Edgewrite with a PDA Stylus Edgewrite with a Desktop Trackball
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EEddggeeWWrriittee:: AA VVeerrssaattiillee DDeessiiggnn ffoorr AAcccceessssiibbllee TTeexxtt EEnnttrryy Jacob O. Wobbrock & Brad A. Myers, Human-Computer Interaction Institute, Carnegie Mellon University www.edgewrite.com Overview EdgeWrite with a PDA Stylus EdgeWrite with a Desktop Trackball EdgeWrite on a Mobile Phone EdgeWrite is a versatile design for Makes PDA text entry more Provides a gestural Provides a gestural means of accessible text entry. It provides stability to accessible to people with alternative for trackball mobile phone text entry for users with motor impairments or under motor impairments. users resigned to on- able-bodied users "on the screen keyboards. go," e.g., while walking. May situational impairments caused by using Characters are made by be less dependent on visual mobile devices "on the go." EdgeWrite moving the stylus along the Trackball EdgeWrite is less attention than Multitap methods are gestural and can be done by edges and into the corners of visually intense and less and/or T9. feel. EdgeWrite characters mimic Roman the EdgeWrite square. This tedious than an on-screen letters, improving guessability and provides stability to people keyboard. Two mobile phone versions: learnability. EdgeWrite is available on with tremor or experiencing various devices for both handheld and vibration. Instead of physical Isometric joystick on the edges, Trackball Edge- front or back of the phone. desktop text entry. Write relies on "pulsing" the ball at angles which Touch-sensitive buttons Thesis indicate desired corners. where the 1, 2, 4 and 5 keys Graffiti "d", misrecognized EdgeWrite "d", recognized A versatile design for accessible text entry Results This is a crossing task. serve as the EdgeWrite corners. based on movement along edges and into Able-bodied novices were 18% Results more accurate than Graffiti after corners can outperform predominant text Able-bodied users wrote at ~10 wpm and ~4% total errors 15 minutes of practice (1.21 vs. entry methods on a variety of desktop and after 45 minutes of practice. They were not trackball users. 1.43 kspc, p<.05). There was no Evaluation handheld computing devices when subject Average Error Rates significant difference in speed Average Speed The mobile phone versions will be evaluated in a study of to motor or situational impairments. 15 (6.6 vs. 7.2 wpm, n.s.). text entry while walking. Able-bodied users will 10 12.75 experience vibrational tremor and divided *Lower kspc is better (i.e. more accurate). M 9.96 10.00 P W visual attention while walking. EdgeWrite will 5 6.75 Alphabet be compared to Multitap and/or T9. Users with motor impairments were 200-400% more All EdgeWrite versions use the same 0 alphabet. Characters are defined by the accurate with EdgeWrite than with Graffiti in writing "a-z" Subject and "0-9" 2 times for a total of 72 characters per user. order in which they hit corners within the Sessions with a 15-year trackball user showed he was faster EdgeWrite square. Example (Cerebral Palsy): "The dog is going fast" (5.0 vs. 4.3 wpm, p<.05) and left fewer errors on average Graffiti: "The g i gbsiangu% fast" (8 errors) (1.35% vs. 2.35%, n.s.) with Trackball EdgeWrite than with his letters punctuation set unset EdgeWrite: "The dog is going fast" (0 errors) preferred on-screen keyboard. He now uses EdgeWrite. a b c ç d e f g . , ' " : ; ? ! Average Jim's Average Speeds Jim's Average Uncorrected Errors Parkinson's MD 7 6 h i I j k l m n / \ | ` ~ @ # $ 98.3% 6 On-screen 94.4% Ew 98.7% Ew 5 On-screen 5 Keyboard 75.9% 4 Keyboard t o p q r s t u v % ^ & * - _ + = n M 4 30.6% Graffiti 33.0% Graffiti e Trackball P c 3 Trackball r W e 3 EdgeWrite EdgeWrite P 2 w x y z capitalization ( ) [ ] < > { } 2 Spastic CP CP 1 1 0 0 100.0% Ew 100.0% Ew 1 3 4 10 12 14 15 1 3 4 10 12 14 15 84.0% Graffiti 96.0% Graffiti Graffiti Ew Week Number Week Number numbers and accents extended set unset 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 · ° ‘ ’ “ ” ® § Other EdgeWrite Versions 9 0 ™ © ¢ × ÷ € ¥ Edges Size Position Sensing £ µ ß ¤ ‹‹ ›› ² ³ Physical Virtual None Tiny Small Medium Absolute Relative Continuous Discrete Accents are made immediately after the letters PDA Stylus Touch buttons? PDA Stylus StampPad Touchpad PDA Stylus PDA Stylus Touch buttons? they modify. Not all letters can be accented. ^ Touchpad Wrist watch Touchpad Touchpad ` ` ^ ~ .. ° ¸ ¿ ¡ – — ± ‰ Lift StampPad Touch buttons? StampPad StampPad Wrist Watch Wrist watch Wrist watch Wrist watch Game Joystick Touch buttons? Thumbstick Thumbstick Wheelchair Thumbstick Thumbstick Wheelchair Wheelchair Wheelchair whitespace extended Snap-to- set unset n o space backspace enter tab i Center t a t n e Touch buttons Touch buttons Touch buttons Touch buttons menu shortcut f f g g ð æ ƒ œ ø m Four Keys Four keys Four keys Four keys Four keys Touchpad g e Adaptive S Timeout h h i These extended characters can be capitalized in the usual manner. f g Ð Æ F Œ Ø Trackball Wand? Isometric joy Trackball Wand? Trackball Trackball i |f word word g| Isometric joy Wand? Isometric joy Isometric joy Movement Wand? StampPad Ceases EdgeWrite Alphabet, version 2.1.5 (C) 2005 Human-Computer Interaction Institute, Carnegie Mellon University Power Wheelchair Joystick.