Margins for Success Piau-Voon Wang, Co-CIO of China’S Noah Holdings India’S Nbfcs Deliver Returns by Going Beyond Banks' Comfort Zones Page 7 Page 15
Asia’s Private Equity News Source avcj.com May 10 2016 Volume 29 Number 17
EDITOR’S VIEWPOINT Have China take-privates spiralled out of control? Page 4
NEWS Affinity, Baring Asia, BlackRock, CDIB, CVC, DCM, IFC, IL&FS, JBIC, Lenovo, Mayfield, NewQuest, Samara, Sequoia, SBCVC, Temasek Page 5
DEAL OF THE WEEK Hotung, CDIB lead round for Taiwan-based ACT Page 12 QIC eyes Asian demand for Australian beef Page 13
INDUSTRY Q&A Margins for success Piau-Voon Wang, co-CIO of China’s Noah Holdings India’s NBFCs deliver returns by going beyond banks' comfort zones Page 7 Page 15
FOCUS DEAL OF THE WEEK
Holes in cyberspace A cut above the rest Asia plays catch-up on high-tech security Page 11 Farfetch brings boutique fashion online Page 12 29TH ANNUAL
15-17 November 2016 Four Seasons Hotel Hong Kong REGISTRATION Book by 27 May and SAVE US$1,100
29TH ANNUAL Brochure available, The 29th Annual REGISTER AVCJ Private Equity & Venture NOW! Forum is the largest and most influential gathering of private equity and download now at venture professionals in Asia. avcjforum.com 15-17 November 2016 NOW OPEN! Four Seasons Hotel, Hong Kong Tuesday Wednesday 15 November 2016 16 November 2016 PE LEADERS’ INVESTMENT SUMMIT SUMMIT (DAY I) VENTURE CAPITAL Thursday SUMMIT 17 November 2016 LIMITED PARTNERS’ INVESTMENT SUMMIT SUMMIT (DAY II)
2015 Forum key statistics:
1,000+ 170 35 525 330 Participants Speakers Countries Companies LPs
Europe U.K. 4% China Hong Kong The 29th Annual AVCJ Private Equity 4% 10% 46% USA & Canada India 12% U.A.E. Japan & 1% 3% South Korea 4%
Malaysia & Singapore 12%
TOP 10 ATTENDING Other Australia COUNTRIES 2% 2%
& Venture Forum Join your peers avcjforum.com #avcjforum
The AVCJ Forum brings together Tuesday over 1,000 of the world’s leading 15 November 2016 GPs, LPs and other professionals PE LEADERS’ SUMMIT Wednesday for three days of quality 16 November 2016 discussions, speeches and VENTURE CAPITAL SUMMIT INVESTMENT networking. These perspectives SUMMIT (DAY I) LIMITED PARTNERS’ come to life at the AVCJ Private SUMMIT Thursday Equity & Venture Forum, 17 November 2016 scheduled for November 15-17 For more information INVESTMENT in Hong Kong. visit avcjforum.com SUMMIT (DAY II)
Europe U.K. 4% China Hong Kong 4% 10% 46% USA & Canada India 12% U.A.E. Japan & 1% 3% South Korea 4%
Malaysia & Singapore 12% Top 10 attending Other Australia countries 2% 2%
Join your peers avcjforum.com #avcjforum 29TH ANNUAL 29TH ANNUAL
15-17 November 2016 15-17 November 2016 Four Seasons Hotel Four Seasons Hotel Hong Kong Hong Kong REGISTRATION Book by 27 May and SAVE US$1,100 With over 170+ speakers and 330+ Limited BOOK NOW!
29TH ANNUAL and save up to Brochure available, The 29th Annual REGISTER Partners expected, make sure you register for AVCJ Private Equity & Venture NOW! Forum is the largest and most influential gathering of private equity and download now at venture professionals in Asia. avcjforum.com 15-17 November 2016 3 days of unrivalled networking opportunities. NOW OPEN! Four Seasons Hotel, Hong Kong Tuesday Wednesday 15 November 2016 16 November 2016 US$1,100 PE LEADERS’ INVESTMENT SUMMIT SUMMIT (DAY I) VENTURE CAPITAL Thursday SUMMIT 17 November 2016 (UNTIL 27 MAY ONLY) LIMITED PARTNERS’ INVESTMENT SUMMIT SUMMIT (DAY II) 2015 Forum key statistics: 2016 Sponsors 1,000+ 170 35 525 330 Participants Speakers Countries Companies LPs
Europe U.K. 4% China Hong Kong The 29th Annual AVCJ Private Equity 4% 10% 46% USA & Lead Sponsors Asia Series Sponsor Canada India 12% U.A.E. Japan & 1% 3% South Korea 4%
Malaysia & Singapore 12%
TOP 10 ATTENDING Other Australia COUNTRIES 2% 2%
& Venture Forum Join your peers avcjforum.com #avcjforum
The AVCJ Forum brings together Tuesday over 1,000 of the world’s leading 15 November 2016 GPs, LPs and other professionals PE LEADERS’ SUMMIT Wednesday Co-Sponsors for three days of quality 16 November 2016 discussions, speeches and VENTURE CAPITAL SUMMIT INVESTMENT networking. These perspectives SUMMIT (DAY I) LIMITED PARTNERS’ come to life at the AVCJ Private SUMMIT Thursday Equity & Venture Forum, 17 November 2016 scheduled for November 15-17 For more information INVESTMENT in Hong Kong. visit avcjforum.com SUMMIT (DAY II) Legal Sponsor LP Summit Sponsors
Europe PE Leaders’ Summit Sponsors U.K. 4% China Hong Kong 4% 10% 46% USA & Canada U.A.E.India Japan & 12% VC Summit Sponsors VC Summit Legal Sponsor 1% 3% South Korea 4%
Malaysia & Singapore Awards Sponsors Exhibitors 12% Top 10 attending Other Australia countries 2% 2% Registration enquiries: Call Anil Nathani on +852 2158 9636 or email to [email protected] Join your peers Enquiry Sponsorship enquiries: Call Darryl Mag on +852 2158 9639 or email to [email protected] avcjforum.com #avcjforum EDITOR’S VIEWPOINT [email protected]
Managing Editor Tim Burroughs (852) 2158 9661 Dangerous demand? Associate Editor Winnie Liu (852) 2158 9663 Staff Writer Holden Mann (852) 2158 9646 TAKE-PRIVATE DEALS INVOLVING US- artillery brought into the fray: on one side stand Justin Niessner (852) 2158 9678 listed Chinese companies used to be relatively the likes of Sequoia Capital, Cathay Capital and Design straightforward, and in some respects they still Shenzhen Ping An Decheng Investment; on the Edith Leung, Mansfield Hor are. A founder-CEO looks at the valuation his other, Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan, Legend Events business has achieved in the US, examines where Capital and China Life. George Sengulovski, comparable companies are trading in China, China International Capital Corp. (CICC) also Jessie Chan, Jonathon Cohen, factors in the compliance costs of a US listing, partnered with a strategic player to counter Sarah Doyle, and asks himself whether it is worth the effort. a buyout bid for Sinovac Biotech submitted Amelie Poon, Fiona Keung, At some point in this process, private equity gets by the company chairman and SAIF Partners. Jovial Chung, involved, prodding the founder in the direction Meanwhile, in the cases of recruitment portal Marketing of a take-private with offers of financial support. Zhaopin and auto listings platform Autohome Agrina Sandri, Priscilla Chu, They submit an offer, perhaps roping in third parties (CDH Investments and Ping An Yasna Mostofi any significant existing investors that want Insurance Group, respectively) made the first to take part in the buyout; and if the founder move and management responded by working Research has a controlling stake in the business, getting with private equity to try and put together a Helen Lee, Herbert Yum, Jason Chong, shareholder approval is rudimentary in most better deal. Kaho Mak, Tim Wong, jurisdictions. Completion takes time, but As to where all this might end – the public assuming shareholder lawsuits can be handled, markets slowdown that started in mid-2015 Sales financing is in place, and there are no challenging did not bring take-private activity to a standstill Anil Nathani, tax ramifications to dismantling the corporate – the regulator offered a hint last week. While Darryl Mag, Debbie Koo, Nathan Ho, Samuel Lau, structure, those involved can navigate the scotching reports of a suspension in listings by Pauline Chen process with a degree of confidence. companies previously taken-private in the US, a AVCJ has records of around 80 take-privates China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) Subscriptions since 2010, many but not all of which featured spokesman said the potential market impact of Jade Chan, Prudence Lau, private equity. Over half were launched in 2015. IPOs, M&A and restructurings of this nature. He Sally Yip These could be described as the post-Focus pinpointed the valuation gap between domestic Publishing Director Media wave, in acknowledgement of the $3.7 and overseas markets and investors speculating Allen Lee billion privatization of the outdoor advertising on shell companies. business that not only put China take-privates The inference is reasonably clear. The in the big league dollar-wise, but also marked privatization-domestic re-listing thesis is no Hong Kong Headquarter out a path to liquidity. Thirty months after the longer the preserve of sophisticated capital Suite 1602-6 privatization closed, Focus Media re-listed in providers: from the 36 parties connected with Grand Millennium Plaza 181 Queen’s Road Shenzhen through a reverse merger, giving a Qihoo’s privatization to the 36 investors that Central Hong Kong string of PE investors a substantial gain (most of bought shares in Focus Media several months T. (852) 2158 9700 it on paper). before the reverse merger was completed, F. (852) 2158 9701 participation is proliferating. It is unclear who E. [email protected] This success has given rise to even larger URL. avcj.com deals and even more demand to participate. these new entrants are or how much they really Transactions are no longer the work of just one know about what they are buying. Beijing Representative Office or two private equity sponsors in conjunction The take-private opportunity cannot last No.1-2-(2)-B-A554, 1st Building, No.66 Nanshatan, with a founder; in some deals, international forever, but as long as it does, the government Chaoyang District, Beijing, GPs have been pushed to one side by local wants to minimize potential damage to the People’s Republic of China funds, insurance companies, sovereign wealth market and to retail investors. Closer regulatory T. (86) 10 5869 6203 F. (86) 10 5869 6205 funds, and high net worth individuals – in short, scrutiny is therefore likely to make it harder for E. [email protected] whatever combination of pricing, flexibility on companies to re-enter the public domain via the terms, and regulatory leverage works best. A-share market. This doesn’t mean the door has In these circumstances it is perhaps only closed, rather that only quality companies with The Publisher reserves all rights herein. Reproduction in whole or logical that investors compete for deals. When quality backers will be allowed in. in part is permitted only with the written consent of AVCJ Group Limited. the founder and CEO of iKang Healthcare Group ISSN 1817-1648 Copyright © 2016 teamed up with FountainVest Partners on a bid last year, a consortium featuring industry rival Meinian Onehealth responded by tabling Tim Burroughs A Mergermarket Group company a higher offer. This led to a protracted and still Managing Editor unresolved battle with more and more heavy Asian Venture Capital Journal
4 avcj.com | May 10 2016 | Volume 29 | Number 17 NEWS
GLOBAL CVC exits China education the process of raising a larger round expected to business EIC be worth up to $700 million. BlackRock closes $630m CVC Capital Partners has sold its stake in CSRC to tighten rules on Education International Corporation (EIC), a global buyout fund China-based business that helps students enroll domestic PE fundraising BlackRock has raised more than $630 million for in universities overseas, to a consortium that The China Securities Regulatory Commission a direct co-investment buyout fund. Investors includes the company founder. (CSRC) will take further steps to regulate the included public and private pension funds, The sale generated RMB4.5 billion ($692 domestic private fund industry in response insurers and foundations in North American and million) for the PE firm, according to a source to an acceleration in illegal fundraising Europe. The BlackRock Private Opportunities familiar with the situation. CVC invested in EIC in activities. All managers are required to disclose Fund III will build a portfolio diversified by 2013, reportedly paying around $200 million for a fund information to the Asset Management geography, strategy and industry sector. Association of China (AMAC). The new rules include a definition of investors qualified to Mayfield raises $525m participate in funds as well as measures to across two global funds tighten control over different private fund assets. US-based venture capital firm Mayfield has DCM China co-founder raised $525 million in capital across two global investment funds. The firm will deploy $400 Ruby Lu joins H Capital million in early stage-focused vehicle Mayfield Ruby Lu, co-founder and general partner at DCM XV; Mayfield plans to invest in about 30 China, has joined H Capital, a China-focused companies, as with its other global funds. The venture capital firm founded by Xiaohong Chen, remaining $125 million is reserved for Mayfield ex-China managing partner at Tiger Global Select, which will target follow-on investments in Management. Lu started DCM Ventures’ China existing portfolio companies. majority stake comprising shares held by minority operation in conjunction with Hurst Lin. investor Actis Capital and Joe Li, the company’s founder and chairman. The buyer consortium is Sequoia backs rival take- AUSTRALASIA led by NLD Investment, a China-based private equity fund. Li and other members of the private bid for Zhaopin Tegel gains on trading management team are working in partnership Chinese recruitment platform Zhaopin, which is with NLD. CVC was previously reported to be already the target of a $1.1 billion take-private debut after $205m IPO looking at a Hong Kong listing for EIC. bid, has received a competing offer from a Shares in Affinity Equity Partners-owned Tegel EIC is China’s largest provider of overseas consortium including Sequoia Capital and Group Holdings closed up 5.2% on the first day educational counselling services, with a 13% company management. The new proposal of of trading in New Zealand following the poultry market share. The company has placed more $17.75 per share represents a 1.4% increase on producer’s NZ$298 million ($205 million) IPO. than 120,000 students in overseas education the prior offer made by CDH Investments and Tegel sold 192.8 million shares at NZ$1.55 apiece institutions, with 18,500 enrollments in 2014 Shanghai Goliath Investment Management. through a dual offering in New Zealand and alone. It also provides test preparation services. Australia, including 9.7 million existing shares. Following CVC’s investment, Isa Wong, formerly SBCVC, New Horizon back Affinity held an 87.4% interest in Tegel ahead of of Pearson, was brought in as CEO. In addition, the IPO, while ICG had 9.2%. EIC acquired New Pathway, a US-focused test China fashion site preparation and college counselling specialist. SBCVC and New Horizon Capital have led a RMB1 billion ($119 million) Series C round for GREATER CHINA Chuchujie, a Chinese mobile e-commerce ($120 million) in a Series A round of funding. Leo platform. Stone VC and Eastern Bell Venture Lenovo launches $500m Group, a Shenzhen-listed machinery maker, led Capital also participated. Chuchujie started the round with a RMB350 million contribution as a shopping guide platform that provided corporate VC fund in exchange for an 11.74% stake. Other investors information on e-commerce deals, but then Chinese PC maker Lenovo Group has launched included Source Code Capital and Plum Ventures. changed strategy to sell clothing directly. a $500 million corporate VC fund to invest in technology start-ups. It will invest in areas such CDIB Capital invests $45m as cloud computing and big data, artificial NORTH ASIA intelligence, and robot, internet and consumer. in Best Logistics CDIB Capital has committed $45 million to Best JBIC to invest in KKR Electric car maker Chehejia Logistics Technologies, a China-based IT-driven integrated logistics and supply chain business Americas fund raises $120m part-owned by Alibaba Group. The company has The Japan Bank for International Cooperation Chehejia, a Chinese manufacturer of smart previously received several rounds of funding (JBIC) has made an LP commitment to KKR’s electric vehicles, has raised RMB780 million from financial and strategic investors, and was in latest North American fund. The size of the
Number 17 | Volume 29 | May 10 2016 | avcj.com 5 NEWS
investment was not disclosed. KKR Americas Baring Asia buys 35% stake bought a majority stake in online jewelry retailer Fund XII is expected to hit the hard cap of $12 Caratlane, providing an exit for its backer Tiger billion, not including the GP contribution. in Telus Global Management. Tiger has committed over Baring Private Equity Asia has agreed to buy a $50 million to Caratlane over several rounds. GEPS seeks offshore 35% stake in Telus International, the business process outsourcing (BPO) arm of Canadian IFC to commit $40m to secondaries managers telecom company Telus, at a post-deal valuation South Korea’s Government Pension Investment of C$1.2 billion ($930 million). India’s Repco Service (GEPS) is looking to make two Telus will retain a 65% stake in Telus The International Finance Corporation (IFC commitments – of $50 million apiece – to International. The parent intends to maintain will commit up to INR2.7 billion ($40 million) overseas GPs operating co-mingled global a long-term ownership position and does not to Indian home finance-focused non-banking secondaries funds. Eligible managers must have plan any change in the support it provides its financial company (NBFC) Repco Home Finance. been in business for at least two years and have a subsidiary, such as facilities, network and IT It will use the new capital to provide loans to track record of investing $500 million or more in support. Proceeds of the investment, which Telus low-income individuals seeking to buy, build or private equity secondaries assets. reported to be about C$600 million – including improve their homes. $425 million in incremental bank financing – AID in $13m round for Snapdeal buys Nexus- home rental site backed TargetingMantra AID Partners and Cool Japan Fund have Indian e-commerce giant Snapdeal has bought contributed to a JPY1.4 billion ($13 million) round e-commerce personalization and analytics for Japan’s Hyakusenrenma, an online vacation service TargetingMantra for an undisclosed rentals platform. Domestic railway operator Keio amount. TargetingMantra, a product of the Corporation also participated in the investment. 500 Startups accelerator program in California, creates technology tools to analyze online shoppers’ buying habits to predict their tastes SOUTH ASIA and recommend products to them via email. DFJ sells India assets to MSDF to invest $50m in will be used to support the parent’s long-term NewQuest broadband network expansion strategy. Indian start-ups Direct secondaries specialist NewQuest Capital “We believe that the company is in a great The Michael and Susan Dell Foundation (MSDF) Partners has acquired the majority of Draper position to build on its past successes and has committed to invest $50 million in Indian Fisher Jurvetson’s (DFJ) India portfolio. The sale establish its position as a leading international start-ups over the next three years. The move involves holdings in between eight and 10 player in the space,” said Jean Eric Salata, CEO of represents an expansion of focus for the US- companies, including Bharat Light & Power, Baring Asia. “We aim to leverage our footprint and based philanthropic organization, which typically Attero Recycling, Canvera Digital Technologies, cross-border capabilities to further enhance Telus makes direct investments in education, skills and travel portal Cleartrip, among others. International’s client portfolio and help expand its development and financial inclusion initiatives. market presence.” IFC leads $60m round for Telus International, founded in 2006, provides Samara recruits partner customer service, IT and business support Lenskart services. It employs 22,000 people around the from Levi Strauss The International Finance Corporation (IFC) has world, with nearly half working in the Philippines. Samara Capital has named Sanjay Purohit, the led a INR4 billion ($60 million) Series D round managing director for India at Levi Strauss, of funding for Indian online eyewear retailer as a partner. He will eventually lead the GP’s Lenskart. Other investors in the round included IL&FS pushes back deadline consumer and retail practice. Adveq Management and existing backers TPG Growth and IDG Ventures. on latest fund IL&FS Investment Managers (IIML) has pushed SOUTHEAST ASIA Mobikwik raises $50m in back the deadline on its growth fund, with final close now expected in the first half of 2016. The TIH buys $46m portfolio Series C funding fund, Tara India Fund IV, launched in 2011 with India-based mobile wallet developer Mobikwik a target of $300 million, though the target was from Temasek unit has raised $50 million in a Series C round of later reduced to $75 million. IIML reported a first Singapore-listed PE firm TIH has purchased a funding led by Japanese internet company close of $40 million last year. majority stake in a resources and healthcare- GMO, Taiwan’s MediaTek, and existing backer focused portfolio from a unit of Temasek Sequoia Capital. The company partners with Titan buys Tiger-backed Holdings for S$62 million ($45.8 million). The retailers to provide digital payment services for portfolio includes interests in PE funds managed use both online and offline, and claims a network Caratlane by the International Finance Corporation (IFC) comprising 30 million users and 75,000 retailers Indian jeweler and watchmaker Titan has and Australia’s Pacific Road Capital.
6 avcj.com | May 10 2016 | Volume 29 | Number 17 COVER STORY [email protected] Lending a hand Momentum is building among India’s non-banking finance companies, and PE, government and regulators see promise in the power to reach untapped markets. Success will require the support of all three parties
EARLIER THIS YEAR, SANDEEP ANEJA, INR5 trillion in 2010 to INR12 trillion in 2015. This have more control over the terms of the founder of education-focused Indian GP Kaizen, rapid growth is expected to persist, since NBFC financing. Thus, though the cost of a particular was faced with an important decision. He had credit is just 13% of GDP in India, compared with deal may be higher for an NBFC than it would be passed on Varthana before, when the non- 26% for Malaysia, 33% for China and 74% for for a bank, the NBFC can derive a better return banking finance company (NBFC) – which lends Japan. than a bank could – particularly given that a bank to many small private schools that are not served This expansion of NBFCs as an element of would not have picked up the deal in the first by India’s traditional banks – was raising its Series India’s credit sector has been attributed to several place. A round in 2014. Back then Kaizen concluded strengths of the model, compared to traditional The small and medium enterprise (SME) the company was not mature enough; but what banks. One major difference is the lower market segment can also be targeted by sector- about now? investment required to build new branches. specific NBFCs, a more recent development Aneja decided to take the plunge, co-leading Banks, which typically offer a wider range of in India’s financial sector. These institutions the INR930 million ($14 million) Series B round products than NBFCs, have correspondingly are set up to pursue more narrowly focused with Zephyr Peacock India. He was not only greater infrastructure requirements, making opportunities, usually by leveraging the founders’ convinced by Varthana’s track record, but also it less economical to set up offices in some expertise in particular areas to identify borrowers encouraged by the founders’ expertise; their geographies than in others. that have been overlooked by banks and even by background in education gave the company an “I’ve seen NBFC branches that are literally other NBFCs. edge over other, non-specialized lenders. “Varthana will always be distinguished from PE investment in India NBFCs a generalist NBFC lending to schools, because it understands the education sector really well,” 1,200 says Aneja. “The credit process of Varthana is not 1,000 dependent entirely on understanding the values of the non-performing assets, or the loan to book 800 ratio, but it is dependent much more on the 600 quality of education.” US$ million 400 Kaizen’s Varthana investment is one example of the many approaches that private equity firms 200 have taken to India’s NBFC industry. Strategies 0 have evolved along with NBFCs themselves, 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 with early generalist participants being joined later by more narrowly focused lenders and ur e esear h investors. Industry participants says this segment of financial services can deliver considerable opportunities for investors able to keep pace four walls, no air-conditioning, two tables, two Varthana is one example of this phenomenon: with its development. computers and that is it,” says Bhavik Haithi, the company, launched by former teacher Steve managing director at Alvarez & Marsal. “A bank Hardgrave and banking veteran Brajesh Mitra, Rising star branch can’t operate without construction and assesses a potential borrower’s chances for NBFCs have become an increasingly prominent infrastructure, and NBFCs can save those costs repayment based on the strength of its business. part of India’s financial sector. A report by the and pass them on.” This approach is seen as more effective than a Boston Consulting Group (BCG) published last Some unique features of India’s market have purely financial form of appraisal, partly because year shows that the NBFC share of the overall also contributed to the NBFC growth story. For the borrowers often do not have an extensive credit sector rose from 10% in 2005 to 13% in one thing, the rapid growth of the country’s credit history and partly because it sees the 2015. This increase in market share is even more economy has created a steady stream of lending success of the underlying business as a better pronounced for narrower segments such as opportunities among large companies; with indicator of creditworthiness. home finance, where NBFCs went from 26% to India’s banks focusing on these businesses, Avanse Financial Services, another education- 38% between 2009 and 2015, and commercial smaller companies have had a harder time focused NBFC that provides loans to students vehicle loans, with growth from 42% in 2013 to attracting financing. pursuing higher education, follows a similar 46% in 2015. This creates a space into which NBFCs can approach. The company, which is backed by the Overall, loans from NBFCs have more than step, and since their customers have fewer International Finance Corporation (IFC), examines doubled over the past five years, increasing from options than most credit seekers, the institutions borrowers based primarily on their past academic
Number 17 | Volume 29 | May 10 2016 | avcj.com 7 COVER STORY [email protected]
performance and their likelihood of graduating product,” says Dhanpal Jhaveri, managing partner Other development-oriented investors and finding a job. for private equity at Everstone. “Given that these are attracted to the sector-specific approach “The biggest mitigating factor to risk, and would be specialized, custom solution-based among NBFCs. For example, while Kaizen the biggest likelihood of them getting their loan programs, borrowers would find it easier had no involvement in NBFCs before its money back, is if the student gets a job,” says to come to an NBFC like ours than to go to a investment in Varthana, the GP is now looking Kaizen’s Aneja. “It is not as if they drag the parents’ traditional banker.” for additional lending institutions that share its property down into a sale and find a buyer. That’s The GP also benefited from a looser focus on education. IFC, which promotes the a long drawn-out process; you may have covered regulatory environment allowing 100% foreign development goals of its parent, the World Bank, your principal but the cost itself is prohibitive for ownership in NBFCs, unlike traditional banks. This has also committed to more narrowly focused a lot of NBFCs.” allowed Everstone to bring in additional partners institutions; not only student lender Avanse, but such as specialist emerging markets investor also home finance provider Repco. PE approaches Ashmore Group and Goldman Sachs. These financial inclusion and development The ability of NBFCs to identify and assess While the financial returns provided by goals are shared by India’s government and lending opportunities in underserved NBFCs were an attractive enough reason for their regulators, which have also shown interest in populations is one factor in their appeal to early PE backers, as the industry has developed promoting NBFCs as alternatives to the country’s private equity. Their potential for high returns, in newer models are drawing in groups that were banks. First and foremost, the advantage of these spite of higher financing costs, is another. NBFCs’ previously inactive in the industry. For example, institutions in catering to SME borrowers passed average return on equity (ROE) has beaten that of CDC Group, the UK development finance over by the banks holds out the potential to the banks in all but two of the last 10 years, and institution, has shown a growing interest in improve employment and development in the the average ROE for NBFCs over the same period NBFCs over the last several years. country’s rural areas and lower-tier cities. was 15.7% compared to 14.1% for banks. CDC already had exposure to the industry Another impetus for the government and As a result, investors have piled in, committing through its fund commitments, but began RBI to promote NBFCs is to relieve pressure nearly $3 billion in Indian NBFCs over the last 10 to pursue direct deals in 2013 as a means of on traditional banks, whose volume of years. The level of investment has grown steadily promoting its financial inclusion goals for India. nonperforming assets is reaching worrying in that time, despite periodic spikes – the last in 2015, when total commitments reached almost $1.1 billion, about double the investments in the “I don’t see how NBFCs’ share is ever going to previous two years combined. That jump was the result of several larger- come down in the Indian context, considering than-normal deals, including Bain Capital’s INR13 how relevant they are at this point in time and billion commitment to L&T Finance Partners, the financial services unit of domestic conglomerate what is the situation of Indian banks, more Larsen & Toubro, and a INR16 billion investment – Sanjeev Krishan in microfinance institution (MFI) Bandhan importantly” Financial Services by IFC and GIC. These deals could be seen to represent the two poles in NBFC The move was in part driven by confidence in heights. NBFCs can provide an avenue for investing, but the space is even more complex. the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) response to the borrowing that would otherwise fall either on the While some stick to straightforward equity global financial crisis, which involved putting already overstressed banks or on the unregulated investments, others set up their own institutions. in place stronger nationwide regulations such shadow lending sector. KKR, for example, has two NBFCs in India: as interest rate caps and limits on loans per “I don’t see how NBFCs’ share is ever going to a structured credit provider founded in 2009 borrower. come down in the Indian context, considering that focuses on entrepreneurs, and a real CDC has committed capital to several MFIs, how relevant they are at this point in time estate-focused company set up last year with selecting Janalakshmi Financial Services, Equitas, and given the situation of Indian banks, more GIC Private as a lead investor. Pan-Asian special Ujjivan and Utkarsh for their resilience in the new importantly,” says Sanjeev Krishan, executive situations investor Clearwater Capital Partners environment. MFIs provide financial services to director for private equity at PwC. “I think the has been involved in the space even longer; its low-income populations – typically loans of up government has been doing a whole lot to NBFC, recently renamed to Altico Capital India, to INR20,000 to start a business – although a encourage the sector, and I think they’re very was founded in 2004 and is targeted at real number have applied for NBFC status in order to cognizant of that.” estate project finance. It raised a $300 million gain access to funding from banks. This combination of policy support and round of funding last year, led by Clearwater. “We felt like they were very focused on low credit penetration – overall and for NBFCs Everstone Capital is one of the most recent helping that bottom half of the pyramid and in particular –should sustain the momentum entrants to the space, creating IndoStar Capital the financially excluded, but they were quick to already present in the industry. BCJ projects a Finance in 2011. IndoStar provides financing adapt in order to be profitable in the new regime, constant annual growth rate of 20-27% through to corporate customer, aiming to meet unique meaning they diversified their product space,” the next four years, with NBFC credit reaching as or unusual needs that would not be met by says Maria Largey, director of financial institutions much as INR39 trillion by 2020 – 33% of India’s financial products provided by traditional banks. at CDC. “Equitas, for example, very quickly went GDP. “There were different types of end users for into affordable housing and vehicle finance. which loans would be required, which a typical They also increased or improved their operating Evolution to come bank may not have considered because, typically, expense ratios by making more efficient As NBFCs continue to expand their share of banks would have a very cookie-cutter lending processes and systems.” the market, industry players expect continued
8 avcj.com | May 10 2016 | Volume 29 | Number 17 COVER STORY [email protected]
savings accounts. Several PE-backed institutions eturn on equity s vs an s have received approval for these licenses, 20 including Kedaara-backed Au Financiers and CDC-backed Ujjivan. Additional regulatory moves desired by PE investors include the removal of restrictions on 15.7