Emerging Concepts in the Management of Acute Retinal Necrosis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Downloaded from http://bjo.bmj.com/ on January 3, 2016 - Published by group.bmj.com Review Emerging concepts in the management of acute retinal necrosis Robert William Wong,1,2 J Michael Jumper,2 H Richard McDonald,2 Robert N Johnson,2 Arthur Fu,2 Brandon J Lujan,2,3 Emmett T Cunningham, Jr2,4 ▸ Additional files are ABSTRACT now exists on the characteristics, causes and treat- published online only. To view Acute retinal necrosis (ARN), also known as Kirisawa- ment of this condition. these files please visit the journal online (http://dx.doi. type uveitis, is an uncommon condition caused by org/10.1136/bjophthalmol- infection of the retina by one of the herpes family of CLINICAL SIGNS AND SYMPTOMS 2012-301983). viruses, most typically varicella zoster virus or herpes Acutely, ARN may present with eye redness, periorbi- 1Austin Retina Associates, simplex virus and less commonly cytomegalovirus. tal pain, photophobia and/or vision loss. On anterior Austin, Texas, USA Clinical diagnosis can be challenging and is often aided segment examination, patients may show episcleritis, 2The Department of by PCR-based analysis of ocular fluids. Treatment scleritis, keratitis and/or anterior chamber inflamma- Ophthalmology, California typically involves extended use of one or more antiviral tion, which may be either non-granulomatous or Pacific Medical Center, fi San Francisco, California, USA agents. Long term retinal detachment risk is high. We granulomatous ( gure 2). Examination of the poster- 3Department of Vision Science, review the literature on ARN and present an approach to ior segment may reveal vitreous inflammation, arter- School of Optometry, University the diagnosis and management of this serious condition. itis, patchy full thickness necrotising retinitis and, in of California, Berkeley, some cases, involvement of the optic disc. Typically, California, USA the retinitis presents as either confluent or multifocal 4The Department of Ophthalmology, Stanford patches of retinitis involving the peripheral retina University School of Medicine, INTRODUCTION (figure 3). An occlusive periarteritis is often present Stanford, California, USA Acute retinal necrosis (ARN) was first described in (figure 4). Second eye involvement occurs in approxi- 1971 by Akira Urayama and colleagues as a clinical mately a third of patients, typically within 6 weeks,6 Correspondence to syndrome consisting of acute unilateral panuveitis although fellow eye involvement decades following Emmett T Cunningham, Jr, 78 MD, PhD, MPH, West Coast associated with retinal periarteritis progressing to an initial infection has been described. The risk of Retina Medical Group, Inc., diffuse necrotising retinitis and, ultimately, rhegma- bilateral infection may be decreased with prompt 185 Berry Street, Lobby 2, togenous retinal detachment.1 The authors sug- antiviral therapy.9 Suite 130, San Francisco, gested the term Kirisawa–Urayama uveitis in honour With prompt initiation of treatment, progression CA 94107-1739, USA; emmett_cunningham@yahoo. of their teacher Professor Naganori Kirisawa, who of the retinitis can usually be halted within com was then Professor of Ophthalmology at Tohoku 2–4 weeks. As the active retinal infection and inflam- University (figure 1). The term ‘BARN’, for bilateral mation resolve, affected areas develop pigmentary Received 4 May 2012 ARN, was coined by Young and Bird in 1978.2 In changes, retinal thinning and atrophy, often produ- Revised 8 October 2012 Accepted 7 November 2012 1994, the Executive Committee of the American cing a scalloped appearance at the junction of Published Online First Uveitis Society refined the definition of ARN based involved and uninvolved retina. Vitreous organisa- 12 December 2012 on clinical characteristics and disease course to tion and traction may progress during this phase, include: (1) one or more foci of retinal necrosis with producing retinal breaks, retinal detachment and pro- discrete borders located in the peripheral retina; (2) liferative vitreoretinopathy. Rhegmatogenous retinal rapid progression in the absence of antiviral detachment occurs in a half to three-quarters of eyes therapy; (3) circumferential spread; (4) evidence of with ARN and may develop weeks to months after occlusive vasculopathy with arterial involvement; initial presentation of retinitis.10 11 Delayed compli- and (5) a prominent inflammatory reaction in the cations of ARN may include chronic vitritis, macular vitreous and anterior chambers.3 oedema, optic atrophy, epiretinal membrane forma- Over the past few decades, our knowledge of tion, viral relapse with cessation of antiviral medica- ARN has expanded greatly. Two recently published tion and phthysis.12 Poor visual outcomes have been nationwide surveys from the UK estimated the inci- associated with extensive retinal necrosis at time of dence of ARN to be approximately one case per referral,13 herpes simplex virus 2 (HSV-2) or varicella 2 million population per year.45In addition, zoster virus (VZV) infection, and misuse of genetic and epidemiological studies have identified corticosteroid.12 certain characteristics that may predispose patients to develop ARN. Newer diagnostic modalities, in PATIENT CHARACTERISTICS particular PCR-based assays, have been developed Although historically thought to affect otherwise to quickly and accurately identify causative organ- healthy adults, increasing evidence suggests that isms and to bolster the ophthalmologist’s ability patients who develop ARN may have underlying to discern ARN from other infectious causes of immune characteristics that put them at an retinitis. Treatment has advanced as well, with both increased risk for the infection. It is widely known improved systemic antivirals and the increasing use that immunosuppression induced by exogenous 14–16 To cite: Wong RW, of local therapy via intraocular injection. While the corticosteroid use may predispose to ARN. Jumper JM, McDonald HR, relative rarity of ARN and the lack of randomised While no racial or sexual predilection has been et al. Br J Ophthalmol clinical trials complicate efforts to establish identified, moderate associations with class II – 2013;97:545 552. evidence-based guidelines, an extensive literature human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antigen Wong RW, et al. Br J Ophthalmol 2013;97:545–552. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2012-301983 545 Downloaded from http://bjo.bmj.com/ on January 3, 2016 - Published by group.bmj.com Review Figure 1 Professor Naganori Kirisawa (upper left; 1907–1980), after whom Kirisawas-type uveitis—most commonly known as acute retinal necrosis—was named, and Professor Akira Urayama (upper right; 1918–1993). Below, fundus photographs of the affected eye from Case 6, a 35-year-old man, described in the original report by Urayama and colleagues, showing panuveitis, papillitis, periarteritis and peripheral necrotising retinitis.1 Images courtesy of Dr Nakiyuri Yamada (http://www. nichigan.or.jp/english/ophthalmology. jsp). expression, most notably HLA-DQw7 (phenotype Bw62) and of progressive outer retinal necrosis (PORN), patients displayed DR4 antigens in Caucasian patients in the USA17 and the most severe immune dysfunction of all, specifically profound HLA-Aw33, -B44 and -DRw6 antigens in patients in Japan, immunosuppresion.20 Originally described in patients with HIV/ have suggested a possible genetic contribution.18 Moreover, AIDS, PORN is characterised by the occurrence of multiple areas Herbort and colleagues observed that the clinical presentation of necrotising retinitis with relatively little vitreous inflammation of herpetic retinitis may correlate with the amount of overall (figure 5). While the original description of PORN emphasised immune dysfunction.19 20 Specifically, they found that in milder involvement of the posterior pole, necrotising herpetic retinitis cases of ARN, patients tended to demonstrate more subtle can involve any portion of the retina, regardless of immune immune irregularities; in more classical cases of ARN, patients status, and it is now generally accepted that the presence or typically exhibited increasing immune dysfunction; and in cases absence of overlying vitreous inflammation is determined largely Figure 2 Granulomatous anterior chamber inflammation with large keratic precipitates in a patient with acute retinal necrosis. Courtesy of Figure 3 Extensive peripheral necrotising retinitis and periarteritis in Professor Rubens Belfort, Jr. an immunocompetent patient with acute retinal necrosis. 546 Wong RW, et al. Br J Ophthalmol 2013;97:545–552. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2012-301983 Downloaded from http://bjo.bmj.com/ on January 3, 2016 - Published by group.bmj.com Review Figure 4 (A) Peripheral necrotising retinitis and periarteritis. (B) Fluorescein angiogram showing extensive peripheral non-perfusion with segmental arteriolar occlusion. Nodular arteritis with Kyrieleis plaques is also evident. by the patient’s underlying immune status. The differential diag- studies investigating viral causes of ARN have used a number of nosis of viral retinitis includes syphilitic retinitis, toxoplasmic diagnostic techniques, including antibody-based analysis of – retinochoroiditis, intraocular lymphoma, sarcoidosis, tubercu- serum or intraocular fluid,18 26 31 viral culture32 33 and patho- losis, toxocariasis, fungal or bacterial retinitis/endophthalmitis, logical examination of retinal specimens,34 often in conjunction Behçet’s disease and other retinal vasculitides. with immunocytochemical studies.35 More recently, PCR-based – analysis of intraocular