a
retail MONTGOMERY COUNTY Retail Strategy Q3 2017
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 b ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
SPECIAL THANKS TO THE FOLLOWING PEOPLE WHO CONTRIBUTED THEIR KNOWLEDGE TO THIS STUDY:
Judy Stephenson - Office of the County Executive - Montgomery County Lily Qi - Office of the County Executive - Montgomery County Gary Erenrich - Montgomery County Department of Transportation CLIENT TEAM (MCDOT) Gwen Wright - Director, Montgomery County Planning Department Rose Krasnow -Deputy Director, Montgomery County Planning Department Rick Liu - Montgomery County Planning Department Roberto Ruiz - Montgomery County Planning Department Amy Lindsey - Montgomery County Planning Department Caroline McCarthy - Montgomery County Planning Department Jacob Sesker - Montgomery County Council (formerly at Montgomery County Economic Development Corporation [MCEDC]) Richelle Wilson - Montgomery County Economic Development Corporation CONSULTANT TEAM (MCEDC) Robert Kronenberg -Montgomery County Planning Department Patrick Butler - Montgomery County Planning Department Matthew Folden - Montgomery County Planning Department Christina Sassaki - Montgomery County Parks Department Patricia McManus - Montgomery County Parks Department Kathie Durbin - Montgomery County Department of Liquor Control Simni Rasolee - Montgomery County Department of Permitting Services Matthew Shanks - Montgomery County Department of Permitting Services
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 INTRODUCTION 1 c
PURPOSE 2 ROCKVILLE 54
SETTING THE STAGE 3 SILVER SPRING 59
SUPPLY-BASED TERMINOLOGY 4 WEST COUNTY 64
DEMAND-BASED TERMINOLOGY 7 WHEATON-GLENMONT 68 WHITE OAK 73 RETAIL ENVIRONMENT 8
RETAIL TRENDS 9 REGULATION IMPACT ANALYSIS 77 RETAILER DECISION MAKING 14
REGULATORY RECOMMENDATIONS 78 COUNTY RETAIL TOPICS 16
MONTGOMERY COUNTY RETAIL HISTORY 17 CONCLUSIONS 84
MONTGOMERY COUNTY REGIONAL STANDING 18 METHODOLOGY 87 REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT 19
INVENTORY SUMMARY 20 TECHNICAL APPENDIX 90 SUBMARKET ASSESSMENTS 23 LOCAL RETAIL INTERVIEW FINDINGS 91 BUSINESS AID ORGANIZATIONS 98 SUBMARKETS DEFINED 24 SUBMARKET DEMAND TABLES 101 ASPEN HILL 25
BETHESDA 29 contents EAST COUNTY 34 GAITHERSBURG 38
GERMANTOWN-CLARKSBURG 42
KENSINGTON 46
OLNEY 50
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
MAJOR FINDINGS that serve a diverse range of populations. eventually become oversaturated with The County can continue to distinguish aging or underperforming retail. This Following a ninth-month study and analysis itself within the DC area by embracing this condition contributes to higher levels of of existing, under construction, proposed, diversity as part of its market distinction. vacancy, lower rental rates, and declining and potential retail throughout Montgomery These diverse populations contribute to the overall sales. The County should prioritize County, the following conclusions were overall spending economy and are integral the repositioning of existing space in reached. to developing an equally diverse range tandem with new development to avoid this 1. Montgomery County is in good retail of retail to serve Montgomery County’s phenomenon in future years. health. Unlike other counties across the neighborhoods and businesses. The United States, Montgomery County has County will benefit from focusing on the 3. Continue to condense retail at major Retail in Montgomery reined in retail development to a larger development and support of these unique intersections. County has historically clustered at major degree, which has resulted in maintaining small businesses, as these businesses are intersections—roads that once were critical relative equilibrium currently and at 5- market differentiators for the DC area. trade routes and are now major commuter and 10-year increments for most of the Additionally, as supportable retail square thoroughfares. Moving forward, clustering 12 submarkets studied. Retail demand footage continues to shrink, these small will remain a sustainable retail development is condensing all over the United States, businesses will become the viable option to strategy. This development goal is which is having a particularly heavy effect best serve the neighborhoods throughout particularly relevant in areas with upcoming on large format, national retailers. These the county. development, such as Germantown- retailers are dealing with the repercussions Clarksburg and White Oak. of overexpansion and shrinking demand. MAJOR RECOMMENDATIONS Montgomery County submarkets, generally, Major recommendations for each submarket The major findings and recommendations are not over-supplied to an extreme fall within the following three major themes: within this report provide context and a deeper degree—a plight that other Metropolitan understanding of how the various submarkets DC jurisdictions are facing right now. 1. Encourage the repositioning of are functioning independently and how they underperforming retail into Neighborhood interact with one another. All together, these 2. There is an opportunity to redistribute Goods & Services retail. Many submarkets major findings present the broad view of how the retail categories. There is room within are oversupplied in the General the County can continue to manage its retail the Montgomery County retail supply Merchandise, Apparel, Furniture, and economy and take advantage of opportunities to shift uses away from general goods Other (GAFO) retail category in part due for innovation and advancement. retail (e.g. clothing, household furniture, to the large number of large format stores electronics) to neighborhood-serving retail throughout the county. As stores within (e.g. grocery, pharmacies, and salons) this category continue to decrease overall within every submarket. This finding square footage nationally and e-commerce presents an opportunity for Montgomery trends continue to threaten brick and County to serve as a model within the mortar sales, these retail locations should DC Metropolitan area as a municipality transition into neighborhood-serving retail. that effectively manages its retail stock to maximize the benefit to its constituents. 2. Prioritize the redevelopment of aging 3. Montgomery County should embrace its or outdated retail space. When new diverse retail supply. Montgomery County development is built while existing contains a true wealth of small businesses development is left to age, retail markets
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 LIMITED GROWTH IN RETAIL DEMAND
Throughout Montgomery County, the retail supply compared to demand is generally at equilibrium. The chart below demonstrates supply and demand for each submarket currently, in 2020, and in 2025. Several submarkets, notably Bethesda/Chevy Chase/North Bethesda, Rockville, Silver Spring, and West County, are currently under supplied, while Gaithersburg should reposition a portion of its supply to other street-activating uses such as medical offices, daycares, and office space that opens onto the street. The Bethesda and Rockville submarkets are projected to experience the most substantial demand for growth. The breakdown of demand by retail type can be found in the Submarket Assessments section starting on page 23.
Aspen Hill Bethesda/Chevy Chase/North Bethesda East County
Gaithersburg
Germantown/ Clarksburg
Kensington
Olney
Rockville
Silver Spring
West County
Wheaton- Glenmont
White Oak
SQUARE FEET 0 500 1M 2M 3M 4M 5M 6M
2016 2020 2025 2016 Demand Demand Demand Supply Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 This page is intentionally left blank. one INTRODUCTION 2 PURPOSE OF THIS STUDY
Retail establishments have a critical impact on The purpose of this study is to: • What national trends are emerging daily life – from providing goods and services that will spur or stall retail growth in to serving as places where residents, office • Identify Montgomery County’s retail Montgomery County? workers, visitors and students intersect on a submarkets from a macro perspective regular basis. that broadly describes its retail • As one of the most desirable environment; retail submarkets in the country, Traditionally, retail space has been an Montgomery County is frequently a afterthought in the planning and development • Document the type, location and first location for retail prototypes. How processes, often added to supplement amount of retail in the county; can the County maintain a balanced other uses or activate the ground level of a supply and demand of retail within • Perform a series of diagnostic building. Among other DC area jurisdictions, each submarket in light of trends assessments of the county’s existing Montgomery County has emerged as a disrupting traditional, brick-and- retail conditions, including submarket- pioneer in using development practices mortar retail environments (such as level analysis of sales and spending; to minimize the oversupply of retail. The e-commerce, transition to retail as connection between sales and need, • Process and evaluate the data entertainment, placemaking, etc.)? ever-changing market conditions, and gathered; Which submarkets will be most the importance of remaining regionally impacted by these changes? competitive in metropolitan Washington, DC • Project future performance given local are all factors that play a role in retail viability and national trends; This study provides information and direction within Montgomery County. for Montgomery County’s stakeholders of • Recommend a series of strategies for every definition to make informed decisions County agencies, developers, property regarding retail conditions and potential. This owners and retailers to continue to study was broken down into 12 submarkets support Montgomery County’s long- based on a market assessment of existing term retail prosperity. retail clusters. In the process of supporting retail fundamentals throughout its urban, In addition to this data-driven evaluation, the suburban-urban, suburban and rural study addresses a series of issues specific to neighborhoods, Montgomery County will retail conditions in Montgomery County. further secure its position as a profitable and innovative environment for stores, services, • How, when and why should the County restaurants, cafes, as well as shopping and support existing and future small and dining. locally-owned businesses?
• Are there any regulatory or market barriers impeding successful business operations for retailers?
• What considerations are retailers applying to their site selection criteria, both within Montgomery County and
Bethesda Row, Downtown Bethesda regionally? Source: www.visitmontgomery.com Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 SETTING THE STAGE 3
WHAT IS RETAIL? for the exchange of goods and informally shops that once dotted most town centers Retail is defined as the sale of goods and/ allowed for the exchange of information and and main streets vanished from all but a or services for personal use (i.e., not for development of relationships throughout the few neighborhoods across the country. A resale). From a market perspective, the term community. Through these activities, a sense consequence of these changes is that local “retail” is narrower. This report defines retail of community was created, not only from retail operations became a less consistent as a commerce-driven entity that provides living in close proximity, but also from shared and secure investment. The movement of a good or service that is in one of three experiences and emotional investment in retail to make it more accessible for a regional categories: Neighborhood Goods & Services neighbors, now known as social capital. audience, as well as time limitations on (NG&S), Food & Beverage (F&B) and General modern consumers, has consequently made Transportation advancements and it so most stores are within arm’s reach, but Merchandise, Apparel, Furniture, & Other opportunities outside of the community (GAFO). many shopping centers have not maintained a loosened these social ties. Stores and quality or convenience-oriented retail mix. Within a neighborhood commercial district, restaurants that had been constructed at an certain types of ground-level uses are more intersection to satisfy an existing demand With the rapid evolution of retail environments effective at creating vibrant environments were no longer necessary or appropriate as caused by the emergence of e-commerce, as than others. Although tax preparation offices, transportation habits and patterns changed well as customers’ desires to return to retail daycare facilities, and catering businesses over time. Trading posts and general stores located at the center of their community, might technically be selling something, they became obsolete. Five-and-dime stores the Maryland-National Capital Park and are not considered “retail” for the purposes and their luncheonettes disappeared. Local Planning Commission is preparing to address of this report due to the nature of their movie houses, clothing stores and hobby proactively the impacts of this evolution on the services and how this methodology calculates retail market as we know it today. spending associated with retail stores. One goal of this report will be to investigate the course of retail across Montgomery County and determine ways to maintain and WHY IS RETAIL SO IMPORTANT? improve its vibrancy to invigorate communities Defining “community” was easy before we at their core. became so readily mobile. Clans, then tribes, then families lived in a centralized manner, gathered together primarily for security, provisions and division of labor. Almost incidentally, the practical purposes of these groups yielded intangible benefits—collective identity and pride.
The focal point of communities was, and often still is, a place of commerce. The market, town square and main street formally provided Fallsgrove Village Center, Rockville Source: www.fallsgrovevillagectr.com
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 4 SUPPLY-BASED TERMINOLOGY
To initiate this study, Streetsense conducted Food & Beverage (F&B): RETAIL-APPROPRIATE SPACE an inventory of all retail-appropriate space This category includes establishments that Spaces categorized as “retail-appropriate” within Montgomery County. Retail supply is serve food and/or alcohol consumed on have the following characteristics: a measurement of the amount of square premises. Retailers in the F&B category footage of retail-appropriate space and the include sit-down restaurants, cafes, bars, • Located at street level. coffee shops, sandwich shops, ice cream ability of the existing retailers in an area • Identifiable as having been constructed shops, “quick-bite” establishments, fast-food to support customer needs. The following for a retail purpose. A storefront or restaurants and similar uses. terminology details common phrases used evidence of an altered storefront throughout the document to describe retail. F&B establishments can attract customers typically indicates a space appropriate from a greater distance than NG&S retailers, for retail use. Converted ground-level especially when they are clustered. A larger residential space is often considered RETAIL CATEGORIES number of patrons will be interested in a “not retail appropriate,” as these locations are not regarded as desirable From the grocery store to the jewelry shop collection of F&B establishments that offer a by quality retail tenants) to the coffee shop, retailers have different variety of options. customer, space, parking, competition, • Visible from a street or pedestrian General Merchandise, Apparel, exposure and potential sales requirements. pathway or have highly visible Furnishings & Other (GAFO): In general, the following categories represent directional signage. This category includes establishments such as groups of retailers with similar needs. clothing stores, furniture stores, bookstores, When developing design guidelines and development packages, these characteristics Neighborhood Goods & Services (NG&S): jewelry stores, gift boutiques, pet stores, should be used as a baseline standard for retail This category includes establishments that sporting goods stores, home goods stores, design. depend on the patronage of local residents craft stores, antique shops, electronics stores, and workers, such as grocery stores, auto parts stores and similar uses. drugstores, florists, bakeries, specialty food GAFO retailers face a tremendous amount stores, delicatessens, butchers, dry cleaners, NON-RETAIL OCCUPIED SPACE of competition, both in stores and online, for laundromats, hair and nail salons, day spas, a relatively small percentage of household Under conditions where the available retail printers, pet salons, machine repair shops, expenditures. Successful GAFO stores attract space exceeds demand, non-retail users shoe repair shops and similar uses. customers from long distances. However, commonly occupy locations identified with retail tenants (storefront spaces, in particular). NG&S retailers rely on spending from nearby these stores also rely on the exposure and foot Non-retail users often found in ground-level residents, students and employees generally traffic generated by an anchor tenant that sites with street frontage include professional located within a one-mile radius. NG&S is draw people with the same customer profile. offices (attorneys, accountants, architects, “convenience-based” retail; it must be close, engineers and similar), daycare/educational with easy access, as these kinds of retail serve facilities, religious facilities, government daily and weekly needs. offices, and residences.
These tenants are generally not open to the public, do not offer goods or services without a prior appointment, and infrequently use the storefront area for display purposes.
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 CLASS OF SPACE CLASS A CLASS C 5 The quality of the ground-level retail space Space that meets the requirements for a Class Space that meets the requirements for a Class within a retail cluster is a critical measure in A rating typically has the following attributes: C rating typically has the following attributes: determining the ability of an area to attract tenants and support customer sales. For each • Located at a corner or prominently • Located among inline establishments. submarket, an inventory was undertaken to situated among inline establishments. • Floor-to-ceiling clear heights of less determine the amount and “retail-readiness” of • Floor-to-ceiling clear height of 14 feet than 12 feet. ground-level spaces. This evaluation provides or more. an assessment of the retail supply within each • Storefront width of less than 15 feet; submarket. • Storefront width of 20 feet or more. and. • Storefront depth of 65’ or more. • Diminished representation of factors Class of space is also predicated on whether listed for Class B space. the space meets the appropriate dimensions • Well-maintained. needed by retail. Specifically, ceiling heights • Clearly visible from primary streets. of 12 feet or more promote a retailer’s ability to maintain visibility from the street to the • Constructed with quality materials. BUILD-TO-SUIT back of the store, to provide adequate • Properly lit exterior and display spaces. Space that is listed as Build-to-Suit (BTS) has HVAC and sprinkler systems, and to use wall • Clear pedestrian and vehicular access. been constructed for a specific tenant or use graphics as a form of wayfinding. Additionally, in such a manner that conversion to another storefront depth of 65 feet or more allows for • Associated or adjacent parking. use or tenant would be difficult or impractical. back of house operations, including storage, This condition is common for suburban preparation space, restrooms and fitting CLASS B retailers, such as fast food restaurants and rooms. large format stores along primary roads. Many Space that meets the requirements for a Class Qualifying the total amount of existing retail of these spaces have unique architectural B rating typically has the following attributes: space currently in supply through a class styles specific to their brands. of space analysis provides insight into the • Well-situated among inline level of efficiency of the existing inventory. establishments. In most markets, it is typical to find retail MODIFIED INVENTORY establishments that maintain operations • Floor-to-ceiling clear height of in substandard spaces and locations. As approximately 12 feet or more. To account for possible adjustments in the new, higher quality space is constructed, • Storefront width of 15 feet or more; retail supply caused by changing demand, new the substandard space is often replaced or construction, and/or stronger competition, a • Well-maintained; and. converted to a non-retail use, but sometimes percentage of probability is assigned to each this retail space is left behind, filled by tenants • Diminished representation of factors class of retail space. This percentage assumes who require a low rent or left vacant for listed for Class A space. the likelihood that retail space currently in the extended periods of time. existing supply will remain. As retail markets are better able to capture expenditures, The following classifications are applied to the overall quality of space also improves. retail spaces that meet the listed criteria: The resulting calculation is known as the submarket’s “modified inventory.”
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 To calculate modified inventory, each retail Center, Middlebrook Square Shopping Center, Hybrid Centers: Increasingly, new retail 6 space receives a class of space designation Woodley Gardens Shopping Center and Saah development adapts to the needs of its (A, B, C or BTS). For each study area, the total Plaza. customer base. As a result, the best format is amount of retail for each class is multiplied by often a combination of the centers referenced an efficiency rating - Class A at 90 percent, Large Format Stores: Although the sizes above. A hybrid between a neighborhood Class B at 82 percent, Class C at 75 percent, of large format stores are shrinking, these center and a large format store/center is and BTS at 50 percent. This efficiency establishments are typically in excess of common throughout the county. Development acknowledges that a percentage of the 75,000 square feet. For the purposes of this trends indicate that a mix of retail uses across existing retail inventory is not well suited for study, any retailer identified as a “large format development types is increasingly common, retail under improved conditions and has the store” is in a stand-alone condition and not particularly as the “main street effect” makes potential to convert to a non-retail use, such included in any of the typologies listed. its way into suburban neighborhood centers. as a professional office or similar use, or be Examples include Germantown Commons, In town center redeveloped. Town Center Retail: Federal Plaza, and Olney Village Center. environments, retail occupies the ground The modified inventory adjustment is a critical level of mixed-use buildings with residences Online Retail/E-commerce: Retail within piece in evaluating the ability of the area’s or office spaces above. While they may be this typology is not represented in the retail buildings (supply) to accommodate the needs seeking to replicate traditional downtown inventory, but contributes to availability of of its customer base (demand). retail streets more commonly found in cities, goods and services within each neighborhood. new town centers are different in that all the Online retail or E-commerce represents RETAIL TYPOLOGIES retail space is collectively owned, managed approximately 8.4 percent of total retail sales.1 and leased. This same property owner or Retailers within the GAFO category are most Regional Shopping Center: Large format manager is typically charged with creating impacted by e-commerce vendors. stores connected by inline shopping centers, and maintaining sidewalks and parks for the typically enclosed and surrounded by parking. purposes of supporting placemaking in the All retailers are typically managed by a town center. Examples include Pike and Rose, OUTLET MALLS single entity. Examples include Westfield Downtown Crown, Rockville Town Square. Montgomery Mall, Westfield Wheaton Mall, The Clarksburg Premium Outlets were not RIO Washingtonian Center and Lakeforest Independent Establishments: Montgomery included in the inventory for this analysis. Mall. County’s commercial beginnings are still Outlet center demand is measured in reflected in the locally-owned stores and a significantly different manner than Neighborhood Center: Anchored by restaurants operating independently of a traditional retail. However, the impact of a grocery store or a large drugstore, larger strip center or shopping mall. Many of the Clarksburg Outlets on the ability of neighborhood centers often include a these businesses are located at crossroads adjacent submarkets to attract retail was mix of service-oriented and convenience- where general stores and post offices once studied extensively in this analysis. based shopping establishments. Examples stood. Examples include The Stonehouse Grill include Aspen Hill Shopping Center, Cabin in Gaithersburg and Country Boy Market in John Shopping Center, Montgomery Village Silver Spring. Crossing, Plaza del Mercado, Wintergreen Plaza and Potomac Place Shopping Center. Pad Sites: Often located along a major roadway and separated by parking from an Strip Center: A row of continuous retailers adjacent shopping center, pad sites are usually that are managed by a single entity. Although associated with fast food establishments, strip centers comprise a variety of tenants, it is car dealerships and banks. Examples include not unusual for these collections to be known Burger King, McDonald’s, TD Bank and Taco by the name of the center. Examples include Bell. 1. US Census Bureau, 2016 Quince Orchard Plaza, Laytonsville Shopping
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 DEMAND-BASED TERMINOLOGY 7
Unmet retail demand is a function of the by the Metropolitan Washington Council of that result from these considerations provide amount of spending generated by customers Governments (MWCOG) with input from the a starting point for understanding the existing minus the amount of retail supply (in this report, Montgomery County Planning Department and potential customer base for the retail the existing supply was modified with a class of provided a base for projecting future population market. These boundaries are evaluated space analysis). Unmet demand thus decreases growth for each submarket. These projections submarket by submarket and certain factors proportionately by the strength of the existing reflect historic growth trends, the current are weighed more heavily depending on the retail environment to meet these consumer housing inventory and pipeline development retail attributes of each submarket. As such, needs. The difference between supply and plans relevant to determining future residential each trade area is crafted based upon the demand is the unmet retail demand for an area. growth. MWCOG projections by traffic professional judgment of the consultant team, analysis zone (TAZ) did not match trade area and additional details can be found in each RETAIL DEMAND boundaries. Combinations of TAZs and portions submarket section. of TAZs were used to match the trade area Retail demand is measured by calculating each geographies. Projected MWCOG growth rates The Primary Trade Area (PTA) identifies submarket’s ability to attract expenditures were annualized and applied to the current the segments from which each submarket’s by populations who might reasonably and estimates provided by Sitewise. establishments draw a majority of their regularly patronize establishments under ideal regular sales. The percentage of household or improved conditions. Historical trends for office occupancy and expenditures captured by retailers is expected employment projections (provided by to be highest in its PTA. Convenience is a major Expenditures are determined from information MWCOG), along with direct information from factor for sales generated locally. Secondary gathered from the U.S. Census Bureau, Esri, previously completed studies about the and Tertiary Trade Areas delineate market U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Sitewise and shifting dynamic of office space in mixed- segments that will also attribute to sales Claritas, Inc., as appropriate. These total use environments impacted the submarket generated at respectively lower capture rates. estimated expenditures are multiplied by a growth projections. As previously mentioned, Please note that retail demand is sometimes capture rate by category to estimate total MWCOG projections were adjusted using 2016 derived beyond the trade area, but the trade captured expenditures. Capture rates represent third-party data. Additionally, adjustments to areas represents the segments from which the the retail submarket’s ability to draw customer these employment growth projections reflect most reliable and majority of sales originate. expenditures within the context of the larger previous research that indicates significant market. They are influenced by the amount, slowing of office demand in office parks. GRAVITY MODELS accessibility and quality of existing and proposed retail development, as well as market TRADE AREAS In order to measure retail potential, the client competition. team utilized a gravity model to determine the Trade areas are impacted by competition, supportable retail square footage per category Capture rates are proprietary information, drive times, sociological and geographic (NG&S, F&B, GAFO). Gravity models, unlike but are provided in the Technical Appendix boundaries, shopping patterns by customer gap analyses, account for factors including of this study for residential, workforce and type, pedestrian volumes and other similar competition, the regulatory environment, visitor customers. Total estimated, captured factors. Additionally, trade area boundaries customer preferences, and retail growth and expenditures in each retail category are may not conform strictly to physical boundaries redevelopment to understand the spending divided by expectations for sales per square such as roads. During the inventory assessment, potential of each trade area’s customer base. foot by retail tenant type. The results of these typical patterns associated with shopping Gap analyses only examine the spending that calculations yield the total amount of demand habits were observed. Rush hour conditions, happens within a specific trade area or that for each submarket within each retail category. ease of crossing major roads and time to travel leaves the trade area without accounting for between neighborhoods are examples of other variables (e.g., such as access, customer Population growth projections prepared variables that were considered. The boundaries behavior).
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 two RETAIL ENVIRONMENT RETAIL TRENDS 9
The amount of retail space in the United States is estimated at 13 billion square feet (CoStar Group, Inc., Q1 2017). The United States has the largest ratio of retail per person (23 square feet) of any country in the world. In Montgomery County, this figure reaches closer to 24 square feet per person.
In January 2017, the CoStar Group released a report estimating that approximately 1 billion square feet of retail space would need to be repurposed or demolished to return the US retail market to a balanced amount of supply and demand. Across the country, in every submarket, oversupply is distributing expenditures across a large number of stores. Silver Spring Co-Op, Takoma Park As a result, more stores are failing to reach also moving into physical spaces. This new of stasis. However, the Internet’s market share sustainable levels of sales per square foot effort to move online retailers into brick and of total spending continues to rise.2 Between and ultimately close. In an oversupplied mortar stores is not necessarily to drive sales, 2015 and 2016, the e-commerce market environment, store closures occur with greater but increase their brand visibility. share of total retail sales grew by nearly 12 frequency until the market has reduced percent, comprising 11.7 percent of total retail the supply to a point where equilibrium is With the online brand retail market becoming sales (excluding fuel and automobiles).³ As achieved. increasingly cluttered, online retailers are now the market share of Internet sales continues looking to distinguish themselves from the to expand, without an increase in overall It is within this context that Montgomery intense competition. For example, a presence spending, the number of brick and mortar County’s retail submarkets are analyzed and along a major retail street or corridor has a stores will decrease, reducing total sustainable forecasted. “billboard effect,” in which new customers are square footage of retail throughout the United exposed to the brand and then driven to visit States. E-COMMERCE the store or the site to purchase their goods or services. The line between online and offline shopping The world of e-commerce is drastically is increasingly blurred.4 Retailers like Bonobos changing everything about the retail economy, What does this transition mean for brick and allow customers to come into the store from the way customers shop to how new mortar retail spaces? According to a study and have a curated, high-quality shopping retailers enter the market. The growth of online conducted by the International Council of experience, but all of the clothing is ordered shopping has increased the overall amount of Shopping Centers (ICSC), North American through an online kiosk within the store. It competition, which has played a role in driving credit loads are currently at a maximum as is possible that large format stores such as retailers that were top performers in the 1990s wages are not rising. Without higher wages, Walmart and Target will move toward a similar out of business. However, in this new era of overall spending does not increase. As a result, business model. As online ordering reduces digital competition, more online retailers are total sales in American retailers are in a state the need for large inventories and stores,
2. “Weighing the Impact on Bricks and Mortar”, ICSC 3. “US E-Commerce Sales Grow 15.6% in 2016,” Internet Retailer. February 17, 2017. 4. “The Retail Transformation” Deloitte University Press. June 16, 2015. Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 large-format retailers will decrease their overall RETAIL AS EXPERIENCE TOWN CENTER RETAIL 10 square footage in favor of a more curated Shopping centers in general are moving Before highway accessibility and suburban experience. This market reality is reducing the toward becoming experience-centric spaces.5 development, urban downtowns had a size of large format stores due to the rising Increasingly, more items are easily bought specific, regional role in society and the inability of even national retailers to maintain online at a better value than in stores. built environment that could not be easily the size of storefronts that were common Consequently, retailers are devising new ways replicated. Even rural downtowns provided before 2008. Shopping centers thus will likely to attract customers to their stores. Centers “just enough” of what customers in the be less focused around a large retail anchor, are changing the definition of an anchor from surrounding countryside needed. The notion and increasingly pivot towards a walkable, a large format store or grocery store to an of building retail space without the sales convenient, multi-stop retail experience for alternative use, such as a medical facility, an to support it would have been considered customers. outdoor dining opportunity or even a climbing foolhardy. gym.6 This effect can be seen in Montgomery In the 1980s, the concept of creating a town County in the need to redevelop older malls Bloomberg reports that the number of walk- center in a suburban community was tested such as White Flint, as well as the inability for in clinics in malls has risen 11 percent since in developments such as Mizner Park in some large format retailers such as Best Buy 2011.7 Such non-retail uses drive traffic to Boca Raton, Florida; Mashpee Commons in to remain sustainable in the county’s retail the adjacent retailers, while also serving the Mashpee, Massachusetts; and Reston Town market. In the long term, the implications community or providing an experience that Center in Reston, Virginia. Montgomery for retail will likely be seen in the continued cannot be achieved online. Allowing for these County made a significant contribution to reduction of square footage of retailers in the alternative uses in commercial centers and the progression of mixed-use main street GAFO category. This anticipated reduction encouraging owners to be creative in their prototypes in 1988 with the completion of the will have implications on the appropriate size tenanting are ways to distinguish brick and Market Square at the Kentlands. Developers of developed retail storefronts and parcels as mortar stores and shopping centers from of these town center environments soon overall retailer square footage continues to online competition. discovered that having convenient retail shrink. One way to shore up the county’s retail available to their on-site residents and and increase the overall resiliency of the retail The importance and relevance of experiential employees increased the value of the homes market is to continue investing in existing retail retail can be seen in the success of Bethesda and office spaces significantly. properties, redevelop aging/underperforming Row. Pedestrian-oriented streetscapes, retail centers and supporting small business with visually appealing storefronts, outdoor Eventually, including retail in a residential owners. Also, developing buildings designed seating and a varied tenant mix contribute or office development was considered a to last and that have flexible build-out uses are to the sense of a vibrant retail center where necessary component of realizing a project’s an appropriate way to allow storefront space people want to linger. Functional retail in the maximum value. However, a common mistake to adapt to new uses, as retail needs change in county, such as a neighborhood convenience made by developers is over-estimating the the coming years and even decades. center like Quince Orchard Marketplace in amount of retail that will be sustained just by Darnestown, continue to fill a need, but highly the addition of new populations added within successful and competitive retail centers have a multi-use development, including residents a true sense of place and foster community and employees. Over-estimating the amount interaction and engagement. of supportable retail square footage leads to vacant storefronts that reduce vibrancy
5. “The Evolution of the Internet and its Impact on Retail Space” Wired. July, 2014. https://www.wired.com/insights/2014/07/evolution-internet-impact-retail-spaces/ 6. “Malls Turn to Climbing Walls and Medical Offices for New Anchors.” Retail Dive. July 15, 2015. http://www.retaildive.com/news/malls-turn-to-climbing-walls-medical-offices-for-new- anchors/422705/ 7. “Climbing Walls are Moving into a Shopping Center Near You.” Bloomberg. July 14, 2016. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-07-14/climbing-walls-are-moving-into-a-u-s-shopping- center-near-you
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 and property values. Though retailers may INTERNATIONAL RETAIL Protecting these international enclaves from 11 be willing to locate in a development initially, Montgomery County is home to three of the the rent increases that frequently come along if the demand cannot fulfill the sales needed 10 most diverse cities in the country.8 This with redevelopment is important. Ensuring to maintain their businesses, eventually these diversity has manifested itself in a range that these business owners are heard by storefronts will also become vacant. This real of international retailers that are clustered maintaining a high level of communication risk should be recognized when reviewing new throughout the county. between the County and Chambers of developments that contain retail. Commerce, and encouraging investment International retailers provide a sense of in existing properties over rebuilding new Several of the country’s most notable new diversity, authenticity and market distinction to buildings that are more expensive to lease can town center developments have occurred in several of Montgomery County’s submarkets. help maintain healthy retail environments. Montgomery County, including Bethesda Row, These retailers serve to ease entry for Rockville Town Square, Downtown Crown and new populations moving into the county, RURAL RETAIL Germantown Town Center. The capacity of the as they can shop for familiar foods, speak One of the more complex retail conditions county to support retail in these development familiar languages and meet other families. configurations is a focal point of this study. in Montgomery County is the points where International retailers are also increasingly submarkets transition from suburban to popular among general customer populations THE IMPACT OF MALLS rural communities. These sparsely populated who are looking for a unique, authentic retail areas of the county are able to absorb With the exception of Montgomery County’s experience. The wealth of locally-owned and support retail differently from the standout performers, particularly Westfield international retail options not only gives others. In the county’s rural areas, the only Montgomery Mall, Class B and C shopping Montgomery County a distinct identity, but supportable types of customer spending malls are showing weak performance in also helps contribute to the important social are often for NG&S tenants, as well as some their current retail environments. Shopping function of retail in society. F&B establishments that are considered malls are struggling due to saturation in the regional destinations (often based on their Areas in Montgomery County that contain market, as well as a transition in shopping rural setting). F&B retailers tend to have a clusters of international retail include habits from interior malls and car-focused devoted customer following and/or have a downtown Wheaton, south Georgia Avenue retail into more walkable, pedestrian-friendly concentration of employment or residential in downtown Silver Spring, Twinbrook, Long retail environments. This trend presents an density nearby. Branch and East Germantown. Shopping opportunity to reposition underperforming centers that contain international retail tend malls into office, residential, or other non-retail to be distinct from non-international shopping developments. centers. These enclaves often sit blocks from
more generic or non-internationally focused Malls in Montgomery County that are currently retail, and this distinction has implications for thriving, particularly Westfield Montgomery tenanting within these enclaves. In addition, and Westfield Wheaton, can be expected improvements in neighboring enclaves will to continue to fulfill the demand within the likely have a positive impact on surrounding submarket for a midrange to upscale mall. retail clusters. However, the overall number of supportable malls within a market, such as Montgomery County and the DC metropolitan area, is much lower than before 2008. Therefore, the success of a mall should not be used as a measure of success to deem that future malls within Montgomery County will also be successful. 8. WalletHub/NBC News. http://www.commdiginews.com/life/gaithersburg-md-the-most-diverse-city-in-the-us-64477/ Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 RETAIL OVER-SUPPLY in cheap commercial buildings to quickly 12 9 Retail over-supply is the overbuilding of retail realize tax benefits. space beyond what is demanded by consumer spending levels. When retail is over-built, there Additionally, the zoning of commercial land are several important repercussions that can along non-residential commuter roadways led take decades for municipalities to overcome. to the development of miles of strip centers. For instance, when retail is developed outside These strip centers are notoriously difficult of prime retail locations, it often experiences to reposition, even though their popularity increased vacancy rates, lower sales and has been waning in recent years as consumer rents, and poorer-quality tenants. Tenants preferences have changed to prefer shopping in the discount retail category who cater to in walkable, pedestrian-friendly environments. local services (dry cleaners and convenience stores) play an important role in communities. The impact of the oversupply of retail space However, generally speaking, oversupply leads on municipalities is the reduction of focus on to tenanting of retailers or non-retail uses that new-build developments and a transition to are not appropriately serving the needs of the redevelopment opportunities. Consequently, Hampshire-Langley Shopping Center, Langley Park planning departments must make decisions community. In these cases, inappropriately side of the street, and integrating corridor located retail cannot be improved with on where retail is appropriate when parcels are considered for redevelopment. A delicate frontages into the neighborhoods bordering cosmetic changes (such as sidewalk or strip centers rather than along the roadways. storefront improvements) alone. balance must be struck between renovating aging or out-positioned retail and the Innovative methods such as these can be Although there are times when retail is development of new mixed-use projects that include a retail component. applied to existing zoning regulations and oversupplied yet several tenants in the market areas across Montgomery County. These are performing well, previously mentioned Zoning retail-use requirements (percent of measures can reintegrate struggling retailers adverse market conditions hold true. The development rules, ground-level mandates, into more effective shopping centers.11 The tenants doing well might be benefiting from etc.) can have a role in generating over-supply. strip center cannot be ignored within the lower rents, while other tenants in the market Additionally, requiring ground floor retail in county—its ubiquitous presence and the may be struggling and receiving concessions new developments does not take into account downward trend of total supportable retail from their landowners. that retail does best when it is concentrated square footage will ensure that, in the future, a portion of these centers will need to be Across the United States, retail has been over- and contiguous along retail streets. The Urban redeveloped and their purpose reimagined. built. This can be seen in the scaling back of Land Institute recommends form-based zoning
department stores, such as Macy’s and Sears, codes that focus on “place, infrastructure, 10 Overall, by increasing the quality of existing in the closure of other national brand stores and urban form.” These regulations retail, rather than just building additional such as The Limited, and in the vast number provide planning departments with enough retail, Montgomery County will increase the of semi-vacant strip centers that line major flexibility to allow the market-appropriate efficiency and overall success of its existing roadways across country. The history of why uses to come into new developments. In its supply, an attribute that contributes to retail looks the way it does now can be traced report on restructuring commercial strips, the long term viability of the business and back to a policy passed by the US Congress the Environmental Protection Agency property owner. in 1954 that created a subsidy for suburban (EPA) recommends that land use and commercial development by modifying the tax development patterns be restructured to code to depreciate new commercial buildings focus on pedestrian and local community uses. 9. Restructuring the Commercial Strip (EPA study, 2015) Recommendations from the EPA include a 10. http://urbanland.uli.org/planning-design/new- in seven years, down from the previous 40- suburbanism-reinventing-inner-ring-suburbs/ year requirement, which sparked construction mix of uses that encourages multiple trips per 11. Reconstructing the Commercial Strip (EPA study) week, positioning retail on the “going-home”
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 UNMET RETAIL DEMAND coupled with the declining levels of supportable for the retailer is on whether or not the space 13 When retail demand greatly exceeds the retail square footage across the United States, will foster an acceptable level of sales. This is current supply (i.e. equilibrium is not met), increase the need for informed, market- particularly true for national retailers, which several consequences occur. The condition appropriate retail development. have strict bottom lines. of unmet retail demand is a systematic one Retail serves four perceived functions: Therefore, when planning for retail in a which leads to increased rents, a lack of retail community, it is important not to take an affordability, a less diverse mix of retail, and a • Community identity idealistic view of what is possible. Communities mismatch of retail supplied versus demand as are capable of supporting a specific amount • Amenity low revenue-producing subcategories cannot of square footage of retail that serves their sustain the inflated rents. • Tax generator needs. Neighborhoods frequently have an However, when demand is slightly greater “ideal” vision of what retail would be best in than supply (between 100%-110%), conditions • Civic use. their community, but it may not reflect market are optimal as a healthy, competitive retail reality. In turn, through recognizing holes in the Each of these uses is secondary to commerce, environment is created. This environment is existing supply, emphasizing locally-serving retail’s primary function. characterized by retailers who must maintain retail, and recognizing that vibrancy on the street level can also be supported through market-appropriate sales volumes to sustain Retail’s success is determined first and their rents and, when turnover happens, rents non-retail daytime uses, a successful retail foremost by generating enough sales to stay in environment can be fostered. are at an appropriate rate to mandate a quality business. When considering whether a location tenant. is appropriate for a retail use, the primary focus
ECONOMIC VIABILITY OF RETAIL
People spend their time in three primary places: their home, their office, and the “third place,” which includes areas in the public realm like parks and plazas, but also shops and retailers in their community. This third place is where people socialize, make connections and foster a sense of neighborhood spirit and identity. This social engagement often happens in coffee shops, at the dry cleaners, in grocery stores, and in apparel shops. In this way, retail often serves as a critical component of a neighborhood’s social fabric. At the same time, retail must retain a level of commercial success that allows establishments to stay in business. This relationship between social importance and economic viability is tricky.
When developed successfully, retail has the potential to serve as the glue that holds people together. Customers are adversely sensitive to retail that is in the wrong place, is the wrong size, or is the wrong type. These factors,
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 Downtown Takoma Park 14 RETAILER DECISION-MAKING
Retail functions best in an environment to shop at more than one retailer per visit. ACCESSIBLE with a low number of barriers. Financial The concept of locating retail within clusters After customers identify and locate a retailer, and psychological factors and precedent is rooted in how Montgomery County’s retail they must physically get to the store or play a significant role in influencing where was built historically, with retailers lining Main restaurant. Whether traveling by car or on retailers locate. Retailers will evaluate both Streets and clustered in downtowns. foot, access to the site is another road block the surrounding demographic statistics that could prohibit the customer from entering as well as site conditions and consumer Today, these districts often still serve as the the store and making a purchase. Constricted behaviors. Demographic characteristics focal points of Montgomery County’s towns access can take many forms, such as a busy used by retailers include population within a and cities, and as places where the community roadway one must cross, construction, or a certain radius or drive time, median household gathers for shopping, entertainment and lack of available parking near the entrance of income, education level, average age or socializing. Retailers and the community alike the store. Large retail tenants, such as grocery average spending on a particular category reap the benefits of strategic planning and and department stores, will evaluate the site of retail. Based on the behaviors of their regulations that foster and preserve these on the ease of access to their location. target customers, retailers will evaluate the clusters. importance of visibility, traffic counts, co- Large traffic volumes without strategic tenancy, access and quality of the center. VISIBLE transportation planning (including stoplights, The ability to see a storefront from a major stop signs, and directional signage) can cause Some retailers moving into urban settings roadway, intersection or pedestrian sidewalk is congestion, chaos and ultimately, a stressful favor high pedestrian counts, active streets, a major consideration for retailers. Generally, environment that customers avoid. Retailers and contiguous retail that is located along retail spaces that are tucked away from view will consider if the surrounding roads can both sides of the street. Other retailers by the natural landscape or poor placement sustain the projected traffic increases in their require a large amount of surface parking will experience lower sales volumes than current state or if the roads will need to be and accessibility from major roadways and retailers clearly visible to passersby. A widened to support traffic increases generated interstates, and can thrive with low visibility consumer’s decision to frequent a retailer can by development. If the answer is the latter, the and no co-tenants. be driven by seeing the retailer’s storefront or retailer will consider the feasibility of widening sign. the road and if the objective aligns with the Each retailer’s requirements are different, as goals of the local transit authority. their requirements are shaped with their target Retailers are knowledgeable of these customer in mind. There is no “one size fits all” psychological shopping patterns and attempt Geographical characteristics can also be a approach to retailer decision making. Although to maximize their visibility in the market by barrier to customer access. Steep inclines or a development may contain retail nodes that locating in places that offer large signage declines, waterways and natural vegetation are of the correct size and dimension, its opportunities. Furthermore, brand recognition can prohibit access to the site. Each potential location or a perception of oversaturation in through a physical presence is becoming retail site will have its own unique barriers to the market might lead to difficulty tenanting increasingly more important to retailers as access and visibility, and will be evaluated on a that space. society moves forward into the digital age. case-by-case basis by prospective tenants. Companies that started online, such as Warby CENTRALIZED Parker, Amazon, etc., are moving into brick and APPROPRIATE Generally, retailers thrive when they are mortar spaces to broaden their customer base Retail space exists in many different forms, centralized in what are known as retail clusters. through increased visibility. from new-to-market Class A ground- Consumers enjoy a “one-stop shop” for their floor retail space in an urban area to an goods and services, encouraging customers
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 aging suburban shopping center along a CO-TENANCY AND COMPETITION STAKEHOLDERS 15 major thoroughfare. The quality and, more Co-tenancy, the term used to describe the In this context, a stakeholder is defined as a importantly, the usability of the retail space combination of retailers surrounding the party whose participation is necessary for is a critical consideration for potential potential site, is a key consideration for the successful accomplishment of the retailer retailers. National retailers have spent years, retailers. Typically, retailers look for sites that endeavor. As retail site selection does not oftentimes decades, testing and analyzing have a tenant mix with uses that complement happen in a vacuum, several key stakeholders site features and capabilities to determine the their businesses in order to drive customers to are involved in opening a new retail location. factors that lead to maximizing profits. For the site for a “one stop shop.” From the private developer to the planning example, national restaurant retailers require department and transportation authority, specific venting systems and kitchen build out Supported by market data, the tenant mix many stakeholders participate in the retailing capabilities, while grocers and department should be carefully selected by landlords process by holding one or more rights within stores require an adequate number of loading and developers to ensure the success of all the property’s bundle of rights and may need docks, back of house storage space, and retailers. Furthermore, retailers constantly to surrender their rights in the property in surface parking. monitor the expansion and contraction order for the retailer to succeed. of their competitors in every market and Quality of the retail space is also considered make informed decisions based on these by retailers. A discount store, whose key values observations. and brand identity include providing goods with a focus on price rather than service, choice or variety, would locate in a Class B or Class C shopping center. On the other RETAIL DECISION-MAKING FACTORS TABLES hand, fine dining establishments seek Class Neighborhood Goods & Mile Range of Avg. Household A restaurant spaces, as customer experience Min. Population Traffic Count Services Demo Income and perception drive their key values. Usability and quality of a retail space can be modified Drug Store 1 10,000 $20,000 15,000 to fit specific tenant requirements, but require Dry Cleaner 3 60,000 $57,000 25,000 additional financial resources. Grocery 3 46,667 $50,000 Not Available Salon 3 36,000 $58,000 25,000 RETAIL DECISION-MAKING FACTORS General Merchandise, Mile Range of Avg. Household Apparel, Furniture, & Min. Population Traffic Count This information is a general guideline for Demo Income understanding the connection between Other density, income and visibility needs by Apparel 10 261,667 $55,000 Not Available retail type. Additional factors, such as Furniture 5 105,000 $55,000 25,000 nearby competition, site conditions and individual retail expansion plans, factor Other 5 133,333 $55,000 25,000 heavily into the site selection process. Mile Range Min. Avg. Household Min Workers/Daytime Traffic Food & Beverage of Demo Population Income Population Count Coffee Shop/Café 1 28,333 $53,333 6,000 27,500 Fast Food 3 56,667 $53,333 21,667 37,500 Full-Service 3 56,250 $58,750 75,000 23,333
Source: Retail Lease Trac | Note: These numbers should not be used as requirements, they are meant to indicate average preferences for a variety of retailers with locations in Washington, DC and Maryland. Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 three COUNTY RETAIL TOPICS MONTGOMERY COUNTY RETAIL HISTORY 17
Rockville Pike is one of the oldest roads THE TRANSPORTATION REVOLUTION in Ame rica.12 Once a foot path for Native In the 1920s, Montgomery County began Americans, Rockville Pike evolved into a allowing auto-friendly retail to develop trade route linking tobacco farms to market along major thoroughfares. Gas stations, centers that also spurred the development of motels, restaurants and produce stands taverns at major crossroads. The central road were built along the various newly paved and the tavern serve as the foundation for roads throughout the county. The continued retail throughout Montgomery County. Other suburbanization of the County was also major roads, including Veirs Mill Road, Georgia fostered by the construction of Interstate 270 Avenue, River Road and Colesville Road, have in 1960, when it was extended to the Capital maintained their significance as retail sites, Beltway. which have remained clustered along these streets for many years. Increased access and flight to the suburbs around this time led auto-focused retail to Highway Lighthouse, Rockville, 1926 EARLY RETAIL define the burgeoning retail supply, like in many other cities during this period. This continues to serve as the central hub of Retail grew slowly in the county up until change is epitomized by large developments each community. Programs such as business the turn of the 20th century, when rail and such as the Hecht’s Department Store (now improvement districts and local chambers electric street cars were introduced. The Ellsworth Place), Wheaton Plaza in 1954, the of commerce continue to push for healthy, establishment of train stations and streetcar first regional mall in the Washington area sustainable retail that adequately serves the stops throughout the County opened and the fourth largest mall in the United needs of the community and supports local, neighborhoods to Washington, DC residents States in 1963, and Montgomery Mall in 1968, regional and national business owners. looking for relief from city life. The influx of the second indoor mall in the county after new customers catalyzed demand for both Wheaton Plaza, epitomize this change. Retail Moving forward with future development housing and retail to support the incoming in Montgomery County today is still largely and revitalization efforts, it will be critical to populations. defined by car-oriented shopping centers. make intentional efforts to keep these unique Shopping centers in every submarket are retailers in place while also allowing for an largely accessible by cars, and the downtown overall increase in the quality and accessibility clusters in Bethesda, Wheaton and Silver of existing retail. In particular, remembering the foundation of retail at crossroads and Spring are all located at major intersections. highlighting the importance of community- MODERN MONTGOMERY COUNTY centric development will allow the county to retain its healthy, vibrant retail and grow Today, a vibrant array of retail types, from responsibly in the years and decades to come. international enclaves to active downtowns to rural neighborhood centers, defines the retail mix within Montgomery County. Diverse neighborhoods, from urbanized Takoma Park, to suburban Gaithersburg foster a narrative of Montgomery County as a hub for innovative 12. http://www.rockvillemd.gov/DocumentCenter/View/1430 and unique retail. Particularly in communities Bonfields Auto Repair, Bethesda on the west and east fringe of I-270, retail Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 18 MONTGOMERY COUNTY’S REGIONAL STANDING
Montgomery County has one of the largest comparable in this measure, but Fairfax COUNTY COMPETITION MAP populations of the counties reviewed in the County is approximately $3,300 higher. comparative analysis (1.05 million residents Montgomery County also has a high median in 2016). Fairfax County is similar in size, but household income compared to statewide has substantially more employees than in and national statistics. Retailers are attracted Montgomery County. Montgomery County to higher levels of spending. However, the has a high relative average age (39.2 years household income, like the spending per Frederick County old) among the reviewed counties, with only household, is average for the DC Metro area. Frederick County having a higher median age. Washington, DC, City of Alexandria, Although it may seem that comparing the Howard County Loudoun County and Prince George’s County various counties in the DC Metropolitan are younger (34-36), while the median ages area can be done as an apples-to-apples comparison, this is not truly the case. The of Montgomery County, Frederick County, Montgomery County Howard County and Fairfax County all hover retail environment in Montgomery County around 39 years old. is affected by regional competitors and Loudoun County is competing for various developers, but Montgomery County residents are spending the lasting impact of these factors on the Fairfax County Washington DC a comparable amount of retail expenditures larger retail system is small in comparison to Arlington County per year to their counterparts in neighboring other factors. Factors that have measurably counties. Loudoun County has the highest impacted the existing retail supply include household income as well as the highest historical precedents, zoning regulations, Prince George’s expenditures per household. Fairfax and major road construction and residential County Montgomery Counties are somewhat development patterns.
COUNTY COMPETITION PROFILE Prince Montgomery Frederick Howard Loudoun Washington Fairfax Arlington Georges’ County County County County DC County County County
Total Businesses, Total Employees: 522,797 122,019 179,531 152,369 384,212 708,509 650,023 142,905
Population, 2021 Projection 1,107,133 258,305 337,725 419,914 966,122 735,210 1,199,361 250,573
Population, 2016 Estimation 1,048,868 246,984 316,627 379,575 919,417 676,929 1,144,095 232,696
2016 Est. Median Household Income $99,233.00 $84,237.00 $110,331.00 $118,545.00 $72,013.00 $70,648.00 $112,427.00 109,708
2016 Est. Median Age 39.2 39.2 39 35.9 36.8 34.5 38.2 34.7
2016 Annual Avg per HH, Expenditure Est. $49,584.00 $47,419.00 $52,345.00 $54,452.00 $43,164.00 $40,830.00 $52,882.00 47,549
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 Source: Neilsen, Sitewise, US Census REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT 19
The genesis of the regulatory environment In the new ordinance, retail and service INCORPORATED CITIES in Montgomery County was established in establishments under 50,000 square feet and 1928 with the adoption of a Euclidean zoning restaurants are allowed by-right in the R-10 Euclidean zoning practices are inherently ordinance. This first zoning code was fairly Residential Zone (a high density residential restrictive with the ostensible intent of simple; its primary purpose was to separate zone characterized by multi-family buildings) securing the health and welfare of the commercial, residential and industrial land uses as well as all Commercial/Residential, populace. As the suburbs expanded and from each other. Employment and Industrial zones. This mixed-use developments began to grow in change should provide much more flexibility number, there was a need to accommodate In 1964, the county adopted its General in the types of services and retail that can this development pattern. The result is Plan, On Wedges and Corridors, which set develop across the county, with a particular twofold. The first is the zoning ordinance of a framework for future development. The emphasis on encouraging retail in mixed-use, today, which provides greater flexibility in framework promoted development in the commercial and industrial areas. the types of services and retail that can be southern part of the county – representing developed. The second is the establishment the “inner ring” suburbs just outside of RETAIL-RESTRICTED ZONES of incorporated communities, which are areas Washington, DC – as well as along corridors that began as small towns but quickly grew in that radiate out from the city like bicycle Montgomery County’s retail environment has population along with their need for services. spokes. The retail environment that followed remained fairly stable over time as a result is concentrated along primary corridors of the zoning and planning framework. By (Rockville Pike, Georgia Avenue, Colesville limiting the development of retail, the county Road), in downtown environments (Bethesda, has avoided the overbuilding crisis that is Silver Spring, Wheaton), and in neighborhood currently hurting retail markets all across the centers (crossroads throughout the county). country.
RETAIL-ENABLED ZONES In particular, retail uses are highly regulated in the agricultural, rural and residential zones, In 2014, Montgomery County adopted a new preventing the county from becoming overrun zoning ordinance that eliminated the long with retail developments. The types of retail list of allowed retail uses by zone, including allowed in these zones is limited to preserve antiquated uses such as the hat shop and the rural and residential character of these abattoir. Instead, the new code introduced a neighborhoods. As such, approval for these generalized retail use called “Retail/Service establishments requires a more thorough Establishment,” under which retail is regulated review process, including a review before the by store size. hearing examiner.
Fire Station 1 Restaurant, Silver Spring
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 20 INVENTORY SUMMARY
OVERVIEW 19,705,719 SF 5,615 The inventory included in this report was Total Amount of Retail-Occupied Total Number of Retailers collected using leasing plans and data from Square Footage CoStar as a baseline, and was verified by site visits. Retailers not listed by CoStar were 6.8% 524 added as a result of the fieldwork and further site visits. Vacancy Rate Total Number of Available Properties
Montgomery County contains 24,740,297 TOP 3 RETAILERS TOP 3 LARGEST PROPERTIES square feet of retail-appropriate space. BY TOTAL SQUARE BY NUMBER OF STORES: Within this, 19,705,719 square feet of space is FOOTAGE: occupied by retail tenants. Of the total retail, 1 Westfield Wheaton there are 5,615 unique retailers. The remaining 1 7-Eleven 1 Giant 1,540,124 SF square footage is either occupied by non-retail 49 Stores 1,191,452 SF 2 tenants, such as a bank or a gym, or is vacant. Westfield Montgomery The vacancy rate for the county is 6.8%, and 2 Subway 2 Macy’s 1,249,536 SF there are 524 available properties. Two of 48 Stores 726,952 SF 3 the most prevalent retailers in the county by Lakeforest Mall square footage are grocery stores: Giant and 3 Starbucks 3 Safeway 994,254 SF Safeway, while the most prevalent retailer is 44 Stores 704,799 SF 7-Eleven, with 49 stores.
7-Eleven, Randolph Road, Giant, New Hampshire Avenue, Westfield Wheaton, University Westfield Montgomery, University Flagship Center, Rockville White Oak Shopping Center: White Oak Boulevard, Wheaton Boulevard, Bethesda
*NOTE: Inventory completed in November, 2016.
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 CLASS OF SPACE 21 SHOPPING CENTER TYPE DISTRIBUTION 6% 5.5M Class A (6,230,090 SF) 5M 18% 25% 4.5M Class B (12,667,270 SF) 4M Class C (4,312,309 SF) 3.5M 3M Square Feet Square 51% Build-to-Suit (BTS) 2.5M (1,530,628 SF) 2M 1.5M 1M RETAIL CATEGORY IN RETAIL-OCCUPIED SPACE 500K
General Merchandise, Apparel, Mall Furniture, & Other (GAFO) Center Pad Site Inline Retail Strip Center Independent 33% (9,763,626 SF) Neighborhood Hybrid Center Large Format Establishment New Town Center Center (Grocery) Regional Shopping 50% Neighborhood Goods & Large Format Store Services (NG&S) (6,504,405 SF) 17% Approximately half of the retail in Of occupied square footage, 86% is Food & Beverage (F&B) Montgomery County is Class B, about occupied by a retailer. The remaining (3,437,688 SF) a quarter is Class A, a fifth is Class C 14% is occupied by non-traditional and the remainder is retail space that retail (such as movie theaters and RETAIL-APPROPRIATE SPACE DISTRIBUTION was built to suit a particular tenant yoga studios) and non-retail uses, such as movie theaters, yoga studios Retail (19,705,719 SF) (such as a stand-alone McDonald’s). 3% 2% 1% or banks. 4% Vacant (1,681,012 SF) 50% of the retail tenants are within 4% the General Merchandise, Apparel, The most prevalent shopping center 7% Bank (953,048 SF) Furniture, & Other (GAFO) categories. in Montgomery County is the grocery- This high percentage is likely due to anchored Neighborhood Center. This Entertainment (913,564 SF) both the site requirements for general type is closely followed by inline retail, goods retailers and the fact that many which is numerous throughout the Gym/Studio (738,531 SF) 86% areas of the county are desirable for county due to the high number of this type of retailer, with high traffic downtowns, and then by the regional Office (483,763 SF) counts and visibility from major roads. shopping mall. Other (264,660 SF)
*NOTE: Inventory completed in November, 2016.
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 TENANT ANALYSIS LARGEST RETAILERS IN MONTGOMERY COUNTY BY SQUARE FOOTAGE 22 The unique blend of retailers in Montgomery 1.4M County (illustrated to the right) is reflective of the
diverse population within the County. 1.2M
Giant is the most prevalent grocery store in 1M Montgomery County, but is the most prevalent overall retailer by square footage. Big box retailers, 800K such as Sears, Macy’s and Target, predominate Feet Square the list of largest retailers by square footage, but 600K other convenience-oriented retailers also occupy 400K top spots, including CVS and several grocery store chains. 200K
Giant and Safeway are the two most prevalent grocery stores by square footage. Whole CVS Giant Sears Kohl’s Kmart
Foods, which is higher-end, and Shoppers Food Target Macy’s Costco Staples Safeway Walmart
Warehouse, which is lower-end, both comprise Shoppers LA Fitness JC Penney JC Nordstrom Home Depot similar square footage. These sizes may indicate Harris Teeter Lord & Taylor Whole Foods Whole that grocery retailers view Montgomery County as a mid-range market more than a specialty market, on average. Burlington Coat Factory Coat Burlington
GROCERY STORE SQUARE FOOTAGE DISTRIBUTION
1.4M
1.2M
1M
20% 800K Square Feet Feet Square
600K
400K 80% 200K Giant Costco Safeway Shoppers Wegmans Harris Teeter *NOTE: Inventory completed in November, 2016. Foods Whole
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 four SUBMARKET ASSESSMENTS 24 SUBMARKETS DEFINED
Butterfly Ln B St D E So o re I- 3 u y a e 79 d 8 t e k d e L 5 h Hall Rd e d a S r r R 3 r G R k I - t s il R R e - l l P s 7 e is d id D M MD-75 e e e 9 Dr a y v aplan M F l B alle d a l 5 v G D l p r v d o R M - i l i d 795 d 1 4 l ls o k ¨§ r 4 d a ¦ o M l R v Liberty Rd W R d s h G t R R R Z 270 e e C ¨§ d t ¦ l i d io il k d u n v y g s 5 n R R d S e d 9 t SUBMARKET MAP o r W 6 d e H R i - s i c o o O a nan I e G Corpo h d o br d ds h ap rate s W ec W Rd land ¤£15 D MD-355 Fo R I-70 d ht P C r s Rd rd r N Main St Rd a R e M r d t Fla k t g i e e M ll Rd H METHODOLOGY 15 s MD ar e - k - s R l S i s 144 h A il e U P R d r sv i u d ri t g MD-67 e G ng t d k M ton Rd io R h k r rt t ke e i a r u Pi MD-32 a d o s on e 7 i C rs r P t M R A e e 2 t J C - h ut ld v n I-695 r D e O O e
MD-17 w r e M d Dividing the retail in Montgomery County Olive School Rd o Ball Rd g R R ¤£340 n t ¨§ 70 ¦ d e s r d l e d l y ger d R e Fin boar R n R a Urbana Pike d Rd p r r B k ho o e e c S C n n M L into submarkets is a critical step in accurately u n i d g r n o n on s u B e L e o a P MD-94 9 L n k H t d N ¨§695 u 7 ¦ - v O D L d i R ld o D R t S 0 ll g R a US-34 M e y Fr w S measuring the retail demand throughout the e o o n d e d e d y k R R l e o l Hoo l ric d l d l P k a M a Rd R i n d o ¤£15 MD-80 V D U St Michaels Rd d s ld g - i r n O Fred l 4 n eri l b d c 7 e R Frederick Rd k R i 8 d R t a e y d County. Montgomery County contains every r H n e R l d O a G x US-15 o e f Adamstown Rd P M n i R i b k d MD-17 o e d I-70 R o I-70 community typology: urban, urban/suburban, c d g o k 5 R T r Gue Rd s 7 u W s h - l b d R l u i D s ¤£40 r k R S d Oland Rd M s M r t k t la y J r o s o iona suburban and rural. i C at l P a n Main St h N ik a ¤£40 e P re n o R D s im d d D L t R a rnt d al ve lle m Bu woo R n B erick A d Bethany Ln vi as s ia red s R h tt H cu d lp d F e MD-28 aw s e R v k d r Lo in R ria e d s d T t C T r R r a e e e d v l d am u R A n ck Each community type is evaluated differently l e i s d I-270 r MD-85 i e R Q de S n R r F re y k e R O y k H l i R il e R o l W d P o d t g x a o n b ll e d u k F d i r i r a n r y s i u R d R g d R b based on its neighborhood typology. B R t R d n
d m u u d R u l C H d y s R o u D d r d om C w I- r l C a R 1 m e I-95 For example, in an urbane environment, O 9 d a T r F W s r N 5 R at c i e k a M t s ins u d s r m R d Rd s e ike e i East Countycky R l e P D e a o d p ill h p r R h ksv - r ia r 1 lc convenience is the critical factor; in a rural h M la 0 I a p i C MD-175 8 H E N ll e Rd t w M d Ba H rn a C R e Rd 195 s e n m ¨§ v w US-1¦ environment where inconvenience is expected, i d o R d p d y d ll W Old Baltimore un M t R e S s on a t l n R h gome w d i ry Rd r r e a pto d e y Stum R k d A L i o d R v n n P k e variety, cost and quality are factoredBerlin Tpke more L R d n o Ten Oaks Rd d ri i a y R R B H i d e Z k g R e t b r r n i P I-195 ¤£15 u u g m T 270 l r b e ¨§ B l Germantown- h ¦ u s l M e i h l l in Rd a D v heavily into customer preference. t v c Dam n -3 o i r s n a l a d d to d 2 C R l e h R R g d M a est ri R n US-1 C P e cr e Field rooke B d e R h g B ville d a B d d Rd w e r o R Clarksburg l y o le High St N S n g d k d w e MD-32 s c w d n H d i R u e T u S o a H c R v R B o o w r c a A r d a r n G e m g £1 ¤ t e The submarket boundarieso respond to R g s e n P s n b it e p e i n v r s k W s n l hite h S i e s e l o F h l l er e a i r W t F y h R Olney i a S d r R H d s D orsey Rd e e d
r o these customer decision points, as well R MD-295
G A VA-655 il G MD-124 a Cl v ¨§95 J t o e ¦ Washington Blvd p e West Countyt p G s a e N 21st St C r o s Harry Byrd Hwy Rd r up as existing retail development patterns. M m R M D- a d H un 2 n ar c 16 R y r Gaithersburgd d y a al Hw C c s r R d oloni B lub R c o £29 Ridge Rd I n ¤ E C Hollow t R Rd Budd d y d d e E r h r US-1 d R Roadways and parks often serve as barriers c W M H h d MD-124 n d il w it y R l Bat es Ferr a n tle r a R y fie I 0 l d d l B 370- 3 7 d R d ¨§ ¦ e 8 e -2 P y Icc MD d c between population segments and retailers. R d e k y P d R e E Market St R R a d US-1 N e e £1 l ¤ d u l r d k E R p i t i n e M R o M H l P e l l H i E l d For example, Rock Creek Park servesa as a r G i a v s n u i n r h y h d o m rr L d b B i I-270 e y o o p e n s D a o m B y R e r L G u C l 4th St h d n R d u Bonifant o submarket boundary for most adjacent areas. o d rc C h J Rockville R W d R S King St E n MD-32 d o e s s R w o u Rive o D r t n e Rd r Rd t White Va t lah o g h vi d d y ra n Aspen Fa i irl R T P a r R nd B e R k R d y Arctic Ave d k The result of this analysis yields 12 distinct g iv c W d 5 o i e 9 r a y r Oak B - d R R R I u k d d e g R t R P o Hill e v h h n c lp ik A s o e k o C l R and P submarkets. These submarkets were l n G v e h i m r l r i ia S o l l o a M l b y e A e e p ib lg River Rd n m m c B onki i e n a a Wheaton- n P u t P o l Pky R l l l e C d i o a a R l k Rd e i C t n e B ll u d determined by assessing the retail clusters r C e d x R h O e g d r e n Georgia Ave t e Tu r L ime ck r R L v erm K a Glenmont y a iln d n L u d E d n R r S d R R H r Mill Rd e throughout the county, referring to expertise R i owde n v P l
e ls i £1 B l ¤ i r c F a l l o k a R a w r c d R e m Sully Rd Be F i r w e ac d e s e h M v l n ill R B R d l d Kensington e d i e within the Montgomery RCounty Planning R d a M le l way o untvil le d S Belt v R Saul Rd ital er Cap T Da e 495 m p l ¨§ ¦ Rd n k d a L 5 e VA-637 v d R B 9 o Tra Department and through the use of retail W r e ck g c a SilverDa o 2 a R e O d l - R d l n l e w i a y l a e y i r y D r D l k A k r w v l y B r d p n Bethesda/ M Crain Hwy D d e s e D lv H R u S r d e h r lle e l C market analysis techniques to group smallere n n s G R p G e a l F o o h e d Springv o r River Rd r s r n x e i t A n c n e Ryan Rd n D R r a l D o w W l o G Chevy Chase/ d a a M l f W i o d e M y e e a r R retail clusters. These submarkett boundaries do o c r B h a ck s r r R g th a Lu l 3 Old Ox Rd l ur e ood v e e e B G - d l C d t vd d Bradley Ln v d o D m R A R A w ro a v o M John Mosby Hwy x n b h
J s d e North Bethesdad t not correspond to jurisdictional lines. O P ol E R ¤£50 lden S G a r s £50 E t ik st-W li B ¤ d e s o e t o d l NW 16th St Hwy p e w l a a R ir O l D r n i n C M h h n A L i e D c e ll r u K - US-301 e m u s R 4 d 1 h b d 0
u C B R r - l VA 267 g O 3 e l l US-50 i d 8 US-50 John Mosby Hwy u P D i H o Van Ness St NW ¤£50 l k m t a e in h d h g io n n L R S a 301 i £ R ¤ D t n Sully Rd r r d d F o y V v p A er a -2 o R W S 6 d 7 x w Reston Pky E
h f NW 13th St La n l n
O 13th St NE d d a M Oak d o t t Rd a ¤£1 v e e R x yers Rd R l r w l H a R r R L e G y R d p US-50 l d b l r £50 ¤ r r d i e i M i
v a K s i N Eastern Ave NE t l e e i r t W d F Q St NW R R t a a ri G e n r Sh d l y e u l KEY d s Park St SE m C R R S H l Ave
d Centra d t H St NE i s 5 l S N l Central Ave R 9 p Braddock Rd d w 2 R e G - l d L r R a o l l C i V I-66 d a l e n v Submarkety Boundary l D r 66 g l a b B g ¨§ l ¦ n o ¤£301 James Madison Hwy e o u G ls R R I-66 i 1 S ¨§66 R 395 d ¦ - ¨§ d W ¦ d S U Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 ASPEN HILL 25
TRADE AREA MAP INTRODUCTION Ednor Road Veirs Mill Road, built in 1838, brings commuters Intercounty Connector and customers from Rockville and Wheaton Georgia Avenue through the Aspen Hill submarket on their 97 way to Washington, DC. With increasing traffic counts in the neighborhood, the Aspen Hill submarket continues to grow, specifically Norbeck Road around the intersection of Georgia Avenue 355 and Connecticut Avenue. Northgate Plaza sits Bel Pre Road to the north of the site of the original general store and post office. Over time, Aspen Hill has maintained a central retail district that serves the surrounding suburban neighborhoods. Veirs Mill Road
Aspen Hill Road Road POPULATION ANALYSIS Rockville Pike Randolph New Hampshire Avenue The Aspen Hill submarket is a diverse, family- centric community, with an average household size of 3.25 people. In addition, Aspen Hill residents are committed to their neighborhood KEY 270 as a place to raise their families. Approximately Primary Trade Area (PTA) 60 percent of residents own their homes with an average length of residence of 19 years. The development of strip and neighborhood- Secondary Trade Area (STA) center type retail is correlated with the fact Submarket Boundary that Aspen Hill’s neighborhoods are largely Connecticut Avenue suburban. Suburban neighborhoods are Avenue Georgia typically served by neighborhood centers and strip centers. PROJECTIONS 2016 2020 2025
ADDITIONAL RETAILER-RELEVANT DATA Households 15,787 15,787 15,787 Median Household Income: $71,032 PTA Employees 8,652 8,721 8,813 Bachelor’s Degree or Higher: 31%
Households 19,747 20,103 20,758 STA
MWCOG Projections Round 9.0; Partners for Economic Solutions, 2016.
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 TRADE AREAS 26 The trade areas for the Aspen Hill submarket SUPPLY MAP were heavily influenced by its close proximity to the highly competitive retail submarkets Norbeck Road of Bethesda and Wheaton-Glenmont. The
Georgia Avenue Layhill Road Primary Trade Area (PTA) was drawn with Bel Pre Road reference to Wheaton-Glenmont to the south and Bel Pre Road to the north. Rock Creek Park is a natural boundary that limits the trade areas to the west. The Secondary Trade Area (STA) is bordered on the north by Norbeck Road. In the south, this area is limited by downtown Wheaton.
RETAIL SUPPLY
The majority of retail in the Aspen Hill Veirs Mill Road Connecticut Avenue submarket is neighborhood-focused, grocery- anchored retail, followed by large format centers. Aspen Hill’s neighborhoods are currently served by a high concentration of large shopping centers at the crossroads of Connecticut Avenue and Georgia Avenue. Together these centers create a diverse, suburban-centric retail mix. The location along two major corridors lends support to the General Merchandise, Apparel, Furnishings, & Other (GAFO) retailers present at this 270 KEY Randolph Road node beyond what would be expected in a Submarket Boundary traditional neighborhood retail cluster. 300-100,000 SF 100,001-200,000 SF
SUM OF MODIFIED CATEGORY SUM OF SQ.FT. SQ.FT.*
Neighborhood Goods & Services 172,958 142,942
Food & Beverage 61,690 43,653
General Merchandise, Apparel, 370,095 319,104 Furnishings, & Other
*NOTE: Modified square footage controls for the likelihood that Vacant & Non-Retail Occupied Space 42,199 31,476 a property will remain a retail space. See page 5 for additional details. Total 646,942 537,176
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 RETAIL DEMAND category at 254,284 square feet, or 60% of by complementary retail uses. retail demanded for the neighborhood. 27 The ability for the Aspen Hill submarket to • The Aspen Hill submarket is home to a capture expenditures within each of its trade There is no additional residential development diverse range of international groups. High areas is driven by proximity to shopping slated for the PTA. However, residential growth concentrations of people who identify as centers. The Primary Trade Area has capture in the STA and employment growth in the PTA Filipino and Vietnamese are located within rates averaging approximately 50 percent for will contribute to an overall demand growth for its primary trade area. Neighborhood Goods & Services (NG&S), 30 both 2020 and 2025. By 2025, retail demand percent for Food & Beverage (F&B) and in the will grow by approximately 8,000 square feet • Additionally, the Aspen Hill submarket mid- to high-teens for GAFO. to 431,312 square feet of total retail supported is exceptionally bilingual. According to by the PTA and STA. Census projections, only 39 percent of its Many Aspen Hill residents and employees population speak only English. A full 37 choose retail offerings along Rockville Pike SUBMARKET-SPECIFIC RETAIL CONDITIONS percent speak Spanish, as well as some and downtown Wheaton, including Westfield English. Wheaton, over those located in the submarket, The customer base for the Aspen Hill especially in the Food & Beverage and General submarket’s retail market has several unique • The cultural diversity of the Aspen Hill Merchandise categories. conditions not commonly found in the other submarket presents several potential submarkets. These characteristics give the avenues for mom and pop stores, and non- The existing demand for the Aspen Hill Aspen Hill submarket core a market distinction traditional retailers. submarket is 423,299 square feet. Due to that not only draws customers from a greater the residential typology of the submarket, distance, but also clearly communicates to the majority of the demand is in the NG&S potential retailers that they will be surrounded
ASPEN HILL SUBMARKET UNMET DEMAND UNDERSTANDING RETAIL SUPPLY AND Retail-occupied DEMAND Total Retail Space MODIFIED SUPPLY Neighborhood Goods There is a categorical mismatch between 2016 & Services (NG&S) the existing retail and what is demanded. Food & Beverage General Merchandise retail currently (F&B) makes up the majority of the retail, while Neighborhood Goods & Services and Food DEMAND General Merchandise, Apparel, Furnishings & & Beverage retail are undersupplied by 2016 Other (GAFO) 111,342 square feet and 23,698 square feet, respectively. While there will always be 20,373 SQ.FT. Retail Appropriate, individual retailers that perform well in an 2020 but Non-Retail oversupplied category, its negative effects Occupied Space will typically be borne by other retailers 11,103 SQ.FT. in that category, and may be particularly 2025 Vacant Space noticeable in the longer term (see page 12 for implications of oversupply). Into 100K 200K 300K 400K 500K 600K 2025, the existing retail supply will still (74,388) SQ.FT. exceed the retail demanded for the Aspen 2025 UNMET DEMAND Hill submarket by approximately 74,000 square feet.
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 ASPEN HILL SUBMARKET STRATEGY forward, there is an opportunity to reposition 28 The Aspen Hill submarket is a prime example vacant/underperforming retail space into of a neighborhood-centric submarket. NG&S and F&B retail. Although the GAFO supply outweighs the Within the Aspen Hill submarket, retaining the demand within that category, these tenants concentration of retail at the same intersection (e.g., Target, Walmart) primarily serve the should be prioritized, but total developed surrounding residents. These retailers are ideal square footage should be reasonably within for this community typology and supports the demand of the submarket. the Secondary Trade Area as well. Moving
OBSERVATION RECOMMENDATION
Developers proposing new projects with retail components should be encouraged to include NG&S (particularly service) and F&B tenants. NG&S retailers are often overlooked or not prioritized within developments due to a lack of understanding that there is a strong The Aspen Hill submarket has considerably more demand for NG&S need for these retailers. Also, there is a perception that NG&S retailers and F&B than is currently supplied in the market. are not credit-worthy. Investigate resources available at the County and state levels that open opportunities for service and food & beverage entrepreneurs which also serve to educate the retail and development community that NG&S is a viable tenanting strategy given the high level of unmet demand in this category.
As property owners consider redeveloping or changing their sites, Many GAFO retailers in Aspen Hill are located in subpar retail spaces, encourage locations with Class C strip malls to be repositioned as and are occupying a total square footage that exceeds what is another real estate use. Remain open to the rezoning of existing retail supportable within Aspen Hill. These factors are driving down retail or commercial zones into non-retail uses on parcels outside of Aspen rents, lowering sales potential, and negatively impacting overall Hill’s retail core. Please refer to page 12 for more information on the quality for this retail type. implications of oversupply.
As GAFO tenants turnover in the Aspen Hill submarket, encourage and promote opportunities for new types of tenant occupancy. Identify The Aspen Hill submarket’s retail mix is misaligned with significantly possible funding sources that would allow property owners to finance more GAFO retail than is demanded by the market. the costs of utilities upgrades or commercial kitchen installation that NG&S or F&B tenants may require.
Montgomery County Retail Study | Q3 2017 BETHESDA/CHEVY CHASE/NORTH BETHESDA 29
TRADE AREA MAP INTRODUCTION
The Bethesda/Chevy Chase/North 270 Bethesda submarket (referred to from 124 now on in this document as the “Bethesda 97 submarket”) is home to approximately a
29 third of all county employment. Wisconsin 370 200 Avenue (which turns into Rockville Pike de r e north of Downtown Bethesda) is the 95 center of downtown Bethesda and has or e Road 28 95 been a retail street for centuries. Over oo o e r ll Road time, retailers have evolved from taverns Po o a R er Par a 355