Impacts of Early Land-Use on Streams of the Santa Cruz Mountains: Implications for Coho Salmon Recovery
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Impacts of early land-use on streams of the Santa Cruz Mountains: implications for coho salmon recovery San Lorenzo Valley Museum collection Talk Outline • Role of San Lorenzo River in coho salmon recovery • History of 19th century land-use practices • How these disturbances impacted (and still impact) ecosystem function and salmon habitat Central California Coast ESU Lost Coast – Navarro Pt. Coho salmon Diversity Strata Navarro Pt. – Gualala Pt. Coastal San Francisco Bay Santa Cruz Mountains Watersheds with historical records of Coho Salmon Dependent populations Tunitas Independent populations San Gregorio Pescadero Gazos Waddell Scott San Vicente Laguna Soquel San Lorenzo Aptos Land-use activities: 1800-1905 Logging: the early years • Pit and whipsaw era (pre-1842) – spatially limited, low demand – impacts relatively minor • Water-powered mills (1842-1875) – Demand fueled by Gold Rush – Mills cut ~5,000 board ft per day = 10 whip sawyers – Annual cut 1860 = ~10 million board ft • Steam-powered mills (1876-1905) – Circular saws doubled rate to ~10,000 board ft/day x 3-10 saws – Year-round operation (not dependent on water) – Annual cut 1884 = ~34 million board ft – Exhausted timber supply Oxen team skidding log on corduroy road (Mendocino Co. ca 1851) Krisweb.com Oxen team hauling lumber at Oil Creek Mill San Lorenzo Valley Museum collection oldoregonphotos.com San Vicente Lumber Company (ca 1908): steam donkey & rail line Santa Cruz Museum of Art & History Loma Prieta Mill, Mill Pond, and Rail Line (ca 1888) Santa Cruz Museum of Art & History The Saw-Dust Nuisance “We have always maintained that lumberman dumping their refuse timber and saw-dust into the San Lorenzo River and its tributaries were committing a nuisance. They are destroying the fish and poisoning the water for human use. A dumb brute has too much sense to drink from the water fresh and inky black from a saw-dust pile…. Poisoned water is slow poison to the drinker thereof….” Santa Cruz Sentinel - 3 November 1877 Known sawmill & shingle mill sites in Santa Cruz Mountains: 1840-1905 San Gregorio Pescadero Gazos Waddell Scott Soquel San Lorenzo Aptos Corralitos Based on Rood (1975) Other Early Human Disturbances California Powder Works CPW Dam CPW Flume CPW Tunnel California Powder Works Dam http://www.santacruzpl.org/history/articles/513/ San Lorenzo Paper Mill http://www.santacruzpl.org/history/articles/545/ Tanneries Lime Kilns Influence of large wood on channel form Low-gradient riffle Ephemeral secondary channel High-flow bank Lateral scour pool Plunge pool Flow High-gradient riffle Backwater pools Dam pool 6 ft Influence of large wood on channel form Low-gradient riffle Ephemeral secondary channel High-flow bank Lateral scour pool Plunge pool Flow High-gradient riffle Backwater pools Dam pool Influence of large wood on channel form Low-gradient riffle Ephemeral secondary channel High-flow bank Lateral scour pool Plunge pool Flow High-gradient riffle Backwater pools Dam pool Loss of structure/function Low-gradient riffle Disconnected secondary channel High-flow bank Flow High-gradient riffle Backwater pool Lingering impacts • Loss of in-channel LWD • Loss of wood recruitment through time • Loss of wood retention capacity • Loss of sediment/water retention capacity • Disconnection of streams from floodplains Conclusions • LARGE woody material is critical to stream function • Restoring these functions is complicated in urban/semi-urban settings • Can’t go back, but can be strategic about moving forward • Road to recovery will be long and slow Habitat Complexity + Abundant Populations Life History Diversity Resistance + Resilience Prairie Creek: relationship between juvenile population size and habitat use Bjorkstedt, Duffy, Szerlong, unpub. data Pools Runs Riffles Prairie Creek coho juveniles 110 Age-2 migrants 105 100 Age-1 migrants 95 90 85 80 Age-1 migrants 75 Fork length (mm) length Fork 70 65 Age-1 non-migrants 60 55 Jan 1999 Jan Oct 1999 Oct Nov 1998 Nov 1999 Nov Mar 1999 Mar 2000 Mar May 1999 May 2000 May Date From Bell (2001) 1840s – 1875 Era of water-powered sawmills – fueled by increasing demand from gold rush – Dramatically accelerated pace – Fallers built beds of small trees to “break” the fall and avoid splintering – Drag crews would often burn brush and slash around the site, then build a skid road – Oxen used to drag logs downslope t skid rows at bottom of gullies. – Logs brought to mills using oxen on “corduroy” skid trails, often in stream bed – Logs transferred to mill ponds; water powered “muley” saws – Transportation limits meant logging generally took place within a couple miles of the mills. Mills then moved to new locations. – Lumber transported to markets by horse or mule – Era dominated by water-powered mills; seasonal operation – Sawdust and refuse disposed of in streams 1876-1905: the peak years Era of steam-powered sawmills, railroad expansion, transition to steam donkeys – Steam-powered mills w/circular saws replacing water-powered mills (operate year-round) – Steam donkeys, oxen as primary means of getting logs to mill sites beginning latter 1880s – Broadcast burning to remove debris and facilitate removal of logs down skid trails – Consolidation of mills into larger lumber companies – Extensive railroad development – 1884 – 34 million board feet cut by 28 sawmills in SC Mountains. – By 1905, nearly all SC Mtn redwood forest had been cut • Tanneries (http://www.santacruzpl.org/history/articles/269/) • Bausch beer gardens lost business on the days a nearby winery dumped pungent tailings in the creek. And the river ran red when Kron's tannery emptied a tanbark vat. Situk River Duck Creek Cook Inlet Sashin Creek Kake Bake Creek Porcupine Creek Locations of coho nomads Carnation Creek rearing in stream-estuary ecotones or estuaries Lint Slough Modified from Koski (2009) South Slough Freshwater Creek Scott Creek? From Ebersole et al. 1997. Envir. Mgt. 21:1-14. From Ebersole et al. 1997. Envir. Mgt. 21:1-14. CA Forest Practices Act 1974 P P P Habitat potential capacity of P P P the landscape Soquel flood, LWD removal 1982 Late 1800s Present Time Hatchery P P P Habitat potential capacity of P P P the landscape 1970s Present Time .