DOCSLIB.ORG

Prediction Markets

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Prediction Markets Wolfers.fm Page 37 Monday, June 8, 2009 3:12 PM Prediction Markets: The Collective Knowledge of Market Participants Justin Wolfers Associate Professor of Business and Public Policy Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia Prediction markets provide an information-aggregation technology applicable to a variety of topics, including political and financial risk. Because of the human idiosyncrasies identified by behavioral finance, prediction markets can fail, but historical data show them to be as accurate as traditional polling methodologies and far less expensive to establish and maintain. n this discussion, I will make three substantive Sports Prediction Markets. Interestingly, I claims about prediction markets. First, if mar- sports betting markets manifest many of the charac- kets really are efficient, as the efficient market teristics expected of an efficient market, and they hypothesis asserts, then the prices that come out of now allow participants to trade stock during the any market contain valuable information. To make game on the likelihood of a particular team winning. the case for this claim, I will use data from sports For example, Figure 1 shows real-time betting dur- betting markets. Second, prediction markets can be ing Game 6 of the 2003 National League Champion- used to track political risk, which can be a key factor ship Series (NLCS). This prediction market from driving investment performance. Third, prediction Intrade pays $1 if and only if the Chicago Cubs win markets can fail, so I will conclude my discussion this particular game. At the beginning of the game, by describing why prediction markets work and it looks as if the Cubs have about a 75 percent chance what causes them to fail. of winning. In the top of the eighth inning, the Cubs go ahead of the Florida Marlins 3–0, and the chance Prediction Markets and the of the Cubs winning the game and going to the World Series reaches 95 percent. Unfortunately, in Efficient Market Hypothesis the bottom of that same inning, one of the great The efficient market hypothesis asserts that market collapses in sporting history occurred. A fan reaches prices fully reflect available information. But the out from the stands and prevents a catch by Cubs degree to which information is available determines outfielder Moises Alou. The Marlins proceed to the form in which the hypothesis reveals itself. In its score eight runs in that inning, and the market strong form, prices reflect all information; in its responds immediately to this new information. In a semi-strong form, prices reflect all publicly avail- matter of minutes, the market price declines from 95 able information; in its weak form, prices reflect cents to about 5 cents. only past data. In any one of these forms, however, The question more important than whether pre- prices can reflect, summarize, and aggregate a huge diction markets respond quickly to news, though, is amount of information, but the unfortunate impli- whether these market prices are accurate. To answer cation of the hypothesis is that excess returns are that question, I have charted data from all 21,885 unpredictable. Thus, prices can be said to follow a major league baseball games played from 1991 random walk. through 2000, and the data show that the predic- tions are quite close to the actual outcomes. For This presentation comes from the 2008 CFA Institute Annual Confer- instance, if the market says a team has a 33 percent ence held in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, on 11–14 May 2008. chance of winning, it actually wins 31 percent of the ©2009 CFA Institute cfapubs.org JUNE 2009 37 Wolfers.fm Page 38 Monday, June 8, 2009 3:12 PM CFA Institute Conference Proceedings Quarterly Figure 1. Real-Time Betting on the Chicago Cubs: 2003 NLCS, Game 6 Price ($) 1.00 Fan Spoils Alou’s Catch 0.80 Top of the 8th Inning 0.60 0.40 0.20 0 8:05 p.m. 9:00 p.m. 10:00 p.m. 11:00 p.m. Note: Time is given in central (Chicago) time. Source: Based on data from Intrade. time. When the market says a team has a 67 percent ing take, which are, again, quite accurate. Therefore, chance of winning, it wins 65 percent of the time, an analyst covering the movie industry may find and when the market says a team has a 90 percent these forecasts quite useful, which means that such chance of winning, it wins 88 percent of the time. an exchange moves us toward the realm of socially The difference is how Las Vegas makes money. But useful prediction markets. the real point is that if a person wants accurate For instance, Deutsche Bank and Goldman information on the likely outcomes of baseball Sachs briefly started a new market (now folded, games, the betting odds do an excellent job of pro- unfortunately) that they called the “economic viding that information. derivatives market.” It allowed investors to trade The same point holds true for other sports. For on the future outcomes of particular economic indi- example, based on market expectations and game outcomes for the National Football League from cators, such as retail sales and business confidence. 1984 to 2000 (i.e., for 3,791 games), a regression The economic derivatives market provided fore- analysis shows a slope of almost 1.0 (0.997 to be casts for nonfarm payrolls, initial unemployment exact). Thus, when the market says that a team is claims, retail sales, and business confidence, and likely to win and gives a margin of a prespecified based on data that Refet Gürkaynak and I gathered, number of points (the “point spread”), that team, on these forecasts were more accurate than an average average, wins by the point spread. or consensus forecast of 35 economists. Do not, however, think of these findings as mere My conclusion, therefore, is that rather than conversation topics. Rather, think of prediction averaging the forecasts of 35 economists, those same markets as a technology that can be used to aggre- economists should be put in a room and told to bet gate opinions about anything of importance. or trade against each other. Taking the market- Socially Useful Prediction Markets. Consider aggregated price from this trading would provide a the firm called the Hollywood Stock Exchange. It more efficient way of aggregating forecasts. The runs prediction markets on the opening weekend task, then, is to harness this technology to more box office take of various movies. Essentially, it challenging issues. One such issue is politics. In fact, allows people to trade, or bet, on how well each prediction markets have been used quite exten- movie will perform. Data from that market can sively to predict political risk, which is a key factor show the aggregated forecast and the actual open- driving investment performance. 38 JUNE 2009 ©2009 CFA Institute cfapubs.org Wolfers.fm Page 39 Monday, June 8, 2009 3:12 PM Prediction Markets Prediction Markets and Political therefore, represent a valuable gain in accuracy and a significant reduction in costs. Risk ■ Results from recent cycles. In the 2004 U.S. In 2003, a recall election was held to remove Califor- election cycle, investors could trade not only which nia Governor Gray Davis from office and replace candidate would become president but also who him with one of several contenders, one of whom would win the Electoral College votes of each state. was Arnold Schwarzenegger. Prediction markets Based on data from Intrade, the prediction market allowed people to trade on the question of whether price accurately predicted every state that went for Schwarzenegger would win the governorship. A George W. Bush and every state that went against contract paying $100 if Schwarzenegger won could him. For the 2004 U.S. Senate races, the Intrade price be traded on two exchanges—Intrade, which is was correct for every state but Alaska. In the 2006 based in Ireland, or the World Sports Exchange, election cycle, most knowledgeable observers and which is based in the Caribbean. Attempts to recall many Republicans did not expect the Democrats to other governors had occurred in California, but win enough seats to gain the majority in the Senate. none had been successful. Nevertheless, I set my But every single Senate race went exactly the way computer to look for arbitrage opportunities the election-eve prediction market said it would. between Intrade and the World Sports Exchange. ■ History of political prediction markets. Such Every four hours, my computer checked these two prediction markets seem like a marvelous new tech- websites and searched for potential profits. By the nology for forecasting election results, but as it turns end of the exercise, I had made no money, but I had out, betting on politics is as old as politics itself. Two learned an important research lesson. When I fol- enterprising economic historians—Rhode and lowed the chart of the two exchange prices, the bid Strumpf—have gathered data on the amount of bet- price in one market was never above the asking ting that has occurred on U.S. presidential elections price in the other, which means that the two markets from 1884 through 1928. Opinion polling did not are closely linked. The price pattern that we are so exist in any systematic or nationwide manner at the familiar with in other financial markets appears to time, but betting on elections occurred regularly on hold true for political prediction markets. the curb where the American Stock Exchange now stands. In fact, large sums of money were traded. Accuracy of Political Prediction Markets. For the 1884–1928 period, an average of $37 million These markets have a tremendous historical record.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Democratic Change Commission
    Report of the Democratic Change Commission Prepared by the DNC Office of Party Affairs and Delegate Selection as staff to the Democratic Change Commission For more information contact: Democratic National Committee 430 South Capitol Street, S.E. Washington, DC 20003 www.democrats.org Report of the Democratic Change Commission TABLE OF CONTENTS Letter of Transmittal ..................................................................................................................1 Introduction and Background ...................................................................................................3 Creation of the Democratic Change Commission DNC Authority over the Delegate Selection Process History of the Democratic Presidential Nominating Process ’72-‘08 Republican Action on their Presidential Nominating Process Commission Meeting Summaries ............................................................................................13 June 2009 Meeting October 2009 Meeting Findings and Recommendations ..............................................................................................17 Timing of the 2012 Presidential Nominating Calendar Reducing Unpledged Delegates Caucuses Appendix ....................................................................................................................................23 Democratic Change Commission Membership Roster Resolution Establishing the Democratic Change Commission Commission Rules of Procedure Public Comments Concerning Change Commission Issues Acknowledgements Report
    [Show full text]
  • Message from the Chair
    Volume 17, Number 3 www.fairfaxdemocrats.org March 2008 Hillary Clinton ran a hard fought cam- the Obama and Clinton volunteers for Message paign in Virginia, but Barack Obama has making this primary such a huge event, from the clearly inspired the voters. FCDC con- and thank you to Fairfax County’s voters gratulates both the Clinton and Obama who brought us some truly remarkable Chair Campaigns on their outstanding efforts. results today. Fairfax County’s Democrats appreciate the We have the momentum. We are living By Scott Surovell, attention you have given us and the excite- in an historic moment. Virginia is going to Chair, Fairfax County ment you have brought to our County. make history in November. We are going February 12 was an historic day for Fair- The Republicans were in hiding in Fairfax to elect a Democratic U.S. Senator, we fax Democrats. No one has seen this kind County today. They were not signing up are going to elect more Democratic Con- of Democratic energy in Fairfax County in volunteers. They were not building their gresspersons from Northern Virginia, and generations. We saw it in the FCDC elec- party. We were. Fairfax County will lead the way as Vir- tions. We saw it in the candidate rallies and Thank you to FCDC Vice Chair Sue ginia votes for a Democratic President for canvasses. We saw it at the DPVA Jefferson Langley for putting together a marvelous the first time since 1964. Jackson Day Dinner. Today, we saw what coordinated effort. Thank you to our Fairfax County Democrats: You ain’t that energy can do.
    [Show full text]
  • Washington Capital of the Union | September 2016
    Essential Civil War Curriculum | Kenneth J. Winkle, Washington Capital of the Union | September 2016 Washington Capital of the Union By Kenneth J. Winkle, University of Nebraska-Lincoln ashington, DC, was the most strategic and vulnerable city in the Union during the Civil War. Sandwiched between the Confederate state of Virginia to the W west and the border slave state of Maryland to the east, Washington sat astride the Civil War’s most critical and active military front, the Eastern Theater. The Union army used the city to mobilize and supply the Army of the Potomac, defend the eastern seaboard, and launch military thrusts toward Richmond. Believing that the loss of the Union’s capital would lead to immediate defeat, the Confederacy targeted Washington throughout the war. From the First Battle of Bull Run onward, Confederate armies repeatedly threatened Washington as part of General Robert E. Lee’s strategy of taking the war to the enemy. Lee’s advances into Maryland in 1862 and Pennsylvania in 1863 were primarily designed to threaten Washington, and in July 1864 Lieutenant General Jubal Anderson Early launched a direct attack on the city, which was repulsed. Throughout the war, the Lincoln administration took unprecedented actions to secure the capital against Confederate attack and suppress internal subversion at the hands of secessionist sympathizers. Meanwhile, the indirect impact of the war posed novel challenges as well as opportunities. The tripling of the city’s population produced a public health crisis that promoted epidemic diseases, including smallpox. Turning Washington into the central site of medical treatment for sick and wounded soldiers in the Eastern Theater, the army established more than one hundred military hospitals in the capital, innovating new approaches to medical care and hospital design.
    [Show full text]
  • FIRST GENERAL COUNSEL's REPORT 6 7 MUR5977 8 9 DATE COMPLAINT FILED: Feb
    NOV 1 i 20U 1 FEDERAL ELECTION COMMISSION 2 999 E Street^ N«W« 3 Washington, D.C. 20463 4 5 FIRST GENERAL COUNSEL'S REPORT 6 7 MUR5977 8 9 DATE COMPLAINT FILED: Feb. 25,2008 10 DATEOFNOTinCATION: Mar. 3,2008 11 DATE OF LAST RESPONSE: Mar. 24,2008 12 DATE ACTIVATED: Apr. 22,2008 13 I 14 STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS: Feb. 15,2013 15 16 COMPLAINANTS: Emcrylde Bradley 17 J. Edward Lupton 0 18 Mischele Seng 19 20 RESPONDENTS: American Leadership Project 21 Roger V. Salazar 22 23 MUR6005 24 25 DATE COMPLAINT FILED: Apr. 30,2008 26 DATE OF NOTIFICATION: May 7,2008 27 DATE OF LAST RESPONSE: Jim. 13,2008 28 DATE ACTIVATED: Jim. 24,2008 29 I 30 STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS: Feb. 15,2013 31 32 COMPLAINANT: Obama for America 33 34 RESPONDENTS: American leadership Project 35 Roger V. Salazar 36 Jason Kinney 37 MichfileDunkerly 38 JayEisenhofer 39 PaulGoldenberg 40 Monica Graham 41 Stephen P. Kennedy 42 William Titleman 43 Richard Ziman 44 Mattis Goldman 45 Paul Rivera 46 Erick Mullen MURi 5977 ind 6005 Pint Genecal Couiuel's Report 2 RELEVANT STATUTES: 2U.S.C.§431(4XA) 3 2U.S.C.f431(8XA) 4 2U.S.C.§431(9XA) 5 2U.S.C.§433 6 2U.S.CJ434 7 2U.S.C.§441a 8 2U.S.C.f441b r-H 9 UCF.R.§100.22(aHb) 00 10 11C.FJL§ 100.57 Lft 11 11C.F.R.§ 114.15 12 0) CM 13 qr 14 INTERNAL REPORTS CHECKED: Disclosure Reports «JT 15 O O 16 FEDERAL AGENCIES CHECKED: Internal Revenue Service r-J 17 18 19 L INTRODUCTION 20 21 The complaints in these matters allege that American Leadership Project ("ALP**), an 22 entity organized under Section 527 of the Internal Revenue Code, has received contributions in 23 excess of 51,000 to influence the 2008 presidential primary campaign between Senator Hillary 24 Clinton and Senator Barack Obama, an^ therefore, should have registered with the Commission 25 as a political committee and properly disclosed its activities in reports filed with the 26 Commission.
    [Show full text]
  • The District of Columbia, Which Is Holding Primaries On
    The Potomac Primary Brainroom Briefing Book Bryan S. Murphy Sr. Political Affairs Specialist Fox News Channel Table of Contents Introduction – p. 3 Virginia Primary – p. 5 Maryland Primary – p. 10 Washington, D.C. Primary – p. 14 Endnotes – p. 17 2 Introduction Republican and Democratic presidential candidates are preparing for Tuesday's first-ever regional primary, when voters in Virginia, Maryland and the District will go to the polls.1 The primaries in the District and Maryland are open only to voters registered with political parties; Virginia does not register voters by party, so both of its primaries are open to all voters.2 The trio of contests on Tuesday are expected to offer a demographic advantage to Obama because of the sizable number of African American voters in all three places.3 Black Democrats, who have supported Obama in his bid to be the first black U.S. president, are expected to factor large in the three so-called Potomac primary races, named after the river that touches all three localities. Obama is looking to the trio of races Tuesday to carry him past Clinton in their battle for the White House, while Clinton dismissed talk that her campaign was in trouble after a series of losses. 4 An Obama sweep in Maryland, Virginia and the District of Columbia, which polls show is likely, could be one of the major turning points in the '08 campaign. 5 Over the weekend, Obama secured a clean sweep in five races: Louisiana, Washington state, Nebraska, Maine and the U.S. Virgin Islands. Clinton's losses, coupled with her decision to replace her campaign manager with a longtime aide and Obama's infusion of new funds, fueled talk that the New York senator's campaign bid was falling on tough times.
    [Show full text]
  • Yes We Can. a Biography of President Barack Obama
    YES WE CAN A B I O G R A P H Y O F BARACK OBAMA Garen Thomas FEIWEL AND FRIENDS New York A FEIWEL AND FRIENDS BOOK An Imprint of Macmillan YES WE CAN. Copyright © 2008 by Garen Thomas. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. For information, address Feiwel and Friends, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Thomas, Garen Eileen. Yes we can: a biography of Barack Obama / by Garen Thomas. p. cm. ISBN-13: 978-0-312-53709-8 / ISBN-10: 0-312-53709-3 1. Obama, Barack. 2. African Americans— Biography. 3. African American legislators— Biography. 4. Legislators—United States—Biography. 5. United States. Congress. Senate— Biography. 6. Presidential candidates—United States— Biography. 7. Racially mixed people—United States—Biography. I. Title. E901.1.O23T46 2008 328.73092—dc22 [B] 2008015316 BOOK DESIGN BY AMANDA DEWEY Feiwel and Friends logo designed by Filomena Tuosto First Edition: July 2008 1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2 www.feiwelandfriends.com A C K N O W L E D G M E N T S I would like to thank my editors at Feiwel and Friends, Jean Feiwel and especially Liz Szabla, for giving me the flexibility to write this story from a perspective not often seen in children’s books. I appreciate your faith in my vision and ability to carry it out from start to finish. Martin Baldessari worked nonstop to locate and get permission for the array of images you see here.
    [Show full text]
  • Permanent Power by Arnold Hamilton As Ususal, the Pre-Legislative Ses- State District Judges Failed to Turn up Sion Rhetoric Was at Times Lofty
    $2.50 25,000 Blue Chip Readers VOL. 41, NO. 2 An Independent Journal of Commentary JANUARY 25, 2009 GOP Takes Aim At Democrats Permanent Power By Arnold Hamilton As ususal, the pre-legislative ses- state district judges failed to turn up sion rhetoric was at times lofty. significant problems with frivolous House Speaker Chris Benge prom- lawsuits or overblown jury awards. ised an agenda that “promotes ideas Even so, Benge, Coffee and GOP leg- to move our state forward.” Senate islative leaders are working to devise President Pro Tem Glenn Coffee vowed a plan that would cut contingency to “deliver a new brand of government fees for trial lawyers – Coffee suggests in Oklahoma.” possibly capping them at 25%. Henry Their carefully-crafted, broad-brush vetoed a tort reform package in 2007 blueprints, however, belied an un- that would have capped non-economic mistakable, overarching goal of the damages [pain and suffering awards] Republican leadership that now con- at $300,000. trols both the House and Senate: per- In a throwback to the anti-union, manent political power. right-to-work campaign, Republican As the 2009 session opens with law- leaders proclaim tort reform would makers facing at least a $600 million throw open Oklahoma’s doors to budget shortfall, GOP strategists are business. pursuing an age-old, zero-sum politi- So what exactly did right-to-work cal game aimed at consolidating their produce? A few new lower paying jobs control of state government by crip- – distribution and call centers come pling Democrats for generations. to mind – but not the good-paying Republicans began successfully at- manufacturing jobs that historically tacking the Democratic coalition in were held by union members.
    [Show full text]
  • Dramatic Catharsis: Barack Obama's Rhetoric of Redemption
    _________________________________________________________________________Swansea University E-Theses Dramatic Catharsis: Barack Obama’s rhetoric of redemption Marshall, Christopher Guy How to cite: _________________________________________________________________________ Marshall, Christopher Guy (2016) Dramatic Catharsis: Barack Obama’s rhetoric of redemption. Doctoral thesis, Swansea University. http://cronfa.swan.ac.uk/Record/cronfa37298 Use policy: _________________________________________________________________________ This item is brought to you by Swansea University. Any person downloading material is agreeing to abide by the terms of the repository licence: copies of full text items may be used or reproduced in any format or medium, without prior permission for personal research or study, educational or non-commercial purposes only. The copyright for any work remains with the original author unless otherwise specified. The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holder. Permission for multiple reproductions should be obtained from the original author. Authors are personally responsible for adhering to copyright and publisher restrictions when uploading content to the repository. Please link to the metadata record in the Swansea University repository, Cronfa (link given in the citation reference above.) http://www.swansea.ac.uk/library/researchsupport/ris-support/ Dramatic Catharsis: Barack Obama’s Rhetoric of Redemption Chris Marshall Submitted to Swansea University in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy SWANSEA UNIVERSITY 2017 I Summary The 2008 election of Barack Obama as America’s first African American president was popularly held to represent a fulfilment of Martin Luther King’s Dream and led to speculation about the implications of an Obama victory for a post racial America.
    [Show full text]
  • THE CANVASS: ® States and Election Reform
    THE CANVASS: ® States and Election Reform A Newsletter for Legislatures April 2008 What Should States Do About Voting Equipment? Inside This Issue After the 2000 presidential election cast massive negative attention on the use of punch-card balloting, many states bought computer voting machines, 1 Voting Equipment? technically known as direct-recording electronic (DRE) devices, to replace 3 Record Turnout punch-card and lever machines. Experts testified that touch-screen, paperless machines were the proverbial wave of the future, and in fact, the Help America 4 Supreme Court and Vote Act (HAVA) -- enacted by Congress in 2002 -- allocated $325 million for Photo ID states to upgrade to the new equipment. HAVA essentially mandated that 5 State Election Legislation states install at least one DRE in each precinct to accommodate disabled voters. 2007 Recap In 2003, researchers began to question the conversion to DREs citing serious 7 Election Chairs Meet in concerns that the machines were susceptible to fraud, manipulation or errors Aspen, CO that would cast election results into doubt. In 2004 misuse of electronic 8 Why Is Election Reform machines led to the loss of 4500 votes in one North Carolina county -- enough votes to affect the outcome of several races. Then, in Florida's 2006 election Still Important? for the 13th congressional district, there was a stunning "under vote" of at least 9 Supreme Court Upholds 18,000 DRE ballots in a race determined by a slim 369-vote margin. A "Top-Two" Primary preliminary GAO investigation into the cause of the under vote was inconclusive. However, on February 8, 2008, the GAO released its final report 11 Worth Noting to the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • CHAPTER 10 AFTER SUPER-DUPER TUESDAY Once
    CHAPTER 10 AFTER SUPER-DUPER TUESDAY Once Super-Duper Tuesday was over, it was obvious to many observ- ers that, for the remainder of February, the calendar of Democratic Party presidential caucuses and primaries was going to greatly favor U.S. Senator Barack Obama of Illinois. A pattern had been clearly established by Super-Duper Tuesday of U.S. Senator Hillary Clinton of New York winning primary elections in the most populous states with the most diverse populations, such as New York and California. Obama, on the other hand, was racking up votes and delegates in less populous states, many of which were holding caucuses rather than primaries. The calendar of caucuses and primaries in Febru- ary, after Super-Tuesday, was mainly composed of these less-populated states, many holding caucuses rather than primaries. These were precisely the kind of states in which Barack Obama had been doing well. NEBRASKA Nebraska never had figured prominently in a presidential nomination race, despite the fact that Iowa, one of the most active of the early voting states, was located just east of Nebraska across the Missouri River. Nebraska’s “first-ever” significant presidential caucuses were held in 2008 on the Saturday after Super-Duper Tuesday. As to be expected at caucuses in a relatively underpopulated state, Barack Obama tri- umphed easily. WASHINGTON STATE The state of Washington made some effort in the early 2000s to become a significant player in the presidential caucuses and primaries sweepstakes. The state scheduled an early primary in the Republican Party in 2000. Although Washington is viewed as being one of the more liberal and progressive states, Texas Governor George W.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix File 1995 Pilot Study (1995.Pn)
    Page 1 of 280 Version 01 Codebook ------------------- CODEBOOK APPENDIX FILE 1995 PILOT STUDY (1995.PN) >> 1995 LIST OF SENATORS BY STATE AL-1: Howell T. Heflin AL-2: Richard C. Shelby AR-1: Dale Bumpers AR-2: David Pryor AZ-1: John McCain AZ-2: Jon Kyl CA-1: Dianne Feinstein CA-2: Barbara Boxer CT-1: Christopher J. Dodd CT-2: Joseph I. Lieberman FL-1: Bob Graham FL-2: Connie Mack GA-1: Sam Nunn GA-2: Paul Coverdell IA-1: Charles E. Grassley IA-2: Tom Harkin IL-1: Paul Simon IL-2: Carol Mosely-Braun IN-1: Richard G. Lugar IN-2: Daniel R. Coats KS-1: Bob Dole KS-2: Nancy L. Kassebaum LA-1: J. Bennett Johnston LA-2: John B. Breaux MA-1: Edward M. Kennedy MA-2: John F. Kerry MD-1: Paul S. Sarbanes http://www.electionstudies.org/studypages/1995pilot/APPPIL95.txt 10/22/2009 Page 2 of 280 MD-2: Barbara A. Mikulski MI-1: Carl Levin MI-2: Spencer Abraham MN-1: Paul Wellstone MN-2: Rod Grams MO-1: Christopher S. Bond MO-2: John Ashcroft NC-1: Jesse Helms NC-2: D. M. Faircloth NE-1: Jim Exon NE-2: Bob Kerry NH-1: Robert Smith NH-2: Judd Gregg NJ-1: Bill Bradley NJ-2: Frank R. Lautenberg NY-1: Daniel Patrick Moynihan NY-2: Alfonse M. D'Amato OH-1: John Glenn OH-2: Mike DeWine OK-1: Hank Brown OK-2: Ben N. Campbell OR-1: Mark O. Hatfield OR-2: Bob Packwood PA-1: Arlen Specter PA-2: Rick Santorum SD-1: Larry Pressler SD-2: Thomas Daschle TN-1: Fred Thompson TN-2: Bill Frist TX-1: Phil Gramm TX-2: Kay Bailey Hutchison VA-1: John W.
    [Show full text]
  • May 29, 2008 - Issue 279
    BlackCommentator.com - Political Analysis: Dynamics of the Obama C... http://www.blackcommentator.com/279/279_obama_campaign_dynamic... May 29, 2008 - Issue 279 Home Political Analysis Dynamics of the Obama Campaign’s Historic Achievement By Dr. Martin Kilson, PhD BlackCommentator.com Editorial Board Prologue This is my seventh probe in real time of the course of Senator Barack Obama's campaign for the Democratic Party presidential nomination. In this article (which I'm writing between May 20th and May 22nd), I want appraise key attributes of the Obama campaign and how they contributed to the historic achievement of the first African-American to gain a major political party's presidential nomination. I conclude the article with a critique of the Clinton campaign's cynical and tawdry race-card maneuvers that have sought to prevent the Obama campaign's historic achievement. Now that the May 20th Kentucky and Oregon primaries have been completed (Clinton winning the former, Obama the latter) and only three primaries remain (Puerto Rico- June 1, South Dakota-Montana- June 30, it is certain that whatever the outcome of those primaries Senator Barack Obama of Illinois will gain the Democratic Party nomination in August. Interestingly enough, two days after Senator Hillary Clinton's victory by 9-percentage points in April 22nd Pennsylvania primary the Wall Street Journal columnist, Daniel Henninger, had decided that the predominate media appraisal that the Pennsylvania victory revived Clinton's chances to win the Democratic nomination was mistaken. Instead, Henninger presented an alternative and prescient prognosis—that the Democratic nomination would go to Senator Obama. Other than ensuring the Greatest Show on Earth will continue, does it 1 of 21 5/28/2008 9:30 PM BlackCommentator.com - Political Analysis: Dynamics of the Obama C..
    [Show full text]