DOCSLIB.ORG

An Examination of Ideology and Subject Formation Among Elite And

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
An Examination of Ideology and Subject Formation Among Elite And AN EXAMINATION OF IDEOLOGY AND SUBJECT FORMATION AMONG ELITE AND ORDINARY RESIDENTS IN THE BAKKEN SHALE, NORTH DAKOTA, 2015-2016 A Dissertation by THOMAS ANDREW LODER Submitted to the Office of Graduate and Professional Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Chair of Committee, Christian Brannstrom Committee Members, Forrest Fleischman Wendy Jepson Kathleen O’Reilly Head of Department, David Cairns August 2018 Major Subject: Geography Copyright 2018 Thomas Andrew Loder ABSTRACT The US shale energy boom of the late 2000s and 2010s has brought both economic growth and negative externalities to communities undergoing extraction. Building on previous research on fracking landscapes – as well as geographies of energy and natural resources and case studies of environmental subjectivity in extractive zones – this dissertation employed a suite of qualitative methods to examine the discourses and ideology used to support and oppose fracking-led development in North Dakota’s Bakken Shale. The dissertation consists of three substantive chapters. The first employs key actor interviews and participant observation to examine how pro-oil ideology is advanced by economic and political elites in North Dakota. This chapter concludes that elites frame support for oil as an extension of existing conservative ideologies prevalent in the state. The second substantive chapter consists of content analysis of coverage of oil- related events in state-level newspapers, specifically concentrating on a 2014 conservation ballot measure and the Keystone XL pipeline. This chapter concludes that pro-oil writers are more effective in their messaging due to focusing on economic and emotional appeals. The final substantive chapter uses interviews and focus groups to gauge fracking opinions of residents of Minot, a key city in the Bakken Shale. This chapter concludes that residents find cultural changes related to oil and gas development of greater consequence than political or economic changes. ii CONTRIBUTORS AND FUNDING SOURCES This work was supported by a dissertation committee consisting of Professor Christian Brannstrom and Professors Wendy Jepson and Kathleen O’Reilly of the Department of Geography and Professor Forrest Fleischman of the Department of Ecosystem Science and Management. Research was supported by a Doctoral Dissertation Research Improvement Grant from the National Science Foundation Division of Behavioral and Cognitive Sciences (#1536201), a Dissertation Year Fellowship (2017-2018), an Energy Institute Research Fellowship (2014-2015) and a Glasscock Graduate Research Fellowship (2014), all from Texas A&M University. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Several people aided me in the completion of this dissertation. My great uncle LaVern Neff hosted me in Williston during my preliminary research trip and took me on my first tour of the oilfields. During this same trip, I was able to stay rent free at my uncle, Thomas Wentz, Jr.’s house in Minot. Uncle Tommy also took me as his guest to the 2014 North Dakota Association of Telecommunication Cooperatives conference, which provided me with my first experience with North Dakota politics. Thanks must also be given to each of my grandfathers; Thomas Wentz, Sr. for sparking my initial interest in North Dakota and LeRoy Loder for putting me in contact with many key Minot respondents. My adviser Christian Brannstrom served as a tireless advocate for both me and my research throughout my graduate career. Additionally, he took time and care in reviewing my writings and pushed me in countless superior directions that have led to this dissertation being radically improved from its initial drafting. My parents, John and Elizabeth Loder, provided untold support throughout my graduate career, for which they deserve praise. Finally, I would like to thank my wife, Emily, for her unending emotional support throughout this project. Without her patience and love, completing the dissertation would have proved a far more daunting task. iv NOMENCLATURE CCW Concerned-Citizen Writer DP Dickinson Press DU Ducks Unlimited FF Fargo Forum FTZ Foreign Trade IAW Industry-affiliated Writer (petroleum) IGW Interest-Group Writer (non-petroleum) KXL Keystone XL pipeline LEW Local Editorial Writer (within ND) LTE Letter-to-the-Editor M4 Measure 4 M5 Measure 5 MDN Minot Daily News NDCSC North Dakotans for Common Sense Conservation NSC Nationally-Syndicated Columnist OHF Outdoor Heritage Fund TT Tioga Tribune WH Williston Herald v TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................... ii CONTRIBUTORS AND FUNDING SOURCES ............................................................... iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................... iv NOMENCLATURE .......................................................................................................... v TABLE OF CONTENTS .................................................................................................. vi LIST OF FIGURES .......................................................................................................... ix LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................ x 1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Study topic and goals ..................................................................................... 1 1.2 Overview of substantive chapters ................................................................... 3 1.2.1 Chapter 4 overview ........................................................................... 5 1.2.2 Chapter 5 overview ........................................................................... 7 1.2.3 Chapter 6 overview ........................................................................... 9 1.3 Study area .................................................................................................... 11 1.4 Overall aims and preview of remaining chapters .......................................... 17 2. REVIEW OF RELEVANT LITERATURE ................................................................... 19 2.1 Introduction ................................................................................................... 19 2.2 Geographies of energy and natural resources.............................................. 20 2.3 Social science studies of fracking ................................................................. 29 2.4 Environmental subjectivities and natural resources ...................................... 44 2.5 Bakken case studies ..................................................................................... 53 2.6 Summary of key findings from the literature ................................................. 56 3. RESEARCH DESIGN ................................................................................................ 60 3.1 Introduction ................................................................................................... 60 3.2 Preliminary research ..................................................................................... 60 3.3 Positionality .................................................................................................. 62 3.4 Research objectives ..................................................................................... 68 3.5 Objective rationale and identification of respondents ................................... 70 3.5.1. Policy rationale and respondent identification ................................ 70 vi 3.5.2 Newspaper analysis rationale ......................................................... 74 3.5.3 Sampling strategy for longer-term residents ................................... 77 3.6 Data Collection ............................................................................................. 80 3.6.1 Policy interview and participant observation procedures ................ 80 3.6.2 Newspaper data collection .............................................................. 84 3.6.3 Longer-term interview and focus group procedures ........................ 97 3.7 Data analysis .............................................................................................. 102 3.7.1 Interview, focus group and participant observation analysis ......... 102 3.7.2 Newspaper coding and analysis ................................................... 110 3.8 Conclusion .................................................................................................. 120 4. HOMO DAKOTICUS ............................................................................................... 122 4.1 Introduction ................................................................................................. 122 4.2 Homo Dakoticus ......................................................................................... 122 4.3 Key themes for the creation of Homo Dakoticus ......................................... 124 4.3.1 The North Dakota Way ................................................................. 124 4.3.2 North Dakota exceptionalism ........................................................ 133 4.3.3 Resiliency ..................................................................................... 139 4.4 Chapter summary ......................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Overnighters a Film by Jesse Moss
    POV Community Engagement & Education DISCUSSION GUIDE The Overnighters A Film by Jesse Moss www.pbs.org/pov LETTER FROM THE FILMMAKER “My sweetheart and my parents / I left in my old hometown / I’m out to do the best I can / As I go ramblin’ round.” — “Ramblin’ Round,” Woody Guthrie The themes of re-invention and self-invention in American life have long interested me and inspired my film work, from Con Man (the story of an Ivy League impostor) to Full Battle Rattle (the Iraq war seen through the prism of role-play). The lure of the boomtown and its powerful place in the American imagination stem from its seductive promise of re - demption and fortune for the brave and the desperate. It is this theme—played out in stark, raw terms in North Dakota and viewed through the prism of Pastor Jay Reinke’s church—that drew me to this story. As a student of American history, I was fascinated by the idea that a boomtown existed in modern-day America. Stories about Williston, North Dakota, suggested an intoxicating and possibly combustible mixture of oil, men, money, opportunity and crime. How did the reality of Williston square with our understanding of historical boomtowns like Deadwood, Dodge City and Gold Rush-era San Francisco? The history of those places is now inseparable from their mythology, and like most people, I’d only read about them in books or seen them depicted in Hollywood Westerns. I was curious to see the real Williston up close and measure it against those iconic locales, at least as they existed in the popular imagination.
    [Show full text]
  • Organizing Around Abundance: Making America an Energy Superpower
    Organizing Around Abundance: Making America an Energy Superpower DRAFT 1 Table of Contents Executive Summary ............................................................................................ 3 The Problem with America’s Energy Policy: We Don’t Have One ...................... 7 Principle #1: Promote Responsible Development of Domestic Energy Resources and Construction of Infrastructure to Transport It ...................... 14 Oil and Natural Gas ..........................................................................................14 Keystone XL Pipeline—Build It Now ............................................................14 Property Rights, Federal Lands, and Resource Development ....................15 The Benefits of Increased Natural Gas Production .....................................17 Home Heating Oil ...........................................................................................18 Coal .....................................................................................................................20 Nuclear ...............................................................................................................22 Principle #2: Encourage Technological Innovation of Renewables and Emerging Energy Resources ...................................................................... 25 Principle #3: Unlock the Economic Potential of the Manufacturing Renaissance by Putting America’s Energy Resources to Work ....................... 30 Principle #4: Eliminate Burdensome Regulations ..........................................
    [Show full text]
  • Senate Journal-JANUARY 25, 2007
    17th DAY THURSDAY, JANUARY 25, 2007 187 JOURNAL OF THE SENATE Sixtieth Legislative Assembly ***** Bismarck, January 25, 2007 The Senate convened at 1:00 p.m., with President Pro Tem J. Lee presiding. The prayer was offered by Father Paul Becker, Corpus Christi, Bismarck. The roll was called and all members were present except Senators Andrist and Bowman. A quorum was declared by the President Pro Tem. CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS SB 2205: SEN. HECKAMAN (Industry, Business and Labor Committee) MOVED that the amendments on SJ page 179 be adopted and then be REREFERRED to the Appropriations Committee with DO PASS, which motion prevailed. CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS SB 2036: SEN. HACKER (Industry, Business and Labor Committee) MOVED that the amendments on SJ pages 176-177 be adopted and then be placed on the Eleventh order with DO PASS, which motion prevailed. CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS SB 2072: SEN. WANZEK (Industry, Business and Labor Committee) MOVED that the amendments on SJ page 177 be adopted and then be placed on the Eleventh order with DO PASS, which motion prevailed. CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS SB 2073: SEN. POTTER (Industry, Business and Labor Committee) MOVED that the amendments on SJ page 177 be adopted and then be placed on the Eleventh order with DO PASS, which motion prevailed. CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS SB 2096: SEN. HEITKAMP (Natural Resources Committee) MOVED that the amendments on SJ pages 177-178 be adopted and then be placed on the Eleventh order with DO PASS, which motion prevailed. CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS SB 2123: SEN. KLEIN (Industry, Business and Labor Committee) MOVED that the amendments on SJ page 178 be adopted and then be placed on the Eleventh order with DO PASS, which motion prevailed.
    [Show full text]
  • Saskatchewan Flood and Natural Hazard Risk Assessment
    2018 Stakeholder Insights Saskatchewan Flood and Natural Hazard Risk Assessment Prepared for Saskatchewan Ministry of Government Relations By V. Wittrock1, R.A. Halliday2, D.R. Corkal3, M. Johnston1, E. Wheaton4, J. Lettvenuk1, I. Stewart3, B. Bonsal5 and M. Geremia3 SRC Publication No. 14113-2E18 May 2018 Revised Dec 2018 EWheaton Consulting Cover Photos: Flooded road – Government of Saskatchewan Forest fire – Government of Saskatchewan Winter drought – V.Wittrock January 2009 Snow banks along roadway – J.Wheaton March 2013 Oil well surrounded by water – I. Radchenko May 2015 Participants at Stakeholder Meetings – D.Corkal June 2017 Kneeling farmer on cracked soil – istock photo Tornado by Last Mountain Lake – D.Sherratt Summer 2016 This report was prepared by the Saskatchewan Research Council (SRC) for the sole benefit and internal use of Ministry of Government Relations. Neither SRC, nor any of its employees, agents or representatives, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, reliability, suitability or usefulness of any information disclosed herein, or represents that the report’s use will not infringe privately owned rights. SRC accepts no liability to any party for any loss or damage arising as a result of the use of or reliance upon this report, including, without limitation, punitive damages, lost profits or other indirect or consequential damages. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favouring by SRC Saskatchewan Flood and Natural Hazard Risk Assessment Prepared for Saskatchewan Ministry of Government Relations By V.
    [Show full text]
  • Honoring Hollis and Theodora Nappen, Bismarck, North Dakota
    Friday, May 4, 2012 Unconventional Ramkota Hotel With the State Historical Society of the Dakota Ballroom elebratingNorth Dakota and its Foundation Bismarck, North Dakota C Dinner, Tributes, Dance State Historical Society of North Dakota Foundation 2012 Recognition Report An Unconventional Man – With Unconventional Vision Honoree: Harold Hamm, Chairman and CEO, Continental Resources, Inc. Building a Legacy – The Investments Tribute to Our Legislature: 2001- 2011 Legislative Assemblies An Enduring Legacy – The Peoples Place Honoring: Governor Arthur Link and Grace Link and Governors William Guy, George Sinner, Allen Olson, Ed Schafer, John Hoeven and Jack Dalrymple A Family Legacy – Power to Preserve History Honoring: Hollis and Theodora Nappen A Leadership Legacy – History’s Trustee Honoring: Terrance Rockstad, CEO and Chairman, Dan’s SuperMarkets of North Dakota A Leadership Legacy – History’s Trustee Honoring: Larry Rolfson, Vice President, Relationship Development, BlackRidge Bank of North Dakota Harold Hamm, Chariman and CEO, WelcomeContinental Resources, Inc., Honoree Greetings from Merlan E. Paaverud, Jr., Director State Historical Society of North Dakota Governors’ Vision Nearing Completion – With Your Support s the 2013 Legislative Session approaches, the Society board and staff Aare preparing a proposal requesting 17 additional staff positions. All of the positions proposed are a necessary result of the expansion of the North Dakota Heritage Center and its growing requests for services to museum visitors, schools, historic sites and communities. As we gather to thank the governors, legislators, donors and supporters, we are reminded that we have the seventh and final recommendation of the governors and the Historical Commission to invest in – “additional history professionals.” The six investments that have been completed to date are the State Archives expansion, regional historic site investments, resources for county and tribal historical groups, investment in heritage tourism, expansion of the Heritage Center and state- of-the-art technologies.
    [Show full text]
  • Winter 2014 | John D
    WINTER 2014 | JOHN D. ODEGARD SCHOOL OF AEROSPACE SCIENCES A MESSAGE 04 08 12 FROM THE DEAN On December 28th 2013 the headlines read; “North Dakota named as one of the six National Test Airspace Sites for Unmanned 04 North Dakota is One of Six Sites Selected Aircraft.” This designation was made by the FAA after a fierce competition that included proposals from almost the entire for FAA-Approved UAS United States. Being designated as a National Test Airspace Site is a huge step forward for the Odegard School’s Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS) program as it continues to be the leader in moving unmanned aircraft into commercial operations in Research AEROCOM UND Aerospace UAS Center expected to play big the national airspace. This announcement heralds an incredibly bright future for UND, North Dakota and the nation. Robert O. Kelley President University of North Dakota role in national R&D program to advance UAS use Bruce Smith Dean It is amazing that this headline can be traced back to a single phone call I received from Senator Dorgan’s Chief of Staff in the John D. Odegard School of Aerospace Sciences summer of 2005. The call referenced the potential closing of Grand Forks Air Force Base and the role the Odegard School could Paul Lindseth Associate Dean 08 UND NDX Spacesuit play to keep it open. Understanding the role that UASs would play in the future of aviation and being able to align the capabilities Ken Polovitz Assistant Dean of the Odegard School and the University of North Dakota not only kept the Base open but realigned its mission to include UASs.
    [Show full text]
  • Artificial Drainage Report.Pdf
    HH3: Souris River Basin Artificial Drainage Impacts Review July 15, 2019 FINAL REPORT Submitted to the International Souris River Study Board by the HH3 Working Group Report prepared by Bob Harrison Executive Summary This project was undertaken as a portion of the Souris River Study. The governments of Canada and the United States asked the IJC to undertake studies evaluating the physical processes occurring within the Souris River basin which are thought to have contributed to recent flooding events. The public expressed a high interest in the issue of agricultural drainage impacts. Thus an “Artificial Drainage Impacts Review” was added to International Souris River Study Board’s (ISRSB) Work Plan to help address their questions and provide information to the public regarding wetland drainage. This report summarizes the current knowledge of artificial drainage in the Souris River basin. The study involved a review of drainage legislation and practices in the basin, the artificial drainage science, the extent of artificial drainage in the basin and the potential influence on transboundary flows Artificial drainage is undertaken to make way for increased or more efficient agricultural production by surface or/and subsurface drainage. Surface drainage moves excess water off fields naturally (i.e., runoff) or by constructed channels. The purpose of using surface drainage is to minimize crop damage from water ponding after a precipitation event, and to control runoff without causing erosion. Subsurface drainage is installed to remove groundwater from the root zone or from low-lying wet areas. Subsurface drainage is typically done through the use of buried pipe drains (e.g., tile drainage).
    [Show full text]
  • Rhoades Ribbon-Cutting a Great Day for VCSU
    ISSUE 071640 NOVEMBER 2013 A Publication for Alumni & Friends of Valley City State University Rhoades ribbon-cutting a great day for VCSU President’sVCSU House Preservation Society seeks support w Homecoming 2013 CONTENTS DEPARTMENTS 1 PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE Welcome to the Bulletin! The Bulletin is published in spring, summer and fall by the Valley City State 2 ALUMNI ASSOCIATION CORNER University Alumni Association. Larry Robinson ..........................................................................701-845-7217 3 FOUNDATION CORNER Executive Director of University Advancement [email protected] 18 VIKING HIGHLIGHTS Kim Hesch .................................................................................701-845-7403 Assistant Director of University Advancement [email protected] 22 vcsu CONNECTIONS Alison Kasowski ....................................................................... 701-845-7216 Assistant Director of Annual Giving [email protected] Loree Morehouse ..................................................................... 701-845-7203 Data Processing and Research Coordinator [email protected] Greg Vanney ............................................................................. 701-845-7227 Director of Marketing and Communications [email protected] Jack Denholm ...........................................................................701-845-7160 Athletic Director [email protected] Mark Potts ................................................................................ 701-845-7228 Sports
    [Show full text]
  • MSU Mesmerized Dakota Square April 4, 2012 MSU Summer and Fall
    April 4, 2012 PIO update This spring brings many oppor - tunities to share in celebration at Minot State University. At the Employee Appreciation Luncheon April 26, colleagues marking five-year increments of service and those receiving MSU Board of Regents Faculty and Staff Achievement Awards will be recog - nized. Congratulations to all award winners and all MSU employees for their service to students and the community! MSU mesmerized The Spring Honor Dance and Dakota Square Powwow Celebration, an intercultur - Nearly 40 Minot State al event honoring the Class of 2012 University groups participated in and their families, is April 27-28. the sixth annual MSU at the Mall, This is an unforgettable event focus - which provided an excellent ing on diversity and appreciation. opportunity for MSU to showcase Individuals do not have to be its students, academic programs, alumni to attend the MSU Alumni services, student organizations Gala April 27 at the Holiday Inn, and other university entities to the Riverside. Tickets for this elegant community. evening of music, auction and fine The theme for the event was dining go quickly. Call the Alumni engagement as students from Office at 858-3234 to reserve a seat, special education classes involved young and old in its unique projects. The Science Club and thus, raise money for scholar - demonstrated how putty is made with two simple ingredients, and MSU’s Jazz Ensemble ships. energized the Sears Court with its fabulous musical selections. Other highlights included Spring would not be complete the potter’s wheel, nursing students giving free blood pressure checks and coffee tasting without congratulating students who from the future Beaver Brew Café.
    [Show full text]
  • Comprehensive Conservation Plan Huron Wetland Management District Madison Wetland Management District Sand Lake Wetland Management District South Dakota
    Comprehensive Conservation Plan Huron Wetland Management District Madison Wetland Management District Sand Lake Wetland Management District South Dakota January 2012 Approved by Stephen D. Guertin, Regional Director Date U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Region 6 Lakewood, Colorado Prepared by Huron Wetland Management District Room 309 Federal Building 200 Fourth Street SW. Huron, South Dakota 57350 605 / 352 5894 Madison Wetland Management District 23520 SD Highway 19 Madison, South Dakota 57042 605 / 256 2974 Sand Lake Wetland Management District 39650 Sand Lake Drive Columbia, South Dakota 57433 605 / 885 6320 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Region 6, Mountain–Prairie Region Division of Refuge Planning 134 Union Boulevard, Suite 300 Lakewood, Colorado 80228 303 / 236 8145 CITATION for this document: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2012. Comprehensive conservation plan: Huron Wetland Management District, Madison Wetland Management District, and Sand Lake Wetland Management District, South Dakota. Lakewood, CO: U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 260 p. Comprehensive Conservation Plan Huron Wetland Management District Madison Wetland Management District Sand Lake Wetland Management District South Dakota Submitted by Concurred with by Clarke Dirks Date Richard A. Coleman, Ph.D. Date Project Leader Assistant Regional Director Huron Wetland Management District U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Region 6 Huron, South Dakota National Wildlife Refuge System Lakewood, Colorado Natoma Buskness Date Paul Cornes Date Project Leader Refuge Supervisor Madison Wetland Management District U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Region 6 Madison, South Dakota National Wildlife Refuge System Lakewood, Colorado Harris Hoistad Date Project Leader Sand Lake National Wildlife Refuge Complex Columbia, South Dakota Contents Summary .....................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Our Hettinger County Heritage
    Our Hettinger .4 County Heritage : .^—-Nir**-* -«-• mim**7:"'» \m •>i»4,V( :/ by ENID BERN North Dakota State Library 604 E Bo ilt vard Avenue BismarcK, ND 55505-0800 Bern ,m Our Hettinger County- d<n heritage . \Q1S NORTH DAKOTA STATE LIBRARY BISMARCK 58501 OCT 20 1975 NORTH DAKOTA MATT I IBriARY 11 33105 66630 4301 T7[oUy 7\ortr\ Dakota, cfa?\e /? J97S Do Z/\e, 7\oriJ\ £>a£o?a State £t£>rary tist?J\ my corr\pftrr{e7\Zs Cntd 3ers\ Our Hettinger County Heritage Cover: The scene is one of shock threshing on the Otto Kibbel homestead. Mr. Kibbel was the owner of the outfit, Fred Wickman tended the separator. North Dakota Statl Ufertff Bixmarf.k NH -PAM Dedicated to the sacred memory of my parents and to all other pioneers who ventured into this region, ready to face the many hardships and to accept the challenges they knew they would encounter in establishing homes and communities out on these vast prairies. V FOREWORD Less than 150 years ago that part of Southwestern North Dakota with which this book largely deals was described and illustrated by most mapmakers as "The Great American Desert". From that point in time to the first of the present century this area was inhabitated for the most part by nomadic Indians and white trappers, ranchers, and a very few homesteaders, or "squatters". Shortly after the turn of the century an increasing number of people came to this area to pick choice sites of free land for homesteading. After the completion of the railroads into the area, the influx of the people became so great that in a few years homesteaders oc­ cupied homestead lumber shacks or sod houses on almost all quarter sections of land suitable for farming or grazing in the area.
    [Show full text]
  • Read Papers Presented at the Conference
    The Kaisers Totebag: Fundraising, German-Americans and World War I Richard Muller, M.S.S The Kaiser’s Tote bag: Fundraising, German-Americans and WW I Germans are nothing if not about tradition, loyalty, symbolism and generosity. These traits, while not unique to Germans, German-Americans or any ethnicity for that matter, are examined here in the context of generating financial and moral support for various factions engaged in fighting WW I. Two families, one from South Dakota, one from New York City provide the context for this paper. England and France were using loans and war bonds to pay for their role in the Napoleonic War and WW I. The United States eventually followed suit, when it entered the war. Fundraising to support war is nothing new. Fundraisers have used “Thank you Gifts” to help raise money for decades. In the fundraising business there is an old adage, if it works once, beat it to death. 148 In this case, Frederick III took a page out of his great grandfather’s fundraising playbook noting how Frederick I funded the Napoleonic War of 1813. Then, the Prussian Royal family asked loyal German citizens for their gold (rings, jewelry, dinnerware, etc.) to support the Kaiser’s need for the materials of war. In exchange for their donation, they received an iron ring, following the practice of “a ‘Thank You Gift’ in return for a quality, soon to be appreciated premium.” This was a sort of “Thank you” gift at the time, much like today’s fundraisers offer tote bags and coffee mugs for donations.
    [Show full text]