Life in a World Heritage City a Case Study of Discussions and Contested Values in Angra Do Heroísmo, the Azores
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Linköping Studies in Arts and Science • No. 646 Life in a World Heritage City A case study of discussions and contested values in Angra do Heroísmo, the Azores Marit Johansson Department of Culture Studies Linköping University, Sweden Linköping 2015 Linköping studies in arts and science • No. 646 At the Faculty of Arts and Science at Linköping University, research and doctoral studies are carried out within broad problem areas. Research is organized in interdisciplinary research environments and doctoral studies mainly in graduate schools. Jointly, they publish the series Linköping Studies in Arts and Science. This thesis comes from the Department of Culture Studies (Tema kultur och samhälle, Tema Q). At Tema Q, culture is studied as a dynamic field of practices, including agency as well as structure, and cultural products as well as the way they are produced, consumed, communicated and used. Tema Q is part of the larger Department for Studies of Social Change and Culture (ISAK). Life in a World Heritage City A case study of discussions and contested values in Angra do Heroísmo, the Azores Marit Johansson, 2015 Cover: The World Heritage Symbol in the cobblestones in Angra do Heroísmo, the Azores Layout: Per Lagman Photo: Marit Johansson Other photos in thesis: David Torell/Marit Johansson Printed in Sweden by LiU-Tryck, Linköping, Sweden, 2015 ISBN 978-91-7519-057-0 ISSN 0282-9800 Contents CONTENTS ABSTRACT .......................................................................................................... V FOREWORD ........................................................................................................ VI PART I INTRODUCING THE CASE, THE AIMS AND THE MEANS ............ 1 1 Introduction .................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Research questions .............................................................................. 3 1.2 Structure of thesis .............................................................................. 10 2 Portugal, Azores, Angra do Heroísmo, UNESCO and World Heritage – how does it all come together? ...................................................................... 13 2.1 Portugal and the Azores – a general background............................. 14 2.2 Angra do Heroísmo – entering the World Heritage community ....... 25 2.3 The legal and administrative apparatus for the safeguarding of the Classified Zone of Angra do Heroísmo ................................................... 33 2.4 Conclusion ......................................................................................... 36 3 Heritage – the critical research discourse ................................................... 39 3.1 What is heritage? ............................................................................... 39 3.2 “The heritage boom” – what triggered the people’s interest for heritage? .................................................................................................. 44 3.3 Heritage, Identity and Politics .......................................................... 47 3.4 A heritage site – the notion of space and place ................................. 52 3.5 World Heritage – the becoming of an academic field ....................... 57 3.6 Conclusion ......................................................................................... 63 4 Methods ...................................................................................................... 65 4.1 The case and the ethnographical fieldwork ...................................... 66 4.2 Qualitative Interviews ....................................................................... 69 i Contents 4.3 Observation studies – getting close ................................................... 74 4.4 Other sources .................................................................................... 75 4.5 Handling the Data ............................................................................. 77 4.6 On self-reflexivity and ethics during the fieldwork in Angra do Heroísmo ................................................................................................. 80 4.7 Conclusion ......................................................................................... 83 PART II ANGRA DO HEROÍSMO – RETROSPEKTIVE ................................ 85 5 The Earthquake ........................................................................................... 85 5.1 The 1st of January – the Inhabitants’ Accounts ................................. 87 5.2 The effects on Angra do Heroísmo as a local community ................. 90 5.3 The Reconstruction of the City of Angra do Heroísmo ..................... 92 5.4 The Missing Memorials ..................................................................... 97 5.5 Conclusion ....................................................................................... 101 6 The Nomination Process – on the process of nominating Angra do Heroísmo to the World Heritage List .......................................................... 107 6.1 The “Key Person” and his Story ..................................................... 109 6.2 The Nomination and the Enlistment ................................................ 112 6.3 Early and present nominations ....................................................... 120 6.4 Conclusion ....................................................................................... 125 PART III RESIDING IN- AND MANAGING A WORLD HERITAGE CITY – LIVING IN, WITH AND BY HERITAGE ....................................................... 129 7 Sufficient preservation, good living conditions and flourishing commerce – how to balance it all? ................................................................................... 131 7.1 The “Gabinete” – the closure of the Conservation Office .............. 131 7.2 “The goal is… is for Angra do Heroísmo to be inhabited” ............ 138 7.3 “The second earthquake” – the Problem of the Termites ............... 145 7.4 Doing business in a World Heritage City – limits and possibilities 150 7.5 Conclusion ....................................................................................... 155 ii 8 When the Cobblestones Cause Debate ..................................................... 159 8.1 A petition trigged by an accident in the streets of Angra ................ 160 8.2 The stakeholders involved – interests, values and capitals ............. 167 8.3 “Inhabitants are the most important stakeholder” – a discussion . 171 8.4 Conclusion ....................................................................................... 174 9 Contemporary Development in a World Heritage City – possibilities and limitations .................................................................................................... 181 9.1 The marina ...................................................................................... 182 9.2 The New Public Library – “É horrível” ......................................... 193 9.3 The hotel .......................................................................................... 206 9.4 The cruise ship terminal .................................................................. 209 9.5 Concluding remarks ........................................................................ 213 10 World Heritage clearly attracts tourists or …? The State of Tourism and Mediation of the World Heritage Status in Angra do Heroísmo ................. 219 10.1 Tourism in the Azores and Angra do Heroísmo ............................ 221 10.2 Tourism – “What is the greatest reason for coming to Angra? Undoubtedly, it is because it is a World Heritage City” ...................... 223 10.3 World Heritage as a brand – the mediation of Angra do Heroísmo as a World Heritage Site ....................................................................... 229 10.4 So what is the state of tourism at this World Heritage Site? ........ 235 10.5 Discussion and conclusion – what can be drawn from the data from Angra do Heroísmo? ............................................................................. 237 PART IV RELATION TO A PLACE ................................................................ 243 11 World Heritage – on the subject of identity, attachment and pride ........ 243 11.1 The value of a World Heritage Classification – Pride, Esteem, Recognition ............................................................................................ 244 11.2 Angra do Heroísmo’s heritage – is it all about Colonial History and World Heritage? .................................................................................... 248 11.3 Senses of a place and belonging ................................................... 252 11.4 Heritage and identity– conclusion and discussion ........................ 257 iii Contents PART V CLOSING ............................................................................................ 261 12 Conclusions ............................................................................................ 261 12.1 Universal or particular? ............................................................... 262 12.2 The dissonance in heritage management ...................................... 266 12.3 Heritage politics in a World Heritage City ................................... 270 12.4 Life in a World Heritage City ........................................................ 273 PRIMARY SOURCES ......................................................................................