Electrification, Heat Pumps and Thermal Energy Storage by MARK M
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TECHNICAL FEATURE ©ASHRAE www.ashrae.org. Used with permission from ASHRAE Journal at www.trane.com and www.calmac.com. This article may not be copied nor distributed in either paper or digital form without ASHRAE’s permission. For more information about ASHRAE, visit www.ashrae.org. Using Yesterday’s Waste Energy for Tomorrow’s Heating Electrification, Heat Pumps and Thermal Energy Storage BY MARK M. MACCRACKEN, P.E., LIFE MEMBER ASHRAE “Electrification” has recently become a widely accepted road map toward the goal of a low-carbon future. The concept is easily understood in the transportation sector: cars using fossil fuels as their onboard energy source can never be carbon free. However, an electric car charged by a carbon-free source can be carbon free. When applied to buildings, one method is to envision stopping the flow of fossil fuels to them and having all energy come from the carbon-free grid of the future. Some skeptics believe it is a pipe dream to have a carbon-free electric grid, but certainly you can’t have a carbon-free building if you are burning fossil fuels in them. Electrification will likely play a part in our low-carbon future, so understanding heat pumps, and thermal energy storage’s relationship to them, will be critical. After the architects have done their best to lower the Energy in Everything energy loads in buildings, many HVAC engineers, given Most engineers understand that the term “heat pump” the challenge to heat a building without fossil fuels, will is a misnomer, mainly because “heat” is a relative term. likely consider heat pumps. Whether the source is air, Ask Google the definition of “heat,” and you get “the water, “ground” or some other source, the press for elec- quality of being hot, high temperature;” but “high” trification will likely require the use of all sorts of heat compared to what? As we learned in our science classes, pumps to help decarbonize the world’s buildings. In there is thermal energy present at any temperature big buildings that means big heat pumps. Because heat above absolute zero, which is −459°F (-273°C). Using pumps are going to become critical to meeting carbon- Rankine or Kelvin as our temperature scales, absolute neutral goals, we need to clearly understand the basics. zero is 0°R or 0 K. Our natural body temperature is Mark M. MacCracken, P.E., is president of CALMAC Corp. He is a member of ASHRAE TC 6.9, Thermal Storage. 32 ASHRAE JOURNAL ashrae.org JULY 2020 TECHNICAL FEATURE FIGURE 1 Energy in everything above absolute zero. FIGURE 2 Water’s phase change (Btu). Steam Condenses (1,526) One British thermal unit (Btu) is the amount of energy that will raise the temperature of 1 lb 1,500 Vapor of water by 1°F. –1,000 Btu/lb A. B. Water Boils (526) 500 One Match Takes 144 Matches Takes 1 lb 1 lb of Water from of Water from 32°F Ice 32°F to 33°F to 32°F Water 400 Water Freezes (346) Liquid Btu/lb 300 144 Btu/lb One Match 144 Matches Ice Melts (202) 200 Typical TemperatureTypical Office to DehumidifyTemperature Solid °R 0 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 pumped from an outdoor airside evaporator to water- °F –460 32 44 72 212 side condenser; to cool the space, this is reversed, so H2O at 1 atm. energy can be pumped from the indoor waterside evap- Water goes through a major phase change, storing lots of energy, at almost exactly the orator to the outdoor condenser. The energy is pumped best temperature for human comfort conditioning. into or out of the space depending on the need. 558°R (98.6°F or 37°C), we like our buildings at 530°R Thermal Energy Storage (70°F or 21°C), we supply liquid to cool buildings at Society has stored thermal energy extensively for about 500°R, or 40°F (5°C). It’s hard to imagine “cold” thousands of years. Many HVAC systems use ice or 40°F (5°C) water as having a lot of energy in it, but at chilled water storage to cool buildings, but is freez- 500°F (277°C) above absolute zero, it clearly does. “Cold” ing a tank of water really storing energy? The accurate and “warm” are relative. Figure 1 illustrates two types answer is actually no. It’s the reverse. To demonstrate, of energy in materials, sensible and latent. Sensible let’s go back to basics. In Figure 2a you see 1 lb (0.5 kg) of energy is the energy absorbed or released by a mate- liquid water at 32°F (0°C) and a wooden match burn- rial as it changes temperature. In the case of H2O it is ing beneath it. about 0.5 Btu/lb (1.2 J/g) in the solid phase and 1.0 Btu/lb It turns out that a wooden match, when burned com- (2.3 J/g) in the liquid phase. Latent energy is the energy pletely, releases about 1 Btu (1055 J) worth of energy, needed to change the phase of a material (solid to liquid so, by definition, the heat from one match can raise or liquid to gas) without a change in temperature. the temperature of a pound of water by 1°F (0.6°C). So, A more accurate naming of “heat pumps” is “energy what happens when one has ice at 32°F (0°C)? H2O goes pumps,” because they extract energy from one tem- through a phase change at this temperature. In Figure 2b, perature level and elevate (pump) it to a higher tem- you see the same 1 lb (0.5 kg) of H2O, but in solid phase, perature level. And like water, energy naturally only so imagine 16 one-ounce (28 g) ice cubes at 32°F (0°C). flows “downhill” from a higher temperature to a lower If you burn the 144 matches, and all that energy goes temperature. into the ice, all the ice will melt. So as odd as it sounds, melting ice is actually absorbing, and storing, massive Big Chillers are Big Heat Pumps amounts of energy. Figure 3 shows the latent energy stor- Traditional heat pumps are reversible, so the heat age capacity of a typical thermal storage tank based on exchangers can be used as condensers or evaporators, water’s 144 Btu/lb (335 J/g). depending on which way you want the energy to go. Changing ice to water is not the only way to store ther- Chillers are heat pumps; the only fundamental differ- mal energy in association with heat pumps. The most ence is that they only pump the energy in one direc- common way is to store it in the ground, with either tion, from an evaporator to condenser. As an example, deep vertical pipes in wells or horizontal fields of bur- in a heat pump used to heat a building, energy can be ied pipe used to convey the stored heat from above- to JULY 2020 ashrae.org ASHRAE JOURNAL 33 TECHNICAL FEATURE FIGURE 3 Thermal energy storage tank capacity. FIGURE 4 A. “Free” cooling with no coincident heating load. B. Simultaneous heating with boiler and “free cooling.” C. Simultaneous heating and cooling with heat pump. Cooling Tower Cooling Tower Cooling Tower Interior and Interior and Perimeter Perimeter Zones Zones Perimeter Perimeter Zones in the Zones in the Building’s Building’s Shell Shell A. B. C. Boiler Chiller Boiler Chiller Boiler Chiller One Tank 8 ft 6 in. Tall by One New York City Project has 44 Tanks thermal energy to the atmosphere, you are burning 7 ft 6 in. Diameter 88,000,000 Btu fossil fuels to add energy (heat) to the perimeter zones 1,655 Gal of Water = 13,786 lb 616 Gal of Fuel Oil ($1,835) 13,786 lb × 144 Btu/lb ~2,000,000 Btu 880 Therms ($1,056) for portions of the day (Figure 4b). When this is evalu- 2,000,000 Btu = ~14 Gal of Fuel Oil 88 Mlb of Steam ($3,520) ated considering the goal of electrification with big heat ~20 Therms of Natural Gas ~7,000 Ton-Hours ~2,000 lb of Steam pumps in buildings to eliminate fossil fuel use, the prac- ~160 Ton-Hours tice seems illogical. To meet simultaneous heating and cooling needs in below ground or back. Because of the relatively low sen- a building, a heat pump can be used to simply pump sible heat capacity of the ground, this requires using a the energy from one area to another. Figure 4c shows a large mass of ground and having heat exchange tubing simplified schematic of a building that has simultane- embedded throughout the ground mass. Another option ous heating and cooling needs and a standard chiller is to put the energy in water, raising its temperature. being used as an energy pump to move excess energy Because no phase change is involved, either much more from the core zones to the perimeter zones. This is water or a very large temperature change would be a very efficient cycle with high heating and cooling needed, compared to using the phase change of H2O as COPs, is all electric and is reducing fossil fuel use at the the storage approach. building. Free Cooling is Wasting Energy (To the Atmosphere) Storing Yesterday’s Waste Energy for Tomorrow’s Heating During the fall, winter and spring, most large build- Using a free cooling cycle, by definition, is wasting ings in northern climates use “free cooling” or “water- energy by rejecting it to the atmosphere.