Justice in Policing Act v. Senate Republican Bill v. Pres. Trump Executive Order

George Floyd Senate Pres. Trump Justice in Republican Executive Policing Bill Justice Bill Order* Police Accountability

Modifies Mens Rea in Section 242 (Criminal Liability) ü û û Ends for Law Enforcement ü û û Funds Independent Counsels to Prosecute ü û û Strengthens Pattern and Practice Investigations at the Federal and State Level ü û û Establishes National Standards for Law Enforcement ü û ü Invests in Public Safety Innovation Grants to Reimagine Policing ü û û

Police Transparency and Data Establishes Public National Police Misconduct Registry ü û ü1 -Database sharing amongst law enforcement agencies ü ü ü Requires Data Collection on ü ü2 û

Police Training and Policies Chokeholds -Federal officers—Bans chokeholds as a use of ü û3 û -All Officers—Subjects officers to federal criminal prosecution for civil rights violation ü û û -State and local officers—Conditions grants on banning chokeholds ü ü4 û

Bans No Knock Warrants in Drug Cases ü û5 û Bans Racial Profiling ü û û Requires Deadly Force to Only be Used as Last Resort ü û û Establishes Duty to Intervene Standards ü ü6 û Mandates Uniformed Officers to use Body ü7 ü8 û Prohibits a sexual act with an individual under arrest, in detention, or in custody ü ü û

* Executive Orders do not have the force of law and may be withdrawn by any Administration

1 Registry while publicly available, does not include all complaints and other data in George Floyd Act 2 Does not require comprehensive data on use of force, limited to deadly use of force as defined in the bill 3 Directs AG to create policy banning chokeholds “except when deadly force is authorized”. 4 Limits funding to states unless they ban chokeholds “except when deadly force authorized” 5 Limits funding to states unless provide reports on use of no-knock warrants 6 Grants to require training on duty to intervene, but not for federal officers 7 Also includes dash cameras 8 State grants for body cameras but no federal requirement, no dash camera requirements