Arxiv:1610.01501V1 [Hep-Th] 30 Sep 2016 Foreword
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
\Hawking Radiation" Conference Manuscript 2015 Laura Mersini-Houghton∗ and Dillon N. Morse∗ ∗Department of Physics and Astronomy, UNC-Chapel Hill, NC 27599, USA arXiv:1610.01501v1 [hep-th] 30 Sep 2016 Foreword The origin of Hawking radiation and the perplexing problem of information loss in black holes has been at the center of decades of discussions. Recently the subject has seen renewed interest as new ideas, approaches and paradoxes have been suggested. Progress in our understanding of this mystery has far reaching conse- quences on all aspects of theoretical physics, from cosmology to quantum gravity. These are what motivated my decision to bring together the leading experts and the founding fathers of this field, for a week-long working session of concentrated effort focused on stimulating progress in the topic. Everyone I contacted enthusiastically agreed with this initiative. That is how the Hawking Radiation conference came about. Due to Stephen Hawkings difficulty with travelling to the USA, we had to hold the conference in Europe instead of in Chapel Hill, USA. I am especially indebted to Nordita, that together with KTH Royal Swedish Institute and Stockholm University, graciously offered to co-host us and co-sponsor the conference with UNC-Chapel Hill. UNC-Chapel Hill leadership, from the Chancellors office, the Provosts office and the Deans office for the College of Arts and Science, fully encouraged and supported this initiative from the beginning. Despite the difficulties that prevented us from holding the conference in Chapel Hill, they decided to bring Chapel Hill to the conference, wherever it was held. The Chancellor Carol Folt, Vice Chancellor for University Development David Routh, Executive Vice Provost and Chief International Officer Ronald P. Strauss, the Dean of the College of Arts and Science Kevin Guskiewicz, and a full team of support from UNC-Chapel Hill, flew to Stockholm to help with all aspects of the organization, to extend Chapel Hills hospitality, and, to welcome the conference participants, through a series of events that included a public lecture by S. Hawking. I am very grateful to them for their support and commitment to the advancement of science. I would like to thank the UNC Global director and her staff, and the UNC Department of Communications, who offered continuous help both, during the organizing of the conference, and in the work needed afterwards in compressing, archiving and posting the video recording. I would like to thank the Rektor of KTH, Peter Gudmundson, and vice Rektor of Stockholm University, Astrid Soderbergh Widding, for their warm welcome and hospitality. The conference was sponsored by UNC-Chapel Hill, Nordita, DAMTP Cambridge University, and the Julian Schwinger Foundation. I am grateful to Yen Chin Ong at Nordita and Malcolm J. Perry at DAMTP Cambridge University from the organizing committee, the director of Nordita Katie Freese, and to Katrin Morck and Philip von Segebaden at KTH, for their help with all aspects of the conference, and especially to my student, Dillon Morse at UNC-Chapel Hill, for transcribing the video recording. I would also like to thank my two colleagues at UNC, Jack Ng and Steve Christensen for offering their support, including help with editing the transcript. The Hawking Radiation conference, which took place August 24-30 2015, was a special and historic event that brought together founding fathers of modern physics. We are making the video recording of the whole week of talks and discussions and the proceedings here, publicly available. We have here recorded the week long talks and discussions in the hope of sharing the results, discussions, debates, enthusiasm, and ideas that came up during the conference, with those interested in the field, especially the current and future young researchers. We hope that reading this material will make every researcher feel they are participating in the conference. The video recording of this proceeding can be accessed here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJC1iUpAADPKTZuyk0lwWWQ9LRJpiRgUv We have tried to stay as close as possible to the recorded words of each speaker. Due to technical difficulties and financial limitations that allowed for only one camera recording, there may be a few minutes or sentences missing here and there, for example if a participant did not use the microphones provided. 1 Any statements in this transcript are exclusively the property of the individual speaker. If used elsewhere, they should be quoted accordingly and have the explicit permission of the speaker. You will notice that the voice of one special person, Jacob Bekenstein, the man who helped lay the foundations of the field, a friend and a scientist I greatly admired, is missing. He passed away a few days before the conference. I would like to dedicate this report to his memory. Laura Mersini-Houghton Department of Physics and Astronomy UNC-Chapel Hill 2 HAWKING RADIATION AUGUST , STOCKHOLM, SWEDEN The world’s leading physicists will gather in Stockholm CONFERENCE PARTICIPANTS: for a week-long workshop on fundamental topics in Stephen Hawking James M. Bardeen black holes, in particular the origin of Hawking Philip Candelas radiation, existence of singularities, and information loss. Steve Christensen Ulf Danielsson The workshop is bringing together eminent Paul Davies Fay Dowker scientists who laid the foundations of the fi eld to Michael Du debate the diversity of views on this notoriously Larry Ford Katherine Freese di cult and important topic in physics at present— Stephen Fulling Werner Israel and to make progress toward a solution and clear Claus Kiefer direction for the fi eld. Jorma Louko Laura Mersini-Houghton Charles W. Misner INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZING COMMITTEE: Paulo Vargas Moniz Laura Mersini-Houghton, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Emil Mottola Jack Ng Malcolm J. Perry, DAMTP, Cambridge University Jérôme Novak Yen Chin Ong, Nordita Leonard Parker Malcolm J. Perry Co-sponsored by the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, the Nordic Carlo Rovelli Institute of Theoretical Physics, the Stephen Hawking Centre for Theoretical Philippe Spindel Physics at the Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics at Kellogg Stelle the University of Cambridge, and The Julian Schwinger Foundation. Leo Stodolsky In association with this conference, Stephen Hawking will present the public lecture Andrew Strominger “Quantum Black Holes” on August 24 at 7 p.m. at the Stockholm Waterfront Gerard t’Hooft Congress Centre. Tickets can be purchased online at HAWKING.AXACO.SE. Francesca Vidotto PHOTO COURTESY NASA COURTESY PHOTO Contents 1 Opening Remarks 8 2 Monday, August 24 2015 Convener: J. Ng 10 2.1 Backreaction and Conformal Symmetry Gerard 't Hooft ............................................ 11 2.2 Backreaction of Hawking Radiation and Singularities Laura Mersini-Houghton ....................................... 18 2.3 Physical Interpretation of the Semi-Classical Energy-Momentum Tensor James Bardeen ............................................ 27 3 Tuesday, August 25 2015 Convener: L. Mersini-Houghton 34 3.1 The Information Paradox Stephen Hawking ........................................... 35 3.2 Black Hole Memory Malcolm Perry ............................................ 39 3.3 Black to White Hole Tunnelling: Before or After Hawking Radiation? Carlo Rovelli ............................................. 49 3.4 A new Quantum Black Hole Phenomenology Francesca Vidotto ........................................... 53 4 Wednesday, August 26 2015 Convener: F. Vidotto 58 4.1 Black Holes as Open Quantum Systems Claus Kiefer .............................................. 59 4.2 Particle Creation From Vacuum in Gravitational Expansion and Collapse Leonard Parker ............................................ 66 4.3 Gravitational Condensate Stars or What's the (Quantum) Matter with Black Holes Emil Mottola ............................................. 69 5 Thursday, August 27 2015 Convener: P. Moniz 75 5.1 Did the Chicken Survive the Firewall Jorma Louko ............................................. 76 5.2 Black Hole Evaporation and Classical Gravitational Waves: Comparison of Calculation Tech- niques Bernard Whiting ........................................... 78 5.3 Gravity = (Yang-Mills)^2 Michael Duff ............................................. 83 5.4 Black Holes and Other Solutions in Higher Derivative Gravity Kellogg Stelle ............................................. 85 6 Friday, August 28 2015 Convener: L. Ford 88 6.1 Quantum Damping or Decoherence. Lessons from Molecules, Neutrinos, and Quantum Logic Devices Leo Stodolsky ............................................. 89 6.2 Puzzle Pieces: Do Any Fit? Charles Misner ............................................ 91 4 6.3 The Generalized Second Law and the Unity of Physics Fay Dowker .............................................. 99 7 Saturday, August 29 2015 Convener: L Mersini-Houghton 104 7.1 Wrap-up Discussion S. Fulling ............................................... 105 7.2 Status Report Stephen Hawking ........................................... 117 7.3 Concluding Remarks Paul Davies .............................................. 118 7.4 A Tribute to Stephen Hawking Michael Duff ............................................. 125 8 Closing Remarks 126 9 References 127 5 Group Photos Listed left to right. Back Row: Jorma Louko, Malcolm Perry, Ulf Danielsson, Emil Mottola, Philippe Spindel, Michael Duff, Bernard Whiting, J´er^omeNovak Middle Row: Francesca Vidotto,