The Status of the Dixie Valley Toad
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Western North American Naturalist Volume 77 Number 2 Article 3 5-19-2017 Between hot rocks and dry places: the status of the Dixie Valley toad Matthew J. Forrest University of California–San Diego, La Jolla, CA, [email protected] Josefin Stiller University of California–San Diego, La Jolla, CA, [email protected] Tim L. King U.S. Geological Survey, Leetown Science Center, Kearneysville, WV, [email protected] Greg W. Rouse University of California–San Diego, La Jolla, CA, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/wnan Recommended Citation Forrest, Matthew J.; Stiller, Josefin; King, Tim L.; and Rouse, Greg W. (2017) "Between hot rocks and dry places: the status of the Dixie Valley toad," Western North American Naturalist: Vol. 77 : No. 2 , Article 3. Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/wnan/vol77/iss2/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Western North American Naturalist Publications at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Western North American Naturalist by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. Western North American Naturalist 77(2), © 2017, pp. 162–175 BETWEEN HOT ROCKS AND DRY PLACES: THE STATUS OF THE DIXIE VALLEY TOAD Matthew J. Forrest1,3, Josefin Stiller1, Tim L. King2, and Greg W. Rouse1 ABSTRACT.—In Dixie Valley, Nevada, an isolated population of toads has been the subject of proactive conservation measures by the Nevada Department of Wildlife and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service since 2008 due to concerns about potential habitat degRadation ReSulting fRom exploitation of neaRby geotheRmal eneRgy ReSouRceS. TheSe toadS appear to belong within the Anaxyrus boreas species group but are commonly referred to as Dixie Valley toads (DVTs). The DVT is currently confined to an extremely narrow habitat range (370 ha) that is geographically isolated from any other A. boreas population. In this study, genetic variations in mitochondrial genes and 11 microsatellite loci were used to assess the affinities of DVTs in relation to members of the A. boreas species group. We compared results from DVTS with pReviouSly publiShed data Spanning much of the Range of A. boreas in the United StateS and new data fRom a nearby toad population within Dixie Valley. Data from both mitochondrial DNA and microsatellites placed DVTs inside the A. boreas species group. In particular, DVTs fell into a cluster of A. boreas from Washington and California, along with other species from the A. boreas species group, namely A. nelsoni, A. canorus, and A. exsul. Genetic differentiation of DVTS waS loweSt between A. boreas populationS in WaShington and CalifoRnia. HoweveR, allele fRequencieS weRe Significantly diffeRent between DVTS and all otheR populationS, including a neaRby locality within Dixie Valley. ThiS genetic differentiation, along with the DVT’s geographical isolation and restricted habitat, warrants recognition of the DVT as a distinct management unit. RESUMEN.—Desde el 2008 en el Valle Dixie, en Nevada, Estados Unidos, el Departamento de Fauna de Nevada y del Servicio de Pesca y Fauna de los Estados Unidos ha tomado medidas proactivas de conservación de una población aislada de sapos, debido a la preocupación de una posible degradación del hábitat resultado de la explotación de los recursos energéticos geotérmicos cercanos. Estos sapos parecen pertenecer al grupo de especies de Anaxyrus boreas, pero se los conoce comúnmente como sapos del Valle Dixie (DVT, por sus siglas en inglés). Actualmente, los DVT están confinadoS a un Rango de hábitat extRemadamente eStRecho (370 hectáReaS), geogRáficamente aiSlado de otRaS pobla- ciones de A. boreas. Se utilizaron las variaciones genéticas en los genes mitocondriales y 11 loci microsatélitales para evaluar las afinidades de los DVT en relación con los miembros de los grupos de la especie A. boreas. Comparamos a los DVT con datoS pReviamente publicadoS de gRan paRte del Rango de A. boreas en loS EStadoS UnidoS, con datoS nuevoS de una población cercana de sapos en el Valle Dixie. Tanto el ADN mitocondrial como los microsatélites colocan a los DVT dentro del grupo de A. boreas. En particular, los DVT se incluyeron dentro de un grupo de A. boreas de Washington y de California junto con otras especies del grupo de A. boreas, como, A. nelsoni, A. canorus y A. exsul. La diferenciación genética de los DVT fue la menor entre las poblaciones de A. boreas en Washington y en California. Sin embargo, las frecuencias alélicas fueron significativamente diferentes entre los DVT y todas las demás poblaciones, incluyendo la de una localidad ceRcana dentRo del Valle Dixie. ESta difeRenciación genética, junto con Su aiSlamiento geogRáfico y la restricción del hábitat, avala el reconocimiento de los DVT como una unidad de manejo diferente. Dixie Valley toads (DVTs) are morphologi- population (K. URquhaRt, peRSonal communi- cally unusual toads with an extremely narrow cation 2016). TheSe agencieS aRe conceRned diStRibution (appRoximately 370 ha) within Dixie that exploitation of geotheRmal and gRound - Valley, ChuRchill County, Nevada (Fig. 1). water resources within Dixie Valley may cause Although the toad is not formally described, it diStuRbanceS to eSSential wetland habitat foR has been suggested that the DVT represents a DVTS (BLM, CCD 2013, BLM 2014). The DVT SepaRate SpecieS (Wildlife Action Plan Team occuRS within the Range of Anaxyrus boreas 2012, RoSe et al. 2015), and the Nevada DepaRt- (Fig. 2), and shares morphological similarities ment of Wildlife (NDOW), the BuReau of with otheR toadS fRom the A. boreas SpecieS Land Management (BLM), and the U.S. FiSh gRoup (WRight and WRight 1949, StebbinS and Wildlife Service (USFWS) currently con- 2003, Dodd 2013). Note that Anaxyrus mem- SideR it an impoRtant and potentially vulneRable beRS aRe tReated aS being in the genuS Bufo 1Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California San Diego, La Jolla, CA. 2Leetown Science Center, U.S. Geological Survey, Kearneysville, WV. 3E-mail: [email protected] 162 2017] STATUS OF THE DIXIE VALLEY TOAD 163 Fig. 1. Satellite map of Dixie Valley, Nevada, area showing locations of sampling sites for Dixie Valley toads and toads from McCoy Ranch. Courtesy of J. Harter, USFWS. 164 WESTERN NORTH AMERICAN NATURALIST [Volume 77 Fig. 2. Map of the Sampled populationS of the A. boreas SpecieS gRoup, mainly fRom SwitzeR et al. (2009). New genotypeS aRe fRom 2 populationS in Nevada: toadS fRom McCoy Ranch (NV2) and Dixie Valley toadS (NV3, in puRple). The daShed line coRReSpondS to the main Split in the micRoSatellite data aS indicated thRough the Structure aSSignment (See Fig 6A). by Some authoRS (See Pauly et al. 2009 foR no perennial streams in the Stillwater Range; fuRtheR diScuSSion). theRefoRe, Recent connectivity between the Currently, DVTs rely on 4 wetlands fed by DVT and thiS A. boreas population iS veRy geotheRmal SpRingS, the only peRennial SouRceS unlikely. of habitable freshwater in their native habitat The Anaxyrus boreas (BaiRd and GiRaRd (Fig. 1). The SuRRounding SoilS aRe pRimaRily 1852) SpecieS gRoup compRiSeS 2 SubSpecieS very dry, alkaline playa deposits covered with that aRe bRoadly diStRibuted acRoSS weSteRn Salt cRuStS (GaRcia et al. 2014), which likely North America and 3 other species with local- SeRve aS impaSSable baRRieRS foR amphibianS. ized diStRibutionS (Fig. 2; StebbinS 2003, Temperatures on the Dixie Valley floor range Goebel et al. 2005, 2009, Dodd 2013). The fRom <0 °C in winteR to >40 °C in SummeR, weSteRn toad, Anaxyrus boreas (BaiRd and with daily fluctuations often exceeding 20 °C. Girard 1852), occurs from the east slope of the Mean annual precipitation from 2006 to 2011 Rocky MountainS to the Pacific Ocean, and waS 102 mm (GaRcia et al. 2014). The geo- fRom noRtheRn Baja CalifoRnia, Mexico, to gRaphically cloSeSt population of A. boreas Alaska and the Yukon of Canada (Goebel et al. toads outside of Dixie Valley is approximately 2009, Dodd 2013). The SubSpecieS Anaxyrus 30 km to the southwest in the Stillwater Wet- boreas boreas (BaiRd and GiRaRd 1852), com- landS (K. URquhaRt, peRSonal communication monly referred to as the boreal toad, occupies 2016). HoweveR, the StillwateR Range, which most of this range. The second subspecies, the iS 110 km long and ReacheS heightS of 1000– CalifoRnia toad, Anaxyrus boreas halophilus 2500 m, SepaRateS the Still wateR WetlandS (Baird and Girard 1853), occurs from northern from Dixie Valley. Water is scarce, as there are California south to Baja California, Mexico. 2017] STATUS OF THE DIXIE VALLEY TOAD 165 The 3 other narrowly distributed Anaxyrus METHODS species also considered by Goebel et al. (2009) to be members of the A. boreas species group We collected SampleS fRom Dixie Valley aRe A. exsul (MyeRS 1942), A. nelsoni (StejnegeR toads (site NV3 in Fig. 2) and from toads in a 1893), and A. canorus (Camp 1916). The black small population at nearby McCoy Ranch (site toad, A. exsul, occuRS only in Deep SpRingS NV2). The latter were included in the analyses Valley in eaSt centRal CalifoRnia (MyeRS 1942, because of their proximity to the DVT habitat Fellers 2005). Similarly, the Amargosa toad, A. (about 50 km away; Fig. 1); thiS iS the only nelsoni, occupies a very limited range, and is otheR known population of A. boreas toadS cuRRently only found in the AmaRgoSa RiveR within Dixie Valley (K. URquhaRt, peRSonal dRainage of SouthweSteRn Nevada (Altic and communication 2016). We integRated new Dodd 1987, Goebel et al. 2005, Forrest et al. Sequence data foR mitochondRial geneS and 2015). The YoSemite toad, A. canorus, iS naR- micRoSatellite genotypeS fRom theSe SampleS Rowly diStRibuted at high elevationS in the with pReviouSly publiShed data fRom the A. Sierra Nevada in California, and is sympatric boreas SpecieS gRoup (Simandle et al. 2006, with A.