Eelgrass in Buzzards Bay: Distribution, Production, and Historical Changes in Abundance ERRATA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
United States Office of Marine EPA Re ion 1 Environmental Protection ' and Es?uarine Protection Boston LA Agency Washington DC 20460 Water EPA 50314-88402 September 1988 Eelgrass in Buzzards Bay: Distribution, Production, and Historical Changes in Abundance ERRATA for Costa, J.E. 1988. Eelgrass in Buzzards Bay: Distribution, Production, and Historical Changes in Abundance, BBP-88-05 - Page 114, the last paragraph should read: These observations do not rule out the possibility that warm temperatures played a role in the 1931-32 decline, but suggest that temperature cannot be the sole factor in causing regional collapses in eelgrass populations. Instead, other unknown factors must be involved. -2 -1 7 Page 26, line 6 should read 107 g C m yr not 10 . EELGRASS IN BUZZARDS BAY: DISTRIBUTION, PRODUCTION AND HISTORICAL CHANGES IN ABUNDANCE Joseph E. Costa Boston University Marine Program The Buzzards Bay Project is sponsored by The US Environmental Protection Agency and The Hassachusetts Executive Off ice of Environmental Affairs THE BUZZARDS BAY PROJECT US Environmental Protection Agency Massachusetts Executive Office of WQP-2100 Environmental Affairs John F. Kennedy Federal Building 100 Cambridge Street Boston. MA 02203 Boston, MA 02202 FOREWORD In 1984, Buzzards Bay was one of four estuaries in the country chosen to be part of the ~ationalEstuary Program. The Buzzards Bay Project was initiated in 1985 to protect water quality and the health of living resources in the bay by identifying resource management problems, investigating the causes of these problems, and recommending actions that will protect valuable resources from further environmental degradation. This multi-year project, jointly managed by United States Environmental Protection Agency and the Massachusetts Executive Office of Environmental Affairs, utilizes the efforts of local, state, and federal agencies, the academic community and local interest groups in developing a Master Plan that will ensure an acceptable and sustainable level of environmental quality for Buzzards Bay. The Buzzards Bay Project is focusing on three priority problems: closure of shellfish beds, contamination of fish and shellfish by toxic metals and organic compounds, and high nutrient input and the potential pollutant effects. By early 1990, the Buzzards Bay Project will develop a Comprehensive Conservation and Management Plan to address the Project's overall objectives: to develop recommendations for regional water quality management that are based on sound information, to define the regulatory and management structure necessary to implement the recommendations, and to educate and involve the public in formulating and implementing these recommendations. The Buzzards Bay Project has funded a variety of tasks that are intended to improve our understanding of the input, fate and effects of contaminants in coastal waters. The Project will identify and evaluate historic information as well as generate new data to fill information gaps. The results of these Project tasks are published in this Technical Series on Buzzards Bay. This report represents the technical results of an investigation funded by the Buzzards Bay Project. The results and conclusions contained herein are those of the author(s). These conclusions have been reviewed by competent outside reviewers and found to be reasonable and legitimate based on the available data. The Management Committee of the Buzzards Bay Project accepts this report as technically sound and complete. The conclusions do not necessarily represent the recommendations of the Buzzards Bay Project. Final recommendations for resource management actions will be based upon the results of this and other investigations. David Fierra, chairman, Management Committee ~nvironmentai protection ~~enc~ Thomas Bigford National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Steve Bliven Massachusetts Office of Coastal Zone Management Leigh Bridges Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries Jack Clarke Cape Cod Planning and Economic Development Commission Richard Delaney Massachusetts Office of Coastal Zone Management Meriel Hardin Massachusetts Department of Environmental Quality Engineering Dr. Russell Isaac Massachusetts Division of Water Pollution Control Dr. Susan Peterson President, Coalition for Buzzards Bay Dr. Don Phelps Environmental Protection Agency Ted Pratt Chairman, Buzzards Bay Citizens Advisory Committee Stephen Smith Southeast Regional Planning and Economic Development District Bruce Tripp Massachusetts Executive Office of Environmental Affairs Acknowledgements The preparation of this report and the analysis of changes in eelgrass abundance at selected areas of Buzzards Bay was funded by the New England Interstate Water Pollution Control Commission as part of a study of Buzzards Bay by the Environmental Protection Agency. This research, however, has a much longer history involving many individuals and organizations. The initial support from this study came from the Lloyd Center for Environmental Studies and the NOAA National Sea Grant College Program, Dept. of Commerce, Grant No. NA84AA-D-00033, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, Proj. No. R/B-68. The volunteers, assistants, and people contributing to this effort are too numerous to mention, but they have my eternal thanks. Table of contents page Title page i Acknowledg i Table of contents iii List of Figures ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... v i List of Tables ............................................................................................................................................................................................................ ix Executive summary x Overview Introduction 1 General biology and ecology of eelgrass. 2 Chapter 1 The distribution of eelgrass (Zostera marina L.) in Buzzards Bay Introduction Region wide summary Chapter 2 Eelgrass (Zostera marina L.) production in Buzzards Bay Introduction 2 5 Comparison of 26 and adjoining shallow embayments 29 Chapter 3 Evidence for long-term changes in eelgrass (Zostera marina L.) abundance in Massachusetts in sediment cores iii Introduction 3 3 Methods 3 5 3 8 49 Chapter 4 Historical Changes in eelgrass (Zostera marina L.) abundance in Buzzards Bay: Long term patterns and twelve case histories Introduction 5 2 Factors 5 3 The wasting disease 5 5 Anthropogenic and natural disturbances 5 8 Recolonization and interpreting historical changes 64 6 5 6 7 6 7 74 Clarks Cove and New Bedford 8 0 Nasketucket Bay, Fairhaven 8 5 East Bay, West Island, Fair 8 7 Sippican Harbor, Marion 9 1 Great Neck, Wareham and the Wareham River Estuary 9 3 Buttermilk Bay, Bourne and Wareham 9 6 Megansett Harbor, Bourne and Falmouth 102 Wild Harbor, Falmouth 104 West Falmouth Harbor 104 Waquoit Bay, Falmout 105 Discussion 107 Impa 107 Causes of the disease, the temperature hypothesis 111 General patterns of recolonization 117 Causes for recent declines 119 Chapter 5 Management considerations of eelgrass populations in Massachusetts Resource assessment 122 Federal, state, and local laws 122 Implications of changing eelgrass abundance 125 Future monitoring 126 Mitigation efforts 129 Future management 130 Water quality prot 133 Appendix I Repositories of aerial photographs and nautical charts used in this study. 135 Appendix I1 A detailed description of eelgrass in Buzzards Bay Introduction 13 6 136 139 141 Fairhaven to Brant Island, Mattapoisett 143 Matta~oisettHarbor and vicinity .....,,.................,....... ................ ,,,....... , 145 Hiller Cove, Mattapoisett to Marion 146 Sippican Neck, Ma 147 Great Neck Wareham to Pocasset, Bourne 148 Bourne: Wings Neck to Megansett 150 Falmouth: Meganse 152 Falmouth: Chappaquoit Point to Gunning Point 152 Falmouth: Woods Hole Area 153 Elizabeth Islands 154 Appendix 111--Alphabetized listing of mapped eelgrass beds by town ................... .. ... ....... .............. .. .. .. ............. ......... .... ............... ....................................... .. ......,................. ... ........................... .. ..,. .. ......, ,, ... ... 180 References Cited ............ ...................... ... ..........,... ..............,,.......,......... ,.. .,.. .. .,,.... ... .,,,........, ............ ....., ,. ,. ...,......... ....... 189 List of Figures Figure 0-1. General morphology of Zostera marina. Figure 1-1. Map of Southeastern Massachusetts. Figure 1-2. Percent cover scale. Figure 1-3. Maximum depth (m MLW) parts of Buzzards Bay. Figure 3-1. Location of sediment Bay and Cape Cod. 37 Figure 3-2. Seed densities distribution in Waquoit Bay. 4 1 Figure 3-3. Sediment core eelgrass seed profiles in 4 Bays. .........................42 Figure 3-4. Depth of depositional markers in core WB4. 4 6 Figure 4-1. Site names around the Westport Rivers. 69 Figure 4-2. Changes in eelgrass bed position and f north of Bailey Flat, Westport. 72 Figure 4-3. Map showing site names around Ap So. Dartmouth. 76 Figure 4-4. 78 Figure 4-5. Boats moored or in transit in inner and outer of Apponagansett Bay on four dates during comparable times in the recreational season. 81 Figure 4-6. Dates and locations of former eelgr around New Bedford. 84 Figure 4-7. Eelgrass distribution 1956 and 1981. 86 Figure 4-8. Eelgrass distribution in East Cove of West Island, Fairhaven during four different periods. 89 Figure 4-9. Recent changes in eelgrass