DOCSLIB.ORG

Squaring Palliser's Triangle

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Squaring Palliser's Triangle Squaring Palliser’s Triangle: The Normalization of Nature in the Canadian Dry-land Prairies 1860 - 1940 By Justin Alan Stefanik A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Geography Specialization in Political Economy Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © Justin Stefanik 2015 Abstract Located within the Northern Great Plains, with an area that intersects the provinces of Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba, Palliser’s Triangle is the driest region in the Canadian Prairies. This arid expanse, first reported by early explorers of the North American West and later mapped and confirmed by the Palliser Expedition Report of 1860, holds an important place in Canadian geography. This research asserts that the colonization of Palliser’s Triangle was more than simply putting people on land that “should never have been broken” (Gray 1967: 7); it involved the systematic production of normality through multiple political technologies. This critical analysis unsettles Palliser’s Triangle through an investigation of nature’s normalization. I employ Foucault’s conception of normalization and its hallmark, homogenization through individualization, to re-politicize Palliser’s Triangle’s colonization and settlement. Normalization, I argue, was produced through the individualization of nature, a shift of the spotlight from a delineated problem region to illuminate identifiable and locatable problematic farms and individuals. In doing so, individual parcels of land and the character of male farmers who managed them were made increasingly visible, strategically shifting attention away from the larger political economy of dry-land settlement. The triangulated “micro-physics” (Foucault 1977: 26) of the ‘soul,’ space, and the norm in Palliser’s Triangle settlement pitted the multiple forces of individualization against myriad forces that resisted being individualized including various Aboriginal peoples, male farmers, women farmers, soils, climate factors, weather patterns, flora, and fauna. This research illuminates the exercises of power that enabled and maintained a precarious settlement in the dry-land prairies despite nature’s resistance. ii Acknowledgments I wish to thank my supervisors Fiona Mackenzie and Simon Dalby for their continued support, patience, and inspiration. While their paths took them away from Ottawa to other locations, they have continued to assist me in my endeavours. Committee member Michel Hogue has also been invaluable to this process and has offered much guidance and encouragement. I would like to thank the Department of Geography and Environmental Studies for the funding and teaching opportunities it has provided me over the years. If I had not been accepted as a qualifying-year Master’s student, or PhD fast-tracked, I would not be where I am today. I would like to thank the administrative staff of DGES Carleton, and especially Natalie Pressburger, who has always given me excellent help, guidance, and support in navigating rules and procedures of graduate studies. In terms of financial support, I would like to than the Government of Ontario for providing me with years of financial assistance through the Ontario Graduate Scholarship program. Finally, this research is dedicated to my wife Karin and my daughter Sigrid. Without their love and confidence I could never have accomplished this immense task. Karin pushed me forward when I felt like giving up, supported this project both financially and in principle, and created the conditions for my success. Sigrid has inspired me to make her proud, to never stop reading and learning, and to put love and family above all else. iii Table of Contents Introduction 1 Chapter 1 Power, Normalization, and Nature 23 Chapter 2 The ‘Soul’: Birth of Palliser’s Triangle 61 Chapter 3 Space: Fields of Comparison 104 Chapter 4 The Norm: Wheat and Whiteness 127 Chapter 5 Scientific Norms, Farmers’ ‘Souls,’ and Spaces of Judgment 164 Chapter 6 Resisting, Repeating, and Reinforcing Normalization in times 199 of Crisis Conclusion 224 Bibliography 241 iv List of Illustrations Figure 1.1 Map of Palliser’s Triangle 8 Figure 2.1 Fertile Belt and Palliser’s Triangle 71 Figure 2.2 Hector Prairie Steps Map 89 Figure 2.3 Dawson’s Geological Map of the 49th Parallel 90 Figure 3.1 Map showing the location of Indian Reserves in 1905 114 Figure 3.2 GIS map showing location of Indian Reserves in 1902 115 Figure 3.3 Dominion Township Plan 118 Figure 3.4 Map of Grid over Western Canada 119 Figure 4.1 Hime Photograph Prairie on the Banks of the Red River, Looking 135 South Figure 4.2 Hime Photograph, Hind Expedition Report: Prairie, Looking West 135 Figure 4.3 Illustrations in Macoun’s Manitoba and the Great North-West 136 Figure 4.4 Beginning a Farm in Western Canada 137 Figure 4.5 The Old and the New Home of a Successful Farmer 137 Figure 4.6 Process of Western Development through Culture 138 Figure 4.7 Township Plan and Homestead Guidelines 138 Figure 4.8 A Country of Swift Changes 145 Figure 4.9 Illustration of Aboriginal Man as Separate from Modernity 145 Figure 4.10 Now Then, All Together! 155 Figure 4.11 The Only Drawback 156 Figure 4.12 Canada: Granary of the World 157 Figure 4.13 Nature being consumed in British Columbia, Canada 162 Figure 4.14 Nature transformed in the North-West 162 Figure 5.1 Individualized Male Scientific Farmer 1 186 Figure 5.2 Individualized Male Scientific Farmer 2 187 Figure 6.1 Dust mulch summerfallow 204 v List of Abbreviations AIAs Agricultural Improvement Associations CPR Canadian Pacific Railway GGG Grain Growers’ Guide PFRA Prairie Farm Rehabilitation Administration vi Introduction We began to observe symptoms that showed us we were nearing the line of desert country, or the northeast extension of the North American arid basin; towards evening we passed many spots where the soil was poor and stony, and the growth of grass deficient. John Palliser, September 14, 1857 I. Palliser’s Triangle: Product of Power, Knowledge, and Normalization Located within the Northern Great Plains, with an area that intersects the provinces of Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba, Palliser’s Triangle is the driest region in the Canadian Prairies (Fig 1.1). The arid expanse, first reported by early explorers of the North American West and later mapped and confirmed by the Palliser Expedition Report of 1860, holds an important place in Canadian geography. Today, most Canadian Geography and Environmental Studies textbooks feature maps and descriptions of Palliser’s Triangle that are designed to educate students about its precarious environment, the follies of its settlement, and the environmental catastrophes of its droughts in the 1930s. Given Palliser’s Triangle’s established position as a topic of Canadian geography, it is unusual that Canadian human geographers, and critical human geographers in particular, have not revisited this foundational geographic region. It appears that the story of Palliser’s Triangle is largely considered settled knowledge, a well-worn linear narrative of dry-land prairie settlement replete with caveats of mistakes made throughout the process. This research asserts that the colonization of Palliser’s Triangle was more than simply putting people on land that “should never have been broken” (Gray 1967: 7); it involved the systematic production of normality through multiple political technologies. 1 This critical analysis unsettles Palliser’s Triangle through an investigation of nature’s normalization. I employ Foucault’s conception of normalization and its hallmark, homogenization through individualization, to re-politicize Palliser’s Triangle’s colonization and settlement. I explain that individualization of lands and bodies, combined with the circulation of scientific farming discourses, allowed for Palliser’s Triangle to be settled and stay settled during the crises of the 1930s with limited political upheaval. Normalization, I argue, was produced through the individualization of nature, a shift of the spotlight from a delineated problem region to illuminate identifiable and locatable problematic sections and individuals. In doing so, individual parcels of land and the character of male farmers who managed them were made increasingly visible, strategically shifting attention away from the larger political economy of settlement. The triangulated “micro-physics” (Foucault 1977: 26) of the ‘soul,’ space, and the norm in Palliser’s Triangle settlement pitted the forces of individualization against myriad forces that resisted being individualized and homogenized including various Aboriginal peoples, male farmers, women farmers, soils, climate factors, weather patterns, flora, and fauna. Some of these non-human forces of resistance, I argue, led to the disasters of the 1930s. Finally, the ‘souls’ of the soil, or the constructed essences of nature, Aboriginal peoples, and colonial settlers were brought into being and made visible through spatial distribution, visual and written representation, and scientific knowledge. Dispossession, starvation, displacement, financial ruin, and environmental crisis were some of the many outcomes of settlement in Palliser’s Triangle, making it crucial to examine the operational politics that made it materialize. 2 Beyond the direct implications for this case study, this research extends Foucault’s normalization to nature through the triad framework of the ‘soul,’ space, and the norm. This framework furthers our understanding
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ft Garry to Ft Ellice Via Souris River, Hind, 1858
    EXCERPTS FROM THE REPORT OF THE ASSINIBOINE AND SASKATCHEWAN EXPLORING EXPEDITION OF 1858 GENERAL REPORT AND NARRATIVE OF THE EXPEDITION The British North American Exploring Expedition, commonly called the Palliser Expedition, explored and surveyed the open prairies and rugged wilderness of western Canada from 1857 to 1860. The purpose of the expedition was to gather scientific information on Rupert's Land, including information on the geography, climate, soil, flora and fauna, to discover its capabilities for settlement and transportation. This was the first detailed and scientific survey of the region from Lake Superior to the southern passes of the Rocky Mountains.[2] The British portion of the expedition was led by John Palliser. Henry Youle Hind (1823–1908) was a Canadian geologist and explorer. He was born in Nottingham, England, and immigrated to Toronto, Ontario in 1846. He taught chemistry and geology at Trinity College in Toronto. Hind led the Canadian portion of the expedition to prairies in 1857 and 1858. In 1857, Hind’s “Red River Exploring Expedition” explored the Red and Assiniboine River valleys, and in 1858, the “Assiniboine and Saskatchewan Exploring Expedition” explored the Assiniboine, Souris, Qu'Appelle, and South Saskatchewan River valleys. The expeditions are described in his reports “Narrative of the Canadian Red River Exploring Expedition of 1857” and “Reports of Progress on the Assiniboine and Saskatchewan Exploring Expedition” in 1858. Following immediately below is the journal entry ‘Itinerary” version of Henry Youle Hind’s two week long journey from Fort Garry to Fort Ellice via the Souris River, during the summer of 1858. Following that summary version is Hind’s official account of the same journey.
    [Show full text]
  • From Wasteland to Utopia: Changing Images of the Canadian in the Nineteeth Century
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Great Plains Quarterly Great Plains Studies, Center for 1987 From Wasteland to Utopia: Changing Images of the Canadian in the Nineteeth Century R. Douglas Francis University of Calgary Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly Part of the Other International and Area Studies Commons Francis, R. Douglas, "From Wasteland to Utopia: Changing Images of the Canadian in the Nineteeth Century" (1987). Great Plains Quarterly. 424. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly/424 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Great Plains Studies, Center for at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Great Plains Quarterly by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. FROM WASTELAND TO UTOPIA CHANGING IMAGES OF THE CANADIAN WEST IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY R. DOUGLAS FRANCIS It is common knowledge that what one This region, possibly more than any other in perceives is greatly conditioned by what one North America, underwent significant wants or expects to see. Perception is not an changes in popular perception throughout the objective act that occurs independently of the nineteenth century largely because people's observer. One is an active agent in the process views of it were formed before they even saw and brings to one's awareness certain precon­ the region. 1 Being the last area of North ceived values, or a priori assumptions, that America to be settled, it had already acquired enable one to organize the deluge of objects, an imaginary presence in the public mind.
    [Show full text]
  • Full Text (PDF)
    Document generated on 09/24/2021 2:41 a.m. HSTC Bulletin Journal of the History of Canadian Science, Technology and Medecine Revue d’histoire des sciences, des techniques et de la médecine au Canada Mid-Nineteenth Century Cretaceous Studies in the Canadian Interior Plains W. O. Kupsch and W.G.E. Caldwell Volume 6, Number 2 (21), mai 1982 URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/800136ar DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/800136ar See table of contents Publisher(s) HSTC Publications ISSN 0228-0086 (print) 1918-7742 (digital) Explore this journal Cite this article Kupsch, W. O. & Caldwell, W. (1982). Mid-Nineteenth Century Cretaceous Studies in the Canadian Interior Plains. HSTC Bulletin, 6(2), 59–84. https://doi.org/10.7202/800136ar Copyright © Canadian Science and Technology Historical Association / This document is protected by copyright law. Use of the services of Érudit Association pour l'histoire de la science et de la technologie au Canada, 1982 (including reproduction) is subject to its terms and conditions, which can be viewed online. https://apropos.erudit.org/en/users/policy-on-use/ This article is disseminated and preserved by Érudit. Érudit is a non-profit inter-university consortium of the Université de Montréal, Université Laval, and the Université du Québec à Montréal. Its mission is to promote and disseminate research. https://www.erudit.org/en/ 5 9 MID-NINETEENTH CENTURY CRETACEOUS STUDIES IN THE CANADIAN INTERIOR PLAINS W.O. Kupsch* and W.G.E. Caldwell* (Received 2 February 1981. Revised/Accepted 19 May 1982.) BACKGROUND TO THE BRITISH AND CANADIAN EXPEDITIONS Mid-nineteenth century geological exploration of the Western Interior Plains of North America, and particularly of the widespread, underlying Cretaceous rocks, has had a profound influence on developing notions of the geological evolution of the region.
    [Show full text]
  • Four Physician-Explorers of the Fur Trade Days
    FOUR PHYSICIAN-EXPLORERS OF THE FUR TRADE DAYS By J. MONROE THORINGTON, M.D. PHILADELPHIA THE four physicians, whose lives Fraser. After Waterloo, David took up I are here recounted, spanned praetice in Paris, while John, following I almost a century of the fur his training in Scotland, returned to ■ J*.. trade in Canada, roughly the Canada and became a partner in the period between the arrival of Lewis and North-West Company. We find him at Clark at the mouth of the Columbia Fort Duncan, Lake Nepigon, in 1807; River (1805) and the completion of the at Sturgeon Lake in the winter 1807- Canadian Pacific railroad (1885). 08, and at the capture of Fort William The successive thrusts of exploration in 1816. through the valley of the St. Lawrence The Hudson’s Bay Company ab- were largely concerned with a search sorbed the North-West Company in for a Northwest Passage to the spice 1821, thereby obtaining a monopoly islands of Asia, and were the forerun- of the fur trade. At this time John ners of Verendrye’s sighting of the McLoughlin was in charge of Fort Wil- Rockies in 1738, of Hearne’s reaching liam on Lake Superior. He reached the Coppermine delta in 1771, and of Rainy Lake House in 1823, en route to Alexander Mackenzie’s journey to Bella the Columbia district of which he was Coola inlet and the Pacific in 1793. made supervisor in 1824, and where he John Jacob Astor’s ship, the Ton- ruled during the critical times of the quin, established the Astoria post on Oregon country, 1824-46.
    [Show full text]
  • The Metis Cultural Brokers and the Western Numbered Treaties, 1869-1877
    The Metis Cultural Brokers and the Western Numbered Treaties, 1869-1877 A Thesis Submitted to the College of Graduate Studies and Research in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in the Department of History University of Saskatchewan Saskatoon By Allyson Stevenson Copyright Allyson Stevenson, August 2004 . 1 rights reserved. PERMISSION TO USE In presenting this thesis in partial fulfilment of the requirements of a Graduate degree from the University of Saskatchewan, I agree that the Libraries of this University may make it freely available for inspection . I further agree that permission for copying of this thesis in any manner, in whole or in part, for scholarly purposes may be granted by the professor who supervised my thesis work, or, in his absence, by the Head of the Department or the Dean of the College in which my thesis work was done . It is understood that any copying, publication, or use of this thesis or parts thereof for financial gain shall not be allowed without my written permission . It is also understood that due recognition shall be given to me and to the University of Saskatchewan in any scholarly use which may be made of any material in my thesis . Requests for permission to copy or to make other use of material in this thesis in whole or part should be addressed to : Head of the Department of History University of Saskatchewan Saskatoon, Saskatchewan S7N 5A5 Abstract i Throughout the history of the North West, Metis people frequently used their knowledge of European, Indian, and Metis culture to mediate Aboriginal and non- Aboriginal social, diplomatic, and economic encounters .
    [Show full text]
  • MAY, 19B1, / ~ECIES
    CIE XVI I MAY, 19b1, / ~ECIES -4. XVII Y 1981 Page Editorial Schools in Connection with the Kildare Place Society in County Waterford, 1817-1840. Thomas Power The Barkers of Waterford . H.F. Morris *From the Memoirs of Richard Rorke "Dec ie" WUIB ~elotikto watorfora ; 11 (Sonnings 1 -will ~bst ract o ) Julian C. Walton In Pursuit of Seafaring Ancestors Frank p. I.:urphy A County Waterford Explorer Irene M. Spry The Towland of Callaghane in 1821 Monumental Inscriptions from Stradbally R.C. Church and Faha Chapel-of-ease, J.H. Mulholland Co. Waterford,up to 1880 Reviews An Early Christian Grave-Slab at Mothel, Conleth Manning 82 O.W.S. Programme June - September 1981 *Cover Illustration: Waterford circa. 1820, taken from Ryland, The History, Topography etc. of Waterford, London, 1814. (see pages 28-36 following) Decies is published thrice yearly by the Old Waterford Society and is distributed free to members in January, May and September. Correction to Decies XVI: In the article Elizabeth de Clares Pur~artv of Callan, c. 1338-1360 an unfortunate reversal of pages 33 and 34 took place in the Latin text of Appendix I1 beginning on page 32. Thus the first account of 1351-2 was from P.R.O., S.C. 6 1237/9 and is followed by a footnote. The second account was from P.R.O., S.C. 6 1237/8 and should have faced page 35. Our apologies to Mrs. Mary C. Lyons for our mistake in assembling her article. Thanks are due to Mr. Luke Myers, whose help and advice in the production of Decies has been invaluable.
    [Show full text]
  • 8 Western Canada
    Western Canada 8 Learning Objectives To describe the physical and historical geography of Western Canada as a basis for understanding the region’s social and economic posi- tion in Canada To emphasize the role of environmental challenges in agricultural regions and the oil sands industry To outline the transformation of Western Canada’s economy from agricultural frontier to “rapidly growing region” To highlight Western Canada’s industrial sector and trends toward more processing of agricultural products, a larger service sector, and growing urban centres with knowledge-based research clusters To describe Western Canada’s resource sector and complexities re- lated to pipelines, pollution, government approaches, and promises. Chapter Overview The geographic dimensions and importance of Western Canada are outlined in Chapter 8 and these dominant themes emerge: 1. Tremendous economic growth in this region in the past decade, followed by an end of the re- source boom in 2014. 2. The region’s continental position results in higher transportation costs in accessing global markets. 3. The continuing role of agriculture as an economic anchor for Western Canada. 4. Alberta’s oil sands and mining activities have brought prosperity to the region in addition to environmental challenges. Western Canada within Canada Western Canada is a rapidly growing region, ranking second in GDP and third in population size of the six geographic regions. Western Canada’s Population Of Western Canada’s 6.7 million people (2016), the Indigenous population forms nearly 10 per cent. First Nation reserves and the urban Indigenous population are increasing in population. Western Canada’s Physical Geography The physical geography of Western Canada features two major physiographic regions—the Interior Plains and the Canadian Shield—and two minor ones—the Hudson Bay Lowland and the Cordille- ra.
    [Show full text]
  • Historical Precipitation Characteristics in the Palliser's Triangle Region Of
    Dustin Roussin and Jacqueline Binyamin Precipitation anomalies and climate variabilities Historical precipitation characteristics in the Palliser’s Triangle region of the Canadian prairies Dustin M. Roussin Department of Geography, University of Winnipeg Jacqueline Binyamin Department of Geography, University of Winnipeg Key Messages • Drought is a recurrent and spatially variable feature of Palliser’s Triangle. • Teleconnections (ENSO, PDO and PNA) affect seasonal and long-term variation in precipitation across the Canadian prairies. • Among teleconnections, the PDO has the greatest effect on precipitation in Palliser’s Triangle.. The Palliser’s Triangle region of the Canadian prairies is a drought prone area. The region’s dry belt extending from Lethbridge, Alberta to Swift Current, Saskatchewan has variously expanded and shrunk over the course of the 20th century. Since1980, it has been expanding east and north towards Regina and Saskatoon, Saskatchewan. Teleconnections such as the El Niño/South- ern Oscillation (ENSO), the Pacific North American (PNA) pattern, and the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) are known to have effects on the precipitation received in the region. The main purpose of this research is to understand how teleconnections alter the pattern of precipitation across Palliser’s Triangle. The PDO was shown to have the greatest influence over precipitation. The study shows that winter values of a teleconnection index have a greater influence on spring and summer precipitation than the spring and summer values of the same index. Keywords: Palliser’s Triangle region, Canadian prairies, teleconnections, ENSO, PDO, PNA Introduction dryness, there is, however, variability from year to year in the amount of precipitation received. Different teleconnections such The Canadian prairies are noted for their agricultural produc- as the El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO), the Pacific Decadal tion, however, there are areas of the region that are known for Oscillation (PDO), and the Pacific North American (PNA) pat- being more prone to drought than others.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dry Belt and Changing Aridity in the Palliser Triangle, 1895–2000 Gregory P
    prairie forum 34, no. 1 (Spring 2009 ): pp. 3 1–44 The Dry BelT anD Changing ariDiTy in The Palliser Triangle, 1895–2000 GreGory P. Marchildon, JereMy PittMan, and david J. Sauchyn Abstract ue to its average aridity as well as historical experience with prolonged droughts, the Dry Belt has long been identified as the most vulnerable D sub- region within the larger Palliser Triangle in the Great Plains of southwestern Canada. Based upon 105 years of climate data, drought maps are redrawn based upon the historical record of drought within the Dry Belt. The result demonstrates that the size of the Dry Belt expands or contracts dramatically depending on the precise period being analyzed. Given current climate change scenarios, we should not be surprised to see a major expan - sion in the area of the Dry Belt in future decades similar to what was experienced between 1928 and 1938 . Sommaire La zone sèche est depuis longtemps reconnue comme étant la sous- région la plus vulnérable du triangle de Palliser des Grandes Plaines du sud- ouest canadien à cause de son aridité moyenne et de son histoire de sécheresses prolongées. C’est en s’appuyant sur 105 ans de données climatiques que les cartes de sècheresse sont revues selon l’historique de sècheresse dans la zone sèche. Les résultats indiquent que l’étendue de la zone sèche augmente ou diminue de beaucoup selon la période spécifique analysée. S’appuyant sur les scénarios de changements climatiques actuels, il ne serait pas surprenant que l’étendue de la zone sèche s’accroisse de façon majeure dans les prochaines décennies par rapport aux cinquante dernières années, rappelant ce qui s’est produit entre 1928 et 1938 .
    [Show full text]
  • Archive News
    L O R E T O C E N T R A L & IRISH PROVINCE ARCHIVES Archive News I N S I D E Special Edition: Bicentenary of Teresa Ball entering TH I S I S S U E the Bar Convent, York—11 June 1814 J U N E 2 0 1 4 Introduction Mother Coyney’s A Most Significant Date ~ 11 June 1814 letter accepting Teresa Ball to Frances Ball, having decided that she had a call to Religious Life, waited patiently until her the Bar mother felt ready to let her go. When she reached her 20th birthday, Mrs. Ball reluctantly gave Convent her consent and Frances prepared to enter the Bar Convent in York, England. Ball Family Tree Mrs. Ball suggested that Frances should visit Cecilia who was an Letter to Ursuline Sister in Cork. Frances spent some very happy days with Teresa Ball from her Cecilia and made new friends while there. Among them were the sister Isabella McCarthy sisters, both of whom later entered in Loreto Abbey, ‘A Tireless Rathfarnham. Worker for the Kingdom’ - Anna Maria The little miniature portrait we have of Frances Ball was probably O’Brien painted during her visit to Cecilia. Frederick Buck, a famous Cecilia Ball— portrait painter living in Cork, was the subject of an article in Irish Mother Mary Art Review a few years ago and the portrait of Frances would sit Regis Miniature of perfectly beside the samples of his work reproduced in the article. Nicholas Ball Frances Ball and his family Extracts from Nicholas Ball escorted his sister to York.
    [Show full text]
  • Topic: the Story of Palliser's Triangle, the Structure of Saskatchewan Soils
    Topic: The story of Palliser’s Triangle, the structure of Saskatchewan soils, the reality of Saskatchewan weather Prepared by Amy McInnis, May 2004, for the Winning the Prairie Gamble exhibit, North Battleford WDM 1. Scientific explorations, the Palliser Triangle, the agricultural potential of Saskatchewan In “A History of Agriculture on the Prairies to 1914,” Lewis H. Thomas writes: “Agricultural activity is impossible without fertile soil and favourable climatic conditions, and unless these qualities be perceived by men, the land will remain untouched.” ( 221-22). The British Parliament and an ardent group of British-Canadian expansionists, centered in Canada West, were keen to settle the area west of Canada to the Rockies, but lacked solid information as to the climate and agricultural potential of the area, necessary to attract prospective settlers (Thompson, 33-34). In an attempt to quash the wilderness stereotype of the West, furthered by the likes of Hudson Bay Company’s Governor, Sir George Simpson, and published accounts like that of William F. Butler’s The Great Lone Land, scientific explorations were launched (Rees, 5-6). 1.1 Palliser and Hind Expeditions On behalf of Britian, Captain John Palliser set out on his British North American Expedition to investigate the agricultural potential of the prairie region from 1857-60. Palliser’s expedition is famous for his delineation of a triangular shaped area north of the 49th parallel, covering 200,000 square kilometers across present-day southern Saskatchewan, southeastern Alberta and southwestern Manitoba, which became known as the Palliser Triangle (Lemmen and Dale- Burnett, 41). Known as “the driest part of the Canadian prairie provinces,” the Triangle is described in the Atlas of Saskatchewan by Lemmen and Dale-Burnett as follows: The native vegetation cover is commonly referred to as “northern mixed grass prairie”, or simply “mixed prairie”.
    [Show full text]
  • NINE Successive Crop Failures in the Drought Core of Saskatche
    WHAT OF THE DROUGHT AREA? WILFRID EGGLESTON INE successive crop failures in the drought core of Saskatche­ N wan, and from four to eight failures in nine years over a much wider territory extending into Alberta and Manitoba, must in­ evitably raise once more the old question as to the suitability of large areas of the western plains for cereal production. So far, a policy of widespread abandonment has been avoided, and in an attempt to salvage an area in which losses have already been appalling, governments and individuals have continued to pour vast sums of money into the Canadian "Dust Bowl", evidently in the belief that the condition of affairs is temporary. Their faith in the ultimate future of the drought area is subject to severe trial after nine years of crop failure, more or less complete; although as the drought cycle lengthens, the probability of the early arrival of a cycle of excessive precipitation and luxuriant growth must increase. It is not yet clear whether the financial resources avail­ able will enable the drought core to hold out until meteorological aid arrives, or, in any event, whether the returns balanced against the cost will justify a continuation of the present degree and type of settlement there. Experience of the past few years inevitably renews interest also in the manner in which that country came to be thrown open to promiscuous settlement, and the responsibility for putting under the plow thousands of acres of tough range grass which have been succeeded by drifting silt and sand on abandoned farmsteads.
    [Show full text]