The Evolution of Sexual Imprinting Through Reinforcement

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Evolution of Sexual Imprinting Through Reinforcement Assortative mating by an obliquely transmitted local cultural trait promotes divergence Justin Yeh University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Do learned birdsong dialects lead to speciation? • Molecular similarity might correlate with dialect similarity (Baker 1975; Baker & Thompson 1982; Zink & Barrowclough 1984) • Genetic cline overlap with cultural cline, but at lower steepness, and the birdsong does not predict genotype (Kenyon et al. 2016) • Bird lineage with song learning has more species than that without (Lachlan & Servedio 2004) Justin Yeh 2 correlation ⇏ causation no correlation ⇏ no causation Justin Yeh 3 Oblique learning: from unrelated individual of the previous generation • Juvenile songbirds learn from adult neighbors • Obliquely transmitted traits are immune to sexual selection (Yeh & Servedio 2015) • If any juvenile can learn from any adult, there should not be correlation between gene and culture Justin Yeh 4 Spatial structure creates gene- culture association • Learning is spatially restricted • Cultural traits can be locally adapted – High-freq vocal signals in cities (Luther & Derryberry 2012) – Tonal languages in humid environment (Everett et al. 2014) Justin Yeh 5 Hypothesis Local genes & Local song & local local oblique reproduction learning Justin Yeh 6 Hypothesis Local genes & Local song & local local oblique reproduction learning Gene-culture association Justin Yeh 7 Hypothesis Local genes & Local song & local local oblique reproduction learning Divergent selection Gene-culture & sexual selection association on song Genetic divergence Justin Yeh 8 Hypothesis Local genes & Local song & local local oblique reproduction learning Divergent selection Gene-culture & sexual selection association on song Genetic divergence Justin Yeh 9 Population genetic model m Justin Yeh 10 Population genetic model m A B a b Justin Yeh 11 Population genetic model m A B a b s H sH Justin Yeh 12 Population genetic model C1 C2 m A B a b s H sH Justin Yeh 13 Population genetic model sD , α sD , α C1 C2 m A B a b s H sH Justin Yeh 14 Population genetic model sD , α sD , α C1 C2 m A B a b s H sH Justin Yeh 15 Population genetic model sD , α, μ sD , α , μ N C1 C2 m N A B a b s H sH Justin Yeh 16 Simulation conditions • All genes and cultural traits start diverged – Contact zone • 5000 generations Justin Yeh 17 Both sexual and divergent selection promote LD Local gene Local song Gene-culture Selection on association song (α, sD) Genetic divergence (LD) Justin Yeh 18 Both sexual and divergent selection promote LD m=0.01, sH=0.09, μ=0, no drift Local gene Local song LD s Gene-culture Selection on D association song (α, sD) 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 Female preference strength (α) Genetic divergence (LD) Note: Intermediate α maximizes sexual selection in phenotype-matching models (Servedio 2011) Justin Yeh 19 Drift and mutation just make things messy Drift & mutation Local gene Local song Gene-culture Selection on association song (sD, α) Genetic divergence (LD) Justin Yeh 20 Drift and mutation just make things messy -3 Drift & mutation m=0.01; sH=0.1; α=1; μ=10 ; N=1000 Local gene Local song LD Gene-culture Selection on sD association song (sD, α) Cultural trait divergence (calculated like Nei’s genetic distance) Genetic divergence (LD) Justin Yeh 21 Mate choice and viability give better evidence than gene-culture correlation • Correlation can be caused by geography • Correlation can be difficult to observe – Oblique learning temporarily and locally removes gene-culture association – Stochastic process may lead to high cultural variation within patches Justin Yeh 22 Why should cultural evolution care about speciation? • group formation, ideological divide, radicalization, etc. • Reduced genetic exchange <--> reduced memetic exchange • Genetic divergence <--> cultural divergence Justin Yeh 23 Acknowledgement • Maria Servedio • Marc Feldman • Courtney Fitzpatrick • National Science Foundation (USA) Justin Yeh 24 Life cycle Drift Oblique learning with Migration cultural mutation Viability Sexual selection selection & reproduction Justin Yeh 25 Drift Migration Oblique learning w/ cultural mutation Sexual selection & Viability selection reproduction • D-M incompatibility for A and B (sH) • Divergent selection on C (sD) Genotype Culture Patch 1 Patch 2 AB & ab C1, C3… 1 1-sD Ab & aB C1, C3… 1-sH (1-sH)(1-sD) AB & ab C2, C4… 1-sD 1 Ab & aB C2, C4… (1-sH)(1-sD) 1-sH Justin Yeh 26 Drift Migration Oblique learning w/ cultural mutation Viability Sexual selection & selection reproduction • Polygyny (sexual selection on males) • Preference (α) to mate with individuals of the same cultural trait (phenotype-matching) ♂ ♀ C1 C2 C3 … C1 1+α 1 1 1 C2 1 1+α 1 1 C3 1 1 1+α 1 … 1 1 1 … 27 Drift Oblique learning w/ Migration cultural mutation Viability Sexual selection selection & reproduction • From the previous generation in the same patch f(ABC1)juvenile=f(AB)juvenile((1- μ) f(C1)adult + μ f(C2)adult) • Gene-culture association becomes 0 within each patch! Justin Yeh 28 Life cycle order & number of possible cultural traits -3 m=0.01; sH=0.1; α=1; μ=10 ; N=1000 m=0.01; sH=0.1; sD=0-0.5; α=1 # of C alleles LD sD Cultural trait divergence Drift Viability Oblique learning selection Migration Sexual selection 29 sD selection Local gene Local song Local gene Local song migration migration Gene-culture Gene-culture α, s α association D association selection Genetic divergence (LD) Genetic divergence (LD) Justin Yeh 30 Scientific Empirical Proof-of-concept method research models Observe nature and build hypothesis Choose Design protocol Gather evidence assumptions and gather data and build model Analyze evidence Analyze data Analyze model Evaluate hypothesis and propose new directions Servedio et al. (2014) Not Just a Theory—The Utility of Mathematical Models in Evolutionary Biology. PLoS Biol 12(12): e1002017.
Recommended publications
  • Avian Vision and the Evolution of Egg Color Mimicry in The
    evo_65_7_cover 6/22/11 7:16 PM Page 1 Volume 65, Number 7, July 2011 VOLUME 65, NUMBER 7, JULY 2011 EVOLUTION VOLUME 65, NUMBER 7, PAGES PERSPECTIVE INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ORGANIC EVOLUTION Convergence, Adaptation, and Constraint Jonathan B. Losos 1827–1840 ORIGINAL ARTICLES 1827 Neutral Biodiversity Theory can Explain the Imbalance of Phylogenetic Trees but not the Tempo –2132 of their Diversification T. Jonathan Davies, Andrew P. Allen, Luís Borda-de-A´gua, Jim Regetz, and Carlos J. Melián 1841–1850 The Impact of Gene-Tree/Species-Tree Discordance on Diversification-Rate Estimation Frank T. Burbrink and R. Alexander Pyron 1851–1861 Dealing with Incomplete Taxon Sampling and Diversification of a Large Clade of Mushroom-Forming Fungi Martin Ryberg and Patrick Brandon Matheny 1862–1878 EVOLUTION Diversity and Demography in Beringia: Multilocus Tests of Paleodistribution Models Reveal the Complex History of Arctic Ground Squirrels Kurt E. Galbreath, Joseph A. Cook, Aren A. Eddingsaas, and Eric G. DeChaine 1879–1896 The Genetic Architecture of Adaptation Under Migration-Selection Balance Sam Yeaman and Michael C. Whitlock 1897–1911 The Influence of an Innovative Locomotor Strategy on the Phenotypic Diversification of Triggerfish (Family: Balistidae) Alex Dornburg, Brian Sidlauskas, Francesco Santini, Laurie Sorenson, Thomas J. Near, and Michael E. Alfaro 1912–1926 The Tempo and Mode of Evolution: Body Sizes of Island Mammals Pasquale Raia and Shai Meiri 1927–1934 Mammals Evolve Faster on Smaller Islands Virginie Millien 1935–1944 Evolutionary Advantage of Small Populations on Complex Fitness Landscapes Kavita Jain, Joachim Krug, and Su-Chan Park 1945–1955 Interspecific X-Chromosome and Mitochondrial DNA Introgression in the Iberian Hare: Selection or Allele Surfing? July 2011 José Melo-Ferreira, Paulo C.
    [Show full text]
  • Reinforcement and the Genetics of Hybrid Incompatibilities
    Genetics: Published Articles Ahead of Print, published on March 17, 2006 as 10.1534/genetics.105.048199 Reinforcement and the genetics of hybrid incompatibilities Alan R. Lemmon1 and Mark Kirkpatrick Affiliation: Section of Integrative Biology, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712 1 Running head: Reinforcement and hybrid incompatibility Keywords: hybridization, speciation, reinforcement, incompatibility, sex linkage, incompatibility sieve 1Correspondence: Alan R. Lemmon Section of Integrative Biology The University of Texas at Austin 1 University Station #C0930 Austin, TX 78712 USA Email: [email protected] Tel: 512-471-3760; Fax: 512-471-3878 2 ABSTRACT Recent empirical studies suggest that genes involved in speciation are often sex-linked. We derive a general analytic model of reinforcement to study the effects of sex linkage on reinforcement under three forms of selection against hybrids: one-locus, two-locus, and ecological incompatibilities. We show that the pattern of sex linkage can have a large effect on the amount of reinforcement due to hybrid incompatibility. Sex linkage of genes involved in postzygotic isolation generally increases the strength of reinforcement, but only if genes involved in prezygotic isolation are also sex-linked. We use exact simulations to test the accuracy of the approximation and find that qualitative predictions made assuming weak selection can hold when selection is strong. 3 Speciation is the evolution of prezygotic or postzygotic isolation. Postzygotic isolation is thought to evolve through the accumulation of genetic incompatibilities during allopatric separation. Prezygotic isolation can evolve through reinforcement, which is the evolution of increased prezygotic isolation as a result of selection against hybrids (Dobzhansky 1940; Blair 1955; Howard 1993).
    [Show full text]
  • Sex Differences in the Recombination Landscape*
    vol. 195, no. 2 the american naturalist february 2020 Symposium Sex Differences in the Recombination Landscape* Jason M. Sardell† and Mark Kirkpatrick Department of Integrative Biology, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712 Submitted May 12, 2018; Accepted April 26, 2019; Electronically published December 9, 2019 Online enhancement: appendix. abstract: Sex differences in overall recombination rates are well Nearly all attention to this question has focused on over- known, but little theoretical or empirical attention has been given all map lengths. Achiasmy, in which recombination is lost to how and why sexes differ in their recombination landscapes: the in one sex, has evolved about 30 times, and the loss always patterns of recombination along chromosomes. In the first scientific occurs in the heterogametic sex (Haldane 1922; Huxley review of this phenomenon, we find that recombination is biased to- 1928; Burt et al. 1991). A much more common but less un- ward telomeres in males and more uniformly distributed in females in derstood situation is heterochiasmy, in which both sexes re- most vertebrates and many other eukaryotes. Notable exceptions to combine but at different rates. In these cases, sex differences this pattern exist, however. Fine-scale recombination patterns also fre- quently differ between males and females. The molecular mechanisms in map lengths are not correlated with which sex is hetero- responsible for sex differences remain unclear, but chromatin land- gametic (Burt et al. 1991; Lenormand 2003; Brandvain and scapes play a role. Why these sex differences evolve also is unclear. Hy- Coop 2012), although overall recombination tends to be potheses suggest that they may result from sexually antagonistic selec- higher in females across animals and outcrossing plants (re- tion acting on coding genes and their regulatory elements, meiotic viewed in Lenormand and Dutheil 2005; Brandvain and drive in females, selection during the haploid phase of the life cycle, Coop 2012).
    [Show full text]
  • Rebecca Jo Safran
    Safran – CV, Page 1 September 2016 C U R R I C U L U M V I T A E Rebecca Jo Safran Associate Professor Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado 80309 E-MAIL [email protected] TELEPHONE 303.734.1495 MOBILE: 303.249.8089 Lab website: [email protected] EDUCATION Ph.D. Cornell University Ecology and Evolutionary Biology January Minor Degree in Biometry 2005 (MA equivalent) M.S. Humboldt State University Ecology May 1997 B.S. University of Michigan School of Natural Resources and December the Environment 1991 RESEARCH INTERESTS Integrative evolutionary ecology: phenotype evolution, gene X environment influences on phenotype, evolution by sexual and natural selection, role of adaptation in the evolution of reproductive isolation, behavioral reproductive isolation, patterns of genomic divergence in speciation, genetic and hormonal control of behavior and morphology, relationships between scales of analysis: individuals to populations APPOINTMENTS Associate Professor, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology. University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado. August 2014 – present. Assistant Professor, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology. University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado. January 2008 – August 2014. Postdoctoral Fellow, Council on Science and Technology and Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey. September 2005 – December 2007 AWARDS & HONORS 2016 Elected Fellow, American Ornithological Society 2016 Invited Participant, Presidential Debate, Conference of the American Society of Naturalists, Asilomar, CA 2015 Elected co-chair (2017)/chair (2019): Gordon Conference on Speciation 2015 Faculty Sustainability Award, University of Colorado 2015 Invited Speaker: Gordon Conference on Speciation, Ventura California 2015 Storer Lecture: College of Biological Sciences, University of California, Davis Safran – CV, Page 2 September 2016 2014 Invited Speaker: National Evolutionary Synthesis Center, Evolutionary Synthesis, Past and Future.
    [Show full text]
  • Evolution of Male Life Histories and Age-Dependent Sexual Signals Under Female Choice Joel J
    Evolution of male life histories and age-dependent sexual signals under female choice Joel J. Adamson Ecology, Evolution and Organismic Biology, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, United States ABSTRACT Sexual selection theory models evolution of sexual signals and preferences using simple life histories. However, life-history models predict that males benefit from increasing sexual investment approaching old age, producing age-dependent sex- ual traits. Age-dependent traits require time and energy to grow, and will not fully mature before individuals enter mating competition. Early evolutionary stages pose several problems for these traits. Age-dependent traits suVer from strong viabil- ity selection and gain little benefit from mate choice when rare. Few males will grow large traits, and they will rarely encounter choosy females. The evolutionary origins of age-dependent traits therefore remain unclear. I used numerical simu- lations to analyze evolution of preferences, condition (viability) and traits in an age-structured population. Traits in the model depended on age and condition (“good genes”) in a population with no genetic drift. I asked (1) if age-dependent indicator traits and their preferences can originate depending on the strength of selection and the size of the trait; (2) which mode of development (age-dependent versus age-independent) eventually predominates when both modes occur in the population; and (3) if age-independent traits can invade a population with age- dependent traits. Age-dependent traits evolve under weaker selection and at smaller sizes than age-independent traits. This result held in isolation and when the types co-occur. Evolution of age-independent traits depends only on trait size, whereas Submitted 29 August 2013 Accepted 26 November 2013 evolution of age-dependent traits depends on both strength of selection and growth Published 17 December 2013 rate.
    [Show full text]
  • II Joint Congress on Evolutionary Biology Montpellier 2018, France August 18-22, 2018
    II Joint Congress on Evolutionary Biology Montpellier 2018, France August 18-22, 2018 Congress book TABLE OF CONTENTS Welcome ................................................................................................................... 04 In memoriam ............................................................................................................ 05 Information ............................................................................................................... 06 Conference information .................................................................................. 06 Congress area map ........................................................................................ 09 City map .......................................................................................................... 10 Corum maps .................................................................................................... 12 Plenary talks ..................................................................................................... 14 Other special events sponsored by societies ................................................ 15 Workshops ........................................................................................................ 20 Other meetings ................................................................................................ 23 Social events .................................................................................................... 24 Outreach .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Janette Boughman
    Seminar janette boughman Fellow, scas. Professor of Integrative Biology, Michigan State University, East Lansing How is Biodiversity Created and Maintained in Our Changing World? Tuesday, 15 May, 11:15 a.m. In the Thunberg Lecture Hall scas, Linneanum, Thunbergsvägen 2, Uppsala www.swedishcollegium.se about janette boughman Janette Boughman is currently affiliated with the Department of Integrative Biology; the Ecology, Evolutionary Biology, and Behavior program; and the Beacon Center for the Study of Evolution in Action at the Michigan State University. She earlier held the posi- tion of Visiting Scientist at the Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology and was Assistant Professor of Zoology at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and a Post- doctoral Fellow and Assistant Lecturer at the University of British Columbia. She has been awarded a Fulbright Fellowship in Arctic Research in Iceland, is the Vice Presi- dent of the Society for the Study of Evolution, and has been an nsf International Re- search Fellow, a nato Postdoctoral Fellow, an nih Postdoctoral Fellow, and a Smith- sonian Fellow. She earned a Ph.D. in Biology at the University of Maryland and an ma in Linguistics from the University of New Hampshire. Boughman’s research uses an integrative approach to investigate the evolu- tion of behavior and the process of speciation. She has authored sixty scientific research papers in leading international scientific journals. She has been continuously funded by major grants from the us National Science Foundation for twenty-three years and currently leads an nsf Dimensions of Biodiversity collaborative research program on rapid evolution in response to changing environments.
    [Show full text]
  • The Interaction Between Learning and Speciation
    THE INTERACTION BETWEEN LEARNING AND SPECIATION D. Justin Yeh A dissertation submitted to the faculty at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of PhD in the Biology Department in the School of Arts and Sciences. Chapel Hill 2018 Approved by: Maria R. Servedio Marcus W. Feldman Joel G. Kingsolver David W. Pfennig Karin S. Pfennig © 2018 D. Justin Yeh ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT D. Justin Yeh: The Interaction between Learning and Speciation (Under the direction of Maria R. Servedio) Assortative mating displays, preferences, or both can be affected by learning across a wide range of animal taxa, but the specifics of how this learning affects speciation with gene flow are not well understood. I use population genetic models with trait learning to investigate how the identity of the tutor affects the divergence of a self-referent phenotype-matching trait. I find that oblique learning (learning from unrelated individual of the previous generation) and maternal learning mask sexual selection and therefore do not allow the maintenance of divergence. In contrast, by enhancing positive frequency-dependent sexual selection, paternal learning can maintain more divergence than genetic inheritance, but leads to the loss of polymorphism more easily. Furthermore, paternal learning inhibits the invasion of a novel self- referent phenotype-matching trait, especially in a large population. Reinforcement is the process through which assortative mating evolves by natural selection to reduce costly hybridization. Sexual imprinting could facilitate reinforcement by decreasing hybridization, or it could impede the process if heterotypic pairs imprint on each other.
    [Show full text]
  • David W. Pfennig
    David W. Pfennig April 8, 2021 Dept. of Biology, CB#3280, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC 27599 email: [email protected] web: https://www.davidpfenniglab.com Synopsis of Research I’m broadly interested in evolution, ecology, behavior, and development. My current research seeks to understand how individual organisms assess and respond to changes in their environment and how such developmental ‘plasticity’ impacts ecology, evolution, and health. Education 2018 Leadership Development Program, Center for Creative Leadership, Greensboro, NC 1999-2002 Summer Institute in Statistical Genetics, North Carolina State University 1991-1993 NSF Postdoctoral Fellow, Cornell University (with P. W. Sherman) 1990-1991 Center for Insect Science Postdoctoral Fellow, University of Arizona 1989-1990 Maytag Postdoctoral Fellow, Arizona State University (with J. P. Collins) 1989 University of Texas at Austin, Ph.D. in Zoology (with J. J. Bull & M. Kirkpatrick) 1982 University of Texas at San Antonio, M.S. in Biology (with G. J. Gamboa) 1979 University of Texas at Austin, B.S. in Zoology 1979 University of Texas at Austin, B.S. in Geology Professional Experience 2012-2015 Caroline & Thomas Royster Distinguished Professor for Graduate Education, Dept. of Biology, University of North Carolina (UNC) 2012-2015 Director, Royster Society of Fellows, The Graduate School, UNC 2007-2012 Zachary Taylor Smith Distinguished Professor for Excellence in Undergraduate Education, Dept. of Biology, UNC 2007 Visiting Scholar, National Evolutionary Synthesis Center, Duke University 2004-present Professor, Dept. of Biology, UNC 2003-2012 Co-director of Graduate Studies, Dept. of Biology, UNC 1999-2004 Associate Professor, Dept. of Biology, UNC 1996-1999 Assistant Professor, Dept.
    [Show full text]
  • Animal Behaviour 104: 175-185
    Animal Behaviour 104 (2015) 175e185 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Animal Behaviour journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/anbehav Exaggerated sexual swellings and male mate choice in primates: testing the reliable indicator hypothesis in the Amboseli baboons * Courtney L. Fitzpatrick a, , Jeanne Altmann b, c, Susan C. Alberts a, c a Department of Biology, Duke University, Durham, NC, U.S.A. b Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, U.S.A. c National Museums of Kenya, Institute of Primate Research, Nairobi, Kenya article info The paradigm of competitive males vying to influence female mate choice has been repeatedly upheld, Article history: but, increasingly, studies also report competitive females and choosy males. One female trait that is Received 18 July 2014 commonly proposed to influence male mate choice is the exaggerated sexual swelling displayed by fe- Initial acceptance 3 November 2014 males of many Old World primate species. The reliable indicator hypothesis posits that females use the Final acceptance 23 February 2015 exaggerated swellings to compete for access to mates, and that the swellings advertise variation in fe- Published online male fitness. We tested the two main predictions of this hypothesis in a wild population of baboons MS. number: A14-00599R2 (Papio cynocephalus). First, we examined the effect of swelling size on the probability of mate guarding (‘consortship’) by the highest-ranking male and the behaviour of those males that trailed consortships Keywords: (‘follower males’). Second, we asked whether a female's swelling size predicted several fitness measures. baboon We found that high-ranking males did not prefer females with larger swellings (when controlling for male mate choice cycle number and conception) and that females with larger swellings did not have higher reproductive Papio cynocephalus reliable indicator hypothesis success.
    [Show full text]
  • EVOLUTION of DIVERSITY in WARNING COLOR and MIMICRY: Polymorphisms, Shifting Balance, and Speciation
    P1: FNE/fgp P2: FhN/fgo QC: FhN/uks T1: FhN September 17, 1999 17:19 Annual Reviews AR093-08 Annu.Rev.Ecol.Syst.1999 .30:201–33 Copyright c 1999 by Annual Reviews. All rights reserved EVOLUTION OF DIVERSITY IN WARNING COLOR AND MIMICRY: Polymorphisms, Shifting Balance, and Speciation James Mallet1 and Mathieu Joron2 1GaltonLaboratory,4StephensonWay,LondonNW12HE,England; e-mail:http://abacus.gene.ucl.ac.uk/jim/;and2Ge´ netiqu´ eet Environnement, CC065 ISEM, Universite´ de Montpellier 2, Place Bataillon, F-34095 Montpellier,cedex5,France Key Words aposematism, Batesian mimicry, M¨ullerianmimicry, defensive coloration, predator behavior ■ Abstract Mimicry and warning color are highly paradoxical adaptations. Color patterns in both M¨ullerianand Batesian mimicry are often determined by relatively few pattern-regulating loci with major effects. Many of these loci are “supergenes,” consisting of multiple, tightly linked epistatic elements. On the one hand, strong pu- rifying selection on these genes must explain accurate resemblance (a reduction of morphological diversity between species), as well as monomorphic color patterns within species. On the other hand, mimicry has diversified at every taxonomic level; warning color has evolved from cryptic patterns, and there are mimetic polymor- phisms within species, multiple color patterns in different geographic races of the same species, mimetic differences between sister species, and multiple mimicry rings within local communities. These contrasting patterns can be explained, in part, by the shape of a “number-dependent” selection function first modeled by Fritz M¨uller in 1879: Purifying selection against any warning-colored morph is very strong when that morph is rare, but becomes weak in a broad basin of intermediate frequencies, allowing opportunities for polymorphisms and genetic drift.
    [Show full text]
  • Accepted Version
    Eawag_07115 Magic cues versus magic preferences in speciation Martine E. Maan1,2,3 and Ole Seehausen2,3 1 Centre of Behaviour and Neurosciences, Behavioural Biology, University of Groningen, Nijenborgh 7, 9747 AG Groningen, Netherlands 2 Eawag Centre of Ecology, Evolution and Biogeochemistry, Seestrasse 79, CH-6047 Kastanienbaum, Switzerland 3 Institute of Ecology and Evolution, University of Bern, Baltzerstrasse 6, CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland Corresponding author: Maan, M.E. ([email protected]) Abstract Question: How does divergent natural selection lead to divergence in mating traits and the evolution of reproductive isolation? Background: Ecological speciation of non-allopatric taxa usually requires the evolution of an association between selective mating and the traits underlying ecological adaptation. ‘Magic traits’ affect both ecological fitness and assortative mating and may therefore mediate rapid evolution of reproductive isolation. Problem: When assortative mating is mediated by separate preferences and cues, as opposed to being based on trait similarity (e.g. assortment by body size or habitat), pre-mating reproductive isolation between non-allopatric populations often requires divergence in both mating preferences and mating cues. Yet, most proposed cases of magic trait speciation rely on observation of divergent mating cues alone, leaving the consequences for reproductive isolation uncertain. Solution: We propose that a distinction should be made between mating cues and mating preferences when documenting divergent natural selection
    [Show full text]