DOCSLIB.ORG

United States District Court Eastern District of New York ------X

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
United States District Court Eastern District of New York ------X Case 1:08-cv-04539-CPS-JO Document 66 Filed 01/13/09 Page 1 of 64 PageID #: <pageID> UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ----------------------------------------X Guy Molinari, William C. Thompson, Jr., individually and in his official capacity as the New York City Comptroller, Betsy Gotbaum, individually and in her official capacity as Public Advocate for the City of New York, Bill de Blasio, individually and in his official capacity as a member of the New York City Council, Letitia James, individually and in her official capacity as a member of the New York City Council, Charles Barron, individually and in his capacity as a member of the New York City Council, Rosalie Caliendo, Phillip Depaolo, Philip Foglia, Kent Lebsock, Mike Long, Tom Long, Sarah Lyons, Andrea Rich, Ida Sanoff, Gloria Smith, Eric Snyder, Luvenia Suber, Kenneth J. Baer, Kenneth A. Diamondstone, Peter Gleason, Mark Winston Griffith, Ari Hoffnung, Stanley Kalathara, Alfonso Quiroz, Ydanis Rodriguez, Jo Anne Simon, New York Public Interest Research Group, Inc., U.S. Term Limits, and Responsible New York, Plaintiffs, CV-08-4539 (CPS)(JO) - against - MEMORANDUM AND ORDER Michael R. Bloomberg, in his official capacity as Mayor of New York City, Christine C. Quinn, in her official capacity as Speaker of the New York City Council, The New York City Council, The City of New York, James J. Sampel, in his official capacity as president of the Commissioners of Elections for the Board of Elections in New York City, and Board of Elections of New York City, Defendants. ----------------------------------------X SIFTON, Senior Judge. Case 1:08-cv-04539-CPS-JO Document 66 Filed 01/13/09 Page 2 of 64 PageID #: <pageID> - 2 - Plaintiffs Guy Molinari, the New York City Comptroller, various members of the New York City Council who voted against Local Law 51, the Public Advocate, voters, prospective candidates, and good-government groups (“plaintiffs”) commenced this action against Michael Bloomberg (“Mayor Bloomberg”), Christine Quinn (“Speaker Quinn”), the City of New York, and other municipal entities (“defendants”),1 alleging violations of the First Amendment of the United States Constitution, the Fourteenth Amendment, the New York State Constitution, the Municipal Home Rule Law, and the New York City Charter.2 Plaintiffs seek a declaratory judgment that Local Law 51, amending the New York City Charter provisions limiting the eligibility of the Mayor, members of the City Council, and other 1 For a detailed list of plaintiffs and defendants and their affiliations, see a prior opinion in this case at Molinari v. Bloomberg, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 101193, at *3-*7 (2008). 2The claims are as follows: (1) deprivation of First Amendment rights to a meaningful vote in violation of 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (“§ 1983”) (Claim I); (2) chilling of First Amendment rights to political expression in violation of § 1983 (Claim II); (3) denial of First Amendment rights to access to the ballot in violation of § 1983 (Claim III); (4) denial of Fourteenth Amendment rights to Due Process in violation of § 1983 (Claim IV); (5) disenfranchisement of voters in violation of Article I, § 1 of the New York State Constitution (Claim V); (6) violation of the requirement of Municipal Home Rule Law § 23(2) that voters approve fundamental changes to the City Council by referendum (Claim VI); (7) violation of the requirement of City Charter § 38 that voters approve fundamental changes to their electoral and governmental structure (Claim VII); (8) actions in excess of the powers of the City Council under Municipal Home Rule Law §§ 10, 23 and City Charter §§ 23, 38, and 40 (Claim VIII); (9) violating the public policy of New York expressed in City Charter §§ 38, 1137, 1138 (Claim IX); (10) conflicts of interest on the part of Council Members in violation of City Charter § 2604(b)(3) (Claim X); (11) conflicts of interest on the part of Mayor Bloomberg in violation of City Charter § 2604(b)(3) (Claim XI); and (12) knowingly aiding and abetting the Mayor’s violations of City Charter § 2604(b)(3) in violation of City Charter § 2604(b)(2) and Conflicts Board Rule 1-13(d)(Claim XII). Case 1:08-cv-04539-CPS-JO Document 66 Filed 01/13/09 Page 3 of 64 PageID #: <pageID> - 3 - elected officials to run for office, is unconstitutional and in violation of Municipal Law and the City Charter and an injunction barring the Board of Elections from listing City officials who have served two consecutive terms in office on the ballot in the 2009 City elections. Now before the Court are defendants’ motion to dismiss this action pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) or, in the alternative, for summary judgment pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56, and plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment pursuant to the same rule. For the reasons stated below, defendants’ motion for summary judgment is granted, and plaintiffs’ motion is denied. BACKGROUND The following facts are drawn from the parties’ submissions in connection with this motion. Disputes are noted. In a 1993 city-wide referendum, New York City voters adopted an amendment to the City Charter instituting a two-term limit for city officials by a vote of 59% in favor versus 41% against, with over one million votes cast. Plaintiffs’ Statement of Material Facts at ¶ 4 (“SMF”); Swain Decl. at ¶ 4(a). The City Charter was accordingly amended to state that it was the public policy of the City of New York to limit the eligibility to run for office of the Mayor, public advocate, comptroller, borough presidents or council members to persons who had not served to or more Case 1:08-cv-04539-CPS-JO Document 66 Filed 01/13/09 Page 4 of 64 PageID #: <pageID> - 4 - consecutive terms in the office they sought to fill.3 In 1996, City Council members presented a proposal to City voters in a referendum seeking to extend term limits from two terms to three terms, which voters rejected by a margin of 54% against versus 46% in favor. SMF at ¶¶ 5, 7; Swain Decl. at ¶ 4(b). At an October 2, 2008 press conference, Mayor Bloomberg announced his plan to support a City Council legislative proposal to alter term limits and to run for reelection, citing the impending economic crisis as the justification. Ex. 28, Press Release, Mayor Bloomberg Addresses New Yorkers About Term Limits, Office of the Mayor, October 2, 2008. The media reported extensive opposition by good-government groups, media columnists, and government officials to the change in the law.4 Local Law 51 (the “term-limits amendment”), amending New 3As enacted pursuant to the 1993 Referendum, the City Charter’s term- limits provisions provided, in pertinent part: § 1137. Public Policy. It is hereby declared to be the public policy of the City of New York to limit to not more than eight consecutive years the time elected officials can serve as mayor, public advocate, comptroller, borough president and council member so that elected representatives are “citizen representatives” who are responsive to the needs of the people and are not career politicians. § 1138. Term Limits. Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary contained in this charter, no person shall be eligible to be elected or to serve in the office of mayor, public advocate, comptroller, borough president or council member if that person has previously held such office for two or more consecutive terms (including in the case of council member at least one four-year term), unless one full term or more has elapsed since that person last held such office... 4See, e.g., Ex. 32, Keith B. Richburg, Bloomberg Is Said to Seek Reelection Despite Term Limit, Wash. Post., October 1, 2008, at A2; Ex. 36, Michael Barbaro, Big Change at Hand, Political Pugilists Are Unusually Calm, N.Y. Times, October 4, 2008, at B1; Ex. 37, David Chen, Clinton: Path is ‘Disturbing’, N.Y. Times, October 16, 2008, at A 36. Case 1:08-cv-04539-CPS-JO Document 66 Filed 01/13/09 Page 5 of 64 PageID #: <pageID> - 5 - York City Charter §§ 1137-38 to extend the number of terms an official could serve consecutively from two to three terms, was introduced on October 7, 2008, “by request of the mayor.” SMF at ¶ 10; N.Y. City Council Introduction 845 of 2008. On October 9, 2008, plaintiff Council members de Blasio, James, and Gotbaum submitted a request for an advisory opinion to the Conflicts of Interest Board of the City of New York (the “Board”), seeking an opinion on whether the City Charter’s conflicts-of-interest provisions would bar term-limited City officials from enacting the term-limits amendment. See Oct. 9. 2008 Letter to Conflicts Board. On October 15, 2008, the Conflicts Board issued its opinion concluding that no violation of the conflicts laws existed or would occur. See Conflicts of Interest Board, Advisory Opinion No. 2008-3 (“COIB Op.”). On October 22, 2008, Council members de Blasio and James commenced a special proceeding against the Board and the City Council, pursuant to N.Y. C.P.L.R. Article 78, in the Supreme Court of New York County.5 They sought judicial review of the Board’s Advisory Opinion and provisional emergency injunctive relief to postpone a Council vote on the term-limits amendment. See Ex. 55, Transcript of October 22, 2008 hearing. Chief Justice Silbermann of the New York Supreme Court denied the application for a temporary restraining order and declined to sign the proposed order to show 5de Blasio et al. v. Conflicts of Interest Bd., Index No. 114189/08 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. County) (Silbermann, J.).
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Italian Americans, Others Call for New York to Honor Saint with Statue
    Italian Americans, others call for New York to honor saint with statue BROOKLYN, N.Y. (CNS) — The outrage over the snubbing of St. Frances Xavier Cabrini by New York City first lady Chirlane McCray’s She Built NYC commission culminated in a march and Mass Oct. 6 to support a public statue of Mother Cabrini, as the patron saint of immigrants is best known. More than 1,000, including many Italian Americans, joined the march in Brooklyn’s Carroll Gardens section led by Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio of Brooklyn and Msgr. David Cassato, director of the Brooklyn Diocese’s Italian Apostolate. Afterward, Bishop DiMarzio celebrated Mass at Sacred Hearts-St. Stephen Church. The march showed support for Mother Cabrini after she wasn’t selected as one of first seven women to have a statue built in their honor by the She Built NYC project, an initiative that aims to increase the number of statues of women in New York City. Mother Cabrini received the most nominations of any of the 320 women nominated, and yet she was passed over. Jane Meyer, a spokeswoman for Mayor Bill de Blasio, said She Built NYC didn’t rely just on the number of public nominations. Instead, it took a “holistic” approach, she said, taking into consideration the advice of a 19-person committee that represented a diverse group of people with a broad range of expertise and backgrounds. “There wasn’t one particular lever that was pulled more than another,” Meyer said. “Maybe it wasn’t clear along the way that it wasn’t the most vote gets it.” Bishop DiMarzio said Mother Cabrini wouldn’t have asked for a statue herself, but noted a statue would honor the memory of immigrants and remind us of our responsibility to each other.
    [Show full text]
  • Philip Foglia, Esq. 1951
    Philip Foglia, Esq. 1951 - 2020 Philip Foglia, son of a highly decorated New York City Police Detective, was raised in the Belmont (Little Italy) section of the Bronx. He graduated from Mt. Carmel, Mt. St. Michael and Lehman College where he was student body president and valedictorian. While in college Mayor Lindsay appointed him to the City’s Diamond Jubilee Committee. In 1973 Phil was awarded a fellowship by the University of California for Economic Development. He attended Pace University Law School, evening division while working full time as Executive Director of the NY Center for Community Affairs administering employment programs in the Bronx. Phil graduated from Law School as an editor of the Law Review in 1980. Phil worked as a community organizer for the Council of Belmont Organizations (COBO), the Italian American Alliance and the Center for Ethnic Affairs. He was a member of Community Planning Board #6 and was appointed by Mayor Koch to the Council on Intergroup Relations, helping to ease tensions between various communities in the City. Upon admission to the Bar, Phil was appointed an Assistant District Attorney in the Bronx working in Appeals and Rackets where he ultimately was elevated to Deputy Chief of Economic Crimes and the Public Corruption Unit. He was cross designated as an Assistant United States Attorney under Rudolph Giuliani assigned to the Organized Crime and Public Corruption Strike Force for over four years. He was the primary prosecutor who sent various public officials to prison. In 1988, he was appointed Executive Assistant District Attorney for Investigations in Queens County.
    [Show full text]
  • Ordine Figli D'italia in America
    nysosia.org H K 7 2/'(1 ,21 “The Order* Sons of Italy in America is the oldest and largest organization of Italian American/ Men and Women in the United States and Canada” Official Publication of the Grand Lodge of New York, Largest Italian-American Fraternal Bi-Monthly in New York State VOL. 55 NOVEMBER - DECEMBER 2017 BLESSED CHRISTMAS HAPPY, HEALTHY 2018 25 TH ANNIVERSARY WINTER HARITY ALL ONOREES Wishing our OSIA family C B H the NNOUNCED Gift of Faith A the Blessing of Hope and Peace at Christmastime and throughout the New Year! State President Robert Ferrito & First Lady Lina Ferrito GALA EVENT SCHEDULED FOR Westchester County Legislators’ Italian Heritage and Culture Ceremonies honoring JANUARY 26, 2018 students who pursue Italian language in high schools of the County. State President HONORING Robert Ferrito also honored for his leader - VERA FERRARA GIROLAMI ship in the Italian American community. NATIONAL PRESIDENT , O RDER SONS & D AUGHTERS State Comptroller Hon. Thomas DiNapoli’s OF TALY IN MERICA I A Italian Heritage and Culture Night celebrat - ed at the Frank LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT AWARDEE Sinatra’s School of Performing Arts In ROBERT FONTI Astoria, where he paid tribute with accolades and citations to six SPECIAL RECOGNITION AWARDEE accomplished people: Elisabetta Calello, PHILIP FOGLIA , E SQ . Joseph DiPietro, Robert Ferrito, Jill Furillo, Hon. Daniel Nigro and Hon. Jimmy Vacca. Press Release on Page 11 Ordine Figli d’Italia in America DEADLINE FOR THE NEXT ISSUE The Golden Lion FEBRUARY Official Publication 9, 2018 New York Grand Lodge All articles for publication must be typed and double spaced.
    [Show full text]
  • GENERAL ELECTION a Non-Partisan Guide to Informed Voting
    01Cover 10/24/05 1:26 PM Page 2 Citizens Union Voters Directory GENERAL ELECTION A Non-Partisan Guide to Informed Voting TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 8, 2005 BOARD OF DIRECTORS Richard J. Davis, Chair Robert Abrams James J. Harrington Malcolm MacKay Luis Garden Acosta Gail Hilson H. Carl McCall John Avlon Chung-Wha Hong Tom Osterman Edward Bautista John Horan John G. Proudfit Henry T. Berger Amabel B. James Bruce Rabb Joel Berger Robert M. Kaufman Anusha Rasalingam Richard Briffault Robert G. M. Keating Luis O. Reyes Lucy Cabrera, Ph.D. Eric Lee Torrance Webster Robinson Noreen Connell Nathan Leventhal Alan Rothstein Christina R. Davis Harold Levy Peter J.W. Sherwin Helena Rose Durst Ogden N. Lewis Edward C. Swenson Gail Erickson Mark Lieberman Karen Washington Edythe W. First Gena Lovett David L. Fogel Theodore S. Lynn LOCAL CANDIDATES COMMITTEE John Horan, Chair Miriam Adelman Nicole Dooskin Rita Kardeman Marc Norman Albert Asfazadour Kevin Duffy Patricia Killen Tom Osterman Scott Avidon Aine Duggan Peter Killen Anne Perkins Thomas Bach Gail Erickson David Charles Klein J. Robert Pigott Jessica Barclay- Lyle Frank Raymond Knowles John G. Proudfit Strobel Martin Gallent Adam Kurtz Anusha Rasalingam Sally Barhydt Arthur Galub Eric Lee Luis O. Reyes Joel Berger Joseph Gapper Sandra Lespinasse Richard Ropiak David Brauner Luis Garden Acosta Mark Lieberman Kenneth Seplow Lucy Cabrera, Ph.D. Elaine Gerstein Perry Luntz Marjorie Shea Andrew Cantor Sally Goodgold Theodore Lynn Peter J.W. Sherwin William Cantwell Craig Gurian Grace Lyu-Volckhausen Robert Snyder Stephan Cotton James J. Harrington Michael Marigliano Edward C. Swenson Christina R. Davis Gail Hilson Kerry McCarthy Karen Washington Richard J.
    [Show full text]
  • The Graduate Student Advocate, December 1992, Vol. 4, No. 2
    City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works The Advocate Archives and Special Collections 12-1992 The Graduate Student Advocate, December 1992, Vol. 4, No. 2 How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/gc_advocate/45 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] Graduate '.. Student -1 City University of New York Volume 4 DECEMBER 1992 Number2 J .J Cuts for Students, .J Raises ~~- for Administrators! & THE MARGINALIZATION OF A ·msTORY .. At a time of severe budget crisis, many CUNY administrators are getting substantial pay raises. Some 20 senior-level administrators in the past two months have been given modified job positions and raises of up to $28,000 per year. The CUNY Central Office claims the raises are justified on the grounds that some administrators will have increased responsibility. At the September 30th meeting of the CUNY Board of Trustees, Dr. Robert Picken, Chair of the University Faculty that 1 Senate, expressed his belief in the face of such disastrous 4 I conditions on so many campuse·s, the administrative raises were "ill-timed and ill-considered." : j .... I At the Board meeting Picken gave a concise summary of the cumulative effects of the budget cuts on teaching conditions 1 at the campuses. He reported increases in class size retrenchment of faculty, and the general deterioration of th~ CUNY learning environment. Class size has forced many teachers to abandon collaborative learning techniques in favor of more lectures, multiple-choice tests and fewer writing assignments.
    [Show full text]
  • United States District Court Eastern District of New York ------X
    Case 1:08-cv-04539-CPS-JO Document 67 Filed 01/13/09 Page 1 of 12 PageID #: <pageID> UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ----------------------------------------X Guy Molinari, William C. Thompson, Jr., individually and in his official capacity as the New York City Comptroller, Betsy Gotbaum, individually and in her official capacity as Public Advocate for the City of New York, Bill de Blasio, individually and in his official capacity as a member of the New York City Council, Letitia James, individually and in her official capacity as a member of the New York City Council, Charles Barron, individually and in his capacity as a member of the New York City Council, Rosalie Caliendo, Phillip Depaolo, Philip Foglia, Kent Lebsock, Mike Long, Tom Long, Sarah Lyons, Andrea Rich, Ida Sanoff, Gloria Smith, Eric Snyder, Luvenia Suber, Kenneth J. Baer, Kenneth A. Diamondstone, Peter Gleason, Mark Winston Griffith, Ari Hoffnung, Stanley Kalathara, Alfonso Quiroz, Ydanis Rodriguez, Jo Anne Simon, New York Public Interest Research Group, Inc., U.S. Term Limits, and Responsible New York, Plaintiffs, CV-08-4539 (CPS)(JO) - against - MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER Michael R. Bloomberg, in his official capacity as Mayor of New York City, Christine C. Quinn, in her official capacity as Speaker of the New York City Council, The New York City Council, The City of New York, James J. Sampel, in his official capacity as president of the Commissioners of Elections for the Board of Elections in New York City, and Board of Elections of New York City, Defendants. ----------------------------------------X Case 1:08-cv-04539-CPS-JO Document 67 Filed 01/13/09 Page 2 of 12 PageID #: <pageID> - 2 - SIFTON, Senior Judge.
    [Show full text]
  • In September 2007
    State of New York Office of the Inspector General Investigation Regarding the Selection of Aqueduct Entertainment Group to Operate a Video Lottery Terminal Facility at Aqueduct Racetrack October 2010 Joseph Fisch State Inspector General State of New York Office of the Inspector General JOSEPH FISCH State Inspector General KELLY DONOVAN DENNIS MARTIN First Deputy Chief of Staff Inspector General NELSON R. SHEINGOLD PHILIP FOGLIA Chief Counsel Special Deputy Inspector General CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................ 1 A. ALLEGATION .............................................................................................................. 1 B. METHODOLOGY.......................................................................................................... 3 1. Investigative Steps.................................................................................................. 3 2. The Senate and AEG Lobbyist Carl Andrews File Lawsuits to Prevent Disclosure ..................................................................................................................................... 4 II. BACKGROUND ......................................................................................................... 8 A. HISTORY OF AQUEDUCT RACETRACK AND VIDEO LOTTERY TERMINAL FACILITY ..... 8 B. ENACTMENT OF CHAPTER 18 OF THE LAWS OF 2008 (TAX LAW § 1612(E))............. 11 C. PROCUREMENT IN NEW YORK STATE ......................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Italian Creativity Celebrating 50 Years of Science and Technology; New York World’S Fair 1965 – Expo Milano 2015
    Free Issue All Things Italian in New York Year 3, Issue 7-8 September-October 2015 $ 4.50 Watch us on i-Italy | TV NYC lIFE - Channel 25: WEB TV: Saturdays 11:30PM & go to www.i-ItalyTv.com Sundays 1:00PM ApplE TV: in the NYC metropolitan download our iPhone app area on all cable operators and connect to your Tv and on the airto your Tv Cover art: John DeSantis John art: Cover Italian Creativity Celebrating 50 Years of Science and Technology; New York World’s Fair 1965 – Expo Milano 2015. Insert NEW! The 2015 A special issue dedicated to Events Calendar sponsored A DIFFERENT Italy, by the Italian Heritage DIverse Italians & Culture Anthony Julian Tamburri, Fred Kuwornu, Committee Jaqueline Greves Monda, Jerry Krase, Paul Moses, of New York. John Viola, Maria Bartiromo, Peter Vallone Sr. Events Dining Out & In Ideas Tourism Italy in New York: Sicilian Magic in the Living Italian in New Baroque Sicily. When Culture, Art, and Big Apple. Restaurants, York: Fashion, Design, History and Art Join Special Events pizzerias, and more Books & Music Forces — and Win P 101 Contents staff&info Free Issue All Things Italian in New York Year 3, Issue 7-8 September-October 2015 $ 4.50 Watch us on i-Italy | TV NYC LIFE - Channel 25: WEB TV: ➜ Saturdays 11:30PM & go to www.i-ItalyTv.com Sundays 1:00PM 20 APPLE TV: in the NYC metropolitan download our iPhone app area on all cable operators and connect to your Tv and on the airto your Tv Maria Bartiromo: Caring ➜44 Cover art: John DeSantis art:John Cover Official Events and Italian For Your Roots Creativity Focus ■ by Lucia Pasqualini Proclamations Celebrating 50 Years of Science and Technology; New York World’s Fair 1965 – Expo Milano 2015.
    [Show full text]
  • Bronx Times: October 12, 2012
    1 BRONX TIMES Oct. 11-17, 2012 wwwbxtimes.com 1 BRONX Oct. 11-17, 2012 To Advertise Call: 718-615-2520 Online: www.yournabe.com Free inside today nity classifieds s 26,29,31 Business Opps Pg 31 Instruction Pgs 27-29,31 Merchandise Pg 31 p Wanted • Financing / Loans • Career Training • Garage / Yard Sales The Bronx’s The Bronx’s elp Wanted • Business For Sale • Education Services • Merchandise Wanted elp Wanted • Misc. Business Opps • Tutoring • Merchandise For Sale • And More • And More • And More d Pg 30 Real Estate Pg 32 Services Pg 32 Automotive Pg 32 l, Commercial • Rentals • Beauty Care • Autos For Sale ntial Services • Properties For Sale • Handymen • Autos Wanted • Open Houses • Home Improvement • And More ovement • Commercial RE • And More torage • And More To Place Your Ad Call 718-615-2520 DICAL ➤ MEDICAL ➤ MEDICAL ➤ MEDICAL ➤ SALES 12 pages of Number One P WANTED HELP WANTED HELP WANTED HELP WANTED HELP WANTED Number One SALES OPPORTUNITIES Dental Assistant RN's, LPN's, BEAUTY Dist. for PAUL Dialysis Nurses/ Techs & MITCHELL, seeks exp'd, Orthodontist Office aggressive, self-motivated Psych Techs (With Exp) sales rep to service salons Work experience and references required, in Bronx. Est. territory. tification a plus. Must be highly energized, For Lincoln, Metropolitan & Kings Sal/Comm. PT, 3 days m player with positive attitude and excellent County Hospitals, Woodhull 914-921-1555 x 106 ustomer service and communication skills. Medical Center & multiple full Salary based on experience. Health, service clinics in Manhattan.
    [Show full text]
  • Investigation of the City University of New York Interim Report
    State of New York Office of the Inspector General Investigation of The City University of New York Interim Report November 2016 Catherine Leahy Scott Inspector General STAFF FOR THIS INVESTIGATION AND REPORT SPENCER FREEDMAN ILENE GATES Executive Deputy Inspector General Investigative Auditor (Downstate Region) MICHELE HOST Chief Counsel ANGELES OKEKE Investigative Auditor PHILIP FOGLIA (Downstate Region) Special Deputy Inspector General (Downstate Region) JASMIN JACK Investigative Auditor JESSICA SILVER (Downstate Region) Deputy Inspector General (Downstate Region) DONNALYNN GAZZA Investigator KENNETH MICHAELS (Downstate Region) Senior Investigative Counsel (Downstate Region) JAMES GIBSON Investigator VAL DOUGLAS (Downstate Region) Supervising Investigative Auditor (Downstate Region) ANNE PETERS DENNIS GRAVES Investigator Supervising Investigative Auditor (Downstate Region) (Upstate Region) ROBERTO SANTANA PETER AMAROSA Investigator Investigative Auditor (Downstate Region) (Upstate Region) EXECUTIVE SUMMARY On October 9, 2016, William C. Thompson, Jr., Chairperson of the CUNY Board of Trustees, formally requested that the New York State Inspector General commence a comprehensive investigation into a number of matters, including the use of City University of New York (CUNY) foundation funds; the relationship between CUNY’s colleges and their affiliated foundations and potential conflicts of interest; CUNY procurement policies; the hiring, expenses, and retention of consultants at CUNY; conflicts of interest at CUNY; and “all of the administrative
    [Show full text]
  • A Commission to Oversee Creation of New Mother Cabrini Statue Published on Iitaly.Org (
    A Commission to Oversee Creation of New Mother Cabrini Statue Published on iItaly.org (http://iitaly.org) A Commission to Oversee Creation of New Mother Cabrini Statue I. I. (October 25, 2019) Governor Andrew M. Cuomo appointed 19 members to a new commission that will oversee the creation of a statue honoring Mother Cabrini. The members will include Angelo Vivolo of the Columbus Heritage Coalition and Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio of the Brooklyn Diocese. The Governor announced the State will commit up to $750,000 for the project and will issue a request for proposals for the design of the new statue. "Mother Cabrini was a great New Yorker and a great Italian-American immigrant who did untold good for the people of this state, and there is no doubt she is deserving of a statue in her honor," Governor Cuomo said. "With the help of this new commission, we are going to get this done to help ensure Mother Cabrini's legacy of service to her community and those who are less fortunate is remembered for generations to come." The commission will provide recommendations to the Governor pertaining to the design, location and installation of the new memorial. The State's requests for proposals will seek ideas for the overall design and the statue's exact location. The commission will initiate broad outreach to the art community as soon as possible, including contacting art institutions and organizations as well as direct artist outreach. Once the design proposals are reviewed by the commission, the commission will select the finalists and present those to Governor Cuomo, who will make the final selection.
    [Show full text]
  • Rezoning Adds Life to Wasteland
    1 BRONX TIMES May 10-16, 2012 TIMES May 1 BRONX May 10-16, 2012 To Advertise Call: 718-615-2520 Online: www.yournabe.com Free inside today nity classifieds s 26,29,31 Business Opps Pg 31 Instruction Pgs 27-29,31 Merchandise Pg 31 p Wanted • Financing / Loans • Career Training • Garage / Yard Sales The Bronx’s The Bronx’s elp Wanted • Business For Sale • Education Services • Merchandise Wanted elp Wanted • Misc. Business Opps • Tutoring • Merchandise For Sale • And More • And More • And More d Pg 30 Real Estate Pg 32 Services Pg 32 Automotive Pg 32 l, Commercial • Rentals • Beauty Care • Autos For Sale ntial Services • Properties For Sale • Handymen • Autos Wanted • Open Houses • Home Improvement • And More ovement • Commercial RE • And More torage • And More To Place Your Ad Call 718-615-2520 DICAL ➤ MEDICAL ➤ MEDICAL ➤ MEDICAL ➤ SALES 12 pages of Number One P WANTED HELP WANTED HELP WANTED HELP WANTED HELP WANTED Number One SALES OPPORTUNITIES Dental Assistant RN's, LPN's, BEAUTY Dist. for PAUL Dialysis Nurses/ Techs & MITCHELL, seeks exp'd, Orthodontist Office aggressive, self-motivated Psych Techs (With Exp) sales rep to service salons Work experience and references required, in Bronx. Est. territory. tification a plus. Must be highly energized, For Lincoln, Metropolitan & Kings Sal/Comm. PT, 3 days m player with positive attitude and excellent County Hospitals, Woodhull 914-921-1555 x 106 ustomer service and communication skills. Medical Center & multiple full Salary based on experience. Health, service clinics in Manhattan. Call 401k benefits available. 718-615-2520 Miracles Can Happen SmartSource Call Maria 917-826-5200 or send resume: To Advertise [email protected] 718-693-2600 Here Classifieds Dependable Sports Home Care me Health Aides (Bilingual a plus) /PCA Coordinators Bi-Lingual h/English, Chinese/English & Creole/English) HHA Core Aides Needed coupons Per Diem: Occupational Therapist Per Diem: Physical Therapist al Social Workers (Immediately in All Boros) Pages 32-36 eceptionist Position Available...Bilingual IMMEDIATE EMPLOYMENT pt.
    [Show full text]