Varsity Cup Panel a Winning Idea
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
intouch with South African Referees Edition 1, 2010 www.sareferees.co.za Varsity Cup panel Luke Burger in action when TUT Gallo/Getty Images a winning idea travelled to Cape Town to face UCT The third edition of the annual Varsity Cup saw the introduction of a specialised in February refereeing panel to oversee the tournament. In-touch spoke to VC panel members Archie Sehlako, Matt Kemp and Ben Crouse about their experience with what has proven to be a successful first season for the panel. he Varsity Cup has quickly established believes that a dedicated panel helps itself as the premier university rugby promote consistency in the referee group, Tcompetition in South Africa, filling since fewer games are refereed by different a niche that benefits both supporters and individuals. players. With the tournament’s profile increasing every year, and used as a testing An added feature of this season’s Varsity ground for referee initiatives such as the Cup is the after-match function held for the white card, a 23-man expanded bench and competing teams, their management staff referees acting as TMOs, the next step has and match officials. Blue Bulls referee Ben been the establishment of a specialised Crouse believes the functions are a great referee panel for the nine-week competition. initiative. ‘The after-match functions are how I came to know rugby, where socialising So what have been the major benefits of after the game leads to enemies on the serving on a dedicated panel? Sharks referee field becoming lifelong friends off it. It also Archie Sehlako says, ‘The players have seen allows the players to revisit some situations the same guys refereeing every Monday. It’s with the referee and to maybe get his view also allowed the guys to get more game time and reasoning for certain decisions. The during the season, which is quite beneficial.’ players are given the opportunity to realise that we, as referees, are human after all.’ Matt Kemp, his Western Province colleague, looks at it slightly differently. ‘Knowing This year has proven to be a successful one upfront that you have a certain number for the first specialised Varsity Cup panel, of games in the competition helps with with this season’s group of referees setting a preparation for those games.’ He also high standard for future panels to follow. Stellenbosch. ‘There are some Tiaan has the fantastic referees in the Varsity Cup, final word so it was a huge honour for me to Golden Lions and Provincial Panel have been appointed to referee the referee Tiaan Jonker was appointed to final,’ he says. ‘This is my third year handle the Varsity Cup final between refereeing in a great tournament - it UCT and Maties on 29 March in never fails to live up to expectations.’ The Big 21 Rasta Four years of shows the service way Craig Joubert Craig Joubert Paddy’s Patch Paddy’s In this issue... pg 4 pg 9 pg 12 SOUTH AFRICAN RUGBY REFEREE SOCIETY NEWSLETTER 1 NEWSLETTER OF SOUTH AFRICAN RUGBY REFEREES’ www.sareferees.co.za What’s on my mind? By André Watson It’s scrum time Dominant scrumming has been a hallmark of South African rugby for decades and yet, while often giving a good account of ourselves, we’ve not always ruled at scrum time as I think we should have. And, in the past, I believe often the referee has been instrumental in negating the power of the pack. ctivities at scrum time were • The props bind on to the hooker, one of the so-called ‘big four’ with all three getting their issues raised at the Lensbury hips and shoulders square to Aconference in 2009. In the opposition addition to the clearer instructions • At the ‘crouch’ command, the referees have received and are now players should ‘barr up’ – their often ahead of themselves implementing in the Super 14, we’ve bodies should be set and ready, and robbing the attacking team gone one step further by retaining with spines in line and chins off of options. the services of World Cup-winning their chest scrummager and respected forwards • There must be a real ‘touch’ In reality there’s nothing new in coach Balie Swart to shed some between props when the what’s outlined here; it’s about light on what happens in the front command is given implementing what’s already clearly row so that referees can ensure a • There must be consistent laid out in the Law book for everyone fair contest. cadence between commands so to read and understand. It’s early players are able to anticipate the in the season, so let’s get on top of It’s not the referee’s job to coach timing from ‘pause’ to ‘engage’ these aspects and bring dominance players during the game and they • On ‘engage’, both front rows must back to what has been a South can’t be held responsible for poor hit straight and stay straight, get African strong point. player technique, but the man in the a strong grip and stay bound until middle can guide players to ensure the ball is out. they follow the rule of Law. Perhaps In summary then: most important is the question While we’re focusing much effort of safety at scrum time: Balie is on the pre- and post-engagement adamant – and he has our support – processes, there are other scrum- • Stick to the that the referee is like a safety officer related issues for refs to keep an on the field and needs to ensure that eye on: engagement scrums are conducted in a safe way. • Flankers who’re either slipping sequence and There should be zero tolerance shown their bind and moving up on the penalise those teams to those forwards who’re not prepared prop or simply hanging off the to scrum within Law. scrum to get an advantage must jumping the gun be penalised • Spine in line, no Here are some pointers to keep • The scrum-half must keep a in mind. visible distance from other individual angles • Both hookers should position players in the scrum • Binding as per Law, themselves at the mark made by • Let’s maintain the five-metre off- no deviations. the referee side line – the defensive team is 2 www.sareferees.co.za NEWSLETTER OF SOUTH AFRICAN RUGBY REFEREES’ Referees and TV CHAIRMAN’S match officials MESSAGE Kicking off in 2010 become one With the rugby season under way and the World Cup around the corner, 2010 is shaping up to be a big year for sport in South Africa. The rugby season has got off to a brisk start and it’s wonderful to see two South African teams vying for honours in the top four of the Super 14. This year’s tournament has been an eye-opener, with a record score achieved between the Lions and Chiefs, and much of the elevation in pace and excitement has been ascribed to changes in the implementation of the existing Laws – particularly at scrums, tackles, mauls and off-sides. There’s more on alliancephoto.com these issues elsewhere in Craig Joubert tries the TMO shoe on during a Super 14 pre-season game. this newsletter. South Africa is experimenting It’s been pleasing to note how successful the Varsity Cup tournament has been, and players, coaches and referees with referees doubling as have all given the thumbs-up to the innovation of a television match officials (TMOs) dedicated team of match officials. to accompany their on-field duties One thing that never ceases to amaze me is the dedication and commitment shown by referees across the country. Not only do we have people like Mark Lawrence recording their hrough an initiative pioneered by SA Rugby 50th Super game, but we have stories on long service by Referees the duties of the referee and the TMO will Gabriel Pappas, Kosie Horn and Ronald David. Well done be combined into one role, leaving the referee as to them and the countless others who give of their time Tthe sole adjudicator of the Laws. This experiment and energy season after season, often with little in the way was implemented in two warm-up matches for the Super of financial reward. 14 and is being used for all televised Varsity Cup matches. Recently all referees have been asked to read and sign a André Watson, SARU’s referee manager, explains, ‘Instead Code of Conduct. This document outlines the relationship of the referees going ‘‘upstairs’’ to the TMO to query between referees and the South African Rugby Union. As whether a try has been scored, the on-field referee will be most of you already know, referees are voluntary members able to consult a television monitor in the in-goal area and of provincial societies. In turn, these provincial societies decide for himself. It will follow the same protocol as a are members of the South African Rugby Referees’ regular TMO decision, except that the on-field ref will act Association – a not-for-profit entity that’s a member of as the TMO himself.’ the SA Rugby Union. Please ensure you’ve received and acknowledged your copy of the Code. André believes that this will result in fewer referrals ‘because the buck stops with the on-field referee – he’s the The FIFA World Cup is about to hit South Africa and I wish one who’ll make the final decision, whether he calls for the our compatriots in the round-ball code all the very best for TMO or not.’ a fantastic and successful tournament.