40-Autumn 2003.Indd
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Adrian Slade talks to former Liberal leader David Steel (Lord Steel of Aikwood) about his career in politics, from his election in 1965, through his period as leader of the Liberal Party from 1976 to 1988 to his recent role as Presiding Officer of the Scottish Parliament. ARCHITECT OF POLITICAL REALISM or all the high hopes of been afraid to take risks and court which had a deep effect on me, Jo Grimond’s ‘Liberal controversy. His introduction of and I joined the Anti-Apartheid Revival’, only three the 1967 Abortion Bill; his crea- Movement that was formed as a by-elections were tion of the 1976 Lib–Lab Pact; his result. Also, much influenced by actually won by the encouragement of the formation Jo Grimond, who was rector of FLiberal Party of the 1960s. The of the SDP; his proposed alliance the university and actually intro- most significant for the future with the new party; his ultimate duced me to my future wife, Judy, was Roxburgh, Selkirk & Peebles, strong advocacy of Liberal–SDP I joined the Liberals.’ where, in 1965, 26-year-old David merger: all have made him John Pardoe and Roy Jenkins Steel, ‘Boy David’ as he quickly enemies, even if those enemies had at different times suggested became known, won the seat with are heavily outnumbered by his that David Steel was always more a 4,500 majority over the Tory. supporters. But, on each occasion, of Social Democrat than a Liberal. Unlike the other by-election events have tended to vindicate How true was that? ‘Oh, Jo jok- victors, Eric Lubbock and Wal- him, and his place in history as ingly suggested it too, at the time lace Lawler, Steel’s majority just the Liberal Party’s architect of of the Alliance,’ he says. ‘If being survived the party’s debacle at the political realism and co-operation a bit of an interventionist Liberal 1970 election and he went on to is firmly assured. also means being a Social Demo- become one of the Liberal Party’s Steel’s Liberalism is deeply crat then perhaps there is an ele- longest serving leaders. rooted in colonial Africa, where ment of truth in it. But, despite Four years ago the creation his father was a minister of the some early efforts by Labour MP of a Scottish Parliament drew Church of Scotland and where John Mackintosh to persuade him back from near-retirement he was educated until coming to me, I never wanted to join the politically. He stood for election boarding school in Scotland in his Labour Party. No doubt, if I had, as an MSP and then became the teens. ‘Right up to independence, I would later have helped to form parliament’s first speaker. Having education in colonial Africa was the SDP! I’m a Keynesian Liberal. recently stepped down, he once as segregated as it was in South Was he a Social Democrat?’ again feels free to talk on wider Africa,’ he says. ‘Even at fifteen, In 1962, when Steel was in issues. that seemed all wrong to me. Then his last year and president of his From the moment he entered my time at university coincided university’s Liberals, uncrowned politics, David Steel has never with the Sharpeville massacre, Scottish Liberal king George Journal of Liberal History 40 Autumn 2003 23 ARCHITECT OF POLITICAL REALISM Mackie offered him his first job and Roy Jenkins, by now Home days, particularly in local gov- – Assistant Secretary of the Scot- Secretary, were very keen that ernment. We suffered the classic tish Liberal Party. This was part I should it take it on. So for all squeeze. I don’t think there was of a successful Mackie plot to these reasons I decided to try.’ much we could have done.’ put him into Roxburgh, Selkirk It was a brave advocacy that ‘The next four years were & Peebles, one of Scotland’s few made him very unpopular with quite different because we ben- seats in which Liberals were in some people. ‘I still get letters to efited from the by-election effect. second place. He went on to this day, calling me Hitler, baby Ladywood had not been a major make huge inroads into the Tory murderer and so on,’ he says. by-election win but Rochdale vote in the 1964 election and to ‘But there was wide cross-party and Sutton were and they were win the by-election that soon fol- support for change, particularly followed by three other wins. lowed. ‘We fought it very much amongst Labour ministers. It People always tend to support on local issues,’ he says. ‘The local took up many hours of consul- winners and that was what we hospital, the threatened Beeching tation listening to doctors, the were. In the same way late, at a railway closure, the revitalisation churches and pro and anti groups, much more difficult time, we of the Borders, which had been but, crucially, Roy found us the were undoubtedly helped by suffering badly from depopula- parliamentary time to get the bill David Alton’s win at Edge Hill tion by the young.’ through.’ a month or two before the1979 When he first entered Par- The new bill legalised abor- election.’ liament, these were the sorts of tion under certain conditions, Steel was soon to take over as constituency issues that Steel putting the decision in the hands party leader. In party terms what concentrated on. But he also of any two doctors who agreed to had he learned from his first ten developed his African interests. ‘I the abortion in good faith. ‘It was years? ‘To concentrate on our remember slipping into Rhodesia not a woman’s right to choose, strengths, such as we had, and not with Archy Kirkwood during the so you still get campaigning on to dissipate – to target seats and Smith UDI regime,’ he says. ‘We that issue, but at the time it was not spread resources too thinly. were arrested on the way out.’ At a pioneering reform compared to Of course we became much bet- this point he proudly produces most other countries,’ he says. ter at that a few years later.’ his ‘Prohibited Immigrant’ cer- His constituents were less Not surprisingly he had found tificate, which he was forced to unhappy with his Abortion Bill the period following Jeremy accept by the Rhodesian authori- ‘It had than his association with the Thorpe’s departure as leader ties. Shortly after this visit he anti-apartheid opposition to the ‘very depressing and long drawn took over from David Ennals as always 1969/70 South African rugby out’ but he refutes any sugges- President of the Anti-Apartheid tour. ‘Menzies Campbell and I tion that the leadership election Movement. ‘They needed some- seemed to did a meeting in my rugby-lov- he fought with John Pardoe had one who wasn’t going to be made ing constituency. It was very been bad-tempered. ‘John and a minister,’ he says. me quite badly attended and didn’t make I always got on extremely well, But, after the 1966 election, unrealistic me popular. At the election the and I hand it to him that, within a he drew third place in the pri- next year my majority went day of my being elected, he came vate members’ bill ballot and to expect down to 500.’ to my office to give me his full shot immediately to the atten- He was not alone in suffer- support. I was devastated when tion of the public at large when us to move ing at that election. All but six of he lost his seat in 1979. Although he decided to introduce a bill the twelve Liberal MPs lost their he never was deputy leader, eve- to legalise abortion in certain straight seats. ‘And the combined majori- ryone thought he was and his circumstances. Until then abor- into major- ties of Jeremy, John Pardoe and economic expertise was of huge tion had been illegal, was often myself, half the parliamentary value, particularly to me because self-induced, and was also the ity govern- party, totalled just 1500,’ he adds I had none. He was a great loss to province of back-street operators with a laugh, although he found the party.’ and private clinics covering their ment so I it far from amusing at the time. When Steel became leader work under other names. In 1968 Wallace Lawler had and he used his first Assembly ‘I had supported change was always won a by-election seat from speech to call on his party to be openly in my by-election and looking for Labour in Birmingham Lady- prepared to share power at some here was a chance to do some- wood (now part of Clare Short’s stage. He sees the Lib–Lab Pact thing about it,’ says Steel. ‘Six or a pathway territory). This apart, why had as a logical sequel to that speech. seven previous attempts had all the party made so little impact ‘It had always seemed to me quite failed for lack of time, but the to get us between 1966 and 1970? ‘The unrealistic to expect us to move most recent, Lord Silkin’s, had Wilson government was very straight into majority govern- already gone through the Lords back into much in the ascendancy,’ he says. ment so I was always looking for a and I decided to pick up his influence ‘And, unlike today, there was a pathway to get us back into influ- draft. Silkin’s son, John, was the strong Tory party.