
    [Show full text]
  • VOL. 1871 the Association of the Graduates of the United States
    L 'X ,2tiacrntz sf 1^tit dXil 1tA OF THE UNITED STATES tILITARY ~CADEMY. ANNUAL REIUNION, JUNE 17th, 1871. [LBRARY U#SIM.A WALMRON & PAVNY. Printers, 37 Park Row, New York. ANNUAL REUNION, JUNE 17 1871 MINUTES OF THE BUSINESS MEETING. WEST POINT, N. Y., June 17, 1871. The Association met in the chapel of the United States Military Academy, and was called to order by General Thomas G. Pitcher, class of 1845, Chairman of the Executive Committee. The roll being called, the following Graduates answered to their names: Class. Class. 1815 SIMON WILLARD 1848 THOMAS D. JOHNS. CHARLES DAVIES. 1850 ZETUS B. SEARLE. 1819 EDWARD D. MANSFIELD. ALEXANDER PIPER. 1822 BENJAMIN H. WRIGHT. 1851 GEORGE L. ANDREWS. 1823 GEORGE S. GREENE 185 ALEXANDER S. WEBB. HANNIBAL DAY. A. T. A. TORBERT. AH ^ c(4DDENNIS H. M AN. E RT ALL 1824 ROBERT P. PARROTT. 1856 JOHN ICL. HILDT. JOHN M. FESSENDEN. EDWAm HOPKINS. S W,WILLIAMI H. C. BARTLETT. 1860 R.. 1826 SILAS CASEY. 1861 EMORY UPTON. 1828 ALBERT E. CHURCH. 1863 PETER S. MICHIE. ^4 (^CPRAFTS J. WRIGHT. 1864 GARRETT J. LYDECKER. 1829 THOMAS A. DAVIES. CHARLES W. RAYMOND 1830 FRANCIS VINTON JAMES C. POST. a,0~~~~~~~~~ ~JOHN P. POST. o 1831 WILLIAM CHAPMAN. JOHN P. STORY. 1832 WARD B. BURNETT. 1865 EDWARD H. TOTTEN. 1833 GEORGE W. CULLUM. WILLIAM S. STARRING. C GEORGEMORELLW. SAMUEL M. MILLS. (1835 OELMENDORF~~GEORGEW· P. SLOAN. 1835 HENRY L. KENDRICK. THO3IAS B. ARDEN. 18 RICHARD P. CHURCHILL 1866CARLES KING 1838 IRVIN MCDOWELL. CHARLES KING. 1841 ZEALOUS B. TOWER. JOHN C MALLERY. 1842 JOHN S.
    [Show full text]
  • Mahan at West Point, “Gallic Bias,” and the “Old Army”: the Subconscious of Leadership at Gettysburg
    Mahan at West Point, “Gallic Bias,” and the “Old Army”: The Subconscious of Leadership at Gettysburg Michael Phipps “In my dreams I hear again the crash of guns, the rattle of musketry, the strange, mournful mutter of the battlefield. But in the evening of my memory, always I come back to West Point.” Douglas MacArthur “…Napoleon stands unrivalled.” Dennis Hart Mahan “God and the soldier we like adore, In time of danger, not before. The danger past and all things righted, God is forgotten, the soldier slighted.” Thomas Jordan 1 Introduction What follows is not a discussion of the direct results of leadership on the Battle of Gettysburg. That subject is one of the most widely and deeply covered in all of American and world history. This paper is rather an examination of the subtle impact on the battle caused by the background of the highest-ranking leaders on the field. In a sense, it is a look at the subconscious of the leadership on the field. The Battle of Gettysburg, and with it the entire American Civil War, was in one sense, not a fight between slave and free, states’ rights and central federal, industrial and agrarian, north and south, “Johnny Reb” and “Billy Yank,” or the overdone cliché “brother against brother.” Rather, it was a fight at the highest command level between men with virtually identical backgrounds. That background consisted of four or five years attending the United States Military Academy at West Point, New York. There at least a year was spent in the classroom of Dennis Hart Mahan, Professor of Civil and Military Engineering and the Art (or Science) of War.
    [Show full text]
  • Casey's Infantry Tactics
    INFANTRY TACTICS, FOR THE INSTRUCTION, EXERCISE, AND MANŒUVRES OF THE SOLDIER, A COMPANY, LINE OF SKIRMISHERS, BATTALION, BRIGADE, OR CORPS D’ARMÉE. BY BRIG.-GEN. SILAS CASEY, U. S. ARMY. ____________________ Vol. I. SCHOOLS OF THE SOLDIER AND COMPANY. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SKIRMISHERS AND MUSIC. ____________________ NEW YORK: D. VAN NOSTRAND, 192 BROADWAY 1862. Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1862, By D. VAN NOSTRAND, In the Clerk’s Office of the District Court of the United States, for the Southern District of New York. WAR DEPARTMENT, WASHINGTON, August 11, 1862. The System of Infantry Tactics, prepared by Brigadier General SILAS CASEY, U.S.A., having been approved by the President, is adopted for the instruction of the Infantry of the Armies of the United States, whether Regular, Volunteer, or Militia, with the following modifications viz.:— First. – That portion which requires that two companies shall be permanently detached from the battalion as skirmishers, will be suspended. Second. – In Title First, Article First, the following will be substituted for paragraph 6, viz.: “A regiment is composed of ten companies, which will be habitually posted from right to left in the following order: first, sixth, fourth, ninth, third, eighth, fifth, tenth, seventh, second, according to the rank of Captains.” EDWIN M. STANTON, Secretary of War. PREFACE. 1 The following volumes of Infantry Tactics are based upon the French ordonnances of 1831 and 1845, for the manœuvres of heavy infantry and chasseurs à pied. Both of these systems have been in use in our service for some years; the former having been translated by Lieutenant-General Scott, and the latter by Lieutenant-Colonel Hardee.
    [Show full text]
  • Civil War Manuscripts
    CIVIL WAR MANUSCRIPTS CIVIL WAR MANUSCRIPTS MANUSCRIPT READING ROW '•'" -"•••-' -'- J+l. MANUSCRIPT READING ROOM CIVIL WAR MANUSCRIPTS A Guide to Collections in the Manuscript Division of the Library of Congress Compiled by John R. Sellers LIBRARY OF CONGRESS WASHINGTON 1986 Cover: Ulysses S. Grant Title page: Benjamin F. Butler, Montgomery C. Meigs, Joseph Hooker, and David D. Porter Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Library of Congress. Manuscript Division. Civil War manuscripts. Includes index. Supt. of Docs, no.: LC 42:C49 1. United States—History—Civil War, 1861-1865— Manuscripts—Catalogs. 2. United States—History— Civil War, 1861-1865—Sources—Bibliography—Catalogs. 3. Library of Congress. Manuscript Division—Catalogs. I. Sellers, John R. II. Title. Z1242.L48 1986 [E468] 016.9737 81-607105 ISBN 0-8444-0381-4 The portraits in this guide were reproduced from a photograph album in the James Wadsworth family papers, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress. The album contains nearly 200 original photographs (numbered sequentially at the top), most of which were autographed by their subjects. The photo- graphs were collected by John Hay, an author and statesman who was Lin- coln's private secretary from 1860 to 1865. For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 20402. PREFACE To Abraham Lincoln, the Civil War was essentially a people's contest over the maintenance of a government dedi- cated to the elevation of man and the right of every citizen to an unfettered start in the race of life. President Lincoln believed that most Americans understood this, for he liked to boast that while large numbers of Army and Navy officers had resigned their commissions to take up arms against the government, not one common soldier or sailor was known to have deserted his post to fight for the Confederacy.
    [Show full text]
  • Vol. Xxxvii, No. 2 November 1996
    Vol LX, #4 Michigan Regimental Round Table Newsletter—Page 1 April 2020 The MRRT celebrates its 60th year in 2020 – and now is a great time to show your support by renewing your membership! (Or become a new member!). Membership is $25 a year – or $5 for students. Checks should be made out to Treasurer Jeanie Graham (the bank does not like checks made out to the RoundTable) and can be mailed to her home at 29835 Northbrook, Farmington Hills, MI 48334-2326. Our April 27, 2020 meeting has been cancelled as stated in a previous e-mail. The Farmington Library has cancelled all meeting room reservations through the end of April 2020. We thank our scheduled April speaker; author Tobin Buhk, who was going to speak on “True Civil War Crime”. Tobin has agreed to reschedule his presentation for Monday, March 29, 2021! Please visit our website at http://www.farmlib.org/mrrt. Several websites with Civil War presentations are listed on our website. The Roundtable has voted to tour the Brandy Station battlefield and the surrounding area! The tour will be the weekend of October 3rd and 4th. Our tour guide will be Clark “Bud” Hall, leader of the 25 year effort to preserve the Brandy Station battlefield. Our trip committee is working on the details of the trip. Of course, our field trip depends on the virus situation – which we will be monitoring closely. Please contact Jeanie (248.225.7596), Linda (586.588.2712), and or Mollie (313.530.8516) to sign up or ask questions. Mollie’s e-mail is mmgalate@gmail.com.
    [Show full text]