A Constructivist Grounded Theory Investigation of College Student Response to Planetary Ecological Crises
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst Doctoral Dissertations Dissertations and Theses 12-18-2020 Making Meaning in the Anthropocene: A Constructivist Grounded Theory Investigation of College Student Response to Planetary Ecological Crises Kristen Nelson University of Massachusetts Amherst Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/dissertations_2 Part of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning Commons Recommended Citation Nelson, Kristen, "Making Meaning in the Anthropocene: A Constructivist Grounded Theory Investigation of College Student Response to Planetary Ecological Crises" (2020). Doctoral Dissertations. 2066. https://doi.org/10.7275/k5ft-tv60 https://scholarworks.umass.edu/dissertations_2/2066 This Open Access Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Dissertations and Theses at ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Making Meaning in the Anthropocene: A Constructivist Grounded Theory Investigation of College Student Response to Planetary Ecological Crises A Dissertation Presented By KRISTEN E. NELSON Submitted to the Graduate School of the University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY September 2020 Education © Copyright by Kristen E. Nelson 2020 All Rights Reserved Making Meaning in the Anthropocene: A Constructivist Grounded Theory Investigation of College Student Response to Planetary Ecological Crises A Dissertation Presented By KRISTEN E. NELSON Approved as to style and content by: ___________________________________________________ Ryan S. Wells, Chair ___________________________________________________ Chrystal A. George Mwangi, Member ___________________________________________________ Brian A. Lickel, Member ________________________________________________ Jennifer Randall Associate Dean of Academic Affairs College of Education DEDICATION In gratitude, I dedicate this study to two sets of conversational partners that have sustained me through writing this dissertation: To the intellectual community, most of whom I’ve never met, that has fed me for many years through their articles, books, websites, podcasts, and newsletters. And to the fourteen individuals who volunteered to be participants in this study. Since our first two-hour conversation, I’ve had the great pleasure of thinking with you, through your stories, artifacts, and musings. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS One strange byproduct of completing my dissertation during the Covid-19 global pandemic is that I was able to do my dissertation defense remotely. I was therefore able to invite all kinds of people to attend from near and far who are important to me and have cheered me on during the thirteen years of my doctoral program. (I am also able to count myself among the relatively few people, I imagine, who have defended their dissertations in their bare feet, a privilege that felt appropriate for a study in which Being at Home on the Planet is a core category.) My Zoom defense allowed me to share this experience with friends and family. It now occurs to me, in writing my acknowledgements, that one outcome of living on the planet for a long time is that the boundaries between the categories of “friend” and “family” become more blurred and irrelevant. Friends are family; family members are friends. First, I want to state my gratitude to every person who was there at my defense, and those there in spirit. Each of those individuals is important to me in their own unique way. Thank you to my dissertation committee – Ryan Wells, Chrystal George Mwangi, and Brian Lickel – for your guidance and support. My dissertation topic has been simmering inside me for a long time. I had the right collection of people – smart and heartfelt – to help me bring it to completion. In particular, I want to thank my Chair and Advisor, Ryan Wells, for the many helpful conversations over the years as I continued to bring definition to my ideas, and to ultimately connect those ideas to a qualitative study. v I want to thank my colleagues and friends at UMass Amherst, within the many communities that make up my life there. At Civic Engagement and Service- Learning we’re doing the hard work of authentically showing up for each other, both through challenge and support, and daring to acknowledge within an academic setting the presence of love in our work. Thank you for helping me hop, hop, hop! I’m also lucky to have the intellectual and soul support of the no-longer-fledgling- but-now-really-growing Contemplative Pedagogy Working Group at UMass Amherst. Thank you as well to my fellow doctoral students on this journey, providing words of commiseration and support. In particular, thank you to my good friends and study buddies Renee Falls and Cathy Manly, from library carrel to Zoom screen, always there, and to Rebecca Clemente for cheering me on. Finally, I am especially fortunate to have met Madeleine Charney and Lena Fletcher at a time when I needed to move from thinking to doing. Together we embarked on three years of coordinating Talking Truth: Finding Your Voice Around the Climate Crisis, a multifaceted program designed to engage people in multiple ways in their responses to climate change. Clearly that provided fertile ground, and deepening friendship, as I developed my ideas. Beyond campus, thank you to Friends of Reusable Bags, in Greenfield, Massachusetts, another opportunity to do practical, hands-on work, this time in my home town. Now that the reusable bag ban, due to the pandemic, has lifted, I hope we can get back to work soon. Thank you to Glenn Johnson for being my “tech nanny” in the early days of transitioning to a digital workflow. Thank you to my long time Farm & Wilderness friends Susan Thompson and Jason Healy. And thank you to vi the “Buffaloes,” my lifelong close circle of friends, for the many, many long conversations, since the beginning of time, but especially during these thirteen years as I soldiered on. It’s fitting that the seeds for this study began at Harvard Divinity School, and in my work at the Oral History Center in Cambridge, Massachusetts, where we all met. I want to thank my parents, Rudy and Shirley Nelson, for being really good parents, for being my friends and thinking partners, and, most important, for always welcoming and liking my friends! I’m especially thankful that you gently nudged me toward divinity school when my questions started to take shape. Thank you to my brothers, my sisters-in-law, my nieces, nephew, and grandnieces for all the laughter in my family. And families continue to evolve and blossom and send off new shoots. To Chuck Roberts, Charlotte Roberts, Sophie Bady-Kaye, and Bob Bady, and everyone you have brought into my life. You are my home on the planet. vii ABSTRACT MAKING MEANING IN THE ANTHROPOCENE: A CONSTRUCTIVIST GROUNDED THEORY INVESTIGATION OF COLLEGE STUDENT RESPONSE TO PLANETARY ECOLOGICAL CRISES SEPTEMBER 2020 KRISTEN E. NELSON, B.A., MACALESTER COLLEGE M.DIV., HARVARD DIVINITY SCHOOL M.Ed., UNIVERSITY OF MASSACHUSETTS BOSTON Ph.D., UNIVERSITY OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST Directed by: Professor Ryan S. Wells Higher education, with its core purpose in the generation and transmission of knowledge, has a particular role to play in society’s response to the global ecological crisis. Yet a key question is whether higher education is part of the problem or part of the solution. Sustainability educators insist that higher education, if it is to adequately address these challenges, must shift away from “mechanism” – a rationalist worldview that historically has shaped higher education’s culture and practices – toward an integrative worldview and epistemology that will guide teaching and learning in the new millennium. Emergent pedagogies and student development theories that are situated in an integrative epistemology are two resources within higher education that can support college students as they grapple with the personal, academic, professional, and existential challenges of the climate crisis. However, current research on college student responses to climate change is typically not centered in an integrative framework. It therefore does not provide the kind of knowledge that can engage with these viii emergent pedagogies and student development theories and practices to enhance their capacity to address the needs of college students within the context of the climate crisis. Using a conceptual framework derived from integrative worldview perspectives, this qualitative study employs constructivist grounded theory to investigate how emerging adults are making meaning of their lives within the context of the existential threats related to planetary ecological degradation. Through exploring connections among young adults’ feelings, thoughts and actions in their responses to the climate crisis, this study offers a conceptualization of identity, Planetary Identity, that is shaped by the reciprocal interrelationship of self and other, including the self in relationship with the other-than-human world. The study also engages in a preliminary exploration of possible connections between this conceptualization and integrative student development theories and integrative sustainability pedagogies. The aim of this exploration is to help initiate a conversation from both sides of higher education, academic affairs and