Cell Size and Proportional Distance Assessment During Determination of Organelle Position in the Cortex of the Ciliate Tetrahymena
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
J. Cell Set. ai, 35-46 (1976) 35 Printed in Great Britain CELL SIZE AND PROPORTIONAL DISTANCE ASSESSMENT DURING DETERMINATION OF ORGANELLE POSITION IN THE CORTEX OF THE CILIATE TETRAHYMENA D. H. LYNN AND J. B. TUCKER Department of Zoology, The University, St Andrews, Fife KY16 <)TS, Scotland SUMMARY Developing oral organelles of dividing Tetrahymena corlissi appear to be positioned by mechanisms which assess distances as a proportion of the organism's overall dimensions. In some respects, the cortex of this protozoan obeys the 'French flag' rule formulated by Wolpert for describing regulation of spatial proportions during differentiation of metazoan embryos. Dividing Tetrahymena of markedly different sizes occur when division is synchronized by starvation and refeeding. At the start of cell division, the distance between old and new mouth- parts varies proportionately with respect to cell length. In addition, determination of the site where new oral organelles will develop is apparently not directly related to the number of ciliated basal bodies which separate the 2 sets of mouthparts; the greater the distance between the old and developing sets of mouthparts, the greater the number of ciliated basal bodies in the rows between them. It is suggested that 2 distinct mechanisms are largely responsible for defining organelle position in ciliates. The new terms structural positioning and chemical signalling are denned to describe these mechanisms. INTRODUCTION Organelles are positioned in a very precise and specific fashion in many unicellular organisms. Precisely positioned organelles form particularly well ordered and charac- teristic patterns in the cortices of ciliates. The spatial complexity of these organelle arrays is comparable with the arrangement of different cell types, tissues, and organs in multicellular animals. Moreover, the body sizes of ciliates and the sizes of positional fields in multicellular animals and their embryos are quite similar (Frankel, 1974)- This fact, together with others, has led Frankel (1974) to argue that some of the mechanisms underlying the spatial specification of pattern are the same in both ciliates and multicellular animals. Universality of mechanisms for specifying posi- tional information, particularly among metazoa, has been proposed in Wolpert's (1969, 1971) theory of 'positional information'. Wolpert has emphasized the fact that positional fields are regulative. Regulative fields are capable of proportionately re- establishing the same pattern after their boundaries have been disturbed or altered. Wolpert (1969) has formalized this in his 'French flag' rule. Examples of such regula- tion are well documented for metazoan development (see Wolpert, 1969; Cooke, 1975)- 3-2 36 D.H. Lynn andj. B. Tucker Strict proportional regulation has not been clearly established for ciliates. Frankel (1974) has reviewed microsurgical experiments which demonstrate that Stentor obeys the 'French flag' rule within certain limitations. There have been several morphometric analyses which demonstrate that positioning of contractile vacuole pores in Tetrahymena (Nanney, 1966, 1967; Frankel, 1972; Doerder, Frankel, Jenkins & De Bault, 1975) and Chilodonella (Kaczanowska, 1974) is probably accomplished by assessment of the overall size of the positional field in which they develop. Kac- zanowska (1974) and Jerka-Dziadosz (1974) have discussed the congruence between the models of positional information for multicellular and unicellular organisms. Many new cortical organelles develop when a ciliate commences binary fission. Is spacing of the sites where new organelles form proportionately related to the sizes of dividing organisms ? It is difficult to assess whether such spatial regulation occurs, rather than positional specification by mechanisms relying on fixed or absolute distances, because, before starting to divide, most ciliates reach a specific, well defined size which shows little variation. However, these alternatives can be tested with the hymenostome Tetrahymena corlissi. In this species, dividing organisms of markedly different sizes occur during refeeding following a period of starvation. Little growth of the organisms takes place in the unusually short period which intervenes between the 2 fissions which follow release from starvation (Lynn, 1975). This paper examines the extent of spatial proportionality in the cortex of T. corlissi, by measuring the distances separating the sites of old and differentiating new oral organelles at the start of binary fission in organisms of varying lengths. Differences in the number of cortical fibre-lattice units situated between the 2 sets of oral organelles have also been investigated. The results are discussed in terms of recent proposals for positional determination in metazoans (Wolpert, 1969, 1971) and in ciliated protozoa (Frankel, 1974, 1975; Sonneborn, 1974). MATERIALS AND METHODS Culture techniques Tetrahymena corlissi strain WT, clone TC-2, was cultured axenically in 2 % (w/v) proteose- peptone with either o-i % yeast extract or o-i % neutralized liver digest. Dividing organisms of markedly different sizes are present after starved organisms are resupplied with nutrient culture medium. A variation of the starvation-refeeding technique described by Cameron & Jeter(i97o) was employed. A 200-ml culture of logarithmically growing T. corlissi (ca. 7000 cells/ml) was centrifuged to concentrate the organisms which were then washed twice in an inorganic 'starvation' buffer (Cameron & Jeter, 1970) and resuspended in 200 ml of starvation buffer. After 24 h, starved organisms were centrifuged down and resuspended in nutrient culture medium. The time at which the organisms started to divide again after release from starvation was ascertained by taking small samples from a culture at regular intervals, fixing the organisms in Lugol's iodine, and counting the numbers of dividing organisms in a standard volume. Experiments were conducted at 18-20 °C. Tetraliymena pyriformis strain W was cultured axenically in 1 % (w/v) proteose-peptone and o-i % yeast extract. Proportional distance assessment in Tetrahymena 37 Staining and microscopy The cortex of dividing organisms was stained with silver (Chatton & Lwoff, 1930; Corliss, 1953), protargol (McCoy, 1974) and nigrosin (MacKinnon & Hawes, 1961). Organisms were photographed with a Carl Zeiss Universal microscope fitted with bright-field, phase-contrast and Nomarski differential interference-contrast optics. Silver-stained organisms were measured with a Leitz filar ocular micrometer mounted on a Leitz Ortholux microscope. RESULTS Positioning of new mouthparts At the beginning of binary fission each organism develops one new set of mouth- parts. These form some distance from, and posterior to, the pre-existing old mouth- parts (Fig. 1). They usually develop alongside a ciliary row (kinety 1) which extends 30 fim Anterior mouthparts Kinety 1 Developing posterior mouthparts Fig. 1. Schematic scale drawing of first (I) and second (II) post-starvation dividers based on average measurements for 50 silver-stained specimens of each type of divider. d is the distance between mouthparts and / is the body length. The number of black dots in the first kinety of each divider represents the average number of basal bodies in the portion between the mouthparts. The old anterior mouthparts each include a curved undulating membrane and 3 membranelles. posteriorly along the length of the organism from the posterior end of the old set of mouthparts (Fig. 1). The distance (d) between old and new mouthparts (measured from the posterior end of the undulating membrane of the old anterior set of mouth- parts to the anterior extremity of the developing posterior set of mouthparts) has been measured for silver-stained organisms at an early stage of binary fission and stomatogenesis (Fig. 1). By this stage, the basal bodies of the developing oral ciliary organelles form a compact group but have not sorted out into the distinct arrays D.H. Lynn and J. B. Tucker Proportional distance assessment in Tetrahymena 39 which will form the undulating membrane and 3 membranelles (Fig. 1). The lengths of dividing organisms in logarithmically growing cultures {log dividers) vary between 6o-8 and 77-6/tm and their mouthparts are separated by distances of 14-1-21-8/un (Table 1). Much greater variation in these parameters is found in organisms after release from starvation. 300 .:> .* o. 200 100 00 400 500 600 70 0 800 Body length, Fig. 2. Graph showing the relationship between the distance between the mouth- parts (d) and body length (/) for 150 silver-stained dividing organisms (50 each of first and second post-starvation dividers and 50 log dividers). The line fitted by linear regression analysis has the equation d = o-3O55(/) - 2'474, where d and / are in /Jm. After transfer to the starvation buffer, the total number of organisms increased by about 10% over 24 h. The sizes of the organisms decreased as starvation pro- ceeded. After 24 h, the lengths of organisms averaged 53-3 fim (43-3-61-5/tm; N = 15) while the widths averaged 18-2 /tm (14-7-22-5 /tm; N = 15). Non-dividing organisms in logarithmically growing cultures have lengths averaging 64-6 /tm (51-1-75-6/4111; N = 15) and widths averaging 32-9fim (25-2-39-0fim; N = 15). Organisms start to divide again about 12-15 n a^-er transfer from the starvation buffer to a nutrient culture medium (see Materials and methods). During this 3-h period, division synchrony of up to 10% was achieved by the starvation-refeeding